Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

First and foremost, you should go check out this post on our main feed for an important announcement about our planned coverage of Andor. Second, hopefully this Q&A ep, the first one actually arriving during the month it was recorded in in forever and which serves as our Rebels finale lookback episode, will serve as a replacement for your ears this week.

We'll be back soon with the first episode of our KOTOR 2 coverage!

Show Notes

Waypoint Radio #123: "Machine Elves"

Henry Cavill's BTS Story About His Infamous Arm Reload In MI: Fallout

Files

Comments

Ward Baker

Does it conform to BDS if you pirate Andor 2 via torrent?

iirate

I don't have a Facebook so I can't comment on the main feed, just wanted to send my love and respect for this choice.

Zach G

Love you guys for this. Free Palestine

Limond

Wish I knew about this before the season started. I gave my money to Disney already because of AMCAs impending coverage.

Verdigree

It's worth noting that in Pathfinder, average people THINK that elves come from a mysterious continent across the western ocean, but their homeland is actually a planet that was conquered by a demon tree, also, not related to this, but their existential ennui of living amongst shorter-lived peoples can be expressed mechanically

Star Crumbsonar

was looking forward towards your coverage but i appreciate your dedication to the cause of Palestinian liberation ❤️

Damian Brown

My number one recommended book (from new canon) that I think the crew should read is the novel Master & Apprentice by Claudia Gray (not to be confused with Master and (no ampersand) Apprentince, a short story by Caludia Gray in the Certain Point of View collection). It has Rael Aveross, another of Dooku's padawans, and explores the relationship amongst the 'descendants' of the Yoda-line (Dooku, Quigon, Obi Wan) as well as the tension between the republic and independant corporations (and the jedi position on the legality of slavery outside of the republic) and jedi theology about prophecy (with some wild takes on that subject by Yoda). Also, it uh, has an iconclastic Jedi named Rael in it... Don't know if that matters or not but it sure is suspicious (genuinely don't know, not a coyler).

Casey Moore

I won’t lie and say I’m not a little disappointed, but good on you all for figuring it out, moving forward, and making a hard choice to be true to your beliefs. No matter what material you cover it will be great listening and I’m thrilled to have it! Also, come on - don’t act like getting to kotor 2 next wasn’t always the plan! :)

The Coffin Club

the best part of talking about Star Wars is that there is so much crap in the mix to talk about and I am eagerly looking forward to KOTOR 2 as a replacement because it's the perfect replacement.

JC

Its word of mouth many would be afraid of- that wouldn’t put money in Disney’s hands, but a podcast then talking about it and by its existence implicitly encouraging people to watch along would lead to many people going to Disney Plus either out of convenience or ignorance. And for obvious reasons they can’t say on their podcast ‘go torrent this’. On a personal level, that should be fine, and if you talk about it with friends who do similarly that should be fine, it’s the ‘public’ word of mouth from social media and among those who for whatever reason would go to Disney Plus that would be the issue.

JC

Anyway big props to you all, huge respect, and glad things seem as amicable and friendly between everyone as ever after the discussion

Christine

Thanks for your honesty and your commitment to supporting Palestinian liberation ❤️

Mint Fresno

Why not just pause the podcast or transition to another non-Disney franchise? This feels like a weird exception.

Alex S

Hey it’s your podcast and you gotta to do what you feel is right. Unfortunately for me my interest in the kotor games are non existent so I’m probably going to check out

cole d

Free Palestine Also if you pivot to the 'Watch This Space' show, you simply must cover The Expanse, it's my favorite sci-fi show of all time and should have plenty of juicy political themes to discuss

Blake Bonsack

Incredibly disappointed. You guys are doing the Maya Pei bit in real life.

Alexander

Does this only apply to Andor or does it also apply to coverage of older Star Wars films and shows, given that they are owned by Disney? e.g. Is coverage of Star Wars media other than video games and old EU novels off the table for AMCA for the foreseeable future? Or is BDS drawing a distinction between older material and new streaming shows? I respect whatever principled stance you decide to take - I’m just curious what the parameters for the boycott are.

Gromzark

So when will you return to new Star Wars stuff? Is AMCA an old canon podcast for the foreseeable future? What's the end goal? Disney publicly divesting? Or does the boycott not end until the occupation ends? Edit: My question was answered in another comment, it's just D+ stuff, so games and books are fair game (for now). Still very, very bummed but at least there can theoretically still be some modern canon and not all legends.

Mike

Pitch: Dune, hidden fortress, the searchers, and other works that were influential to starwars.

The Younglings Had It Coming

Sad about no Andor, but support thr decision. So glad you're going to experience my favorite video game and mu babies Atton, Visas, and Kreia, though! Also, recommendation wise, The Courtship of Princess Leia is the best book in the EU. There are some I like better, but that is objectively perfect Star Wars to me. (Also: FARSCAPE!)

Corybdis

I hate that you had to make this choice. I'm sad for all the joy that got pulled out of the airlock. I'm hopeful watching people disagree and still choose the work. You remain an important part of my days and contributors to my thoughts. LFG, Kotor 2. I'm here for all of it.

A More Civilized Age: A Star Wars Podcast

As discussed in the episode, the boycott is explicitly on Disney+. The point of BDS' actions is to strategically impact things in a clear, measurable way, and with reasonable asks of supporters. It's important to actually do the thing BDS is asking for because it demonstrates what collective action *can* do (giving leverage in the demand), and because it shows that it isn't impossible for people to join the boycott. So: Books, comics, games, etc. are not covered by this, nor are things available in physical formats. That could change one day, and if so, we'll cross that bridge. But until then, we've got a lot of Star Wars to cover still

Connor O'Brien

This was a great call! Much love to you all for making a hard choice.

Toshio

I'm disappointed too, but 'not doing a podcast about a Star Wars show' is hardly the same as leftist infighting or the Maya Pei bit.

steven w

Rough, it sucks that andor coverage was the thing I know I was looking forward to because of the times we live in. Because the show has a message. Honestly, the world sucks and the silly little star wars podcast I love brings me moments of joy. I get why you have made this decision. Though, I don't know how you will do any shows/movies that are on Disney+ now. For at least a very long time. Thanks for letting us know, I'm sure this was a difficult decision as your season 1 and or coverage was what brought me, and many others I assume, to your show. Guess I could play KoTR 2 as I never have. Long post with not much to say. Thanks for the pod. Edit: to be clear though, my disappointment in a lack of a podcast on this show is in no way equivalent to what people are going through in Palestine.

Ryan Wagner

Hey guys, have loved the podcast for many years now, and I support what you support in principle, but I'm a bit puzzled how this decision squares with having a podcast that primarily covers Star Wars TV series (especially the animated series) as all of them both past and present are now available exclusively on Disney+... And beyond that are produced and distributed by the Walt Disney corporation. Whether it's something new like Andor or something older like Clone Wars Season 7... It all falls under this box. Like many I was thoroughly looking forward to your coverage of Andor season 2, a show that is clearly incredibly timely for our current year and global political situation. At the end of the day this seems like a very broad blanket decision from the BDS movement. Unlike some of their other targets, Disney has no direct or indirect involvement with Israel or the war machine. Choosing to lump them in because of two isolated casting decisions is odd to me. And on top of that, something like a Marvel character established decades ago being a Mossad agent or Gal Gadot being in the Snow White movie that bombed and will be forgotten in a year has no real bearing on Star Wars. With all that said... There is sadly no end to the conflict in sight, so I doubt there is an end to this boycott in sight. I love KOTOR 2, and am looking forward to your coverage of it. But there's not a lot further you can go in terms of pre/non-"Disney" Star Wars barring this becoming a podcast that purely covers old EU novels from the 90s... As you pretty much alluded to. And if that's what your decision is for the future of the podcast after KOTOR 2, then that will regrettably be the end of my patronage at that time.

Connor O'Brien

Also everyone wondering about the parameters of the boycott should go to thr BDS national committee website or social media where they very clearly articulate the parameters and goals of the boycott!

steven w

Edit I see it doesn't apply to anything that's on physical media. So one day andor will be on blu-ray.

Alexander

Cool. Just wanted to make sure that if I don’t already own KOTOR 2, I could get it and follow along with y’all without breaking the boycott due to not having bought it previously.

Rick R.

I've been looking forward to your Andor Season 2 and Clone Wars Season 7 coverage for years, so this is incredibly disappointing.

Rachel Saywitz

I’m of course a little bummed, but I wholly support this decision and all of you!! And I hope y’all know that so many of us continue to enjoy this pod, whatever you discuss. If anything I feel a bit more emboldened to strengthen my own praxis like you guys have just done. (and at the very least we’ll have Andor DVDs in a few months hopefully lol so all coverage is not lost) Time to find myself a used KOTOR II copy….

steven w

i may be wrong but seems the boycott is only on Disney+ not physical media produced by Disney. Not super big distinction, but seems the idea is just to not promote Disney+. Someone smarter/better read can correct me.

Gromzark

I'm pretty angry. I'm going to sleep on it and see if I'm less grouchy when I wake up and if not I'm just going to cancel my membership for a while I think

Ryan Wagner

I understand the boycott is targeting only Disney+, but if they could watch these series on Blu-Ray and still create podcasts off them... Then why are they not doing that rather than going to KOTOR 2 and planning to mine EU novels? The reasoning (I assume), is that by covering these shows it could still encourage people to sign up for Disney+.

Colin Luton

Point of clarification? So obviously it's going to be hard to cover D+ content if the panel can't be subscribed to D+. Does that mean if Andor season 2 comes out on physical media it can be covered? Or is promotion of content available on D+ also off the table? It seems like the BDS boycott is specifically about pinching a revenue stream where as the SAG/WGA was about shrinking brand mindshare, is that an accurate-ish assessment?

Cats Akimbo

Appreciate that you brought attention to this as I didn't know BDS was prioritizing Disney+. I've cancelled my d+ subscription and look forward to more kotor!

Thursday Garreau

Love to see the BDS support. It's the right call - and I'm happy to hear about KOTOR 2 cutting the line! For other Star Wars stuff to cover, I'll shoutout the Alphabet Squadron trilogy - 3 books from the current canon, about a group of motley New Republic pilots who are all traumatized weird fuck-ups. You get a great pilot drama that also gives some phenomenal peeks inside the Empire right before and immediately following Palpatine's death, with some fun espionage twists and turns.

nearer

especially right now, i’m really feeling the disconnect between andor’s messaging and disney the corporation, and honestly this feels like an inevitable extension of that conflict. thank you for your candid messaging, and i’m excited to see what the future holds.

James

I'm bummed, I've wanted to follow season 2 with you all since the first finished, this is the right call. No sense throwing a tantrum over losing a treat to a good cause. Solidarity is tough but vital. We can suffer a little for homies who are suffering a lot.

Patrick McCann

I am sorry but this is performative and dumb. At this point we can just assume that Andor S2 and Clone Wars S7 are never going to be covered. So why keep doing the podcast if you are not going to even follow what you set out to do?

Steve Brown

I really disagree with this decision, but I love you four and I'll keep my sub. I hope you change your mind, I don't see how this helps end the genocide.

astral_chord

Here to voice support of your decision. Eager to hear everyone's thoughts on KotoR 2!

justthisguyok

Just want to voice my support for this decision. I also was not aware that Disney was on the BDS list. I just cancelled my subscription. If you choose "other" as the reason for cancelling, there is a box to type in, so hopefully that shows up on a report somewhere if you put BDS like I did.

Karrius

Thanks for making the right decision, and sorry you're getting so much flak from people who just don't get it.

Mary Frances Striby Chang

Personally disappointed but I support the members for making this principled decision according to their conscience. Thank you for your honesty. Sounds like a difficult decision you all had to come to together.

Alexander Pereira

I'm bummed but I respect the decision. I greatly enjoy y'alls commentary and literary analysis, it great expands what I take away from any of the media we've focused on. Andor Season 2 is so incredibly ripe for your brand of commentary that I was almost more excited for that than the show. I do fear in our current political climate, Disney isn't likely to read weakened Andor season 2 numbers as a result of the BDS movement but instead as a way to continue to trim back on diverse casting and interesting, political story telling. And for what feels like a weaker reasoning by the BDS movement than things like Microsoft/Xbox. A pair of actors and a character seems like a weak basis compared to active and full-throated support of the apartheid state by Intel and Microsoft. Still, solidarity in this is vital and I support that. As someone else has pointed out, there are two more Thrawn trilogies to hit up and I am also excited to see you get to those.

Ian Paul

Joined the Patreon to show some support for the decision. It was something I was feeling worried about not being able to watch Andor, at least through Disney +, and I'm glad I might be able to watch concurrently at some point in the future. I'm excited for Kotor, I get why some people might not enjoy it as much, but I have been almost as excited for Kotor 2 coverage as Andor coverage.

Holden Linnan

I really hope this isn't the beginning of the end of modern Star Wars on the show, I'm a huge bad batch fan and I've been so excited for you to get to it, the boycott seems to have no end in sight so I don't know what that means for the future. I am in favor of you supporting Palestine, however Andor(both seasons so far) seems to be growing in relevance by the day and feel like if nothing else the political messaging in Andor should grant it an exception, I could just be coping but nonetheless I love the show and support y'all making the right decision :)

DinoFugazi

I understand the decision entirely. Palestine must be free. Israel is conducting a genocide. These are the big issues, the ones that really, really matter. As far as things that matter less, I don't think BDS is ever going to not target Disney+, and I don't think creating carve-outs around physical media is a solution to this problem. I expect that aligning 100% with the BDS movement is going to mean becoming a Star Wars legacy podcast for years, if not forever. I will continue to support this crew, but I have complex feelings about my own disappointment with what this decision means for the future.

regular bird

Not sure what I was looking forward to more; season 2 or AMCA talking about season 2.

Holden Linnan

I don't quite understand it because reading the BDS guidelines I understand it says not to support Disney plus however it seems that they only say that in relation to problems with Marvel and Snow White, not pertaining to Star Wars, I understand Disney owns both but I don't really care about Marvel but I do love Star Wars. So I don't feel morally wrong because I haven't supported any Marvel projects or Snow white, it just sucks Disney has an ever-growing monopoly on entertainment.

Colin

I hope Mask of Fear: Reign of the Empire is high on the list of recommends, but I understand if it’s too close to Andor to cover

Holden Linnan

Yeah and the boycott is related primarily to Marvel and doesn't seem to involve Star Wars at all

TheSnowballzz

Feeling this. I respect this is their decision, and why, but really what does this mean for the show in the long-term? BDS is absolutely not clear on what, if anything, would remove D+ from the list.

Holden Linnan

how many people listen to this podcast who don't already watch star wars and have disney plus? I think them putting a disclaimer up in each episode and suggesting people to use torrent is a viable alternative

Buddy Lowe

For the reasons listed on the bds site, I’m not sure Disney+ will ever be taken off of the boycott list. So, without physical releases, I don’t think we’ll get to watch some of these newer shows.

Holden Linnan

If they pivot to 'Watch this Space' I genuinely pity the guy doing the letterboxed

N

Love and respect to all of you- Just rejoined the paid Patreon and looking forward to kotor II

Joseph Dealy

Fully agree with this. If this is the new standard, the show as we've known it is over. What a massive massive disappointment.

Rav

I hope that when the time comes to cover it that you still go over season 2 by episode or arc rather than all in one go. Other than that, while I was looking forward to the coverage, I'm glad of this decision you all made and am excited for KotOR 2, a game I know nothing about.

Jackson Floyd

While I agree with the sentiment and respect the decision, I have a feeling that Andor S2 or any of the D+ shows won’t be covered. I have a suspicion that BDS will not be removing Disney from their boycott list any time in the near future.

Joseph Dealy

I think it'd be more intellectually consistent to just end the podcast. Even covering legends content, Star Wars is still owned by Disney. If this is the line in the sand, what are we even doing here?

Thursday Garreau

The boycott is targeted specifically at Disney+.

Thursday Garreau

Additional note: Alphabet Squadron is written by the author of the best class storyline in the The Old Republic MMORPG (where every single playable class has their own branching single-player storylines, of WILDLY variable quality). While I can't speak for most of TOR, playing as an Imperial Agent is some of my favorite pre-Andor Star Wars fun *ever*.

Joseph Dealy

Because Gal Gadot was cast in Snow White, a movie that bombed and cost Disney a ton of money? It's just performative bullshit that does nothing for the actual cause of ending the genocide, while simultaneously supporting a game published by Microsoft. It's a baffling deicison.

Dave Mohan

You were talking about Witwer on one of your last Rebels cast. I would say he's one of the top 5-10 people out there regarding Star Wars insight. If you look up and listen to his Episode 1-6 film commentaries, there's a lot of things he claims that after digesting, you realize he is 100% correct.

Anna Lackey

I’m very disappointed to hear that you won’t be covering Andor, I’m also disappointed that you’ve opted to move to a game created by a Microsoft-owned studio. In both cases, the issue isn’t directly funding either Disney+ or Microsoft, but providing them with publicity and engagement. As Microsoft is directly and materially complicit Palestinian genocide and is one of the longest standing and most urgent targets of BDS, I would strongly urge you to rethink your decision to cover Kotor.

Anthony

I've been looking forward to your Andor coverage since S1 came to a close but I respect and support this decision and I've enjoyed the lens you bring to the material enough that I'm here for wherever you choose to point the lens next (I assume Babylon 5 is a tease but I'd be here for that!). Also, thank you for surfacing the disagreement but not outing the people taking different positions. I don't want to know and I'm glad you chose the team over the show.

Rayinthefog

I don't love the idea of boycotting a company for hiring actors or portraying characters from a given nation, and I think that doing so on the basis of some tangential connections to Israel in particular sets a pretty rough precedent, especially given that you're instead directing attention towards a game owned by Microsoft, who we know are actively supplying the IDF with their infrastructure. I know it's a very complicated situation and I agree wholeheartedly with the intent behind your decision, but this leaves a real bad taste in my mouth.

Anthony

I agree with this but I think with Andor in particular, I don't see how the coverage would be everything we would want it to be if the hosts had to look the other way on a real world genocide.

Holden Linnan

but why? Disney has many other sources of income so why are they just saying boycott all of disney plus and not other disney products? Star Wars doesn't seem to be involved at all in the reasons for boycotting so it just doesn't quite make sense to boycott all of Disney plus for 2 Disney projects, one of which already did awfully

Holden Linnan

I just kinda assumed they already thought about it and discussed it

Ryan Wagner

Both of them (Snow White and Brave New World) didn't do well, and ironically neither of them are currently on Disney+ (though both likely will be in the future). So I agree it is a bit of a nonsensical target.

Keeper

Microsoft did not own the studio when they made the game. The Xbox version was actually kinda famous for having been pushed out earlier than the PC version and thus without patches. All due to Lucasfilms wanting the game on shelves before Christmas IIRC.

Anthony

agree with this. if the show is special to us because it speaks to real issues, we can't prioritize the show over the real issues and not expect both the show and ourselves to be diminished.

Holden Linnan

I didn't know they weren't on Disney plus, that absolutely makes no sense at all then

Keeper

That and a majority probably already have it. Be it from earlier release, Humble Bundle which has had it plenty of times or just Steam sales where I’m pretty sure it has been $1 plenty of times.

Keeper

LucasArts actually. If you want to go back in time to the decades before Lucasfilms got bought by Disney and Obsidian by MS.

Joseph Dealy

Explain to me how Disney is providing any support whatsoever to the Israeli government.

Scotty Jones

I really wish people knew what "performative" meant and that this is as material as a podcast can be. I personally could not be happier to see Obsidian's best work covered (as much as I love New Vegas) and to watch my favorite crew unpack a true deconstruction, ideological baggage and all.

Keeper

No, its cause Disney have not released physical versions of a majority of their shows. There is no box set with all Clone Wars seasons etc.

Ryan Wagner

There was another comment here that I was replying to, which has since been deleted. That comment stated there were Blu-Ray releases of Clone Wars Season 7 and The Bad Batch. I have no idea, I don't follow Blu-Ray releases anymore.

Peter Johansen

We all need to do what we believe is right. I'm disappointed but appreciate your decision making and communication.

arcee

I can respect the decision to abide by the BNC's boycott, but I do question their decision to boycott an entire streaming platform just based on Disney working with racist Israeli actors and putting a character in a Marvel movie. Gal Gadot's been hired by a number of production companies over the past few years, are we boycotting all of them too...? By all means people should boycott Captain America and Snow White, but it seems like casting quite a broad net, to the point that any impact will likely be pretty diluted. But I'm not an expert I suppose.

Holden Linnan

I could be wrong but I think Snow White is Gadot's first movie since her support of Isreal, but even then she's still in Red Notice on Netflix so shouldn't that have a boycott applied as well?

Ciarán

If I'm disappointed at all, it's at all the people here in the comments trying so hard to wriggle out of what is and has been a successful campaign to boycott, divest from, and sanction Israel for their crimes against the Palestinian people. The point right now is to get over your "but my show!" reaction and show solidarity. If you were here for the strike, you already know.

Rodrigo Campos Varandas

I respect your decision to stick to your principles. I'm here just to add to the voice claiming for the coverage of the new Thrawn books after KotOR 2 if the boycott still on

Ryan Wagner

There's a significant difference between a Star Wars podcast temporarily boycotting the company that produces Star Wars, whose labor is directly striking against them... Versus indefinitely boycotting a company for a conflict they have no involvement in because they happened to cast two specific individuals in two separate projects a few years ago... Neither of which had anything to do with Star Wars.

Ciarán

If you listened to the podcast, you already heard Austin talk about how BDS works, including how they choose targets. If you need to read up, there's plenty more info on the BDS website. It's dishonest to frame this the way you have. AMCA are showing solidarity with the boycott called by BDS on Disney+ (not the company). If you have issues with BDS' reasoning for the boycott, you should take it up with them, but as I say, they've got a pretty good track record.

Ciarán

Incidentally, it's very easy for you to call the other boycott "temporary" and this one "indefinite" when only the latter is ongoing.

Joseph Dealy

Ryan is absolutely right here. I fully support BDS. But the logic behind the Disney+ boycott is threadbare at best, counterproductive at worst. But instead pivoting to a game produced by a Microsoft-owned studio? Counterproductive and pointless.

justthisguyok

Yeah this decision is 100% going to materially harm the hosts in the form of lost income, so it's about as far from performative as you can get. Baffling that so many listeners to this show seem to not understand the ideological basis for it whatsoever.

Ciarán

A lot of people suddenly becoming experts in the nitty gritty of boycotts when their favourite show is on the line I guess.

Ryan Wagner

I did listen to the 14 minute podcast. I get how it works. I think in this particular case BDS has made a pretty dumb and broad decision with very flimsy reasoning. And it doesn't take applying much critical thinking to see that. Blindly supporting everything they say to do is not exactly helpful to anyone. They need to pick their targets smarter. Regardless of that though, this is a podcast entirely focused around Star Wars. It started specifically to talk about animated Star Wars series. And the discussion of Andor Season 2 was much anticipated by virtually everyone, including the Podcasters and the Patrons/Listeners. So this update is pretty much saying the podcast now faces an existential moment. The Strike was temporary because strikes very much are temporary. The Israel/Palestine conflict has been going on since before any of us were born and has no end in sight. A boycott by BDS because of the conflict is thus definitionally indefinite. What action are BDS calling for Disney to take in order to end the boycott of Disney+? There is no explanation given. The only thing they've done is cast two actors a few years ago.

Joseph Dealy

Thank you Ryan. Extremely well said. I sincerely hope the podcast reconsiders it's decision. This is based on nothing and helps no one.

Espiox

I'm disappointed, but I respect the decision. If you're pivoting to KOTOR 2 though, I *really* hope you can do something to make it more listenable for folks that aren't playing the game along with the show. I found the original KOTOR episodes kinda boring and hard to follow, plot-wise.

ChromeViper

and if we're saying that supporting star wars supports genocide, then let's not pretend that disney is going to change their ways or that them getting on or off a list is what matters. If we're going to get on a soapbox about morals, then stick by them. If i believed that, personally, i would likely have deleted the rebels coverage and quit the pod. But i guess that's easy to say when there's no financial incentive..

ChromeViper

call me crazy but i think talking about the show that actually out loud says "genocide is bad, guys" in a time of genocide is probably a net benefit, not some evil, amoral act, particularly if you consider that the ring-wingers of the world make a thousand youtube videos every day critisizing star wars from the angle of "disney sucks and is woke and must be destroyed". Why can't the left do the same?

Groose Caboose

I respect BDS a lot but putting an entire platform on the boycott list because of 2 actors cast in movies already widely rejected by audiences (that aren't SW-related either, mind you) feels really flimsy. I can imagine this is one of the reasons for dissent among the AMCA crew. Personally, I'm really disappointed, because I'm losing out on something that I was very much looking forward to for something that I think will have zero material impact. Half the reason for the boycott doesn't even make much sense because the character in Brave New World has had every bit of her Israeli backstory scrubbed from the movie.

Erowik

On one hand: without your voices analyzing the show, the general public will remain relatively ignorant of how Andor's depiction of imperial oppression relates to the need for the BDS movement. On the other hand: Maybe your absence from the conversation won't really matter as much if we assume that you won't catch the attention of newer Andor fans. But consider this, Star Wars Theory will have more posts on Andor Season 2 while you remain silent. Please review Andor Season 2 and then Boycott the rest of Star Wars forever as penance. Nothing else in the franchise matters as much as this show.

Erowik

By boycotting Andor now, you let Star Wars Theory slander the show uncontested. (I'm being petty. Sorry)

Holden Linnan

I think you might be getting a little extreme at the end there, maybe instead just go through with Andor s2 and then adhere to the boycott

Mark S

Argh, was looking forward to the AMCA coverage almost as much as the show. Still, it's the right decision and I respect you all so much for taking it.

Erowik

Last bit of extremely selfish whining from me: Your spreading of political theory in conjunction with this season's lessons either can change enough of the public towards more progressive politics to help the people, or your show doesn't have enough influence over enough people to matter. I choose to believe the former.

Holden Linnan

not to mention Gadot's now non-existent career which is good because she in genuinely one of the worst actors in hollywood on top of being in support of a genocide

Holden Linnan

I am in favor of the boycott, but I don't think it should apply to D+, ultimately its the civies choice and I will respect it no matter what

Erowik

You are right of course. This sci Fi show isn't going to save us, so neither is a podcast about it. It's just entertainment. No reason to get overly invested (saying this more to myself)

Matthew Cunningham

I wouldn't say the High Republic initiative goes as deep as religious epics, but it certainly does raise questions and challenge along similar lines. As well as touch on the relationship of different people, institutions, and beliefs to Jedi and their more distant but still too cozy relationship to the Republic.

Ciarán

"do Andor and then boycott the rest of SW as penance" I hope that's a joke, very weird comment to make

Matthew Cunningham

There's a solid main story list on one subreddit or another that's easy to pull. The idea is worth the revisit if things are looking more permanent and need a longer running throughline.

Cory Paton

I don’t mind as the team will still be talking about Star Wars. However, the reasoning behind having Disney+ as a boycott target on the BDS website is flimsy at best and even seems to be outdated/written prior to Brave New Worlds release. The 2 projects with Israeli actors aren’t even on the platform yet and neither are particularly effective “Israeli Propaganda” because the acting is bad and the comics history of the Marvel character is non-existent and indicates that Disney or Marvel already thought it would be bad to have a pro-israeli character in the movie and changed it. Very weird boycott choice. Free Palestine!

Tom L

As creators, they have every right to make the podcast they want to make. I'm however supremely disappointed. Yes I recognize that it's selfish and I just like my Star Wars show, but the BDS concerns with Disney+ are hard to understand in my mind. I'm not interested in this podcast as a Legacy Star Wars thing, and I can't think of anything more relevant today than analyzing what is going to be a wildly popular show about resisting fascism. It's a waste of a moment, and a waste of a platform to ignore it.

Erowik

My take sounds dumb I know. I just feel like the lessons of Andor being properly unpacked by AMCA could do more good than boycotting the show as it helps inform the public's understanding of these issues. If boycotting Disney+ is constructive, I would presume boycotting a Disney-owned IP would have relative value. I figure if they have to stomach breaking the boycott temporarily to discuss Andor, they can compromise by boycotting the IP for a time. Denying Disney money in any way would be progress , I gather.

AbominaBill

I respect the cast's decision to stand by their principles but it's really hard to see this as anything but a complete abandoning of all contemporary Star Wars media in perpetuity. What does a BDS withdrawal of a boycott look like when the infraction is for things that have already happened and are viewed to have a lasting negative effect on perceptions of Palestinians and their plight? How long does a media company have to go without hiring Gal Godot or legitimizing the Mossad in their comic book movies to get off the list? 5 years? 10? I know being a good ally is listening to and respecting the wishes of the groups that are out their fighting for the rights and lives of their people but it feels like this stance is not at all the same as showing support for SAG during their contract negotiations or strikes. I can't imagine any single event that repairs the damage BDS feels has been done to their cause by Disney and consequently it feels like the things I was looking forward to, and I know you all were too, are just never going to happen now. What a bummer.

Tom Burmeister

Props for your position, but I can't see Disney+ ever coming off that list. It feels like your actually just gonna accidentally cede cultural territory to the Right, because the guys who want to 'keep politics out of Star Wars' are going to keep making shouting. This all just makes the Gilroy lead Mothma show less likely to happen, and more apolitical glow stick waving the sad future of Star Wars. And seriously, you need to watch Bad Batch!

Nicolas Jouan

Instead of stopping your podcast and shooting yourselves in the foot while Disney ignores you, you should review Ashoka and unpack how laughably bad it is.

Jackson Parry Smith

It's the right decision. I for one will stand by and follow along with yall no matter what you decide to do.

Tom Burmeister

Sorry this was insensitive to what had obviously been a hard decision to make. I'll keep supporting, because whatever you talk about is interesting. Just horrified about trying to play Kotor 2 with a 14month old baby.

Eve Golden Woods

You're doing the right thing and I will continue to support the pod in as many ways as I can. You have my respect and admiration for making the hard choices ❤️

Anthony

that would ring hollow I think, given the subject matter. how are they supposed to speak about the morality of Andor while turning their backs on something no better happening in the real world?

RagnarTheRok

I respect your choice - but I find the timing of implementing this boycott JUST as Disney+ is rolling out a very expensive piece of anti-fascist art with (according to reviews) an allegory to the Palestinian conflict - a bit odd.

Darcy

Thank you for sticking to your principles even when it's inconvenient. It's easy to support something in ways that won't negatively affect you, and it's really important that people with bigger platforms like you are using them to support the Palestinian cause and draw a line in the sand about supporting genocide.

Lexi

Sagrona 🥂 I think the energy in the comments speaks to the quality, insight and joy of your Andor coverage has brought to so many fans. I can't say I'm a fan of the game coverage but the story of Kotor 2 is wild! Given the future of star wars may be off limits for a while would you consider the "Legacy of the force" books for some alternative timeline & Mara Jade?

I-Hsien Sherwood

Everything that needs to be said about the show’s decision has already been said here. So let’s talk about Rebels. As a fellow Mortis hater, one thing I really liked about its incorporation into Rebels was that we never see the Mortis gods as living beings, just art—and art specifically called out as archetypal. For me, this points to Mortis being a mythological representation of aspects of the Force shared across cultures, not undeniably a physical place you can get to via hyperspace. (What does God need with a starship?) And I’m happy to leave the Father, the Son, and the Daughter there. I recognize this probably doesn’t comport with Filoni’s vision, but I’ll cling to it even if the Clone Wars depiction becomes incontrovertible.

Groose Caboose

My 2 cents after thinking on it: I think the good that y'all can do in talking about Andor the way you talked about S1 far, FAR outweighs the completely negligible impact of this boycott for 2 failed actresses that they're probably not gonna cast again anyway. I think you can be critical of some of BDS' targets even while supporting their cause. I hope y'all reconsider.

Neil Hickinbottom

Up to you to follow your principles, I respect that, but this is a journey I cannot come with you on. Not at this moment with this show. Will be parking the Patreon temporarily until Andor Season 2 is back on the menu.

Joseph Dealy

It's a boycott called for because Gal Gadot was cast in Snow White. Fuck Gal Gadot, but who does this help? Is the demand to digitally remove her from the film? What is the ask here? 95% of people who watch that movie (which bombed) have no idea who she is or what her stances are regarding the IOF. This is intellectual masturbation masquerading as praxis on the part of BDS. It has no achievable goal or purpose and does nothing to stop the genocide. Boycott Microsoft and other BDS targets. Free Palestine.

Viren

I don't think anyone is asking for them to turn their backs on the genocide that Israel is doing to the Palestinians. In fact, bringing it up during discussions of Andor would make perfect sense, and could shine light on it that way too. I mostly just do not see what is being asked of Disney here by the BDS leadership. The movies this concerned are already out. One of them also stars an actress who is an outspoken pro-Palestine advocate. With most other BDS targets there's some sort of continued presence in Israel. A factory. A sponsorship campaign. A part of the supply chain. Some clearly targeted thing that can be ended by the force of a boycott. With the current explanation on the BDS website, there is no specific target. This will go on forever unless Israel stops their genocide, but as big as Disney is, I really doubt they have influence over that

Joseph Dealy

I guess I don't understand how watching it on a bluray release a year from now doesn't violate the spirit of the boycott, as Austin said on bsky, but pirating it now isn't an option? Both deny D+ the revenue stream. It's such absurd semantics. Ultimately, like many things in life, I blame Gal Gadot for existing.

Joseph Dealy

@keeper Discussing pirating Andor S2, not KOTOR 2.

Joseph Dealy

Given your internal disagreements, is every member of the pod committed to not watching any of Andor S2 until such a time as BDS removes D+ from their list? If half of the panel watches it currently and half doesn't, how is that in any way workable on future podcast episodes? 2-3 people know what the series is as a whole, and 1 doesn't? How do you talk about the series if that's the case?

Christian Hagen

While I respect your decision and very much support providing economic and political aid to the palestinian people, I don't share the view that Disney+ should be boycotted - especially as it seems like collective punishment on a nuanced political show like Andor. Through the strikes you had my continued support, but since the podcast is moving away from talking about the shows (for an unforeseeable time) I will wait to see if you return to it.

Tygre

While I share the cast's desire to see a free Palestinian people in a free Palestinian state, this specific BDS boycott seems on it's face to be based on simply casting Israeli actors in roles or having Israeli characters in shows. My love for the Palestinian people does not translate to a hate for the Israeli people. I abhor the constant deflection on this issue to false cries of antisemitism, but in the case of this specific BDS boycott they strike too close to the mark for me. Respect to the crew, but this is not a road I can follow you down.

Nas

I think live-action Zeb is about as perfect a translation of his Rebels design as you can get. Does it mean it's not slightly cursed? No, it is. Some designs just work better in the realm of animation.

Landy Mandy

Looking forward to Kotor 2. Any ideas on how far into the game we should play in preparation for the first episode of that?

Korlis

I'll keep it brief. I respect your decision to postpone covering Andor and understand why it might not have been a unanimous decision. Everyone has to come to their own conclusions about how to engage, critically and commercially, with art and boycotts. Each BDS priority target has different justifications and for me, while I fully appreciate the sentiment behind it, the Disney+ call didn't leave me feeling morally compromised the way Microsoft's actions do - which is why I'm engaging with one but not the other. Nevertheless, I support you standing together with the cast members who were unwilling to cover the show or other Disney+ work. In any case, I look forward to the KOTOR II coverage and whatever else is in AMCA's future.

Scotty Jones

Read your shallow grasp of the situation one of the other 5 times you said it. Disney's investment arm is quite tied up in Israel, but pointing to a famous actress who was marketed with the Israeli "warrior" mystique and targeting one aspect of their business makes perfect sense strategically. I'm sorry you have to be the wise treat enjoyer, but you do not have the hold of this that you think you do.

Korlis

With respect, this is a misleading framing of the BDS justification. It isn't about merely having Israeli (or Jewish) characters and actors. It's about the specific casting of Gal Gadot, who has actively screened Israeli propaganda, and the featuring of comic book characters associated with positive depictions of Mossad, the Israeli intelligence service.

Mr. Encyclopedia

All y'all who think watching Andor and talking about it is anti-facist praxis need to read about capitalist recuperation of radical politics.

Steve Brown

the contempt in your words for anyone who doesn't respond just as you do is not gonna win allyship to our cause. you can support Palestinian liberation and also find this particular boycott to be wrong. it's OK to have mixed feelings. stop with the purity tests, it isn't helping

Tygre

With respect, the BDS justification is so flimsy in this case that it's open to many competing framings. I am not personally comfortable with the stated reasoning in this particular instance, it hews too close to anti-Israeli-people rather than anti-Israel-state for me.

Ciarán

With respect to all of you who disagree, Steve, if the contempt you're reading into my expression of disappointment is enough to drive you away from supporting a righteous cause, you need to give your head a wobble. This isn't a purity test, go watch the show if you like, but you can't compel AMCA to cover it. I'm sure people are genuinely disappointed that they don't get AMCA Andor S2 now, but I really don't like the immediate wave of bargaining and nitpicking, looking for any excuse to dismiss the boycott because now it affects you

Ciarán

Would highly recommend you donate the money you would have spent on the patreon directly to help people suffering in Gaza, it would really mean a lot

Steve Brown

it's okay to have nuanced opinions about this decision. the hosts themselves don't even agree

R-Priest

Happy you’re all playing KOTOR 2, but I think not covering Andor now is the wrong choice and I hope you reconsider.

Chris P.

Support you guys’ decision, with ya’ll for the long haul wherever we go. Would absolutely love you to cover Babylon 5! Think that would be tons of fun.

Justin

I support your decision. Looking forward to KOTOR 2 and whatever comes next.

Holden Linnan

If so I think the Andor season 2 would greatly suffer, it wouldn't have the same hype

Ron Crawford

I cannot think of something that would make me unsubscribe faster

Mike

That’s just saying “I love Star Wars but I ignore all of the lessons it tries to teach” 😂

Mike

You ignore the millions of dollars Disney has spent to support the IDF’s genocide of Palestine…

Mike

Some would say extremely fine

Joseph Dealy

That famous Star Wars lesson: don't hire Gal Gadot for your stupid Snow White remake. 🙄

Joseph Dealy

Genuine question; what the fuck are you talking about? Even BDS makes no such claims. Have evidence of Disney giving millions of dollars to the Israeli state or military?

tammy trashbags

I understand why there would be a split panel over this. I personally don’t see how a targeted boycott of Disney+ makes sense at this point, even and especially after consulting BDS’ site. No one should be working with Gal Gadot, who has happily served in the IOF & spreads propaganda willingly. No one should support hasbara stories like that of Sabra. Neither this actor or character is, as far as I’m aware, currently on Disney+, and I don’t see an endpoint of this boycott as a result. I am in accord with BDS’ goals and methods, but don’t believe they’re beyond reproach, and this particular decision does seem odd to me. However. This is clearly not a ‘performative’ action by AMCA. It is a decision taken out of genuine thought & desire to have solidarity with a people who are currently under genocidal assault & starvation, and it is a decision that will likely have a real financial impact on them. While I don’t think BDS is beyond approach, I also think there’s something to be said for respecting & hewing to their decisions even when we disagree with them. It’s not what I would do in this case - but I can’t vociferously fault it, and I certainly won’t be cutting my support to AMCA as a result! I’m sad to have what would no doubt be some of your best work delayed, maybe even indefinitely. But the best thing to do with that frustration right now is to channel it right back into aiding the people of Gaza. I recommend Gaza funds dot com as a resource for giving directly to families under siege. Peace ✌️

David Caffrey

Really respect and support the decision here

BestowalDonkey8

Oh wow a Mage: The Ascension reference in the year of our lord 2025?!

Jesse Mumm

It’s worth noting Ahsoka S1 is actually available on Blu-ray and would make a very sensible and timely continuation following your Rebels coverage. In fact I’m ITCHING for you to discuss it after hearing you form thoughts on the direction of Rebels and the characters (whether for better or worse, I’ll keep that to myself). Clone Wars S7 was great, but not essential for this in any meaningful way. It would make sense to revisit S7 before the Maul Show actually. Unless I’m misunderstanding the limits of the Blu-ray workaround.

sethmilk

I'm looking at the BDS website right now ("act now" section) and it does not make a distinction between Disney and Disney+. It's the Disney logo (not D+) and the in the "pressure targets" list the full quote is "Disney: The Disney-owned Marvel Studios (US) is promoting in the next Captain America film a “superhero” that personifies apartheid Israel. Both companies are therefore complicit in “anti-Palestinian racism, Israeli propaganda, and the glorification of settler-colonial violence against Indigenous people,” as Palestinian cultural organizations have stated." As with many others, I am disappointed but understanding of the decision. I do find it ironic that I can't comment on the main feed because it requires a fucking facebook.

rosa www

(Edit: The reply I replied to got deleted, but I'll leave this up because I still think a lot of people could be more chill about this whole thing.) This is a group of people who are not only co-hosts but also friends, and I find your assumption that "1-2 members" just pressured the rest into giving in frankly disrespectful. If you disagree with the decision, that's your prerogative, but you should reconsider how you talk about the people who make this podcast you supposedly like. This statement & pivot was made in a fairly short timeframe and mentions that there will surely be more discussions on this or similar topics, and that "views will also continue to evolve & change", which I think is more honest than making a definitive statement when they are clearly divided on this.

Steve Watts

If you're looking for future suggestions in case this goes on for quite a while, could I suggest the New Jedi Order? That book series is not especially good, and it's WAY too long--19 books, iirc?--but if there's a way to reference a skip list or something to make it more manageable I think it's a really strange and interesting time capsule of the politics of its time, and it'd be interesting to hear you guys sink your teeth into it.

Holden Linnan

theres no sense in following a boycott that makes no sense, the movies being targeted aren't even on D+ so whats the point of the boycott? they aren't getting anything from it

Erykah Bendu

My disappointment is FAR outpaced by my pride in you wonderful people. Free Palestine Forever. 🇵🇸

Joseph Dealy

It's Gal Gadot in Snow White. It's based on nothing more or less than that. Disney is providing zero material support for the genocide of Palestine and choosing the correct targets for boycotting should, I think, be a priority of the movement.

Holden Linnan

if you read the pdf it does specifically call out Disney plus, I don't think this part of the boycott makes sense but it does call out D+ specifically

Kat Reynolds

nothing but respect for your choice. from the river to the sea, palestine will be free!

finestaut

Rough stuff. While I don't agree with this call, I totally respect it, and you've got my continued support.

Mike F.

I appreciate the candor(ous). Will be watching this space.

B.E. Albert

lot happening in these comments but I wanted to say I came here for your insights and commentary as hosts and not for the specific subject matter you choose to cover: I will increase my patreon support for the time being because I know unfortunately this is causing a shift for some. appreciate all you do, don't read the comments lmfao

Alex S

Can’t y’all just bootleg Andor 🤷‍♂️

Miles Wilson

Just want to add to the support (that I’m very grateful to see y’all getting). Fuck the treatlerites and everyone making bad faith (or deeply delusional/entitled) arguments about why THEY don’t think the boycott or y’all’s choice makes sense. Deep respect for making this call; solidarity forever, free palestine. Would listen to this crew cover literally anything

Holden Linnan

its not delusional or entitled to debate the validity of certain boycotts, I support Palestine, and I support the boycotts, but that doesn't mean I'm going to follow them blindly, I'm obstaining from coke products and am buying a used rather than new laptop to not support Dell, but the Disney+ boycotts are illogical, the movies that they have an issue with aren't even on Disney+ nor are they Star Wars related

Holden Linnan

This is just unfair and hostile towards them, as content creators they have a greater responsibility then we do when it comes to boycotts because they can spread the word more then us, I agree with the cause they are supporting and while I don't agree that they need to follow this specific aspect of the boycotts they're decision can not be reduced to 'liberal backpatting'. They made a decision that is ethical, but not necessary.

MillieLily

Hey gang, I've been following and supporting AMCA since very soon after its inception. I had kinda given up on Star Wars as a whole after the Disney acquisition, but I always enjoyed your banter, takes and discourse about Clone Wars. Your coverage of the first season of Andor is actually what got me back on the train, and the show quickly grew to be my favourite piece of Star Wars media, and I say this as someone who grew up with the original trilogy copied onto VHS by my parents. I totally and entirely understood and respected you pausing and switching what you were covering during the strikes last year. What work was struck was clear and logical and the aims and objectives of the strike were transparent, attainable and ultimately, obtained. Like many other people, I'm extremely dissappointed in your decision not to cover the second season of Andor following BDS's targeting Disney+ with its partial boycott. On a timing level, this stings. Both the fact that this announcement came instead of the eagerly anticipated coverage of the first set of episodes. But also, The BDS call for boycott started last year. If you following this boycott truly comes from an ideological place, why do you feel comfortable keeping your coverage of Rebels up when it was produced in that period ? Then there's the content of the call for a boycott from BDS, of which I'll post the text here : "Cancel or don’t sign up for Disney+ subscriptions! Disney and its subsidiary Marvel are complicit in glorifying Israel’s regime of genocide and apartheid against Indigenous Palestinians. Marvel’s Captain America: Brave New World and Disney’s Snow White star actors Shira Haas and Gal Gadot, respectively, that have consciously and irrefutably taken up roles as cultural ambassadors for Israel, directly representing genocidal Israel’s propaganda efforts. For Captain America, Marvel and Disney are reviving the racist character of Ruth Bat-Seraph, whose decades-old backstory includes working for Mossad. Disney+ is therefore clearly implicated in enabling Israel’s genocide by dehumanizing Palestinians." So because the actresses in two movies that already came out, flopped, lost Disney a lot of money and aren't even yet on Disney+ are Isreali this leads to a neverending boycott ? Cause it's not like they're going to recast those movies now. There's no path for Disney to comply (not that they would in any case but hey). I just don't see how this advances the Palestinian cause. I truly deeply feel that you doing a fundraiser, or sending the proceeds from patreon during the theoretical coverage of Andor to a charity would do a lot lot more to move the needle on that front than being silent. Missing the opportunity to reach a larger audience with your analysis and discourse while the iron is hot seems like a huge loss and I just don't see the benefits. Tangentially, the boycott only targets Disney+ but names Disney as a whole. I don't see how you can ideologically justify continuing to support the company financially by acquiring physical media instead. The money goes to Disney in any case. This also means that AMCA will never cover a huge part of what you set out to do initially. Season 7 of Clone Wars will not be released on disc. All in all, I think this is the end of my financial patronage, at least for now. I'm just not that interested in KOTOR 2 (Also doesn't Microsoft, another company boycotted by BDS get money from that too?) or the old EU novels coverage. Best regards, Emily

MaZZM

look yall I’ll mail someone a flash drive with clone wars on it Also play KOTOR 2 with Restored Content Mod

noshotsfired.tv

Well there’s some on the cast who didn’t agree either so I wonder if you’re telling them to fuck themselves too.

Strange Door

You have my full support. This won't be forever. People doubted SA apartheid would fall, then it did, and everyone who had boycotted over decades had in some small but significant way put their shoulder to the wheel. I understand that by making this choice you are putting your money where your mouth is, this is your livelihoods. Everyone here should support it. And I agree with you doing KoToR2 despite the Microsoft connection - it is different from current Disney+ shows driving signups. Anyway. This won't be forever. When Palestine is free, on top of everything else, imagine how joyous it will be to watch Andor together knowing you did the right thing.

noshotsfired.tv

I really don’t understand how covering a Disney+ show is fine as long as you watch it on physical media.

noshotsfired.tv

The podcast coverage is toast. It’s not going to hit at all coming out months after the fact.

Holden Linnan

I agree wholeheartedly with everything, I was waiting all day for the podcast to drop and I was happy for the QnA but I know that they have so much to say about Andor season 2 and to wait and lose steam and hype for such an illogical boycotting decision just seems like it will needlessly hurt the quality of the podcast

Jesse Mumm

I do agree with this on second thought. It’s true that the boycott is directed at D+ subscriptions and not Disney products as a whole, and that specificity is part of making a boycott successful, but it would still possibly service to direct people to subscribing because that’s the most convenient way of accessing the product. But this logic also directly applies to KotOR2. Most casual folks aren’t gonna hunt down used copies to follow along, they’ll go get it cheap on Steam or on the Switch.

Jesse Mumm

It’s still targeted at Disney and Marvel as a whole, but the specificity of Disney+ is because that’s the most immediate and easily actionable and visible way to hit Disney to send the message.

noshotsfired.tv

It’s odd to assume you know what everyone else is doing with other boycotts. And to be so smug about one that the very cast of this show seems to have been wholly unaware of for weeks.

Holden Linnan

its a null choice, I think it is both ethical to boycott Disney+ or to not do so, and by not doing so they are, in my opinion, hurting the podcast, I love the podcast but I have no interest in kotor, i tried listening to their first playthrough and couldn't really get into it and I imagine many other followers of the podcast feel the same way

MrContent

I had a VHS of Fly Away Home so you know I've seen that dozens of times. What's the harm in.... one little bonus episode about geese huh?

Holden Linnan

we need a community effort to pirate star wars for them lol

Ogremode

Been meaning to pull the trigger for a while now, but I'm here now to support y'all sticking to your guns and not covering Andor yet! A tough call but the right one—going by the replies, the audience clearly could not handle Andor coverage without disrespecting the D+ boycott.

Falcon

This makes no sense to me. Not the support of the Pro-Palestine movement in general. I'm sure everyone on the podcast and every one of your listeners are in that camp. I mean a strict supporting of the BDS movement and derailing your work for it. This isn't like the actor's/writer's strike. Those were people directly involved with the creative process asking for people to do something in solidarity with them. And, importantly, it was something that was definitely going to come to an end in the not too distant future. The BDS movement is insanely broad. From what I understand, if one were to actually try to abstain from everything they're asking of people you'd basically be living in the woods with no electricity. There's nothing ethical about living in a capitalistic society. Like, they're asking people to stop using Windows machines and install Linux instead. Cmon. That's sunshine and rainbows. It's not realistic. (They've changed their stuff so many times it's not even clear if they're calling for an active boycott against Disney/D+/Captain America 4 anyway.) And let's be honest, what's a couple dozen people not watching Star Wars really going to do? Not to mention, there's been armed conflict in the middle east for how long? Since in the beginning of time? The current conflict has been ongoing for years already, with no end in sight. Yes, obviously that is awful. But we're talking about this in the context of the work you do and entertainment you provide. So by making this move you're effectively signing up to not watch any Star Wars media indefinitely. Andor is a perfect piece of media in this moment of history to use as a vehicle to highlight the what's going. The story and depictions of inequalities and oppression in Andor should be used as a spotlight for drawing parallels to the real world. By not watching Andor as it airs you're missing the moment when it matters most. When everyone is excitedly tuning in and you can take a moment to clue your listeners into real world atrocities, places to volunteer, and ways to donate.

Michael Ruiz

Happy to see you all support the movement. One more reason we listen and support!

Patrick Matsutani

Insane to see how many people willing to pay you for your work are willing to demand you compromise your principles so they can listen to you talk about Star Wars tv shows as they come out LMFAO No one's as disappointed as the cast is. Question the decision all you want, but I haven't seen a single comment complaining about the decision that doesn't look like the whining of a child. Are your thoughts on boycott strategy really worth sharing or are you just mad you lost your favorite toy? Come on now. It's a Tuesday. Chill with the extremely unemployed behavior guys

Strange Door

The BDS movement have asked it's supporters to boycott Disney+. You can think this is strategically wise, or not. You can action it, or not. But it is not a null choice. Palestinians have not asked me to pick up a gun, they have asked me to endure a podcast changing it's format. It seems like the very very least I can do to not unsubscribe from people who are actually listening to what Palestinians are asking.

Jake VanDeventer

So is the BDS movement, if all they’re targeting is the IDF-supporting megacorporation’s streaming service.

Holden Linnan

its not whining, its a rational debate about the purpose of the boycott and if its worth it in this instance, no one should be insulting or showing the rudeness that you have. we're not demanding anything, at least I'm not, I'm voicing my opinion on a podcast I really care about and the validity of a boycott that doesn't make sense in this instance

Steve Brown

...you're the only one who sounds like a child here

TheSpiderDork

Free Palestine. good on all of you and looking forward to KOTOR2

Miles Wilson

Given that the point of my comment is to support the cast in the tough decision they came to, no, I’m not lmao. They’re all explicitly committed to Palestinian liberation, and regardless of if they all agree on the specific action taken here, it’s their show, their call to make, and this is what they’ve gone with. Not that I think your reply is really in good faith, either, since that’s clearly not who I’m speaking about

Holden Linnan

well instead of following the pointless boycott of disney+ that isn't going to change anything in palestine i'm going to match my subscription fee to disney+ and donate that to Palestine, and that way I can actually be doing something to help

Patrick Matsutani

White boy I'm trying really hard not to insult you further but you just invoked rational debate in the comments of a podcast Patreon and you have to know the low hanging fruit you've presented me with. I've got nothing to say besides I hope you have a blessed day brother 👍

Jena Westergreen

Damn, decision aside I was looking forward to having a 5 hour episode from you guys to chew on throughout my week, haha. I enjoy listening to ya'll no matter what you're talking about. I had picked up Kotor 2 right after I finished my Kotor 1 playthrough and then paused after a couple planets, guess it'll be time to pick that back up! In response to finishing Rebels - I really like the world between world stuff, even if its not "vague" as you mention in the episode about it. Personally any opportunity for more mystical and strange lore, and different ways to interact with the force, I'm pretty stoked for. Visions is often good for that, since it's new perspectives on interacting with the force and star wars in general. Not sure Filoni really has the vision to make the Mortise stuff as epic as I'd like, but I like lore so I'm interested to see where he goes with it in the future.

Maeve

Happy yall are taking a united front by standing with Palestine and respecting the BDS movement, no matter how tough that decision was. Fuck the people who want you to betray yourselves and compromise your principles just for a little content. Free Palestine and enjoy kotor 2 brothers 🤙

Pilcrow

The thing about it only being Disney+ is literally what BDS is saying. I also think that's weird, but that's not a call AMCA is making

Steve Brown

literally some of the hosts want to cover Andor. so, are you criticizing them too with such harsh words?

Holden Linnan

ngl you cooked with that i respect it

Falcon

Come on what? I just read through all of the replies after making mine and I'm pretty much in line with everyone else disagreeing with AMCA's collective decision. The BDS movement isn't clear on their specific objectives/goals, their asks are unreasonable and/or don't make sense, there's no end in sight to the movement, and AMCA is losing the ear of the people when it matters most.

Pilcrow

The boycott was implemented a year ago. AMCA is only learning about it now

Karrius

It's absolutely whining. Just because caring about others doesn't make sense to you, doesn't mean it's irrational.

Karrius

The asks aren't unreasonable. That you don't like being inconvenienced doesn't make it unreasonable.

Karrius

It's still promoting the show.

Karrius

The point is that targeting D+ is easy and actionable and easily measured.

Pilcrow

Austin says in the episode that they could cover Clone Wars season 7 if it were released on physical media because BDS is (currently) only calling for a boycott of D+, so it seems like a physical release of Andor s2 would work the same way

Strange Door

Just to be clear, this is not a boycott organised by American liberals, this is coming from Palestinian organisations. That is a huge and important distinction. It is maybe the only distinction that matters. So feel free to do whatever you like, I'm not judging you, but if Palestinians have decided this is a worthwhile angle to pursue then I'm going to do it.

Pilcrow

Instead of Watch This Space, you should rebrand as Media Club++, and work the manufactured rivalry to drive fans to your respective Patreons

Krzysztof Ceran

For me Alphabet Squadron is one of the best Star Wars things ever made. I was surprised how it affected me.

John Huppenthal

I respect their decision to not go forward with coverage. But there was also disagreement amongst the crew about how to handle this, so I think a discussion of this particular boycott has merit. I have happily boycotted game pass because of Microsoft's complicity. I stay the fuck away from McDonald's, Sodastream, etc. But I do think the people who question this particular boycott are worth listening to. The reasons they are calling for a boycott don't seem to be as directly related to Isreal's genocide as the other boycotts. Casting a staunchly pro-Isreal actor in one movie, and having a character that has a comic book history (not even touched o a bit in the actual movie) of being a Mossad agent seem iffy enough that I get where the questioning this boycott are coming from. I respect the hell out of the BDS movement. They are trying to do an impossible thing here and their goals are unimpeachable. They know more than most of us what helps and what doesn't. But they are also led by people like you and me and we need to not treat them as an infallible guiding light that we follow unquestioningly. It is healthy to challenge and question. It's not disrespectful to disagree with a particular tactic. I still absolutely respect AMCA's decision here and I'm looking forward to the KOTOR II coverage.

Strange Door

I'm not going to keep posting here but there is one point I need to squash: that this is a pointless, performative protest by American liberals. BDS is run by Palestinians. That's it. They have thought about it and asked us to do something. And it might be very hard for us to see how anything so small could move the machine of genocide, but they have asked us nonetheless. And when someone whose house is burning down asks you for a piece of thread you don't say "Thread?? Huh, I thought you would want water?? No thanks." You shut up and give them the damn thread.

Krzysztof Ceran

Many people have voice their opinion here, I doubt anybody came with insight the AMCA crew didn't think of themselves. I've been a supporter since the beginning, I'm staying a supporter. (plz cover Alphabet Squadron k thx bye)

Alex Langley

It's killing me that we may never get to season 7 of The Clone Wars (let's be real about the likelihood Disney ever changes course), especially given that it'll no doubt be *extremely* required watching before the Maul animated show. That said, I'm looking forward to KotOR 2!

Alex Langley

Wait, am I missing something about season 7 not being on physical media? There do appear to be The Clone Wars complete collections, which include season 7. I would still ABSOLUTELY take that before KotOR 2 lol

Lilith

100% support y'all. Doesn't really matter whether I 'agree' with this particular call by AMCA or BDS. I am part of neither thing, so it's not my place to voice my opinion here. That said, considering y'all are split in some way on this decision, it's wild to me to see people taking such absolute stances in these comments, either that this is a terrible decision that you should be ashamed of or that anything else but this decision is being a treatler (what the hell even is that term, why is everyone so online). It's like AMCA's own fans are determined to belittle the considered stance of some portion of the hosts they claim to be such huge fans of? What is wrong with y'all, there's clearly room for nuance here, no? 😕

Ryan Wagner

No. Anyone can be wrong about something or make a mistake. And that's okay. You can support something without blindly listening to everything 100%. Their given reasoning for boycotting Disney+ in particular does not make very much sense, and they have no stated goals/objectives for removing Disney+ from their boycott list... Despite Disney not actually having any involvement in Israel or the conflict (unlike the vast majority of their targets).

Alex S

It’s a bit of a flip comment but I do respect that it’s their show and they’re dealing with this situation the way they are comfortable with and respect them for it.

Colin Luton

But season 7 is on Blu-ray tho, which is why I'm a little confused, maybe Austin didn't know that when he said it but I just wanted clarification on why specifically it can't be covered. Maybe this is what the panel disagrees on

Holden Linnan

its not that the ask is unreasonable, if they had actual reason to boycott disney+ it would make sense, but theres no logic behind the boycott

Falcon

The one talked about the most was them asking people to ditch Windows and run Linux instead. Sounds pretty unreasonable to me. Idk if that's even on the website anymore though, because like others have said, their asks aren't clear. I shouldn't have to download a pdf to get the full story. I'm okay with being inconvenienced for a short time to support a just cause. I'm not okay with being asked to abandon a hobby/fandom I love for an indefinite amount of time with zero reasonable justification given with a scope that's either constantly changing or just straight up doesn't make sense. There is no sound logic to BDS and their asks around Disney.

Ron Crawford

Yeah even as someone who disagrees with the decision but will likely be sticking around, the total venom some people are coming at this with is wild. From the exact show people are heated about - aren’t you tired of fighting with people who agree with you?

Anthony

If something non-Star Wars is a possibility can I suggest: Mass Effect

Rick R.

As far as I can tell those are bootlegs and Disney has never released S7 or bad batch on physical media.

Holden Linnan

I understand that, but for me if the boycott in question has no logic behind, the source is irrelevant, I fully support Palestine and plan to donate to help but I don't want to follow the boycotts that make no sense

Postboy

And by that logic as well, they could pirate Andor and not watch it on Disney+, kind of blowing up the entire basis for the pivot.

A More Civilized Age: A Star Wars Podcast

Hey, we could've been clearer about this, but Obsidian developed KOTOR 2 for Lucasarts 21 years ago. Lucasarts is who owns and publishes and profits from KOTOR 2, not Microsoft, which only bought Obisidian a few years ago. Importantly: BDS has repeatedly outlined clear tiers of engagement with the Microsoft boycott, with the highest priority being Game Pass, then specific games, then all games published by their sublabels. KOTOR 2 is not any of those.

Postboy

If I had to guess, the first episode will likely be the tutorial section and the entirety of Peragus.

Ryan Wagner

Disney is a mega-corporation like any other, by that nature they are "evil" to an extent. But that's part of the bargain when we're watching Star Wars, an IP entirely owned by them, or listening to a podcast discussing Star Wars for entertainment. No one has given any explanation of how Disney is "mega-evil", especially wrt Palestine. Not even BDS themselves. Who, yes, are using a flimsy excuse of specifically casting two Israeli actresses two years ago... And otherwise have had 0 involvement in anything related to Israel/Palestine. We're not talking about Lockheed Martin here. We're not even talking about Coca-Cola here. (Edit: This was directed at the second half of taijitu's post)

Alex Cannella

Boy, I sure hope y'all pivot successfully. You're doing an incredibly noble thing at great personal sacrifice, but damn, real shame I'll never hear AMCA talk about Andor again. 🤣 Watching this space.

Defrost

What I don't understand is what the end game for the boycot is... Have disney destroy the media already made? Like what are the concession wanted by the movement from media companies?

Ryan Wagner

I'm aware of Walt Disney the individual's past. It has little bearing on the Walt Disney company of the modern day. It's also something that has been true as long as I've been alive, and thus also as long as Star Wars has been owned by Disney. I don't understand the ask for a Star Wars podcast to stop covering Star Wars. It's the entire mission statement of the project. If it starts covering some other topic... It ceases to be a Star Wars podcast and becomes a podcast about something else.

TheSaint

Covering Andor pushes people to Disney Plus. Even if they pirate personally, even if they start in and end every episode with “here’s how you torrent” it, the fact is most people will choose the easy way. By loudly and pointedly rejecting coverage in this moment, they give people a real push to take action. I canceled my subscription and based on the comments so have lots of other people. I am not under any illusion that is going suddenly change Disney or the Palestinians plight, nor are the hosts or anyone else supporting this. But despite how history sometimes portrays it, change doesn’t happen in a single moment. It’s a long an arduous process, filled with failures, regressions, and false starts before things truly get better. It was 32 years from the beginning of the South African boycott to the end of apartheid, 46 years from Stonewall to gay marriage and that fights far from over, and I’m sure along the way people were saying “this is pointless”, “this is performative”, “We’re hurting ourselves more than them”. Doing something doesn’t always work, but doing nothing never does. As Nemik says, you have to try. I say all this as someone with mixed feelings about this decision. I have been in a dark place for months and this was something I was desperately looking forward to and I feel rather depressed about this decision. I didn’t finish the first KOTOR series and I don’t know if I can do this next one. I fear quite strongly that this will be the death of the show, either completely or my own enjoyment of it. But it is pathetic weakness to do nothing and get mad others for using what little power they have to try something in face of the ongoing injustice and the general regression of human civilization. I’ve spent too long hiding, agonizing over all problems and yet unwilling to take even the smallest sacrifices to fight against it. I won’t do that here, I’d rather do something pointless and futile than self-servingly tell myself “There’s nothing I can do about it” again. Throwing a bucket of water on a house fire house might not do much, but it’s better than sitting on your ass while yelling that anything less than a firehose is pointless.

TheSaint

Playing a decades old game that is no longer canon is on a completely different level than covering show that is actively coming out on Disney Plus. Sure maybe a handful of people will play Kotor2 and go “Man, I really got watch Tales from the Jedi now, better sign up for Disney Plus”. But that will be more than offset by the people that hear their decision and decide to unsubscribe and avoid supporting Disney. As to being a “meaningful sacrifice”, again no one is expecting this be some decisive blow, no one is expecting this to be the beginning of the end for Israel or anything else. But just maybe it can be a small part of building up a movement, a single water drop of water in a slowly filling lake, a hope for a day when the dam overflows and real change can be effected. And on the flip side, if this sacrifice is so meaningless, why not just do it? Frankly, I’m choosing to take this as the kick in the ass. I canceled Prime and Audible, I reopened my long abandoned “Betterish Brands” document for updating, and I am researching my local protests. It isn’t much and might all be pointless, but sulking and complaining is definitely pointless. Do what you will and allow the rest of us to do what we can. Leftists have spent far too long bitching at each other about what to do rather doing anything and I for one am tired of being part of the problem, even if I am not sure if I am part of the solution.

Holden Linnan

all of your arguments hinge on the idea that boycotting disney+ is going to benefit directly or even indirectly Palestine, a very shakey idea that I personally don't think holds any ground

JC

1) All the more reason to set an example for their listeners to drop Disney Plus, by doing this they have brought more attention to the BDS campaign and can neither make people aware who weren’t before or inspire them to action 2) There is the threat of legal action if they explicitly say ‘go torrent this’ on a podcast that is decently known and that people in Disney are probably aware of in some shape or form

rosa www

aside from their asks about microsoft being pretty clear (& easily found by googling "bds microsoft" - you don't even have to download anything!), they also pretty much always say "boycott when possible". you are being asked to do something and then can make your own choices - if you don't think those asks are reasonable, sure. that's your opinion. i think you should probably make a better effort of informing yourself first, though ("i shouldn't have to download a pdf"? really? that's where you draw the line?). lastly, i don't think i can explain how callous you sound to me when you say you're "okay with being inconvenienced for a short time to support a just cause", genuinely. the genocide in gaza has been ongoing for almost 2 years now. the occupation of palestine for decades. as ogremode said, come on now

Lilith

People seem thrilled to unleash pent-up vitriol on each other in these comments, even though reading them suggests that almost everyone here is in complete support of Palestine and disagree on a specific boycott target of BDS and AMCA's approach to it. I guess it's simply hard for me to understand how that degree of misalignment warrants speaking to each other with contempt. What's the point?

Ron Crawford

Why Amazon/Audible? Is it just their general shittiness or was there a call for it I missed?

Karrius

Ok, Holden, you don't think it matters. The thing is, nobody thinks what you think matters either.

Holden Linnan

does that not also apply to you Karrius? I do not want to be disrespectful or rude to anyone whether I agree with them or not but if thats your argument then why is anyone saying anything at all?

Ross Disney

Everything by Gray and Freed should be the priority, then High Republic

Anna Lackey

I appreciate the clarification, I’m not very familiar with the games side of things. However, given that the issue is platforming/promoting and not direct financial support, I don’t agree with the logic that KOTOR II isn’t supporting Microsoft. I understand that they haven’t had much time to do research or give this the thorough discussion and thought this deserves, but I hope they consider this going forward.

Karrius

If you don't want to be disrespectful or rude, why are you continuing to be nothing but disrespectful and rude? We get it - you don't want to support the BDS movement. You've said so over and over and over. Move along.

Thomas Bennett

Sad to hear we won’t be getting Andor season 2 (for now), glad you guys are standing in solidarity with BDS, and excited for what the civies are cooking up for “this space” with the opening. If I might, I’d like to add my voice to the recommendations for Reign of the Empire: The Mask of Fear. Alexander Freed absolutely cooked with that one.

Holden Linnan

well apparently I haven't said it enough because I do support the BDS movement, that doesn't mean I'm going to follow everything it says blindly, that is the whole point of what I've been trying to say

Karrius

What low effort trolling. The boycott is bad because it's useless backpatting, but then suddenly it's bad for not boycotting enough. 0/10 try harder.

Karrius

No, you don't. Why not just be honest? You keep saying "It's irrational, it's irrational", saying you don't care about their reasoning. You don't care - that's fine. Just be honest and don't pretend to hold positions you don't!

Holden Linnan

I do, but you seem to be incapable of understanding that I can agree with you on a movement but have a difference of opinion on a smaller part of it, not everything is black and white. I'm not gonna reply anymore because you seem to care more about coming after me than actually commenting on the situation and talking about, I hope you have a good day Karrius :)

grant crawford

Hey guys, I would listen to you all talk about anything but if you are sticking to SW you still got: JJM's KOTOR comics, the Cal Kestis games, Hunters before it gets shut down, Zahn's new trilogy (or old sequel duology), Pak's Vader comics, hell, Galaxy of Fear

TheSaint

Bit of both, they are on the BDS list alongside Disney, though they ask to avoid products (ie Ring cameras) rather than canceling subscriptions. I chose to do that because of their kowtowing to Trump (canceling DEI, donations, sponsoring the Easter event, etc). It was something I was already considering and had already curtailed my ordering. It’s impossible to avoid everything shitty, but with a little effort, you’d surprised how much better you can do. I recently went to a local computer parts store when I built a new computer rather than ordering off Amazon and quite enjoyed the experience. It was more expensive but the people were very helpful and returning was easy after an incompatible part. I also found a gardening company that is employee owned when I needed some irrigation parts. It took longer, but it feels a lot nicer to support workers than Bezos.

Falcon

I have been looking into it more, and it still makes zero sense. Under their "Consumer boycott priority targets" there are companies like HP, Dell, and Reebok. (These are seemingly blanket boycott everything listings, not the "boycott when possible" companies.) But then there's Disney+. Not Disney the company, just the service Disney+. And under that they list... two movies that aren't even on Disney+. It makes no sense. Multiple people here have already stated very well that the inclusion of Disney in any fashion is dubious at best. Also, their Microsoft boycott ISN'T EVEN ON THE BOYCOTT PAGE. Why is it on a separate page? Make up your minds! Multiple comments on here have talked about a pdf that seemingly gives more information than what's available on their website. I'm taking their word for it. Am I supposed to throw out everything made in China because of what they're doing to the Uyghurs? No, because that's unreasonable. I also think it's unreasonable to indefinitely boycott the biggest entertainment company/properties in the world because they happened to cast a couple of Israeli people (years ago at this point) in all of two movies. If I let my heart bleed for every just cause, I'll have nothing left. I've seen what can happen to people that get wrapped up in this sort of stuff. Am I privileged to be able to say that. Yes, to a degree. But I'm just a guy. One person. I work. I have issues just like everyone else. I do what I can, where I can, when I can. Inb4 I'm a Disney shill. I think all the major corporations should be taxed into the ground, pay workers living wages, etc. I can support a cause in my own way. However, I'm not going to blindly support an organization that makes illogical or unreasonable asks simply because the cause is just.

Allen Boudreaux

While in principle I agree with the pro-Palestine politics here and respect your right to make this decision, I was excited to hear your take on Andor and I just don’t have it in me to stick around for another year of y’all playing an outdated video game. I feel like you’d do more good for the cause by applying your progressive political lens to the world of Andor and the events this season will cover (which would make for particularly incisive and potentially edifying discussion around the topic of the war in Gaza) than following an ideological purity boycott that if not applied and justified selectively in this way should probably just end a podcast about a Disney-owned franchise entirely. I am, respectfully, out.

disasterlaster

I respect the decision. Kind of wish this had been announced earlier than yesterday but understand it's a tough choice. I'd be lying if I said this wasn't disappointing but not getting podcast coverage is nothing compared to what people are enduring in Gaza and the West Bank so I can't meaningfully complain.

Rose Guillamire

I'm much more down on KOTOR II than I used to be (I don't care about the bugs/cut content, I just think it's very of its time) so I don't think I can bear to listen to a podcast about it. But I'll wander back once you folks move on to the next thing.

October

Difficult situation, respect the decision to delay/cancel. I think the BDS D+ decision is relatively flimsy but won’t litigate the small stuff. But that motivation means it’s unlikely to be removed from the list, which is a pretty fundamental challenge to a project explicitly exploring Disney’s Star Wars.

TrueLily

There's nothing leftists hate more than other leftists with different views.

Perditax

Thanks for doing this, must have been a tough decision. Even though I spent all yesterday refreshing my feed just in case, I was actually relieved when I read your post. It would have hung over the episodes if you hadn't addressed it and I think this was probably the right call

Joramsim

i'm happy that you stick to your guns. i really am. But i doubt not watching disney+ because they casted 2 israeli actors some years ago has more of an impact then your show has on people. I know the show you are providing has continuously been something that has kept me going, giving me something to look forward to and been something that gives me joy in times where its hard for me to get that. I doubt i am the only person feeling that way. You guys had an impact. A massive one. You kept me going many times. I know this sounds harsh but this feels like doing away with something that has a real, actual positive impact on people for something that, im sorry for this choice of words for lack of better vocabulary, feels more like "virtue signaling" than something that will actually do anything to end the injustices in palestine. Covering Andor and using that time to talk and raise awareness about the genocide in palestine would probably be more effective. I doubt I can change your minds about this but i am really sorry but i tried with the kotor coverage before and it just doesnt... do it for me. i am really sad because now one of the anchors that kept me going has disappeared for something that feels like a somewhat flimsy reason to me, I would think donating money as long as you cover disney+ stuff would be more effective in helping palestinians than not watching star wars. I am sad to say goodbye to this show but i just dont have any interest in what this podcast will be covering for the foreseeable future and therefore i am sadly out. I will miss you guys, you really were a light in my life. This one really hurts.

Colin

I support the ongoing BDS movement, but I don’t understand how this wing of it could produce actual tangible results. Both movies are already made, so what can Disney possibly do to get off the list?

Joramsim

I dont know if all that I wrote makes sense so I want to say whats most important to me: You guys have had an Impact on people. A massive impact. On me at least. Doing away with that for something that will not have any influence on the situation instead of using your platform to have an impact in this specific case, using your coverage of an anti-fascist show to raise awareness or donating income from covering disney+ would be things that can actually help. It is you guys' decision but respectfully, I believe you chose wrong.

Kai Z hasler

I honestly don't mind the pivot; it's about what works for you and what decisions you can live with. If disney era books are still on the table I second mask of fear and the new thrawn trilogy. I also think its fun to take a look back at old legends stuff. I'd be interested to see your critical take on the clone commandos books. Or if the plan was to get to the original trilogy in time, that has physical versions, so why not skip ahead?

Kai Z hasler

I think lasats should have facial fur as well tho, I think that would make them less cursed

John-Paul Bala

Wouldn't it be more impactful to give a portion of what you guys get to help Palestine? Do charity streams and raise awareness about the genocide? Every episode talk about whats happening and how people can help? Incoporate it into your coverage of Andor? Like many have said you guys have had a real impact on me and my politics. I am the person I am today because of you and all the work you've done here and in so many other places. I don't know the numbers but to me it seems like so many people jumped on the podcast when you first covered Andor. If you covered the 2nd season you could really make a difference to all those new people. Have the courage to remind them every single episode of the horrors that are happening right now in Gaza and convince them to help in any way you can. I hope you guys change your mind one day but I'll continue supporting anyway because you're a big part of my life and I do really believe your voices have an incredible impact on people.

TrueLily

Wanted to voice that I understand the difference in opinion and ultimately will support either decision here. It doesn't really matter to me what you cover, I'll be Watching This Space either way, but it's ultimately a personal matter for you four to decide what you're comfortable with.

James L

I can't help but be disappointed by the news. But I also know that what makes this show so enjoyable is that all of you do it because you want to and that cannot be forced. Maybe this hurt is just from the last minute nature of it all? My level of dejection has me thinking about "parasocial relationships" so I think I will need to take a step back from listening for a while. Hopefully I can enjoy a nice backlog of episodes at a later date. My own head has been full of questions that are probably full of straw-man arguments, false-equivalencies, and other fancy fallacies with Wikipedia pages. And I don't want my selfish rambling to give the impression that I don't support Palestinian justice. So you can stop reading now if you like, I just needed to put my thoughts somewhere. ----- In the current era of box office results and an obsession if media is profitable, I have tried to take up the mindset that the only thing that matters is if the art was made at all. Having a massive show about fascism, colonialism, other themes made by people like Diego Luna, a member of the Zapatista movement, feels more like pulling off a successful heist rather than anything. I know there is "no ethical consumption under capitalism" but I also know that it is used as an excuse to do nothing. This is one of the conflicts in my head. I also think that this podcast sells itself short on it's levels of influence. You have even hinted (maybe jokingly) that Tony Gilroy at least knows about your show. Your coverage of the only, and maybe last, major show covering the political issues we all care about does have more impact than anything I can do. I have learned so much about media literacy and critique from this podcast, especially from your Andor coverage. Maybe that isn't something to be proud of? I also know culture and its impact is hard to quantify, but saying it is worth it for the lost Disney revenue to pressure them to act, somehow isn't fitting in my head. I understand the BDS strategy of targeted boycotts over untargeted. And while I see their monetary and capital focused goals for the other companies, the Disney+ boycott has no stated method of removing itself from the list. I already hadn't watched either of the mentioned films and both are not Disney+ exclusive productions, having had full theatrical runs. Targeting Disney over other studios who have also worked against Palestinian liberation by supporting certain actors feels more like bad luck rather than being part of a movement. Is there any plan to talk to anyone at BDS on the show or otherwise to try and find a way forward? I enjoyed hearing from Adam Conover during the strikes about how progress was going with the dispute, and also learning that certain studios had negotiated their own side deals to keep working. But I know that all this was a surprise to you also. The harshest thought I can't get out of my head is that if the BDS movement is the leading authority for Palestinian liberation through this collective boycott action, why was it only discovered and announced hours before the scheduled release of the Andor coverage? But I know that is an unfair question. Another gap in my head that I need to find a way across is that this is "just a podcast" and "that it is important that this podcast silence itself to take a stand." At the most selfish level, Andor Season 1 and this podcast as a companion piece was perhaps my favourite media experience. The sense of a community enjoying a work of art together was new to me and I have no ready replacement. I am not on discord or other social media sites. I don't talk to people about art like this, so I enjoyed listening and learning. Writing this comment has been painful.

scarlet

We all have to do what's right for us and the world we want to live in. Good luck, you're clearly taking some heat and I hope people chill and remember that what we like about the show is you guys. If you were betraying yourselves to do it, it wouldn't have been as good. Hearing you all talk about the books was hella fun and I LOVE B5, but I think I remember there's a different podcast with some media crit gays doing B5 right now

justthisguyok

"because they cast two israeli actors" is at best an ignorant and at worst an intentionally disingenuous characterization for the reason and purpose of the boycott. Gal Godot sepcifically is an Israeli right wing media ambassador and propagandist. I would suggest you do a little more research on the topic before accepting that narrative at face value, if the issue means anything to you.

Mathew Finch

More specifically, the call to action for BDS is to cancel Disney+

Flynn Nicholls

Support y’all’s decision. I’m sure it wasn’t easy to make, especially on short notice and with differing opinions. Looking forward to KOTOR 2!

Benjamin Walker

You guys. They are doing a literal genocide with a smear campaign/inciting of rebels to justify it arc on Andor. Everyone already boycotted the shows/movies that put them on the list because they are uninteresting. BDS is just straight up incorrect for including them on the list. Other streamers carry content that is much more overtly hostile to the victims in this genocide and they aren't even on their boycott list.

Mike

I started listening to the the pod because of Andor S1 but stuck around because I was interested in what you were talking about, regardless of the specific topic. I was really looking forward to listening to your S2 commentary, but I am willing to follow you on the pivot.

Brendan Connors

I like your analogy, and I suspect this was exactly the line of thinking for the AMCA member(s) who advocated for the pause & pivot. However, I think there's a real possibility that decision will kill A More Civilized Age in the long term. That would be doing more harm than good, certainly in general, but also specifically to the Free Palestine movement. AMCA picked up a LOT of listeners during Andor S1, and we've been eagerly awaiting their real-time coverage of S2. We're hungry, and are likely to satiate our hunger with other podcasts. No other SW podcast is as far left or as Pro-Palestine as AMCA. It's entirely reasonable for the hosts (and us listeners) to consider whether they could be of more help by repeatedly talking about Palestine during the pod to their growing listener base.

Brendan Connors

A more apt metaphor ight be someone who's house is burning down asking you to crash your car into a fire hydrant. It's not just an inconvenient sacrifice for you, it could financially ruin you. And it's not likely to help save the house (fire hydrants don't turn into fountains if you crash into them like in the movies).

J. Yabuki

I usually don't comment on things like this, and am very conflict-averse. Also, sorry for further cluttering this comments section with further discussion on an unrelated point. However, something about the responses to your decision here and elsewhere really struck a nerve with me, as a trans woman and a person of color. There is value in discussing the efficacy of different tactics. However, there is also value in being heard. As a trans woman, when somebody is willing to fight for me, to listen to me, even when it's hard, even when it won't do much, that's an act of love. As a person of color, when someone is willing to fight for me, to listen to me, even when it's hard, even when it won't do much, that too is an act of love. Love is hard to come by. We live in a world that is powered by malevolence and indifference. Nobody gets out clean. The television shows that you love fund propaganda for genocidal bombing campaigns. The books you love fund transgender suicides. Amidst all of this, you have the opportunity to offer some of your love to the ones the world is trying so desperately to crush. To offer them an ear, to offer them a little relief, by turning off your television and putting down your books for just a moment. It may not be a tactically necessary move. You might not get anything out of it. But for the recipients of your love, it is life-affirming, and it is vital. That so many people would so bitterly refuse to do so—because they can't conceive of sacrificing even the smallest things—because they have never had to consider that they live in a world inhabited not only by narratives, but also by people—it hurts. But I am glad that you are sticking to your principles. Thank you.

Craig

I will continue to listen as AMCA becomes a Star Wars video game podcast for the rest of its existence, but I am sad for this decision as it does seems to be the death kneel for the pod. The movies are already out (and, hey, both essentially bombed) and boycotting seems like it will only hurt AMCA and will not harm Disney in the slightest. I respect your decision to take a principled stance on something that is important to the collective, I just am saddened that it happened at this stage. I understand the discovery of the boycott was just made, but the timing feels strange.

Joramsim

I fully understand and respect what you are saying here but I think that there needs to be added another perspective here. The things you are describing as "the smallest things" can be the things other people hold onto for their life. I think it is unfair to set a universal value for certain things because of how you feel about them and then putting a moral obligation around it. As a member of the LGBTQ+ community myself I think allyship is very important and what you are saying here is totally true and valid about feeling heard and loved - but that isnt what the palestinians need. They are being starved, bombed, massacred out there. They need awareness and aid. This Podcast can provide both better by raising awareness and raising money on their platform to the biggest audience they possibly can - and that is what they get by continuing their work. Because their work is already what keeps some people going, just read these comments. For many people this podcast is the place where they can think about something they love, this podcast educates people, this podcast makes people look forward to the next week. Why take that away for something that does not have an impact on the situation? Why is that trade worth it?

J. Yabuki

Thank you for trying to understand. I don’t think you do. I can see how one could come to this conclusion if they viewed “the Palestinians” as a problem to be solved by Western interlocutors without their input. This is, perhaps, the hegemonic position of Western society writ large. Still, I am frustrated that so many people value a TV show more than they value solidarity with oppressed people. Frankly, I find this whole thing deeply dehumanizing. In any case, genuinely, thank you for trying to understand. I hope one day we will see eye to eye.

J. Yabuki

Also, I’d like to clarify—I don’t think this is some kind of great sacrifice. I think it’s basically nothing, in terms of what is being sacrificed. The fact that some people feel so threatened by it is what bothers me.

Scottee

Speaking from my own entirely honest stance as a listener... Honestly, I really enjoy your discussions, but I don't think I can hang on for another full playthrough of a game I could never get into, only for it to then be followed up by books I could never get into. I don't see a way for Disney to get off BDS' list considering they already released the movies and they already flopped. I first found this podcast and learned a lot about progressive causes, and came to support the AMCA and F@TT Patreons off and on specifically from your coverage of Andor S1. I wish it was, but I don't think this particular instance of this particular boycott is going to be helpful. I don't think that refusing to cover one of the most prominently anti-fascist TV shows being made will actually be a net benefit. I don't think that ceding this particular ground of cultural discussion is going to have a positive impact. Still, I wish you all the best.

Scottee

That seems... Sort of weird? So it would be better to buy it physically and give Disney money instead of, I don't know, happening to visit a friend's house and seeing it play on their laptop because they happened to find and download it online?

Falcon

I haven't seen anyone here claim to value Star Wars more than human life. A lot of people are disagreeing with AMCA's decision because the BDS movement asks around Disney don't make sense. 1) BDS calls out only D+ and not Disney as a whole. Why? Giving Disney money for physical releases is okay? Why? Not to mention going to a Disney park gives them WAY MORE money than a D+ sub. 2) It seems that BDS's only reason is that two (non-Star Wars) Disney movies simply have Israeli actors (hired years ago), but those movies aren't even on D+. 3) BDS offers no explanation for how "Disney+" can get itself removed from their list, so this boycott is indefinite I guess. At least one member of AMCA connected the same dots as well since they were in disagreement over this decision. This podcast started as a group of people watching and talking about Star Wars tv shows, a property owned by Disney. Future events obviously aren't predictable, but cmon. They had to at least be generally aware of what they were signing up for. It's disappointing for so many listeners because they're halfway through this journey and are seemingly all of a sudden getting cold feet that Star Wars is owned by Disney. This is all compounded by this coming at a time when their voice is needed most.

Littlest Longbow

Surprised to see how many comments are on this decision, I’m still gonna be watching Andor and will miss your coverage but I 100% support y’all’s decisions. I mean at the end of the day you guys provide the content that we consume and if people don’t want it they can just unsubscribe. But I really respect yall for taking this stance and I like the excuse to play KOTOR 2. See yall on the Ebon Hawk

RetroMG

I support the decision ya'll have made. I was looking forward to the Andor coverage but I'm excited to hear about KOTOR 2. I've never been able to get into KOTOR 1 or 2 but I enjoyed listening to you talk about KOTOR 1

RetroMG

Also on the topic of "watching this space," I would absolutely love to listen to you guys discuss virtually any piece of media. Bab 5, Hannibal, whatever. You guys mentioned Severance once and I have been DYING to hear your thoughts on Severance. If you ever decide to branch out, I'm 1000% in.

justthisguyok

The answers to your questions are clearly answered on the BDS website. The reason it's only D+ is because unsubscribing from D+ takes literally 20 seconds so people will actually do it. Whereas "don't consume any media made by any corporation with ties to Isreal" requires a bunch of work from well-meaning people and they are more likely not to participate if the ask is this large. It's the bare minimum to send a message.

Tom Burmeister

Mad pivot - HBOs 2000s show Rome - the original 'More Civilized Age!' ;-) Thirteen!

justthisguyok

"it's open to many competing framings, such as this completely false one that I'm trying to sell you" lmao

Falcon

That actually answers none of my questions. But you know what's even easier than canceling your D+ sub? Not watching the movies that BDS seemingly has a problem with (again, for dubious reasons). Which, again, are not even on D+. BDS's boycott of other companies seem to be a flat total blanket boycott of the companies outright. If DIsney is so bad, why is a single service they provide being the thing called out? Can I buy a Reebok shirt and just not their shoes? See how their treatment of Disney doesn't make sense? And how is Disney supposed to get off the list? Their problem is effectively that the movies exist with the people that are in them. But Disney can't unrelease or unmake the movies. They're already out in theaters. People have seen them. So again, what's the point of calling out those movies in relation to D+?

justthisguyok

I'm gonna be honest with you I'm not gonna get into a nitpicky little debate about BDS strategy with you. I think it is very telling that when asked to do something very small by a longstanding Palestinian activism campaign that your response is to barrel into the discussion with Big White Nerd Energy to say they're doing it wrong. They are asking for your allyship. If you don't wanna give it, then that's for you to live with.

Falcon

The details DO matter because THEY DON'T MAKE SENSE. At no point does BDS directly link Disney/D+ to the Israeli government. Does boycotting tech companies that directly supply Israel with hardware/software make sense. For sure. Does boycotting a media company because Israeli actors exist make sense? No. BDS has done literally nothing to connect those dots. Am I Pro-Palestine? Unequivocally yes. Am I going to blindly follow the asks of a single Pro-Palestine organization without thinking about it? No.

Patrick Kay

Hope y'all get to cover more modern "Canon" stories in novels and comics that aren't tied to Disney+. Speaking overall I think the current crop of writing 2014 forward is much higher than it was in the EU, even with TROS being a whiff. You have two separate Thrawn background trilogies, all of The High Republic, Doctor Aphra, and multiple good video games to choose from. I may even recommend the Aftermath trilogy to understand the construction of the new "Canon" (though you'll have to hold your nose at Wendig). Hell, even the recent Lego stuff is extremely funny and quasi-canonical. I think anywhere you take the podcast will lead to more Star Wars appreciation, so the world is your bounty!

Moxie

As a long time listener who has never posted I felt compelled to jump on here to say that I am in full support of your decision to not cover Andor in solidarity with Palestine! Part of the reason I listen to this series is that y’all are outstanding human beings, and this shows that.

Zach G

Gee a lot of people want to claim "Pro-Palestinian" while shitting on and nit-picking the methods of a Palestinian organization. Get the fuck over yourselves if you think that watching a TV show is somehow praxis and more important than a very thought-out and deliberate boycott campaign. If cancelling Disney+ is too much for you then stop pretending you are progressive and just shut up - we don't need to see your half-assed comments about how you actually know more about this issue than the people dedicating their lives to it. For fucks sake I've never seen more pathetic people in my life. Whining about a fucking podcast while people are being burned alive. Western apathy has never been so disgusting.

Holden Linnan

you do realize that at least one person on the podcast agrees that the boycott on d+ doesn't make sense as they said they debated it?

Jacob Magraw

Love the pod and respect the decision

Karrius

The other boycotts aren't even total boycotts. You're just making stuff up. They don't make sense to you because people are trying to explain it to you, and you refuse to listen. The problem is entirely with you. It's not "because there are israeli actors". There's more detail than that. But again - you refuse to listen, and you intentionally misrepresent what is being said. You're either bad faith or very stupid.

Astrid

My first thought when I read this was just "Well, this kind of sucks but you can't force a willing mind". People are talking like you will have a good pod come out of doing something members aren't comfortable with and that just isn't true. But reading all these comments makes me think that declining to engage with D+ actually can make some slight positive difference, an absolutely worthy effort for a four person podcast (+producer). Whether it gives some slight hope to Palestinians in the diaspora or just makes your common or garden subscriber have a half minute of introspection on the topic, I absolutely support the stance.

Rachael Ward

As a long time listener of AMCA, I will confess to being a little bummed out on having to wait on hearing your thoughts about Andor Season 2. I really enjoyed the feeling of watching along with you all when season 1 came out and I continue to revisit those episodes. That said, I respect your decision and your integrity for staying true to your beliefs.

Rachael Ward

That and I'm super stoked of the opportunity to play KOTOR 2 with all of you. Of the two KOTOR games, the ideas presented in the sequel continue to fascinate me to this day and any time the main franchise touches or hints at those ideas gets me very excited. I.e Yoda in season 2 of Rebels saying "Malachor" made me jump out of my seat. Looking forward to making a new Jedi exile and playing through an old favorite that I haven't played in half a decade. Thank you AMCA! Will definitely continue to "Watch this Space"

Falcon

So the AMCA crew is very stupid? Because at least one person on there came to the same conclusion. "The following are the BDS movement’s current top priority boycott and pressure international corporate targets. We have split these targets into three sections: 1. Consumer boycott priority targets - The BDS movement calls for a complete boycott of these brands carefully selected due to each company's proven record of complicity in Israeli apartheid." "1. Consumer boycott priority targets: Chevron (including Caltex and Texaco brands) Intel DELL Siemens Hewlett Packard (HP) Carrefour AXA Reebok Disney+ SodaStream RE/MAX Israeli produce and other products in your supermarkets" "Disney+ Cancel or don’t sign up for Disney+ subscriptions! Disney and its subsidiary Marvel are complicit in glorifying Israel’s regime of genocide and apartheid against Indigenous Palestinians. Marvel’s Captain America: Brave New World and Disney’s Snow White star actors Shira Haas and Gal Gadot, respectively, that have consciously and irrefutably taken up roles as cultural ambassadors for Israel, directly representing genocidal Israel’s propaganda efforts. For Captain America, Marvel and Disney are reviving the racist character of Ruth Bat-Seraph, whose decades-old backstory includes working for Mossad. Disney+ is therefore clearly implicated in enabling Israel’s genocide by dehumanizing Palestinians." That is all, word for word, directly from BDS's boycott page. They call for a "complete boycott" of the targets listed as "Consumer boycott priority targets". Disney+ is on that list. Under the D+ entry the only "evidence" they provide for D+ being complicit is that... Israeli actors exist in Cap 4 and Snow White. I've heard sus stuff about Gal Gadot, but as far as I know they didn't make her the Queen of Israeli in the movie. And again, the Israeli character in Cap 4 just exists. In the final product she works for the US military. The only similarity to the character of the same name from the comics is that she's from Israel. Disney has nothing to do with however that character was written in the comics decades ago. How do either of those instances in any way equate to Disney funding genocide? If BDS has a problem with those actors, how does that get D+ on the list? Those movies aren't even on D+. If they have a problem with those actors/movies, then call for a boycott of those actors and/or movies. Not to mention, Gadot was cast in 2021 and filming took place in 2022. The current conflict didn't even start until 2023. But that's not the case BDS is making right now. They said these Israeli actors exist in Disney movies, so boycott D+ even though these movies aren't on D+. The dots don't connect, and the ask doesn't make sense even if they did.

MK

I came here to say this as well. Although I am a massive NJO defender and I think it's the best long form thing in the old EU and, for me, features some of the best arcs (personal and political) in Star Wars. I'll caveat by saying that I grew up with this series and fundamentally it defined my star wars fandom more than anything else (even the films) and to a large extent the characters who came out of the EU are the ones I am most attached to in star wars. For AMCA purposes I think they'd need to at least read the X-wing novels, I, Jedi, and the Hand of Thrawn Duology for it to resonate fully. But if you like Star Wars at it's most serious and self reflective, I think the NJO does that really well. Nothing else challenges the political and spiritual dimensions of the universe so comprehensively and I think the Yuuzhan Vong are such a fully realized entity and a rare wholly original creation in Star Wars. But mostly, Nom Anor is that dude and needs more press. A more practical suggestion is to go full sith Karpshyn's unbelievable Bane trilogy, which can be read in a vacuum and is just 3 bangers in a row, followed by Luceno's Darth Plagueis, which is the most heroic piece of lore gap filling. It gives such an incredible portrait of the vast conspiracy that's behind the Prequel trilogy.

Will

Nothing but love and respect for y’all. Being able to make decisions under complicated circumstances and continue to respect each other is why I continue to have such respect for y’all.

Elliot Reynolds

my humble suggestion for Watch This Space: Farscape

Ethan Lindsey

I agree - alphabet squadron or the new canon Thrawn trilogy would also be worthy.

noshotsfired.tv

Maybe but they can’t let that get in the way of their righteous screed.

John Gaucher

Austin, regarding your thoughts on the effectiveness of media criticism and if it moves any political needle. Through your criticism you have given me a lot of mental tools and actual referential tools for real life and I have used them. Like the show said, every small thing is part of resistance. You have had an impact on my life with your criticism. Devaluing your work a bit! Cheers AMCA.

ARC-7271

I’ve been a listener for almost 2 years now and this is my first time commenting, but I just listened to the first part of the latest episode and wanted to leave a positive comment in support of you all. I think I’ve seen some of the Reddit threads you guys brought up and I can only imagine how awful it would be to read for you, given how frustrated I was with many of them. While I’m super disappointed to not hear you guys talk about Andor S2, Clone Wars S7, etc. for a while, I completely understand the various reasons and issues you all mentioned and totally respect the decision to not compromise anyone’s values. I’ll be here for KOTOR II and whatever else you decide to do next! Free Palestine 🍉

K M

hi, i had been a patron supporter for a while then had to step back because of financial reasons but i wanted to reup my support given whats going on and the respect i have for you guys for making this decision. also kotor 2 is one of my favorite video games of all time so im fucking HYPE and hope you guys have fun. my fav unromanceable companion of all time is in this game (***-***) so i hope someone else also gets angry that hes unromanceable

Matthew York

Austin, make them watch Gundam. That’s in space.

Kevin Hoerr

Not to add more noise and also respond out of band with the new mainfeed episode, I fully support y'all's decision to pivot, and am more hyped that eventually you would be able to cover one episode a week! Doing an arc an episode would be an insane pace especially for how Andor season 2 is playing out. Also really appreciate the in-depth discussion around weight of media and media criticism in the world of living under empire, as Austin has said previously - this is why I love listening to the pod more than the "content" itself! This has given me the opportunity to actually finish up KOTOR I (I stopped around Manaan and just listened to the rest of the episodes posted) in preparation for playing along with KOTOR II. I suppose the stories aren't that interconnected but it helps me feel engaged with y'all in that way. I feel that way about the books too - I suppose it's easier for people to get on board when covering shows but the books and games are Content and I am here for it! Watching this space!

K

Hey yall I’ve been listening since the start and after the last mainstream feed i felt like i should chip in too: totally support your decision, appreciate yall talking about your decisions and reasons. Discussing how people react to terrible things and why is….also what the Star Wars discussions are about? Anyway, I am just interested in what yall have to say pretty much regardless of the content. All the pivots have introduced me to interesting Star Wars content I would never have known about otherwise. For example, loved when yall talked about the omnibus of comics. Also LOVED when you brought Adam on for an in depth discussion of the SAG strike! I played that for a lot of friends! Anyway, love listening, yall are doing great and I appreciate you.

Heather Eileen

Sorry to hear people have reacted negatively about the decision to not cover Andor season 2. I understand and support y'all (besides, it gives me time to rewatch season 1 on bluray). Looking forward to hearing about KOTOR 2

jo

hi! after listening to the main feed episode, i also just wanted to add my voice here! i completely support y'all in doing KOTOR and i'm really looking forward to it!! it's disappointing to hear that you've received the response you have, especially because this is your show as creators!! i love listening to it and it's a very special part of my week that i always look forward to, but that doesn't mean i have any sort of ownership over it! so while i don't really feel like my 'support' is necessary for the show to PIVOT!, i did really want to say how excited i am about this direction, how much i appreciate the show and all you do to make it, and the political angle you bring to both the analysis of the media and to the creation of the show itself! i have enormous respect for you all :)

moet

Long time fan of the pod, and just wanted to say that I really respect your guys' decision, and appreciate the candid discussion about how you came to this decision. Very excited for the KOTOR 2 coverage, and looking forward to whatever you guys do in the future!

John Goodson

Wanted to chip in and mention that the decision to pivot and the well considered discussion there got me to finally become a patron

Ayao

In the scenario that showing solidarity means giving up Star Wars for the rest of time, then it's worth more to give up Star Wars. There's plenty of other distractions out there in the world to talk about, it's no big deal.

OGMisterTea

Thank you for continuing to demonstrate in public navigating the complexity of how to be a person you want to be

The Narrator

Yes! Farscape is great, unique, and rather Star Wars-esque in many ways.

The Narrator

While I'm sad to have to wait to hear your thoughts on Andor Season 2, I understand your reasons. I've been boycotting Amazon since 2012 over their labor practices, so I know hard it can be to get other people to understand why you're giving up a convenience for conscience. I also wanted to let you know that I would be super enthusiastic to hear you all discuss the Aaron Allston X-Wing novels, as those are some of my favorite books since I was a teenager. There was also a suggestion of doing other scifi shows, so may I suggest Farscape? It was a very unusual show for its era, and Star Wars-esque in being a space opera with an anti-authority streak.

Sylvie

For what it's worth I'd like to offer a message of support and uncertainty. I have no idea what the right thing to do is, and I don't know if there is a single right thing. I found contradictory positions put forth by several hosts to be compelling. It seems pretty clear that everyone is acting in good faith under circumstances less than ideal. I'm sorry for the people being terrible. I've been looking forward to the Clone Wars finale longer than anyone's been looking forward to Andor Season Two and I don't mind waiting longer for both. KOTOR II will be a very fun time, and I'll follow this podcast's fun and insightful brand of analysis where it goes, through however many Sheev pivots it takes. As long as I have the income I'll be keeping up my support.

Sylvie

And hey, if this goes on, maybe this will be the perfect time for AMCA to boldly go. DS9 in particular feels relevant, and Lower Decks is a gem.

Ben Callicott

I also wanted to add my voice to those that are supporting the team’s decision to pivot to KOTOR 2. I have supported this show since day one and will continue to do so as long as I can. Authenticity and integrity is always appreciated. Continue being true to yourselves. Love the latest ep and I’ve enjoyed having an excuse to replay a beloved game. All the best to the four of you.

Jesus

God I miss Mister Tua

Maggie Hussung

I really appreciate y'all making the call to boycott Disney+ rn. Nothing but love and respect for y'all. We've waiting years for Andor season 2 and we can keep waiting, I'm sure y'all coverage is gonna kill it whenever it makes sense to cover it. Sorry part of the audience is mid <33

Jennifer Simonovich

Just a quick note to say thank you for your clarity and thoughtfulness and that you have my full support! 💜

Emily Lewis

Honestly, even setting aside any and all ethical and political questions of the boycott, I think it’s great that you’re waiting on Andor. Not rushed and not having to do whole arcs together to keep up with the show release sounds like a win to me.

Mike

I'd just like the record to show my money is for Austin's LP and I don't even know what a podcast is

Parker

Not sure I'm saying anything that hasn't already been said, but I really appreciate your thoughtfulness and transparency. It's a difficult thing to navigate as an individual, but as not only a group but a group with a platform, it's a thousand times more difficult, and I appreciate your consideration of all the dynamics involved. I am grateful for the frank discussion of ambiguity, compromise, and personal ethics; whether it's Star Wars or BDS, y'all have always provided valuable insights and helped me and many others approach and grapple with things from new perspectives. The backlash is frustrating, especially because you're great about not bringing that attitude to your perspectives; I admire your ability to strike a balance between empathy and assertiveness and your willingness to admit your own mistakes or doubts. It has alway felt to me more honest than preachy, and that's rare. Keep up the good work; I look forward to more KOTOR and whatever else is on the horizon.

Eribu

❤️ and positive feedback b/c it's disheartening to hear y'all have had a deficit of that lately. Was I excited to hear about Andor S2, a television series I only know through your coverage? Yes. Am I excited to hear about Kotor II, a game series I've always been been curious about but only know through your coverage? Also yes. Also looking forward to more novels!

Eribu

I'm here because I am fundamentally uninterested in hearing about Star Wars from ppl who think empire is good. A consequence of believing that empire is bad and having integrity in a world dominated by empire is that there's going to be difficult, troubling questions. The show you make is good *because* this was a hard decision for you. I'd infinitely rather yall take your time and get to Andor whenever you get to it (or not) than burn yourself out worrying if making your show is betraying yourself.

Marandahir

Late to the party, but I was surprised during the last Rebels AMCA episode that you missed commenting on your boy Gilead Pelleaon!

Verdigree

The Mortis Fam never bugged me that much, and after Rebels, I feel they're by no means singularly unique or all-important, they're just more humanoid looking than the wolves or the Bendu and looking at them as one face of a Force with infinite facets, I'm way more endeared to those wierdos