Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

We may not have been there on opening night, but AMCA went to the opening weekend of The Mandalorian and Grogu and recorded this on the evening of Memorial Day while the experience was still fresh. It's a good thing, too, because as we write this summary it's proving impossible to recall details of what we talked about. The gang kept returning to the question of the film's raison d'etre. Does it stand on its own as a Star Wars movie? Does it serve to expand the creative possibility space of The Mandalorian? Does it speak to people who don't follow Disney's Star Wars output closely? Does it speak to those who do? Do we still like Grogu? Where's Kallus? Did all those Hutts deserve to die in an airstrike? Should the New Republic have an all-cameo pilot fighter squadron? Is this a Dave Filoni movie? A Jon Favreau movie? Do we remember? Does it matter? Do you ever think about how a movie can be dumb and good like Point Break?

Comments

Patrick Kay

I don't feel like writing an email but y'all should do the Star Wars (2015) Marvel comics run also, Kieron Gillen takes it over at some point and most all modern canon comics are pretty good! Hope you enjoyed or "enjoyed" the movie!

Bobby Chaudhuri

OMG, I can't believe that you all went to see this movie and yet still not cover the Peabody awarding winning Andor season 2, no offense to you guys, as it kinda belies your decision not to cover Andor season two. Regardless I hope that somehow enjoyed this movie though it sounds like this movie "could have been this or that..." but never realizes any of a cinematic vision or even wider potential which is quite sad to hear and sounds like the film with a budget of 165M not including marketing, unlike the 1st season of andor which you did cover is very cinematic in scope

David Hex

The BDS boycott target is specifically Disney+ and not all of Disney.

Bobby Chaudhuri

Ok thanks for clarity on that which is still ironic to me as this movie will ultimately be on Disney plus... And season 2 of Andor (spoilers) Is extremely on point politically

Kore Signet

This doesn't seem to be in the RSS feed? ):

Matt Colston

Yet again Star Wars films entering the Cal Kestus, double jump he does era.

M. E. Johnson

Same! I’m sure someone just posted the ep in the wrong spot on Patreon or maybe Patreon itself isn’t putting them in the correct spot

Nicholas Clark

Same thing happened to today’s shift f1 episode. I don’t know if Patreon changed something with the tagging on the backend.

Damian Brown

I'm not actually even sure BDS is even still boycotting D+, it is not on the website that I can see

Crispytp

Might be the first time I’m going to send in a letter because I just do not agree and see things about the movie that are opposite to everyone here. I liked it! A lot of the stuff you talked about not hitting for you hit for me, like the action scenes, Shakari being a bop to me, and really liking Gorgu’s solo section. But it’s interesting to me in a way that there’s such a visceral opposite in opinion between my thoughts on the movie and the rest of you all and other people who were negative on it

Bobby Chaudhuri

Ok that's Bizarre as I just checked their website as well and I agree with your comment

freejinx

Not sure it matters, but Filoni didn’t direct the movie. I get most of the critiques. this is John playing with Dave’s toys. It’s probably unfair to say “Dave doesn’t have it anymore” you’ll get to it eventually but Ashoka mostly works and the episodes he directed piqued my curiosity.

Mark Shatraw

Dave Filoni's favorite thing in the world is turning to the camera and telling you he's the same kind of Star Wars fan as you

basebornmanjack

“I would rather rewatch Obi Wan Kenobi than rewatch this” man come home. return to yourself. touch some grass for a minute and let the recency bias work itself out cuz you hated Kenobi

Nicholas Kent

I have my criticisms of Dave Filoni but for the love of god can someone out there finally give Jon Favreau some blame for this Mando shit? He’s put up Denver Iverson shooting splits since Iron Man 1.

Bobby Chaudhuri

How would the BDS boycott only affect Disney Plus but not all Disney proper, that seems very strange and is the current boycott still undoing. I have respect if it is all Disney but not bizarrely choosing one or the other

A Quality Interruption

The continual teasing of Ahsoka is killing me. I need validation on this one. I need to be able to put it to bed.

I-Hsien Sherwood

Star Wars had become a TV property, and this movie proves it. Anime series inevitable insert films between seasons where nothing is allowed to happen. A character introduced in a Naruto movie will either die or never be heard from again. Any new powers or abilities will be lost or deemed too dangerous to use. The movies exist as fan service so audiences can see their favorite characters on the big screen. And that’s where we are now with Star Wars. The movies are a rare “treat,” not the main storyline. You want plot development? Better sign up for Disney+ because that’s the only place it’s going to happen. Everything else—movies, theme parks, comics—are going to be circling the drain of nostalgia. The era of risks is over.

Lev

I'm like 45 minutes in and they've never mentioned Jon Favreau? Do they know he directed this and not Dave Filoni?

Verdigree

Perhaps naming him Grogu was the big mistake, because even though "Baby Yoda" made you think "baby" it also never lets you forget the "YODA" part

Solomon Mars

I didn't see the movie, wasn't going to, but I wonder why they decided now should be the time for a mando movie instead of at the high point of the hype for it around season 2?

Verdigree

Maybe what actually happened is Grogu opened The World Between Worlds for him and Mando and they went backwards in time to before the first episode, so that's why it's connected to nothing, is actually the FIRST chronological thing just like the Clone Wars movie Rotta came from

TrueLily

I think we just have to accept that Star Wars is bad now. Like for all the talk of "what should Star wars do to be good, should it take big swings or play it safe" I think the answer is it's time for this franchise to die

Stacy

At least Disney didn’t make you pay movie theater prices to go see Obi-Wan.

Mike Church

As loathe as I am to ever do the “as a parent” thing… This was the first theatrical Star Wars release that my 10 year old son and I were able to watch together. From that perspective, this movie was everything I hoped it would be. Every time I felt my eyes roll into the back of my head when one of the million shallow cameos came across the screen, it was wiped out by the joy and laughter I could hear coming from the seat next to me. I wish it did more deep Star Wars nerd stuff or was challenging in literally any way but, despite its flaws, it’ll be a lifelong glowing core memory for my son and I.

Adam Reinardy

BDS is all about very targeted boycotts. The idea is that if you tell someone to boycott all of something in the modern age it’s a much harder ask. Like, if someone said boycott Procter and Gamble, how many things would you have to stop buying? Better to specifically target something that is relatively easy to boycott that will still put pressure on the entity you’re looking to effect. For myself I’m not following this particular boycott because I don’t know what BDS’s goal with Disney is. Yes, hiring Zionist actors and portraying Zionist characters is bad, but how would know if they change their ways? The two examples specifically called out were the live-action Snow White (with an outspoken Zionist actor) and that last Captain America movie (with an old Marvel Zionist superhero, that was mostly cut out of the movie anyway) which both flopped and came out a year and a half ago. So I don’t understand what Disney’s path to redemption is, and I don’t think the examples given stack up to something like Microsoft which is way more directly involved in the ongoing genocide and I am boycotting.

Ellie O'Daire goes another recall on my Mach E

Exactly 1/3rd of my theater reacted to Dave appearing on screen in the hat. By which I mean I said "dammit Dave" out loud and the only other two people in the theater didn't react at all.

Stacy

Disney is too darn cowardly to ever let Grogu speak and it’s ruining the character Like, make him non-verbal if they want! But don’t make him keep a man alive for days and then go back to being a baby. Babies don’t do that!

Alex S

Left the theater thinking the movie was okay. A couple hours into to this podcast, now I fucking hate it 😂

Samuel Pullen

Just thinking about the checked out none performance by weaver in this . If you literally have nothing to work with , what else can you do . Star Wars has and can do so much better . I wonder if young actors who want to make good stuff they believe in like say ..Inde Navarrette , are deciding they have a better chance to just break into the industry by sheer force of will. Than rely on poisoned bread crumbs by the likes of the Hat man Dave for the chance of better work in the future .Especially with very vocal bunch of chuds in “ nerd “ fandom willing to culture war you to death if they think your “woke casting “ . While getting no protection from studio heads that want to replace you with IA anyway . It’s not like the pays that good anymore ether .

Stacy

I’m assuming that when we don’t see Zeb, he is Holo-chatting with Kallus. J

d

Exactly. I respect the boycott, I love that they really walk the walk when it comes to personal values, but it also means they have no idea what they're talking about re: Filoni. He's involved in Clone Wars S7, Ahsoka, Bad Batch, Maul, and Tales Of. All of those are either bangers or at least pretty good. Favreau meanwhile did Lion King, Jungle Book, and Mando lol

Paul Engle

They address this on the pod: yes, Obi-Wan was garbage, but they at least tried for something with that show, which is more than I can say for this movie. Also speaking for myself, the Obi/Anakin emotional climax - while not perfect - still had more sauce than this entire freaking movie.

Scotty Jones

truly the first time I have heard y'all summarize anything and gone "this is silly", in a way even Clone Wars wasnt.

G. Tyler Ernst

Is there any way we can get a link to that Reddit thread with the music? Was surprised it wasn't in the episode notes lol.

Begemott

I hear what Austin's saying about not liking Disney/Filoni's big swings, but I'd rather see big swings even if they're bad, because it's more interesting. The same way that the prequels are more interesting to talk about than any random bad EU novel or TFA.

Alex Langley

I've often wondered what living in a Dark Souls style world where everything has stagnated and festered; nothing can move forward, and everything is cursed to become the basest version of itself, would be like.. so thanks, Star Wars, for clearing that up!

Mads Dahl Olavsbråten

I'm with you! I went in with low expectations, and I came out having seen a movie that was basically fine to pretty decent. Maybe they soften during the podcast, but I just had to quit about halfway in, the negativity was on a level I just don't need right now. Usually listen to every little second I can get from these fine folks, but this just wasn't for me.

Jared Myer

I know it’s been said to death, but given that the only “good” Star Wars at this point is Andor and the animated stuff, and most of that is relegated to D+, I wish the pod would just pick a new direction to go in. I like the conversation about the Vader comics, but it feels like something to fill time until they figure something else out. Traitor by Matthew Stover has been teased a few times, and I wish they’d just bite the bullet and commit to covering the NJO. It’s 19 books, which is a lot, but man… those books have meat that this crew would dig into. I’m not saying it’s all good at all, but it’s all big ideas, big conversations about the Force and the Jedi and war and the politics of the galaxy. And I’m relistening to old episodes of the show, and it seems like their prime complaint about the idea of the Vong stems from a misconception about them that the books do address. I just want to hear this crew be engaged and locked in again, and I want to be on journey with them, whatever that looks like.

Matthew Penny

Anything but Andor Season 2 🥲

Matt Owens

I cringed really hard whenever I saw Dave Filoni in this movie. Then I realized that’s my fault for knowing what Dave Filoni looks like.

Duncan Mackenzie

Fantastic episode, great analysis, agree all the way. The "grogu re-learns about the world" stuff reminded me of that hack bit in TFA when Han shoots Chewie's bowcaster for apparently the first time and lets out a cartoony "wow I gotta get me one of these" type line.

Carson Bush

I can't believe I'm parasocially invested enough in this podcast to go watch this fucking movie

LovelyRose

The way they talk about this movie makes me think about movies that are for anime adaptations, where they're kind of for people who have a loose idea of the general plot of the actual series, so they don't have to worry about being up to date or plugged in, and that nothing that happens in it will be referenced or actually be a part of the series. The Mandalorian and Grogu is the Cooler's Revenge of Star Wars movies.

Kat Reynolds

that long pause after rob's "well... more mandalorian stuff will happen i am sure" made me laugh. honestly thought you guys ended it there

Jackson Flickinger

When you guys choose to engage with a topic, you’re the best podcasts out there. I wish you would all do so when something doesn’t meet your expectations. There’s only so much you can get from groans and “it’s so bad.” Criticism is warranted. But a lot of it boils down to, “this isn’t what I wanted from the story” so you chose not to engage. This also colors anytime you talk about the prequel movies, Obi-Wan, etc. I listen to this podcasts because I want to engage with the story on a deeper level. It’s hard to find outlets that can do that at as high of a level as you all. And you’ve done so for stories that aren’t exactly high quality before. So it’s sad when you decide that something isn’t worth your time. There’s stuff to find in all stories.

Brandon

In the second episode of season one Grogu chooses to save Din from the space rino on discount Tatooine tho 😭

A-Z couple

They have said in a previous episode that they won't do Andor season 2 or anything that is only available via Disney+ as part of or in solidarity with a boycott of Disney+.

Matthew Penny

I'm aware, so watching Mandalorian and the cash grab is a choice!

MythicalMothman

All the cameos did nothing for me, EXCEPT for one that I legitimately thought was so cool - the Red Jammer (the Y-wing that shows up with the New Republic squadron and even gets namedropped). That one was so obscure, I always wanted it in my heart but never thought it would show up anywhere - because it's never actually been onscreen before, it was an unused model in the back of a studio shot that model makers thought was really cool. Something about that felt so special that I was internally cheering and clapping. Commenting before getting to the end of the episode so hopefully I don't look stupid explaining this here :)

Nicky Abbott

Hey, you wondered in the latest Vader podcast about if Padme ever shows up as a ghost. She doesn't technically but Vader tries to bring her back in the VR game Vader Immortal and he hears a flashback of her voice. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1qAuJuheRrk

Bryan Hansen

re: the action scenes feeling unimpressive/weird, is this a situation like with Marvel movies where they have this stuff in the pipeline for years irrespective of the plot/details of the movie?

justthisguyok

I haven't listened because I haven't watched the movie yet, but I was re-listening to AMCA Episode 3 about the Clone Wars movie / pilot where Ali says "If I'm ever asked to care about Jabba's middle aged son, I'm done." and I'm wondering if this is addressed in this episode. I'll take my answer off the air, thanks.

Joel Davis

Yall need to get on Ahsoka

Todd Claybaugh

I'm so happy I watched this movie on a plane and didn't pay to see it in the theater. Also, I want more of spicy Natalie. I love listening to her rant.