Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Now that it's finished, what did you think?

Files

Previews only

Comments

Matt M

I enjoyed it, but the narrative did not feel nearly as tight as the pacific, let alone Band of Brothers. Maybe it’s because so many people died, but I also didn’t feel as invested in any of the characters in the series as I did in the other two

AlexF

Overall all i liked it and i think it was pretty good. The main issues would be that the changed the objectives of some missions, such as the Munster mission, where the group was specifically tasked with targeting the church. In the show they had them target the railyard, with the church being near by and possible collateral damage. Another thing that bugged me, was that they were taking the piss out of the british, for "not" being able to properly hit their targets, when the american air force was in a similar situation. It sucks to see them treat a major ally of World War 2 like that. Another issue for me was that it felt disjointed, due to the jump between the major characters. It felt more disjointed (at least for me) when compared with the Pacific, where there were also more main characters, but where i didn't get the feeling of it being disjointed. The air scenes were pretty good, although there were times where the CGI was pretty bad. Overall, i would say it was pretty good and the theme/intro song was also great!

Doug Poland

I appreciated their attempts at historical and technical accuracy and to dramatize the stories, over time, with many people. It wasn’t perfect, but I felt it conveyed the essence of the situation with people I could identify with.

Kevin P

I agree with Matt. I think the scope of the unit is just a little too large for this kind of project. The inclusion of the Tuskegee men was nice but I almost would have preferred an entire series about them. Same for the spy whose name I cannot now remember. It also doesnt help that bombing missions are, let's face it, not as action oriented as an infantry assault so there wasn't as much variety in events to carry through to the various character development bits. There only so many ways to make guys sit in plane for 8 hours then fly through explosions and fighters for an hour before turning around not feel samey after awhile in terms of TV viewing at least. I think narrowing the scope to fewer characters would have helped make those moments have more weight.

Kevin P

Certainly not a whiff by any means but not the strongest of the three series either.

David Wilma

The prior comments summarize my feelings—wonderful show, characters somehow thinner than Pacific or BoB, throwaway plot line like Sandra the Spy, balanced by exquisite attention to detail. Perhaps the problem was Eighth Air Force missions had a certain sameness we don't see in ground combat. The airmen interact over the radio and intercom behind masks denying us any sense of emotion. They brief, they take off, they fly, they get shot at. We saw all that in prior classic movies even a TV series. I give the series four stars out of five. I would not have minded a historical summary of the strategic bombing campaign with some statistics, but those realities might conflict with the Holy Writ of Air Power. A story line missed was crews interned in Switzerland and Sweden, although probably not part of the 100th BG story. One rumor around the Air Force was crews who just diverted to get out of combat. I will watch again now that I know who wins.

Roger Germinder

It took me a couple of episodes to warm up to it. It didn’t grab me but it was good enough to come back for more. There was no connective tissue at the beginning to say ‘these were real people and real events, not just a pastiche’. BoB did that perfectly. You knew those interviews were of the men you were about to see acted out, but the mystery was kept as to which was which toward the end, even tho you could figure some out. It was hard to keep the characters straight when wearing the oxygen masks and I agree with the previous post that there was a monotony to the missions and it was hard to feel the drama at first. The ‘Great Escape’ part is when it started coming alive for me. And we saw Rosie and Crosby really shine. It came to a climax for me with the epilogue of the real men’s’ biography in season 9. That made me emotional. It was VERY worth the watch and very well done in every respect. And I’ll probably watch it again soon to pick up all the bits I missed the first time.

Einar Nørbech

Better than expected. And its weird seeing all these young actors tho, but thats because im the older one now. In terms of accuracy, ive actually come to terms with artistic expressions after watching Netflixs all quite on the western front. However, in terms of presentations of facts i will give it less praise. The Norden bombsight was not the second best kept secret of the war. The Germans har got their hands on it. And it was not the best bombsight in existence afaik. It was just that the American population thought so during that time. The British didnt use it, because it wasnt good enough.

Tom Bateman

I loved it. Very different from what I was expecting. I have a new found respect for our Air Force. Some truly harrowing stuff in this series. I highly recommend it to any WW2 aficionado, but just don't try to compare it to The Pacific or Band of Brothers. This is nothing like those shows.

Christopher Cardona

I enjoyed the series, however it felt extremely fast paced. I think the series could’ve gone without the Tuskegee Airmen segment and instead focus solely on the 100th Bomb Group. There should’ve been an episode on the Second Schweinfurt Mission or “Black Thursday”, since it is mentioned in this channel’s video of the mission that none of the 100th B-17’s were lost. Band of Brothers and The Pacific had a three episode arc that solely focused on a single battle. For Band of Brothers it was the Battle of the Bulge and for The Pacific it was the Battle of Peleliu. Masters of the Air could’ve focused on Big Week for their three episode arc. A 10th episode could’ve allowed this to happen. I felt the first 5 episodes were best, either focusing on a mission or the aftermath of one.

Mike Glish

I find it hard to suspend my disbelief with all the CGI. It feels like a video game. I much prefer the vintage footage that is available and the interviews with veterans who were actually there. Good documentaries that use this footage and interviews along with scholarship such as the excellent ones put out by Operations Room are my preference.

Martijn Riepma

I liked it, more than the Pacific less than band of Brothers. I was really disappointed with episodes 7&8 I expected big battles for the Normandy landings. But all we got was 5 seconds. Also didn't like how much the show shifted towards the ground instead of the air. It's called masters of the air not masters of the air on the ground. I wanted to see big plane battles.

Thomas Vernon

Rough around the edges in places and definitely far from perfect, but I feel it could have been (a lot) worse. CGI constantly jumped between being amazing in some places and PS2 game-grade in others. Really shined in the first few episodes, started to dip in quality later on but the finale made up for it with an excellent ending to the story. And the musical score is magnificent. I’d probably give it a 7.5/10.

Alexander K Leach

The show was intense. It shows the harsh reality of the war in the perspective of the bomber crews of WW2.

Christopher R.

I will be honest of the 3 BoBs, Pacific and MofA, Masters was my least favorite I had a really hard time getting into the characters and while it was visually stunning when showing the air battles I still found it kind of Meh

Michael Llaneza

It's amazing to me that no executive realized the potential of a Captain Westgate of SOE series, best character in the show by far.

David Wilma

I worried they would show the fate of a number of female SOE operatives. Too much even for streaming.

L P

Sums up my view exactly…and I had real trouble with the CGI. No sense of mil strategy or historical context. I feel an Ops Room series coming on!

Teddy Young

Even before it devolved into a small ball version of The Great Escape, it lacked the sweep of history present in Band of Brothers and Pacific. Experiencing life in a bomber was cool though.

Siggy Scolnik

I really enjoyed the bomber and fighter combat scenes, but production screwed up not giving us one episode about their training. I found myself not caring about the characters and was bored by the pow episodes. B-

M

It was okay. But too much cgi. The flight characteristics of the B17 were not properly captured. Too many stories going on. And all of the main characters survived. Therefore it was entertaining but it did not grip me like the other series.