Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Important discussion required.... What are the most unforgivable historical mistakes in War Films/TV? 

We want to hear the ones that make you cringe! 

Files

Previews only

Comments

Mayank Jha

Crimson Tide... the whole movie!

Eric

Everything in "Fury".

EliWritesStories

The Philippine front in 1945 feels slept on despite Manila being considered the Stalingrad of the pacific.

Jason Fontella

The modern US Marine hand and arm signals used in Saving Private Ryan. Sticking with that film, let's add the switching out of the sniper scopes on the beach.

Roger Bron

"Longest Day," John Wayne as the commanding officer says he wants the bodies of hanging paratroopers cut down, even though snipers will kill those doing this task. I can't say this is historically inaccurate, but it seems senseless.

Darth Rust

Do you mean in specific, or in general? In specific, Top Gun, because they so perfectly understood the Navy's fighter personalities that it was a horrific mistake to relay it so faithfully. In general, portraying military operations as a legend of zelda quest with a single target/switch/thing or "that one" magic piece of hardware that makes it all suddenly come together.

Ryan Butler

I’m going to be a pedantic bitch here. Greyhound always sticks in my craw. I loved the book it was based on. But in the book one ship was American, one was British, one was Canadian, and one was Polish. Having Eagle have a Polish accent would have required no effects or explanation other than a different voice actor. The movie was amazing but it was clearly a passion project that only exists because Tom Hanks wanted it to and Apple needed launch day content. There was no need to wonder if the polish accent was going to play well in Topeka. So if you are making a faithful telling do it all the way. The free polish get pretty much ignored by the western canon other than a Bridge too Far. Having the Poles lose Eagle which was their home more than any of the other ships’ crews deserved telling. It would have confused some people but that’s what Wikipedia is for. Sorry I know this wasn’t what you were looking for but my dog is the only one I know offline who will listen to my grouching on this.

Kane Fowler

Every single film or TV series that finishes a radio message with “over and out” 🙄 Over means I want a reply and out means I do not require a reply. The radio procedure in the films/TV is generally shocking. As an ex RadOp it hurts my soul 😂

Jeff Le

Bayonet charge in we were solders!

Mark

The whole of the firm battle of the bulge, the 1965 version. The firm was taken in the wrong country and at summer. I don't think there was a single German tank in the firm or from the right period.

Will Mill

Every movie that has a KIA notification from recent wars. There is a process. The family is notified not by a sudden out of the blue knock. There is a team that makes sure the faily is there and not in some place that will cause the family more harm. Also, the families get, about, a cash advance so travel and other such minor issues are not forced on the family. There is a well thought out and rehearsed process.

Will Mill

Another huge issue is communications in recent war movies. Even an infantry platoon has radio equipment that allows instant air cover requests of medical evacuations. People are not alone (Soul Survivor is not included in this generalization). Longest medical evac I ever had was 22 min.

Justin Heron

Crimson Tide. Everything. But more specifically ‘fuelling’ solid fuel missiles and not leaving plot time/tension catching the Russian missiles still on the ground.

Charlie Murphy

Unforgivable is a strong word. Movies are more about eliciting the feeling of being in a place and time and not really about technical accuracy like documentaries. However, film and documentaries complement each other, and one need not try to be the other. For example, some of the inaccuracies in Band of Brothers were because of how those real soldiers perceived things at the time, right or wrong. Some were done so an episode has a satisfying narrative structure or so it can fit about an hour's length. Regarding this scene from the Band of Brothers episode Replacements, it may have been better to do something with the British tankers stopping for tea, as Webster mentioned in his book, Parachute Infantry, that he was disgruntled with that. Having said all that, the opening scene in the James Bond flick Tomorrow Never Dies (not really a war movie of course) where the Russian General says the nuclear torpedoes will make Chernobyl look like a picnic is definitely silly.

Scott O

I would not say unforgivable but Scottish accent on a certain Russian Sub Captain. Makes me laugh at first. All the English accents in Enemy at the Gates. I guess doing a bad Russian accent would have been worse? Both good movies.

ZetaZ98

The fake massacre that didn't happen in Death of Stalin. I realize its a comedy, and that the USSR did plenty of killings of its own civilians, but that is all the more reason not to be making up shootings in the streets that never actually took place. It wasn't even one of the killings the movie played up for laughs, they were completely straight-faced about the scene.

ISAF_Ace

Any film with an air battle in showing wildly exaggerated aircraft losses. Midway is by far the most guilty of this by turning 3 US dauntless losses from the last raid on the Hiryu into 20+.

Tom Wire

Any historical film with Mel Gibson!

TheOperationsRoom

I just can't understand why they wrote the "my orders are no unnecessary destruction of property" for like the one British character in the whole series. I felt like it was just an underhand way of trying to peddle a pro-American/anti-British story or slant for audience targeting. They were probably one script meeting away from having them refuse to engage because they were busy drinking tea.

Tom Bateman

THE HURT LOCKER... since when are EOD techs snipers fighting alongside Delta Force operators? I can't believe that film won the Best Picture Oscar.

Trevor Kuta

I recently read band of brothers and according to the book this did happen... Im wondering if the book is accurate about that though.

Carson Pollard

As a medico I definitely second this. We can have you in a German quaternary trauma centre same business day, free shipping.

Carson Pollard

I had this misconception about the real B O Bulge and was then surprised to find out it actually happened in winter, due to Battlefield 1942 actually 😂

Carson Pollard

To be fair, it does mean when you hear real good radio chatter in media, you feel real good. Curious your thoughts on Black Hawk Down, as a pro to this (mostly) ameteur 😁

Carson Pollard

Hey I love it! I'll listen to your historical nerdery all day, any chance you're Polish yourself? Or just someone who knows WW2 wasn't just the Poms and Yanks - as an Aussie I know this feeling well 😂

Carson Pollard

Did you see Ian's video on this? I find it painful how *close* they got with this rifle, yet so far

Carson Pollard

SEA in general in WW2. Even Aussies don't seem to realise what was done and what it cost, at most usually knowing broadly about Kokoda

EliWritesStories

Oh yeah. I got a personal family history with Corregidor and Bataan and I would love a miniseries that covers things like the Burma campaigns and the Army's operations in the Philippines. A Japanese invasion story would be awesome too.

TheOperationsRoom

From the book - "A British tank was coming up. Martin ran back to it, climbed aboard, and told the commander there was an enemy tank just below and to the right. The tank continued to move forward. Martin cautioned the commander that if he continued his forward movement the German tank would soon see him. "I caunt see him, old boy," the commander replied, "and if I caunt see him, I caunt very well shoot at him." "You'll see him damn soon," Martin shouted as he jumped down and moved away." Quite reasonable that a tank crewman should be able to see the tank he's aiming at. Why did they feel the need to invent this weird "no unnecessary destruction of property" thing?

Kane Fowler

I haven’t watched it for a while but I seem to recall it was pretty good. My experience is UK Army and though US military should follow NATO voice procedure (ACP-125) I’m conscious it does vary by unit. I’ll have a re-watch 🙂

Kane Fowler

Had a quick skip through. It’s not too bad, it might be for editing purposes to keep time down but they often miss out over/out or call signs at the beginning of transmissions. It’s better than a lot of them though 🙂

Talbot-Jaaskelainen

It's not really a war film, but in the movie Black Sea, when the salvage team reaches the German submarine and find one of the deceased crew chained to a bed and one of the characters implies it was done because of cannibalism, that's just horrendously stupid. Why make a movie about submarines, and then suggest something like that happened? Like how does one not realize that before things get into the point where cannibalism would be necessary, the air would have run out ages ago. I am a huge submarine nerd and I like submarine movies, even the ones not so good and accurate ones, but that absolutely stupid thing ruins this movie so badly :D

Markus Parizo

They didn't even get the actual EOD tech procedures right in this movie, basically a Hollywood cowboy movie about a guy miraculously not getting himself killed, when in fact his complete disregard of procedure would have absolutely resulted in his death in that OE.

Brandon Young

Has anyone mentioned references to air-to-air missiles fired in a sequence and being called out as "Fox-1, Fox-2, Fox-3"? Not a specific movie but it always makes me cringe XD