Chapter 1: Here We Go Again (Patreon)
Content
Tattoo POV
“With a smile wreaking havoc on the media, she makes you wanna know her secret—so mysterious~.” The song drifted out of the television beside me, bright enough to make my teeth hurt. On the screen, a purple-haired girl smiled into the camera while a crowd waved lights beneath her. The speakers were cheap, the picture kept cutting out whenever somebody walked too close to the antenna, and the little shit who was supposed to be watching the front entrance had somehow decided none of that mattered as much as catching the rest of the performance.
I looked from the television to him. He was moving his lips along with the words.
“Can you shut that shit off?” I snapped. “You’re on guard.”
He startled, nearly dropped the remote, and finally remembered the gun hanging against his chest. The music died mid-cheer. For a moment, the only sounds left were the rain ticking against the tall windows and the miserable old pipes knocking somewhere inside the walls. The kid straightened like that might make up for the last five minutes. I kept staring until he turned toward the entrance.
Three months ago, a man like that would have been running errands for somebody who ran errands for me. I had to remind him which direction to point his fucking eyes. Things had been going downhill ever since the failed attempt to grab Lucius Fox. Before that, people had moved when I spoke. Fox was supposed to have been the sort of score that put me back where I belonged: Wayne money, Wayne connections, the kind of man whose disappearance could make important people answer a telephone. Instead, the job had gone bad, and I had been left discovering how quickly friends stopped remembering your number when your name started getting passed around as a warning.
Black Mask had given me another chance tonight. I wasn’t about to waste it because one of my boys wanted to watch a concert.
The mansion helped. It sat well back from the road, past a stretch of a dead garden that had probably cost more to maintain than I had made in my first ten years on the street. Inside, there were stone columns, high ceilings, and windows big enough to give a decent view of the lawn if the rain hadn’t turned everything beyond the glass into a black smear. Somebody had built this place to prove they could afford rooms they would never use. Now, the furniture wore dust covers, half the lights didn’t work, and we had dragged a television into a drawing room where the only decent chair had a split down the leather. The rich abandoned a place, and the rest of the city found something to do with it. That was Gotham.
For tonight, it was a place to keep two expensive problems until the boss finished his business. Commissioner Gordon’s daughter was one of them. I didn’t need to like the commissioner to understand what having his kid in a chair could do to a man’s priorities. A few hours of hesitation, a few orders that came too late, and something that should have been a police operation became tomorrow morning’s paperwork. The boss hadn’t bothered telling me everything moving through the city tonight. He had told me what my part was, and he had made it very fucking clear that the girls needed to be alive when he called.
The second problem was currently watching her own muted performance with a look of wounded disappointment.
“That wasn’t very nice, Mister Kidnapper,” she said. “I worked really hard on that performance.”
I turned toward her slowly. Ai Hoshino sat beside the commissioner’s daughter with her ankles tied to the chair and her hands bound in front of her. At least, they were supposed to be bound. Whoever had tied the knots had left her enough room to move her wrists together, which explained how she was holding a plastic cup of iced coffee between them. There was even a straw. I stared at it, then at the guilty expression on the kid by the television.
Of course, it had been him.
“She asked for something to drink,” he muttered.
“We have water.”
“She said she gets headaches.”
Ai lifted the cup a little. “It was very thoughtful of him.”
I could feel a headache coming on. Three months. That was how long this girl had been in Gotham’s face, and somehow that had been enough to get her into every shop window, every argument about music, and apparently the heads of people I was paying to know better. At first, I had thought she was another pretty face somebody with money was trying to make famous. Then the clips had started circulating. Concert footage, interviews, some little wave outside a building that people had replayed like she had performed a miracle. I had heard her voice from passing cars and watched a bartender abandon a perfectly good conversation to turn up the television when she appeared on the news.
I understood the appeal better than I wanted to. Even sitting in a dusty room with rope around her ankles, the girl made it difficult to look anywhere else. Her hair was a deep purple that ought to have looked ridiculous. Instead, it looked natural, which was worse. So did her eyes. Bright purple, with those strange star-shaped marks that kept catching the light whenever she turned her head. I knew what dyed hair looked like. I also knew Gotham had stopped being the city where you could look at somebody unusual and assume the explanation came out of a bottle. Maybe they were contacts. Perhaps she was a meta. Maybe a manager somewhere decided it was more beneficial for business if nobody got a clear answer.
Whatever it was, she knew how to use it. Sixteen years old, according to the interviews the news kept showing, and already better at managing a room than the men I had brought to guard her. In the space of an hour, she had learned which of my boys got flustered when she smiled, which one wanted to be thanked for being reasonable, and which one could apparently be talked into making a coffee run during a fucking kidnapping. She never ordered them around. She asked little questions, remembered a detail somebody had let slip, and looked pleased when they answered. By the time I noticed what was happening, they were behaving like disappointing her would be rude.
The commissioner’s kid was different. Red hair, pale face, mouth pressed tight whenever she thought we weren’t watching. She kept looking at the doors. Every time one opened, her shoulders lifted a fraction before she forced them down again. Ai had been talking to her since we brought them into the room, and the girl answered in the careful voice people use when they’re trying very hard to sound older than they are. I could work with scared. Scared understood the situation. The other one was starting to piss me off.
“You think this is funny?” I asked.
Ai’s smile softened. “I didn’t say that.”
“You’ve had plenty else to say.”
“It’s a long evening.” She glanced at the television, then back at me. “And you turned off the music.”
The kid near the entrance made a noise he tried to disguise as a cough. That did it. I crossed the room, caught a handful of purple fabric beneath her collar, and pulled her up far enough that the chair scraped across the floor. Coffee sloshed against the lid of her cup. Beside her, the redhead went rigid.
“Listen here, you little bitch. You’re not on vacation.” I leaned closer, letting her get a good look at my face. “Keep running your mouth, and you won’t be singing again. You understand me?”
Cold crawled between my shoulder blades. It came so suddenly that I stopped with the last word still in my mouth. For an instant, I had the sick certainty that somebody was standing directly behind me, close enough to put a hand on my neck. I looked over my shoulder. There were my boys, the covered furniture, and the long windows reflecting the room at me. Beyond the open doorway, the entrance hall lay empty beneath the gallery.
Something soft touched my wrist.
“Mister,” Ai said quietly, “you shouldn’t do that. You might get hurt.”
I turned back, ready to make her regret it, and found that she wasn’t smiling anymore. The change was small enough that I couldn’t have explained it to anybody afterward. Her face had gone still. Her fingers rested against my wrist without trying to pry it loose, and those purple eyes were fixed on mine. The stars in them looked black. I shifted, trying to get the light out of them, but the darkness stayed. Behind me, something ticked softly against stone. A settling pipe, maybe. Old houses made noises. I knew that. My grip loosened anyway.
For a second, neither of us moved. Then I let her down. The chair legs hit the floor, and she settled back against the cushion, coffee still held between her hands. I told myself I was remembering the boss’s instructions. She was worth money. She was leverage. There was no point damaging merchandise because some girl had gotten under my skin.
“Keep an eye on them,” I told the boys. “Both of them. And nobody gets them another fucking thing.”
I walked toward the office without looking back. Every step across that room felt longer than it should have. The gallery stayed empty. Nothing moved behind the sheets draped over the furniture. The back of my neck prickled, and it took everything I had to keep my pace steady until I reached the office and shut the door. The latch clicked into place. I stood with my hand against it for another moment before crossing to the desk.
The radio sat beside a stack of papers the boss had sent over, its little green light steady in the dark. No alarm. No warning. Two separate reports had put Batman and Robin outside the city tonight, and nobody had called to say that had changed. I had spent enough years in Gotham to know what happened when you got careless around the Bat. Tonight, for once, we had checked.
The new one was there, too, of course. Red and blue, always talking, always showing up in somebody’s shaky phone video with a joke ready. My boys passed those clips around when they thought I wasn’t looking. I had heard enough about stolen purses and lost dogs to last a lifetime, along with a few stories about crews left stuck to walls for the police to find. An inconvenience. That was what I had called him. A kid who wanted people to like him, and people like that usually talked before they did anything serious. If he turned up, I’d have room to work with that.
“It’s fine,” I muttered, pulling the chair away from the desk. “The Bat and the brat aren’t in the city.”
Before the night was over, I would have given every dollar in that room to hear Batman’s voice outside my door.
Barbara Gordon POV
Today was supposed to have been a good day. That was the part I kept getting stuck on. This morning, I sat in Dad’s car with my schoolbag against my knees, trying to decide whether telling everyone I had seen Batman before first period would sound like bragging. By tonight, the rope around my wrists had rubbed my skin sore, my phone was gone, and a man with tattoos on his face had threatened to hurt a girl for talking too much. I could still remember how annoyed I had been about the rain on the way to school. It made me want to go back and shake myself.
I had known Dad worked with Batman. Sometimes he came home with that particular look on his face, tired and distracted but carrying a little less weight than when he had left, and I could usually guess they had spoken. Meeting him myself had been different. He had been beside the police cars when Dad stopped, with Robin a few steps away watching the street. The cape, the cowl, the fact that people seemed to find somewhere else to stand when he turned toward them—it should have been intimidating. I had certainly forgotten most of the intelligent things I might have said.
Then he had looked into the car, greeted me by name, and asked whether they were making me late for school. Something unexpectedly gentle about the question: he had listened to my answer, too, instead of treating me like furniture until the adults finished talking. Dad trusted him. I could see that in the way they stood together, and for a few seconds I had understood it. In the gray morning, with his cape moving in the rain, he had reminded me of something from an old picture of angels: dark wings, a severe face, and the promise that somebody was standing between you and whatever came out of the night.
I would have liked to hold on to that feeling now. It was getting harder every time one of our kidnappers checked his watch.
Black Mask’s men had talked enough for me to understand what they wanted from Dad. A deal was happening tonight, and they needed the police to find something else to do. Apparently, kidnapping the commissioner’s daughter was how they intended to make that happen. I kept turning the idea over, trying to understand how anybody could think this ended well. Dad would do everything he could to keep me safe. I knew that with a certainty I couldn’t quite manage about anything else. I also knew that, once I was safe, every man in this house would have a very bad time explaining his choices.
People at the precinct had met Batman under worse circumstances than I had. I had seen them sitting on benches while officers took statements, one arm in a sling or both hands clenched between their knees. Some had kept looking toward the windows even with half a dozen police officers around them. The loud ones always seemed to get quieter when somebody mentioned a rooftop. I had once asked Dad why a man with three assault charges had started crying over a photograph of an alley. He had given me a long look and changed the subject. That had told me enough.
Remembering those men should have helped. Mostly, it made me wonder whether the people holding us had forgotten what city they lived in. I tried to sit straight and keep my breathing even, because if I started thinking about how far away Dad might be, I could feel myself getting close to tears. The room smelled of dust, wet coats, and coffee. Somewhere beyond the windows were gardens, a road, and people who probably had no idea we were here. I had never hated a piece of glass as much as I hated the enormous windows I couldn’t reach.
Beside me, Ai Hoshino tilted her cup toward me. “Do you want some, Barbara?”
Of all the things that had happened tonight, hearing her say my name still made a completely ridiculous little flutter go through my stomach. I looked at the coffee, then at her, and tried to remember how ordinary conversation worked. “I’m good, Miss Ai. Thank you.”
“Just Ai is fine.” She smiled, warm enough that for an instant the ropes and the men with guns seemed like something happening at the edge of a different room. “And you’re sure? There’s plenty.”
I shook my head. My hands were trembling, and I didn’t want her to notice. She let the offer go without making me explain, settling the cup against her lap. That small kindness made me like her even more, which was inconvenient because I was already having trouble separating the person sitting beside me from the girl I had watched on a stage a few weeks ago.
Dad had been invited to the concert as part of a public appearance. There had been photographs to take, people to thank, and a conversation about the police that I had politely stopped listening to after the third speech. I remembered thinking he looked almost as uncomfortable in front of the cameras as I felt standing beside them. Then Ai came out, and the whole room changed. People who had been checking their watches put their hands down. Conversations died without anybody asking. Even Dad had turned toward the stage and stayed that way.
I had seen good singers before. I had watched people hit every note and move through a performance without making a mistake. Ai made it look as if she had noticed each person in the audience separately and was pleased they had come. The turn of her head, the way she leaned into a line, the little smile that arrived just before a chorus—all of it seemed effortless until I tried to imagine doing any of it myself. I wouldn’t have known where to put my hands. She seemed to belong under those lights as naturally as other people belonged in their own bedrooms.
Afterward, I had watched the clips again. So had half of Gotham, judging by how often I heard her name at school. Her songs had started turning up on radio stations between traffic reports and warnings about streets to avoid after dark. Message boards argued over whether she was as good as people said, then posted links that usually settled the debate for a few minutes. Three months earlier, I hadn’t known she existed. Now I could recognize her voice through a shop wall before I reached the door.
The real girl beside me had coffee on her sleeve. A little had escaped when Tattoo grabbed her, leaving a dark patch near her wrist. She was only three years older than me. I knew that from an interview, but it hadn’t meant much until now, when I couldn’t stop looking at the stain or remembering how easily he had pulled her out of her chair. I had been halfway to saying something before I remembered the guns. Then he had let her go. I didn’t understand why. I had seen his face change when she touched his wrist, and whatever he had noticed had made him leave the room in a hurry.
“Ai?” I kept my voice low. The nearest guard stood by the doorway, trying hard to look as though he hadn’t been listening to her music. “Aren’t you worried?”
She looked down at the stain on her sleeve and brushed it with her thumb. “About this? It’ll probably wash out.”
“I meant…” I glanced toward the men, then back at her. I didn’t want them hearing how frightened I sounded. “About being here.”
For a moment, she watched me without answering. The smile on her face changed, losing some of the brightness I’d seen in interviews. What remained seemed quieter and more attentive. “You’ve been very brave,” she said.
That nearly did it. My throat tightened, and I swallowed before I could trust myself to speak. “Dad will find us.”
“I’m sure he’s trying.”
“And Batman,” I said, a little more firmly, because I needed to hear it. “He helps Dad. He’ll come.”
Ai glanced toward the office door. A soft laugh escaped her, and something about it made the fine hairs on my arms lift. The stars in her eyes looked dark again. I blinked, trying to work out whether a shadow had moved across her face, and by the time I looked properly, they were bright. She was still watching the door with a small, private smile.
“It’s fine, Barbara,” she said. “I have a friend who’s probably already here.”
I followed her gaze. The office door was closed. The man beside the television had started looking at his watch, and somebody in the entrance hall coughed. Nothing about any of it suggested help. When I turned back, Ai had balanced her cup against her thigh and hooked a finger beneath the collar of her sweater. A fine chain slipped into view. At its end hung a small red spider.
I stared at it; I knew that shape. I had seen versions of it painted on school notebooks, drawn in the corner of a bus shelter, and copied badly onto a shirt in a shop window. This one was small enough to hide beneath her clothes, and when she rubbed her thumb across it, the movement looked familiar, almost unconscious.
“Spider-Man?” I whispered.
Her smile answered before she did. “He worries.”
I looked from the pendant to her face, suddenly remembering dates. Spider-Man had started appearing about three months ago. So had Ai. I had never connected the two because there hadn’t seemed to be a reason to connect a singer to a masked boy swinging between buildings. Now, I was sitting beside her in a room full of Black Mask’s men, staring at a spider she wore against her skin, and wondering whether the people who had taken us knew something everyone else had missed.
Maybe she was a friend he had rescued. Perhaps she had met him before either of them became famous. Maybe that was why she was here at all. The questions crowded together so quickly that I couldn’t decide which one to ask first. Ai tucked the necklace beneath her sweater, carefully settled her coffee on the little table beside her, and looked toward the office again.
“Stay close to me,” she murmured.
The office door burst open.
Wood cracked across the room. I flinched so hard the ropes bit into my wrists, and Tattoo came through the doorway backward, one shoulder tearing into the broken frame before he struck the rug. His momentum carried him into a covered sofa. Dust billowed from the sheet, and the little table beside it tipped, spilling something that shattered against the floor. Ai caught my sleeve as I jerked away from the noise. I heard somebody swear, then the scrape of a gun being lifted.
A white strand crossed the room before I could turn my head. The guard beside the television made a startled sound as his weapon snapped upward and stuck against the wall. More webbing caught his wrists and spread across his chest, pinning him where he stood. He struggled once, hard enough to make the gun’s sling pull tight across his shoulder, and accomplished nothing. In the entrance hall, another man backed into view with webbing wound around his arms. He stopped when he saw the doorway, looked behind him, and slowly lowered himself to the floor.
Then Spider-Man stepped out of the office.
For a few seconds, relief was so strong that it made me dizzy. The red suit, the blue panels, the white eyes—I recognized him all at once, with the same strange feeling I got when somebody from a screen turned out to occupy real space. He was here. Ai’s friend was actually here, standing on the other side of the room with splinters falling around his boots. I nearly called out. Then, he turned his head toward us, and the sound caught in my throat.
He looked at the ropes first. I knew that because his gaze dipped toward my hands before moving to Ai’s chair. Ai gave him a small nod, her fingers still hooked around my sleeve. He held our direction for another moment, then looked toward the guard sitting in the entrance hall. The man hurriedly pressed his back against the wall and kept his hands visible. Spider-Man turned away and walked toward Tattoo without a word.
I had watched enough footage of him to know how strange that was. Everyone had. He had appeared in Gotham three months ago and somehow found time between stopping robberies to become involved in the sort of things nobody expected to see a superhero doing. An elderly woman near our building had told the same story for a week: he carried her shopping home after a bag split. Pictures showed him crouching outside a third-floor window while a little boy reached for the dog in his arms. One afternoon, I had seen him on the subway eating a hot dog, the bottom of his mask pushed up just enough to take a bite while a man beside him complained about the trains.
They had looked like two people having an ordinary conversation. That was what stayed with me afterward. Gotham had people who flew over it and people who watched it from rooftops. Spider-Man might spend the morning swinging above traffic, then turn up standing in the same line as everyone else, talking about the weather or asking whether somebody had dropped their change. He made it easy to imagine that, if you needed help and called his name, he would hear you. By the time I saw that hot dog on the train, people were already repeating his favorite introduction: your friendly neighborhood Spider-Man.
I had thought it suited him. Most of the time, he seemed delighted to be there, as though being able to climb a building meant he ought to help somebody get something off its roof. Even when he was fighting, he talked. The jokes in the clips weren’t always good, but I remembered the people laughing after the danger passed, sometimes shakily, sometimes because they finally had permission to stop being frightened. His voice had become part of how I recognized him.
Now all I could hear was Tattoo trying to get air back into his lungs.
Spider-Man stopped beside him. Tattoo rolled awkwardly onto his side, and I saw that his arms were already caught in webbing behind his back. He tried to pull a knee under himself. Spider-Man bent, gathered a fistful of purple fabric at his collar, and lifted him until his feet barely touched the floor. The movement looked horribly easy. Tattoo was a large man. I had felt his weight in the room all evening, in the way the others stepped aside when he passed and the way my stomach tightened when he came near our chairs. Spider-Man held him with one hand and brought him close enough that the man’s face was only inches from his mask.
“Where… is… Black Mask?”
His voice was low. It carried clearly through the room anyway, and I felt Ai’s fingers tighten once against my sleeve before she let go. Tattoo opened his mouth. Nothing came out at first. His eyes flicked toward the hall, toward the man webbed beside the television, and finally back to the white lenses in front of him. Spider-Man waited. He didn’t shake him or raise his voice; somehow, that made watching worse.
I understood then how much of a face I was used to having. Superman smiled in photographs. Batman’s mouth was visible beneath his cowl; this morning, I had watched the corner of it shift when Dad said something under his breath. Even Robin had a face below the mask, something I could look at and recognize as a person deciding what to do next. I had grown so used to Spider-Man’s voice filling in the missing pieces that I barely thought about the fabric covering everything else. With him silent, there was nothing to read.
Those white eyes stayed fixed on Tattoo. The man shifted in his grip, and Spider-Man adjusted his hand by an inch without seeming to think. I remembered how quickly he had pinned the guard to the wall. I couldn’t even have warned somebody in the time it had taken him to do it. The ropes around my wrists suddenly seemed very thin, and the room felt different now that I understood how little its guns and locked doors had mattered to the person standing in it.
All evening, I’d told myself what Batman would do to these men. Now, with Spider-Man in front of me, I couldn’t make that familiar image feel frightening enough to match what I was seeing. An old photograph came into my mind without permission: a bat tangled in a web, a spider waiting above it. I had hated that picture when I first saw it. The memory made my stomach turn now.
Spiders could prey on bats.
It was a strange, awful thing to think about somebody who had come to rescue us. I knew that. I also couldn’t stop looking at the hand holding Tattoo upright or at the man’s increasingly desperate attempts to find somewhere else to put his eyes.
“Before you speak,” Spider-Man said, “keep one thing in mind. I can rip a parking meter out of the ground.”
Tattoo went very still. The guard by the television stopped struggling. I could hear rain against the windows again, the slow drip of something from the ceiling, and my own breathing, which sounded much too loud. Spider-Man leaned closer. His free hand rested at his side, relaxed, and for some reason I found that almost as unsettling as the one gripping Tattoo’s shirt.
“Throwing you through that door was a fraction of what I can do to you,” he continued. “The next words out of your mouth had better be a first name, followed by a last name, and an address. Repeat as necessary.”
“Roman,” Tattoo said immediately. “Roman Sionis.”
The rest came out in a rush. A street number, a street name, an explanation of which entrance Black Mask used and how recently Tattoo had spoken to him. He stumbled over one part, corrected himself, and repeated the address without being asked. I watched the man who had threatened Ai hurry to make himself understood, practically choking on his own words in his eagerness to keep them coming. Every time he paused to breathe, his eyes searched the mask for any sign he had said enough.
Spider-Man listened. Once, his head tilted a fraction, and Tattoo hurried to explain a detail he had left out. The exchange lasted less than a minute. It felt much longer from my chair. I found myself thinking about the people who would read about this tomorrow if anyone ever heard the whole story. They would say the hostages had been rescued. Dad would come through a door, and I would finally be able to let him see how scared I had been. Officers would take statements, somebody would find a blanket, and there would be questions about whether I needed a hospital. I wanted all of those ordinary, familiar things so badly that my eyes started burning.
But I also knew I would remember this part: the broken office door, the strange silence, and the discovery that the friendly hero from the train could make a roomful of armed men forget how to argue. I looked toward Ai, suddenly needing to see whether the person who actually knew him felt any of what I did.
Ai was watching him with both hands tucked close to her chest. Her shoulders had loosened, and there was a brightness in her face that I had never seen onstage. When Spider-Man shifted his grip on Tattoo’s collar, she leaned forward a little, completely absorbed.
“So cool,” Ai whispered.
I stared at her. Then I looked at the terrified man hanging from Spider-Man’s hand, the guards trying to make themselves smaller against the walls, and the broken door behind him. Ai followed my glance and gave me a small, almost embarrassed smile. For the first time since meeting her, I had no idea what to say. I had spent half the evening wondering how a girl could be so calm in a room full of dangerous strangers. Apparently, I still had a lot to learn about Ai Hoshino’s friends.
Chapter 1: Here We Go Again End
Author's Note: I wanted to try a different type of story besides Fate. So I wrote this story after reading a Webnovel story about Spider-Man and Ai.
Tattoo is actually a guy in DC who works for Black Mask; he appears in early comics.
The next chapter of Hero King is nearly done; I just had this idea and wanted to share it next chapter should be out this weekend.