Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This is a list of the books I would recommend every student of history to have read at least in part, so as to understand the nature of History as a field, its quirks, its methods and so on.

All of these books I originally found on /r/askhistorians' reading list, and have slowly read over the years.

Essentials

Edward Hallet Carr, "What is History?" (1967)

This book is still assigned to students at universities to this day, and covers pretty much every important facet of the profession of the historian.

In it Carr discusses the role of the historian, the pitfalls one can fall into, the role of narrative and moral judgments, of bias and history as a "science."

Supplemental

John Lewis Gaddis, "The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past" (2004)

This is a more recent work, and covers much of the same ground as "What is History?" and so in theory it could replace that book as the essential of this list, but I'm hesitant to do so due to my fondness of Carr's book.

This book is snappy, easy to read and full of illustrative prose. I kept this book with me in the semester when I was taking the bus to University to attend lectures for "Examen Philsophicum" which is a prerequisite number of subjects you need a baseline understanding of before going on to undergrad studies. The book helped prepare me for what history actually was, and gave me a strong foundation to do well on historiography exams.

Peter Novick, "That Noble Dream: The 'Objectivity Question' and the American Historical Profession" (1988)

This one in my opinion is incredibly important if you want a strong handle on the nature of "objectivity" in the study of history. The aforementioned books go over these things as well, but they don't delve as deeply into it as Peter Novick.

Peter Novick's book also benefits from being set in a specific context, as it traces the development of schools of thought surrounding the objectivity of the historian in the American historical community.

William Cronon, "A Place for Stories: Nature, History and Narrative" (1992)

This article printed in the Journal of American History and accessible on JSTOR also expands on the nature of narrative and how historians write stories to give meaning to the facts by excluding the irrelevant and including the relevant, separating story from non-story.

Historians have an important responsibility fraught with many pitfalls, as it's their role to organize all of the sources and facts in order to tell us what we're supposed to learn from them.

It's a great and short read that I encourage, especially since it's accessible for free on JSTOR.

I want to post a few reading lists like this as I collect books for a topic and read them, to give good concise recommendations for things. Let me know what you think.

Comments

Ultra_Man

Very useful! Thank you!