Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Siobhan

Month 10, Day 16, Saturday 6:00 a.m.

Siobhan let the silence stretch before she inclined her head.

“Go on.”

Some of her fear remained, a low hum beneath her ribs. The hot, jagged readiness that had carried her through the confrontation, first with Thaddeus, and then with Zard, had begun to ebb, though, leaving her more curious than inclined to stab anyone. That was probably an improvement.

She was tired, too. Reading Myrddin’s journals had become much easier since the third branch of her Will had unfurled, but copying each page they looked at into the miniature book hidden against her hip, every glyph and stray annotation, had pressed her close to her limit. She had held the lock open far longer than she would have believed possible a month ago. And already the ache behind her eyes was fading faster than it ought to. The sleep-proxy raven might account for that. Or perhaps this was a sign that her overall skill as a thaumaturge was improving from all of her efforts.

Across the table, Thaddeus kept his hands in view, clasped loosely together. “I was raised by two people who required me to address them by their given names. Never Mother or Father. I realized well into my adulthood that even their names might not have been real. Even with the benefit of age and perspective, I know and understand too little about them. I do know that they were very talented thaumaturges. I believe you understand the role that talent plays, not just in ease of spellcasting, but also in the incremental but ever-increasing advantages in the Will’s growth?”

Siobhan admitted internally that, with such a fascinating hook, she didn’t feel she knew nearly enough. But rather than openly announce her ignorance as she might have were she Sebastien right now, she simply nodded lightly.

“I do not know whether they conceived me to combine what they considered their spectacular bloodlines into an ideal specimen, or acquired me elsewhere for the same purpose.”

“Acquired?”

“Adopted, if you prefer.”

She did not. “Specimen?”

“Their word, on occasion. Not in my hearing, they believed.” His mouth twisted. “I was a child who snooped. I found a Red Guard badge hidden in a drawer when I was perhaps six. I never mentioned it to them. It may have been genuine. It may have been stolen, or forged, or kept for some reason I could not imagine. But I believed they were agents, and that belief colored everything after.”

Siobhan wondered, briefly, whether that belief had led a grown man into a red coat and a badge of his own. She did not ask. His expression did not invite it.

“They taught me magical theory as soon as I could read. Physical discipline. Meditative exercises before I understood what the little games before I was allowed to eat were for.” His clasped hands on the table tightened, then loosed again. He was still staring at them when he spoke again “I began casting in secret at seven.”

“Seven?”

The word escaped louder than she intended.

He his gaze rose to meet hers, but she was too surprised to read his face properly.

The University allowed admission for those seventeen and older. Thirteen was common for children from families filled with thaumaturges who had someone willing to take on their instruction personally, or for apprentices of more archaic generations. Eleven, for children judged gifted and mature enough to bear it. She had started at eleven.

Nine was generally considered the youngest viable age, and even that was rare and dangerous; some of the caution was sound practical sense about a developing mind and Will, and some of it was the sort of numerological superstition that clung to any threshold. But seven was simply reckless.

“I knew the risks,” Thaddeus said. “They had never hidden how the world worked from me. I understood Will-strain, backlash, Aberration, before I understood why other children cried when they fell. And yet—“ He paused long enough, and the silence was deep enough, that Siobhan could hear the sound of their breath and the beat of her own heart.

At seven, a child could recite a warning without understanding that the consequences applied to them. ‘And why do children cry when they fall? Because it hurts. But isn’t it also because they want their parents to notice and comfort them?’

“Most of the danger from casting young is from a mind too small and flighty to hold the Word steady. I did it anyway, at night, with the door shut.”

“Why?”

He took long enough to answer that she thought he might refuse.

“Because I wished someone would catch me,” he said. “I imagined it often. A hand on my shoulder, a voice gone sharp with fright. Do you have any idea what could have happened to you? And beneath the fright, because I was clever, because I was strong and special, a little awe. Worry and pride together. Now, I think of it like a small child packing their rucksack and running away from home in protest of their poor treatment, all while waiting to be found, hugged tight, and returned to the warmth of the fireplace to recover. I wanted to be a thing someone could lose.”

Siobhan’s hand curled on her knee and forced herself to breath deeply through her stomach and lower her tightened shoulders. She had wanted Grandfather to notice her cleverness, too. To stop discussing research and notice that she had let go of his hand.

“The woman—my mother figure—found out about a year later. She caught me casting a spell on my bedside table. She was furious.” His voice remained level, but his gaze had return to his gently clasped hands. “Unfortunately, not for the reasons I had so anticipated. I had ruined their experiment. Contaminated the data. Years of careful control, wasted. I kept waiting for the hint of concern, but it never came.”

“I was sad, and I was enraged, and I was eight. I turned back to the spell on my desk and the magic slipped. There was a backlash, physical, and the desk exploded. A large splinter of wood pierced her eye.” He said it plainly, without apology or relish.

“It was an accident,” Siobhan stated firmly, as she would have for any panicked and horrified child in that situation.

“An accident,” Thaddeus repeated, so low it was almost a whisper, though his tone did not hold agreement, and he did not nod.

“She became very calm. She pressed her hand to the eye, but blood and vitreous fluid were spilling through her fingers. Her other eye was watering so badly she struggled to look at me, while I was sobbing and apologizing and trying to go find the healer’s kit.

“She stopped me—grabbed me by the arm. She said she would tell the man they needed to begin again with another child.”

Siobhan’s eyelids fluttered.

“She said that next time they would be stricter, and that clearly there was no need to wait until nine.”

“Then she locked me in the basement. They were a team,” he sneered, “and would decide exactly what to do with me together.”

Siobhan said nothing.

“The man never came home. Days passed. The woman grew agitated, and after a while she left to look for him. She did not return either. I never learned what happened to them.”

“How long?”

“Long enough that I began to calculate how many days a boy could survive on the water dripping down the wall. Getting out took a great deal of ingenuity, days of painstaking work, and all of my meager magical skill. Once out, I stole supplies, all the coin I could find, and a couple of books. Then I left.”

“Alone.”

Thaddeus leaned back and gave her a humorless, tiny quirk of a smile. “Not for long. A small sect of the Stewards of Intention took me in. They confiscated my belongings and my books and worked me as one might a donkey. And that is all there is to that part of my life.”

It was not, Siobhan suspected, all there was. But she knew the shape of what he had not said. A child who stood in front of people who measured them by what they could provide would learn to make that measurement so impressive no one would think of discarding them.

The recognition landed in her chest with an uncomfortable weight. It did not make what he had done to her in the tunnels any smaller. It did not make her trust him. But it made a terrible sort of sense of him, and she resented that a little.

“I think,” she said slowly, “that I understand that child better than I would like.”

Thaddeus inclined his head, as though she had confirmed something he had already suspected. “I have told that story to one other person. She is dead.”

He let that sit between them. “Do you know why I told you?”

Siobhan did not answer immediately. She didn’t know what he expected her to do with this information. Was it an offering, a payment, a key held out for an exchange? Did people tell stories like that to make themselves less frightening, or to lay claim to something?

“To receive sincerity,” he said, when the silence had gone on long enough, “one must give sincerity.”

“And what is it you want in return?”

He considered her across the table. “Do you think I am trustworthy?”

The question was too blunt to be a trap. Or perhaps it was blunt enough to be one. All she knew for sure was that this felt dangerous. But she had promised herself she would stop living in fear. Siobhan arched one eyebrow high. “Do you think you’re trustworthy, Thaddeus Lacer?”

“No.” He did not hesitate. “But I am sincere. And if I have to choose a side, I will choose yours.” He leaned forward across the table, not reaching for her, but with his hands out in a motion that was not quite supplication and not quite an invitation for her to grasp them.

She almost laughed. The sound caught somewhere behind her teeth and died there.

“Children trust their parents blindly,” he went on, “partly because they have no alternative. They depend on them completely for survival. They lack the strength to do otherwise, and so their trust is not a choice so much as a necessity. Strength brings perspective. And that perspective is invariably accompanied by the recognition that one’s parents were flawed, perhaps grievously.” His thumb pressed into the back of his other hand, digging deep. “There are no paragons of virtue. People hurt others, even those they mean to protect. Especially those, sometimes.”

This was not a very compelling argument, given the story he had just told her and her own experiences with Ennis. “And?”

He enunciated clearly. “You are not helpless.” He stared at her as if trying to give the statement more weight. “You do not depend on me for your survival. You do not need me to be completely trustworthy.”

She understood the argument. She understood the emotions. She understood the kind of person such experiences could shape. That did not mean she believed that person necessarily had the right answers. “I used to believe,” Siobhan said slowly, “that I could never truly trust or rely on anyone. That depending on another person was weakness.”

He remained silent and let her piece together what she wanted to convey.

“At some points in our life, with some people, that can be true. It can also be exhausting to maintain that vigilance. Isolating. I’ve learned that I dislike living that way.” She met his eyes. “I might once have agreed with you. My objection is that sincerity on its own isn’t enough. If you want someone to invest in you, they should know what they’re investing in. Trustworthiness, openness, honesty, those give the other person a real chance to choose. Sincerity without them isn’t...” She searched for the word. “It isn’t true sincerity. It’s only feeling strongly while keeping the other person in the dark.”

Even as she said it, she thought of Damien carrying gear for an organization that barely existed, of Ana tearing up a cheque to buy her way into a secret, of Oliver’s manipulations and how they had made her feel. Her own secrets were not small, and they were not harmless. Some of them, perhaps, she ought to address.

Not with the man across from her, though.

Thaddeus shook his head slowly. “A relationship can be deep and meaningful without either person knowing the other entirely. I would argue that no one is ever known entirely.”

“Sure,” Siobhan said. “But can any of us really say that our secrets don’t affect those close to us at all, and never will?”

His jaw worked. He looked at her as if she were a glyph in Myrddin’s journal, just on the edge of recognizability, and yet stubbornly refusing to resolve into coherence. “No. I suppose we cannot.”

The disagreement hung between them, unresolved. Siobhan did not expect absolution, and she would not grant it. What he had told her explained much. It changed nothing about what he had done in the tunnels.

Thaddeus shifted, his gaze sharpening. “Your shadow-familiar,” he said.

“You told me once that it was harmless,” he said. “Was that true, or was it a lie?”

Siobhan held herself still.

Her thoughts sprinted ahead of her face. Why ask now? Why tonight, and at this point of the conversation? Was he just asking to see if she flinched, literally or metaphorically? She let a wry smile curve her mouth. “I take it you mean your window.”

Something flickered at the corner of his eye, perhaps amusement. “I meant my window,” he agreed.

“It was true when I told you.” She kept her voice light and level. “My capabilities have expanded a great deal since then. Now it can be harmless.” She paused, letting the darkness pooled beneath her chair thicken a fraction. “Or it can be extremely, singularly deadly.”

Whatever conclusion he reached, he kept it to himself. “Noted.”

The quiet that followed was not comfortable, but it had stopped tightening. “It will be dawn in a couple of hours,” he said. “Do you still have time to discuss what we read tonight?”

She looked to the books in front of her, but found herself more curious about whatever Thaddeus might have to say.

He leaned forward, his attention sharpening into the hunger she recognized from her own reflection. “The Work. He capitalizes it everywhere. What is it?”

“I do not know. It runs through every journal I’ve opened, but he never defines the whole of it. Only the pieces. What he developed, what he lacked, what he would need to succeed.”

“A body of pure celerium, in one unbroken piece.” Thaddeus tapped the table once. “That is not a Conduit. Does it not seem more likely something meant to be inhabited?”

“That question takes on new meaning when you consider that he seems very sure celerium comes from Titan corpses. And if Titans were failed attempts at…apotheosis…”

“A hypothesis,” he interjected. “Unproven. And we do not even know exactly what Myrddin meant by that term. It is too open to interpretation.”

She nodded. “All I can say is that I do not know, and I do not understand. If my knowledge of Myrddin holds true, perhaps his goal was something that we cannot think of because we don’t know enough to think of it.”

His laugh was short and genuine. “You give the man too much credit. He was human, mortal, and our goals and desires always have the same few themes.”

Siobhan looked down at the ring on her finger. “This is a piece of the corpse of something that tried to become a god.”

“Hubris can fell even the greatest,” he muttered distantly, his gaze following her own. “None of us are immune.”

She thought of the method Myrddin had developed to turn beast cores into celerium, and wondered for a moment why he had not simply tried to recombine celerium from the same source, or turn celerium into more celerium. After all, a purified beast core returned more celerium than its original volume.

Perhaps it had to do with the identity, the thought-weight that he kept talking about. Or perhaps there was some other obvious limitation that she was too ignorant to grasp. Reading a recipe had never made anyone a chef, and Myrddin had spent decades on this. She had spent weeks, and still had classes, a sleep-proxy to renew, and a Red Guard deadline ticking down.

‘I can’t learn all of this alone. I can’t even learn the half of it.’

But she would not have to. The Midnight Court stood ready among the Starpeak clouds, waiting for people whose knowledge, hands, and minds could carry what hers could not.

They spoke for a while longer, and then she turned to her books, trying to glean clues from shamanic knowledge that someone had deemed too powerful or dangerous to be shelved on the floors above.

When dawn approached—though she never would have known it without her pocket watch—she re-shelved the books and left. Thaddeus offered to walk her to the transport tubes, and since she did not want to call upon Legion and rip open a portal to the spirit realm to escape, she allowed it.

Siobhan walked south until she found a gloomy alley with now windows. Then she let Legion open the way.

The spirit realm received her badly.

Siobhan caught her balance against a wall and snatched her hand away. The brick was warm.

The buildings climbed past any height their foundations could bear, their upper stories leaning inward until the strip of sky between them narrowed to a seam. Windows stacked upon windows, hundreds of them, most dark. Shadows pooled thick as tar in every doorway and gutter, and she could not tell where any of them ended.

She had not felt this small in a long time.

Spirits moved through the street. Most wore something near a human shape: a woman of lamp-smoke drifting from door to door, a cluster of children with faces like smudged chalk, a stooped figure hauling a cart that left no tracks. They paid her little mind.

Others did. Three crouched along a rooftop ledge, lean and angular, their limbs folded in too many places. Their heads turned together as she took a step forward, their eyes growing larger with hunger, as if she were a mouse and they a trio of cats.

‘I am unsettled’ she realized. In a place like this, she might as well have been bleeding freely in the ocean. It was not safe.

She stopped and rolled her neck to stretch the muscles, pressed her hands to her diaphragm, and Willed herself to calm and confidence. ‘I am Siobhan Naught,’ she reminded herself. The Midnight Court pressed overhead like a hand on the crown of her skull, and the corridors loosened back into fog and pale distance.

Legion said nothing, which she suspected was tact. Perhaps they were maturing. She changed her mind when they stuck out their tongue and made an exaggerated, mocking face at the trio of rooftop predators. When Legion turned around and started wiggling their backside up at the roof in an elaborate dance that required them to change their physical anatomy just to maintain balance, she turned and walked in the direction of the guiding light beacon she needed without waiting for Legion to finish.

When they realized, they scampered to catch up. “Why’d you leave? I’d almost enraged them into attacking, and then I could have had a nice snack.”

“Disgusting.”

Legion frowned thoughtfully. “True. Now that I don’t have a real body, it might not be safe, either. I wouldn’t want to get contaminated.”

A few minutes later, she stepped out onto the carpet of Oliver’s fancy office at the Verdant Stag.

Oliver had been bent over a ledger. He was now on his feet with a battle wand in his hand and his chair on its back behind him.

“Myrddin’s balls,” he said.

“Good morning.”

“It is not.” He lowered the wand by stages, one hand pressing the other down as though it might not agree to relax. “Siobhan. You cannot do that in front of people. I mean that as a strategic recommendation and as a personal plea.”

“Was it that bad?”

“I’m a Null. Magic slides off me like rain off oilcloth.” He righted the chair with more force than it required. “And for about three milliseconds before you appeared, I was certain that the world was ending. I had the absurd thought that something large and hungry was standing behind me, and then my stomach flipped like gravity had disappeared and I might simply fall off the face of the planet.”

He rubbed the back of his neck. “It felt like a door opening and footsteps moving down the hall in a house I know is empty. Like lying on the bed as a child, certain that something is breathing in the dark space underneath me.”

Siobhan frowned. If a Null could feel it, then other people surely could, right? If it was that impactful, anyone who had felt it once might recognize it again. A herald announcing her before she arrived. She wondered how far the sensation reached. Surely not too far, or she would have noticed random people on nearby streets reacting. And in the tunnels, when Legion had torn the doorway open with Thaddeus closing in, he had not faltered at all. Perhaps fury had drowned it out. Perhaps he simply had better nerves than Oliver. She filed the question away in her mind.

“I’ll be more careful,” she said. “I need to tell you something, but I can’t as Siobhan. I want to try as Sebastien.”

He gestured toward a door to the side, which opened onto an adjoining dressing room. It was full of fancy clothes, a couple of masks, and some battle artifacts.

Behind the closed door, she let the amulet’s change wash over her. Bones and weight shifted, and Sebastien looked back at her from the narrow mirror, then wiped off her makeup. She did not leave immediately. Instead, she though of what she would say to Oliver.

The vow sat in her throat like a swallowed stone. She pressed against it with her Will, slow and deliberate. ‘My name is Sebastien Siverling. This body is Sebastien. Sebastien made no promise to Kiernan.’ The stone did not dissolve, but it shifted, and the space around it widened enough to speak through.

When she returned, Oliver had poured two glasses of water and left both untouched.

“Myrddin describes an ideal body for the Work,” Sebastien said. Her throat tightened on each phrase, but the words came. “One enormous, unbroken piece of pure celerium. Something meant to be—“ Her jaw locked. She waited it out. “Inhabited, perhaps. He says celerium comes from Titan corpses. He calls the quality it shares with beast cores and elementals thought-weight. And he suspects the Titans were failed transformations. Attempts at apotheosis that ran short of energy.”

Oliver sat very still. Then he reached for his water, drank half of it, and set it down precisely within its own ring of condensation. “There’s a joke in there somewhere. Every Conduit in Lenore,” he said, “is a piece of a dead god?”

She shrugged. “A failed god.”

“But what is a god?”

“Exactly. Too vague to be useful, especially since the Titans are all dead now anyway. I’m sure being a successful god involves immortality. But still…it’s unsettling.” She had always thought of the Titans as some other species that had simply gone extinct. And, though she had not spoken of it to Thaddeus, she had also wondered if the Cataclysm itself had some correlation. After all, supposedly the Titans had been around for it. Most even thought it was what drove them insane, though there was no real evidence for that.

This idea of apotheosis lent some insight into the ancient religions, perhaps. Historians had posited that the idea of gods were once popular because after the Cataclysm, so much knowledge was lost that almost all magic was transmogrification, which could lead societies to a more mystical mindset. The more magic and the natural sciences began to be understood, and the more society stabilized into larger groups, the more personal power shifted to individuals. Then, they had less incentive to believe in some outside super-powerful being or force. Also, the thaumaturge’s mindset required so much personal belief, a kind of supreme hubris about one’s authority over reality, that it was hard to allow room for much else.

Those who still persisted were considered strange and, perhaps, somewhat mentally unbalanced. They might call themselves churches, but normal people called them “cults.”

Even the Church of the Radiant Maiden acknowledged that the Radiant Maiden herself was not omniscient or all-powerful. She was just the pinnacle example of her species and the qualities of Radiant planar energy. But, perhaps by some interpretations of the word, she could be considered a god. ‘She’s lived for thousands of years. Even if she’s not technically immortal, that doesn’t make much difference to a species that lives a few hundred years at most.’

But if some of the Titans had gone around stomping on and devouring every little community that didn’t agree to worship them, superstition would have been a matter of survival.

“Someone from the Architects read this too?”

“Yes. In fact, it happened to be Archmage Zard.”

“You met Archmage Zard?”

“And made an enemy of him for life. I almost tried to kill him.”

Oliver stared at her. “Have you lost your mind.” It was not a question.

“I think I could do it,” she insisted.

After arguing with her for a full ten minutes, Oliver sat back down, tapping one finger against the glass as his gaze turned inward.

Sebastien sank into the other chair, sweat cooling at her hairline, and let him think. Her own thoughts had already drifted back to the creepy-feeling spirit realm portals. If opening a door rang a bell, perhaps she did not need a door. Her sigils already reached across the city, and Myrddin had inspired her.

Author Note: I will be back with the next chapter next Thursday, the 19th. :)

Weekly discussion thread on the Alcove: https://alcove.azaleaellis.com/t/chapter-307-weekly-discussion-a-specimen/999

Comments

BlastYoBoots

Hah, I’d hoped so! She WAS copying all the books’ contents down and they didn’t even know it!!!

Dan

Thank you for the chapter! Ohhhh can she just step through the Spirit Realm like walking through a mirror to each of her waypoints? It would be nearly teleportation! Also well done whoever questioned if she was transcribing while reading! Siobhan is becoming an outright monster of a thaumaturge!

frankie doerr

I’m gonna need a couple reread to digest all this thanks for the info dump this is gonna keep me up all night

Justin Barnett

This gives a lot of context to why Thaddeus wants the title of archmage.

da-re

Wonderful chapter as always :) Also, damn. Lacer's backstory hit like a ton of bricks. That was so much worse then I ever thought it would be. Also also, I hope that the mention of Damian and Anna means that S will potentially come clean to them. She really needs friends that are her age that she can relate to. That she doesnt have to hide from and also except her completely.

Jordan

I have a continuity question, if Thaddeus was raised this way and ended up, with some other weird group taken advantage of, does this conflict with his previous story to Sebastian about his magical training, and that he had been tricking his tutor with transmutation instead of transmogrification, cause this would probably be age appropriate 11-14 most likely, does he just get adopted or brought into some other place than the group mentioned that took him in and someone started paying for a fancy tutor?

Dan

I'd guess there's something involving the Red Guard here. If he demonstrated magical aptitude and was persistent to join, they may have accepted him when he was of age. And it seems like he was 'mistreated' (unsure of censorship) while with the Stewards of Intention so he likely would have jumped ship the moment he was able.

Can't Pick

Ahhhhh I was so excited for Thaddeus' backstory and now I want moreeeee! It's like when we saw Siobhan's grandfather for a whole book and then barely learned anything about him, like how he made artifacts that can be triggered with pure will.

Allie C

I'm guessing that the way Siobhan would try to kill Zard is related to magic she can use because of Legion... Girl, why are you putting so much faith in an entity that just changed their body to better waggle their butt at some random spirits? And that's assuming they aren't hatching secret plans to free themselves of their vow. Also, the woman Thaddeus told about his childhood... I'm getting Damien's mom? I've wondered since near the beginning if they were lovers at some point or if he had unrequited feelings or something.

Current

That was the best chapter so far, thank you.

Ange

Here I am trying to digest the complex emotions and then BAM Legion taunting Spirit realm inhabitants in the most childish ridiculous manner possible. You're able to so skillfully and naturally diffuse tension and balance seriousness and humor in a way that's just so impressive every time. I definitely need to reread this and sit with it oof but I am dying to know what Thaddeus thinks/feels after hearing her spell was harmless but is not anymore. And absolutely screaming about the idea that she might be able to jump into the spirit realm without a door! And how the shadow portals make people feel, I can't wait until we find out what Betty tells everybody. Thaddeus shifted, his gaze sharpening. “Your shadow-familiar,” he said. “You told me once that it was harmless,” he said. “Was that true, or was it a lie?” - since it's both his dialogue this should be combined into one paragraph and the second he said should probably be removed. she found a gloomy alley with now windows - should be 'no'

Ange

Similarly to Sebastien's fake backstory, someone could easily have seen Thaddeus's talent and taken him as a ward

Jordan

I figured that would be a way to explain it, but made me wonder,

Dan

We'll see if Siobhan figures out that a doorway can be on any surface, so she can literally 'move through shadows' without needing to open a 'door'. Her emblem would become a holy icon then. Agreed, removing the second 'he said' and combining '"Your shadow-familiar," he said. "You told me once that it was harmless."' together would work. Then adding a separate line for "Was that true, or was it a lie?" works. There's an implied pause too which adds tension.

James Barclay

If changing identity can bypass vows, recreating that transformation amulet (and maybe investing some thought-weight into a spirit world monument) for Thads might be a solution.

Adam

Thank you for the chapter! 🙏🏽 I hope we get to see Siobhan using piecie of Newton for experiments soon.

Emma Mass

That wasn't siabhons grandfather, that was myrddin. Hey grandfather made the self charging defensive amulet with a variety of built in protections which have been invaluable to Siobhan even tho it wasn't finished. Not an artifact that operates purely on will but still incredibly impressive

Tanna

Amazing chapter

Russell whisenant

I always figured they were Platonic if only because he didn't kill her husband, but now I'm rethinking that. There don't seem to be any other candidates we've heard of for that one person he told before and the fact that she was the only one who knew his tragic back story makes the bond feel more somehow. I can see them being more than friends, though how she persuaded him to spare Mr. Westbay still confuses me.

Russell whisenant

It would help especially given his current efforts, but I wouldn't call this a solution by itself. I always got the impression that red guard oaths were in a league of their own, especially the secret vows they use to bind their members. Remember how he said his oath to the architects was to vague to bind him to anything and they didn't even use an intent aligning ritual first? He never expected her oath to the architects to really bind her and took her haggling over terms as a sign of how honorable she was that she actually intended to keep her word. The other magical vow she evaded was similarly dismissed by him as the light version. He was proud of getting his apprentice out of anything more restrictive.

Russell whisenant

Those last couple of sentences – such a cliffhanger. Do you think she's talking about inverting the spirit world viewing spell to spy on the material plane from the spirit world, or some means of getting to those locations physically without making "a door"? It is so intriguing, and so frustratingly unclear.

Russell whisenant

If the part of the spirit world she's connecting to the physical world controls whether people get an eerie feeling from it this is super useful, but otherwise it feels like a nerf.

Ange

Noticed a mistake I don't think anyone else mentioned while rereading: 'forced herself to breath deeply through' should be breathe

hhttghlk

"A child who stood in front of people who measured them by what they could provide would learn to make that measurement so impressive no one would think of discarding them." And now I feel bad for giggling at Thaddeus' reaction to potentially being recognised as an archmage.

Russell whisenant

You know at some point after facing her greatest fear, conquering it, and forcing it to turn its unfathomable power to her surface Siobhan got cocky… I like it! Confidence looks good on her! I'm still trying to pen down exactly when the attitude shift occurred. I mean she's never been a shrinking violet and binding Legion is all the explanation you need for her confidence reaching the next level, but I still feel like there was time between her binding Legion and her deciding she could kill Thaddeus or Zard.

Nytram12

Some of the earlier chapters of this book had her thought process around what she's trying to achieve and how she has decided to be more deliberate in her choices and actions

Allie C

It could easily have been a really deep platonic friendship. If it was more, I'm wondering if Thaddeus didn't know that she would end up with someone like Westbay from the beginning. Of course, they could have been having an affair with the understanding that her children would have to be legitimate. I don't think we specifically know her background, but if she was from a crown family there's almost no way she would have been able to marry an orphan commoner without totally splitting off from them. They would both have known any dalliance they had was doomed, and Thaddeus was probably much less powerful and famous back then.

Tanna

The oath between Siobhan and Legion became a physical object in the Spirit Realm, so maybe that could be a way to attack it directly instead of subverting individual tenets one at a time. I can't really imagine that happening before he gets far enough on his own to confess to attacking her. Maybe afterwards Siobhan can help him break the oath completely so they can be proper allies.

Dan

It might also cause everything to fall apart; if Thaddeus can gain a pure Celerium body to get around the vows he might connect Siobhan and Sebastien together which would trigger the Red Guard vows AND would potentially kickstart the gu since the Royals being threats against the Raven Queen are now threats against Sebastien

Lady Merlin

Amazing chapter. So much character, history, and story developments. This was my favorite, though: "And if I have to choose a side, I will choose yours." He was ready to go up against an archmage with her, and I know there are trust issues to work out - but I hope this works out for both of them, whatever that looks like.

CodeLabMaster

Thaddeus bringing up the role of talent/bloodlines here, and how Damien's mom married into the Westbay family, makes me suspect that if Sebastian ever goes to that Gervin soiree that they were invited to by Lord Gervin back in book 3, they are gonna get a lot of marriage offers from Crowns families. Before hearing this story, I could imagine Siobahn simply dismissing them or getting annoyed, but I wonder how she might react now. This is maybe the most unsettled we've seen Siobhan before aside from her fight with Lacer. Each chapter leaves me wanting more! Masterful writing!

Sadtyre

Could also be that only nulls feel this strange unsettling feeling. We still don’t know too much about the origins of nulls, I think. For all we know could have some instinctual connection to the spirit realm.

Russell whisenant

Wow. A null being more sensitive to this kind of magic is not something I would've thought of since it's kind of the opposite of how they interact with most magics, but you're right that we don't know.

Sindri

Good call about the future Mrs Westbay. I don't think they were ever lovers, but they were good enough friends that he committed to protecting her children after she died, even when he's willing to let the rest of the city rot.

Sindri

The problem is, sometimes Thadeus is not *able* to choose a side. She can't ever trust him with the important things, because if she trips one of the cows he hasn't broken yet, he has no choice in what comes next. And he's broken all the vows that come up frequently, but the ones he doesn't have many chances to stretch are as strong as the day he joined the Red Guard; she has no way to know how many more of those hidden traps are still beneath the surface or what might trip them. If she does something like reciprocate his confessions of childhood trauma, any part of her story of what happened when she was a child might force him to do something both of them will regret forever.