Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • 591553663.mp4

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 video. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

Hello everyone!! Hope your 2026 has been off to a great start. What better way to ring in the new year than to obsess over everything we did in the year prior?

This is a review of everything I did related to MTS in 2025 - every long-form video, the short-form vids, Patreon and Nebula, the whole nine yards. Since this is a meaty boy of a video, I've got timestamps for each section below. Feel free to jump to whatever sections you're most interested in.

In addition, I have three follow-up questions for you based on the results of the surveys I ran last week. (Which btw, thank you to everyone who sent in feedback, it was all incredibly appreciated!)

FEWER EXCLUSIVE VIDEOS?

A constant theme I saw from the paid member survey was that the exclusive videos were appreciated, but folks could do with fewer of them.

Would you be happy with fewer exclusive videos on the Patreon (let's say 1-2 a month instead of 1 a week)?

MORE CASUAL SURVEYS?

If I do end up reducing the pace of exclusive videos, I'd still like to keep up with posting polls for both paid and free members. I think it's fun to get your takes on all things music.

Would you be cool with polls for both paid and free members still happening, even if they don't lead to videos about the topic?

(I also saw free members requesting polls for future main channel videos - I'm going to try that in my next update post later this week.)

NEW DEEP DISCOG DIVE PROCESS?

In the video (at 01:06:15), I go over a new potential process for the DDD - one that's more community-driven.

Would you like me to make the next DDD with that process?

And that's it for now! I'll be back later this week with a rough schedule of my first main channel videos for 2026. Until then, stay cool and be well!

TIMESTAMPS

00:00 Intro

01:24 Why am I doing this?

02:32 What happened this year?

05:33 Reviewing Every Video on the Main Channel in 2025

07:08 "The Weirdest Instrument I've Ever Played"

10:42 300k Q&A + Full-Time Announcement

12:13 "Why Joker 2 is a Better Musical Than You'd Think"

15:54 "The Hidden Toll of Touring No One Sees"

17:29 "Copyright is Broken on YouTube"

19:51 MJ+Prince+Madonna DDD Compilation

21:59 Chance The Rapper DDD

23:27 Sidebar about Chance

28:54 "I Only Listened to The Radio For A Month"

30:19 "The One Part of Making Music No One Talks About"

31:13 "Why Music Festivals Don't Feel The Same Anymore"

33:34 "We Need To Talk About AI Music"

35:52 "The Billion-Dollar Tours That Changed Everything"

37:56 "catching up with the 2025 Grammys"

39:04 Oasis DDD

40:47 Madonna DDD

41:51 "When Fake Bands Score Real Hits"

43:02 "Best Music of 2025 Awards"

44:52 "Top 10 Albums of 2025"

48:09 "The Biggest Music Streaming Service You've Never Heard Of"

49:26 "The Best Album of 2026 (Isn't An Album)"

50:48 "'The Worst Song Ever'"

52:02 "I Ranked Every Big Album From 2025"

53:36 "The Most Expensive Music Videos Ever Made"

54:20 Michael Jackson DDD

55:49 "Ranking 2025's Songs of The Summer"

56:50 "The Secret Technology Behind Every Major Concert"

57:31 "The Subtle Clues That Give Away AI Music"

58:50 Short-Form Videos

01:02:32 Patreon + Nebula

01:03:31 Patreon Survey Results

01:06:15 New DDD Process???

01:09:23 Record Pull

01:10:58 Goals for 2026

Files

Comments

Plexxl

The community DDD is a great idea. I think a cool way to go about it is if you're taking community input, it's to try and see how your community thinks about the artist at the start of the DDD research versus the end, especially when it comes to people who might not be familiar/avid listener of that artist.

Rvel_07

I’d still love for you to choose maybe one or two artists a year on your own accord because the more unconventional picks that likely wouldn’t win a vote like Chumbawumba make for very interesting videos!

MysteryMii

The music note in the time section is a change related to YouTube rolling out a cheaper version of YouTube Premium that didn’t remove ads on anything that had music in it a while back. It mainly just indicates whenever YouTube has detected a majority of the video has copyrighted music in it, and therefore is not ad-free for Premium Lite members.

Violet

RIP Hype The Snare 2025-2025

zyslythe

I really like the idea of the new DDD process, personally. I wonder though, would it be possible to somewhat merge the ideas of the DDD updates and the listening club/album reactions in certain instances? Also, will the fan-made discord used for the trivia be considered the official one?

Violet

I wonder if there’s a middle ground for the top 10 of the year video where Patreon and nebula get the longer version and YouTube gets the shorter version?

Bob Nick

Here is my Personal feedback from this: Wait your name isn't Michael? Wait your 30? Thought you were at least 25. I feel like the new idea for the DDD process looks good, I feel like i would enjoy it personally, would definitely do a trial of it. Record Pull I would say doesn't work in its current form, An idea i have for it (Which is kind of what i do for my content) is make it like a format for IG where you share what you have been listening to that week and sprinkle one or two songs from smaller bands and artists that are submitted and have it link to a playlist if wanted. My final "totally serious" video idea since you want to hit 400k subs is in January 2027, you do the same video as this one but with no cuts and you do it while eating a Subway Footlong Sub for every 10 YT subscribers in 2026, For example you need 40k to 400k, if you reach it you will have to eat at least 4k sandwiches, even if you finish the presentation, keep going. Anyways keep on doing the amazing work - Bob

Rudi

Great recap vid, I think i agree with 99% of your takes, I just hope that the format of the best of music for INSERT YEAR HERE videos doesn't change, I understand those are a copyright hell to go through but its fun to just hear the year for 11 minutes or so. Also love the idea of community DDD, and a continued RIP to the "learning to like" videos, maybe that would be a cool series to make a patreon/nebula exclusive? I feel like the community here could be a great way to get suggestions for that video format, but I also understand if that idea is just never coming back.

Joey Q.

I think the new process of the DDD is going to be very cool and I can't wait for the video about your CD collection. Overall, very pleased with this Mic The Snareholder PowerPoint presentation.

Ryan Vollert

yes yes yes to the new DDD process. I’ve been wondering for a while now, as someone in the process of putting together my own video essay, what do you use to download clips and music videos? recently found out the site I’d been using (cobalt) no longer supports youtube so i’m in need of an easy to use site that runs (relatively) fast and without pop-ups.

Leendert van der Plas

If your channel becomes a woodworking channel, call it Mic The Chair

Katt i Låda

idk I am biased i guess, cause I am just watching, going, wait, that was a flop? "but I liked that video!" at all of these. It's really cool to hear u explain ur perspective on all of this though. The new DDD concept sounds really cool, u should definitely do that

Carson Mellon

I can say from personal experience, year end list season doesn’t appeal to the audience if they don’t know who you are. I can’t even count the number of year-end lists I’ve gotten recommended, but I didn’t watch them because I didn’t know who they are. So, either you change the way you do year end list season as a whole, like you mentioned, or you keep it the way it is and see if a natural growth in the channel can result in more views on those videos as your name gets out there. Love your vids :)

Leaforator

Finally! At last we've got Mic the Snare-sident's Address to the Patreo-Nation! For real though, I've always had a curiosity for the dichotomous relationship a creator and audience have with videos, so this was really eye-opening regarding what your personal barometers are for failure and success in the field. What does worry me going forward (as a viewer/fan) is the increased first-week metrics on new videos to not flop, particularly the impact it already seems to be having DDD regarding the choice of artists to cover. The new metrics (and your takeaways from this year) favouring big MJ and Beatles tier artists kind of limits what the DDD can be IMO. I see a *lot* of requests in the community for smaller, more music-nerd-core artists like Ween and Swans, and that may make people feel like they're less involved in the process (even if someone with slightly more mainstream taste like me wouldn't be into them). There's also the issue that who counts as a major artist might end up being a very America-centric thing. I know this may be because your audience is largely from the States (I'm assuming?), but the new metric focus might start sidelining big artists from outside the US, even if they were a Big Deal™ everywhere else. For example, I'm Australian, so artists like Kylie Minogue, Crowded House or INXS (who are all HUGE in the UK and are held up as living legends here) may likely not get covered because of their comparitively small status in America. Regarding the new DDD process, I think it's probably best to do a one-off experiment first before going all in on it? Like, the teases are some of the most fun parts of the DDD experience (at least for me), and removing them entirely for the process might take away some of that fun. I'm of the opinion that having a Patron sourced DDD Decision list is probably a more realistic option, but everyone else already seems to be on board with the proposed process, so what do I know. I think my biggest nit-pick is that DDD releases could be a little more frequent. I really hope I'm not coming across as skewing negative for the sake of opposition or feeling entitled over your creative ventures in this wall of text; I've loved pretty much every video you've made this year (I think I've rewatched the MJ dive at least 10 times!), and I really hope you're able to keep making videos on whatever you want :)

Garrett Auld

I really like the idea of being able to pick the artist again for DDD, but I do also think it could maybe lead to an over saturation of certain types of artists, like the legacy pop and rock artists due to sheer popularity. I think episodes on artists I’ve known very little about have introduced me to some of my favorite music, like De La Soul or King Gizzard. Id love to have input and some updates especially if it’s artists I know, but also some out of the box picks. Keep up the great work man

Josie Authers

for the joker 2 video i’ve seen a lot of videos in that style use “in defense of _____” as a title, which i think would have worked very well in this case

aproperkatie

So, I want to comment on the DDD stuff first and foremost, since that's what got me into your channel. Let me start by saying that I love the DDDs, and since at least the Bowie DDD, I've followed along with every band and artist you've covered. By that I mean, I've listened to the complete discographies of every band and artist you've ever done a DDD (yes, even Prince and King Gizz). It's not only made me even more of a music fan than I already was, but it helped me fall more in love with bands and artists I already loved, and even introduced me to bands and artists I hadn't given much of a chance. For that, I owe you a lot. With that said, the thought of you no longer covering bands/artists that aren't massive breaks my heart. I get that the Ratboys DDD didn't do great, nor did Chance's DDD this year, but that's a whole lot of the fun of them for me. You made me a fan of Ratboys and made me give Chance a shot. But like...what are you defining as massive here? I wouldn't call King Gizz or Sufjan massive on the levels of MJ or The Beatles, but they're way more well known than Ratboys. I'd argue Chance is more known than them too. But those dives still cracked over 100K. And if you stopped covering lesser known artists, then we wouldn't get cool experiements like that Chumbawamba dive from a few years ago. That's one of your best dives ever, but it just wouldn't be possible if you didn't do "big" artists anymore. So what is your line between massive and not massive? If some of the artists you consider not massive enough are the ones you did those old short form dives on, does that mean you're no longer going back to redo them? What's happening there? And with THAT out of the way, I love love love LOVE your idea for the new DDD process. This is exactly the sort of thing I hoped you'd announce the moment you started a Patreon. I'm really curious how you plan on going about that. Is it gonna be as massive of a poll as the ones from the past, or a more truncated one? Would you do a separate poll for redos of old dives? I've also noticed you have a tradition of covering polarizing/bad artists at least once a year. Would you have a separate poll for that too? Regardless of how you go about it, I'm really excited for it. Maybe I can even get a head start on following along with your dives. (Just please consider taking risks on lesser known artists sometimes. I won't lie to you Mic, I love your work, but you're starting to sound a little too content brained in this. )

Valtteri Nietula

I think I commented this on another post as well, but even if you end up scrapping record pull, it would be interesting to hear more about the behind the scenes process of music licensing.

Andrew Behm

This is a very neat format, haven't seen anyone do this before. Popped over to Patreon to leave this comment, but I've been following you for a while and it was so cool to see you start posting on Nebula, and then posting your exclusives there as well is awesome! However, I do feel bad because I'll watch your videos on Nebula, love it, but then have it recommended to me soon after on YT and not watch again. Thankfully I'm just one person, but would hate to contribute to tanking any video's success. Also, hope you do get to speak on a panel, that would be awesome!

Duke86fan

honestly i've never been into the "look at the algorithm" situation... because i love when a youtuber is just "lets have fun with what we like and have fun"... but at the same time its kinda like this is your main job so you need them to do good... its a lot of big complication of art vs commerce... personally i prefer the caddicarus side where you do what you want and broadcast yourself but i understand so much why people have trouble with all the algorithmic work.. and its interesting to see the process for that detail

Antoinette

I'm all for a Blur DDD!!!

jayjie

i appreciate the look inside ! i said just as much in the youtube comments, but ive watched the chance ddd about a dozen times so far. chance embodies joy, or at least naïveté, & so does his ddd. its clear that u felt that. im also grateful u learned ur lesson from the hypebeast thumbnails. now im talking 2 u like ure my son. or nephew, in the case of that 1 commenter who always says 'hi uncle mike, mom misses u.' im not that commenter. ive watched every video uve put out or re-released this year in full & ill confess that i do not rly remember the hydraulophone 1. i think it was mainly just the subject of the video that didnt catch my eyes & ears as much as ur other videos, even tho it should on paper - travel vlog, unique instrument, sick cause. but i cannot recall what exactly transpired within it. finally, i cant remember what ur verdict was on musi in that video, but that IS the app thru which i consume ur ddds when im on the road for my job. i believe i said just as much in a comment on that video. my rationale is: sometimes i dont wanna open up youtube & get hit with the endless scroll. i wanna get 2 ur videos in fewer clicks with less distractions & that app does the trick. this was a real insightful look at the process, thank u once again. manifesting a beach boys ddd in 2026 but as always u do u king.

Mam man

Hey Mic! I have been watching your channel since the Nirvana DDD. Your videos have given me immense joy and they have created a spark within me to explore more music. This video was a really interesting look into what has happened in your video making journey this year. Some suggestions I had are as follows: 1) THE DDD Thumbnail: It's really sad that the stupid content farm thumbnail for Chance's DDD got you more attention than the normal one. But I think that you should do the thumbnails for the Deep Discog Dives in the style of that brief period in 2023 (i.e. LDR, Aphex Twin, Coldplay and The National). Those looked good and aside from your dads and your best friends, all of them got decent views. Also, change the D'Angelo thumbnail as well. 2) DDD Poll Thing: I'm happy that you'll be bringing the polls back. 3 and final) Your videos on audio tech are really good but with the In Ear video, I found it kind of difficult to understand some of it. I hope THAT you will make the technology videos more accessible. These are the things I had to say about your videos this year. I enjoyed almost all of them. And I hope that I'll still be watching this channel at the end of the decade. Thank you for introducing me to grae and SIMBI and I hope you have a great year ahead. PS I couldn't separate this in paragraphs since my Enter button posts the comment. So, it's in a long ass paragraph now.

David Dalby

Is that Metroid Prime music I hear in the background? Excellent choice

Dr. Katz

Just wanted to say thank you for introducing me to so much music I’d never heard of before and being so passionate about music. I’m someone who now only exclusively watches your videos on Nebula & Patreon I hope you don’t get too discouraged by the lower views on certain videos. As for stuff I’d love to see more on the channel/patreon/nebula is more discussions about new music. Doesn’t have to be full Fantano-style reviews but, I love hearing you talk about music that otherwise wouldn’t have a chance to be discussed on the channel (e.g. the ranking every big album of 2025, end of year discussions/polls). (Also I’d love to see more interviews and more record pull.)

Jacob Gregersen

I will say while I get not being able to make niche DDDs anymore I do hope you can find ways to talk about smaller artists because both the chance DDD and especially the National DDD were able to suck me into the artist.

claireimy_bearimy

Ok this must be divine timing because I just applied for a marketing/content creator job in local government?? If I end up getting it, you bet your ass I'll be coming back to this to better analyze my own work. That said, this is sooooo endlessly fascinating to me! If I remove my ardent supporter glasses and put on my general public ones, I can kind of see how the flops ended up flopping and the hits ended up hitting. Though as a travel lover, I'm so sad most of your travel videos ended up flopping! I don't get much PTO so it's nice to live vicariously through my favorite creators sometimes. 😊 And just between you and me--you have an excellent face that deserves to be in more thumbnails! I don't know what the general public is thinking in that regard. Also, your DDD idea? Fabulous!! DDDs really lend themselves well to conversation throughout the process so hopefully this can help us all connect more and build excitement for the final product. I'd love to see this for the next DDD! I look forward to goading everyone here into making the DD1D (One Direction DDD) of my dreams a reality and reliving my fandom days every step of the way. (Btw, if you ever did want to learn woodworking, I happen to know an excellent teacher. Not to brag, but my dad built a huge wooden chest for my elementary school's lost and found that still looks brand new today, over 20 years later! He also has some killer music taste, though I may be biased there. Just saying! 😄)

Muse of Salzburg

A month of year end stuff would be a bit much but something I’d be down to see is a more casual video about anything and everything in music you just want to talk about more, like if you took your Underrated Albums and Honorable Mentions sections from your year end videos and made them their own thing, though I suppose you did kind of do that with the Ranking All Albums vid, but I bet you could frame it differently

Richard Batchelor

Hey, not sure if you saw the private message I sent you on discord recently. You may want to check on that 'Katherine Jayne Diss Track When'. She put out a new album this week and uhhhhh, she saw the video and has thoughts.........

avian

coming into the comments a bit late, but this was a really interesting video! i’ve been a big fan since around the time of the bowie ddd, and i appreciated getting a chance to glimpse behind the curtain! this does get addressed in the video, so i won’t dwell on it too much, but i do think storytelling is absolutely a big part of a video’s long term success. there are a bunch of ddd’s i’ll regularly go back to, even if i’m not a huge fan of the artist, just because the story of the band is so interesting (i.e. fleetwood mac, the beatles, prince), or the perspective you add to their work is compelling in its own right (i.e. ajr, taylor swift). i think of videos like jenny Nicholson’s evermore video or defuntland’s recent video of disney’s living characters and i can’t imagine most of the audience tuning into those videos are huge theme park buffs, but are probably more casual fans who appreciate both the deep dive aspect and are interested in the storytelling that comes with it. i really liked the chance the rapper video, but i wonder if part of the reason why the “hypebeast” thumbnail/title worked so well is because it set the expectation that the video would be exploring the reasons for chance’s “downfall”, and that got people who were otherwise unfamiliar with chance the rapper (or the ddd series) to tune in. it’s unfortunate that that’s how the system is set up, but i hope my two cents can offer at least a little perspective on what i think may have occurred.

Rob Wilson

is this how being a shareholder feels?