[Weekly Update] Chinese Setting in Non-Chinese Films - Part 1 (India (Patreon)
Content
After an incredible experience of rewriting the script three times, falling sick, computer glitching out, Internet dropping out, falling sick for a second time this month, and rendering issues, our next video on Chandni Chowk to China is finally ready to be shown tomorrow.
I can't wait to find out all the mistakes I made mere seconds after its release.
Anyway, since we are talking about an Indian movie with a Chinese setting, let's keep exploring this topic a bit more.
But first, here's the housekeeping.
CHANNEL UPDATE
Next Video
Our working schedule is quite chaotic at the moment, as I have quite a few projects going on at the same time. Which ever video gets finished first will be published first. The topics I'm working on includes:
America in Chinese Movies
The project is gradually becoming about how Chinese movies (and Japanese movies) depict gun violence in America. Seriously, whenever America shows up in a Chinese film, a gun is going to appear.
As I already have a few Japanese movies included, I'm thinking of including Korean films, as well. I'm not as familiar with Korean cinema, however. So, if you have any recommendations, let me know.
Chinese Action Genre Has an Uncool Problem
This is a topic I noticed back when I was working on post-retirement Jackie Chan two-parter. Though no longer doing all the crazy stunts, Jackie continues to act in action movies, often directed by younger directors. It's honestly an honourable thing to do. He loves being on set, and he loves lending his star power to a new generation who may not have the chance to shine otherwise. Understandably, this resulted in a lot of Jackie Chan stinkers. But it also gave us The Shadow's Edge.
Regardless of quality, however, these action movies all have a similar problem: They are tried really hard to be as cool as the best of Hollywood (Dark Knight, Ocean's 11, Mission Impossible), and all of them fail for the same reason. It's an interesting phenomenon that only old farts like me who still watches every new Jackie Chan movie will notice. And I intent on explaining it to an audience who has seen none of the movies.
Hollywood travesty: Mummy 3
I'm planning on a three part series in which I review a bunch of Hollywood movies with Chinese settings that are produced with the Chinese market in mind, starting with The Mummy 3.
Just typing this out feels weird. Why would Hollywood executives believe a Hollywood interpretation of China is ever appealing to a Chinese audience.
Was it because Americans loved Spaghetti Westerns? But, iirc, most of the Spaghetti Westerns also failed to make money, so...
MEDIA TALK
How is China depicted in other countries' movies? In developing our review for Chandni Chowk to China, I watched 2 additional Indian films with a Chinese setting, the 2019 drama Made in China, and the 2011 action film 7Aum Arivu, neither of which I'd recommend to you :/
Despite the title "Made in China", the Chinese setting is more thematic and political than it is scenic. Despite film on locations (in Hong Kong, I believe), the film never shows off the geography of the city, staying rather intimate with the character in depicting a almost hostile social atmosphere towards the protagonist, a failed Indian businessman and a fish out of water.
In one scene, the protagonist approaches taxi driver, attempting to speak in Chinese by reading off a book, before asking if he can speak English, to which the driver says "no no no" and drives away. It is unknown if the film intents to depict the Chinese general racial hostility towards Indians, or if it's just because the protagonist is Indian Peter Parker. Though in this case, I'd say either interpretation is valid.
I can't say this depiction is invalid. Chinese people are often only selectively friendly. Still, this cold and impersonal atmosphere, which permeates the entire setting, rendering most Chinese characters faceless symbols of hostility, is not particularly neutral. It feels very obviously coloured by the then recent souring of Chinese/Indian relations. But even without that, the Chinese setting does come off feeling like how Japan is depicted in Lost in Translation.
An then there's 7 Aum Arivu, which isn't at all shy about depicting China as the enemy. In fact, the film is frequently shared as Chennai vs China, and they do not team up at the end to defeat Doomsday. The sci-fi plot revolves around a secret Chinese plot to start biological warfare against India. The Chinese government is very much depicted as the USSR was in Cold War era American films, with its ancient residents waiting for the rescue of an Indian hero.
Indian cinema, especially Bollywood, commonly depicts its neighbouring countries as military or ideological enemies in the process of building national pride and patriotism. Other examples would include Pathaan (2023), which sees a rogue Pakistani general attempting bio-warfare against India. Yeah, bio-weapon seems like a big thing in Indian movies.
Pakistan tends to be the rival in most of these films. China really is a newcomer to the villain repertoire. During the 2010s, there are also films like Baby (2015), which deals with terrorism in the Middle East. The film is okay, but from what I understand, Indian cinephiles was not particularly fond of the heavy American action influence in this film or the genre as a whole.
This makes China's role in Indian cinema a lot less remarkable and alarming as it'd seems. I suppose, for a country that outputs as much movies as India, with such a strong inter-regional competition, it naturally pressures filmmakers into more sensationalized stories, thus resulting in films that utilize whoever India sees as villain of the week.
The only real disappointing thing, in my opinion, is out of all the films I have watched, be it about China, Pakistan or the Middle East, none of them really attempt to depict the people. I understand in a war film or a thriller, focusing only on the government is the natural thing to do. But such depiction ultimately dehumanizes an entire country, even if just very subtly so.
Anyway, that is the update for this week. Let me know if your country does similar things, depicting other countries as the villain to drum up national pride. China does this mostly with WWII movies. Korean War films were less common but is still being made. But if it's a modern day setting, most filmmakers tend to choose fictional countries and unnamed adversaries just to be politically safe.
In any case, I'll see you tomorrow with a new video.