Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Never done something like this before but I wanted to open this conversation up with you all because I’m genuinely curious:

As both the listeners and listener “characters”, which do you prefer? Listener characters to be more blank slates on which you can project yourself or listener characters who truly are their own characters with their own specific backstories and discernible characteristics.

This style of content is based so heavily off of listeners being able to see themselves in the listener “characters” as they interact with the voiced characters, but those are usually for audios roleplays that are more one off audios and not long standing series.

With Glenwood, a lot of our listener characters have developed a life of their own! Both narratively and from the fandom itself. And I’ve tried to find the balance between keeping listeners vague enough to be anyone while also including enough personality to make them feel like real people.

Many people, however, have been asking to see more of the listener’s backstories that would truly make them more like characters than self-inserts.

I would love to know what you guys think about this and where your preferences lie!

Comments

Dolls- circus

I prefer listeners which have more of a personality personally! It gives me something to work on when it comes to drawing then or thinking of headcanons! It’s also makes a lot of the romance more compelling!

Billy Denton

I think you need to be able to self insert up to a point, but there's still a lot of room for characterization within that space. The only time I ever find myself turned off by distinctive listener characters is when they do something very strongly opposed to what I would have done

Pqwnch

Definitely with series like Glenwood im 100% invested in seeing listener characters backstories and letting their own personalities shine through in the storytelling. For sure in one offs and stand alone stuff it's fine for us as the listeners to be insert characters.

ANDROID 22

I say start them out as a bit of a blank slate but maybe with a little bit if a personality, like you did with seer they liked to hord protein bar.

bubbles

personally i love having back stories! i can make Anything a self insert and when a listener character has a back story that i get to fill the shoes of, it makes me feel so much more connected to the other characters! like im truly in their world and kind of takes my mind off of my own reality.

Strayrherainbowace

I personally really love it when listener characters have their own personality and traits, yeah you're not gonna see yourself in all of them but you're still gonna love their stories and root for them to get what they want. Like I see a lot of myself in Knight, especially with how protective of my partner I am. Do I see the same thing with Seer, Dear, or Ranger? No, but you better bet I'm going full commentary mode when I'm listening to their audios. I'm their jimminy cricket. That's how I see it at least

Ashley

Me personally, I like it when the listener has a more defined backstory. Not specific reasoning, just find it more interest when imagining what the listener would look and sound like. Even if the listener is supposed to be us, I cant imagine all of them looking and sounding like me. Especially since I like picturing the scenes play in my head like a movie

Milla

I’ve always viewed them as characters! Like reading a book in first person. Your them but also not? I feel like it gives the whole story more depth and makes the connection seem more real. Like if I was really talking to Claire as ranger I definitely wouldn’t be so “ranger-y” but I love the way you portrayed the two, it adds so much chemistry.

Yoshisohappy

I think the narrative personality fits them perfectly—It makes them easier to latch onto and makes their position in story pop out—because if they’re too blank slate it’s easy to forget they’re there because often times they don’t get a say or a moment to jump in, ya know? It makes them feel less like a simply looking in point and more like a character that has their own motivations and strives

Mr.G78

I would definitely love to see more backstories! Plus, your stories are so GREAT that it never really bothered me that I couldn't self insert myself in them.

Sir.Wolf

I think a bit of background is okay but not too much because that would make it hard to feel like the listener if it's to much, sure over time they develop quirks and knacks but it's so much fun to listen slowly getting to know more of them, if we knew everything from the start it would be no fun to listen, I really liked the audio between characters without the listener invold showing a Glenwood from different eyes

Squeak

I like a good mix! Its actually one thing I've always thought you already do better than most in the audio world! I think whats already happened, where the listeners start out fairly simple, then become more complex as the story progresses, is best. And in a world like glenwood, it helps differentiate all the different storylines and makes the relationships seem more real. And even when a character does things I don't think I would do, it doesn't knock me out of the story as a whole. For example: Ranger is probably the character i relater to the least, but i still love those stories, cuz Claire is amazing. With so many characters, we can all have different ones we self-insert on, versus just coming up with headcanons about. For me, i self-insert the most with the Open-wielder, the rest I imagine different genders and personality types for!

SN-386_Carnation

I'm honestly very split on which one. I do love both versions. The more background information gets released about the listener, for example if we ever meet Rangers family or something, it could be very different from what I imagined but that's perfectly fine with me! I just accepted it and love it even more

holly

ummmm i like the way they are!!!! listening to audios helps comfort me and its much easier to do that when they’re easy to self project yourself into 😇😇

Azearah

In a long form series I think it's better for each listener character to be distinct from one another. Having a backstory adds more because if the listener has greater depth, their stories will be more compelling.

Scourge

I imagine myself as Seer as for the other listeners. I'm not sure. I think both ideas have merit. Through personally I find it hard for me to imagine what they look like. I sort of have a rough idea bur not much else

Lunerwolf

I think giving them some back story would be pretty cool please it would do good in the long run could lead to more plot lines

Tay

I absolutely love the listeners to be more like a character, while having parts of them that are ambiguous/up to the listener to decide. Like a happy medium. That’s mostly bc I don’t like to fully put myself in, I like being able to create a character in my head and put them in tbh. I genuinely love how they are rn, because it does kind of meet that happy medium. But this is your universe, if you want to make them more/less detailed that’s completely up to you!! 😊😊💛 (Especially if you want to add more lore for the listeners, I am so on board!)

Luna

I love when the listener characters have lore. It makes me connect more with certain ones and I love them even harder because of it. I'm here for dat lore

Logan 2511

For me personally, the longer a character is around, the more I give them my own personality in my head. Like, beautiful to me is a lot more confident and a sarcastic asshole, especially to Beth, than Dear can ever hope to be. Due to who they associate with, they naturally become their own people. So I for one would love to see more backstory on each of the listener characters.

WolfLord11

For me personally, I’m a little of column a, little of column b kinda person. like way you do them now is kinda this sweet spot where if people want more of a self insert they have one with a little bit of a skeleton. But if people want more of a character, they already have a something that they can start adding to as they learn more

River Styx

I love having backstories for listener characters, it only gets in the way of it’s a lot of lore dumped on me all at once. Gradual revealing on the backstory is perfect. And I think keeping the Listener characters gender neutral is enough for people to relate

Cole Blackblood

I personally like a bit of both - give us some events and particular "canon" aspects to touch on and enjoy, and then leave room for the Listeners to fill in the blanks. Including parts of their past that lead to things happening in the audios, or can be referenced? Chef's kiss. But that doesn't cover *all* of their backstory or character in entirety, leaving room for us Listeners to fill in the blanks and add our own flair. For example: Knight. We know they got together with Evie after a confession together, and they have been close for ages. But we don't know the exact details of when they first met, or how many other times Knight has shown off for her or defended her - just that they've done so. It's detailed enough to give an idea of a character, but vague enough to leave room for Listeners to have their fun. Or Dear - we know they're very self-critical, and hold themself to a high standard, but we don't know precisely why they got to that point as an OW. Me, I like to think they had high pressure from their school and parents due to being an Open-Wielder (AKA "Honor Kid Syndrome").

BeyondFables

I think the balance has been really good so far, as someone who likes both. I like to imagine myself as a character rather than just project, but room for imagination is great

Dr.green

For me, if it's gonna be a long running series, I want some character to latch on to. Even if a listener character doesn't appeal to me I can still listen in as a outside observer. I'm not really a submissive person, and I'm more of an extrovert rather than an introvert. But most listener characters with personalities tend to be the opposite of me but I still enjoy many of the stories for the story. Usually if a listener character is left blank in a long running series, they just get boring and harder two right around so I suggest giving your characters more life to them.

Delta_03

I think it's great the listener characters have their own lives, it makes the series less stale. To me it feels like playing a character in a game or reading a sole protagonist book you know? Someone that has their lore and personality but still someone people could project themselves in if they wanted too.

PubbyButch

I like having the characters with their own lives, it provides a depth to the world building you’ve got going on, plus it helps with connecting to the VA’d character and I feel that it gives off like a personal one-on-one DND vibe.

AngelicMenace

I LOVE listener characters, it feels like playing a character in a game or movie. Listeners with their own lives/backstories and personalities bring more life into Glenwood (and overall all the roleplays)

Vesryn

I think the listener characters having at least somewhat of a backstory is helpful for the dynamic between the voiced characters and for adding more to the storyline. It seems like it would be difficult for listener characters (especially within a big plot like Glenwood) to not have any personality traits/characteristics. It would sound like all the voiced characters were talking to the same person. And I don't think the voiced/listener dynamics would be as interesting. A possible happy medium, which I already see with some of the listener characters, is giving them a backstory (maybe that is not so much based on decisions they have made), and leaving their current timeline a little more ambiguous (with a couple personal characteristics). I think good examples of these are Knight and Ranger. Both have characteristics that pertain to their backstories and characteristics in their current timeline, but there's still enough room for listeners to project themselves into the characters. People are going to resonate with some listener characters more than others, regardless if they have much of a backstory or not.

Naomi Webb

personally I feel it depends on the style of audio. As glenwood is an on going narrative vs say a setting where you have specific one shots it certainly changes the nature of the listener as the nature of well a storyline implies a need for the listener to have certain characteristics eg ranger needs to be defensive and suspicious of Claire, Seer's foreknowledge means the character would react differently etc so personally I think for Glennwood it makes sense simply so the story well works as personality does help plot (although some vagueness is also needed which you've done well)

BirdsEye_View

The listener characters having some background story and details about themselves helps them feel a bit more fleshed out but still enough for listeners to come up with on their own. It's fun to learn more about the listener characters (ex: Ranger's baking skills) while listeners themselves can come up with whatever backstory they want for those details. It's kind of like giving audiences some parts or a framework to build from but still leaving a lot of personal creative liberties with those and other characteristics.

Rogha

I personally think it’s best to have a little bit of both. For the listener characters to have a lot left up to the listener to decide who they are while having certain characteristics, personality traits, or small individual background facts to be cannon. Like to have their job and family be up to the listener but to have stuff to go off of like they’re a menace to the people in their life they care about or they overwork themselves a lot due to stuff in their past but have said stuff be up to the listener or they have a bad relationship with their family but the who and why they do is up to the listener. Things that are fact about them but still something the listener can make their own. Like a complete blank slate doesn’t help with story telling or being able to visualize a scene happening but having a complete cannon backstory or all their personality and traits all decided already takes you out of the experience and it just feels like any other tv show.

tigerlilytea

Me personally, I am here for the story. So I think you should do what makes sense for the storyline. Besides, I don’t think there’s anything wrong with bit of escapism of escapism. I wouldn’t mind being a different person during these role-plays.

Ari

I think having the balance makes sense to an extent but as someone who really enjoys the story of it all, giving characters including listener characters, more of their own unique personalities and histories is really nice. I wouldn't mind if the balance leaned more toward giving listener characters more characterization. Still happy if the balance stays the same though.

Lacaille

I like the listener characters having different personalities/backgrounds because it makes their relationship with the speaker character feel more fleshed out and genuine. Not only that but it makes Glenwood feel more realised and full as a whole. Otherwise if all the listener characters are the exact same blank slate then in a weird sort of way to me it’d feel like the same listener is dating the whole town at once and that they’re a magical entity that everyone falls in love with. Maybe that’s some ppl’s schtick but I don’t love the feeling of feeling like I’m just listening to a one dimensional harem dating sim - I like the story and world building and all the characters that help make the world more interesting including what the listener characters have to bring to the table in terms of narrative/exposition or perspective on a situation unique to their experience

Banshee

Personally I’ve never been able to see myself as a listener anyway and I make them into my own character and just make other self inserts that don’t have anything to do with the story, I like seeing listeners backstories, even if they’re vague, that way you can add your own little bit of backstory, giving them a little personality or traits makes the relationship with the character more realistic imo and I like seeing why listeners/characters are the way they are

Joseph Colton

I prefer see more backstory and made them into set characters