Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Talking through some of the challenges and considerations that go into making a documentary, as well as specific points of research.

Also it looks and sounds the way it does because I was like "hey, Dan, let's play with old cameras again" and set up the XF100, but then didn't take the time to fine-tune everything to actually play nice with the XF100.

Files

Wrestling is Weird WIP Vlog 01

Dan rambles about the current project, challenges, research paths, and things he thinks he knows but isn't confident that he actually knows. Edited by Jessica Babineaux

Comments

The Paladin Breakstar

As a wrestling fan both enjoying the current product and despising the current corporate meddling, this title alone has me incredibly hyped

JETTA RAE

Dan, please. Some of your loyal fans are pro wrestlers. Show us mercy. (I have not yet watched the video but look forward to doing so)

Kathy Clysm

Uh if you're gonna focus on interviews, I am kind of hoping you'll consider talking to some fellow creators like FD etc as well, I feel he'd have some interesting takes to add

A.k

Haven't watched this yet but am deeply excited as someone who is very into my local pro wrestling scene. If at all at interest to you, I do have a mutual friend with a former WWE wrestler who still actively wrestlers in the UK independent wrestling scene, as well as friends in the semi professional independent uk wrestling scene. Be more than happy to pass on contact info, though obviously there are geographic issues as my contacts are primarily in the independent UK scene. The texture of local independent scene is really interesting when compared to larger scale groups like WWE/AEW though. One of my favourite local wrestlers may currently being scouted by WWE, this would be very deserved, he's very talented. but I'm saddened by the concept that someone who has performed at local Pro Wrestling Ceasefire (UK charity wrestling events raising money for Palestine) might get swallowed up by this machine

Massimiliano delli Ubaldini

Your discussion about doing research, reading texts, and finding interviewees, right down to some books being dead ends only after you read them, were dead ringers for the process of writing A Skeptic's Guide to Hypnosis. It's refreshing to see the sausage-making of documentaries and essays come full circle back here. Some excerpts from Body Drop reminded me strongly of The Unreality of Pro Wrestling by Super Eyepatch Wolf. I wonder if he read this book, because the theses are strikingly similar.

Susan Held

Most of what I know about pro wrestling I learned from Margo's Got Money Troubles, as a point of reference.

Brent Hirose

Pro Wrestler here, very excited to sit down and watch

Julia-n

So, I think there's more in the circus vein here, aside from the origins of pro wrestling as a concept. Which is to say, I posit that there's been a through-line from the origins to the present day. Both are, fundamentally, traveling stage shows where the main focus is the thrilling physical prowess of the performers. Both depend on acting and clowning to put over the perception of danger and risk and to carry their (often weak!) storylines. Both carry a significant amount of actual physical danger and risk (without any health insurance, usually) and the jobs are inherently temporary. In both cases, there's a lot of overlap with film stunt acting skills. And hell, they both take place in a non-ring ring! If this is legitimately interesting to y'all, most of the folks I know anymore are circus people and I know at least two circus historians. At the very least, one of those folks (I'm thinking of Betsy Golden Kellem, who's also a parent at my circus studio) could absolutely point you in the right direction in terms of what was happening with circus and wrestling in the 19th century. As for modern wrestling performers, I don't have as many specific contacts here (but maybe a few degrees of separation!), but it would be fascinating to talk to Leah Sparks (circus artist turned active pro wrestler) or to Sidney Akeem (Reggie when he was in WWE, active on the independent circuit). I think Ess Hödlmoser, who is a circus artist, actor, and stunt actor, and who had a prior life in competitive in Muay Thai, would also have heeeella interesting thoughts. Ess and Leah are both Canadian, too!

riteofashkente

I'm already really excited for this documentary based on this vlog and for any more behind the scenes content, it is really interesting to hear about all the work that does go into making a documentary but never makes it into the final product! I also hope that one of those friendly faces is F.D Signifier

acertainsam

Hey, Dan. This was very interesting and I'm really excited for the video now. Just a small caution about using the point about kayfabe as an insight into political communication: basically what you are getting at is a very important and well-established point about ideology and social-psychological partisanship within the political science literature. Kayfabe can be a very useful analogy to explain it, and many poli sci professors use it in a classroom setting, but I'd caution against presenting it as a novel insight or emerging out of the world of armchair political discourse.

Mable Valley

Wrestling really reminds me of the point made in “Why It’s Rude to Suck at World of Warcraft” about paratext feeding into the text in a very direct way, both in terms of sportswriters attacking kayfabe and causing promotions to reinforce it (and also later wrestling-focused writers. It’d be hard to name a more influential sportswriter on their chosen sport than Dave Meltzer). but also just. If you go to any indie show the barrier between fan opinion and performer is so insanely thin. They’re coming out to sell merch after the show.

With Quiet Eyes

There is something deeply on brand about how you're holding the books up to camera so I can see the "CALGARY PUBLIC LIBRARY" stamp on Body Drop.

Alex London

The interesting thing that I hope you bring up in the doc is that the fixing was not always a linear process, especially once titles were involved. There are some infamous incidents where a promoter wanted control of a title, so despite the match being scripted a certain way, the guy who was better at wrestling for real just threw out the script and won on behalf of his boss

Lea Chinelo

After finishing this video I of course had to immediately go to YouTube to watch Psycho Mike duke it out with the dog, a sasquatch, the ref, and finally himself. Magical.

Grigorios

Some comments from a big wrestling fan. I'm sure some or all of the points I'll discuss have been considered, of course, but I want to raise them because if they were missed, they will be pretty notable omissions: As you touch upon in the vlog, the assumption that historically there were two types of fans, smarts who know wrestling is fake, and marks who don't, might have never been actually true. Regarding the present, the mainstream belief ithin wrestling fandom is that everyone does know wrestling is fake, but there is still a distinction between marks, who just watch the shows, and smarks, who also follow social media and the journalism around wrestling. If you ask the smarks, they probably consider themselves the minority of fans. I suspect this is still wrong; that outside of a relatively small portion people, who just tune in for the occasional PLE, everyone is a smark. Looking at the reactions of fans at wrestling events I find it hard to believe they don't follow the news. For example, I don't think CM Punk and his constant playing to the smarks would be as popular for the past 15 yeras (and lest we forget he wasn't even wrestling for half of them) if the majority of fans weren't in on it. Another example, the biggest reaction fans gave to a promo last year, was Becky Lynch making a joke about John Cena breaking up with Nikki Bella (https://youtu.be/qXD63V56oqc?t=190). This is not storyline knowledge, it's backstage knowledge from 10 years ago. So I wanted to raise this as a point of caution; in the vlog you didn't touch a lot upon the reality show aspect of wrestling, but I suspect for most fans it might be more important than the theatrical performance. On a sidenote, I think this may explain why wrestling feels smaller now than it did in the '80s; there is no general audience, it's only smarks. Cody Rhodes isn't a household name in the way Hulk Hogan was. John Cena and the Rock became household names but not as wrestlers. I also want to add that I think keyfabe is in its own way alive and thriving. The term neo-keyfabe was coined by I believe Josephine Riesman to describe the current state of wrestling, where old-school "everything is real" keyfabe is dead (even though that may have always just been a pretense), but there is a blur of the line between storyline and reality. I'm sure this has come up in your research, so I won't talk about it. The only specific point I want to make, is that the "reality" side of the narrative might still be more fake than even the fans assume. There are cases where there are obvious indications, where everyone agrees the reality is probably not the official narrative. For example, the main storyline leading into wrestlemania 40 was about the Rock stealing the main event from Cody Rhodes. How much of that was real we will never know, but everyone agrees the official narrative is unlikely to be the full truth. However, there are even widely accepted truisms that I suspect are part of the fiction that nobody, even the most proud "never get worked" smarks ever question. For example, fans wince when a wrestler gets chopped. It is commonly accepted that this is a very painful move that you have to be tough to take, and this adds to the realism and narrative of a match. I think this belief isn't entirely true: while chops can indeed hurt (plenty of wrestlers have cuts on their chests from them), they can also sound devastating while being pretty painless. Exhibit A: Goldberg laughing at how painless Gunther's chops were. Exhibit B: Chelsea Green in her Chris Van Vliet interview was asked about being chopped by Penta and she said it was a 0 on the pain scale. On other things: - I wanted to bring this up but then I saw someone else already did, so I just want to second that the comparison between politics and keyfabe is fairly popular among people who know what keyfabe is. - In case you aren't aware, former WWE and indie wrestler Maven Huffman has a youtube channel discussing stuff like how matches are put together. He's a carnie, so, you know, grain of salt, but there is useful insight about the backstage process of wrestling. - In terms of the extent to which matches are scripted, there is indeed a high variation. In general, the office will decide the length of the match, the winner, and they will dictate specific spots advancing a storyline (e.g. the involvement of other wrestlers, or the way the match ends). The bookers alongside the wrestlers will decide on the general structure and some big spots, taking commercials into account if we're talking TV, and then in the ring the wrestlers will improvise around those plans. However, there seems to be a trend towards more and more precisely scripted matches these days. This especially relates to the rise of extremely athletic wrestlers The big acrobatic spots can't really be done without preparation.

potted_penguin

Very excited about this video! One thing I wanted to mention is that "everyone but literal children knows it's scripted" might not be 100% accurate. I recently watched my first wrestling match with some friends, and there was a person near us in the audience who got extremely antagonistic and violent towards the antagonist. (Bottles were thrown.) That person was drunk, so not at their best judgment, I'm sure, but the outrage at the way the fight was going before the "good guys" won felt extremely genuine. They even left early, saying they couldn't keep watching anymore. IDK if the fact that this was in central Europe and not in Wrestling-World-Hub-USA has something to do with it, but I'd still wager that not *everyone* knows it's scripted. Before I watched that match, I knew next to nothing about wrestling, and only as I watched it, it became clear to me that it must be scripted.

KevinR

I'll just offer general encouragement here. This looks to be hitting from a perfect angle for me. I know I have a huge (and bias-inducing) blindspot around wrestling: it's not for me, and I'm not seeing whatever it has that makes it valuable to lots and lots of other people. Since this project looks to be starting an outside viewpoint and building the history of how wrestling came to be what it is, maybe it will bring that insight that I'm lacking.

Zhed

My last exposure to pro wrestling was listening to Dan Rykert talk about it on Game Informer videos like 15 years ago, so this will be neat

Mr. Grahf

I cannot imagine a world where you haven't already watched or even talked to supereyepatchwolf about this, but in the event that somehow no one has turned you on to his wrestling videos let me say: go watch his wrestling videos. From the sound of it they would be almost exactly what you're looking for in terms of what you're hoping to accomplish.

Brent Hirose

Hey team Dan: BC based indie wrestler who came to wrestling after 20 years as a professional theatre artist. Would be happy to chat if that perspective might be helpful, I've got a lot of thoughts on what you mentioned in the video! Otherwise looking forward to the final product;

Ted Koutz

Obscure clown fact: I've read that "clown" is a good lateral career move if you're already in the circus and age out of certain roles (like trapeze artist) or if you're injured on the job. Also horrifically, this book, written for teenagers from the standpoint of a career one may want to go into, also mentioned that clown makeup can hide scars. Couldn't tell you the title other than it was published in the 1970's by Ringling Bros. I no longer own this and passed it on to a friend who did Burning Man things, this was years ago and I don't remember if any kind of clownery was involved in what she got up to EDIT: this seems a little similar to the carnival roustabout --> pro wrestler pipeline you mentioned

J Savage

I recommend checking out The Iron Claw movie which is an interesting and tragic look at the Von Erich family pursuing careers in the professional wrestling world during the time it was consolidating down from independent leagues into what became wwf. Also Super Eyepatch Wolf did a series on the rise, fall and redemption of Roman Reigns which has a lot of info about how a wrestler can become a star or fail to. I have been to a lucha libre match and there might be something in the way the crowd participates in the ritual of the show. It's a regular past time for some with types of crowd interactions separate from what's happening in the ring. Might be worth attending some live matches to see.

Malcolm Ryan

This reminds me of a “chair wrestling” circus performance I used to be part of, where a wrestler would face off against a desk chair. 🪑

Ryeman

A lot of people are saying “I hope you have x content creator in your video”. While I think it’s fine to talk to them for research, I kind of hope you keep their interviews to a minimum and try to prioritize interviews with actual working professionals in wrestling. Eyepatch wolf and FD are recognizable voices to your audience, but they aren’t experts and if I want their opinion on wrestling, I can just watch their videos.

Graham Koch

As a wrestling fan I can't wait to see what you come up with. If you're looking for some examples of how others have tried to get wrestling topics and information to non wrestling fans there are two videos that come to mind. One is Super Eyepatch Wolf's "The Unreality of Pro Wrestling: FINISH THE STORY" which talks about how wrestling is used to tell stories both real and fictional. The second would be a video made by the musician Semler, who released "They Won't Put Chyna In The Hall Of Fame // A Video Essay" which was made as an explanation to their fans about why they would release a song about Chyna. Super Eyepatch Wolfs Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=POsvxBJfTwg Semler's video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KYHIS3VGw9g

Austin Priest

I'm sure you are already aware, but folks in the YouTube orbit that good be good to ask are Loading Ready Run who have multiple members who are wrestling fans (also I think the next Autumnal Rumble should feature Hat Dan). Another person that would be good is James Stephanie Sterling, who has done local/regional wrestling in England (and maybe other places?)

FruitFrakker

Btw since you mentioned other fictional sports, it might be interesting for a beat to compare with say the Harlem Globetrotters or Savannah Bananas; namely that those sorts of exhibitions are *purely* about the athletic spectacle, that the form of athletic competition is sort of vestigial, whereas in pro wrestling the idea that there are stakes in the matches is critical to its appeal.

Utilitarian

I am so, so excited for this upcoming video. I don't really watch wrestling anymore but I loved Loading Ready Run's "Sidewalk Slam" podcast/youtube videos while they were still making them. Honestly Graham and Adam from LRR might be great folks to connect with for some of that early "talk to friendly folks" research.

triggthediscovery

Kayfabe is so weird to me, it's like it's too embarrassing to admit you like being lied to so you construct an extra layer of fiction to insulate you from that basic reality. I get that it can be a useful term while talking to outsiders, but it's use internally between fans is baffling. I would enjoy art far more if I could believe it was real, I don't know why wrestling fans are so eager to remind themselves its fake (maybe reality is better written?)

Brendan Hinman

Tim Faust (Crulge on various social media, of “The Boys are Back in town” fame and “Health Justice Now”) did a fantastic article on the lack of health insurance and its effect on the industry. He’s a brilliant source and was part of a shockingly successful indie promotion (as was I) in Austin before a big schism. He could be a great source! I’m in a promotion called Fight Opera, and I help out with other promotions so if you want some doofus’s perspective I’m also here

Fry Exists Under Capitalism

I don't know much about pro wrestling, or about scholarship about pro wrestling, so maybe this is old news, but the game Worldwide Wrestling RPG might be of interest to you. It's a tabletop RPG about pro wrestling where a lot of the game's mechanics are about the tension between the performer and their character in the ring. (For example you can roll to break kayfabe.)

FoldableHuman

That sounds really compelling, can you name any specific examples for us to chase down?

Alex London

Probably the two biggest examples are Stanislaus Zbyszko beating Wayne Munn in 1925 and Dick Shikat beating Danno O’Mahoney in 1936. For a while, champions had to be able to actually “shoot” wrestle if need be, to protect against getting double crossed by an opponent throwing out the script

Neebletown

Not really shoot match,es but an iconic example of a wrestler and a promotor disagreeing on the outcome of a match was the famous Montreal Screw Job, in which Bret Hart believed he was going to win only to have the ending of the match changed on him without his knowlege or consent. Hart, by all accounts a much tougher guy than his opponent, Shawn Michaels, likely couldn't have been legitiimately beaten by Michaels so the promotion turned to skullduggery. I think a similar event was (accused human trafficker) Fabulous Moolah stealing a championship from Wendi Richter.

Neebletown

I'm sure this'll come up in your research, but in terms of national attention for pro wrestling I don't think we're near the peak right now. It's hard to compare apples-to-apples, but in the late 90s during the Monday Night Wars viewership peaked at 8+ million households who were watching WWF (https://wrestlenomics.com/wwf-wcw-monday-night-war-tv-ratings-wwe-wcw-nitro-wwf-raw-cable/), whereas today the wrestliing numbers are much closer to sub 1.5 million for WWE (https://wrestlenomics.com/tv-ratings/) . That's not to say that it was more lucrative then, as I think generally prrices and monetization of wrestling has been pushed to the fore so WWE/TKO might be bringing in more money with less viewership

Mopman43

Just about the only thing I know about the history of professional wrestling is that Sputnik Monroe had a really interesting career as a heel wrestler (figuring out that when you're a heel wrestler in the south in the 50s, associating yourself with the black community makes you one hell of a heel to the white crowd) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sputnik_Monroe

Saxifrage

Have you ever gone through the due diligence part you talk about at the start with a certain project and found that no, your take isn't new at all and there has already been so much coverage from that angle that the project just becomes non-viable? I'm thinking of the line from your video on memestocks where you say due diligence can be as much of a reason not to invest in a project as to do so 😆 I'm guessing you do have project ideas that end up on the cutting room floor before you make much of them in the first place

Benjamin Zuses

I want to watch this but I can't because when I try it insists I "Log In to prove I am not a bot" but there is no way to do that in patreon. And there is no way to get a link to watch it on YouTube (Where I am logged in). Anyway if you could post these with a text link to the video in the description that would be swell.

Aidan O'Grady

As someone who's watched wrestling his entire life, definitely looking forward to the full thing. A couple of aspects I think it would be interesting lenses: 1. The international aspect, I think it'd be good highlighting how wrestling culture grew to vary, with Japan, Mexico and Britain in particular growing their own identities that are still a verbal short-hand. When you say "the British style", wrestling fans will instinctively know what you mean. 2. The role of athletic commissions. This one I think would tie in very nicely with what you were saying about the origins of kayfabe. There are some states where the athletic commission still has jurisdiction over shows held within that state and impose regulations. Whilst there are instances of reasonable rules regarding medical staff, or the use of mats around ringside, there are also particularly frustrating examples, most notably a couple of years back Oaklahoma taking umbrage with Nyla Rose being a trans wrestler performing in matches with cis-women.

sierrah r

"When the Hulking swirl came through, it did not simply Hogan. It showed me where the *true* power lies, brother. Later, people asked me if a monster came that day. All I could say was what the storm itself said to me: "Whatcha gon do when Hulkamania runs wild on you?" -Brian Oliu on Hulk Hogan coming to Tuscaloosa, which is a thing that he did

RJ Gryder

Most of what I know about wrestling is from Behind the Bastards (well, that and one tumblr lesbian I follow who was REALLY into Sasha banks/Mercedes mone) so happy to hear the Robert Evans mentions & the frame of kayfabe in political communication. I do hope you’ll include some women pro wrestlers in your interviews & analysis!

flick

Apologies if many other people have made this suggestion, but you may be interested in Roland Barthes writing on professional wrestling. In his essay collection Mythologies, he directly discusses the connection between wrestling, theatre and pantomime. I don't know if people who discuss wrestling refer to it much, but It's a very foundational text within cultural studies, so it could be a good one to read :)