Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Echoes In Eternity Poll

  • Option One 15
  • Option Two 5
  • Option Three 25
  • 2026-05-02
  • —2026-06-02
  • 45 votes
{'title': 'Echoes In Eternity Poll', 'choices': [{'text': 'Option One', 'votes': 15}, {'text': 'Option Two', 'votes': 5}, {'text': 'Option Three', 'votes': 25}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 6, 2, 17, 39, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 5, 2, 17, 39, 7, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 45}

Content

As some of you might be aware, depending on how thoroughly you read the announcements channel in Discord, Nothing Is True will be coming to an end in August, with it's Forty-Second chapter.

At that time, it's slot as a flagship story will be getting replaced with Echoes In Eternity, the story wherein Pyrrha Nikos is reborn as The Warrior of Light.

As I am working on shaping it from some half-developed snippets into a proper AU, I'm waffling between several options, and I wanted to put those options to the people who would be reading the story.

Please consider these not just from the lewd perspective, but the narrative perspective.

Option One: Pyrrha is reborn as a half-hyur, half-elezen girl from Ishgard. Anastasia Haillenarte was born as the bastard daughter of Chlodebaimt, one of the sons of the House, and a young female soldier under his command. After the soldier became pregnant, she was sent back to Ishgard itself, and Chlodebaimt was killed in battle. Anastasia and her mother were kept close by the Count and Countess Haillenarte, who saw the daughter and unofficial wife of their lost son and refused to leave them in the mire of peasantry, before her mother is killed during an attack on the city. Feeling stifled and out of place, Anastasia eventually ran away to help the Eorzean Alliance fight the Garlemald Empire at Carteneau, before she was badly injured and sent into the future by Louisoux as per FFXIV canon.

Option Two: Pyrrha is reborn as a viera from Dalmasca, having fled when the Garleans glassed Rabanastre, and ending up fighting them at Carteneau and being sent into the future as per canon. Naturally, her backstory wouldn't be as relevant here, as we hardly interact with Dalmasca outside of a small raid series, and it wouldn't be as intimately or significantly skewing things as her being Ishgardian would.

Option Three: A combination thereof. Her mother was a Dalmascan viera that fled to Eorzea and ended up meeting Chlodebaimt, wherein they ended up getting pregnant with Pyrrha. Rather than leave, her mother stays in Ishgard, and both of her parents are killed defending the city from an attacking by Nidhogg's brood, leaving Pyrrha to be raised by her grandparents, which leads to the same running away scenario as Option One. In this option, she would be a viera like option two, just with the Ishgardian background of option one.

To be clear, in options one and three, she has the same background and emotional/social connections in Ishgard. The differences will be what race she is, and how certain characters react to her...though being a bastard daughter, non-family people in Ishgard will look down on her regardless.

Please put some thought into this. I'll be leaving the poll up for a month, feel free to discuss it here or in the Discord, and I'll respond as I can. It will be easier if you discuss it in the Discord, but I won't ignore Patreon posts either.

Find the link to the discussion in the forum section below.

https://discord.com/channels/499699300675092529/1500190377057980613

Comments

A Standup Philosopher

To clarify Option Three, since it might not have been clear: In option three, Pyrrha would be a Viera.

MuuWai Alissa

Honestly I love where it is, and it continuing that way would also be acceptable for me, not sure if other people agree

Benjamin Bravo

I'm really hoping we stick with option one since in my opinion it would be amazing to see how Joan/Anastasia and Hilda interact, option three isn't bad but feels like it'd be missing part of the connection with her being visibly Viera instead of Elezen.

Lyn Shukaldes

One. Idk just seems like her having enough background memories to function within her new world with the bones of a support network waiting sounds like a good place to start.

A Standup Philosopher

She will have the memories and sorta-background regardless. She'll still be Anastasia Hailenartte, bastard daughter, wehther its option on or option three. It's only the race that changes. I'll add some clarifying language.

Jade Isentry

This Hilda interaction would be no less possible, or even any different really, either way, honestly.

Jade Isentry

The thing is, option 1 fits closer to my original view of her from the story so far (in physical appearance I mean), but option 2... well... It's always fun to give the MC something that makes them stand out from the crowd, and see what happens as a result, and with option 1, she's just another bastard-half-elezen among the masses thereof. So it's actually kind of a hard pick between them.

A Standup Philosopher

Yeah, Hilda might be the only half-elezen we see, but you KNOW that they would be everywhere in Ishgard. Elezen nobles fucking their hyur commoners/servants left right and center.