Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

I've been asked to comment on the GPL discussion/reaction in the 3D printer community. Because this gets into international legal issues and I'm not a lawyer, I'm not sure I'm qualified to accurately address it but I'll let you know how I'm trying to handle it at Filament Friday. 

For those that don't know the background, GPL or General Public License is the licensing used to release Arduino software IDE/Programming Code. As I understand it, anything that uses Arduino and the code that runs it is required to supply the source code (upon request) if the design is shared publicly. If the design is kept private than the source does not need to be shared. Since many of the 3D printers sold use Arduino based Marlin, that GPL carries over to many 3D printers and the source code. Any modifications are also required to be shared as I've been told.

At the heart of the CR-10 firmware is Marlin as can be confirmed with a GCode command. They modified the open source Marlin and added recover from power loss feature and filament runout (CR-10S) and didn't share that code modification. They told me via email they would share the base Marlin code if you asked, but not the modifications and that's where the issue became more interesting to many people. The recover from power loss appears to be some interesting engineering and it would be nice to see how they did that. And GPL should force that release.

When I first found out about their GPL non-compliance, I wanted my machines to be compliant so I asked the Marlin team: if I reflash my CR-10 Mini, that I use on the channel publicly, with open source Marlin would my machine then be compliant with the GPL? I was told YES. So I reflashed my CR-10 Mini and mentioned it in the CR-10 mini updates video. I even linked to Chris's Basement YouTube Channel for those that wanted to do the same by following his great instructions. 

I also did a CHEPCLUB.com post about reflashing it with my splash screen. This reflash does eliminate the recover from power loss and any filament sensing (though the Mini never had that). Maybe I should have shared why more here. Sorry for that. But if you aren't using your machine publicly, I'm not sure you are violating anything. Again this is where lawyers come it.

I've used my GPL compliant printer in all my latest videos so I was not violating anything as far I as I understood. If anybody asked I will send them the source code.

I think its great that the community is responding to this and drawing a line in the sand and I wish we could see the same response to printers that shutoff the heated bed protections or use wiring that is not to code that I showed in previous videos. Frankly, those tend to NOT get a lot of views so I'm a bit surprised at how the community has jumped on this one. Having a printer that is not properly wired to mains seems a lot more important than a GPL license but I don't choose the battles. I don't recommend printers that don't have proper wiring.

So I will continue to use my GPL compliant printers. If you have a CR-10 or Mini and want to reflash to be compliant, follow Chris's Basement Video. I have added a warning to my affiliate links about GPL. And I'll leave the choice up to you if you want to buy or not. I don't make much from the affiliate links, its more for convenience than anything else and I find many people use them more to buy electronic components than 3D Printers.

Thank you for listening. Your comments are welcome.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Anonymous

Thanks Chuck for putting this out. It's always good to get multiple takes on these kinds of things. Not my favorite type of content to put out, but nessasary at times I guess. Most users wouldn't even know that the printer they bought was infringing on GPL nor would they care probably, but it's good to get it out in the open none the less.

Bill Karkula

Good insight, Chuck. Creality is trying to pass the buck on responsibility by claiming they signed a confidentiality agreement. It's only a matter of time before the community figures out how to implement the two unique CR-10S filament runout and resume features. Sorry that Creality has become the poster child when there are others in violation, but their response bundled with an ad for their latest printer that is also in violation of GPL did not help.