Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Has anybody tried out the new XYZmaker Beta software?

It's a free download from their XYZprinting.com site. 

They offer an 80 page manual, which is nice, that states it is available for Windows, Mac and Linux but right now all I see is a Windows download option.

Since I use mostly Mac I haven't tried it on my Windows Laptop yet. It's reported to be like Tinkercad. The interface in the manual looks like they copied a lot from Tinkercad.


Has anybody tried this yet?

I use Tinkercad all the time so I'm not sure this will make me switch. Sometimes Tinkercad can lock-up on me because of the Internet connection but other than that I like how I can access my files from any computer and from anywhere that I can get a connection. That is the advantage of the cloud. So XYZmaker being a download running locally is a different approach.


I have to wonder why XYZprinting would invest this much time in a software tool I can get for from from Autodesk for free. 

Maybe they plan to make it work directly with their new $269 DaVinci Mini?

Design and print from one application?

The manual doesn't show that as it has you download the .STL.


This is one area I feel is missing from the 3D printing world. There is no cooperation. Tinkercad could be modified to add a Cura or Slic3r to its interface so you can go from design to print. All they need is a setup for each printer supported same way S3D does.


It seems like companies are trying to do too much by themselves. Why didn't XYZ just work with Autodesk to make Tinkercad directly output a 3W file. Seems like that would have a been a great marketing tool for both companies.


If they truly want to make it easier for beginner's to 3D print, then there needs to be more cooperation. This do it all alone mentality seems to be just adding layers of confusion for the beginner.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Anonymous

I Repetier'd my Da Vinci so this wouldn't be for me. I watch you use Tinkercad and make it look so easy. I tried a couple of times and I guess I'm all thumbs when it comes to design - just couldn't get the parts right. Personally I use openSCAD as I'm very comfortable programming - programming parts just works easy. Good question on why so much work to provide all from one source solutions when there are so many good alternatives.

Anonymous

I used Tinkercad when I first started 3d designing then I discovered 123D Design from Autodesk and it's much more powerful and easier to use ( for me anyway) than Tinkercad and best of all you can use it offline.