Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

The article linked below about 3D Printer sales increasing was interesting in itself but what really caught my attention was the picture featuring a Makerbot Replicator and the Eiffel Tower design that I recently printed for Filament Friday. 

Article on 3D Printer Sales


It looks like they printed the base in quarter sections on the Makerbot's advertised 25.2 L x 19.9 W x 15.0 H cm build area. Based on the dimensions and the picture, they printed it huge. They probably did that so the detail would print successfully. Very common trick by 3D printing companies.


The almost completed model on the left of the Makerbot looks fantastic but the back side bottom is grey instead of the orange. Looks like the final piece might be on the build platform. The finished design on the left looks like the bottom feet are warped a bit yet the printer implies it was printed upside down. Very strange. It's also strange that the first floor railing is shown printed successfully so I suspect they printed the first level platform separately since the piece on the Makerbot is upside down (no railing) without platform overhang. That's a great idea to split out the first floor platform and then the railing underneath printed upside down eliminating the need to print with supports.  I didn't think of splitting it like that.


This may seem like a strange series of observations, but these are some of the things I look at when viewing pictures from 3D printer ads. These types of pictures can be misleading to a new buyer. It implies this is an easy print for the Makerbot but clearly they have done some unique custom splitting of the model to get it to print on the Makerbot (if that design truly was printed on a Makerbot). They also have to glue it together which can many times leave unwanted seams that just don't quite fit together properly. The finished model looks like it has some tape holding it together and I cannot detect any offset seams.


And why would they have a grey piece in the back rather than the orange? They must have printed it multiple times in a plastic they trusted, which makes sense. As I've said before, many of the great prints you see on various ads and even on some YouTube channels have been printed a few times to get the "bugs out" before showing the final design.


I think I learned more from that picture than the actual article. It gave me several ideas on how to make the Eiffel Tower print with more detail. I have to break it into many smaller separate pieces instead of relying on the pieces released on Thingiverse and this will allow me to print it a LOT bigger than what I had planned so the detail will print even better. 


Who needs a $2500 Makerbot when a little creative splitting can make a sub $500 printer give me the same results. A picture really does paint a 1000 words.

Files

Previews only

Comments

elproducts

That would be a huge task but at $2500, you could have 10 fab mini's cranking it out in parallel. So not a bad idea after all.

Anonymous

$2500 !! I'm definitely not in that market and I doubt I could even justify it for a business investment. Maybe if it could design the part based on voice input and color mix extrude using raw pellet material. They must be feeling the burn from below - there are some very capable low cost printers. I'm thinking MAKERFRONT X5 verses one Makerbot. So true the ads make it look just like sending a document to your printer - only taller. Unfortunately the reality is you need to seek help and get your hands dirty from time to time.