Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • temp_test.stl
  • pla_temp_test.factory
  • pla_temp_test.gcode

Missing 1 full-res photo, 3 files, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

I found a temperature test tower on Thingiverse but they jumped around with the temp labels so I designed my own in Tinkercad that jumped up every 5 degrees and then tested it on the Fabrikator Mini (shown) and the MAKERFRONT. I used Simplify3D to set seven different processes. The first was just the raft 1 mm tall and then every 10 mm I changed the temp to the value shown in the print. I was testing some Inland Green PLA on the Mini and Inland Blue PLA on the MAKERFRONT. In both cases, the temp had very little affect. The print looked great at all levels.

I had each process in S3D set to wait until the temp stabilized but it just printed right through without pausing so I'm not sure what I did wrong there. The temperature changed five degrees while it was extruding plastic. I think this is why I can see a slight shift at each temp level.


Overall it showed me that temp was not a major factor in getting good prints from this Inland filament. It might have more to do with the extrusion rate which I had set to 1.00 extrusion multiplier and auto extrusion width. I plan to try manual extrusion settings and make a tower showing those changes in multiple processes just like the temp changes.


I may also try this with some ABS in the near future.


The file is attached if you guys want to try it yourself. I will put this up on Thingiverse at some point but for now it's for Patreon Supporters only.


For those with Simplify3D, I also attached the S3D .factory file so you can just load in the 7 processes at one time without having to make them all yourself.


For those without S3D, I attached the G-Code file for the Fabrikator Mini. This should fit on any printer that accepts G-Code.


If you try it, let me know your results.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Brandon T

My OCD has had me doing these sorts of temp/speed/extrusion rate/supercalifragilisticexpialidocious tests to try and get "The Perfect Print" and, as far as I can tell, the only way you're going to get That is if you only ever print a single model. :-| My 14-year old son just had his birthday (April 15th), and being a Dark Souls addict I decided to spend way more time than I normally would for pretty much anything to make him a "statue" from a game model, which began with me printing smaller-scale parts at different temps (with my desired layer height and other settings already settled upon) to see what difference it would make, and I am still left with a ~10C temp range that is "probably the best" but might simply be due to me changing temp variables mid-print. This hobby is going to kill me.

C. R. Messen

I think, the test model can be anything as long as you know every little detail of it. The problem with this model is it hasn't had any detail to see the effect of the settings. You can only measure the structural integrity and smoothness of the surface. You use the chess peace for first print, I use this model for filament and printer testing: <a href="http://www.thingiverse.com/thing:1187856" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">http://www.thingiverse.com/thing:1187856</a> It's a relatively small object and it has every feature for a good test. It has overhangs, thin column (arm), large flat plate (skirt), small details (hands) and it needs support too (chin). So I can measure almost every aspect of the filament and printer with it. Btw, It was the first print on my Fabrikator Mini with a very old PLA filament and it came out almost perfectly ;)

elproducts

That's why I wanted to try it. Flow rate seems more of a factor as I dig deeper.