Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

by Keith Phipps

Amid the changes in the ways we watch movies over the last few decades, there’s one loss I’m not sure has gotten enough attention. While much has been written about the disappearance of video stores, shortened theatrical windows and so on, has anyone considered another once-thriving vanishing species: the second-run theater? A refresher: in the limbo after a movie enjoyed its theatrical run but before it made its way to home video (and, before that, television) it would play for a time at second-run theaters, budget houses that would inherit often beat-up prints of yesterday’s hot movies and show them for a steeply discounted price.

They were nobody’s idea of a movie palace, but they had their place in the movie theater ecosystem, one akin to the Egyptian plover, those tiny birds that live on the pieces of meat still left in crocodiles’ teeth. They also made moviegoing easy for those with less-than-deep pockets, particularly if you lived near one. I saw many films I might not have otherwise seen thanks to the dollar house near my childhood home, from The Man From Snowy River to License to Drive. (They weren’t all great.) And why not? Spend a buck or two. Take a chance.

The second-run theater got big before it all but went away. (Though I’m happy to report the dollar house I grew up with reopened after shuttering for several years. It now plays first-run movies at discount prices.) Madison, WI, where I lived for several years in the late ‘90s and very early ‘00s, had two second-run multiplexes. Sure, aesthetics were an afterthought and the movies were in mono, but visiting them was a bit like stepping back in time to get a redo in what played the proper multiplexes a few months earlier.

Such venues were largely ’90s creations and, like the second-run theater itself, they’ve pretty much vanished. (Though Madison’s Market Square seems to have survived. You can currently watch Free Guy and Dear Evan Hansen on its five screens.) Several factors contributed to their decline. The switch to digital required an expensive upgrade most theaters couldn’t afford. And when you live on slightly worse-for-wear movie prints, what do you do when the prints go away? The switch also coincided with a shortening theatrical window, the rise of the DVD and streaming markets, and so on. The Hollywood aftermarket, or at least this manifestation of it, has become a thing of the past.

Is it mourned? I’m not sure. But I think something has been lost with its disappearance and the opportunity to pay a couple of bucks to see a movie on the big screen for a discount price. We’ve normalized event movies and going to the movies as an event, a big-deal outing with big-deal expectations. To say nothing of meal-sized snacks, 30 minutes of pre-movie ads and trailers, and so on. It’s almost always a whole super-sized thing, and often that’s what moviegoers want. The theaters you could pop by for a bit just out of curiosity once had their place, too, and I’m not sure anything else has filled it.

Did Persona ever play this sort of second-run house? Probably not. But there are many ways to check it out at home and then listen to our newest episode. You’ll have to go to theaters to see Last Night in Soho, however, the subject of our next episode. It inspired a spirited discussion but we all agree it’s a movie best seen on the big-screen.

While you wait for that, some pieces to read:

• Alan Cumming serves as one of the most colorful elements of Goldeneye, undeniably the best of Pierce Brosnan’s James Bond movies. For Vulture, he talked about what it was like to play the role of a hacker with bizarre fashion sense.

• For the Los Angeles Times, Brian Tallerico spoke to Steve Martin about L.A. Story at 30.

• At Polygon, Tasha Robinson power-ranked the Eternals and pondered some lingering Eternals questions.

• Always busy, Tasha Robinson also spoke to the terrific Regina King.

• At The Ringer, Keith Phipps considered what kind of directors thrive in the IP-driven blockbusters world (and which ones don’t).

• For The Guardian, Scott Tobias revisited Steven Spielberg’s made-for-TV breakthrough Duel.

• And at The Reveal, Scott looked at Korean director Kim Jae-woon’s TV excursion Dr. Brain, Keith Phipps took a 10-years-later look at Melancholia, and together they reviewed future Next Picture Show subject Passing, Belfast, and the dread Red Notice.

Files

Comments

Alexis Chang-Powless

I live near a second-run theatre. Movies are $5 and they survived the pandemic by selling movie popcorn to-go. They've also pivoted to playing movies you typically would only see in an art-house theatre. I recently saw the excellent documentary The Rescue and saw Night Raiders & Pig in the past couple months. Covid numbers are relatively low where I live, so I've been enjoying going relatively frequently. We upgraded our TV near the beginning of the pandemic, but nothing compares.

Brad Sanders

[a fellow Dayton native has entered the chat] The Danbarry Dollar Saver had locations in Dayton and Huber Heights in the late 90s/early 00s where it was $3 normally but $1 on Tuesdays, if I recall correctly. That was a common outing for my family of 7 in the summertime. Also they briefly turned the Mayflower in downtown Troy into a dollar theater and I saw Anchorman there like 10 times.

Ross C

In Edmonton in the 90's, the huge sparkling brand new suburban multiplex somehow went out of business after only being open a year or so. It reopened as a dollar theater, and I doubt there's ever been a nicer "Loonie Movie" experience.

Brendan Steele

As a Madisonian, I was happy to see the shoutout to Market Square! One of the best things about that theater is the eclectic range of movies they grab for second-run screenings. Sure. I saw Transformers: Dark of the Moon there (because I wasn't going to spend $15), but I also saw Moonrise Kingdom. They also used to host a horror movie fest. I got to see Stuart Gordon (RIP) introduce a screening of Re-Animator.

Green-billed Magpie

are they mourned? they are definitely mourned, Keith! I bemoan the loss of second-run theaters regularly. Oddly, a couple that I was familiar with closed even before the shift to digital. I'm sure there were other economic reasons involved, but I always thought "you're charging a dollar. if you need more money, just charge $2, or even 3!"

Jonathan Anderson

So, where I used to live in Minot, North Dakota, our second run was the Oak Park Theater. It had a bunch of well maintained vintage arcade machines that were a big attraction for us kids, and the actual theater was huge, but the floor was infamously so far past the point of no return in terms of stickiness that it could take shoes right off your feet if they weren't well tied, and I know I'm not exaggerating because it happened to me. In the 2011 Souris or "Mouse" River Flood, the theater was almost totally underwater as the river was right across the road and a lot of us assumed that would be the end of it, but happily they took the opportunity to all but start over. Since then they've started to do a lot of repertory programming, especially during the pandemic, and a couple of weeks ago they did a Boris Karloff double feature with Karloff's daughter actually in attendance (Boris lived in Minot for about a year in the 1910s doing theater). I speak fondly of very few aspects of Minot these days, but that theater is definitely one of the things I miss.