Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I honestly didn't expect to have to make a post like this, but there are a few things I need to clarify regarding the recent OC poll, my decision to break the tie, and the removal of content featuring Roxy and Carla (characters from Roxycatfights).

1. About the OC Poll

We had exactly 12 valid entries participating in the Original Character poll.

From the beginning, everyone knew that only one character would ultimately win and be featured in the upcoming comic.

I expected everyone involved to understand and accept that their character might not win, regardless of how much support they received. Unfortunately, the reaction from one particular individual proved otherwise.

Disappointment is understandable. Disrespectful behavior over the results of a community poll is not.

2. Why I Chose Natasha Loclear as the Winner

Since the final poll ended in a tie, I decided to use my own vote as the tiebreaker.

However, this decision wasn't arbitrary. Several factors influenced my choice, and I'd like to explain them.

Impartiality and potential favoritism

Carla belongs to Roxy, who is my friend, a former moderator of our Discord server, and someone I've collaborated with professionally in the past.

Had I chosen Carla, it could easily have raised questions about favoritism, considering my personal connection with her creator.

I wanted to avoid making a decision that could reasonably be perceived as favoring someone simply because of our relationship.

Natasha's performance throughout the polls

Natasha had been leading from the beginning, both in the first poll and throughout most of the second one, often by a considerable margin.

As far as I'm aware, this support came without any organized campaigning on Discord, in the comments, or on other social media platforms.

Of course, campaigning wasn't prohibited, and I'm not suggesting that anyone did anything wrong by encouraging others to vote. I'm simply explaining what I observed during the polls.

Character variety

I've already drawn Carla several times in previous projects or comissions, so she's had multiple opportunities to appear in my artwork.

Natasha, on the other hand, has only appeared in two of my illustrations, both created more than two years ago.

Giving a different character another opportunity was also something I considered.

Visual contrast between the fighters

Last but certainly not least, there's the artistic side of the decision.

As you probably know, I frequently draw complex fighting poses, exaggerated proportions, and compositions where the characters' bodies overlap in ways that can become almost abstract.

Because of this, I always try to create strong visual contrast between opponents. Differences in clothing, body proportions, hair, and skin tones can make a significant difference in how readable the final illustration is.

The winner of the opposing team's poll was Tier Harribel.

Carla and Harribel share several similar visual characteristics, particularly their tanned skin and blonde hair.

Natasha, on the other hand, has much lighter skin and blue hair, creating a stronger visual contrast with Harribel.

From an artistic perspective, this was another factor in Natasha's favor.

Taking all these points into consideration, my vote went to Natasha Loclear. That vote broke the tie, making her the official winner of the OC poll.

3. About the Removal of Roxycatfights Content

Following the announcement, I received some unnecessarily rude comments and messages regarding my decision.

I've been running this Patreon for several years, and I've never experienced this kind of reaction to a poll result before.

Some messages described my decision as "insulting" or "Awful," while others made their continued financial support conditional on me producing a comic featuring Carla.

Let me make something clear: you are absolutely entitled to disagree with my decisions, feel disappointed, or even cancel your membership if my content no longer interests you.

What I will not accept is being pressured or treated disrespectfully because a particular character didn't win a community poll.

As a result of this situation, I decided to remove the content featuring Roxy and Carla from my gallery.

If someone was here exclusively for those characters and had no interest in supporting my work otherwise, I see no reason to continue hosting that content on my Patreon.

However, I want to clarify one important point.

I have not revoked Roxy's permission to use any of the artwork I've previously created featuring her characters.

She remains free to use and share those illustrations as she sees fit, and you may still be able to find them on her social media pages.

I genuinely recommend checking out her work, because she's a talented writer.

If any of those illustrations are no longer available through her channels, that was her own decision, not something I requested.

Unfortunately, this entire situation has also damaged the professional trust necessary for me to continue collaborating with her.

I still consider Roxy a friend, and I have no intention of turning a personal friendship into a public dispute. That part of our relationship is private.

However, my decision regarding future professional collaborations is final.

There will be no further projects from my side involving Roxycatfights, its original characters, or its stories.

4. A Final Word About Respect and Community Behavior

Lastly, I'd like to address those who joined this Patreon during the past month specifically to support Carla in the poll.

If you're unhappy with the outcome, I understand. You're free to express that disappointment respectfully, and you're equally free to discontinue your support.

However, I have already taken action against those who crossed the line by directing disrespectful comments and messages at me and my work.

Those individuals have had their most recent month's membership refunded and have been banned from my Patreon.

Disagreeing with a decision is not grounds for a ban. Disrespectful behavior toward the creator and the community is a different matter.

I put a great deal of time and effort into my illustrations and comics, and I value the community that has supported my work over the years.

I appreciate everyone who participated in the polls, supported their favorite characters, and respected the results, regardless of whether their choice won.

I want these events to remain something enjoyable for everyone involved, not a source of hostility whenever a vote doesn't go someone's way.

I hope this explanation makes my reasoning and the actions I've taken clear.

My decision is final, and I consider this matter closed.

Comments

CerealRocks

It's sad that some people get so personal with fictional characters that they resort to toxicity. 😔 We're supposed to be here for the art, not the characters!

StrongBid

Couldn't agree more!!

that one random guy

You having the choice for who goes on for the tournament is fair skar as you are the artist that does the work. Just unfortunate that it did result in said works being removed. I do genuinely hope further disputes don't also result in more older works getting pulled as being a patron subscriber, that just means less stuff. A bummer to see how all this played out.

colt67

Dang sorry this turned sour for ya. Hopefully time heals whatever if any wounds to yall friendship.

YukiHikari

You're the artist so it's your call, don't let anyone can force you to do what you dislike. Still looking forward to your works.

Jose Gabriel Perez

Dang that sucks you handled this great and I hope this doesn't sour your relationship with Roxy it suck for this to ruin such a long friendship

not real

It’s a drawing ffs. Sorry you had to put up with this petty nonsense

Moonbear28

I'm so sorry this turned out this way! I really hope everything settles soon and everyone can enjoy the amazing work you create! I'm sad to see the Roxy content go of course, but you've got to do what's right for you! I'm excited to see your work regardless of who wins because you're style is phenomincal and your composing is stellar. The characters featured are simply a bonus! All said and done, I hope you're ok, and I'm looking forward to everything coming up! ♡

Senko Kurosaki

I suppose this means that the lucy vs inoue commission comic will remain unfinished?