Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

There part of the Book Review is now complete! Thanks for taking part and see you next time! :)

Oof-Tee-Poof, everyone!! 👋

Here is a chance to get your comment read out in the next Book review video!

If you are reading along with the reviews, we are covering chapter "Careers Advice"! So if you have any thoughts, opinions, comparisons or questions regarding these, please leave a comment below!

I do have to ask, try to keep them fairly short, like 4 or 5 sentences. That way I can cover more when making the video. Also try to keep them on subject and not referencing anything that we are yet to cover. Ideally, keep it to 1 comment each if you can (if you have more to say after commenting, you can edit it and add to it! :) ). These are just rough guidelines rather than rules, I want to be able to fit in as many of you as possible! :)

NEW FEATURE!! - As some of you may want to make a comment, but not have it replied to by others, you can now Message me your thoughts on the chapters by DM'ing me on here. If you do, please follow all the above rules, especially avoiding mentioning things in future chapters or books! Oh and please start your DM message with "Book Club -"!

To anyone that does reply to comments below, please make sure you are being friendly and respectful! A lot of tone and meaning can be lost in text, after all! If you disagree with someone on something, keep it polite and remember the golden rule in life - Sometimes you have to just agree to disagree! :)

Thanks, guys!! :)

Files

Comments

Badger Kat (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-03 02:00 Greetings, Veggie and Woozle! Take a moment to breathe and hydrate! Ch 29 - I can understand why Harry would lie about why he no longer has occlumency lessons, how would he explain that without explaining what he did and then having to explain what he saw? Even if Snape hadn’t told him not to, Harry never would’ve told anyone, in my opinion. He was horrified by what he saw. Even though he did violate Snape’s privacy, he was looking more for information that might relate to either him or Voldemort than something personal about Snape. - I don’t know why Hermione would think that constantly badgering someone would be a good way to convince them not to do something. Her methods aren’t always good, I think she is right about house elves, but she doesn’t go about that in a good way either. - I really like that Harry has a chance to discuss the scene from the memory with Sirius and Lupin. And that he pushes back on the excuse that they were young. - The Weasley Twins and their legendary exit from Hogwarts. In the movie, I believe this takes place while everybody from Dumbledore’s Army is in detention. In the book, it seems so far the only repercussion is Dumbledore having to go on the run. So far, none of the students got in trouble or had to go to detention. As always, thank you for all your hard work, remember to take care of yourself and the lovely noodle!
2026-08-06 13:37 Greetings, Veggie and Woozle! Take a moment to breathe and hydrate! And please take a break whenever you need to! Ch 29 - I can understand why Harry would lie about why he no longer has occlumency lessons, how would he explain that without explaining what he did and then having to explain what he saw? Even if Snape hadn’t told him not to, Harry never would’ve told anyone, in my opinion. He was horrified by what he saw. Even though he did violate Snape’s privacy, he was looking more for information that might relate to either him or Voldemort, not something personal about Snape. - I really like that Harry has a chance to discuss the scene from the memory with Sirius and Lupin. And that he pushes back on the excuse that they were young. - The Weasley Twins and their legendary exit from Hogwarts. As always, thank you for all your hard work, remember to take care of yourself and the lovely noodle!

Greetings, Veggie and Woozle! Take a moment to breathe and hydrate! And please take a break whenever you need to! Ch 29 - I can understand why Harry would lie about why he no longer has occlumency lessons, how would he explain that without explaining what he did and then having to explain what he saw? Even if Snape hadn’t told him not to, Harry never would’ve told anyone, in my opinion. He was horrified by what he saw. Even though he did violate Snape’s privacy, he was looking more for information that might relate to either him or Voldemort, not something personal about Snape. - I really like that Harry has a chance to discuss the scene from the memory with Sirius and Lupin. And that he pushes back on the excuse that they were young. - The Weasley Twins and their legendary exit from Hogwarts. As always, thank you for all your hard work, remember to take care of yourself and the lovely noodle!

Alex Hopps

Hi veggie, Mcgonagal has had some amazing moments in this book. Definitely my favourite teacher. Every interaction she has with umbridge makes getting through this book easier in the harder parts. I love ginny so much and im glad were finally starting to get to see her character more and more

Jake M (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-03 02:00 S'mae Woozeggie! So here it is... probably the best McGonnagall scene cut from the films. "Would you like a cough drop Dolores?" . Add to that her telling Peeves how to unscrew the chandelier - absolute queen! XD Will probably add more later. If I don't- oopsie! All the best for the next month. Where has this year gone!?
2026-08-06 14:15 S'mae Woozeggie! So here it is... probably the best McGonnagall scene cut from the films. "Would you like a cough drop Dolores?" Absolute sass queen! XD Interesting how Harry so readily remembers what present Sirius gave him the Christmas *before* last... When Hermione asks for Ron's opinion on the Sirius plan Harry is reminded of Mrs Weasley talking to her husband... Subtly foreshadowing anything, I wonder? On the subject of careers - what do you think your profession would be in the Wizarding World? All the best, hope all your big life adminny things get sorted and you can relax in time for your birthday month- where has this year gone!?

S'mae Woozeggie! So here it is... probably the best McGonnagall scene cut from the films. "Would you like a cough drop Dolores?" Absolute sass queen! XD Interesting how Harry so readily remembers what present Sirius gave him the Christmas *before* last... When Hermione asks for Ron's opinion on the Sirius plan Harry is reminded of Mrs Weasley talking to her husband... Subtly foreshadowing anything, I wonder? On the subject of careers - what do you think your profession would be in the Wizarding World? All the best, hope all your big life adminny things get sorted and you can relax in time for your birthday month- where has this year gone!?

Logan

Hi veggie! I’ve been catching up over the past few weeks/months as I’ve been so busy! I was pleasantly surprised to see that you had remembered me when having a rant on boxing! I still to this day listen to either this book club or a Harry Potter audiobook before going into the ring to calm the nerves. hope you’re keeping well! Ron mentions that he has as much chance of winning the quidditch house cup as his dad does of becoming minister of magic. What law or policy do you think Arthur would introduce would if he were in power?

Sten4321

Hi Veggie So much happens this chapter, i am surprised it wasn't split up into at least 2 smaller chapters. - McGonagall is amazing this chapter... (as usual!) She is, imo, up there with Flitwick as the best (and with Sprout only "really" competent) teachers.. - Nice to get Lupins and Sirius takes, too bad the talk where interrupted, maybe with more time they could have figured out a better way to communicate in the future? - The Twins have a much more awesome exit here, even Peeves honers them! - It seems that the "absence" of snape means that Harry actually does well in his potions class, this really isn't helping his reputation as a teacher...

S1lm4r1l (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-03 02:00 Hi Veggie and the goodest girl! Surprise! Yet another contrary opinion, Snape is supposed to teach Harry Occlumency, Snape chooses to invade Harry's privacy because he thinks that's the best way to motivate Harry. Regardless, Harry responds to violations of his privacy, with similar memories being invaded much more maturely than Snape does. Harry is a better and bigger man than Snape is, by a long shot. After everything Dumbledore and Snape have said about Occlumency and how important it is that Harry learns it. Snape decides to end their lessons in a fit of childish pique, deliberately placing Harry in danger. I can understand Snape's anger at Harry's snooping, (even if I think Snape and Dumbledore were wrong to keep this information from Harry to start with.) Snape placing his own feelings above Harry's wellbeing causes Lupin and Black to go ballistic, especially as Dumbledore is apparently unaware. Its not an apology, nor do they take full responsibility, but Lupin and Black are very self-critical and self-aware during their conversation with Harry, and most of their dialogue explains rather than justifies the Marauder's actions. I think it says a lot that they felt about what they did at the time as well. Harry's academic performance improves with Snape ignoring him and he feels much better than usual, which just demonstrates how much Snape bullies Harry normally. I think its hilarious that Snape improves his teaching methods by finding even more ways of being unprofessional in class! Is Umbridge's clipboard similar to the Warhammer Dwarven Book of Grudges? (A record of all the wrongs ever perpetrated against the Dwarfs) Does Harry actually have a criminal record do you think? Did Snape deliberately smash Harry's potion, or was it Harry's own fault? You've definitely noticed already but this chapter is loaded with great quotes: "The thing about growing up with Fred and George is you start thinking anything is possible if you've got enough nerve." "May I offer you a cough drop Dolores?" "Give her hell from us Peeves!"
2026-08-06 15:06 Hi Veggie and the goodest furball! Snape is deliberately endangering Harry's life by refusing to teach him. He cares more about himself than he does about Harry. He's a teacher and has a duty of care! The Marauders felt bad about how they treated Snape at the time. Terrible behaviour, but they weren't sadists! Snape's lack of professionalism makes Harry feel better and improves his academic performance. He's just not a good teacher. I think Snape has some agency over which memories they see, so in my opinion he's been violating Harry's privacy from day one. On a related point, I think Snape has repeatedly used Legilimency on the Golden Trio for years and years before the Occlumency lessons started. Is Umbridge's clipboard similar to the Warhammer Dwarven Book of Grudges? (A record of all the wrongs done to the Dwarfs) Does Harry actually have a criminal record do you think? You've definitely noticed already but this chapter is loaded with great quotes: "The thing about growing up with Fred and George is you start thinking anything is possible if you've got enough nerve." "May I offer you a cough drop Dolores?" "Give her hell from us Peeves!"

Hi Veggie and the goodest furball! Snape is deliberately endangering Harry's life by refusing to teach him. He cares more about himself than he does about Harry. He's a teacher and has a duty of care! The Marauders felt bad about how they treated Snape at the time. Terrible behaviour, but they weren't sadists! Snape's lack of professionalism makes Harry feel better and improves his academic performance. He's just not a good teacher. I think Snape has some agency over which memories they see, so in my opinion he's been violating Harry's privacy from day one. On a related point, I think Snape has repeatedly used Legilimency on the Golden Trio for years and years before the Occlumency lessons started. Is Umbridge's clipboard similar to the Warhammer Dwarven Book of Grudges? (A record of all the wrongs done to the Dwarfs) Does Harry actually have a criminal record do you think? You've definitely noticed already but this chapter is loaded with great quotes: "The thing about growing up with Fred and George is you start thinking anything is possible if you've got enough nerve." "May I offer you a cough drop Dolores?" "Give her hell from us Peeves!"

Sunblooded (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-03 02:00 Hey woozle!!!!!!! And veggie too I guess I missed the last 2 book clubs cus I was busy working abroad at summer camps for kids with special needs all summer (Orlando and New York) so had no free time to do anything, just got back so glad to be back in the book club Getting career advice is useful, especially at this point (this is the equivalent of GCSE exams so they’d be thinking about what subjects to take for NEWTS (A level equivalents), but something similar at the end of second year when their picking their OWL subjects probably would have been useful cus remember how they choose them (Harry just did whatever what did and someone (dean I think?) was just jabbing at the paper with his wand picking whatever subject it landed on
2026-08-06 16:01 Hey woozle!!!!!!! And veggie too I guess I missed the last 2 book clubs cus I was busy working abroad at summer camps for kids with special needs all summer (Orlando and New York) so had no free time to do anything, just got back so glad to be back in the book club Getting career advice is useful, especially at this point (this is the equivalent of GCSE exams so they’d be thinking about what subjects to take for NEWTS, A level equivalents), but something similar at the end of second year when their picking their OWL subjects probably would have been useful as well, cus remember how they choose their OWLS (Harry just did whatever subjects Ron did, and someone (dean I think?) was just jabbing at the paper with his wand picking whatever subject it landed on) Also about taking submissions for art I’d love to do one, I’d LOVE to do either chapter 33 or 35, I’d love to do both (I do digital art as a hobby) if possible but don’t wanna take too many if loads of other people want to do art for them) of this book (I don’t wanna give spoilers by saying the chapter names) also it’s a LONG way off but I’d also LOOOOOVE to do the epilogue of deathly hallows Could be fun to maybe do general fan art/ videos/ songs submissions (ones that don’t spoil anything up to this point) too, similar to how people send in the book covers, could be a fun extra (I’d be happy to run/ moderate it if needed to make sure there’s no spoilers)

Hey woozle!!!!!!! And veggie too I guess I missed the last 2 book clubs cus I was busy working abroad at summer camps for kids with special needs all summer (Orlando and New York) so had no free time to do anything, just got back so glad to be back in the book club Getting career advice is useful, especially at this point (this is the equivalent of GCSE exams so they’d be thinking about what subjects to take for NEWTS, A level equivalents), but something similar at the end of second year when their picking their OWL subjects probably would have been useful as well, cus remember how they choose their OWLS (Harry just did whatever subjects Ron did, and someone (dean I think?) was just jabbing at the paper with his wand picking whatever subject it landed on) Also about taking submissions for art I’d love to do one, I’d LOVE to do either chapter 33 or 35, I’d love to do both (I do digital art as a hobby) if possible but don’t wanna take too many if loads of other people want to do art for them) of this book (I don’t wanna give spoilers by saying the chapter names) also it’s a LONG way off but I’d also LOOOOOVE to do the epilogue of deathly hallows Could be fun to maybe do general fan art/ videos/ songs submissions (ones that don’t spoil anything up to this point) too, similar to how people send in the book covers, could be a fun extra (I’d be happy to run/ moderate it if needed to make sure there’s no spoilers)

John Phillips (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-03 02:00 You mentioned last chapter that you hope we get even more insight to how Harry feels about his dad bullying Snape and we do in this chapter. Harry questions how his parents even ended up together. Harry also doesn't want to tell Ron or Hermione about what he saw. I do like that he confided in Ginny that he wanted to speak to Sirius and I love her line about Fred and George. This is also a subtle moment but right before Madam Pince shoos Harry and Ginny out of the library, Harry looks at Ginny and he doesn't know exactly why he feels more hopeful, but he does when he looks at her. It could be because he spoke about his wish but I also think Harry is starting to subconsciously notice Ginny in a certain way. That's just my interpretation. Also, I can understand that Sirius and Lupin are trying to console Harry about what he saw and James was their best friend so they're not going to speak ill about him but I also think they're kind of downplaying the severity of the whole bullying Snape situation. Those are my thoughts and this is another really great chapter.
2026-08-06 16:18 You mentioned last chapter that you hope we get even more insight to how Harry feels about his dad bullying Snape and we do indeed get more insight in this chapter. Harry questions how his parents even ended up together. Harry also doesn't want to tell Ron or Hermione about what he saw. I do like that he confided in Ginny that he wanted to speak to Sirius and I love her line about Fred and George. This is a subtle moment but right before Madam Pince shoos Harry and Ginny out of the library, Harry looks at Ginny and he doesn't know exactly why he feels more hopeful, but he does when he looks at her. It could be because he spoke about his wish but I also think Harry is starting to subconsciously notice Ginny in a certain way. That's just my interpretation. Also, I can understand that Sirius and Lupin are trying to console Harry about what he saw and James was their best friend so they're not going to speak ill about him but I also think they're kind of downplaying the severity of the whole bullying Snape situation. Those are my thoughts and this is another really great chapter.

You mentioned last chapter that you hope we get even more insight to how Harry feels about his dad bullying Snape and we do indeed get more insight in this chapter. Harry questions how his parents even ended up together. Harry also doesn't want to tell Ron or Hermione about what he saw. I do like that he confided in Ginny that he wanted to speak to Sirius and I love her line about Fred and George. This is a subtle moment but right before Madam Pince shoos Harry and Ginny out of the library, Harry looks at Ginny and he doesn't know exactly why he feels more hopeful, but he does when he looks at her. It could be because he spoke about his wish but I also think Harry is starting to subconsciously notice Ginny in a certain way. That's just my interpretation. Also, I can understand that Sirius and Lupin are trying to console Harry about what he saw and James was their best friend so they're not going to speak ill about him but I also think they're kind of downplaying the severity of the whole bullying Snape situation. Those are my thoughts and this is another really great chapter.

Alias93

Hi Veggie ! That’s the first time we see Ginny and Harry having a one on one conversion, she has come a long way from not being able to talk around him. I like that she’s the one to suggest there might be a way for him to talk to Sirius, which was something that Harry really needed to be able to process what he saw in the pensieve. Although Harry didn’t seem to be quite convinced by what Sirius and Lupin had to say about James. What did you think about the fact that Harry is doing much better at potions when Snape is leaving him alone? That doesn’t reflect well on Snape as a teacher, not to mention what he does at the end of the lesson. It was quite considerate of Fred and George not to disrupt students preparing their exams, which makes the decision to have them ruin an O.W.L. exam for their grand exit in the movie a bit out of character.

Florian

Hi Veggie, Awesome Chapter again. I really like the battle between McGonagal and Umbridge and the moments before it started. The german version of this scene is one of the most memorable in the whole book, in my opinion. The way Rufus Beck (the german Audiobook reader) pronounces "Hustenbonbon" (cough drop) is so fun xD

S1lm4r1l

Does Snape intentionally break the potion? I've always thought Harry was distracted and it smashed by itself.

S1lm4r1l

If I could change a single small thing about the series. I'd make Arthur Minister for Magic at the end of Book 7.

Sten4321

the way it is written it very much hints at snape breaking it, or allowing malfoy to break it as harry turns his back to it.

Garfnob (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-03 02:00 Greetings, Chapter – 29 - Harry was so close to getting it. The James and Black thought Smape really deserved it. He was there Malfoy. - This chapter reiterates it was because they were board, not out of sadism. Could what they did be defined as sadistic, yes. However that was not the instigating motivation. nuance matters. - They gave up on calling Black Snuffles fairly quick, except for Hermione. - McGonagall is a great head of house. - so much I want to say about the implications of the fire conversation, but apparently the most important line when it comes to the fight was not here as I thought it was. I will come back to it later. Yes it was a fight, which Snape lost. It was not one sided bullying. It even had the ring on onlookers. It was just missing the trope of the fight chant. Should it have happened, no. was this kind of thing common in the 70s (when the scene was set) I would have to say yes as it still happened in my day the 90s (when the book was written). - as someone that was bullied in school this is not something one should carry into adulthood. I know everyone is different. I will leave off my rant about where it all went wrong with kids. sorry about the abnormal length. P.S. do the spaces make it easier or my normal way?
2026-08-06 19:49 Greetings, Chapter – 29 - Harry was so close to getting it. The James and Black thought Smape really deserved it. He was there Malfoy. - This chapter reiterates it was because they were board, not out of sadism. Could what they did be defined as sadistic, yes. However that was not the instigating motivation. nuance matters. - They gave up on calling Black Snuffles fairly quick, except for Hermione. - McGonagall is a great head of house. - so much I want to say about the implications of the fire conversation, but apparently the most important line when it comes to the fight was not here as I thought it was. I will come back to it later. Yes it was a fight, which Snape lost. It was not one sided bullying. It even had the ring on onlookers. It was just missing the trope of the fight chant. Should it have happened, no. was this kind of thing common in the 70s (when the scene was set) I would have to say yes, as it still happened in my day the 90s (when the book was written). - as someone that was bullied in school this is not something one should carry into adulthood. I know everyone is different. I will leave off my rant about where it all went wrong with kids. sorry about the abnormal length. P.S. do the spaces make it easier or my normal way?

Greetings, Chapter – 29 - Harry was so close to getting it. The James and Black thought Smape really deserved it. He was there Malfoy. - This chapter reiterates it was because they were board, not out of sadism. Could what they did be defined as sadistic, yes. However that was not the instigating motivation. nuance matters. - They gave up on calling Black Snuffles fairly quick, except for Hermione. - McGonagall is a great head of house. - so much I want to say about the implications of the fire conversation, but apparently the most important line when it comes to the fight was not here as I thought it was. I will come back to it later. Yes it was a fight, which Snape lost. It was not one sided bullying. It even had the ring on onlookers. It was just missing the trope of the fight chant. Should it have happened, no. was this kind of thing common in the 70s (when the scene was set) I would have to say yes, as it still happened in my day the 90s (when the book was written). - as someone that was bullied in school this is not something one should carry into adulthood. I know everyone is different. I will leave off my rant about where it all went wrong with kids. sorry about the abnormal length. P.S. do the spaces make it easier or my normal way?

Dodolulupepe

Hi Veggie! The library scene is actually one of my favorite moments from this book; I have such a soft spot for it. Harry, for a week straight, had kept any hint of his real reason for feeling awful from Ron and Hermione. The wish to speak to Sirius was burning inside of him, but he didn't tell them for all that time, probably because he thought they (well, at least Hermione) would just dissuade him - and that ended up being right. Ginny didn't nag him, she let him take his time and say what was on his mind...and this was what finally let Harry say what he so wanted to. Her approach to him here shows she knows him really well. And I definitely think the reason Harry felt a little more hopeful is not just what he thought, but that this is the first hint of him starting to like Ginny :) You said last review that you'd praise the book immensely if Harry had more self-reflection about what he saw and talked to someone...well, you got your wish and then some! I have to say I'm a bit disappointed in Sirius and Lupin here. They're MUCH more mature and better people now than at 15, but they still couldn't really condemn their past selves. "Sometimes got a bit carried away" is a very light way to describe bullying. And then the trickle truthing ("and stopped hexing people for the fun of it" - Harry asks about Snape - "well, Snape was a special case" - and Lupin responded here "slowly", like he was choosing his words carefully). And remember what James "promised" in the memory, that if Lily went out with him, he wouldn't lay a hand on Snape? Well he lied...we hear that he hid his continued bullying of Snape from Lily... And what a legendary finish. This chapter literally had four amazing scenes back-to-back and I only could talk about two of them in a good length...

Madikuma95 (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-03 02:00 I think one reason Sirius and Lupin are downplaying the incident is because for them it happened 20 years ago and didn't have a big impact on their lives (unlike for Snape, it's his worst memory). For Sirius and Lupin, so many other tragedies have happened since then that they probably forgot about it. I always assumed Snape knocked Harry's potion off the desk, but the text isn't 100% clear. 🤔 I feel like students should be given career pamphlets at the *start* of the year, to know which classes to take to earn the required OWLS. Which wizarding career would you want to go into? And what do you think of Harry's choice to become an Auror? PS. Fred and George are awesome!
2026-08-06 22:27 It's kinda not great that Harry thinks Draco deserves the same as what James did to Snape, especially since he already beat up Draco earlier in this book. 😓 I think one reason Sirius and Lupin are downplaying the incident is because for them it happened 20 years ago and didn't have a big impact on their lives (unlike for Snape, it was his worst memory). I always assumed Snape knocked Harry's potion off the desk, but the text isn't 100% clear. 🤔 I feel like students should be given career pamphlets at the *start* of the year, to know which classes to take to earn the required OWLS. Which wizarding career would you want to go into? And what do you think of Harry's choice to become an Auror? PS. Fred and George are awesome!

It's kinda not great that Harry thinks Draco deserves the same as what James did to Snape, especially since he already beat up Draco earlier in this book. 😓 I think one reason Sirius and Lupin are downplaying the incident is because for them it happened 20 years ago and didn't have a big impact on their lives (unlike for Snape, it was his worst memory). I always assumed Snape knocked Harry's potion off the desk, but the text isn't 100% clear. 🤔 I feel like students should be given career pamphlets at the *start* of the year, to know which classes to take to earn the required OWLS. Which wizarding career would you want to go into? And what do you think of Harry's choice to become an Auror? PS. Fred and George are awesome!

jolt45

Howdy Veggie and Woozle, McGonagall really is the perfect foil to Umbridge. The description of McGonagall's facial expressions are pure gold. Remember how I said Hermione and Lupin are analog characters from their respective years? Well, Hermione spent most of this chapter trying to convince Harry not to risk expulsion but he contacts Sirius anyway. Failing to convince your friend to behave is very Lupin-like. What did you think of Sirius and Lupin's defense of James? Are you going to offer a special Patreon discount to any Hogwarts students that promise to get rid of this old bat?

Diego Zenhäusern

WFFTITWFF Veggie! It just always gives me chills when Peeves – who we haven't seen respect or fear ANYONE besides Dumbledore (one of the most powerful wizards ever) and the Bloody Baron (a creepy, bloodied ghost) – salutes Fred and George (two simple students) and even takes orders from them!😮 It weirdly is one of the most memorable moments of this book for me.😅 On another note: This is actually the chapter where Filch lost most of my sympathy when I first read these books. Up until this point I always was on "his side". I assumed he was just trying to intimidate the students with his talk about torturing them (since as a Squib he had no real way of "controlling" them otherwise). And so I saw him as a "nice" and misunderstood man that had to act cruel to "survive". But his pure glee at the thought of getting to whip the twins was clearly not an act, since he had no idea that he was being watched. And it really bumped me out.😕 To end on a happy note: McGonagall offering Umbridge cough drops is pure comedy gold, and I'll never not love it!😂

Alias93

Yeah that's how I read it too, Snape breaking it on purpose to punish Harry, probably because he noticed that the potion was correctly made and he would have to give it at least an okay grade, and we can't have Harry starting to think he's good at potions...

Noni

Hey Veggie I love pissed off McGonagall. I wish Harry hadn't lied to Hermione about why his lessens with Snape had finished although I do understand him not being ready to share what he'd learnt about his father. Snape’s behaviour to Harry in class is petty and vindictive and inexcusible for a teacher.

S1lm4r1l

Lily didn't agree to that 'deal' though. She made her own choice to date Potter Snr without conditions.

Dodolulupepe

Yeah, I know, I was just pointing out how it's disappointing he didn't even hold himself to that very low bar that she wanted (and she did still want him to not go after Snape, otherwise he wouldn't have hid it from her actively during the relationship (well, during the first part in 7th year, I doubt Snape and the Marauders saw each other after that much))

Ирина Устюгова

It's not what is written in the text, though. You didn't use a direct quote, but rather your own interpretation. Here is what Lupin actually said: 'Well,' said Lupin slowly, 'Snape was a special case. I mean, he never lost an opportunity to curse James, so you couldn’t really expect James to take that lying down, could you?' It's heavily implied that Snape was attacking James first. If someone is attacking you and you retaliate, it's not bullying - it's self-defense. And it's not exactly the first time Snape went after the Marauders. In Prisoner of Azkaban, we learn that he stalked the Marauders, hoping to dig up something on them so they could be expelled. Even more, Rowling mentioned that James's dislike of Snape was, for some part, because he suspected Snape and Lily to be close and was jealous. So I always get the impression that James couldn't care less about Snape in his 7th year and just wanted him to leave him and Lily alone. I mean, James had everything he wanted at this point: he was Head Boy and was dating Lily. I just can't see him actively provoking or bullying Snape and risking losing everything he had. While Snape probably couldn't get over the fact that Lily and James were now together, and he maintained this resentment towards James for the rest of his life, even when James was freaking dead.

Dodolulupepe

I don't believe Lupin's narration is entirely honest, because of a few things: 1. the minimization of the incident in the 5th year - if Harry had never brought that one up, Lupin and Sirius likely would have been dismissive of it too; 2. how Lupin said this "slowly" in your quote, implying careful choosing of words, therefore not total honesty; and 3. and the most importantly, that if it had been only self defense in the 6th and 7th years, why would James have had to keep it hidden from Lily? You make a good point about James having everything he wanted by then, but we saw how he acted in the memory, he was already acting untouchable, with how openly he was talking about the werewolf stuff and how he was strutting around like he owned the place. I don't think he would consider it "risking losing everything he had" to continue to antagonize Snape into his 6th and 7th years too; he was arrogant, and would not have wanted Snape to get "free" of him so to say, especially in these later years now that after his end with Lily and 'making his choice' (referring to the last conversation they had in the DH memory), Snape would have fully joined the side of the Death Eaters. I don't see how James would've let Snape go in this period. James wouldn't have lost the feeling of projecting his power over him, being in control, as we saw in SWM, so quickly. But really, my whole opinion on this all hinges on James keeping it hidden from Lily what James was doing to Snape in the 7th year. If James had all been in the right in that year regarding Snape, Lily would have been totally on board of being on James's side and James would've had nothing to hide, in fact would've likely boasted/complained of it. I think your interpretation makes a lot of sense too, but this detail is primarily why I hold to my own.

Ирина Устюгова

I really doubt bullying as grand, public, and extreme as in Order of the Phoenix could have realistically happened without Lily finding out about it. When James and Sirius bullied Snape in the 5th book, the moment it started, there was already a whole group of onlookers. I'm pretty sure that by the next day, the entire school knew about the incident. Considering James and Lily only began dating on their 7th year, it's safe to assume they spent most of their free time together. James couldn't bully Snape in classes in front of teachers, so it would have to be those rare moments when they met in the corridors and hexed each other. And even if we assume that Lily wasn't present herself, she had friends who would definitely have told her about it. And why didn't James tell her about it? Probably because at this point he knew for certain how close she and Snape used to be and that it was a very touchy subject for her. Imagine they're on a date, she kisses him, and James is like: 'BTW, Snape and I cursed each other today.' What would that achieve except hurting her? It would also be extremely strange and insensitive of him to try to boast about that while knowing Snape was her ex-best friend. Also, I don't see why Lupin would lie. First of all, I'm sure if it was a lie, Rowling would have made sure the reader found out about it sooner or later. It's a children's book series, she wouldn't leave something like that vague. I don't like how we assume that anything bad said about Snape must be a lie or the result of an unreliable narrator, while taking everything else in the books at face value. Second of all, Lupin was always pretty fair to Snape. Sometimes even too much, for example, when he blamed Harry for being prejudiced against Snape, which was ridiculous. He probably felt indebted to Snape for not intervening and stopping the bullying back in their school days, and also because Snape helped him with his condition in the 3rd book. Plus, if he wanted to lie, why create a half-truth? He could just say that James stopped attacking Snape altogether. Full stop. It's not like Harry could verify his words anyway. As for them never mentioning what they did to Snape and Lupin talking 'slowly' - could it simply be because it happened more than 20 years ago? Sure, this memory held great importance to Snape because it was the moment before his friendship with Lily was destroyed forever. But would Sirius or Lupin, who don't have a Pensieve to dwell on memories, even remember every detail before Harry asked them? Sirius spent years in Azkaban, and Lupin was trying to survive in poverty as a werewolf. They probably had a general idea of what happened in their school days or remembered the most vivid incidents, but it's completely possible that this specific moment wasn't nearly as crucial to them. Also, James changed - that's what Lupin and Sirius explicitly said. And he clearly changed enough to become Head Boy and for Lily to notice. Of course, you can say they're lying again, but then it becomes a real problem when we disregard everything good about James and ignore everything bad about Snape.

Connor Wilkinson

Hi Veggie and Woozle Chapter 29 * I enjoyed the back and forth between McGonagall and Umbridge. * What did you think about Sirius and Lupin’s side of the story regarding James and Snape?

S1lm4r1l

Whilst everyone talks about the incident's effect on Snape, I think it was similarly powerful for James. If he was absolutely dead set on Lily, and saw how she responded to his treatment of Snape, perhaps that was the catalyst for him changing, deflating his head a bit. We know Snape's Worst Memory happened at exam time, end of the year. So everyone had the entire summer to mull over what they'd done or not done. I think James saw that his antagonization of Snape wasn't getting him any closer to Lily, and resolved to do things differently, or try to. Even so, Lily still didn't go out with him until the 7th Year. The fact that James and Snape wouldn't be seeing each other nearly as much in 6th and 7th year, taking different classes, probably meant they had less opportunities to be awful to each other. We know that James and the Marauders became much more interested in running around the grounds and Hogsmeade together after they became Animagi even writing the Map together. Whilst James Potter still wouldn't have been thrilled about Snape's bullying of Muggle-borns, his Dark Arts fixation and his Death Eaters-in-waiting friend group. The fact that Snape's relationship with Lily was irretrievably broken would've gone a long way to removing James's desire to bully Snape. We're also assuming that Lily would still care about Snape after this incident and as he falls headfirst into his Death Eater role. The conversation she has with him when he tries to apologise makes clear that "Mudblood" was the last straw for her and that their friendship had been rocky for some time. I'm sure there were still plenty of times when James was awful to Snape, but I suspect Snape had far greater motives for being awful to James, certainly after James and Lily became an item. It is also possible that Snape blamed James for him saying "Mudblood" and destroying his friendship with Lily. Can anyone truly say that Snape wouldn't want revenge? We saw what he was willing to do in the memory. Inflicting flesh wounds with Dark Magic. We know he invented/reinvented Sectumsempra within a few months of that incident. I think James grew out of / lost interest in Snape after their 5th year, especially as he had much more exciting adventures with the Marauders to undertake and Lily to occupy him. Any incidents between him and Snape mostly would've been triggered by Snape, in my opinion.

Dodolulupepe

Ok, these are fair replies, I see where you two are coming from

Esmeralda Joy

Hi Veggie, This is not the first time we see Madam Pince seemingly overreact to broken library rules. I like to think that feeding the wrong book chocolate could summon a demon or open a time rift, so she has to be super strict...Or maybe she just enjoys using her power like Filch. I love Mcgonagall soo much!

Inseriousity

I do like these moments where we're reminded that there's an actual school going on. My own careers advice was not that great. I recall being told I'd receive some leaflets and nothing ever happened. What was your own careers advice like (if you even had one, I think its very hit and miss around the country)? I read somewhere once that most kids these days say they want to be a Youtuber/influencer when they grow up. What sort of advice would you give to anyone that wanted to be a youtuber?

S1lm4r1l

Harry being good at potions? Imagine that!

Schaumkus

Hi Veggie, this is a chapter where the reader can have a small postitive break with the McGonagall-Umbridge argument and the Weasleys escape. When I was younger I was always confused with Umbridge‘s title „Under Secretary“. In this chapter she flexes her title again as if it’s something super big and important. I’ve grown up with the german version and Under Secretary was translated 1:1 to „Unter Sekretär“. Only way later I found out that Secretary and Sekretär are two totally different jobs. In the UK it is an important political figure who ranks just below the minister. In modern Germany a „Sekretär“ gets usually associated with a person who handles the appointments, mail etc. of an important figure and holds zero political power themselves. And the word „under“ even lowered it for me, because it sounds like Umbridge wasn‘t even the main one. I think they should have used a slightly different translation, so the younger audience also understands it. When Harry talks to Black and Lupin, the one line from Lupin always left a bitter taste in my mouth. He excuses James Potter’s behaviour because hes 15. I never understood how that even is an argument to have. Being 15 does not allow you to be a bully. Cheers

Sten4321

Wait! "Under Secretary", is an actually important job in england??? i've also always thought her flaunting being an "under-"secretary as if it was an important position was the joke... xD

Japunaka (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-03 02:00 Hiya Veggie and Woozle, This is my first time commenting (and probably my last, because I'm usually a quiet listener) I'm not actually caught up, but I thought I'd jump in here to tell you a cool detail only people reading the book (instead of listening to the audio books) would know and it seems like noone has mentioned it yet. In the book some of Harry's thoughts are written in italics and some aren't. Usually if there is a sentence like "said a voice in his head" it's in italics. I just thought you should know because I wanted to give you the same experience I had when I read it for the first time. I remember having many theories about it xD I'm very sorry if someone has already mentioned this, as I said I'm not completely caught up. I hope you and Woozle have a lovely day, Tuturu
2026-08-12 21:42 Hiya Veggie and Woozle, This is my first time commenting (and probably my last, because I'm usually a quiet listener) I'm not actually caught up, but I thought I'd jump in here to tell you a cool detail only people reading the book (instead of listening to the audio books) would know and it seems like noone has mentioned it yet. In the book some of Harry's thoughts are written in italics and some aren't. Usually if there is a sentence like "said a voice in his head" it's in italics. I just thought you should know because I wanted to give you the same experience I had when I read it for the first time. I remember having many theories about it xD I'm very sorry if someone has already mentioned this, as I said I'm not completely caught up. I hope you and Woozle have a lovely day, Tutturu

Hiya Veggie and Woozle, This is my first time commenting (and probably my last, because I'm usually a quiet listener) I'm not actually caught up, but I thought I'd jump in here to tell you a cool detail only people reading the book (instead of listening to the audio books) would know and it seems like noone has mentioned it yet. In the book some of Harry's thoughts are written in italics and some aren't. Usually if there is a sentence like "said a voice in his head" it's in italics. I just thought you should know because I wanted to give you the same experience I had when I read it for the first time. I remember having many theories about it xD I'm very sorry if someone has already mentioned this, as I said I'm not completely caught up. I hope you and Woozle have a lovely day, Tutturu

Japunaka

I wholeheartedly agree (I'm German as well). Rufus Beck made a lot of bold choices during the book series (It took me a long time to get used to "Lestrange" not being pronounced french) but I love his McGonagall and especially in this scene. It is so fun, like you said!!

Florian

Yeah, his Lestrange was a choice xD

S1lm4r1l

They did feel bad about it. Which invalidates the argument that it was sadism. Sadists don't feel bad about the hurts they cause.

Sam-I-Am

Hi Veggie and Woozle! I still have to catch up with past book clubs, but didn't want to miss leaving a comment for this one. This chapter (and the book as a whole) is a lot more heartbreaking to read through as an adult. When it first released, I was 11 and found Harry's teenage angst to be annoying (I hadn't quite reached my own teenage angst years yet). Now, I just want to give Harry a big hug. A few notes on the chapter: -It speaks volumes that Harry risks using Umbridge's fireplace to speak to Sirius and Lupin. In the last book, Harry also communicates with Sirius through the fireplace. But he sends him away right before Sirius was about to tell him something important regarding the first task. Here, his need to talk about what he saw his dad doing outweighs his need to protect Sirius' whereabouts -Lupin and Sirius beaming as they reminisce about James is so sad. It's clear how much they miss him -While I do think that both Sirius and Lupin downplay James' actions a bit here, I do appreciate that they can at least admit that they were idiots If James were still alive, how do you think he would explain his past actions to Harry?

Maria (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-03 02:00 Hi Veggie! As many have said, I love the interaction between McGonagall and Umbridge. I do wonder if Umbridge sat in on all the career advice sessions, or just Harry's. What do you think about Harry wanting to be an auror? When Harry is leaving Grimmauld Place at Christmas, Black gives him a package and says to use it if Harry needs him. Why do you think Harry didn't use the item Black gave him? It seems like the perfect opportunity. There are lots of adults letting Harry down in this chapter. I don't think Lupin and Black did a very good job of explaining themselves to Harry. But, Snape's behavior in this chapter is inexcusable as a teacher. I think he has handled the occlumency situation very unprofessionally. Also, we hear that Hagrid is still limping; what's going on with him?
2026-08-15 02:43 Hi Veggie! This is a great chapter for Fred and George, not to mention Peeves! As many have said, I love the interaction between McGonagall and Umbridge. I do wonder if Umbridge sat in on all the career advice sessions, or just Harry's. What do you think about Harry wanting to be an auror? There are lots of adults letting Harry down in this chapter. I don't think Lupin and Black did a very good job of explaining themselves to Harry. But, Snape's behavior in this chapter is inexcusable as a teacher. I think he has handled the occlumency situation very unprofessionally. Also, we hear that Hagrid is still limping; what's going on with him?

Hi Veggie! This is a great chapter for Fred and George, not to mention Peeves! As many have said, I love the interaction between McGonagall and Umbridge. I do wonder if Umbridge sat in on all the career advice sessions, or just Harry's. What do you think about Harry wanting to be an auror? There are lots of adults letting Harry down in this chapter. I don't think Lupin and Black did a very good job of explaining themselves to Harry. But, Snape's behavior in this chapter is inexcusable as a teacher. I think he has handled the occlumency situation very unprofessionally. Also, we hear that Hagrid is still limping; what's going on with him?

Garfnob

i am not the one that called them Sadistic. they felt bad later, not at the time. that would not mean they where not sadistic in the moment. i do not think that was there motivation as i noted in my comment. an action can be Sadistic without the person being a Sadists. Sadistic definition - getting pleasure or satisfaction from causing pain, suffering, or humiliation to others. they did get pleasure out of it at the time, and it was humiliating to Snape.

Garfnob

might want to try to make your thoughts more concise. this is way long.

S1lm4r1l

Yeah, I was way too long, shortened it down.

S1lm4r1l

Its one of those jobs that doesn't sound important, but is.

CJ Haaay

Hi Veggie! Hope you are doing well. • How do you feel about the “perhaps Malfoy, or someone who really deserved it” line? I can’t imagine F + G (or Harry, for that matter) doing anything like that to anyone • I like that Harry is thinking about this introspectively. It’s a very coming of age moment, when you stop idolising your parents and think of them as flawed people, and also who you are and what kind of person you want to be. • What career would you want to have in the wizarding world? • Harry doing better when Snape ignores him really lets you know what kind of teacher Snape is • McGonagall is the best, I shall say no more on the matter • Sirius and Remus seem to be taking the situation very lightly, I’m not sure how I feel about that Have a great week!

ChrisG9018

Hi Veggie I love the fact that the twins created a swamp, what a shame the movie didnt show peeves saluting Fred and George. I wonder what peeves will do to carry on. The Career planning scene is great. we know some jobs Animal care, st mungo's, hogwarts and the ministry, i wonder what other jobs there are in the magical world. thanks you for all your waffles

Sanji Joestar

*reads San-Jee Joe-Star Hi Veggie and Woozle! First time in the Book Club, glad to be here. I've recently got my hands on the Full Cast Audiobook and finished Hogwarts Legacy, so I'm back into exploring some Harry Potter related content and I found your channel. I love seeing other people's reactions to stories I enjoyed and a chapter by chapter review of the series was exactly what I needed, so Thanks for that. I also got a new found appreciation for some secondary/minor characters such as Krum, Phineas and Kreacher etc. I also can't wait for you to get to one of my favorite scenes in this book, glad I caught up before you got there. Sorry If this is quite lengthy, I'll try to keep my comments much shorter in the future. Order of The Phoenix is one of the few books I read physically (thanks to my sister) alongside Chambers and Goblet. The Goblet copy I owned had missing beginning and end pages so I actually never knew about the story of Frank - the Riddle family caretaker - or that Rita was an unregistered Animagi until much later when I did a full reread lol. This chapter was quite fun and my favorite part was definitely McGonagall's support for Harry and her stance against Umbridge. Would have loved to see that side of her character in the movie. The Sirius conversation really shows how much Harry wants to make sure he's not getting the wrong picture. Quite odd that he asks the bully's side and I do agree they're downplaying it, but again it's the only people he can ask. Love Lupin even if he was passively complicit. I do believe his father and friends became better people as they grew up and that Snape's hatred for them is still warranted. Stopping Occlumency however just puts them at risk. Fred and Georges are awesome in this chapter, even Peeves had to pay his respects lol. One last thing that's been on my mind over the book reviews is S.P.E.W. In the books there's a lot going on regarding what house elves are and want but as a whole I'll always agree with Hermione. My problem isn't really what she does but how the book depicts her character. Maybe I'm missing something but it almost feels like it's making fun of her movement (even to the name S.P.E.W., translated as a joke name in almost every language. In french it's called S.A.L.E. which is the french word for 'Dirty' or 'Unclean'). There's a lot of justification in the story from the wizarding kind for why this whole situation is ''better'' for the elves and that if they're granted freedom it will basically destroy their lives. If it was just the elves wishing to help people, why are they called slaves? Why do they have a symbol of enslavement? It feels wishy-washy to me. Hogwarts' house elves under Dumbledore are probably more fairly treated than most of them so I'm not even sure they could be seen as the standard. Dobby, Winky and Kreacher show a trend where they're basically dehumanized and humiliated. Even as a 'free' Elf Dobby needs to be ordered to lie to a superior and not to hurt himself. And I can't really believe the idea that they're fine with it because somehow elves 'AGREED' to 'ENSLAVEMENT'. Those two words seem incompatible. I do like some of the stuff explored through them, I just don't feel like most of it is treated very seriously which is why we focus so much on Hermione's 'unreasonable' plans despite being an intelligent character. For example, she doesn't really notice how SPEW sounds like. Even if it was a joke from Ron, H.E.L.F. sounds much better lol (House Elf Liberation Front and a pun between HELP and ELF). She's a young teenager so she's not gonna change the world in a few books but still. Sorry for the long rant, I just felt like I had to talk about this. Again thanks for reading and I can't wait to see more.

Gugurupurasu Daikirai

Hello from the fourth circle of hell where the temperatures have been ungodly ever since a surprisingly mild July, Am I the only one who ships Argus and Umbridge? It's one of my favorite ships. I had never seen Argus have so much joy as when he got the approval for whipping students. That moment is so cute in a weird way. They're made for each other It was nice to see Sirius and Lupin again. Do you have any thought as to why they both reacted so strongly to Harry no longer doing his Occlumency lessons with Snape and strongly insisted they continue?

Liz

Hey Veggie and Woozle I hope you're well. It's been a while since I've been able to comment, busy life etc. One thing thats happened since last time I commented is I managed to go to the Warner Bros Studio Tour in London finally. It was an early Xmas/birthday present from my mum and my partner came with me. It was so incredible and I'd love to go again so we are trying to sort with friends of his to go as a group 😄 Chapter 29 One of my favourite chapters. I love Fred and George mainly for the chaos they give Umbridge (I won't use most people's favourite nickname for her only for your sake 😆). Of course my favourite part of this chapter is Harry's meeting with Professor Mcgonagall about his future career. I do feel for Harry being upset about James's behaviour in Snapes memory though. Lupin tells Harry that Snape gave as good as he got. It wasn't one sided bullying. Its not mentioned in the books but I believe James Potter was raised to be intolerant of the Dark Arts. A slight mention from Sirius about James hating the Dark Arts. I think it's one of the pieces of information J K Rowling wrote after all the books were out on Pottermore. (If I'm wrong anyone can feel free to correct me.) I really look forward to your thoughts especially on Mcgonagall vs Umbridge haha 😄 Take care Veggie and Woozle

PumpkinSparks

Hey Woozles Hooman :) After missing last bookclub (seriously where did July go? I swear it was like 3 days long!), I would have been devestated to miss this one. I don't know what it is, but this is one of my favourite chapters in all 7 books. So much happens, but nothing really happens. Every plotpoint is important and needed to happen, but they're all kinda mundane (exept for the end with the twins). It's just life happening, and I love it! - Harry and Ginny actually developing a friendship and their own report - Ginny showing more of her savvy and rebellious side and once more being more twin akin than any other Weasley kid - the twins laying low for the break, because they don't do chaos for chaos sake - it's targeted - McGonnagal being the absolute goat once more!!! - I get that 15 year old Harry wants to be an auror. But darling, have you considered teaching? You seem to really enjoy it and have an aptitude for it - Hermione trying so hard to stop Harry from being reckless and stupid (she doesn't understand why Harry NEEDS to talk to Sirius, because Harry once again doesn't share...) - the whole conversation with the gay uncles (I know they're not gay or together, but the way they are written it makes so much more sense to me. And you cannot tell me, especially in this chapter, that they did not serve 100% gay uncle vibes!) - the twins just twinning and coming through big time. What do you mean they created a swamp in a corridor? While the movie version is incredibly fun, I do prefer the books more calculated exit - PEEVES SALUTING THE TWINS!?!?!?!?! Did anyone see that coming? I sure didn't! Since I didn't send love towards the noodle last month, please give her a big cuddle from me :) PS since you've been wondering where exactly all the Germans come from: in my case it's Hamburg and I split my childhood between Hamburg and an eedy biddy tiny village near Flensburg (fun fact, that area is where the angles came from, so my people gave your country its name XD). Except for my preference for coffee over tea this pumpkin is 100% a northerner ;)

PumpkinSparks

I do remember reading something about the Potters aversion to the Dark Arts and I think it was Pottermore. So I think you're right about that. Usually I don't give too much about the additional info since the author said a lot in interviews or twitter that contradict the canon or just simply make no sense (Pottermore is slightly higher on the credential list, but has some huh?-moments as well), but in this case it's an additional info that enhances the established canon or adds layers to something already hinted at.

PumpkinSparks

Yeah, same. I was so confused when I first read it! I really don't understand why they chose a literal translation. Especially since we have an equivalent: Staatssekretär. It immediately sounds WAYS more important!

Methanoutput

Hey Veggie and Woozle! I love Mcgonagall in this chapter. She manages Umbridge so well, while being able to motivate Harry. Still she does stay realistic and tells him how hard its gonna be and provides all the necessary information of becoming an auror. I think i would have gone mad, with someone interrupting me all the time. Also i don't know if you figured out what the Overlay is supposed to show, but it should be the logo of the Auror's office! Hope you and Woozle have a great day and cant wait to hear your thoughts!

Alan Michener

Hi veggie I feel like I almost missed this one. Something no one has mentioned yet that I find hilarious is that Seamus spends 5 whole minutes looking for leaks in his cauldron because of Hermione's warning which sounds like hissing. Also I love how Hermione also snaps at Ron that he should take notes in history of magic instead of her. Now I feel like this is my controversial opinion. I don't think Sirius and Lupin downplay what Harry saw in the memory. Sirius even says he is not proud of what happened in the memory. And Sirius even mentions how they were arrogant little berks. Both Lupin and Sirius seem to regret there actions of the past which makes me wonder if snape would actually have an adult conversation with them about the past if he could then maybe let go of his hate. But alas no Snape would rather still act like he is 15 and keeps making snide comments to his tormentors of a decade and a half ago. Also portal swamp is the funniest things ever and I love how uncaring Fred and George are and they even admit that they did that.

Garry (Not Jerry)

I suspect possibly Peeve’s “respect” to Fred and George is more contingent on the nature of the order 😆

Simon audsley

"I see you shiver with antici... Interesting that it's Ginny he talks to about his problems and not Hermione or Ron, also that Ron and Hermione remind him of Mr. and Mrs. Weasley. The films didn't really show these small personal relationship moments very well. McGonagall and Umbridge are still the best of friends, and we get a nice bit context for what harry saw and also get to see that both Sirius and loopin have grown up a bit more than is shown in the film. The twins are much more considerate toward other students in the book by not interrupting the exams. ...pation"

Garry (Not Jerry)

I don’t know if you can make the comment about Sirius’ gift here, it’s a connection Veggie might not have made and I wouldn’t want to spoil the reveal for him, but maybe I’m being overly cautious.

Garry (Not Jerry)

Hi Veggie! 🥦 (apparently that’s the recommended emoji) “Harry did not have time to feel awkward or embarrassed”. Yes, I know that feeling! Just get it out, Harry. It was a nice convenience that Lupin was there too, wasn’t it? I never considered this before, but do you think Lupin was being a little bit rude by staying? Harry only wanted to talk to Sirius. I never understood the head in the fire thing. Seems easier to just go all the way in rather than crouching on the stone floor. Bring a cushion next time I guess “Set by a competent teacher”. I guess she was just talking about Lupin, but technically I think Barty Crouch Jr was quite a good teacher as well, what do you think?

Maria

I didn't think it was a spoiler as Veggie knows all this information, but maybe I'll just take it out.

Music Here

Another all-time great chapter! I think Fred & George’s exit is the climax of the entire Umbridge plot. You’re yet to see the aftermath, but does it feel like the climax to you too? And did it feel that way in the movie? I don’t think it quite did, even though it's a good scene. I feel like bashing the movie, so here are a few reasons this chapter works better in the book: 1. Another great Umbridge/McGonagall scene, this time with McGonagall *directly* defending Harry. These scenes were sorely missed... 2. “Give her hell from us, Peeves.” Peeves had never listened to students before, so this feels meaningful and epic, like 5 books of buildup finally paying off. Peeves wasn’t even in the movies... 3. Fred & George’s exit gets room to breathe. In the movie, it’s immediately undercut by Harry’s vision of Sirius. I guess this is technically a spoiler for the next chapter, but the book lets the moment linger. 4. Snape’s memory shatters Harry’s idealized view of James. He can barely function without more info. It’s INSANE that the movie never addresses this. Harry just moves on like he saw nothing! 5. Ginny is actually a character. This is always worth mentioning 😁

Diego Zenhäusern

I mean of course he wouldn't have been on board if they'd told him to be nice to everyone.😅 But I still think he wouldn't have saluted to Harry if he'd asked him to make Umbridges live hell. He might have done it because he felt like it anyways, but I can't see him saluting.🤷‍♂️😅

Réka Kovács

After you talking about the "gay uncles" (which btw I love the ship between them) I accidentally read "twinks" instead of twins 😂

Réka Kovács

Omg, I'm glad someone mentioned the full body vs head travel, cause it never made sense to me! You could just travel completely and come back after you are done in seconds, why leave the body behind and the head travels? Makes 0 sense to me...

PumpkinSparks

I absolutely agree with your take on the conversation. It ties in with the question why Lilly would date and marry James. Because even just 2 years later than the memory scene the marauders already started to change and grow up, and they kept growing as a person. Even Black who absolutely has a case of arrested development (and unlike Snape has good reasons for it) has reflected on how they behaved and changed his mindset. Seriously in my opinion Snapes behavior is just pathetic...

Réka Kovács

Hi Veggie and Woozle! It's been some time since I commented, I was busy during the school year and then had the best vacation of my life (so far 😅) I think what Snape did with Harry's potion is horrible. I understand why he is mad at him at this time. Teachers are also human, so sometimes it does happen that you are not a big fan of some students, for example they are rude or disturb class regularly, etc. But I would NEVER give them a bad grade because of that (nor would I give a good grade to a student who is nice, but hasn't done well on a test). You grade their knowledge/skills, not whether you like them or not. I love the scene with the career advice. Of course the argument between McGonagall and Umbridge is iconic, and I love McGonagall's sass, but I also love that she actually stands up for Harry and says she will do anything in her power to help Harry become an auror. I'm sure you will talk much about the conversation between Harry, Sirius and Remus, but what still bothers me is that I also don't really understand how Lily fell for James. I mean sure, he didn't bully Snape in front of her anymore, but is that really enough after she hated him? What do you think made her fall in love with James? And the twins leaving was just iconic of course 😅

Garry (Not Jerry)

So, I think I have a sort of answer, even though it’s my own question. 😆 Two things: 1. The connection between the fireplaces remains open, so you can just easily pull yourself back through if you need to. (You don’t need more floo powder, you don’t need to re-state the location) 2. While Harry’s head is in the other room, he can still hear what’s going on in Umbridges office, so he knows if someone is coming, which was useful.

Andrew K

Hi Veggie! Not much to say that hasn’t been said already, so I’ll leave you with this; Thank you once again for this series and the level of detail and commitment you put into it. Very appreciative to have literally hundreds of hours of Harry Potter content to listen to. I’ll definitely eventually go back and listen from the start (yes even your Prisoner Of Azkaban chapters - which I still loved every video and enjoyed them) Can’t wait for you to explore the last several chapters of this book. All the best! I am strapping to watch and cover AEW All In tonight (it is a Wembley stadium!). Stay well!

Réka Kovács

Fair enough! Glad you answered your own question, didn't really think of those :D Still, it seems uncomfortable and unnecessary. Sure, it was useful to hear what was going on, but if he fully traveled, there wouldn't be a risk of someone seeing his body there if he didn't manage to pull himself back fast enough (and no one would realize that fast that he was gone from the school). But then again, if he just fully reapppeared without hearing someone coming, they might see him there. Random question, but I wonder if you could travel with the invisibility cloak on? I guess even then it would be noticeable if someone appears in the fireplace, even if you don't see who it is, but maybe he could just escape fast under the cloak before Umbridge/anyone would even fully comprehend what is happening?

Howiedoing

Obviously a pretty good profession for Harry in the future but after seeing his work in the DA, when I first read this book I got admit I was surprised he didn’t want to be DADA teacher one day. Such a great McGonagall book absolutely love the career advice part. And what can I say about the twins and that fantastic display they’re both extremely talented indeed. Happy almost NFL season

Emory

Hi Veggie and Woozle! I think I'm somehow managing to make it in here before the cut-off, it's been a crazy month with starting grad school so wasn't sure if I was going to be able to haha. I love McGonagall holding her own against Umbridge in this chapter and (figuratively) standing behind Harry. It has always bothered me in the movie when there is that scene with McGonagall and Umbridge on the stairs, and McGonagall steps down when Umbridge accuses her of disloyalty, becuase it completely changes the way her character is shown and diminishes the ways she resists Umbridge's regime. Sorry I'm sure you're already tired by this point, but eager to hear your thoughts if it hasn't been discussed much yet.

STAYoung

If I remember correctly the italics are very prominent in the next book with Harry's inner thoughts. I haven't listened to the audiobooks but from the specific internal debate I'm thinking of, the narrator will probably give the italics a different delivery.

STAYoung

(If I understand what you took out) - Technically Harry knows about the information too, it's just that he either forgot it or told himself not to use it and THEN forgot it. I think it's best to not mention it as it adds to the tragedy for both Harry and likely Veggie by the end

STAYoung

R.I.P to another legend. There's a limousine waiting for him along with a .. pIZzA

STAYoung

Shut up Veggie, you can keep talking though Woozle Finally up to date with the Book Reviews again!!! This time last year I had a lot of hectic months but I'm glad I can relax more this time around. You got what you wanted. The last chapter wasn't brushed off and re-contextualised everything Harry had ever heard about his parents from adults. For a while Harry thought his dad was like Biff from Back to the Future 2; forcing his mum/high school obsession to marry him. Ginny's character shone in the library. She has a good read of Harry but misread his discomfort as connected to Cho, acted as a new perspective than what he usually gets from Ron and Hermione (which we see later in the common room), and is human too with how they both forget they're eating chocolate in a library. Everything about the career advice and twin's exit is perfect. Most of it has already been covered but additional highlights include McGonagall indirectly calling Umbridge an incompetent teacher, and seeing how deranged Umbridge is in thinking that this is all a conspiracy to get Dumbledore as Minster for Magic. Given Trelawney got fired soon after she praised Harry post-Quibbler article, are you worried for McGonagall blatantly standing against Umbridge and supporting Harry? Good old Lupin acting diplomatic as usual but also good on Sirius for saying what Lupin actually meant regarding the "arrogant little berks" line. Them both reacting so dramatically to Harry not learning Occlumency shows how much they care for him. The extra context is helpful in fleshing things out and it's nice to see Sirius and Lupin reminisce good high school memories together, but also acknowledge the bad side. Looking forward to your thoughts. Your movie recap will be very quick indeed

Dobby Delfstoffer

Hi Veggie! I've been very busy so I've missed the last few book clubs, but I'm back with another Dutch fun fact! The Pensieve is called the Hersenpan in Dutch. Hersens means brain and pan is a (cooking) pan, but Hersenpan is also used to talk about someone's mind. It's not as good as the Pensieve, but still a fun phrase for something containing someone's thoughts! See you next time!

Steven

Hey veggie! “I should have made my meaning plainer,” said Professor McGonagall, turning at last to look Umbridge directly in the eyes. “He has achieved high marks in all Defense Against the Dark Arts tests set by a competent teacher.” McGonnagall has always been my MVP in this book. Just completely and utterly done with Umbridge's BS XD She just does not care in the slightest and I am here for it!

Bram

Hi Veggie, see you are still bizzy doing the book club! YES! Since I forgot to make a comment this month I would just like to say how much I've been enjoying the book club. I have been behind lately since I fell in to a little hole when caught up a year back, so I've listened too all of them twice an am now finally caught up. I have to honestly say how much I liked your own summaries at the beginning when rewarching. Giving a lot more personality I feel. You once asked what we did while listening. Well, I do basically listen when ever I feel like it while literally doing anything. Hobbies mosly. See you next month for a book reaction.