Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

It's that time again, guys! And this time we are treated to what many apparently see as the WORST CHAPTER IN THE SERIES! XD

We discuss sausage sandwiches, Shame Wells, Wacky Politicians, what Punting is, sausage sandwiches again, and Cuddles the Monkey. We also discuss this apparently controversial chapter!

One thing I have taken from the Book Club.. I definitely go a lil harder on Hagrid than most, but I don't think I over stepped the line. XD But JEEZ!

Hope you enjoy the video and have a great month!

Files

Movie Watcher Reads Harry Potter For the First Time! - Order of the Phoenix Chapter 30!

Check out the Patreon for the Full Length Movie reactions (you will need your own copy of the movie remember), and some other early access stuff coming soon! There is no minium Pay amount, so pay as little as you like! :) - https://www.patreon.com/VeggieGamer My Mail Box is Now OPEN! Find the Address and other info here! - https://youtu.be/sw1g4bfySAo Come join the official Veggie Discord server! :) - https://discord.gg/mw36C7d GET YOUR VEGGIE MERCHANDISE HERE! - https://www.redbubble.com/people/VeggieGamer GO GIVE ME A FOLLOW OVER AT TWITCH TO BE A PART OF THE FUN! - https://www.twitch.tv/veggie_gamer GET 15% OFF YOUR E-WIN RACING CHAIR BY USING PROMOTION CODE : Veggie US store: http://www.ewinracing.com/ European store: https://www.ewinracing.eu/ CCs used in my Sims 4 series can now be found here! - https://docs.google.com/document/d/1b2u8qVdJ0KAjbtG2ZPHv-DjIs2Ds4xUrtHTiKEVPahA/edit?usp=sharing CHECK ME OUT ON INSTAGRAM & TWITTER! - Veggie_Gamer CAN WE GET THIS VIDEO TO 100 LIKES, VEGGIEKNIGHTS?? If you can spare anything, Patreon (NO pressure): Want to see more of this? Give the video a thumbs up and let me know in the comments :) Hit me up on the following websites! Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheVeggieGamer/ Twitter: https://twitter.com/Veggie_Gamer Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/VeggieGamer Be sure to Follow me on Roblox (I can not accept Friend Requests) - https://www.roblox.com/users/135078748/profile End Card music - Artist: UnderwaterBeats Track: Evolution Licence:https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0

Comments

Alex Hopps

I literally checked for this about 1 min ago then immediately got the notification. So confused by the hate for this chapter people seemed to be showing in the comment thread. I have no problem with it. Im looking forward to the next chapter too. But we are rapidly approaching the stuff that really does my head in

S1lm4r1l (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-02 15:00 HYPE! We hear about Lee Jordan having an injured hand after a Detention with Umbridge. Harry recommends Murtlap Essence to stop the stinging. Its a throw-away comment, so easy to forget. I don't think she does it to every student, like every bully and predator they pick their targets.
2026-10-01 18:22 HYPE! We hear about Lee Jordan having an injured hand after a Detention with Umbridge. Harry recommends Murtlap Essence to stop the stinging. Its a throw-away comment, so easy to forget. I don't think she does it to every student, like every bully and predator they pick their targets. Just as an aside from last chapter. Sirius fully believes that Snape is a traitor working for Voldemort and that is significant in colouring his perspective. It is easy to allow our own knowledge that Snape is good tinge our understanding. I know Sirius said he was coming to Hogwarts to "have a word with Snape" but I think he was fully intending to murder Snape for his treachery, knowing the importance of Harry's Occlumency which Snape mysteriously stops giving Harry. He makes no effort to restart the lessons despite Lupin and Black saying they're gonna talk to him and inform Dumbledore.

HYPE! We hear about Lee Jordan having an injured hand after a Detention with Umbridge. Harry recommends Murtlap Essence to stop the stinging. Its a throw-away comment, so easy to forget. I don't think she does it to every student, like every bully and predator they pick their targets. Just as an aside from last chapter. Sirius fully believes that Snape is a traitor working for Voldemort and that is significant in colouring his perspective. It is easy to allow our own knowledge that Snape is good tinge our understanding. I know Sirius said he was coming to Hogwarts to "have a word with Snape" but I think he was fully intending to murder Snape for his treachery, knowing the importance of Harry's Occlumency which Snape mysteriously stops giving Harry. He makes no effort to restart the lessons despite Lupin and Black saying they're gonna talk to him and inform Dumbledore.

Cari Ann

I really liked how in the earlier chapters you couldn't figure out what was causing hagrids wounds. I definitely feel bad for gwarp, but hagrid never should have asked them to help with him, he should have already gone off with him somewhere in my opinion, he shouldn't be leaving him in the forest alone like this. I haven't commented on the book club posts in a bit but hopefully I will be back in the next chapter.

Alex Hopps

Was gonna mention lee jordans detention but couldn't remember if it had happened yet lol

Alex Hopps

Ill be honest, i wish you hadnt suppressed the urge to have the quiddich rant. Azkaban book club was 3 years ago, and i never had a problem with anything you said. To this day i still dont know how the league works and ive read these books probably 15+ times. *edit- i looked down the rabbit hole, it takes 6 games for every team in a 4 team league to all play eachother. I spent a little too long working out different permutations for scenarios where multiple teams win 2 games and how scores could be factored in (basically i should go to bed and give my adhd brain some rest)

Alex Hopps

I feel like im spamming comments again. So ive attached a picture of my cat because shes beautiful and it makes comment spam more forgivable. Im struggling to understand the justification for the hagrid is awful comment. I think it is a bit mental to ask a couple of 14 year olds to sneak into the forest to try and teach him english lol. But i think the word awful is a bit strong. I think grawp wouldn't of survived long term in the giant colloney. I wouldn't of abandoned my brother in that situation. Maybe the skrewts were abit much for lessons, and maybe bringing norbert, aragog and grawp into the grounds of a school were all a bit wrong, but im not aware of any students encountering any of them other than the trio. The problem is, hes abit oblivious to the dangers that normal people face because his life isn't filled with risk in the same way. Yeah hes a bit thick, and has previously been manipulated a bit too easily, but my views were solidified in book 1 chapter 1: Minerva "do you think its wise to trust hagrid with this" Albus "i would trust hagrid with my life"

Felix Henson

OH yikes. Did not realise Veg was doing this. Sorry but I can't support anything Harry Potter atm given JKR's nonsense.

Alex Hopps

More spam, sorry, have another cat picture I will forever be a hagrid apologist. Better than a snape apologist. I really don't know what else hagrid was supposd to do. They watched the bigger giants literally kill eachother. He says clearly in this chapter, the other giant were gonna kill him. He was crying saying he couldn't just leave him there. Its may. Hes been back since October. Its been 7 months, i dont think the centaurs pose a threat to the giant. And they dont seem to be particularly under threat from him. They are smart enough to stay clear. Ill admit asking harry and hermy to visit does potentially put them in danger. But i think its a rough situation for hagrid to navigate. I dont know what else he could do really Edit- regarding ron and his stick attack. Rons wand wouldnofndone more damage to gwarp of he had fed it to him. Harry ron and hermy could of all avada kedavad him and he wouldnt of noticed

Alex Hopps

Were 4+ years into one of the best, most in depth book clubs ever. Very kind and respectful community. We dont hate anyone. Respect to you and your views. Were not trying to upset anyone. Just chatting 6 hours of waffle a month for a 50 minute chapter and loving every minute of it

Gugurupurasu Daikirai

Actually missed it, it's on time this month. I had always wondered about the details of the trip to bring Grawp to Hogwarts forest. I especially am curious about how they crossed the English channel to get to the UK because the giants are presumably somewhere in mainland Europe. The movie doesn't really capture how unreasonable a request this was by Hagrid.

Ирина Устюгова

I really doubt Grawp would be better off with the rest of the giants. We already know about the slaughter in their ranks, where they killed the most reasonable leader and chose a more violent replacement. We also know that the giants who didn't agree are being beaten up regularly. And Death Eaters are already actively recruiting in their camp, and it's working. Grawp is smaller than average for a giant, so eventually he would have ended up killed or as cannon fodder for Voldemort's army. At least Hagrid sincerely cares for him. Having him tied up seems harsh, but he's probably used to much more brutal treatment in the mountains. I would also say that I don't really care for movie Hagrid. I mean, he is kind and sometimes funny, but nothing really special for me. While book Hagrid is in the same league as characters like Snape, he is so much more complex, interesting, and cool. I also like the detail of how Harry grabs Hermione and pulls her out of harm's way. It reminds me of how in Goblet of Fire he grabbed Ron and Hermione and pulled them to the ground before spells could hit them. It really shows how fast Harry's brain works in situations like this and why Ron and Hermione choose to follow him in times of crisis. While in the movies, it seemed like they followed him just because he's the main character or a moral authority.

Jake M

I didn't realise this was considered the worst chapter in the series. Interesting, I am intrigued to know why.

Alex Hopps

I think shes about 11 but we we didnt get a lot of details when she moved in

Madikuma95

Hi Veggie, just wanted to say thank you for all you do with the book club, and don't let anyone shame you for enjoying a book.

Simon audsley

Harry called out that hermione was going to harangue him about fred and George, but she cleverly changed it to another subject, one which is a sore spot for harry which he can't defend. It was technically cuddles, cuddles said it scrunched his face up and looked at Keith, keith then said did you say that or did I, cuddles shook his head in response, keith then replied "yes I thought it was me". Since you mentioned dreams the one I had this morning was a doozy, It featured Vincent price, roddy mcdowall as his peter Vincent character from fright night, a buxom blond bar wench a faked death, a return to movies, a murder plot and people tuning into victoria sponges. I can pinpoint where all elements came from but I'll blame my homebrew stout.

VEGGIE GAMER

Hahaha! Oh the 'subtle little innuendos' these stars used to sneak into their actors for the audience XD (I am being scarcastic of course XD). Haha, that sounds like a wild dream!

Garfnob

i would argue that if a person gets hurt by an animal it is ALWAYS the persons fault. in a class settings it is not 100% on the student as the teacher is still teaching them how to be around the animals safely. is it cruel to pike someone in the shoulder to get their attention? also you have to remember Grop is a "person" so how Hagrid treats him is not likely how he treats animals. if that is good or bad we do not know. i know i treat animals better then i do people. is it racist to call an elf and elf? that is just stating a fact. some of the party involved are racist because they thing the others are lesser because of their race, but that is not the same thing. The same as people being racist does not make the institution racist. you said it yourself the forest does not belong to anyone. so it is as much Grop's as the centaurs. It is neither of theirs

VEGGIE GAMER

Sorry Garfnob - I honestly don't understand this message. Please check over the spelling as I am guessing you mean 'Racist' rather than 'Resist'. I sadly won't get get notification, unless you delete and do it again, but I was a bit baffled by what you were trying to say here. I would say it is cruel to jab someone that you expect to be respectful and not instantly grab and kill someone you want to look after them, but I could be wrong. Maybe I am resisting something!

VEGGIE GAMER

Oh actually I would see a reply in my notifications, sorry!! But it may not be as clear! I will still try to get to it! :)

Madikuma95

I'm curious about Fry's version of the "Weasley is Our King" song, because I never found Dale's version grating or annoying.

jolt45

Hey Veggie! I'm sorry about the long comment! I did say it was around ~900 words and that I could cut it down to 600 but you said I should send the whole thing... I know it was exhausting to read but I appreciate you giving me the time to get my thoughts out about Quidditch!

Garfnob

Sorry about the spelling. I know it is atrocious. I try to use spell check, but when I us a word that is just not the correct one spell check does not help. OP. updated. I hope sufficiently.

Garfnob

regarding the quidditch cup. i always understood the record is what mattered and the points were to break ties. admittedly with so few games ties must be common. the snitch is already stated to be almost impossible to see, so making them different would not matter. having two is interesting. do not worry. the Vikings will chock, they always do.

John Phillips

There's nothing wrong with reviewing Harry Potter.

VEGGIE GAMER

please don't apologise for the length of hte comment! I remembered when reading it I agreed to it and it was amazing to hear your fixes! :)

Inseriousity

Worst chapter might be pushing it but I'm inclined to agree that it's a really weak chapter. I read this book when I was 11 so that may also have something to do with it but this chapter is a scene-setter. It's not all that interesting on its own and is clearly just used to introduce some pieces for future chapters which I will avoid going into here. For context, for my entire childhood, I skipped chapter 1 of Goblet of Fire any time I re-read the books (which was a lot) because I thought it was boring and I just wanted to get straight to Harry. I later came to appreciate how it was setting future things up from a different perspective. I suppose I'm saying in a really long winded way that I can understand why people think this is a poor chapter but also that kids are dumb so that may have something to do with it as well.

Noni

Don’t forget to post the next book club chapter.