Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Harry Potter Poll! - What Book Scene Would You Have MOST Wanted To See In The Movie? (Patreon)

Published:
2022-11-14 21:21:33
Imported:
2026-08
Tags:

Poll

Harry Potter Poll! - What Book Scene Would You Have MOST Wanted To See In The Movie?

  • Arthur vs Lucius's Battle of the Book Store! 38
  • Sir Nicholas' 500th Death Day! 49
  • Hermione Learning from Ron what Mudblood means! 82
  • A More 'Book Accurate' Duelling Club scene! 16
  • Lockharte's Valentines Spectacular! 47
  • Other (Please Comment below!) 7
  • 2022-11-14
  • 239 votes
{'title': 'Harry Potter Poll! - What Book Scene Would You Have MOST Wanted To See In The Movie?', 'choices': [{'text': "Arthur vs Lucius's Battle of the Book Store!", 'votes': 38}, {'text': "Sir Nicholas' 500th Death Day!", 'votes': 49}, {'text': 'Hermione Learning from Ron what Mudblood means!', 'votes': 82}, {'text': "A More 'Book Accurate' Duelling Club scene!", 'votes': 16}, {'text': "Lockharte's Valentines Spectacular!", 'votes': 47}, {'text': 'Other (Please Comment below!)', 'votes': 7}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2022, 11, 14, 21, 11, 31, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 239}

Content

Hi guys! The finally Chamber of Secrets Book Review should be out this week! So sorry for the wait!

I thought it may be cool to run a poll about the changes the Movie made to the Book, and which you would most love to seen on the big screen!

I have chosen the 5 most obvious that came to my mind, but please suggest your own in the comments below!

Love you guys! Hope you have a great week! I'll cover this poll in the Book Review, so please vote and comment soon!!

Comments

Elaine

Harry and Cho's date at miss Puddifoots

Garry (Not Jerry)

I’m afraid it’s got to be the death day scene. Not because it was the most important to the story, but because it would have been cool to see. The Percy/Penelope reveal would have been a good one too! And the De-Gnoming!

Josh Z

Hey veggie I recommend increasing the number of chapters you cover from three to four going forward as all remaining books are a decent bit longer than the first two on average. Just a thought. Love the reviews regardless.

Brittanee Collins

The fact the mudblood scene is included but inaccurate just rubs salt in the wound. A simple things that would gave Ron more characters depth instead of the comedic sidekick they made him to be

Maxwell Long

Tbh the first two movies aren't missing *all that much* as the books are so short, relatively

Xeph

Once you get to around book 4 polls like this won't be possible anymore

VeggieGamer

Hopefully we can include some kind of other polls for book 4 onward! I do hear that is where the BIG changes start rolling in on the movies!

S1lm4r1l

There's gonna be sidequests and sideplots you're gonna absolutely love.

Jake M

I chose the duelling club because I think how it's done in the film doesn't give Hermione the opportunity to get Milicent Bulstrode's cat hair, she just randomly has it ready without any satisfying explanation. A lot of the other things were sort of comic relief, but this was actually quite a key plot point they missed.

RavenLord

I didn't like that the movie depicted Hermione as not only knowing what a mudblood was but also being so upset about it. It was nice in the book that there was actually information she didn't already know, and finding out, she didn't make a big deal of it. It didn't have the emotional impact on her in the book as it did in the movie, and I just thought it was overdone in the film, her reaction. It meant Draco in the movie drew blood (figuratively speaking) and hurt her; he got the satisfaction of seeing the look on her face. If any of that made sense; I wrote a bit convoluted there, LOL.

Kristin Carter

I wish we had seen when Ginny sent Harry that valentine's day "Cupid" 🤣🤣

Michelle747

Harry spending the last month of his summer with the Weasley’s. Or the Mrs. Mason freaking out about birds after an owl was sent to say no magic. Or how all Harry ate for a days was tomato in a tin for punishment.

Garry (Not Jerry)

Have you done the math on this? He’s averaging around 1 book review a month. 198 chapters total. 3 chapters per review. It will take 5.5 years. With four chapters per review, a little over 4 years.

Garry (Not Jerry)

(To be clear this is not a complaint 😂 im excited)

Josh Z

I hadn't done the math but I see it is hardly justifiable given he's doing a lot more than just the book reviews 😂

Annamarie schwirian

Same , I think the little parts with Ginny were so important to there relationships in the final 2 books

Kristin Carter

Definitely, people thought their relationship came out of nowhere in the movies because they cut out everything leading up to it

Mio

Chose the duelling club because I don't think the movies ever gives context to what different spells do and how much Harry knows or doesn't know during his school years. A more accurate duelling club scene could have provided som much needed information.

Dara Jeeling

the valentines special - BECAUSE it would have been hilarious! and there was me - like "all the missing stuff from the Half Blood Prince" and I am sure you figure out what I mean by this once we reach the book!

Bjørge

the whole thing with gilderoy teaching harry to be famous would could be nice in the movie

Ashley Faith Reacts

I wouldn't still be so pissed about the mudblood scene if they had included a Deathday extravaganza!!!