Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

YEP!... We broke the 5 hour mark! XD  These chapters were excellent though, so we had a lot to discuss!  Just a couple of notes - I get a little silly in the 3rd chapter here regarding the Firebolt giving Gryffindor an advantage, sorry if I go a little over the top! XD

Brilliant discussion regarding Hermione in this one, with may different views and opinions!  We go on a couple of tangents here or there, but I hope they aren't too annoying!

Oh!  And we discuss at the start the possibility trying out a 2 chapter episode in the future.  Please let me know your thoughts on this (it will mean more regular, but shorter videos).  I am happy to do it whatever way works best for you guys!

Have a wonderful weekend, guys! Love you!

Files

Movie Watcher Reads Harry Potter For the First Time! - Prisoner of Azkaban Chapters 11, 12 & 13!

Check out the Patreon for the Full Length Movie reactions (you will need your own copy of the movie remember), and some other early access stuff coming soon! There is no minium Pay amount, so pay as little as you like! :) - https://www.patreon.com/VeggieGamer My Mail Box is Now OPEN! Find the Address and other info here! - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G362I7JPgWY Come join the official Veggie Discord server! :) - https://discord.gg/mw36C7d GET YOUR VEGGIE MERCHANDISE HERE! - https://www.redbubble.com/people/VeggieGamer GO GIVE ME A FOLLOW OVER AT TWITCH TO BE A PART OF THE FUN! - https://www.twitch.tv/veggie_gamer GET 15% OFF YOUR E-WIN RACING CHAIR BY USING PROMOTION CODE : Veggie US store: http://www.ewinracing.com/ European store: https://www.ewinracing.eu/ CCs used in my Sims 4 series can now be found here! - https://docs.google.com/document/d/1b2u8qVdJ0KAjbtG2ZPHv-DjIs2Ds4xUrtHTiKEVPahA/edit?usp=sharing CHECK ME OUT ON INSTAGRAM & TWITTER! - Veggie_Gamer CAN WE GET THIS VIDEO TO 100 LIKES, VEGGIEKNIGHTS?? If you can spare anything, Patreon (NO pressure): Want to see more of this? Give the video a thumbs up and let me know in the comments :) Hit me up on the following websites! Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheVeggieGamer/ Twitter: https://twitter.com/Veggie_Gamer Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/VeggieGamer Be sure to Follow me on Roblox (I can not accept Friend Requests) - https://www.roblox.com/users/135078748/profile End Card music - Artist: UnderwaterBeats Track: Evolution Licence:https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0

Comments

RhiLou32

I'm honestly just impressed at your ability to talk for as long as you do! FIVE HOURS?? 😂

Jake M

The Hobbits the Hobbits the Hobbits the Hobbits to Isengaard to Isengaard...ahem, I mean, yay 😁

Marc Post Jr

I was JUST thinking about this and here it is <3

Lydia57

Perfect timing ⏱️ starting a long day of work. This will help the time go by quicker 😊

rreowenn

I think the two chapter idea is really good, means you get to keep more of your day to yourself when you have to record and means we get more frequent uploads. Also it means there's less to discuss in each "episode" so the discussion can be more in depth!

rreowenn

Oh also, I think there were only three other students at christmas because of the murderer on the run, so parents wanted their children safe at home.

Jacqueline Chaiton

I don't mind the longer episodes personally, but I regularly listen to Hardcore History by Dan Carlin so I'm probably not the best judge of that, lol. But I treat these videos the same way I do his episodes, like an audiobook where I pause and come back to it when needed. Also, I keep forgetting to ask this, but do you think Malfoy is so actively trying to ruin Hagrid because of how Hagrid treated him during the detention in Stone? He is 100% petty enough for that. Oh also it was Steve Kloves, the screenwriter, who loved Hermione.

John Phillips

I'm noticing that you really have it out for Gryffindor in the Quidditch chapters. It's not a big deal that they win and I think you're letting your bias affect your judgment. I'm getting the impression that you are not only biased in favor of Hufflepuff, but also biased against Gryffindor. I sincerely hope that you don't let it get to you in the later books.

VEGGIE GAMER

Hi John! I am so sorry about this! I don't know if you have got to the Book Club part yet, but I read your comment there and apologise! I know I am being really bias against Gryffindor and I will try my best to stop that. I am aware some of the things I say are unfair and that probably clouds the reviews a bit!

rreowenn

And you don't come across as being nasty about the quidditch! The wizarding world and especially quidditch is extremely prejudiced, which is explored throughout the books. Similarly to the muggle world, you have to have money and power to achieve in it. I guess gobstones or maybe wizards chess is what you would do instead if you couldn't afford a broom.

Garry (Not Jerry)

To be clear I don’t think mcgonagall actually *bought* the nimbus 2000 for Harry, she just made “arrangements” for him to get it. He wasn’t allowed one as he was a first year, so they had to make special arrangements so I assume she ordered it using some kind of school fund. Mcgonagall is absolutely 100% taking the piss by asking trelawney if she wants “tripe”. 😄

Jacqueline Chaiton

Agreed, but I think they probably took the money from Harry's vault for the Nimbus.

Gothic Llama

I think it's a great idea to cover 2 chapters in the Book Club episodes instead of 3. We could have more extensive discussions about them, as it's already hard to try and not write a very long comment about three chapters - with only two to cover, it would be easier. Anyway, it was nice listening to this one and hearing your thoughts as always.

Ziro the Hutt

I take some issue with the analysis of the Lupin and Snape Bogart stuff. I get what you are saying Veggie, but you are looking at this in hindsight now, when you were fine with it in the moment until it was brought up. Now its fine to then analyse after and hearing the back and forth on the comments, its interesting hearing all sides. However, for me, nothing is going to change the relationship Snape and Lupin have - and we'll get into that another time as the James's gang with Lupin and Sirius is brought up - so if he thinks the greater thing to do is help Neville in that situation, over a bit of humiliation for Snape; so be it. Both are adults and Snape is an experienced teacher. Let me make myself clear, its not nice for Snape, and perhaps Neville to go through some stuff later as a consequence of it; but if Snape can't handle a bit of brief needling and humiliation from kids as a teacher, he has no business teaching. And for Neville, as painful as any abuse or bullying that may arise out of this is; its just one of those things that will happen at a school. When we were at school we had good times and bad; but its these experiences that help form the people we will become. Its life, nobody is perfect. I think you should give the two chapter setup a try Veggie. I'm fine with the longer vids, but it was noticable last time you were tiring and getting things mixed up understandably. Plus at this rate you are releasing one vid a month, so if you could do two chapters a fortnight - or thereabouts - and be fresher by the end of them; then go for it. This is only book three as well, and most of the others are double the size of this book, so perhaps a change of system would be more beneficial. Good point about the similarities between Neville and Pettigrew though Veggie, both are kind of hangers-on, but Neville eventually grows out of that and becomes a true Gryffindor hero and does his family proud; whilst Peter remains a sycophant who clings to power, and through his cowardly actions, betrays his friends and becomes a serf for Voldemort. Ron and Harry are prone to blow up in paroxysms of emotion at times in the books, and while I can understand how they feel as the Firebolt is confiscated; Hermione, for as much as it will pain them, is absolutely right to have the broom tested. She knows the fury that will rain down on her from the boys about it, but is looking out for Harry. She is showing her Gryffindor colours here as she knows she is going against her friends, but its the right thing to do, and as Dumbledore said in the first film, sometimes standing up to your friends takes copious bravery. People say the movies do a disservice to Ron, but I always reply that he is no saint in the books, and at times, like he is here, he can be a right dick.

Rebecca May

Just a quick thing... I do want to point out that in the film, you do hear Lily screaming on both occasions when Harry falls unconscious in the presence of a Dementor (or a Boggart pretending to be one). If you listen closely, she's screaming, "Harry!", and Harry himself specifies (first in the train carriage and then on the bridge speaking to Lupin) that he is hearing his mother screaming. .... That being said, I don't blame you in the slightest for thinking it's the train's whistle, because it's always pissed me off how much Lily's scream sounds like a train whistle in that film. It's so annoying. Possibly not helped by the fact that I think it was a deliberate artistic choice in the first instance to blend the train whistle with the scream, to turn it into a "cool" transition. It may also have been intended to make it less scary for the younger members of the audience, I guess. Also, I personally really enjoy the long videos, but I really wouldn't mind either way. I think all things considered it may be worth trying the two chapter format for a while, it's a really good idea. Honestly just do what makes you happy - if it turns out you preferred making the three-chapter videos, you can always switch back! :)

Melanie P

I actually agree with what a professional teacher should do in the boggart/Snape scene. I don’t think there’s any professionalism in Hogwarts. I love this series and I love to see the discussion. I also found the boggart exposing every students’ biggest fear a bit of a route for bullying and cruel practical jokes. If it was a more private style lesson, the boggart is a wonderful way to face your greatest fears and capture your courage. I love the detail of discussion in this series you’re doing.

John Phillips

Okay. On a note unrelated to Quidditch, this isn't a spoiler so hear me out, I know you mentioned that Ginny is not in this book as much as the previous book. I think another comment in a different video mentioned that she becomes a minor character for sometime. Again, I'm not spoiling anything, but you start seeing a lot more of her in Order of the Phoenix. She is one of my favorite characters and I like all of her moments.

Giorgia M

I pretty much agree about Lupin’s professionalism. I think the concept of Hogwarts and the parameters of the story within that require you to sort of suspend your disbelief of a lot of things allowed to happen there and the teachers behaviour a lot of time would not make sense real world. I more so go off of intention but consequences of those intentions also matter. Lupin should not have let Neville make a teacher ridiculous, not only for Snape but for Nevilles sake, there is a duty of care we don’t want to escalate an already hostile relationship between Snape and Neville. But I don’t think his intention was to humiliate Snape but more to allow Neville space to stand up for himself in a way which I can forgive more easily. As for Hermione, I was a bit hard on her but it’s only because I get annoyed at the moral superiority of Hermione rather than in this specific incident and her close mindedness to others opinions in general. It’s more of a culmination of events that peak at the firebolt scene. While I think protecting her friends was the most important thing, I would’ve been happier if she tried to reason with Harry and then proceeded to make that choice if he wouldn’t listen but I still understand it. A lot of the things that have created this opinion of Hermione come later so I’ll say no more. She’s still one of my favs and I see a lot of myself in her, that’s probably why I find her so annoying at times lol. Also, I’d just like to say that the boys treatment of Hermione after is horrible and I feel so sad for her. I think that behaviour is worse than the firebolt situation alone but I don’t think that’s the only thing that is causing friction between Hermione, Harry and Ron at that time. Overall, it’s more that I critique Hermione more harshly because she acts like she knows best a lot so I’m always analysing her decisions whereas I have a lower standards for the boys because they very clearly don’t know best :)) it’s probably because Hermione is more mature so I treat her like an adult when she is still just a child like the others.

Hawwah

Hi Veggie, this was a very interesting episode! Lots of food for thought! You came up with some points I haven't considered before and I've been reading and re-reading this series for years. You're right - all Harry's incoming post should have been checked for possible curses. Given the strict security measures at Hogwarts, it seems strange that this was overlooked. How come people barely mentioned Neville? I think it's safe to say it's because they are saving it for the next Book Club. And I honestly believe it has the potential to be just as controversial as the toad incident. That's all I'll say about it to avoid spoilers. I agree with the people who suggested to cover just two chapters per episode. Maybe you could create a poll about it? I loved loved LOVED the segment when you talked about Harry having a such a better broom than everyone else. I absolutely agree with you - it's simply not fair. TBH, I actually thought about going on a little rant about it in my own comment, but I decided against it in the end because I was afraid it might be perceived as too confrontational. But you said everything that was on my mind, so thank you for that! There's a double standard regarding Harry for sure. When the Slytherins have better equipment than everyone else, they are considered cheaters, but when Harry does the same thing, we're supposed to root for him. Regarding the deleted scene with sir Cadogan. The huge spoiler I warned you about was Sirius Black's second attack in chapter 13. Chapter 14 deals with its aftermath, so I think you should finish listening to it before reacting to the scene. But it's ultimately up to you, of course.

Rod

Have a nice day. And I just LOVE your expression when you realized what my comment was about. That's how I felt when I read the book. My first reaction was "wait, what?"

Hawwah

Surely McGonagall can't just take money from one of her student's vault without his knowledge? Gringotts would be a horrible bank if that was the case.

Wayne Joy

I always took it as either the funds came out of Harry's trust account for which Dumbledore would probably be a trustee for (Hagrid did somehow have Harry's vault key in Philosopher's Stone), or McGonagall used some Gryffindor house discretionary fund.

itsanursething

Fun fact! What you experienced as a child, and your example of throwing someone who is afraid of spiders into a room full of spiders (or something similar) IS indeed a technique to overcome phobias. It's called flooding. But it's not used much anymore...ethical reasons as you can imagine.

Katik

Just to clarify the Quidditch tournament rules at Hogwarts - it's simply each team playing against each other once. There's no Final as such, when there is a game referred to as a final it simply means the last (the final) game of the season for those two teams. Given that there is only 4 teams and only playing each other once (so only 6 games), the last two games will most likely determine the final standing. There's no knock-out! When Snape says that Gryffindor will be out of the running he simply means they already lost one match, and if they lose another one, they have no chance to win the cup even if they win the last one - so "out of the running" simply means "will have no chance to win the cup". There's no question of not getting into the final as that is not how it works.

Dara Jeeling

I am fine with two chapters for the book club, since the books (and I sometimes think the chapters, too) get longer (and more complicated) also... there will be more "controversial" things in the following books - I dare say! Have a nice weekend!

Janne (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-20 18:00 I haven’t finished the video so I’m sorry if it’s discussed further, but Harry having the Firebolt doesn’t mean he’s better than anyone else, just faster. If he had no talent (being a good flyer and able to find and keep track of the snitch plus the hand eye coordination to actually catch it), then he would be a useless player even on the firebolt. It’s mentioned before about how good of a player he is, even better than Charlie, so it doesn’t really matter what he flies. I believe all the talk surrounding the match and Ravenclaw having no chance really is just team confidence boosting and excitement over their team having the greatest broom in the world, since it’s so expensive and desirable, and not them saying it’s a guarantee
2023-03-11 12:05

Dara Jeeling

IF there is such athing, I wonder why it was not used on Rons wand in book 2... Same thing if it's school money...

Dara Jeeling

On the "broom" part.. I always thought it to be unfair as well - BUT... Malfoy senior bought the best brroms for the whole team Harry got a gift from his godfather (after he missed like 12/13 birthdays) I also see Quidditch a bit like all sport in Rl where equipmet plays a part in winning - like Formula 1/Car driving competitions - something like Biathlon (winter sports) IF your ski is prepared better (or you have an allowed new ski that works better) you stand a higher chance at winning, IF you are good. It's not a though Harry is bad at Quidditch - but now he also has the better equipment. To make it even, the school would have to provide "good" brooms for everyone, so that all the students are on a same footing, equipment wise. So yeah - I still think it unfair and yes, there are double standarts for Harry!

Dara Jeeling

I agree with you! It's something different to buy brooms for a whole team - or one student getting a gift. I also agree on the talent part! And tbh it's as that in RL - in any sports that works with equipment. If someone has a new/better equipment they CAN beat the others but are not bound to. I always thought it's rather "unfair" not to have decent schoolbrooms that will be used for Quidditch matches/teams so no "I get a new broom every year" thing. The school provides the equipment and any outdated ones could eb used for flying lessons. I mean there are brooms for flying lessons..

John Phillips

That's true. In the final Quidditch match of this book, it was still a very close game despite Harry having the firebolt.

Hawwah

I think we're on the same page. Of course Harry is good at Quidditch, I never doubted that. But we are told that Cho is also very good - Oliver Wood hoped she wouldn't be able to play, which suggests he considers her a real competition to Harry - but she has a so much worse broom. Who knows how the match would have looked like if Cho had had a Firebolt too.

Rhea H Pelotto

Dearest Veggie,  I have followed your book reviews from the very beginning yet I have been waiting and waiting and waiting  to comment until you get to a specific part of this VERY BOOK and you are ALMOST THERE but, you just  mentioned something  that I absolutely can not let pass up!!!!!!!  Your reviews reach  far and wide.... so you might find it interesting to know you have an unashamed, possibly just a little biased 😉, extremely loyal, LIFE LONG NEW ORLEANS SAINTS FAN watching every single minute of your reviews lol. In fact, the pic I use on  my profile is me heading into a Saints game in the Superdome!!   Small world, huh?? No need to discuss or think about the call you referenced any farther as it has scarred me forever 😫😫😫😫 Anyway Vegg, like I said you will be seeing my name pop up in the future. And even tho this comment isnt specifically "Potter related" I wont pass up the opportunity to say thank you, thank you, THANK YOU  for all the hard work and effort you do to give these reviews to the GLOBAL PotterHead community!! I've been wishing for something like this for literally YEARS and you are truly going above and beyond my highest expectations on what it could be!! I'm so freakin excited to continue your Potter journey with you!! You are AWESOME,  despite being a Rams fan lol j/k , j/k 😉😉.... now, back to the review  

Thunderbird

Have a nice day! 😄 I’m glad you like Oliver Wood in these chapters and find him funny. I like his character very much in these first three books. To understand him a bit more (that he is not just absolutely careless) I have to mention that Quidditch is his absolute passion leading him to become a professional quidditch player for Puddlemore United (though "only" as a reserve player) after his time at Hogwarts. Also I am definitely down for doing two chapters per book club. I think this would be in your and our favor. But if you are more comfortable doing three chapters at a time then that is also perfectly fine. Do what you feel is best. 😊

Inseriousity

I did think when you started that doing 3 chapters might result in super long reviews, these books really do get deeper and divert much more from the movie versions so lots to talk about. If I had one tiny suggestion about it that you can take or leave as you wish, maybe do 2 chapters but bump it up to 3 if Max thinks that the chapters youre doing end more neatly with an additional chapter. Can't really think of a non-spoilery example so hope I've explained this properly but just a thought to consider :)

Giorgia M

Sorry just wanted to add quickly. While the book is from Harry’s perspective, it is still third person so Harry is not the narrator, therefore, we can hear his thoughts only but that doesn’t completely skew the narration of what is going on in Harry’s environment. This is part of the reason for the “Hermione could be seen in the common room” or whatever, as that is the narrator talking so it sounds quite cold. Harry himself can be bias but the narrator isn’t really as they aren’t part of the story.

Janie

Have a nice day Veggie! :) I don't really care whether you do 3 or 2 chapters, I'm really fine with longer videos, I don't usually watch it all in one go anyway. But my suggestion would be doing 2 chapters for longer chapters and 3 when they're shorter. You can finish this book with 3 chapters but the chapters in the next books are going to be much longer so then you could do just 2 (I hope that makes sense). But eitherway I'll still watch your videos no matter how long they are :)

RhiLou32

Hey Veggie, finally got around to finishing this video! I left a comment on youtube explaining something, but I just wanted to go into a bit more detail here: The discussion around the Firebolt being a "cheat code", and Quidditch being "pay-to-win" is an interesting one, but I definitely think a lot of your views on it are to do with the differences between the movie (getting the Firebolt at the end of the year) vs the book (getting the Firebolt mid-season). Harry is a fantastic Quidditch player, that much has already been established in the last two and a half books. And he always had a better broom than 95% of the other Quidditch players at Hogwarts (the Nimbus 2000 was brand new in his first year, and only in his second year did anyone have a better broom, after Lucius Malfoy bought Nimbus 2001s for all the Slytherins). But having a better broom doesn't always mean you're going to be better than everyone else. The Slytherins lost to Gryffindor in CoS, despite having better brooms than the entire Gryffindor team, AND Snape giving them the Quidditch pitch to practice when Gryffindor should have been there. A bad player on a great broom is never going to outperform a great player on a bad broom. Charlie Weasley has been described as a fantastic player, and we know the Weasley family don't have much money. Fred and George too, for that matter. Sure, Harry is a great player, and now has a great broom....but he had a great broom from the start. As for your biases towards Hufflepuff, I find them highly amusing. One of Hufflepuff's main traits is supposed to be loyalty, so you definitely fit that one!

Annette Elliott

On the bogart & Neville. I think Lupin was trying to shore Neville up after Snape was so nasty about Neville. Postponing it would have undermined Neville further and Snape still would have reacted the same no matter when it happened. Also the kids have to learn how to deal with them. If not at school then when?

Sam-I-Am

After Snape put Neville down, if Lupin had turned him away or said he couldn't face the boggart that would have been harmful to Neville's confidence and sense of worth. I do empathize with Snape being made fun of because of the boggart situation, but he's an adult and a professor. He shouldn't let it bother him so much to the point where he's lashing out on others, especially students, because of it.

Kunzite Blossom

I never did think about the fact everyone believes Sirius is the reason the Potters are dead...and that he is most likely after Harry. Why wasn't Harry's mail being checked? Though in this situation. I can understand why Harry and Ron are mad at Hermione, I mean they are two teenage boys, one of who just got the best broom. That's almost like getting the best car out there after getting your license. Clearly they would be upset over having it taken away in just a few hours. Though I know Hermione does it out of Harry's best interest and safety. I believe the reason Lupin gives Harry chocolate is because its said (I believe) that even though its a bogart, its affect is the same as if it was a real dementor. This is why Harry is still capable of passing out, which would be why he still needs chocolate.

Diego Zenhäusern

I've only wartched the intro, so here goes: I'd be in favor of the chapter system for future reviews. I mean I love the revies but 5 hours really is quite long🙈 and I think it would definitely also be easier for you if it was 2 instead of 3 chapters. Also: Really enjoyed your opinion on Lupin at the beginning. I used to defend Lupins decision by saying that it would have destroyed all of Neville's confidence if he'd just chosen someone else after hearing his fear. And I kinda still do (because Neville really needed some confidence)🤔. But I definitely agree that it wasn't the professional response...and that teaching the Boggart leson in this way probably isn't professional in the frst place (I think it should probably be a thing were only one person is in the room or soomething like that).

Emma Servi

Just a little think when dean offered to forge uncle vernons signature I don’t think he was gonna use a spell he was literally just gonna sign Harry’s permission slip and seeing as we’ve never heard of them needing to sign anything prior to this it wouldn’t need to be accurate because they wouldn’t know what his signature looked like. Also as someone else put I think the quidditch tournament is just you play each team once, the only thing I can think to compare it to is the rugby six nations you play each team once and then based on wins loses and point difference one team comes out victorious so if there are two teams that have the same stats, they’ve won all their games but one it’ll come down to the amount by which they won or lost those games to decide who wins the tournament.

S1lm4r1l

The first book makes plain that Harry does not get sent mail, so therefore, nobody needs to check it because he doesn't receive any. Christmas is probably the first time this year that Harry gets mail. We have no idea whether Harry's mail is getting scanned at all. Maybe it is and Harry just doesn't know about it? Interestingly enough though, this point does come up in future books on a number of occasions. I think Hermione is 'wrong', but perhaps not in the way you might think. Hermione has no proof that Black has sent the broomstick, has no proof that anything is wrong with it at all. In the next chapter, Ron drags his bedcovers downstairs, waves them bloody and cat-hair covered in Hermione's face and accuses Crookshanks of eating Scabbers. In this instance, Hermione takes the complete opposite view, that Ron has no proof of wrongdoing, that there's no proof Scabbers is dead. When Harry makes the point Hermione makes about Harry's broomstick to Hermione (that the evidence seems to point in that direction,) she is offended that Harry sides with Ron. If Hermione was not determined to be on Crookshanks side, I think she absolutely would be arguing that Crookshanks had eaten Scabbers. Arguably, far more evidence exists for Crookshanks having eaten Scabbers, than there is for Sirius Black sending the Firebolt.

Hawwah

You're right, Snape should have praised Neville when Neville didn't follow instructions and put the whole class in danger for the millionth time. Heavens forbid Neville faces any consequences for his own actions!

Frederique Gillespie

Hiya Veggie! Thanks again for the awesome content! I personally have no preference between two or three chapters per instalment. Since you’re doing the commentating, editing and posting, my honest preference would be to have you choose whatever’s easier for you. I’ve read these books so often that I’m now reading them in Spanish to try and revive my notions of that language. That’s not a humble-brag. I’m just to illustrate just how much you’ve blown my mind with your super insightful thoughts on why the Boggart-Dementor affects Harry as though it were a real Dementor. OMG. It’s so obviously what you said (the Boggart feed on your perception of fears), but I had never thought of it. And since our brains cannot tell the difference between an imagined pain/fear and a real one, it has the same impact... Neville should absolutely not be punished for losing the passwords. Punish Sir Cadogan for changing it so often poor Neville can’t keep up. Heck, station an adult, house-elf or all-too-willing Head Boy at the door to give Sir Cadogan the password as needed. But punishing Neville would be punishing someone for failing to complete an impossible task. As a now-adult reader, I can 1000% understand that Hermione did the right thing in going to McGonagall about the Firebolt. However, I do think there was a third option somewhere between leaving it to Harry and going behind his back. She could have given Harry an ultimatum. “Either you go, or I will.” At this point in the story, Harry may be all kinds of sassy and typical teenager, but part of that is that he really has no idea that he’s got much to contribute to society. He’s still not very far in time from the boy who didn’t believe he could possibly be a wizard and thought Hermione was much better at magic than him. His flying skills and playing Quidditch are the only things he feels confident about. Yes, he is obsessed with Quidditich in a way that makes him a very normal teenager, but Quidditch is also the first thing he’s ever been good at. Going behind his back to take the Firebolt away... She should have given him a head’s up. That’s all.

Frederique Gillespie

Honestly not sure what kind of "evidence" Hermione was looking for: Crookshanks munching on Scabbers? I mean, we know why there wasn't evidence, but still...

Ian Graham

Hermione was right about the fire bolt as it was sent by Sirius as she suspected

Kristen Campbell

Please continue to do 3 chapters. I don’t mind the long reviews. I enjoy hearing your view of things. I believe Harry’s mail wasn’t getting checked because Sirius is on the run and wouldn’t be able to get any kind of gift or cursed object for Harry. As you read on you’ll see how he was able to get the broom for Harry. I listen while I work so the length doesn’t bother me but do what’s best for you.

VEGGIE GAMER

NO WAY, RHEA! That is awesome! I was so close to choosing Saints as my team (I personally think the Rams and Saints have the best kits, which was basically the level I was going on when getting into the sport XD). The year I chose Rams was the year the Saints won the Superbowl and the Rams went 1-15! XD But I am always up for the underdogs!! So yes.. that call.. lets not discuss it! XD I really, really appreciate your kind words! This story has grabbed my imagination so much even though I have gotten into it so late!

itsanursething

Have a nice day (now that I've finally finished the video) One of the things that I love so much about these books is that no one is perfect. ALL of the characters are flawed, just like ALL humans are flawed. We all make mistakes, and I love that we see characters that we love making mistakes. We all can't make the right decision every time. I think that's something we need to remember as these videos go on, because a lot of people seem to be attacking the characters for making human mistakes (at least, that's how it comes across to me). Also, theses are teenagers! They're all going through changes and hormones and life is hard and confusing, and they're bound to be irrational and judgmental. Most teenagers are! Especially Hermione. Poor thing. I know she's not the most empathetic in these chapters, but she's exhausted and probably lonely, so I'm not surprised she bursts into tears so often! BTW Veggie, Hermione is a year older than the boys. Her birthday is in September, so for most of third year she's 14, while Harry and Ron are 13. Last thing, here's what the Harry Potter wiki has to say about boggarts: "though a Boggart who transformed into a magical being or object could replicate its abilities to an extent, this would be a weaker facsimile of the real thing; thus, a Boggart transformed into a Dementor had weaker magic than a real Dementor (according to Professor Lupin, who exploited this effect to simulate a Dementor attack in Harry's presence to help him perfect the use of the Patronus Charm at no serious risk to Harry Potter's soul)." I had to look it up because it just made no sense to me! Loved your thoughts about it too! I'm excited about your posts no matter how you decide to do them. Two chapters, three, maybe even just one if there's a particularly loooong chapter. Do what you need to Veggie. You'll have loyal listeners no matter what :)

Saiyasha

Well, Cowdemort is now living rent free in my head for the rest of eternity

Saiyasha

I'm going to defend McGonnagal here a bit, becuause it is not a professional setting. At the first Christmas Dinner we hear about her getting Tipsy and Hagrid giving her a kiss on the cheek, I would say that this dinner does fall outside of proffesional. You can't excpect the teacher to never let loose. if anything, it is kind of Dumbledores fault for putting students and teachers on the same table, then again, with so few people it would not have mattered

Michelle Linardis

Two chapters would be far more easily for you to fly through, as we progress through the books, the plots and chapters get bigger and far more complicated. Thank you for another wonderful video!

Saiyasha

You are confusing Lee Jordan and Dean Thomas. Dean is in Harrys Year, lee is in the twins. We actually meet him the very first time in the first book on the trainplatform, where he has brought some kind of Tarantula and the Twins go to see

Saiyasha

Lupin is shaken because Harry produced a full Patronus and you know which form it takes. It's pretty much like seeing his best friends ghost

H

Have a nice day! A lot of great discussion here, Veggie! So many interesting things about Hermione! Many ways of seeing it, many great explanations for why she acted like she did (completely understandable, imo, so I agree with you). I think the skill element of flying the brooms make sure that it's not just about having a fast broom, so I think it's not as black&white as you describe it in this video, but it's still quite unfair, of course! Regarding the quidditch "final", it's probably just a handy term because JKR isn't that interested in sports, and therefore not that good at describing table situations etc. It's just meant as a way of describing the match that will decide the outcome of the season, I'd say. Oh, and I was one of them who mentioned the fact that two chapters at a time could mean a book club of the same length for each video anyway, and I have to say that you make a great point at the end there, so I completely get why you'll try to do that! Really looking forward to the next video, as always.

Luci Love

COW-de-MOO-rt 🤣🤣🤣 🐮 Mooments like these are why we love you all the more, Veggie!

Luci Love

I think the first one who leaves the table where thirteen are seated dies is an old superstition. I first encountered it in an Agatha Christie book aptly titled "Thirteen at Dinner" aka "Lord Edgware Dies" but I'm pretty sure it's much older than that even.

Mordimer

Trelawney for years predicts death of everyone around her, I'm not surprised McGonnagall is annoyed ;)

Mary

I love these long videos because I can either binge the whole thing or split them up! I’d say as the books go on though you might need to do 2 chapter reviews.. potentially even single chamber reviews for some of them but it’d be hard to figure that out until you’ve read them

Mary

With regards muggle studies I’m pretty sure Hermione is learning about Health and Safety. I always imagined her reading about lifting with the knees etc and saw it as a little funny tidbit added by JKR. Also asking ‘Why do muggles need electricity’ I never saw it as derogatory… don’t forget the wizard students don’t even know what electricity is or what it does at all. So I suppose an answer might be what they can use it for ie communication, cooking… things that the wizarding students take for granted with spells etc…

Regina

What I have often wondered here is: Did Hagrid actually know about what Sirius did? Because after the scene in the Pub I‘m on the side of he didn‘t. Hagrid seemed only then to realise what had happened especially in regards to meeting Sirius at the Potters‘ house when he went to get Harry. The fact that Hagrid only then thinks ‚well I‘m glad I didn’t listen to him then‘ and thinks about why Sirius would have given his motorbike away just like that… I really think that Hagrid didn’t actually know about that. Fudge even says that the details aren’t known by many. So I think Hagrid genuinely couldn’t have told Harry about Sirius. Otherwise, I don‘t think he‘d have put pictures of Sirius in Harry‘s photoalbum.

Insanityandbeyond

I think the chocolate is there as another potential red herring if we're looking for weird things to find the bad guy before the end of the plot, its a bit weirdly nice