Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

THIS PART OF THE BOOK CLUB IS NOW COMPLETE! THANK YOU ALL FOR TAKING PART AND SEE YOU NEXT TIME!!

HI GUYS!  WE ARE GOING TO TRY A 2 CHAPTER EPISODE OUT! DON'T WORRY, THIS DEFINITELY DOESN'T MEAN WE WILL NOT BE RETURNING TO 3, JUST WANTED TO SEE HOW IT WORKS OUT.  LIKE MENTIONED IN THE PREVIOUS EPISODE, THIS WILL MEAN MORE REGULAR EPISODES, SO WILL NOT SLOW OUR PROGRESS THROUGH THE BOOKS DOWN! :)

Here is a chance to get your comment read out in the next Book review video!

If you are reading along with the reviews, we are covering chapters "Snape's Grudge" and "The Quidditch Final"! So if you have any thoughts, opinions, comparisons or questions regarding these, please leave a comment below!

I do have to ask, try to keep them fairly short, like 4 or 5 sentences.  That way I can cover more when making the video.  Also try to keep them on subject and not referencing anything that we are yet to cover. Ideally, keep it to 1 comment each if you can (if you have more to say after commenting, you can edit it and add to it! :) ).  These are just rough guidelines rather than rules, I want to be able to fit in as many of you as possible! :)

NEW FEATURE!! - As some of you may want to make a comment, but not have it replied to by others, you can now Message me your thoughts on the chapters by DM'ing me on here.  If you do, please follow all the above rules, especially avoiding mentioning things in future chapters or books!  Oh and please start your DM message with "Book Club -"!

To anyone that does reply to comments below, please make sure you are being friendly and respectful!  A lot of tone and meaning can be lost in text, after all!  If you disagree with someone on something, keep it polite and remember the golden rule in life - Sometimes you have to just agree to disagree! :)

Thanks, guys!! :)

Files

Comments

Lisette C.

Just a quick comment :) Did you notice that Harry now has lost the map to Lupin without ever seeing Pettigrew's name on it?

Jake M

Poor Neville - banned for Hogsmeade indefinitely!? Not only this, but forced to wait outside his common room while a supposed mass murderer is on the loose? Talk about an irresponsible punishment. Feels like a throwaway comment from the author that we aren't meant to think about, but I can't help feeling sorry for Neville, who probably already feels awful for 'losing' the password list, and now has his weekend trips cancelled and trolls leering at him on a nightly basis to make things worse.

Annamarie schwirian

Can we please talk about the inappropriate comment professor cuckoo aka professor Trelawney made to Hermione. I mean yes it's basically true but it is never a teacher or professor place to mock or ridicule students. This upset me when reading the books beyond belief because book Hermione is the perfect representation of a female nerd. (Movie Hermione looks and smarts made her seem like a fictional character where the books made her realistic )

Annamarie schwirian

Plus the fact that hogsmead is where everyone dates in later books. I felt this made him less likely to be able to date in school.

Jake M

I think he must be allowed in later books? He appears in the Hog's Head for the first DA meeting... But then again, so does the underage Dennis Creevey so who knows 🤷‍♂️

Kunzite Blossom

Neville's punishment for the password list being stolen seems a bit harsh. No longer allowed to know the password and just has to sit and wait around to enter with another student. Given a supposed killer is on the loose, and has tried to get in the common room twice (succeeding once) it doesn't seem safe to just let a student sit out in the open. Also not allowing him on the Hogsmeade visits. This does come back to play later on so please remember this scene. I would love to see how you would view these punishments now vs later. Thoughts on Harry's protection before the match? I find it amazing how everyone is ready to protect Harry

Dara Jeeling

*evil cackle* Snapes Grudge - no it's NOT suspicious at all when Ron bursts into Snapes office (without knocking) and just yells "I gave that to Harry" - why the heck would he think Harry is in trouble - if he had not been in Hogsmeade? Also... am I the only one who thinks Snapes comment is hilarious? "your head is not allowed in Hogsmeade. No part of your body has permission to be in Hogsmeade." *still cracks me up* Not saying much towareds the Quidditch chapter. (well yeah Slytherin was playing nasty, again - sadly) Veggie - do what makes you feel the most comfortable! Thank you!

Will

We've reached one of my favorite parts in the book. The Marauders map trolling Snape. Which of the marauders insults was your favorite? Now I must confess, I've never liked Hagrid that much (controversial, I know), but I do respect him for scolding Harry and Ron about their fight with Hermione. And after all Hagrid says to them, Ron still doesn't listen. I find it unfair that Hermione needs to apologize to him about Scabbers but he doesn't apologize to her about every nasty thing he has said and done during their fight. But yeah, he's a teenager, so whatever. And I didn't even stay mad at him for long because I was already laughing at the comments he made during divination class. But then... I hated reading chapter 15. Because how unrealistic it would be that literally everyone is against Slytherin. Are you telling me that no Slytherin has friends in other houses. That's absolutely ridiculous. I wish they stopped antagonizing my house. (They won't) But that's all this salty Slytherin has for you today, have a good day Veggie!

Kattie Martin

I think it made perfect sense for Hagrid to chastise the boys over their treatment of Hermione. I’m not surprised that she’s upset but can’t feel like she can show it to them. All of this has reminded me of the time my nephew’s bird was attacked by the family cat. He was understandably upset (plus he’s very sensitive) and was saying that while he understood she wasn’t trying to be mean and it was in her nature to attack a bird he really didn’t want to see her at the moment. Having an 8 year old understand something that a 13 year old seems to struggle with is surprising but then, Ron never liked Crookshanks while my nephew did love the cat.

Rebecca May

I really admire Hermione in these chapters…She is taking on so much work, and Ron is relentlessly punishing her for (among other things) putting his and Harry’s safety above their friendship. She’s miserable, alone, stressed and exhausted, and she still finds time to put others before herself and help Hagrid with Buckbeak’s case. If Ron hadn’t finally forgiven her and taken on some of the work himself, I’d have been so angry. One thing I’m sure Hermione and Snape would agree on is how unbelievably frustrating it is trying to keep someone as stubborn and reckless as Harry safe. Say what you will about Snape, he certainly had the measure of Harry when he said: “You have a habit of turning up in unexpected places, Potter, and you are rarely there for no reason.” Ain’t that the truth. I also find it very interesting that the film gave Snape’s line about James “never setting much store by the rules either” to Lupin… I’ve often felt that in many ways, Snape and Lupin are two sides of the same coin. I’m really looking forward to hearing any thoughts or theories you may have about the incident between Snape, James and his friends that very nearly cost Snape his life. I won’t say any more about it myself for now, but even from the few clues we get in these chapters, it’s no wonder that Snape is so angry around Lupin, particularly during the scene in Snape's office. P.S. Thank you for making these videos, Veggie, they’re something to look forward to and always make my day so much brighter. 😊

S1lm4r1l

I can appreciate the circumstances and pressures Snape is under. But his mischaracterisation of James to Harry has always rankled me. It is possible Snape simply mis-remembers rather than engaging in outright deception but other characters remember this incident very differently. Notice too, the difference in approach between Snape and Lupin when it comes to breaking the rules. Snape uses insults and threats whilst Lupin effectively guilt-trips Harry over his parent's deaths. Which do you think is more effective? I understand your criticisms of Quidditch and the Firebolt, however, let me share some thoughts. Firstly, Harry is given the Firebolt, he doesn't buy it himself. Hardly pay-to-win. Secondly, a good broom can help you but skills as a player are still important. You couldn't stick Neville on the Firebolt and watch Gryffindor sweep the Cup. Thirdly, Malfoy's father has more than enough money to afford a Firebolt. The avenue is certainly open for him to get the equipment Harry has, even if that's not true for all the other players. Fourthly, even if you don't have a Firebolt, you can still out-think and out-play your opponents. Cho's blocking tactics are extremely effective at reducing Harry's broom advantage and Firebolts don't make you immune to Bludgers or collisions with other players. After reading these chapters are you seriously telling me you'd prefer Malfoy to win because he has a slightly slower broom than Harry? =) (Might edit this later)

Rebecca May

While the delivery of Snape and Lupin's criticism is obviously vastly different (I'm not disputing that), both of their arguments essentially boil down to the same thing... That *everyone* - whether that be the Minister of Magic, the Hogwarts Professors, his friends, or Harry's own parents - has tried to protect him, and yet he seems incapable of following the rules and taking the threat of Sirius Black seriously.

S1lm4r1l

I think the lack of concern is intentional. I don't think Harry's desire for vengeance has changed at all since the 3 Broomsticks. In any case, all these rules, regulations, Dementors, trolls, teachers on heightened alert and it hasn't helped keep Harry safe at all. Black made it all the way into Harry's Dormitory remember. And Harry tried to run after him on that occasion. The only security measure that helped (ironically considering Veggie's criticisms of it) was the Fat Lady's passwords and Black found a way around that pretty quickly.

Briana

Hi Veggie! I’ve been watching since the beginning, but finally caught up so I can comment along :) It’s my first time listening to the audio books (Stephen Fry version), so it’s been cool to experience it differently. “Ron had become an instant celebrity. For the first time in his life, people were paying more attention to him than to Harry, and it was clear that Ron was rather enjoying the experience.” I think this is an interesting statement to keep in mind when thinking about Harry and Ron’s friendship, and how each of them handle the spotlight throughout the series. Thoughts? I’m sure there will be a discussion about Neville’s punishment, but I just wanna say, poor Neville being abandoned by Harry and left all alone :( I wonder what he ended up doing all day. Snape accuses Harry of not caring that so many people are concerned for his safety, but it finally sinks in when Lupin relates it to his parents. I think part of this is that Harry’s not used to having someone trying to keep him safe like a parent would, and the reminder of their sacrifice makes him feel guilty. I love the end of The Quidditch Final, the whole game is so exciting and builds the intensity to their win. It’s my second favorite quidditch moment in the series :) Also, I definitely agree that you should pay attention to any dreams or jokes that they make. They’re very interesting to see during a reread.

Collin Anderson

We finally meet pumpkin pasty, harry instantly has a crush on her. I love the line “don’t be a gentleman and knock her off the broom.” Wood would do anything to win this game. Neville not be able to get the password doesn’t makes sense to me, because once someone lets him in then he will know the password and then can get in by himself.

Hawwah

You're not the only one. I LOVE Snape's sarcasm, his biting remarks, his dry humor. I sincerely believe he's the wittiest character of the series. Fred and George could never.

John Phillips

At this point in the series, Snape's history with Harry's father is starting to get interesting. There's a lot of heated arguments about Snape vs. The Marauders and its gotten so bad that you're not even allowed to talk about it on Reddit (at least on the r/HarryPotter subreddit). Don't be surprised if a heated argument starts in the comment section of this book club. About the last Quidditch match, this was the most intense and brutal out of all of them so far. Harry's firebolt might be the fastest, but it was still a very close game regardless. In real life sports, there are a lot of players who have better equipment than the rest of the players on every team, so I don't think it's jarring that Harry was given a better broom than the rest of his team and everyone else's team.

Dara Jeeling

I get that! Being Slytherin myself. I still can not think that literally all Slytherins are evil/nasty. We only get to see the ones that are acting like what Rowling wanted them to act like. to be honest, that is one of the things about Hogwarts Legacy that I do not like. We get friend characters from all houses, BUT the one who has to teach you the unforgivables is the Slytherin. *sigh* WHY the heck could it not have been the Hufflepuff/Ravenclaw/Gryffindor? And the Slytherin could have been the one explaining about beasts or stars? o not get me wrong - I love the Slytherin quest line - but it would have been so much more fun if it had been another house. Also... Before there was even a way to be sorted I always wanted to be Slytherin - and then you always get to discuss why you want to be evil. It's not as though Slytherins house traits are "being evil" - they are ambition, resourcefulness, determination, and cleverness ( and whilst I am not ambitious per se, I am very determined and I tend to think I am very resourceful... Clever... not sure, if I am it's more a cleverness of the heart then the mind I guess). *Slytherin hug*

Dara Jeeling

I think by now we have figured out who is on which side in the book club and I for one just ignore comments of those who in my eyes have prooven not to be willing to peek past the obvious. I am a big Snape fan (and no I do not need any reminders of his faults, I see him as a "faulty" person - he is still my favorite in the books) and I have had my fair share of nasty / biased comments about that. BUT I usually try to see people standings when they ave different points of view. I also love the Marauders - even though I am not happy with them as youth s BUT it's such an intresteing group, how can you not love them? Also I think it is interesting to see how the "now a days students" could be Maruaders as well... Sort of... I mean Harry, Ron and Hermione... Ginny as the red headed love interest of the black haired boy.. Neville who tends to hang around Harry, Ron and Hermione (at that point) As said, I for myself decided not to comment to the users that I think are not willing to overthing their standpoint. I want to enjoy the book club not have the same arguments (mostly - Snape is a bully and ignoring everything else).

Preetam Ozarde

While you have a point that Hermione would be allowed to be frustrated at Harry, I think she understands him enough to know that being stubborn and reckless is a large part of why he is able to accomplish the things he does. If he wasn't stubborn and reckless, she probably knows that Voldemort would have come back year 1/year 2. That's the reason why we don't see her be frustrated at him much at all during the books, I think. On the other hand, Snape is another matter. First of all, he hasn't told Harry anything about his past or his vow to keep Harry safe. So tell me how exactly he expects to get through to Harry when all he's done for 3 years is treat him and his friends with hate and contempt? And while he's right about him turning up in unexpected places, he doesn't have the measure of Harry at all. He has all the wrong assumptions of why Harry is there most of time. I believe he has also grossly misunderstood both Harry's and James' characters by hiding behind his own insecurities. Obviously, they're not perfect people but then almost none of JKR's characters are. On a side note, I'm curious to know what exactly you're thoughts are on the Snape - Whomping Willow incident.

Josh Z

Veggie I have to defend Harry and the firebolt by saying that an exceptional broom does not guarantee a good Quidditch player, and honestly. besides Quidditch and DADA Harry is little more than slightly above average in terms of his academics. Your criticism of these Quidditch games compelled me to remind you Neville and Hermione can barely mount a broom let alone fly around on one. I bring this up because this Gryffindor team as a whole has something intangible that can't be bought or manufactured in chemistry. Trust me, come later books you will wish you appreciated the OG team a lot more.

Rebecca May

I didn’t actually say that Snape had Harry entirely figured out, or that he’s right in *everything* he says about Harry… My comment was specifically regarding Harry’s tendency to turn up where he’s not supposed to be, and not normally for innocent reasons. I personally don’t see that Snape makes many wrong assumptions about Harry’s reasons for doing what he does. Of course, he has mischaracterised the underlying cause as Harry being arrogant rather than reckless and stubborn, I will agree with you there (but I don’t think he mischaracterises James very much at all). That being said, I think it’s a bit unfair to say that Hermione is allowed to be frustrated with Harry because she likes him, but Snape isn’t allowed to be frustrated, because Snape doesn’t like him. And whether people care about him or not, NOTHING that anyone says – Snape, McGonagall, Hermione, Ron, Lupin, Mr Weasley – has got through to Harry, up until the point that Lupin quite rightly reminds him that his parents literally died to try and keep him safe. I’m quite sure that very same thought crossed Severus’ mind (at least when it comes to Lily) and may be the source of a lot of his anger and frustration, but you can hardly expect him to explain that to Harry. (You also say that all Snape has done for 3 years is treat Harry with hate and contempt, but that’s not entirely true. Harry also knows for a fact that Snape has actively tried to save his life before. If he stopped and really thought about that for a minute, he might realise that Snape could have a good reason for being angry at him for choosing to sneak into Hogsmeade. But of course, he doesn’t. Instead, as we see in this very chapter, he immediately latched on to a reason to entirely discount Snape’s efforts, and clung to it so he could continue hating him in peace.) I’d really rather not get into an in-depth discussion about the Whomping Willow incident this early on, if that’s all right. I’m sure there will be a great deal of opportunity for that when it comes up again later in the books.

Rebecca May

That's entirely my point. It is intentional. Severus and Lupin are both correct in their criticism, despite the difference in the way they each try to get through to Harry. Also I could be wrong - I'd have to go back and watch to make sure - but I thought Veggie's criticism was specifically meant for Cadogan's system of constantly changing the passwords, which subsequently forced poor Neville to write them all down. I think we'd all agree that the Fat Lady did a much more admirable job of protecting the Common Room in the circumstances.

Florian

Hi Veggie, what do you think about Hermoine's and Professor Trelawny's behaviour during their confrontation? Also I really liked that Hagrid, knows he is unreasonable about the creatures he looks after.

Vampiric Angel

Hey Veggie, some dot points for you I am so glad Ron had some time in the sun and felt important. Snape is so much more intense in the book, in the movie, it's a simple out of bed at night situation instead of catching him from Hogsmeade. I wish these insults made it into the movie. I found the Quidditch game entertaining with the commentary from Lee Jordan. I love that there is a physical Quidditch cup mentioned, unlike the never seen House Cup.

S1lm4r1l

Definitely, think Veggie's gonna look back on this Quidditch team with fond memories.

Hawwah

We have to talk about Neville. I think there are two separate issues to discuss. Firstly, did Neville deserve punishment? Secondly, was McGonagall's punishment appropriate? I personally believe McGonagall was right to punish Neville, but I think denying him the house password was too much (I have no problem with the other punishments). Neville is a fan favorite character, so people tend to overlook his flaws. When it comes to Neville and Professor Snape, many people simply say that there's nothing wrong with Neville's behavior and Snape just picks on him for no reason. (Because he's sooo evil.) However, it turns out that McGonagall agrees with Snape that Neville's behavior is unacceptable. So, is McGonagall evil too, or could it be that Neville really is problematic? Remember when we first met Neville? He had just lost his pet toad. That was our first clue that he was not a very responsible person. Shortly after, in the very first potions lesson, Neville didn't follow Snape's instructions, botched his potion, hurt himself and endangered other students. (Only after this incident Snape started to pay extra attention to Neville.) Then, in the first flying lesson, Neville didn't follow Hooch's instructions and got himself hurt again. Neville's grandmother sent his permission slip to McGonagall directly because she thought it was safer (implying Neville would have likely lost it if she had given it to him). So, Neville being reckless and endangering himself and/or others as a result is something that is well established in the books. Other characters acknowledge Neville's irresponsibility as well. It's not something that Snape or Snape's fans made up. And now Neville did it again. He lost his list of passwords and he couldn't be bothered to inform McGonagall about this huge security breach. You said last time that Neville didn't have any malicious intent. I agree. However, I think that's not good enough. Negligence can be morally wrong too. If Black really had been the mass murderer everyone believed him to be, Neville's negligence would have cost Harry his life. Let that sink in. So I understand why McGonagall was furious with Neville and why she punished him. I just don't agree with denying him the password. That needlessly humiliated Neville and put him in danger in case there was another Black's attack. Snape can be unpleasant, but his punishments are very tame in comparison to hers. He never wilfully put a student in danger.

Janie

You're definitely not the only one. This line makes me laugh every time. Most Snape's lines do, in fact.

Hawwah

Neville knew. He knew the passwords were missing the day Harry got his Firebolt back. That was Thursday. The match and Black's attack was on Saturday. So Neville had at least 3 days to inform McGonagall. He did nothing. EDIT: I don't have a big problem with Neville writing the passwords down - it was clearly not a bright idea, but I wouldn't consider it morally wrong. I don't blame Neville about losing the list either, because Crookshanks stole it. However, not informing McGonagall about the possible security breach is inexcusable in my opinion.

Rebecca May

Okay, sorry, my bad. I went back and re-read and I'd just forgotten they were missing for that long. I don't think the edit in your main comment is necessary because of my mistake (I'm off work with a bad cold today so I'm a little fuzzier than usual), but of course you can leave it in if you wish, since it's your comment after all. :) I'll remove my comment. (And yes, you're right, I agree that Neville should have reported the passwords missing since they were gone for so long.)

Janie

I'm one of those people that feel the need to defend Neville because yes, he is one of my favourite characters. Yes, he has flaws, but every character in those books has them. That's what makes me love those characters even more, because they're not perfect. But I agree with you - he should have reported the stolen passwords, I can't argue with you about that.

Janie

I don't know what Ron was thinking, talking Harry into going to Hogsmeade. He knew Black was after Harry and after Black tried to attack him I'd think he'd be more concerned about their safety. I guess I'll never understand thirteen years old boys :) Am I the only one who finds it weird that Ron knew that Harry would be in Snape's office after returning from Hogsmeade? How did he know? How did he know what to say? And I don't know why but I just can't imagine Hagrid and Buckbeak on the Knight Bus.

Hawwah

@Rebecca May That's okay. This series is so long, it's completely natural to forget/misremember things. It happens to me too and not only when I'm feeling unwell. I hope I wasn't too harsh in my response. Get well soon! @Janie I agree with you that every character has flaws. Except Cedric. Cedric was flawless and that's why he had to die so soon. He was too good for this world :'(

Rebecca May

@Hawwah Thank you! Hopefully with some rest I should be fine soon. :)

Helen

A random thing I enjoyed in these chapters is the use of floo powder within the school. I love the scene where Snape throws a handful of powder into the fireplace, shouts at Lupin and Lupin proceeding to climb out of the fireplace. Such amusing imagery. It does lead me to wonder… can fireplaces that are connected to the floo networking able to work like a two-way radio/walkie-talkie? Why don’t we see this utilized more often?

Thunderbird

Just love the fact that Harry's head is actually revealed in front of Malfoy in Hogsmeade. That would have been so funny if it was in the movie! Also Harry could have just stayed in the secret passageway and checked the map until Snape was gone. But I guess he completely panicked. Him and Ron did not a very good job at trying to be innocent. 😄 Also Harry’s sass is coming back, saying "maybe Malfoy is having hallucinations" to Snape is a bold move. And it gets even better when all the marauders insult Snape (who knows exactly who they are) and Lupin’s only comment about them being "we’ve met". Just a great chapter! I also like we get more information about Hermione from Hagrid. No wonder she is cracking with all her classes AND helping out Hagrid with Buckbeak’s case AND going pretty much alone through it. Harry and Ron can just be glad she let it out on Malfoy (already at this point of the story).

itsanursething

I wanted to be in Slytherin because green is my favorite color. Also, I though Tom Felton was cute. Haha! But I was sorted into Hufflepuff, which I pride myself on now. Either way, it is weird that Slytherin is ALWAYS bad. That's just statistically so unlikely.

itsanursething

Harry is 13 years old. How many 13-year-olds do you know that think logically enough to always follow the rules? I don't blame Harry for breaking rules and trying to be normal, when all his life he has been treated either as abnormal or abnormally special. He just wants to be a kid, regardless of how many times people have saved his life, he wants to be like everyone else. And breaking the rules is a part of that.

rreowenn

The front doors were being taught to recognise Sirius! I wonder how that works. Are the doors sentient with brains or is it more of a mechanical process? Also I think Snape was right to tell Harry off for going to Hogsmeade under the circumstances but a teacher should never bring anyone's parents or grudges against them into their job (although Lupin does mention them too), that's completely unfair and unprofessional. And then Trelawney insulting Hermione! I think the Hogwarts teachers are lacking in training haha. We also learn in chapter 15 that there aren't really knockouts and quarter/semi finals in quidditch, each team just does their three games each and whoever has the most points at the end wins the cup! And then there's the tactical discussion of Harry needing to catch the snitch after they are up enough points which certainly makes it more exciting. And finally, what do you think about Harry seeing Crookshanks with the dog?

rreowenn

I think this comment should have been in the previous installment? We met Cho last time! Also I think the punishment for Neville is that nobody is allowed to tell him the password, and even if he heard it he would forget it because that's what made him write them down ion the first place bless him.

rreowenn

I imagine Ron probably got back to Hogwarts at the same time ish as Harry since the normal path is implied to be shorter, and was waiting for him and after a few minutes realised he should have been back and went to look for him. It's not weird to assume that Snape caught him because Harry had said Snape has been hanging around and Draco would have gone immediately to Snape. Ron is smart enough to know that Harry had the stuff in his pocket, and even if he didn't he probably saw the zonkos stuff on Snape's desk or something the second he entered the room and it just came out.

rreowenn

I'm not sure if you should edit out the part about the marauders being students because although Veggie has seen the film it doesn't explicitely state who the marauders are or how they created the map.Might be best to leave that until the chapters in the shrieking shack?

Collin Anderson

You are right I got my chapters mixed up

Michelle Linardis

Before I start, I totally agree with the idea of covering two chapters per video. As you go forward, especially beyond this book, the chapters are going to get longer and more in-depth, so reducing your vids to two chapters, (although it will take longer), would be less challenging for you. You will find as you read, that a Harry POV/protagonist/Gryffindor bias seems to be a little more prevalent. Lupin was also being just as petty in encouraging a student to humiliate a teacher in the Boggart class, but people overlook it because Lupin was ‘nice’, and was also a Gryffindor. So on this note, is McGonagall's punishment of Neville justified? Or is it 'okay' because she is Head of Gryffindor? Substitute her for Snape, and we would see things far differently. Ah, chapter 14. A favorite of mine in this book. "What would your head have been doing in Hogsmeade, Potter?" said Snape softly. "Your head is not allowed in Hogsmeade. No part of your body has permission to be in Hogsmeade." I love this Snape quote – taking note of the fact that he said this ‘softy’. Fun fact - ‘Soft’ is actually one of the third most common words used to describe him in the books. There are a lot of truths and interesting things mentioned in this chapter, and about this dangerous prank/joke….we’ll find out more soon…

Diego Zenhäusern

To kinda quote Kingsley: "You can think about him what you wan't but you've got to admit: Snape's got sassy replies"

Diego Zenhäusern

I have to say that Harry and Ron refusing to make up with Hermione even after the talk Hagrid gave them is probably the moment in all the books where I'm most disappointed in them😕 I also like that we get another peak at the complexity of Snape's character: He's absolutely right in that it was reckless of Harry to go to Hogsmead and that he deserves to be punished for it. And I actually believe that he was concerned for Harry's savety. And we also get a hint, that his hatred of James might have a deeper cause than just a simple teenage rivalry. But: He also clearly let his hatred of James blind him and took obvious joy in the prospect of Harry being punished. And this attitude of his also prevented him from being sucessfull in dissuading Harry from doing such a thing again in the future (in contrast to Lupins more compassionate and understanding but still very stern approach).

Kevin Morris

Proud Gryffindor here: GRYFFINDOR WINS THE QUIDDITCH CUP!!! Hey Veggie! Just to explain since I know you were a little confused about how the standings worked for the Hogwarts Quidditch Cup. The way that it works is that the amount of points your team scores is cumulative and the team with the most points at the end of the season wins the Cup. Hence why it's important to do things like outscore the other teams and why capturing the Snitch is so important. This why the final ends up being Gryffindor versus Slytherin, it's not that there was an extra game after all the games had been played, it just so happened (because JKR wrote it that way) that Gryffindor and Slytherin had the most points headed into the last match of the year, so whoever finished the match with the most points would be the champions. Also, just wanted to point out that based on the scores from the matches all season, Hufflepuff came in last place...HA! (Just kidding, love you Veggie!!)

Rebecca May

I love the way you've talked about the James/Snape/Lupin situation here - couldn't have said it better myself 😊

Janie

You're probably right. Still, his sudden appearance seems too convenient, in my opinion.

Jacqueline Chaiton

I understand that this was a plot device needed for Lupin to have the map, but honestly why did Harry not just stay hidden in the secret passage and use the map to see when Snape had left then used the invisibility cloak to get back to Gryffindor tower? Snape doesn’t know how the passage works so he wouldn’t have found him.

Kunzite Blossom

The password thing does make sense. Sir Cadogan was the only one who would take the job as guardian after the Fat Lady was attacked. According to the wiki (I only have the audio books so I cant get the exact text) "Several students complained about how he constantly challenged students to duels and his changing of the passwords - he was known for thinking up ridiculously complicated passwords, and changing them several times a day," Now, given Neville has a habit of forgetting stuff (he got a Remembrall in his first year for a reason), it doesn't surprise me he would forget who knows how many passwords got set for the day. I'm sure plenty of students had trouble. So even if a student did help Neville get in and yes he would hear it and know it, the password would probably have changed before the next time he needs to enter.

Kunzite Blossom

Oh for sure. I mean, just cause you have a faster broom doesn't mean you'll see the snitch first. If the other seeker sees it first and is closer, (or at least manages a head start towards it) they could probably catch it before the seeker on the faster broom. I just feel like Veggie didn't think of it that way given Harry generally always catches the snitch. I mean...Harry literally catches it even after it had been next to Draco.

itsanursething

To quote Dumbledore from AVPM, “Malfoy, you little 💩!” He, and the rest of Slytherin, were particularly awful in these chapters, don’t you think? I’m surprised that some of the players weren’t suspended or removed from the match after the awful fouls they committed. That being said, that would have been a VERY entertaining quidditch match to see on the big screen. A lot of people are talking about big moments in these chapters, so I want to comment on some small details that I only just noticed. First, Hagrid mentioned God. To my knowledge, this is the first time we’ve heard a wizard mention any deity in the books. Mostly they say something like, “Merlin’s beard!” I’m just wondering if the wizarding world follows any sort of organized religion, because in my limited knowledge, magic = bad in most Christian faiths. I mean, Hogwarts has Christmas and Easter holidays, but is that just for the students with muggle parents? And Harry had a Godfather - was that because Lily was muggleborn? I’m curious about your thoughts on this. As someone who wears glasses, how the HECK did Harry manage to see Crookshanks walking along the edge of the Forbidden Forest, at night, from the Gryffindor TOWER, without his glasses on?? I can barely make out any shapes without my glasses, let alone at night and from that distance. Does Harry really need glasses? Was I the only one surprised by Snape referring to himself as “master of this school” when trying to open the Marauder’s map? Where did that come from? And finally, did you notice when Lupin took the Marauder’s map before leaving Snape’s office he said, “I’ll take this back”? Maybe a little slip up from him? Or intentional foreshadowing? As always, appreciate your thoughts and ideas Veggie!

Giorgia M

Feel absolutely terrible about Neville’s punishment. I understand that McGonagall didn’t have malicious intent and wasn’t getting enjoyment out of Neville’s punishment but it’s incredibly irresponsible. He’s just to float around out in the corridor? With a killer on the loose? Even if she know Sirius is only after Harry, why risk it? If the password system really is the only way they can figure out, why not have a buddy with Neville to let him in or something? He didn’t lose the passwords on purpose. It was an accident. I have such a problem with strictness or harsh punishment when I don’t think it’ll achieve anything. Isolating Neville won’t make him less forgetful. Also despite my grievances with Hermione last chapters, I think the Ron and Harry are being little daftys. They should’ve let the grudge go, icing her out is not on at all. I understand Ron’s hurt as he loved Scabbers but they should be trying to sort it out instead of being proud. What do you think of the changes in the Hogsmeade chapter? The race back to Hogwarts always makes me nervous!!

Sam-I-Am

Fair points about his forgetfulness, clearly he's not a perfect character. But to say that makes Neville problematic though? I'd argue the toad being lost shouldn't really be counted as something his fault. I'm sure most 11 year olds would also struggle to keep track of a pet toad at all times, not just Neville. As for Snape, I don't think he's evil, but the way he speaks to and about some of the students is inappropriate and unprofessional. To be fair - most of the Hogwarts professors are unprofessional in different ways, even Dumbledore himself tbh (don't get me started on him giving last minute points to Gryffindor to win the house cup in book 1, snatching it away from Slytherin...so unfair). Back to Snape lol - while I can understand and sympathize with his frustration at Neville not following the instructions, the way he handles it is not great. And clearly Snape's methods don't really do much to fix the problem. It just results in Neville being more terrified of him and learning to rely on Hermione sneaking him help/answers. It would have been nice if Snape had noticed that his methods weren't making the situation better and pivoted, trying a different approach.

Sam-I-Am

Summed up the complexity of Snape's character perfectly!

Sam-I-Am

Neville's punishment makes no sense, especially given that the professors are all worried about a presumed mass murderer in Hogwarts. Neville not having the password and being forced to wait in the corridors makes him more vulnerable. I forgot just how sassy book Harry is! I love it! Not only does it make him more relatable and realistic, but it shows us that in the comfort of the magical world Harry finds his voice. During the summers when he's with his terrible aunt and uncle, he's walking on eggshells. Yes we've gotten glimpses of him making sarcastic snide comments to Dudley and negotiating with Vernon, but for the most part he's pretty careful about not saying or doing anything that would further anger Petunia and Vernon for fear of punishment and retribution...it's heartbreaking. One thing that bothers me about Sirius getting into Gryffindor towers - why weren't the portraits shown a picture of Sirius and given strict instructions not to let him in even if he somehow got access to the right password? They already had a scare of him being in the castle once, even though they searched and couldn't find him, they knew it was a possibility he would come back and try to gain access to the Gryffindor towers again

Hawwah

Someone once explained to me that in British English, "master" in this context simply means "teacher". Just like Snape's title "Potions master" means "Potions teacher". I checked (no pun intended) my Czech edition of the book and "master" is indeed translated as "teacher". EDIT: I looked it up in an online dictionary and found this: UK old-fashioned a male school teacher "Mr Wells was my Latin master at school." (https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/master)

Diego Zenhäusern

Thank you two! It's always nice to see other people that can appreciate his complexity and don't just fall into one ot the two extremes when it comes to his character🙂.

Hawwah

If Neville losing his pet toad was an isolated incident, I wouldn't make too much of it. But Neville consistently displays sloppy and irresponsible behavior. One time can be an accident or a case of bad luck. But when it happens regularly, that's a character flaw. I mostly agree with your second paragraph. This is something I've been arguing the whole time. Yes, Severus has his flaws and yes, he's not a perfect or ideal teacher. There are certainly things he could have done better. I never claimed the opposite. My point has always been that his teaching methods aren't any worse than those of the other teachers and his punishments are remarkably tame in comparison to McGonagall's. Snape's detractors paint him as some evil child abuser, but Snape is actually the teacher most concerned with his students' safety. He's always here to the rescue when something goes wrong and we never saw him wilfully put a student in danger, while teachers like McGonagall, Hagrid, Lupin and Dumbledore did it multiple times. (And those are the "good guys" - I'm not even counting the villains like Quirrell and fake Moody.) "It would have been nice if Snape tried a different approach" - yeah, probably. But the exact same thing could be said about McGonagall! Yet I don't see people calling her a child abuser who bullies Neville. And that's what pi..es me off so much - this double standard. I don't mind if people don't like Severus, I just wish they were fair to him. (To be clear, I'm now talking about the fandom in general, not about you specifically. Judging from your comment, you're being fair to him and I appreciate that.)

Diego Zenhäusern

Totally agree with you on the Neville front! I used to kinda gloss over this. But previous discussions in this group really brought to my attention how much McGonagall fails here as a teacher. She really should have at the very least assigned someone (either someone new every day or always the same person for a week) that would let Neville into the tower in the evening after the lessons. And to be honest: This punishment makes no sense anyways now that the fat lady is back as Neville managed to get by two entire years without having to write down all the passworts when the fat lady was around. Because she's not crazy like Cadogan and changes the passworts all the time😅 P.S. I'm as well really disappointed in Harry and Ron that they didn't let go of the grudge after the heartfelt talk Hagrid gave to them😕

Hawwah

McGonagall really has a track record of assigning strange punisments. First she sent 4 first years to the Forbidden Forrest where something was killing unicorns, and now this. When I said Snape was a cinnamon roll in comparison to McGonagall, people thought I was crazy, but I knew what I was talking about.

Sam-I-Am

Omg yes! I was gonna mention the Forbidden Forest punishment, but didn’t want to get too sidetracked haha. And funnily/oddly enough, in second year when Harry and Ron seriously screwed up big time and broke wizarding laws, she gave them the most basic and normal punishments. Like what?!?

EifossofiE (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-20 18:00 Hello Veggie! Don't worry about saying "the wrong thing" It's your honest opinion and your genuine interest in discussion that's the reason we are here! At least I :) I read the third book the first time when I was 10 years old and I loved Quidditch. As an adult I wish there was a time limit of the games, or less points for catching the Snitch. The games in general would make more sense then. A general input about Snape: I always believed that there was more to Snape than we where told, even as a kid reading the book. Here is why: Dumbledore felt like a steady, calm, wise, kind, trustworthy, all-knowing, person right from the start. It felt like Dumbledore knew things that I, as the reader didn't and that's what held the story together. He trusted Snape for reasons we were not told. If he was so wrong about Snape, the foundation of his character is shaken. And that in turn would shake the foundation of the whole story. So basically I trusted Dumbledore to trust Snape :) Keep doing what you are doing Veggie! Love from Sweden :)
2023-03-18 14:18

emmainkeri

I mean we do see people use floo powder sort of like face time, several times in the books, don't we? 😅

Saiyasha

I love some many things about these chapters that are not in the Movies. The Foreshadowing of who the Marauders are and more importantly, Snapes History with them. It is never quite clear who Snape _exactly_ means with Harry "getting it directly from the Manufacturers", but my guess is that he thinks either that Harry got it from Lupin or that it was handed down from his father. I don't think he is insinuating that he got it from Sirius, at this point everyone still believes Sirius to be a dangerous murderer and it would not make sense at all. How much more the strain of Hermiones workload is shown. She is doing _way_ to many things at the same time and she is really fraying at the edges here. And we again have her shown in a very different light, prone to introvertness and tears when pushed to the brink, but also proud and stubborn in her way. It is shown here, that a simple apology would have been all Ron needed. An acknowledgement from hermione that she had fault in what happened. Granted, the circumstances of her just sobbing about Buckbeaks lost case may have softened his response, but i think the aplogy was really all he wanted. Last but not least - I have to give it to the movie for once. Hermione decking Draco full fist is way more satisfying then just a slap, Though Dracos whiny reaction to the book slap makes him look like even more then a whimp

Rebecca May

@Diego 😂😂 (It's true though. The sass is incredible.)

Katik

Hi Veggie, two things from me this time, one new and one old. By the old one I mean the first time I read this book - the Quidditch chapter, the match and the Gryffindor win description was the first part of this book series that actually made me tear up :) (It might have even be the first time in my life I cried reading a book rather than watching TV / films ) The new one is an observation I noticed this time around re-reading these chapters. When Snape has Harry in his office there's a lot he's saying, BUT: The point he makes about everyone including the Minister of Magic and Dumbledore putting a lot of effort into protecting Harry from Sirius, while Harry repays them by breaking the rules and walking into Hogsmead, is actually exactly the same point Lupin makes only a few minutes later about Harry's parents giving their lives to save him and he should not risk it by being irresponsible. Funny how these two conversations were placed right next to each other! Harry never even takes it in the first time from Snape, but coming from Lupin it has a great impact. I really don't want to restart the Snape debate in the comments here but I think it's nicely shown how there's two things going on there. First Harry is obviously prejudiced, hates Snape and likes Lupin - since what they both said was 100% correct, it should not matter who it comes from, but Harry will not even consider Snape might be right in this. On the other hand - let's forget Harry is prejudiced - people might be making a very good point, be right in everything they say, but the way they say it makes all the difference. It really does not help that Snape is furious, gleeful at catching Harry, and the very next thing, before he even lets his point sink in, he insults Harry's dead father. Snape is simply a very bad communicator here and regardless of what he says, it will never be accepted simply because of how he delivers it. (Which now I think about it, is a very nice foreshadowing for another scene at the end of this book where his anger completely gets in the way of getting his point across.)

Dara Jeeling

Great look on Dumbledore... Also great to see how a younger erader went with that. I was like 17 when the first book came out - and for me Snape was painted to characteristicly evil in book one - so I never believed he would be the bad guy in the end. (also the description of him knocking Quirrel off helped) And afterwards it was like "na - don't believe he is the bad one - we were led down that path before - to obvious" Also it always sort of irked me that Dumbledore said "Please" since this could be meant two ways. (Also I loved Snape - because he was so flawed - so no way I was believing him to be bad) BUT I never thought about putting so much faith in Dubledore. (I love getting differnt views, so thank you!)

S1lm4r1l

> "Snape is simply a very bad communicator here and regardless of what he says, it will never be accepted simply because of how he delivers it." Couldn't have put it better myself. He's very clever. But emotional intelligence is not his forte.

S1lm4r1l

> "Was I the only one surprised by Snape referring to himself as “master of this school” when trying to open the Marauder’s map?" He's the potion's master. Without prompting the map knows that Snape is a Professor.

S1lm4r1l

> "I'm not sure if you should edit out the part about the marauders being students because although Veggie has seen the film it doesn't explicitely state who the marauders are or how they created the map." Done. Good thinking.

itsanursething

We don't know who Moony or Prongs are yet. Or the Marauders in general. That's kind of a spoiler...Might want to edit that part. Sorry!

itsanursething

Facts! If you want someone to listen to you, maybe don't insult them and their dead family first? Just a thought...

itsanursething

Yes, he's the potions master, because he is a master of potions. You never hear any of the other teaching positions referred to as "master". No charms master, herbology mistress...only potions and Headmaster (but that one makes sense to me). He doesn't say that he's the POTIONS master though. Just "master of this school." Not even A master. The verbiage just sounds funny to me. Like he was trying to sound more important than he is to make the map listen to him.

Saiyasha

But he watched the Movies, isn't explained at some point?

Janie

Sadly, it's not really explained in the movie. People might guess though but it's never really said.

Kunzite Blossom

Communication is key. Obviously if you're going to talk crap about someone's family, no matter how good your intentions are: they aren't going to listen to you. What 13 year old (or anyone of any age) is going to listen to someone who just gives insults about said persons parents. As a professor there should be a level of professionalism and throwing insults crosses that line. But it's only made worse that Harry is prejudiced, but I feel like overall Snape really hasn't been that nice to Harry (like up front. not just like saving him behind the scenes) to really let Harry even take a chance to accept Snape isn't all bad until after Snape has died and was shown the memories he was. So I can understand where Harry comes from in hating Snape. Especially in scenes like this.

Kate Bogd

Hi Veggie! I got really disappointed in Ron and Harry when even after Harris encouraged them to make amends they still continued to be mean to her. But I’m glad they finally figured it out, even if it is in a sad circumstance. Ron has always been one of my favorite characters, maybe because of how passionate he is. It shows here clearly: first he goes overboard with hating Hermione, then he get completely focused on helping Buckbeak. He is a very fierce friend (in these cases to Scabbers and Hagrid respectedly) and I love this about him. It’s clear in Chapter 14 how much Harry cares about the image of his father. I always felt like the movies flipped the importance of Lily and James. In the book it’s the comment about James that tips Harry over to blow up aunt Marge. And here it’s the comments about James that trigger Harry again. You see how much Harry associates himself with his dad. Lily is barely mentioned in this book even by other characters. Where as the movies make Lily way more important, especially through the scene on the bridge with Lupin. I think it weakens the later moment, when Harry thinks he saw his dad casting the Patronus. Anyways it is a specific choice the movies made and I don’t understand why exactly. I also wonder why Harry and Ron decided to take divinations and continue on without trying to switch to another class? They obviously don’t enjoy it and probably just stick around because they need to meet some minimum amount of classes. But what made them think they would like it in the first place? I wish we learned more about classes-picking.

Marianne

Hi Veggie! I have just joined the patreon and am so excited to be apart of the book club! I have always been confused with Snape’s reaction to seeing the Marauders Map after taking it from Harry. He acts as though he doesn’t know who Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot and Prongs are. With him being at school at the same time as the marauders, I would have assumed that he heard them calling each other by these nicknames all the time (This is shown in the film, Order of the Phoenix in snape’s memories of him being bullied). Maybe he does know who they are but doesn’t want to tell Harry for some reason? After all he did make the statement ‘Maybe he got it directly from the manufacturers. What do you think, Veggie?

Benjamin Hütz

Hey, first of all sorry for not commenting on the last few episodes... i had a serious car crash back in december and broke my hip and some vertebras in my neck. Im only recently been able to use my hands again to comment. I really love how there are security trolls for hire... i laugh every time i read this :D

H

I would love Veggie to answer "that's no excuse!! :@" to this! Glad to hear that you're better!

Raider Max

Hope the recovery goes smooth bud!

Raider Max

So far what has been your favorite thing to happen in the book but not the movie? At this point for me it's the encounter between Harry, Snape, and THE professor Remus John Lupin but that will change. Yes I know they had an encounter in the movie but the book was better and made more sense.

Astrid

You are such a sweetheart for worrying about how the appearance of people is described in these books! To be fair, our heroes aren't supermodels either :)

Kevin Morris

In reference to religion in the Wizarding World, it’s actually mentioned quite a bit. It seems like wizards actually do practice religion. I think the biggest example is that both the headstones for Kendra Dumbledore and James & Lily Potter have Bible verses on them.

Simon audsley

Nanu Nanu Another set of chapters with more character growth than most of the movies put together, the directors may say they liked Hermione the best but I'm not sure what books they we're reading as the characters bare no resemblance. So when you're listening are you tweaking characters so they look more their ages rather than the movie ages and have adjusted the height of hagrid as he's taller in the books?

ambiture

Any chapter where we get to indulge in Lee Jordans world class commentary is a good chapter in my eyes! I love how into it Jim Dale gets when Wood saves the penalty. Sounds like he had fun in the recording booth that day, LOL

Maria

Hello! I've been listening to your Harry Potter reviews for quite a while, but I've just joined the Patreon, and I'm excited to be commenting for the first time. I haven't read Prisoner of Azkaban in many years, so I'm struck by how differently I view the events in Snape's Grudge. When I was a kid reading the books, I was more on Harry/Ron's side when it came to telling the teachers about the secret passages and Harry going to Hogsmeade. Now, reading it as an adult, Lupin and Snape's comments about what Harry is risking by going to Hogsmeade really resonate with me, and I agree that it's very irresponsible and a little selfish for Harry to be risking his life for candy and fun. I'm really disappointed in Harry and Ron in these chapters. I suppose that shows the difference between a child and an adult's thought process and shows how accurately Rowling is able to capture how kids think. It also shows how mature Hermione is in this regard; she's really the hero of this section of the book. Also, I find the security trolls to be interesting! In the first book, the troll that attacks Hermione in the bathroom is portrayed almost like an animal without any intelligence. But the security trolls must be able to communicate with Hogwarts staff and follow instructions, so, now that I think about it, it seems strange that no one was able to talk to/reason with the troll in the first book. Maybe I'm misremembering, but I wonder if anyone tried to communicate with it? But, in any case, I love the image of security trolls guarding the Fat Lady. Plus, I love the image of Harry's disembodied dead appearing when he threw the mud at Draco in Hogsmeade. That should have been in the movie in my opinion.

Maria

I love that line! Maybe one of the best quotes from the book.

Garry (Not Jerry)

We’ve had this discussion before. But I’ll come at it from a different angle. I take some offense with Neville being called “sloppy and irresponsible”, because I myself am quite forgetful and I know what it’s like to lose things all the time. Yes, there are measures you can take to help you. Writing things down, setting alarms, keeping a tidy room, but ultimately sometimes you just can’t help it. As for telling Mcgonagall about the lost passwords - I believe it simply did not occur to him to do so. Heck, it didn’t occur to me until you pointed it out. Not really a good excuse but…sure in hindsight I’m sure he realised he should have done it. Im sure he will learn his lesson and report it immediately next time he loses something important, but ultimately I don’t know how you can blame someone for not doing something that it never occurred to them to do in the first place.

Garry (Not Jerry)

“Little daftys” - he’ll like that one 😄

Garry (Not Jerry)

Not sure that cadogan would have followed those instructions tbh. He would challenge black to a duel but probably honour the password system more highly and let him in if he had it.

Methanoutput

I don't have much to say, but did you notice at the end of the chapter 'Quidditch Final' that Professor McGonagall sobbed harder than Oliver Wood? Could you imagine McGonagall crying over something like this in the movies? As always, I hope you are doing well, Veggie. I'm also interested in knowing if you enjoyed doing two chapters because those five-hour videos are great, but I bet they are hard to record.

Garry (Not Jerry)

Harry just picked it because Ron picked it. I imagine arithmancy and Runes sounded boring to them. And Ron probably didn’t want to do muggle studies because I think his dad was way too into muggle stuff.

Garry (Not Jerry)

I don’t know whether veggie actually knows who the marauders are. He might do, but it isn’t actually mentioned in the movies so I wouldn’t assume he does. I will say that personally I don’t believe Snape knew what their nicknames were (not at this point anyway) although he has suspicions

Garry (Not Jerry)

Hi Veggie, if you’ve made it this far, we’ll done! Hopefully your hot chocolate (if you have one) won’t have gone cold! 1. When Snape makes Harry read the marauders map in the movie, I don’t think it’s clear that the map itself is making fun of Snape, not Harry! This always bothered me! 2. I’m really mad at Harry and Ron for forgetting to help Hagrid with the hearing! Hermione did everything herself while doing all her classes and the boys ignoring her because of a broomstick! 3. In defence of Mcgonagall, Neville had proved himself to be untrustworthy with the password, and by not allowing him to be told it, she was actually keeping the rest of Gryffindor House safer!

Darcy

Hi Veggie, long time Youtube watcher, first time on the Patreon! Excited to be part of the book club. I wanted to touch briefly on a topic from a previous chapter (regarding Sir Cadogan and the Fat Lady) as I missed that deadline. From what we know about the paintings from Pottermore and extra JK knowledge is that they are not sentient but behave as though they are. They act as a representation of the person based on what the painter knew about the person, and can learn new stuff from around them. I think they are very comparable to AI nowadays. It is almost like they are programmed to act like a person but cannot know more than what their programmer knows, or what they learn later. Sorry to be off topic, I thought of this comparison and really wanted to share it. Love you videos!

Janakin B

Hi Veggie, the thing Hagrid, Snape snd Trelawney have in common is that all three are very knowledgeable and skilled in their fields but all three are horrible teachers. Hagrid is horrible because his assessment of danger is practically not present, Snape is biased, sometimes cruel and has no patience or will to actually convey his knowledge to the students who are not on Hermiones level of comprehension and Trelawney simply does not really has no knowledge of her skill. Pedagogically they are all subpar.

Garry (Not Jerry)

What do you mean trelawney has no knowledge of her skill? Are you saying that she is not skilful, or that she is skilful but doesn’t know it, or that she is skilful but doesn’t know how to pass on the skill to students?

SpeedyBrandon95

Hey Veggie, I thought Snape’s interrogation was a rollercoaster of emotions and intentions. I think originally Snape was in his own way trying to get through the seriousness of keeping safe, but he suddenly switched when Harry’s attitude was reminding him of James and then he was angry when Harry thought James had saved Snape’s life.. however from Snape’s perspective, James had been bullying and tormenting him and only stopped when he didn’t want to be caught. I find it interesting that this is the first reference to James being a bully and a flawed character instead of the perfect great man that Harry thought he was.

Annette Elliott

I like that in the books we already see a bit of the fact that Harry's dad wasn't as perfect as he thought. This is Harry's first hint at the fact that James, like any other person, had feet of clay. I also like the fact that Hagrid called Ron and Harry out about their treatment of Hermione over the Firebolt and Scabbers. Also, as much as I love the punch she gave Draco, I really like that Hermione was so stressed out by everything that she totally lost it and slapped Draco in front of everyone.

Bianca Nedelea

Hey Veggie, good to be here. I really love how Hagrid stood up for Hermione here, since she was right and a really good friend. Keep up the good work!