Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi guys!  Time for another book review! And WHAT a couple of chapters we have here (with no Quidditch rants!!)!

Today we talk about Much Ado About Nothing, Star Wars (again) and Last of the Summer Wine, as well as a few minutes about Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban.

Hope your week is going great, and that you are looking forward to the weekend!

Love you guys!  And thanks to everyone that took part in the Book Club!

Oh, P.S - I dont' make it clear at the start, but Kenneth Branagh played Lockhart in Harry Chamber of Secrets! XD

Files

Movie Watcher Reads Harry Potter For the First Time! - Prisoner of Azkaban Chapters 16 & 17!

Check out the Patreon for the Full Length Movie reactions (you will need your own copy of the movie remember), and some other early access stuff coming soon! There is no minium Pay amount, so pay as little as you like! :) - https://www.patreon.com/VeggieGamer My Mail Box is Now OPEN! Find the Address and other info here! - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G362I7JPgWY Come join the official Veggie Discord server! :) - https://discord.gg/mw36C7d GET YOUR VEGGIE MERCHANDISE HERE! - https://www.redbubble.com/people/VeggieGamer GO GIVE ME A FOLLOW OVER AT TWITCH TO BE A PART OF THE FUN! - https://www.twitch.tv/veggie_gamer GET 15% OFF YOUR E-WIN RACING CHAIR BY USING PROMOTION CODE : Veggie US store: http://www.ewinracing.com/ European store: https://www.ewinracing.eu/ CCs used in my Sims 4 series can now be found here! - https://docs.google.com/document/d/1b2u8qVdJ0KAjbtG2ZPHv-DjIs2Ds4xUrtHTiKEVPahA/edit?usp=sharing CHECK ME OUT ON INSTAGRAM & TWITTER! - Veggie_Gamer CAN WE GET THIS VIDEO TO 100 LIKES, VEGGIEKNIGHTS?? If you can spare anything, Patreon (NO pressure): Want to see more of this? Give the video a thumbs up and let me know in the comments :) Hit me up on the following websites! Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheVeggieGamer/ Twitter: https://twitter.com/Veggie_Gamer Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/VeggieGamer Be sure to Follow me on Roblox (I can not accept Friend Requests) - https://www.roblox.com/users/135078748/profile End Card music - Artist: UnderwaterBeats Track: Evolution Licence:https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0

Comments

emmainkeri

Absolutely perfect timing! I was just about to do some (or a lot of) cleaning and this will help immensely! Thanks Veggie.

emmainkeri

Woozle on the thumbnail 🥺❤️

Garry (Not Jerry)

Mcgonagall did not get a ridikulus, because Hermione failed to use it. But I was thinking you could turn the exam results paper into a childrens Colouring book 😂

Dara Jeeling

I treated myself to a (non vegan) all you can eat sushi with a friend of mine at a restaurant. I (or we) usually do not often eat out. And this specific restaurant has a robot who delivers - it's shaped like a cat and it even purrs if you scratch its ear. So yeah, Sushi and sparkling water for lunch for me! what a great way to end my holiday - after being a cabby for my family the whole day.... so looking forward to it!

Mary

Ahhh! Perfect timing! Housework to do and toddler asleep! Earphones in and I’m ready to go! 😃

emmainkeri

The muggle studies professor couldn't be a muggle, because [of reasons explained later]. I do think it's beneficial that the teacher knows BOTH sides really well, so they would have to a wizard. Also I feel like placing a muggle in the midst of teen wizards could be potentially risky? Muggles don't have the means to control the students. But the class should definitely have a field day visiting muggles in a muggle city. So, a muggle born witch or wizard would probably be the ideal choice for a teacher.

emmainkeri

Ron does indeed have large feet! It's mentioned at least a few times in the books, even in the first description we get of him in the Philosopher's Stone: "He was tall, thin and gangling, with freckles, big hands and feet and a long nose." :)

Florian

Dammit, I wanted to write the reason why muggles can't be at Hogwarts, but I can't just mark it as spoiler. But It will be covered in the next book.

emmainkeri

Harry at Ollivander's in PS: "Which is your wand arm?" "Er - well, I'm right-handed." In this Azkaban chapter, I think "wand hand" was used because Sirius was holding the three wands still in his hand and Ron was preventing him from pointing them at the trio.

S1lm4r1l

I had some Mexican-style rice with some chicken, beans and spices. I was literally just thinking "Huh, Veggie should be getting one of those book review videos out soon." Happy days. Regarding the supposed plot-hole with Fred and George not noticing Peter Pettigrew in close proximity to Ron: Firstly, they don't know everyone's names in Gryffindor Tower. Perhaps they assume Peter Pettigrew is simply a Gryffindor they don't know. Secondly, they don't use the map openly, it's a secret, something they stole from Filch. They probably used it incredibly sparingly. You have to get the Map out and speak the code-word to activate the Map. It's not like they would spend hours and hours gazing over it. Thirdly, Fred and George have far better things to be doing than looking for their brother on the Marauder's Map. Fourthly, the Marauder's Map is pretty large and Hogwarts Castle is spread over 7 floors with multiple large towers, and there's the Hogwarts grounds to consider. The idea that Pettigrew's name would come up again and again and attract their interest is ridiculous. If it isn't a Teacher or a Prefect who can punish/prevent their antics, they're not interested.

Rhea H Pelotto

I've been waiting for this and got excited when I saw the notification.... but, seeing the thumbnail, now I'm super nervous. 😟😟 You've been gone for awhile and I don't have Twitter or anything. Omg I hope everything is OK.

VEGGIE GAMER

Oh Rhea, Woozle is completely fine!! I am so sorry I made you worry! It is purely because of the Animagi featured in these chapters that I decided to have her in the thumbnail! Sorry for causing the concern!!

Will

I had a burger for lunch. More fun facts about my Sirius tattoo, I knew I wanted a Harry Potter related tattoo but I didn't want the Deathly hallows tattoo because it's the most popular tattoo to get as a HP fan. So I wanted something different that also relates to my favorite character. It was the 3rd tattoo I got and I was 20 at the time. Now I have 7 tattoos. I understood your bit about the Star Wars boggart thing immediately. I also love star wars, favorite movie series for sure. (I also have a Star wars tattoo)

Rhea H Pelotto

Oh Thank Bob!!!! I'm sorry I immediately started worrying!! My fur babies are my everything , just like sweet Woozle is to you. Can't wait to get home and cuddle up with my Persimmon and Papaya and watch this!!! So happy everything is OK 🥰🥰🥰🥰

Hawwah

On the boggarts again. Unfortunately, people DO argue that Snape being Neville's boggart proves Snape is a horrible person. I didn't make it up. Even here in the book club, when we first discussed Neville's boggart, several people commented how horrible it was that Neville's boggart turned into Snape. But when the boggart turns into McGonagall, it's suddenly not horrible, because... reasons? Because... Hermione's actually not afraid of McGonagall? How do you know that? People say it with such a confidence - oh, she's actually not afraid of McG, she's afraid of failure - but we don't actually *know* that. It's just one of several possible interpretations. People insist that in Snape's case, only the literal interpretation - the least favorable to Snape - is possible. In McGonagall's case, however, only the figurative interpretation - the most favorable to McGonagall - is possible. Why is that? Why the double standard? Neville said that his fear was Snape, that's true. But take a look at this exchange: (Hermione runs out of the trunk shaking and screaming.) "Hermione!" said Lupin, startled. "What's the matter?" "P-P-Professor McGonagall!" Hermione gasped, pointing into the trunk. "Sh-she said I'd failed everything!" Lupin asked her what the matter was and she said PROFESSOR MCGONAGALL. She didn't say "I failed everything", "I'm a failure", "I'm useless" or anything along those lines. She said PROFESSOR MCGONAGALL. Only after that she added what "Professor McGonagall" had said, almost as an afterthought. But what if the scene played out differently? (Hermione runs out of the trunk shaking and screaming, just as before.) "Hermione!" said Lupin, startled. "What's the matter?" "P-P-Professor Snape!" Hermione gasped, pointing into the trunk. "H-he said I'd failed everything!" If this was how the scene played out in the book... ...would people still defend Professor Snape like they're defending McGonagall? ...would they still insist Hermione's fear isn't actually Snape, but failure? ...would they still say it was just a coincidence that the boggart assumed his form? OR ...would they consider it another proof of what a horrible person & teacher professor Snape is?  Call me a cynic, but I have zero doubts that the latter would have been the case. (If this post comes across as angry, I'm sorry - that was not my intention. It's just that I hate unfairness. And double standards. Both in real life and when it comes to literary characters. And I believe people are being very unfair to Severus in this discussion. So I naturally feel the need to defend him. Also because he's an underdog and I have a thing for underdogs. He's already being treated unfairly in his universe and now out-of-universe, too. It seems he just can't catch a break.) EDIT: I really don't mind if people don't like Severus. I just wish they would be fair to him. He is not above criticism - nobody is. (Ok, maybe Cedric.) But please, be consistent when doing so. And ditch the double standards. EDIT: Veggie, did you really read all that?! EDIT: So now I've been watching the video from the beginning and I just came to the point when Veggie contemplated the idea of Hermione's boggart turning into Professor Snape. I swear I didn't know about it when I was writing my comment! Great minds think alike :)

Melanie P

As a competitive person myself, I found your enthusiasm for your team endearing. I’m a ravenclaw but I don’t have a problem with others expressing their joy when their team does. The one thing about these early books that has driven me nuts since I read the books years ago… i find dumbledore adding points to gryffindor after they have already decorated the final feast for the actual house cup winner a little insensitive and rubs salt in the wound of the house that originally won and then got the rug pulled out from under them. I am a huge proponent of meritocracy and fairness. If he’s gonna give gryffindor the extra points, do it before they are about to aqard the cup. It feels cruel. And probably doesn’t help the animosity between the houses. Specifically, gryffindor and slytherin.

Tiegan

Hey veggie! I’m halfway through the video and you mentioned that you are “half ambidextrous” and use one hand for some things and the second hand for other things. This is actually called cross dominance or mix handedness. I also have it and always wondered if it’s an actual thing so I thought I’d share with you the proper term to look up more if you want 🙂 it’s slightly more likely for people with autism to have it which is interesting.

VEGGIE GAMER

Tiegan, I don't know why, but you saying that people with autism are more likely to have "crosss dominance" makes complete sense to me! Very interesting!

Janie

I haven't finished the video yet but I do have to react to this. To answer your question about Snape being Hermione's boggart instead of McGonagall - If he was head of Hermione's house and her favourite teacher, that means someone who Hermione respects above all the other teachers, then yes, it would be probably him who would turn into her boggart and tell her she'd failed. So to me, Hermione's boggart isn't any specific teacher, but rather being told she failed by someone she respects and who she would never want to disappoint.

Giorgia M

There’s a character in the next book that I’ve heard someone mention they always picture as Brian Blessed, I’ll bring it up later!! I can’t think of anything for him right now!

Hawwah

You always say that McGonagall is Hermione's favorite teacher, but is there actual evidence for that? I honestly can't remember.

Mary

Richard Wilson would have been a good Filch. Somewhere they could have had a student leaving muddy footprints and him exclaiming ‘I don’t believe it’ 😂 Or maybe a good Borgin/Burke… he’d be good being sinister 🤔

Hawwah

Facts!

Giorgia M

Oh just got to add, unprofessional is kind of a catch all which I think there are levels to. Getting in a heated argument with a student would be unprofessional. Telling a student they are ugly would be. Spending all your lesson talking about your person life would be unprofessional. Coming to work in your jammies would be unprofessional. But these are not all the same. It’s about context and reasoning. Just like any job, if there is personal reasons affecting your performance at work like a recent loss or death where you are being neglectful of your duties, you shouldn’t be at work, but that would be dealt with sympathetically by upper management. As it should have been here. But if it’s your own petty issues causing malicious, targeted behaviour, it wouldn’t be treated like that by HR. Everything in life is about context. Some types of unprofessionalism are worse than others, they should all be called out but it doesn’t always reflect on the person or consequences the same.

Ziro the Hutt

On Heir To The Empire, thats what a lot of the Ahsoka series coming in August will focus on as Thrawn reappears. I think Brian Blessed could have played Mad Eye also btw. I really should check out Much Ado; I like Shakespeare, but only have seen his tragedies and historical plays, not the comedies.

Kattie Martin

Had a hotdog for lunch, not very vegan. Also, I realized after posting my comment that I might have put in a few difficult words. I'm just passionate about my dislike for how they did Ron dirty in the movies.

Giorgia M

Definitely!! I started thinking about it and I think he could’ve done a lot of characters justice actually. I could imagine him doing Ollivander, even though John Hurt was perfect.

Jacob sparks

For the Quidditch cup in year 1 harry was injured for last game and they lost. Draco was not on the team that won. In year 2 the cup was cancelled half way through the season because of all the attacks going on and no one won.

Florian

I apologize, if my comment in the book club was interpreted as spoilery. It really sucks, that I don't get any notification, if someone responds to my comments :( I thought that because of past interactions between Sirius in Dogform and Crookshanks, that it is so obvious, that it wouldn't count as spoiler.

Janie

I'm not sure it's specifically said but, at least to me, it was implied a few times. For example when Hermione talks about Divination being kind of questinable subject, she says that even McGonagall thinks so. So it's obvious Hermione at least highly respects her. Maybe when I have time, I'll try to look for more specific examples :)

Hawwah

I don't deny that Hermione respects Professor McGonagall. But doesn't she respect the majority of the teachers? How do we know which one she respects the most? Now that I'm thinking about it, the only two teachers Hermione is openly disrespectful to are Professor Trelawney and Professor Snape.

Caroline

I had homemade wild-garlic soup with asparagus for lunch 🍃 its seasonal now in Germany. Is this a thing in the UK, too? Thank you so much for the new video 🙏🏼 and please stop apologizing for everything. I have a vague suspicion that this would save a lot of video time. 🤔😉 it’s also quiet funny and you dont have too like every aspect of the book, thats totally ok. Would be boring if you would. Im sure/ I hope nobody here is mad at you for criticizing Quiddich or other things.

S1lm4r1l

There's no evidence to say that Hermione fears McGonagall more than the other teachers. It isn't a double-standard because McGonagall isn't malicious. Snape is. He is cruel, vindictive, callous, harsh. People are not interpreting Snape in the least favourable manner. We have to contextualise the incident around what we already know about the characters. The real McGonagall would never treat Hermione like the Boggart did, reducing her to the verge of tears. Meanwhile, Snape routinely frightens Neville, bullies him, belittles him, humiliates him. The Boggart only needs to turn into Snape to terrify Neville. But this other Boggart has to up the ante in order to terrify Hermione as McGonagall. Snape is viewed unfavourably, because he is shown unfavourably. That's it. You might as well argue "Why is everyone giving this Voldemort guy a hard time? I'm sure deep down he's a real softie! Look at all these times he's real nice to those around him." Snape is not a good person. He occasionally does good things, often only through a great deal of coaxing and manipulation on the part of others.

Hawwah

@S1lm4r1l I politely told you several times that I do not wish to enagage with you. Why can't you respect it? You're not interested in a serious discussion. You purposefully post claims that are both blatantly false and as outrageous as humanly possible, just to provoke me and elicit strong reactions from me. In other words, you're trolling. I told you repeatedly that I do not wish to participate in that. Your further trolling attempts aren't going to convince me to start enganging with you again. On the contrary. Please stop.

Charlotte

u literally just described urself😭 I never really comment on here but i read all comments and you are always coming up with the most wild and non-sensical reaches to defend snapes actions. Snape is one of my fave characters but i understand that he is flawed and is supposed to be a morally grey character, that up until deathly hallows we as readers are supposed to be annoyed by. Snape, (alongside draco) are literally written by jkr to be the antagonists in harry’s school life and that’s just fact. no amount of misinterpreting scenes and making it seem like he’s actually a really nice guy is gonna change that. and guess what, he’s still one of my fave characters, characters don’t have to be good people to be good characters.

Giorgia M

Toast jam and peanut butter, a cup of tea with alpro soya milk in and no sugar, very specific. Sorry I was going to wait till Fenrir Greyback was discussed in the books but I’ve got to the part about the potentially problematic nature of lycanthropy as an allegory of homosexuality/aids. I will discuss it more in later books but I will say that it’s not exactly flattering to gay people. It is still a clearly debilitating disease being a werewolf, and the fact that it’s a monster who can’t control attacking others seems a bit weird. It’s not exactly empowering for people who are gay or who have aids, is it? There’s even more weird implications with Fenrir Greyback and his backstory (which I can’t discuss yet), as a werewolf who chooses to stay (at least partly) a wolf, who prays on people and kills for pleasure (as we learned in the films). Which I think highlights JK’s own implicit biases, but there’s more information about that character we are yet to get to that I actually have to actively not think about the comparison to gay people or it starts to ruin the story for me.

Katie

Egg sandwich with salad on the side. Veggie, are you a Doctor Who fan? I'm not sure if you've ever mentioned it on a video before. When you mentioned Richard Wilson it reminded me he's in episodes nine and ten (a two-parter) of the first series. They are probably my favourite two episodes in the first season. Would definitely recommend if you haven't seen them.

S1lm4r1l

@Hawwah > "I politely told you several times that I do not wish to enagage with you." You literally replied to one of my comments yesterday. > "You're not interested in a serious discussion." Pot calling the kettle black. > "You purposefully post claims that are both blatantly false and as outrageous as humanly possible, just to provoke me and elicit strong reactions from me. In other words, you're trolling." No I don't. I can back-up everything I've ever said with textual evidence. > "I told you repeatedly that I do not wish to participate in that." Don't reply to my comments then. > "Your further trolling attempts aren't going to convince me to start enganging with you again. On the contrary." One could describe your repeated and utterly nonsensical defence of Snape in similar terms. Snape gets treated differently to McGonagall because he treats the students differently to McGonagall. That's not difficult to understand. I'll do my best to avoid your comments. Despite their provocatively partisan perspective.

Hawwah

@Charlotte "you are always coming up with the most wild and non-sensical reaches to defend snapes actions" It would be very useful to me if you provided me with some examples; without them I have literally no idea what you are talking about. I'm always willing to discuss my views and my interpretation of the books with others*, it is actually a hobby of mine, but I have to have something to work with. Your criticism is so vague that I don't even know what exactly you're criticising. (*Except for S1lm4r1l. Heavens knows I tried, but even I have my boundaries.) "Snape is one of my fave characters" Same. "but i understand that he is flawed" Same. "and is supposed to be a morally grey character" Aaand there's where we start to differ. Severus Snape is the most selfless character of the series. He dedicated his life to the fight against Voldemort at the tender age of 20, and he stayed at that path, unwaveringly, for the next 18 years. He sacrificed everything he had - his personal life, his intellect, his ambitions, his reputation and in the end his very life - to help bring down Voldemort. He willingly put himself in mortal danger to protect others. He gave up everything and gained nothing, and he did it simply because it was the right thing to do. Please explain to me how all this constitutes "a morally grey character"? Or let me put it this way. If Severus is morally grey, then all the other characters are pitch black. "until deathly hallows we as readers are supposed to be annoyed by Snape" If this really was JKR's intention, then she failed miserably. When the first book came out, Snape immediately became one of the most popular HP characters and has remained one ever since. He's been repeatedly voted favorite HP character, or ended up close second, losing only to Hermione. (Yes, even before DH.) About the half of the fandom figured out Severus’ true allegiance before the final book came out. I still vividly remember those heated, never-ending discussions back then. Some of them still can be looked up on the old discussion forums. "we as readers are supposed to be annoyed" As far as I'm concerned, the only thing I am supposed to do as a reader, is to read. The books are canon, the author's intentions are not. Otherwise, why not just sell books equipped with manuals? "On page 30, you're supposed to be annoyed. On page 100, you're supposed to be sad. On page 150, you're supposed to laugh." No, thank you. "Snape, (alongside draco) are literally written by jkr to be the antagonists in harry’s school life and that’s just fact." Actually no, that's not a fact. Snape is a false antagonist (red herring) in the first book, but in the last chapter it's revealed that the real antagonist is actually Quirrell. At the end of HBP Snape becomes a false antagonist once again, but just like last time, he is vindicated in the end. Professor Snape was never an antagonist. He was just mistaken for one. "making it seem like he’s actually a really nice guy" Whoa, whoa, whoa, wait a moment. I never said Severus was a nice guy. He was not. I repeat, Severus Snape was not a nice person. But he was a good person. Those are two very different and completely unrelated concepts. "characters don’t have to be good people to be good characters" Absolutely! But that was never in question.

Hawwah

@S1lm4r1l "You literally replied to one of my comments yesterday." I replied to Rebecca May's comment. Is your name Rebecca May? "Don't reply to my comments then." I stopped replying to your comments months ago, when you claimed that Professor Quirrell cared about Harry's safety. "I'll do my best to avoid your comments." Don't "do your best". Just ignore me like I've been ignoring you. It's not that hard. Jeesh.

Isis Peoples

I disagree with your comment about the bogart. There's a particularly horrific bogart on the way in....lol I won't say what book 😉 and there it makes Harmonie reaction seem trivial Additionally your bogart may not be screaming out the room terrifing but that doesn't mean the next person's isn't. If IRL Harmonie was told by McGonagall she failed everything! She's indeed run out in tears screaming because her life would be "over". Also consider the unnatural stress Harmonie is under all year and the added intensity of exams. She's a haur away from massive breakdown, thus the screaming The true magic and skill in conquering a bogart is in conquering your fear. If you lack the ability to conquer you'd indeed be terrified Lastly, we talk strengths and weaknesses of our characters. Harry is BRAVE! To a fault. And his bravery carries him though the series. Harmonie often operates through/dispites her fears and her fears guide her decisions and often are her own worse enemy

itz_Cherise

McGonagall is Hermione’s Head of House as well as Deputy Headmistress, so if Hermione failed all of her classes, McGonagall would be the one to inform her and let her know what her options are. Hermione is not afraid of McGonagall, she’s afraid of failing classes. After all McGonagall wrote letters to the Ministry about Hermione being a model student in order for Hermione to get the time tuner. Why would she be afraid of her when she knows the high regard McGonagall holds her in? It’s VERY different from Neville who is very much afraid of Snape.

Isis Peoples

Hermonie is extraordinarily loyal and protective. Youll find shes at her most passionate, most protective, most willing to break some rules; When it comes to her friends. Sometimes the things shell do will seem out of character, until you reach like book 6 and realize: Oh No, Harmonie being outrageously loyal performing actions in contradiction to her other default traits is 100% in character. I encourage you to look at "book Harmonie" considering her trait to prioritize loyalty and how that may sway her decision making and rationale Particularly now around Hagrid shes feeling full support and fiercely protective Harmonie: ive been totally against maps your cloak sneaking out for your protection all year. But right now this very second Hagrid needs us, where is your cloak! Now lets go!

Rebecca May

A cheese, mayonnaise and crisp sandwich for me. :) I personally think that Hermione would always have been bookish, even before Hogwarts - that kind of hunger for reading and absorbing knowledge doesn't come out of nowhere, and needs to be nurtured. That being said, I absolutely think being accepted into Hogwarts would have amplified that quality far beyond what it might have been at a Muggle school! Hogwarts is absolutely a character in Harry Potter... It's why I get so emotional reading about or watching Hogwarts get destroyed in Deathly Hallows (particularly in the film). It's like watching someone you love fall apart and knowing they'll never be quite the same ever again. As far as Ron's opinions about werewolves go... While we know that the Weasley's are very accepting of Muggle-Borns, that doesn't necessarily mean that they are accepting of all outcasts in wizard society. Although Ron could also have learned those attitudes at school, rather than at home, I think learning them at home is much more likely - seeing as Harry doesn't seem to have picked up the same prejudices. (Lycanthropy as a metaphor for HIV/Aids isn't necessarily problematic at this point in the story, but it does become so later on!) Loved the video as always Veggie! I was hoping to watch it all yesterday but this week has just been so hectic for me.

S1lm4r1l

> "Severus Snape is the most selfless character of the series. He dedicated his life to the fight against Voldemort at the tender age of 20, and he stayed at that path, unwaveringly, for the next 18 years. He sacrificed everything he had - his personal life, his intellect, his ambitions, his reputation and in the end his very life - to help bring down Voldemort. He willingly put himself in mortal danger to protect others. He gave up everything and gained nothing, and he did it simply because it was the right thing to do." I won't force you to talk to me. But I will simply say on behalf of everyone else that I don't think you understand his character at all. This is a extremely fanciful, overly romantic, actively deceitful head canon. I'll also remind you that everything you wrote is also true of James Potter and Sirius Black. And unlike Snape, it didn't take someone they cared about being in the firing line before they clued up. Finally, (because you keep bringing it up as some sort of cardinal sin.) Yes. Quirrell did care about the safety of his students. Umbridge says that Quirrell was a good teacher, because he taught age-appropriate subjects and did not put his students in danger in the class room. Regardless of her many other flaws, Umbridge correctly deduces that both Hagrid and Trelawney are not up to scratch. Whilst all the other teachers pass her inspections. Quirrell cared about the safety of his students, or cared about appearing to be a good teacher enough to ensure none of them hurt themselves, with the exception of Harry, whom he was told to hurt by Voldemort. Harry and Ron refer to Quirrell's classes as 'a bit of a joke'. Indicating that they were neither exciting or dangerous. We have no other evidence whatsoever regarding Quirrell's attitude towards keeping his classes safe.

Kunzite Blossom

Same thing happened to me. I even edited mine and apparently it was still spoilery. I do think the part about communication seemed fair as we have seen the two near each other. and Crookshanks protecting Sirius. So they do seem to be able to communicate even at this point. I think what got yours was mentioning their plot to kill Peter, cause that wasn't brought up at this point. We just know Crookshanks knows Sirius and is willing to protect him, but we don't know about the killing plot.

Kunzite Blossom

A note on my bookclub post: I apologize if my comment had a spoiler. I did edit my comment after I was told it contained a spoiler as I mixed up chapters on my notes and forgot to separate a few chapters. At the time of writing my comment I was just about finished with my relisten and notes for Half Blood Prince, so I am quite a head and when looking back on Azkaban notes I didn't realize I hadn't separated them. I noticed a few days ago someone said it was still from future chapters although listening again to the chapters it doesn't appear to contain any spoilers as far as I'm aware. I did ask the person who told me it was still a spoiler for what was. Onto the review, I'd like to think Hermione had a love of knowledge prior to learning she was a witch, but after just made her work a little harder. She didn't want to attend a school where some of the students already had knowledge of magic and she knew nothing, which is why she started studying as soon as she could. I don't think that kind of effort would just come out of nowhere. It would have already needed to be there. Given both her parents are dentist, they had to have been good in school and probably expected the same of her. With the wand hand, I agree its probably what feels most comfortable. I'm also the same way just opposite. I'm left handed but playing guitar, using a mouse, throwing, etc. I use my right hand (I can kind of write with my right hand but it's worse). But I assume that's just what happens being left handed growing up in a right handed world. I find it interesting you are right handed but use your left for various things.

Ziro the Hutt

Watching Throne Of Blood too eh? You have some good tastes in films Veggie, Kurosawa was the man. He loved Shakespeare too, and Ran, a late film of his, is his interpretation of King Lear. Btw since you love Star Wars, there are many elements that Lucas used from another Kurosawa film called The Hidden Fortress, specifically around the droid characters.

Hawwah

"Hermione is not afraid of McGonagall, she’s afraid of failing classes." That's one of several possible interpretations. It's not some indisputable fact. "Why would she be afraid of her (....)? Because Hermione has been severely punished by McGonagall before. She also saw how severely McGonagall punished Neville recently. Hermione knows that if she fails/disappoints McGonagall, there will be harsh consequences. "It’s VERY different from Neville who is very much afraid of Snape." Again, that's an interpretation, not an indisputable fact. I could ask the same question, why would be Neville afraid of Snape? Especially since Snape's punishments are very tame in comparison to McGonagall's.

Diego Zenhäusern

I feel you there! I'm always anoyed at the fact that patreon only sometimes sends you a message when someone replies to your comment but not always. I mean, would it be that difficult to programm that or at least make it an option int he settings?

Diego Zenhäusern

I whole heartedly agree with you! There are many little things I don't like about these books but I still absolutely love them overall! It's the same with plotholes: Just because there are some plotholes that doesn't mean that the story suddendly is horrible and that you have to bend over backwards in order to come up with some explanation to enjoy it. It just means the author didn't think about this one thing and that is all it is💁‍♂️🙂

Diego Zenhäusern

I don't think this is a spoiler but I still won't go to much into it since it is kind of a plot point in a later book: Another problematic thing is that Lupin is basically the only really "good" werefolve we get to see. So the books throw shade on the characters being prejudiced but if you look a little deeper they're basically telling you that Lupin is just a good egg but most other werewolves still suck. Instead of doing the opposite where it shows us multiple good wereweolves that are just (constanly) missunderstood and then also Greyback to show that werwolves are also only people and so of course there are bound to be genuinely f*cked up ones as well.

Diego Zenhäusern

Well you just spared me the effort to explain my take on Hermione in muggle school because it is basically exactly the same. So thank you 😅🙂!

Diego Zenhäusern

Zucchini risotto To answer your question in the video on the Trelawney discussion: You said that you think Trelawney's response to Harry's prophecy was based on logic and not on a prediction of her own. So her being wrong wouldn't necesarily mean that her predictions are generally fake/wrong. Here is the passage from the book: "Harry cast his mind around and it landed on Buckbeak. "A hippogriff," he said firmly. "Indeed!" whispered Professor Trelawney, scribbling keenly on the parchment perched upon her knees. "My boy, you may well be seeing the outcome of poor Hagrid's trouble with the Ministry of Magic! Look closer... Does the hippogriff appear to... have its head?" "Yes," said Harry firmly. "Are you sure?" Professor Trelawney urged him. "Are you quite sure, dear? You don't see it writhing on the ground, perhaps, and a shadowy figure raising an axe behind it?" "No!" said Harry, starting to feel slightly sick. "No blood? No weeping Hagrid?" "No!" said Harry again, wanting more than ever to leave the room and the heat. "It looks fine, it's - - flying away..." Professor Trelawney sighed. "Well, dear, I think we'll leave it there.... A little disappointing... but I'm sure you did your best." Relieved, Harry got up, picked up his bag and turned to go, but then a loud, harsh voice spoke behind him." Now, Trelwaney doesn't outright say that she thinks Buckbeak will day because she has seen it herself, but she definitely strongly implies it. I mean if she were basing her repliy on facts and probability rather than her "knowledge" of the future she would say something like: "That doesn't seem very likely,,,but I guess we'll see." and not "A little disappointing...but I'm sure you tried your best." Also: It woudn't really make sense for Trelwaney to asses the quality of the students predictions based on logic/ probability rather than checking the predictions with her own "abilities", would it? I mean in that case it could might as well be McGonagall that is grading the exam🤔 So I don't see why we should assume that her implying buckbeak is going to die shouldn't be interpreted as another (implied) prophecy of hers. But to end on a lighter note: 1:17:13 "I'd be amazed if we hit 5h this time!" the dramatic ironie of this line is just comedy gold to me😂😅

Janie

@ Hawwah When was Hermione severely punished by McGonagall? If you mean when she sent Harry, Hermione and Neville into the Forbidden Forest in their first year, that was two years ago. I'm pretty sure Hermione got over it by now, and there's no mention anywhere in the books that Hermione has any kind of trauma because of it. Honestly, I have no idea how you manage to come up with some of your interpretations. It really baffles me.

Garry (Not Jerry)

I didn’t think your comment was a spoiler. Maybe the original version was. You are talking about the “stone throwing” event, which doesn’t happen in the book, but if it was it would be covered at two points in the story - so you could argue that you can’t talk about it until we have gone back in time and revisited that moment in the books?

Dara Jeeling

Sort of the same here - I can write with both hands equally "nice" and I can even do it with both hands at once. Needed to leran after breaking my right hand as a child several times. As a kid I was "right" handed - or so everyone thought until my mom discovered by acciddent that I tend to do all delicate things like sewing, stitching really all tinkering stuff with my left had as the domninat one.

Dara Jeeling

i am with you there when it comes to not reading certain users. After ONE really biased oppinion I just stopped reading andything that person posts - I have no wish to be in their line of fire. Heck, reading him/her I even thought I should probably quit eing a patreon. I decided against it and just ignore them. Wish there was an ignore button for those people I do not wish to read (or reply to my comments) And I am usually really interested in different views I find them fascinating But someone who thinks he/She understands what JKR meant and is not even able to discusss - because their oppinion is the only ne they wantto have... NO THANKS!

Jacqueline Chaiton

Ramen :) History of magic is mandatory from first year to fifth year. You can drop it after that. Also I think the difference with McGonagall being Hermione’s boggart and Snape being Neville’s, McGonagall is just the one telling her she failed. Failure is the real boggart. Neville’s is straight up just Snape. I imagine Ron would have gone last since his last name starts with W, but she wanted Harry to go last because *drama* As to whether McGonagall thinks poorly of Trelawny or divination in general, I think the correct answer to that is yes. No one won the quidditch cup in chamber because the tournament was cancelled after Hermione and Penelope were attacked. One theory on the whole not seeing Pettigrew on the map thing, one fan theory is that you can’t see someone in their animagus form on the map unless you know they are an animagus. There’s also a fun/sad theory about crookshanks but I can’t say more until deathly hallows. Also I’m glad you like my personal head canon thing 🤣 I do the same thing with the Disney Star Wars stuff, mainly because I don’t need to know what happens the day after happily ever after (ROTJ)

H

Kunzite: I answered you in the original thread now, but I can partly do it here as well, in slightly shorter form, in case you don't get a notification there: I completely misread your post, and therefore thought you hadn't edited it. I therefore sent a spoiler warning about it, but when reading it now I finally understood it the way you actually wrote it. 100% my fault. Especially annoying since your point wasn't mentioned by others, so it would be a great addition to the book club as well. At least it can still be mentioned later as well, so Veggie can still react to it, but still annoying that I misread it. I hope there are no hard feelings! It was a good comment.

S1lm4r1l

@Janie When you start from the opinion that Snape is a good person and work backwards, anything is possible.

Frederique Gillespie

Fish and chips today, tuna salad sandwich tomorrow. I love these. I'm finding out all kinds of fan theories I never heard of and watching your reactions is always so entertaining. Freddie

Janie

Pizza! I think Hermione was the same nerdy bookworm even before she started Hogwarts. People are usually born with this kind of passion for knowledge and Hermione's parents being very educated and inteligent people (they were dentists after all) just proves that it was probably a trait she inherited from them. Being accepted to a school of magic might have made her thirst for knowlege even greater, since she would learn a lot of new and interesting things, but she was always like that.

Shiby23

Since you enjoy Jacob Kawolski or whatever from Fantastic Beasts, i'll lay it out like this. You can leviosa you could achio, you could use spells on a MUGLE teacher without them having any form of defense other than detention. An actual MUGGLE teaching Muggle studies would just enforce the fact that they are "no mages" and it would become a larger problem seeing them as "weak". PS 1:30ish you brought up no one really does any area of effect type spell in the OG potter movies. After playing the game and you saying that now... I don't think there was a single spell that took out 2+ other than the patronus shield.

Caroline

I totally agree! It's sad that some fans overthink things so hard that they seem to lose every joy in the HP universe. Some topics are fun to discuss, but you shouldn't take them too seriously and stop when it's enough.

Kevin Morris

Steak The problem with a Muggle teaching at Hogwarts is that it’s established in the franchise that Muggles can’t see Hogwarts. It looks like a old, moldy ruin to them, so it would be hard for a Muggle professor to teach there, let alone even find it. The fact that this is established canon leads to a potential plot hole in the Fantastic Beasts films...

Jake M

Marzipan chocolate balls. Veggie, it's important to keep the book version of Quirrell's ending as the canonical one in your head! Otherwise the thestrals make no sense later on. Also it's particularly egregious the third movie never explains Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot and Prongs since in the fifth film he shouts out "They've got Padfoot!" while Umbridge has him hostage. I imagine movie watchers at the time must have been a little confused as to wtf Padfoot meant, given the last mention of that name was two films ago?

Thunderbird

hash browns The part where you choose either from the books or the movies, whichever you like better, is new to me. I just created two entirely different universes in my head, to me those are almost two separate stories. I also do this with different ships, honestly I don't even know anymore how many universes of Harry Potter exist in my mind. 😄

itsanursething

everything bagel chopped salad mix with shrimp A little late to the game on this one! I think a muggle born witch or wizard would make the best muggle studies teacher. They have the muggle knowledge and would likely live full time in the wizarding world. That just makes the most sense to me. About the boggarts. You don't CHOOSE your boggart. The boggart changes into whatever IT thinks will scare you the most, so you don't get a say. If you were to happen across one "in the wild" you don't have time to prepare what it's going to be. If that makes sense. So, yes, I agree, letting Neville embarrass "Professor Snape" (the boggart, why it's in quotes) wasn't super professional, he couldn't help who it turned into. Just like Hermione didn't choose Professor McGonagall to be her boggart. P.S. GO HAWKS!!! Yes, I'm from Seattle.

itsanursething

Hogwarts is DEFINITELY a character! The first time I went to Leavesden Studios, when I walked around the corner into the room with the model of Hogwarts that they used to film...I burst into tears! I started saying "it's real!" over and over. Yeah...I'm that cool.

Giorgia M

I wouldn’t worry!! I don’t think Veg will read the replies, similar to the book club. Yeah definitely agreed, she could’ve used that opportunity in a much better way, instead of just highlighting the issue but not actually challenging the prejudice. Since 50% of our supposed “gay” representation is evil and targets children specifically (when that’s a horrible lie that used to be circulated about gay people) I feel extremely uncomfortable by it. Seems like she may have just added in the gay thing after, trying to be socially conscious but not really doing much to make it consistent and thematically sound. At best it’s ignorant and performative and at worst, it’s homophobic.

Rebecca May

Awww that's so sweet!! I definitely had tears in my eyes the first time I saw that model too, it's incredibly special ♥

Anders Ekren

Chili beans with tomato sauce!

Darcy

Yup exactly, I didn't going detail with my comment bc he hasn't learned about Fenrir yet but the children thing is disgusting. Especially with what we know about JK now, it's not surprising she would make that comparison

Regina

I see that no one commented about Wolfstar here so I will do that now. I read the books as a late teen and was desperate for some representation. So maybe I read too much into it (though I felt like I was proven right when the director of this movie told David that his character was gay and so David and Gary actually acted as if Remus and Sirius were estranged lovers). There’s lots of little moments in this book where Lupin acts strange when Sirius is mentioned. In a way he doesn’t when it concerns James or Peter. But really it’s the 5. book that stood out to me. I might comment on a few of them if I don’t forget. I still love Remus/Tonks (and find it a little funny that she’s Sirius’ cousin) but my LGBTQ-heart just wanted Sirius/Remus to be a thing. It would also make Remus’ story that much more heartbreaking if he had to believe that the person he loved killed his best friend and not ‘just’ a friend betraying another friend.

Insanityandbeyond

omg you'll never read this now but you talking about Much Ado at the Beginning, and Kenneth and Emma Thompson and Unmbridge in is so interesting. Because I wonder if you know the real rather tragic lore . Helena Bonham Carter is also in it aka Bellatrix. At the time, Lockhart and Emma Thompson were married and british acting modern royalty almost, and a year after the film Kenneth started an affair with Helena Bonham Carter, who was good friends with Emma Thompson too. All three in Harry Potter, and in the 90s involved in BBC period dramas and the like. Its kinda fascinating because looks wise and everything else its almost the mirror image British version of the Brad/Angelina/Jen thing