Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

THIS PART OF THE BOOK CLUB IS NOW COMPLETE!  SEE YOU NEXT TIME! :)

Here is a chance to get your comment read out in the next Book review video!

If you are reading along with the reviews, we are covering chapters "Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot and Prongs" and "The Servant of Lord Voldemort"! So if you have any thoughts, opinions, comparisons or questions regarding these, please leave a comment below!

I do have to ask, try to keep them fairly short, like 4 or 5 sentences.  That way I can cover more when making the video.  Also try to keep them on subject and not referencing anything that we are yet to cover. Ideally, keep it to 1 comment each if you can (if you have more to say after commenting, you can edit it and add to it! :) ).  These are just rough guidelines rather than rules, I want to be able to fit in as many of you as possible! :)

NEW FEATURE!! - As some of you may want to make a comment, but not have it replied to by others, you can now Message me your thoughts on the chapters by DM'ing me on here.  If you do, please follow all the above rules, especially avoiding mentioning things in future chapters or books!  Oh and please start your DM message with "Book Club -"!

To anyone that does reply to comments below, please make sure you are being friendly and respectful!  A lot of tone and meaning can be lost in text, after all!  If you disagree with someone on something, keep it polite and remember the golden rule in life - Sometimes you have to just agree to disagree! :)

Thanks, guys!! :)

Files

Comments

Raider Max

The Marauders story is one of things most fans of the books agree was the number one thing left out of the book. Absolutely an amazing piece of back story. This is a other one of my favorite chapters of the entire series. Chefs kiss!

Methanoutput

I'm so excited for these chapters; everything makes so much more sense to me in the books, as I mentioned in my comment during the previous book club! I know that many other points will be brought up by other people, but the thing that stood out for me was the explanation of the Whomping Willow. I mean, why it was planted at all on school grounds. I genuinely hope that this might take a bit less than 5 hours. I mean, it must be really exhausting! But I can imagine that you might love to talk about this stuff for a long time, and I would love to listen for a long time too! As always, can't wait to hear your thoughts, and I hope you're doing well, Veggie!

Raider Max

Agreed! That blew my mind the first time I read it. Lupin is such a tragic character.

FrenchieG

I also think the exclusion of chapter 18 and the explanation of Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot, and Prongs is the biggest omission in the films. This chapter sets up why Sirius and Lupin are such an important part of Harry’s life, why Harry’s patronus is a stag, and why Snape has such a hatred for this group of boys. I think it’s a crucial part of understanding the rest of the story.

Diego Zenhäusern

Something that I didn't think about when I read this book as a kid, but that I've come to realize in recent rereads: The "prank" Sirius played on Snape was actually an incredible betrayal of trust towards Lupin! I mean imagine if Lupin had had to life with the fact that he killed Snape just because Sirius had pulled a "prank" on him.😮 So nowadays I'm actually surprised that Lupin could forgive him for that. (Though I don't think it's unrealistic or anything since I was perfectly ready to look past Sirius attempted murder of Snape myself when I read those books for the first time and was about the age the characters would have been in the story🙈😅)

Marianne

Hi Veggie! Chapter 18 made me desperate for a marauders story with Lupin being the main character. The story of his childhood and how Dumbledore was determined to give him a chance at a normal school life is so interesting and tragic to me. Lupin has always been my favourite character and I would love to see his story from being a newly bitten werewolf at 5 years old, to an adult who has lost everything and trying to be accepted in the magical community. I would watch that TV show in a heartbeat!

Sandra

Hi Veggie :) It always frustrated me that when Scabbers is revealed as Pettigrew, no one cast Petrificus Totalus (muscle-freezing spell) on him. Sirius says he'd better not scarper by turning back into a rat when Pettigrew is bound. PP is such a complete idiot, I bet he hadn't even thought of using his Animagus powers to escape. Of course The Servant of Lord Voldemort must escape for the HP series to continue, but it still annoys me :) I absolutely love that the Weasleys’ lottery win is the way Sirius knew where Pettigrew was. It makes the ‘waste of money’ Egypt holiday pay off so much. Sirius says “he’s at Hogwarts” in his sleep, after he reads the Prophet article where it says “where the five younger children attend”. To have such an important pay off is so good. Have a great day from Bristol!

Dara Jeeling

Controversial oppinion incoming... Chapter 18 is one of the reasons I am a) not a fan of the Marauders per se (group bullying and playing dangerous "pranks" on a fellow student) b) Sirius for me is just what people use to call Snape - a bully ( and after Pettigrew my least favorite Marauder) to be honest, the only Marauder I like is Lupin - I still think he was irresponsible, but I like him. and yes, I can hear the screams... don't care, actually! Lupin states, that James and Snape had a disliking towards each other ( we know why) but I always wondered, why Sirius also had that disliking. BUT as being someone who was bullied at an all girls school (yes boarding school) - I am not okay with what was done (for whatever reason) to Snape. And the "prank" Sirius tried to pull - for me that is no prank but a murder attempt - at the cost of one of his "best friends". If you have friends like this, you do not need enemies! James reaction sets him apart - because he stopped "the prank" Lupin had no fault in it - since we already know that being tranformed he can do nothing but attack - sort of And honestly? Do not even get me started on Dunderbore - ahem - Dumbledore... a responsible headmaster would have made sure Sirius got expelled for that and would not force the victim to never speak about it. Is it a wonder, Snape hates every single one of this group? (he did not know until that night, that it was Sirius who was trying hard to get him killed) I am NOT okay with Snape wanting to put both Sirius and Remus into Askaban - but I get why he hates them! sorry for the long rant!

Rebecca May

Hi Veggie 😊 I know you’re aware of the argument that anyone who likes Snape has been blinded by Alan Rickman’s portrayal of him. While I personally find that argument insulting, I think a similar logic could be applied to Sirius Black and Gary Oldman (this was touched upon in the last book club). After all, Gary Oldman’s portrayal of Black is so heartfelt and charming, you can’t help but love him. He makes it so easy to forget what we learn about Sirius in the books. In these chapters we find out so much that makes me incredibly angry at Sirius – and I feel so bad for Snape. Sirius was willing to commit murder when he was just sixteen, and nearly twenty years later, he still believes that Severus deserved to die. Why? Because he had the audacity to question the Marauders and dared to poke his nose into their business. That Sirius sees nothing wrong with this totally disgusts me. Can you imagine how Lupin would have felt after returning to human form and finding out that he’d killed someone, all because Sirius thought it would be funny? Don’t get me wrong, I wish Snape had got a hold of himself long enough to listen to Lupin and Sirius explain about Peter. But I understand why he’d have difficulty seeing Sirius as innocent, or incapable of betrayal and murder, after everything Sirius put him through. It must have been awful for Severus… Forced to cover up the fact that someone literally tried to kill him, and watch those responsible carry on with their lives as though nothing happened. It’s pretty clear that the Marauders never faced any consequences for this.

Hawwah

Dara and Rebecca already summed up perfectly my thoughts on the incident that nearly cost Severus Snape his life when he was 16. It was a murder attempt. Not a "prank". A prank is only a prank if the target finds it funny as well. That's clearly not the case here. Remember when Harry was having tea with Lupin and Severus came in and brought the potion? This is how he was described in that scene: "He backed out of the room, unsmiling and watchful." [PoA, chapter 8.] Severus Snape is the bravest man Harry ever knew (Harry's words, not mine), and yet, when he's near Lupin, he's watchful and makes sure not to turn his back to him. That's trauma manifesting. And yet, when Severus learns that Black is hiding in the Shrieking Shack, he doesn't hesitate. He doesn't waste any time and immediately sets off to the place where he almost died. School is in danger - students are in danger - that's all that matters to him. He's indeed the bravest character of the series. As for Black, if he wants to convince people he's not a deranged murderer, he shouldn't laugh about his past murder attempt and claim it served his victim right. As for Lupin, if he wanted to get Severus on board, he really shouldn't have diminished his near-death experience and resulting trauma as a "schoolboy grudge". What an awful thing to say. I don't blame Severus for losing it. PTSD is no joke.

Hawwah

Thank you for this.

Sandra

"I wish Snape had got a hold of himself long enough to listen to Lupin and Sirius explain about Peter."- Snape is so logical. A genius. Perhaps the extent of the Marauders' bullying (and almost being killed as a child!) understandably clouds this logic with solid hate.

Rebecca May

@Hawwah You're welcome. 😊 I've actually had this comment prepped for a while because I thought it was really important to say, and these chapters were the right time to bring it up.

Rebecca May

@Sandra - I really do think so! I know he explains the Trio's behaviour later on by saying they were under some kind of enchantment... But I think it completely makes sense that Snape just can't see past the image he has in his head of these people. It's sad but I can't really blame him.

Dara Jeeling

I can only agree - Snape is a very brave character. Not saying he is great per se - but he has always been the best written character and my favorite one. also... do not let special persons get to you!

Hawwah

@Sandra Yes, he was unhinged in that scenes. But I think it's worth noting that it was Lupin who really triggered his PTSD. Severus was still relatively calm until Lupin called his near-death experience and resulting trauma a "schoolboy grudge". Then he really lost it and I don't blame him.

Rebecca May

@Hawwah - Yeah, much as I love Lupin, him straight-up minimising Severus’ trauma really, really annoyed me

Hawwah

Thank you, Dara :)

Monique

Interesting you think it was to be helpful due to safety of the school or kids. I always took from it that it was more because he was thrilled to be 'right' about Lupin and get his chance at revenge. I also think that lots of folks don't put together the reason Lily and Snape were not friends when she died. He and his friends were to the Marauder's what Malfoy, Crab and Goyle are to Harry, Ron and Hermoine. He was involved with dark magic. He was going around calling people mud bloods, hence why Lily ended their friendship. He called her a mudblood. Snape wasn't just an innocent outcast that people picked on. Or at least that was my take on it when it becomes clear why he and Lily didn't have any relationship after they left school. I just mention it because I remember being shocked that he had done that to her after she had been his friend for years and years. Interesting to read your take on it though

Will

Where should I even begin with? Let's just begin with Peter Pettigrew. I believe that he is one of the most hated characters in Harry Potter and for good reason, but oh my god, he is so interesting. People underestimate how smart and talented Peter is. He is an animagus, that should be enough proof. Yes he did need all the help he could get but in the end, how much could James and Sirius really do for him? He became an animagus successfully and that is on him. He also gave Voldemort information for a year before Voldemort killed Lily and James. Peter was a death eater and he kept that a secret for a year. He is a very vile man but there is no denying how smart and cunning he was. And let's not forget that he was the one to kill the 12 muggles instead of Sirius. Peter is not a bad wizard, he is not useless just a little pathetic. And he is for sure one of the best death eaters Voldemort could have. And yes let's talk about Sirius's prank. As I have said, Sirius is my favorite character in the whole series. But how stupid and hateful can a person be to try to get someone else killed? He doesn't even seem to regret it. Come on Sirius, you're better than this. I'm very interested to hear your thoughts about Peter, Veggie.

Hawwah

@Monique No, it was the other way around. The Marauders were to Severus what Draco and his goons were to Harry - except about 1000x worse. Draco, as bad as he was, never tried to feed Harry to a werewolf and never sexually assaulted him in front of a crowd. Draco was primarily a verbal bully. He very rarely resorted to physical violence. James on the other hand was a full blown sadist.

Rebecca May

Just want to jump in here and say YES. Completely agree with all of this (probably controversial to someone, but not to me 😂). My feelings towards Sirius are a bit complicated, but he's absolutely a bully.

Hawwah

I'm not trying to start an argument. Also, if you don't want to discuss with me for whatever reason, that's fine and you're absolutely entitled to that. But since you yourself described Sirius as stupid and hateful for trying to get Severus killed - and you acknowledge that he doesn't regret it even 15+ years later - I wonder why is he your favorite character?

Will

One of the reasons is because I watched the movies first and I saw Gary as Sirius and I found Gary really attractive. Then I read the books as a child close to being a teenager and back then, a huge Marauders fans so I didn't think anything of the prank. So I just found everything about Sirius to be cool and sexy and all that. Now as an adult, I can actually see the flaws he has. This prank, how he treats Kreacher... when he did that prank, he was a teenager and since then he has grown, he has become a better person. And while it seems that he doesn't regret the prank, it's probably because he knows that Snape is alive and well so he probably believes no harm was done. So yea Sirius is my favorite because he's just really cool and sexy and nostalgia also plays a big part of it.

Hawwah

Hi Dara! I want to join Rebecca and say a big YES to your comment. (With one exception - I dislike all the Marauders. I used to like Lupin but after SWM I couldn't anymore.) Your opinion really shouldn't be controversial. It's one thing to dislike a character and a whole another thing to argue he should have been murdered at the age of 16. (And yes, sadly a substantial part of the fandom argues exactly that.)

Lisette C.

Hi Veggie! This is my second favorite book in the series and these chapters here are largely why. I just love complex characters <3 I find it's really telling how Lupin speaks about Snape here. It is so clear that he has put their childhood disagreements behind him and that he now deeply appreciates Snape for agreeing to make the Wolfsbane potion for him. Neither Snape nor Sirius has gotten that far. Also, when Lupin talks about the possibility of him biting someone during the Marauders' nightly adventures, he sounds incredibly sad. Makes me wonder if he has ever bitten anyone. He has lived many years as a dangerous werewolf after all. He might not even know if he did. Hard to imagine the toll that must take on someone's conscience. I personally love Snape. Both in book and movie version (and I read the books before there were movies to confuse Alan Rickman into it all). But in this scene we really get to see his bad sides. His childhood trauma is so all consuming that he seems to be caught in a flashback of sorts. He is unable to listen to reason, almost like he is caught in a fight-or-flight moment. It's heartbreaking. And poor Neville who never lost his list of passwords. My head canon was always that Pettigrew never shifted back (simply to avoid being recognized), but this time I noticed the specific description of him pointing with his middle finger, because he had lost the other. And it got me thinking… Would someone do that naturally, if he had been a rat since he lost his finger? I would imagine it would feel awkward due to lack of practice.

Dara Jeeling

Monique... For me, too the Marauders where the ones bullying. They usually went 4 on one - very brave. It started, because James was a snob - who thought he was better then Snape AND wanted to get to know Lily better. How would you react, if someone exposed your underwear in front of a large crowd? Not saying that Snape calling Lily the M word was great - but he had just been exposed in front of a lange group of peers. He was just a teen and may have lashed out. He tried to apologize. Snape was imvolved with dark magic, yes, he was. Have you spared a thought sbout who would want to be friends wuth the kid who was constantly harrassed and bullied by a group of populat kids? Let me tell you (as someone who was bullied a lot in school ) that most of your peers ignore you or also pick on you. Most people do not wosh to be your friend, because they fear of being bullied, too. So you are not choosy and take which ever friends you can get. Let me also tell you, that one can loose their composure and temper if things go badly for a long time. I broke one of my bullies nose - one day - after she dripped hot wax down on my head. My friends in school were either older and tried to help - or younger. I am far from "Snape was innocent" but I csn sort of understand why he had the friends he had - and even to a degree why he was so into the dark Art.

Kunzite Blossom

The explanation of the marauders, a big detail ignored in the films. Thoughts on Ron and Hermione also attacking Snape, not just Harry like the film? Thoughts on Crookshanks's role in all this? Even stealing Neville's password list! Really makes me feel bad for Neville's punishment he received earlier. He didn't technically lose it, it was stolen.

Jacob sparks

Finally you get the information overload. It's the information in these chapters I believe that makes you think oh that's why when reading a 2nd time. Yes we have time turner to come but some of this information has been relevant to events not only in this book but the other 2 books as well.

Alchemist

Hi Veggie, I'm a fellow diehard Huffie commenting for the first time! Keeping it short to not make the next video even longer. ;) I just want to say that I find it amazing that the Marauders went through the looong and difficult process of becoming animagi, just out of solidarity with Remus. I wish I had friends like that - amazing!

S1lm4r1l

Superb piece of characterization, Sirius has been giving the rat 'murder eyes' for ages. Only the mention of Snape diverts his attention. In an earlier book club, I mentioned that other people remember the 'incident' differently to Snape. Lupin says that Sirius alone pranked Snape and James saved him. Sirius does not contradict this version of events. James Potter risked his own life to save Snape's, a person he hated. When Lupin reveals his condition, James Potter nor Sirius are scared at all. Most wizards are utterly terrified of Werewolves. They both stick by him. They become Animagi for him. It's a beautiful friendship. Everyone from Hagrid, McGonagall, Dumbledore, Flitwick, Rosmerta, Fudge, says James Potter was a great person. Even Voldemort says he "admired his bravery" and yet because Snape says otherwise, a lot of fans think he's completely terrible. Sirius says that Snape waged a continuous campaign of trying to get the Marauders thrown out of school. This doesn't justify what Sirius did at all, but it isn't hard to understand why Sirius wanted to scare Snape and wasn't fussed about possibility that Snape could've been infected too. He'd have been in the same boat as Lupin. An important point I should stress. Werewolf attacks can end in death, but these cases are rare. Finally, the contrast between the 2 adults who care the most about Harry is very interesting. Snape belittles, ignores, rages and completely refuses to listen to Harry, whilst Sirius understands Harry's reservations. He respects Harry, listens to him, and accepts his decision to let Pettigrew live, even if he disagrees with it. Very interested to hear what you think of Pettigrew, did they cast right with Timothy Spall? Someone has created CGI images of certain characters: https://www.buzzfeed.com/alexalisitza/harry-potter-ai Some we haven't met yet obviously, but they might help to get certain actors out of your head. (Might edit this later.)

Hawwah

Thank you for answering.

Rod

Hey Veggie, hope you're having a great time. I've read this book multiple times, but here's something I just noticed now: why wasn't the tunnel to the Shrieking Shack blocked during the year? Earlier they were even closing mouse holes, but no one thought of closing a passage linking the school grounds to a perfect hideout? At least Dumbledore, Lupin and Snape know this passage exists, and they also know Sirius is aware of it. Maybe other teachers do too. Lupin might not want to mention it because of his shame about his past, but Dumbledore (who created the tunnel to begin with) and Snape wouldn't have such concerns, and would be more worried about keeping Sirius out. Seems like a tremendous oversight.

S1lm4r1l

> "but I always wondered, why Sirius also had that disliking." Because Sirius resented the fact that Snape envied his upbringing. Sirius was pure-blood. Born to wealthy parents, a scion of an ancient and noble wizarding family. He had almost every conceivable advantage it is possible to be born with in the Wizarding World. Sirius hated it. He hated his parents, hated their arrogance, their disdain for half-bloods and muggleborns. Hated their cruelty, their obsession with dark magic. Hated how their politics changed his younger brother and that Regulus died for their beliefs. Snape was the sort of person that the Blacks wanted for their son. The son Sirius refused to be. Cunning, talented, resourceful, an active practitioner of dark magic. A budding Death Eater in the making. Someone worthy of the name Black.

Ashley Evers

It was always my impression that Mrs. Figg was lying about being able to see the dementors, so she could be a witness for Harry. I could be wrong though.

Dara Jeeling

and Sirius detected ALL of that on the first train ride? He should have been a seer! as stated before, I think that the Marauders had a big part in Snape choosing to be a Death eater. Also... I would really love you, to ignore me. I do not post on your comments, since I can never agree with you, so please from now on stop replying to me. Thank you

Rebecca May

It's established that Snape believes every one of the Marauders was in on the so-called "prank". As such, I would hazard a guess that Snape views James' rescue attempt as self-preservation because if Severus had died, at the very least Sirius would have been thrown out of Hogwarts, and possibly James too. So in Snape's mind, James was simply trying to preserve his friendship group and stop them from getting expelled. Again, just a guess, but a good one I think. :) (Not saying that saving Snape wasn't the brave or right thing to do: it definitely was. James has his good points, but I just don't like him much... Not because "Snape says so", but through my own judgement of events seen or spoken about in the books. While we're on the topic though, Snape also risks his life for people he hates... Surely if you admire that behaviour in one person, it should be admired in another?) Also, I'm genuinely interested to see the source of your information for the point - "Werewolf attacks can end in death, but these cases are rare," if you were able to find it? I'd never heard that, and I'd be interested to read more. :) Either way, it's clear that Severus believed - rightly or wrongly - that he was very close to death during that experience.

S1lm4r1l

The Tunnel goes from the grounds to the Shrieking Shack, a building that you cannot get out of. They wanted to protect Harry and other students. Nobody ever thought there was a chance anyone would get inside the Shrieking Shack. Completely correctly as it turns out. Even Fred and George never find out where it goes. Only reason Harry and Hermione do is because they watch Sirius drag Ron into the tunnel.

Rebecca May

Still bizarre that no-one ever considered that Sirius could have been hiding out in there though, once they knew Sirius had made it onto school grounds...

Katie

You're right Ashley - JKR has confirmed that squibs can't see dementors and that Mrs Figg was lying. My head canon is that witches and wizards can invite muggles (and squibs) to these hidden magical places. Hermione's parents visit Diagon Alley because they are shown how to get there, otherwise they'd never see the entrance to the Leaky Cauldron. I think it's the same with Hogwarts and Filch would have been shown how to get there. Otherwise squibs and muggles wouldn't be able to get close enough to the castle to see it because they suddenly realise they need to be somewhere urgent.

Ashley Evers

I guess we can rule out the theory that only the Marauders can see each other on the map, since Snape can see Lupin on it in these chapters. A couple of people have already mentioned this, but I certainly do have the same problem with Sirius andRemus as I do with Snape. Their actors are all so talented and charming, and the movies leave out their worst moments. Movie Sirius is one of my favorite characters, but I’m struggling to find much to like about book Sirius. It’s interesting to hear Sirius describe Peter as wanting to know that Voldemort was “the biggest bully in the playground”, especially since we know that the Marauders did behave like bullies sometimes. Don’t get me wrong, I think Snape’s sins are ultimately worse, but the Marauders have done some terrible things as well.

Jake M

Harry is so blasé with his "one treasured possession" that he inherited from his father... In the first book he leaves the invisibility cloak at the top of the Astronomy Tower (did we ever establish how Dumbledore knew it was there? I think he knew about the whole Norbert thing and that's why he gives Gryffindor the lost 150 points back at the end and a bonus ten for the trapdoor shenanigans, knowing they were just trying to help Hagrid... Anyway, wrong book). Two years later, he's left it lying around a vicious tree for his least favourite teacher to find! I would not trust Harry with anything important, physical or otherwise- tell him a secret and Ron/Hermione will know within the hour, after all XD If only Snape had waited a few more minutes before his pantomime 'TADA' reveal (I like to imagine it complete with fabulous jazz hands), especially since Pettigrew's name had already been mentioned...if he'd witnessed the truth, do you think he would have helped clear Black's name, or denied everything out of spite?

Jake M

Great point about Oldman being affable- for me I read the books first but I think maybe i was too young (six or seven?) to consider the serious implications of his actions, and thought it nothing more than a silly prank? I connected to Black as a father figure who actually cares about Harry for once (I grew up without one) so liked him despite his flaws.I don't think anyone here means to be insulting if they mention the Rickman portrayal, for me it's always fascinating how certain characters become favourites and so I have definitely asked questions that may come across as rude without meaning to 🫣 Even today I'm still struggling to work out exactly why I like Lupin so much! But it's hard to interrogate myself, people would think I'm mental 🤣

Jake M

Ooh, the marauders causing him to become a Death Eater is an interesting thought! I do wonder, were they nicer to him, would he have hung around with them, or at least a group that Lily didn't find detestable? It seems like Snape largely grouped himself with people who accepted who he was, unlike Sirius and Prongs who mocked him from minute one.

Dara Jeeling

My experience sadly shows that kids/teens are reluctant (to say the least) to befriend someone who is bullied by a group of peers - so I always wondered if Snape would have been able to have other friends had the circumstances be different... I know he was sn odd one (or what kids/teens see as odd), he had his flaws and may have been into the Dark Arts already... that does not excuse the M word - and I guess he gave as good as he was able to. But I think the Marauders treatment (and Dunderhead - I mean Dumbledores ignorance) may have left Snape with little choice as to who he could be friends with. Obviously all of Gryffindor was out...

Dara Jeeling

can I ask a question? if you do not wish to answer, look at it as s rethorical one, please! What sins do you see in Snape? As said, it can be rethorical - since I know the flaws I see in him

Dara Jeeling

I liked book Snape first. A lot of my views are based on the books - and I had to reread a few times, whenever someone brings up good points. Also... as much as I loved Alan Rickman - he (and Maggie Smith) were two casting choices I did not like. To old... I enjoy seeing him as Snape - but I enjoy him in each role (maybe not Hans Gruber so much) but I was always like "he's supposed to be 30+"

Michelle Linardis

I wholeheartedly agree with Dara, Hawwah, and Rebecca. Lupin is the Marauder I can tolerate a little bit more, but I would have liked him better if he learned to stand up to his friends and realise how toxic they were for him. How they treated a peer who never instigated a single attack, is appalling. No prank/joke/trick should EVER put someone's life at risk.

Michelle Linardis

Hey Veggie! Ah, now the reasons have been brought to light of Snapes’ further resentment of Remus, Sirius, and James. The prank/joke/trick – Something that is sadly played off so light-heartedly, is actually rather traumatic and devastating the more you think about it. Snape was tricked into going into the Whomping Willow, not knowing what he’d find there. Instead, coming face to face with a fully transformed werewolf, one who was not lucky enough for Wolfsbane in this time. Snape was so close to being mauled/turned/killed, and yet people think it’s a joke. I mean, no wonder Snape wanted them expelled, and for a good reason, too. The Marauders were seriously dangerous, and Snape was silenced by Headmaster Dumbledore himself. For someone who was relentlessly bullied (JKR’s words), that’s just heartbreaking. He couldn’t even get support from the staff. Something convinced Snape to go in the Whomping Willow, and it must have been a powerful enough reason to send him in there. My guess is that Sirius must have told Snape that Lily went in there and was in danger – why else would he listen to Sirius? After all, it was a prank. I mean essentially, Sirius weaponised his best friend just to eliminate someone who he bullied for years. And yet people (and here, I mean some fans), blame Snape for this. Honestly, my heavy opinion of my dislike of the Marauders and their behavior is a reason that makes me feel appalled to be a Gryffindor. Just to this present situation – Snape was yet again, silenced. Snape knew Sirius was capable of murder, so it only makes sense he believed him to be Lily’s killer. When you put yourself in Snape’s shoes here, you see things very differently. Seeing people dismiss a childhood trauma and labeling it a 'childhood grudge', really breaks my heart.

Annamarie schwirian

I feel these chapters are so important to the overall arch of Harry's story line ,especially telling his father's past.

Ashley Evers

I'm pretty sure I could write a thesis or two on that subject, but I'll try to sum up and focus on the worst ones :) The fact is that from the very beginning, Snape was extremely attracted to the Dark Arts. And that’s not just a scary term for magic, there are plenty of dramatic, damaging spells that aren’t considered ‘Dark Arts’. This is magic that is especially cruel and/or destructive. When he was following his own personal inclinations, he voluntarily chose to attach himself to a group of genicidal blood purists, in spite of the fact that he had to know that they specifically hated a group that included the person he claimed to love the most in the world. He knew when he told Voldemort the prophecy that it would lead to the deaths of the family involved, or at the very least the child. And this is where Snape isn’t served very well by the information we are given. I understand why, we see things from Harry’s point of view, so we can’t see everything that Snape would have been feeling or thinking, but as far as I can tell, Snape regrets getting Lilly killed. And that’s it. We are never given any other motivation for his actions. We are never shown any evidence that his opinions have changed in any other way. We are shown that he is still attracted by the Dark Arts and still enjoys being needlessly cruel. Honestly, this is a failure on the author’s part. I think she thought his ‘love’ was more of a redemption than I do. At first I felt the same way, but the more I think about him being obsessed with a woman who rejected him years before she died for the very valid reason that he was racist against people like her specifically, the less I see his ‘love’ as a redeeming quality. Especially as he was perfectly fine with her husband and son dying. All the evidence suggests that if it had been Neville’s family instead of Harry’s, Snape would have gone on being just fine with racial cleansing and the murders he facilitated. Like I said, it’s possible that he came to deeply regret all his former beliefs and actions, not just the ones that led to Lilly’s death specifically. But we aren’t really given any evidence of that. We are given evidence that he is still cruel and vindictive, even when there is no possible benefit to himself. I feel very, very sorry for him on many levels, and he is a very interesting character, but I’m not very sympathetic toward him anymore, I’m afraid.

Darcy

Something that I think is important to think about here is that Snape was a part of Voldemort's inner circle during the first Wizarding War. It is very likely he knew that Sirius had been framed and that Peter was the one to give up James and Lily's location. Snape said nothing and allowed Sirius to go to jail for murder because of a high school grudge.

Darcy

It makes more sense for Sirius to have not moved on since he has been in jail with dementors feeding off of him for 12 years. He hasn't had the chance to grow, mature, and move on

Lisette C.

Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love Sirius too 🙂❤️

Methanoutput

Yeah many people like the backstory of the Marauders and i do too! But they are not necessarily perfect people... Even now, when you would forget about all the bullying, i don't like Sirius that much and i don't think Harry would have had it better, if he lived with a 'free Sirius'. If i could wish for Harry to have another 'start' or home, i think i would like him to live with Tonks and her parents. Mainly because she is my favorite character and i think it would be fun. :D

John Phillips

There's no basis in this assumption. Snape thought Sirius was the rat and was angry for good reason.

Rebecca May

@Jake M - Thanks! I was six years old when I started reading the books, and I think I’ve liked Sirius less and less every time. While I know he has his good points, I think I love him only for who he is to Harry and to Lupin, and not for himself… If that makes sense? I always enjoy your comments, nothing ever comes across as insulting… But some people (not necessarily here on Patreon, but in the community generally) certainly do mention Alan Rickman in a way that is definitely meant to downplay the intelligence of people who like Snape! Again, totally not referring to you though 😊

Rebecca May

@Dara - I’m sorry to hear that you didn’t like Alan Rickman’s casting… I thought he was perfect. Of course too old, it would have been great if he was younger, but an actor’s age has always mattered very little to me if they can portray the spirit of the character faithfully in all other respects. I think I read the first book before watching the film and then experienced the rest alongside each other… It was so long ago now! 😅

Florian

ok, I see, I messed up last time, I listened along and got one chapter ahead without noticing. So I keep the question for this time. What do you think about Sirius ability to communicate with Crookshanks to plan Peter's assassination? Also, I think it is quite funny that there quite a few plot holes in the Harry Potter series, J.K.R tried to talk away, and even the Fandom like us need to create head cannons to make sense of them xD

Marianne

Ah okay thank you for clearing it up. It's just something I always assumed but I guess it was never confirmed. I have edited my comment so that Veggie isn't told incorrect information.

Thunderbird

Those chapters are amazing, so much backstory and information! Some of my favourites from the whole series. 😊 Also Sirius’ line «I want to commit the murder I was imprisoned for» gives me chills every time I read it. I read through a few comments before and find the discussions of Snape and Sirius very interesting. As for me, Sirius is my favorite character in the whole series BUT he already was before I saw the movies. I was actually a bit disappointed when I saw he was portrayed by Gary Oldman for the first time. Not because I don’t like him (I think he is an amazing actor) but because in my head Sirius looked very different. It took me a few watches but now I enjoy Oldman’s portrayal of Sirius very much. Also I wanted to say that although Sirius is my favorite character I absolutely hate the «prank» he pulled on Snape. There is no excuse that would justify what he did. And to me it is very sad that Sirius and Snape both are blinded by their hatred for each other so much that they are not willing to listen to what the other has to say. The reason why I like Sirius so much is that although he seems (or seemed) like this very fun and carefree character, he is incredibly passionate about the people he loves and would do anything for them. Him being wrongly imprisoned for killing his best friends just breaks my heart.

Jake M

@Rebecca it definitely makes sense! Since the books are written from Harry's perspective we mostly get his rose-tinted Impression of Sirius- while he's alive, at least. I think he does start to consider his negative traits in hindsight (mainly his treatment of Kreacher) but as readers we mostly get this "badass father figure on the run from the law" interpretation , until we start diving deeper XD

Jake M

Great points, although I disagree on the Lily thing- I think it was just Snape's curiosity that got the better of him. In the DH pensieve memories he's asking Lily "Where DOES Lupin go?" which made it clear to me the marauders became somewhat of an obsession (understandably so) and so any opportunity to find out the truth he would jump on it? And no doubt Sirius told him in a goading manner ("If you're so brave .." etc), as bullies are wont to do. That was my take, at least.

Jake M

It's a shame we don't witness their reunion as death eaters...Snape confronted with living proof that Sirius was innocent? I imagine he has rather surprised.

Jake M

I have to wonder whether JKR wrote this with the mindset of "kids think pranks are funny, and nobody got hurt in the end so it's fine", and it's only with our more mature eyes we can look at it and see how bad this one was? HP mania took off just after PoA was published so she was still writing ostensibly for children/teenagers before then.

Michelle Linardis

No, he - as the rest of the Wizarding world - suspected Sirius as the Potters' murderer. So he didn't 'allow Sirius to go to jail.' Because Peter had fled, leaving behind a finger, and his friend was framed. Sirius laughed like a madman when he was arrested. So of course people believed he was the murderer, because where was the proof that said otherwise?

Josh Z

Here we are the first major plot point the movies severely butcher. The Marauders back story. It's stuff like this that make me scoff at how lazy the movies really are and disagree with people who think the TV show is the cash grab, no the movies were the cash grab, made when the books were only half finished, half..finished. Do people ever stop and think about this I do and it depresses me a lot. Anyway with these chapters I have to call out adult Snape and Siruis, equally pathetic for not being able to move past their hatred. James is the most interesting character to me, who at his core is a good person, maybe too good because he makes Peter secret keeper and that's what ultimately gets him killed. Loyal to his death sadly. As for Sirius I think you can see traces of his family's pure-blood superiority in his hatred of Snape, he believes his blood status makes him better than Snape. I don't believe James felt that way I believe jealousy over Lilly being friends with Snape is where their mutual dislike came from, that and the difference in popularity. It makes me wonder if you remove Sirius do Snape and James just let each other be because it seems like he was a terrible influence

Hawwah

@Darcy If Severus had known it was Pettigrew who betrayed Lily to her death, he would have never let him get away with it. Also, since you diminish Severus' PTSD as a "high school grudge", I think you might be a bit biased.

Michelle Linardis

It's more than just curiosity, really - he already had the theory by piecing together events such as Lupin leaving the grounds on the full moon every month. So with the thought that one of his bullies may potentially be a werewolf, probably sent him in a desperation to get them away from him. I don't blame him for thst at all - Lupin *was* dangerous, and James/Sirius used that for entertainment.

Hawwah

@Jake M Severus learned the truth some time between the end of PoA end the end of GoF (Dumbledore must have told him.) Look at his reaction to Black at the end of GoF - very different from his reaction here.

Hawwah

Imagine calling a person suffering from PTSD "pathetic" because he's not able to move past his trauma.

Josh Z

Trauma is one thing his grudge with the Marauders lasting the rest of his life is the pathetic part, just as Sirius is equally pathetic, their behavior as adults is equally pathetic.

Hawwah

When it comes to the "prank" (gosh I hate it when people diminish a full blown murder attempt like this), people sometimes conflate what we, the readers, know, and what Severus knew. Black told Severus how to get past the Whomping Willow. That was it. He didn't tell him what was under the WW. He didn't tell him it was an enclosed area, a dead-end corridor. He didn't tell him that a transformed werewolf was roaming there freely. Severus didn't know it was a death trap. He couldn't have known. Black on the other hand knew it perfectly well.

Michelle Linardis

It really does grind my gears. Dismissing someone's traumatic experience and diminishing it as a mere 'grudge', is appauling. I hope they do not judge real people in that way.

Dara Jeeling

that could explain a lot. When the books came out I was already a young adult (and about to be a mom in 1999). I love the books - but even in the first book I was never convinced that Snape was the bad guy. and after that book I was sure Snape is not on the dark side (not that he never was). Heck even before there was an official sorting I was sure I wanted to be a Slytherin. Today I am a proud Slytherpuff.

Katherine

@Rebecca @Dara. I love Snape as a character. He has alway been my favourite. I enjoyed Alan Rickman as Snape :) and have thought a younger Alan Rickman would be perfect- so I just imagine a younger one same voice though.

Rebecca May

@Katherine - I’m pretty much the same! Imagine the same attitudes, same voice etc., just a bit younger 😊

Rebecca May

@Michelle - I think you can still be a proud Gryffindor and dislike the Marauders! (Any or all of them) I certainly fall in that category… I don’t think they necessarily need to be held up as the representatives of our House. 😊

S1lm4r1l

> "It's established that Snape believes every one of the Marauders was in on the so-called "prank". As such, I would hazard a guess that Snape views James' rescue attempt as self-preservation because if Severus had died, at the very least Sirius would have been thrown out of Hogwarts, and possibly James too. So in Snape's mind, James was simply trying to preserve his friendship group and stop them from getting expelled. Again, just a guess, but a good one I think. :)" Ironic, James saves Snape for the same reasons Sirius puts Snape in danger. I like it. > "(Not saying that saving Snape wasn't the brave or right thing to do: it definitely was. James has his good points, but I just don't like him much... Not because "Snape says so", but through my own judgement of events seen or spoken about in the books. While we're on the topic though, Snape also risks his life for people he hates... Surely if you admire that behaviour in one person, it should be admired in another?)" Of course. My problem with Snape is that it is rarely instinctive. Dumbledore has to spend ages manipulating and coaxing Snape towards doing the right thing. He wanted to die after Lily's death, and didn't care a whit about Harry until Dumbledore told him that Harry was how he would redeem himself. > "Werewolf attacks can end in death, but these cases are rare," if you were able to find it? I'd never heard that, and I'd be interested to read more. :)" Well, its logic. We know that werewolves very rarely have children. And that lycanthropy can only be transferred via werewolf bite at the full moon. We know that there are quite a few werewolves around, Lupin has to spend time amongst them. Almost all these wizards must have been the victims of non-fatal werewolf attacks. There's no other way for them to be werewolves. We even meet someone recently infected with Lycanthropy in St. Mungo's in the 5th book. The staff even offer counselling, indicating that it isn't a particularly rare phenomenon for people to be attacked by a werewolf and survive. Hence why, unless there's literally dozens and dozens of deaths because of werewolf attack a year. It isn't mathematically likely for most werewolf attacks to be fatal. Certainly we know Fenrir Greyback makes a point to try and attack at least 1 person a month and Lupin claims that a lot of werewolves share his ideals that werewolves should revenge themselves upon Wizardkind. Does that make sense? > "Either way, it's clear that Severus believed - rightly or wrongly - that he was very close to death during that experience." Snape claims Harry should be thanking Snape 'on bended knee' for saving him. Wonder what people would say if James Potter had expected similar treatment from Snape? We aren't ever given any indication that James Potter held this life-debt over Snape.

Kevin Morris

Let me start by saying that I love the movies, and Prisoner of Azkaban is one of my favorite of the films, but I was so disappointed that they left SO MUCH of the Marauders' backstory out of the movies. This whole chapter is incredible and really sells the amazing sense of friendship and loyalty to each other that existed between James, Sirius, Remus, and (for a while) Peter; becoming Animagi just so Lupin wouldn't be alone or ostracized. That's beautiful! I also love how this chapter portrays the characters of Dumbledore and James. First, Dumbledore being compassionate enough to give Lupin a chance not once but twice, first as a student and again as a teacher, even when so much of the rest of the Wizarding World has rejected and antagonized him. Then James, who despite his rivalry and animosity with Snape, was willing to risk his life to save Snape because even for as much as he disliked Snape, he was still not willing to just let him die. You can argue that he also didn't want Sirius to get in trouble for endangering Snape's life and not wanting Lupin to have the guilt of possibly killing someone, but I think it's a sign of James' more nobler and heroic nature shining through. This is of course, the incident that Dumbledore is referring to when he told Harry that Snape can never forgive the fact that James did indeed once save his life. The last thing I wanted to say is that it always kind of bothered me that James and Lily didn't just make Dumbledore the Secret Keeper. Yes, it was a sign of his faith in Peter (though clearly misplaced) that made him believe he could trust someone he felt was one of his very best friends, but at the same time, it would have made so much more sense for it to just be Dumbledore. Neither Voldemort nor any of the Death Eaters would ever have been bold enough to try and get the secret directly from him.

S1lm4r1l

Snape was trying to get the Marauders expelled long before Sirius attempted to murder him. At that time, he had no reasonable justification.

S1lm4r1l

> "It seems like Snape largely grouped himself with people who accepted who he was, unlike Sirius and Prongs who mocked him from minute one." They mocked him as soon as he expressed the hope that Lily would be in Slytherin. Up until that point they had completely ignored the both of them. > "How they treated a peer who never instigated a single attack, is appalling." That's not true. We know that's not true. The Marauders and Snape were as bad as each other. Snape never passed up an opportunity to curse James Potter. Snape arrived at school knowing more curses than most of the students in 7th year. Snape even admits that the Marauders "turned his own spells against him." The idea that Snape was this angelic lamb who never did anything wrong is ridiculous.

S1lm4r1l

I disagree. Snape went from being a student at Hogwarts to being a teacher. His behaviour and attitudes did not change (in order to maintain his cover.) Snape the adult is pretending to be who Snape the student was. Not much room for growth there.

S1lm4r1l

A haunted building that you can't enter normally? A building that shows no outward sign of trauma? A building with only 1 entrance and exit? Sirius would've been stupid to hide in there.

Lisette C.

I can't agree with you at all there 🙂 To me the way his reactions are described in this chapter (and the hospital scenes) paints a clear image of a man who has never gotten over his trauma regarding these people and who is locked in a past fight-or-flight reaction.. But we can agree to disagree 😘

Mel

Hi veggie! I've been following you since the beginning of your HP marathon on YouTube but I just joined patreon :) First of all, sorry if there are mistakes, English is not my mother tongue. I’m so excited to join the party ! :D I'm coming in for a pretty intense chapter. We finally get to the heart of the matter about the fight between the marauders and Severus. It's quite a controversial subject; and that's why we often have two teams: those who love the marauders and those who hate them. I think it should be more nuanced than that. Since I was a kid, marauders have been my favorite characters, so I'm probably biased in my judgment. However, I totally recognize how unacceptable what Sirius did was. He should have been expelled from Hogwarts for it. I totally condemn the harassment. That "joke" was horrible towards Severus, but also towards remus, poor thing if he had killed Severus by accident...I can't even imagine. However, JKR's work is not Manichean, everything is not black or white. Severus was bullied when he was younger, but that doesn't stop him from doing the same to Neville, Harry, Hermione and probably other innocent students, and he knows what it feels like to be bullied. It didn't stop him from being insulting to Lily etc. when he was young either. And in the opposite direction, Sirius was able to make this unacceptable « prank » and on the other hand, to be of an unfailing devotion towards his friends. I don't give any mitigating circumstances to Sirius and James for their behavior towards Severus, they often went too far, but Severus was no angel either. Marauders are hated for hating a person... and as I often say "do 100 things right, we'll only remember the one time you did one thing wrong." And I kind of get that feeling with marauders. People immediately attacked them... Snape doesn't deserve that, but neither do the marauders. They should have just ignored each other. Aaaaand this is the very moment I'm going to get hated on my first comment... We often tend to blame the marauders for their actions, but wouldn't that be something Fred and George could have done? For example, towards Percy, I find them very pushy. I wouldn't be shocked if they were picking on the Slytherins just for fun. There is a scene that I have in mind in the beginning of Goblet of fire for example but I don’t want to spoil anything so I’ll stop here but your readers will understand I think. And yet, coming from them, it doesn't shock anyone... Talking around me, the twins are loved (and I Love them too), but I'm curious to have your opinion and the opinion of the bookclub about that :) Thank you for everything you do, it's always 5 hours of fun aha. Love from france, xx

Michelle Linardis

Funny that we only have the word of Sirius and Remus - Severus' actual bullies. I wouldn't believe the word of my bullies, especially one who tried to kill me. Severus had every right to want them expelled. Also funnily enough, we have no proof Severus instigated any attacks against them. Take your headcanon elsewhere and stop harassing Snape fans, including myself. Your arguments have no leg to stand on, and I do not want to waste my time listening to people like you who fail to understand the book content.

S1lm4r1l

> "The last thing I wanted to say is that it always kind of bothered me that James and Lily didn't just make Dumbledore the Secret Keeper. Yes, it was a sign of his faith in Peter (though clearly misplaced) that made him believe he could trust someone he felt was one of his very best friends, but at the same time, it would have made so much more sense for it to just be Dumbledore. Neither Voldemort nor any of the Death Eaters would ever have been bold enough to try and get the secret directly from him." Ah. But if Dumbledore told them the whole prophecy, they might have made the same connection that Dumbledore did. That their child would have to die in order for Voldemort to be destroyed. Either way, they very clearly did not trust him with their lives, with their son's life. Completely correctly given the way Dumbledore weaponizes and uses Harry in order to ensure Voldemort is destroyed.

S1lm4r1l

> "They should have just ignored each other." Snape's politics made that an impossibility.

S1lm4r1l

> "Funny that we only have the word of Sirius and Remus - Severus' actual bullies." 2 people who tell the same story versus another person who tells a completely different one. And you believe the 1 person, whom we know lacks relevant information or seeks to outright lie to Harry about his father? > "I wouldn't believe the word of my bullies, especially one who tried to kill me." Even if they were right? Even if someone's life hung on your actions? > "Severus had every right to want them expelled." No. He didn't. Not before the murder attempt. > "Also funnily enough, we have no proof Severus instigated any attacks against them." We know there were incidents where Snape used spells against them and that they turned his spells against him. They saw Snape use these spells and copied him. > "Take your headcanon elsewhere and stop harassing Snape fans, including myself." I haven't harassed anyone. I've been able to back-up everything I've said with evidence from the books.

Hawwah

@Mel Welcome to the Book Club, Mel! "We often tend to blame the marauders for their actions, but wouldn't that be something Fred and George could have done?" Yes, and many fans, including myself, consider Fred and George bullies.

S1lm4r1l

10/10 Comment. That's exactly how I feel as well. The Marauders were awful to Snape, but they are at least great towards each other, demonstrate a respect towards others and see the value in every life. I don't think we should be saying "Its okay to join the political plot of a genocidal racist that seeks to subjugate and exterminate entire groups of people" simply because you were bullied as a child. Can you imagine a serial killer saying "No, no. YOU have to feel sorry for ME, not my victims, because I was bullied at school"? Lots of people are bullied at school. I was bullied at school. Never in a million years would I act towards Neville the way Snape does. He's a student Snape is responsible for, someone he should be able to trust, confide in. He could've been the person Dumbledore wasn't in the aftermath of the murder attempt. He could stand up for Neville, help him. But he doesn't. He does the complete opposite. The Marauders were bullies when they were children. Snape is a bully as an adult. Had Voldemort chosen Neville, Snape would've died a loyal Death Eater. Lily couldn't convince him to abandon the political views of his friends whilst they were at school. I doubt she'd have been able to convince him as an adult.

S1lm4r1l

> "It makes me wonder if you remove Sirius do Snape and James just let each other be because it seems like he was a terrible influence" I think Sirius and James egged each other on. The comparison with the Weasley Twins is apt I think. Alone, they probably weren't too bad, (Not good, but not terrible either,) Together, they were diabolical.

Rebecca May

"My problem with Snape is that it is rarely instinctive. Dumbledore has to spend ages manipulating and coaxing Snape towards doing the right thing. He wanted to die after Lily's death, and didn't care a whit about Harry until Dumbledore told him that Harry was how he would redeem himself." > I absolutely refuse to judge Severus for saying he wanted to die, in the moments after he learned that he'd lost the only person who he'd ever loved, the only person to show him true kindness. I know you'll disagree, but I think it's possible Snape would have decided to protect Harry on his own (and in fact, I find it absolutely disgusting that Dumbledore chooses to manipulate Snape at a time when he is in so much pain, and so deeply vulnerable). I also think that Severus may not have started in a place where making personal sacrifices for others was instictive, but by the end of his life it absolutely was. "Does that make sense?" > It does, thank you. I appreciate you explaining your reasoning - although regardless, I believe fearing death from a werewolf is a completely natural fear for a person to have. "We aren't ever given any indication that James Potter held this life-debt over Snape." > We are, in fact. During "The Prince's Tale", Lily says: "I heard what happened the other night. You went sneaking down that tunnel by the Whomping Willow and James Potter saved you from whatever's down there -" James may never have asked or expected Snape to thank him, but I would argue what he actually did was far worse. It's heavily implied that James went around telling people he'd saved Severus' life, playing the hero without any context whatsoever, knowing that Snape had been forbidden to speak of it or contradict him. If that isn't blatantly rubbing it in Snape's face that Sirius got away with trying to murder him, I don't know what is.

Karen

Hi Veggie from a longtime watcher on YouTube to a new Patreon and fellow vegan! Can I just say that Ron’s broken foot/leg is much more gruesome in the books. Also, Ron is much better friend in the books verse the movies. Hopefully the new MAX TV series will give Ron the Justice he deserves.

S1lm4r1l

> "I absolutely refuse to judge Severus for saying he wanted to die, in the moments after he learned that he'd lost the only person who he'd ever loved, the only person to show him true kindness." Nor do I, but I think people miss that Snape's desire to protect Harry was not an instantaneous switch from Lily to Harry. His thoughts were entirely selfish at that point. > "I know you'll disagree, but I think it's possible Snape would have decided to protect Harry on his own" If we assume that Snape made that decision then, in the moment, then I don't see how Snape's decision wasn't influenced by Dumbledore. > "I find it absolutely disgusting that Dumbledore chooses to manipulate Snape at a time when he is in so much pain, and so deeply vulnerable" So do I. > "I also think that while Severus may not have started in a place where making personal sacrifices for others was instictive, but by the end of his life it absolutely was." For which he should receive kudos. James Potter was already at that point, regardless of his treatment of Snape otherwise and his many other flaws by the age of 13-14ish. > "I heard what happened the other night. You went sneaking down that tunnel by the Whomping Willow and James Potter saved you from whatever's down there -" My point was that Potter did not expect anything from Snape in gratitude. He saved his life because it was the right thing to do. Now, maybe if Dumbledore doesn't swear Snape to secrecy about Lupin that might be different.

Rebecca May

I don't deny for a moment that Snape's decision was influenced by Dumbledore. :) I just think that if he'd been given time to grieve, process and heal, he may well have come to that decision on his own, in time. I'm afraid we'll have to agree to disagree about James. I don't see him making any personal sacrifices (up until the time he gives his life for Lily and Harry, which was of course admirable). I think he only saved Severus because he realised the dire consequences Snape's death might have for himself and his friends.

S1lm4r1l

> "Because he had the audacity to question the Marauders and dared to poke his nose into their business." True. But you have to remember, expelling Sirius would've sent him back to his parent's house permanently. He hated his parents and their house. Sirius clearly thought Snape was trying to get the whole lot of them expelled. Whilst this hardly justifies attempted murder, Sirius was clearly determined to avoid going back there as much as he could. He runs away a few short years after this incident remember. > "It’s pretty clear that the Marauders never faced any consequences for this." Not serious consequences anyway. Harry receives several weekends of detentions after he almost kills Draco. Seems reasonable to assume that Sirius received something similar. Although perhaps that's just me being optimistic.

Rod

The house was never haunted, and there's no basis to assume there's only one entrance and exit. People fear the house and the doors and windows are boarded up, but other than that it has no protection. Any semi competent wizard would easily get past a boarded window. And if the staff believes Sirius is using dark magic to get in, the tunnel would be seen as a vulnerability that needs to be addressed. Dumbledore is being careful enough to block every crack to the castle, it's hard to think he would ignore a large tunnel known by Sirius. And even if he did, Snape, who didn't forget his own experience in that tunnel, would certainly remind him.

Michelle Linardis

You are full of inaccuracies and false statements. I've seen your outlandish comments to others. Considering you hate Snape so much, you dismiss what is written to suit your own headcanon. I will not be taking your statements seriously from someone with such blind hate. You have NO evidence to support your nonsense. When people tell you to stop responding to them, and you continue to do so, that is harassment. So stop responding to me.

Dara Jeeling

@Mel bonjour and that is wher most of my french writing ends - I understand it quite well though! Welcome to the book club. Fred and George did push a Slytherin into the vanishing cabinet and Montague was sort of missing for weeks, before they found him stuck between the two cabinets (and the Hogwarts one was then moved to the RoR - and Montague told Draco about what he hears, which is why Draco got the idea of fixing them) I like Fred and George, even though I do think they are not as funny as everyone thinks it's more that people laugh at th "pranks" they play on students from rival houses (or the pink toad) I myself I do not hate the arauders, I just think that actions speak louder then words. So they are sort of grey or me (but Snape is grey as well) My few cents: Pettigrew - he is actually the worst for me. Someone who thrived in school with people he called friends and I am sure (just my imagination) used their help a lot and then threw practically 2 of his friends - plus Lily and Harry into deaths/prisons way... NAY! Sirius - I stated that before... For me he is not much about Pettigrew with trying to pull that "prank", just because he had an instant disliking towards another student because of Sapes choice of house... I do not deny the grown up version is kind of decent - if you consider him wanting to murder again (after trying with Snape with hs prank). Not sure if this is out of Loyalty towards James/Lily/Harry or because he just wanted revenge... James - we do not know much about adult James, apart from what other characters tell us. Teen James was not a nice person (it seemed) until he got his head out of his arse and tried to be good enough for Lily (and yes I think Lily is the main reason he outwardly stopped bullying Snape). Remus - he is grey as well, we had been made a Prefect and he still did not step up and intervened on behalf of Snape. I know his live is sort of more complicated and I give him the benefit of the doubt ususally. I guess there are only 4 characters on Harry Potter I tend to "hate" (moe despise the most - they are fictional characters) 4) Bellatrix for what she did to evilles parents 3) Pettigrew because... yeah... he is disgusting 2) Voldemort because... he is Voldy. 1) Umbridge - because in my eyes she is worse then even Voldemort. I have strong dislikigs to other characters, but those 4 are my tops... as said welcome!

Mel

@S1lm4r1l Yes, I totally agree. @Hawwah Hi, thank you hawa ! Ah I'm surprised to read that, in general in the French fandom, the twins are loved and I never heard anyone say they went too far. Probably because they are in the house of Harry Potter and the people they make fun of are often unloved characters. Like Percy, Draco or Dudley. @Dara Jeeling Bonjour :D et merci beaucoup! Once again I hope that my English will be understandable, if not I apologize in advance! Yes, I remembered that there was a story with the Slytherins. I was also thinking about Dudley eating the candy at the beginning of GOF, or even Quirell getting snowballs in his head. Maybe it's a childish joke but I don't know, if it's repeated, it can become emotionally tiring for the person who suffers it and it can be considered bullying. As I said in my comment, marauders are my favorite characters. Of course I hate peter now, knowing everything he did. But during the marauders’s era, when they were young, peter wasn't inherently evil, just a follower and not brave. Not a great character, but not the black beast either. But the peter of today? That's a no, too. Probably the worst character in the saga. It's funny what you say about James. Because except for the whole thing with Snape, I don't feel like he's a bad guy. Do you have a particular scene in mind? I remember him being described as arrogant and showing off a little bit, but as a popular teenager. I don't want to conflate them, they're two different characters, but when Ron suddenly becomes famous after quidditch matches, he's showing off too. I just see it as a kid who knows he's popular and enjoys it. Sirius, I'll admit, is my favorite character of the group and has been since I was young so I have a hard time changing my mind about him, though I remain objective about his bad choices. Even more so since I'm an adult. But for the time being, his thirst for revenge is human. His image has been destroyed and yet he doesn't want to restore it. He just wants to make Peter pay and anyone would want the same. Even Harry. Under more legal conditions, of course, but he is still for the death penalty than Azkaban. But we mustn't forget that Sirius was wrongly locked up for 12 years, thinking only of his friends who died, all the time (or most of the time?) in his dog form! Animal instincts must have taken over and honestly, everyone would have a bit of a murderous spirit towards Peter in such conditions. But actually, his aversion to Snape is for his house and his questionable choices (mudblood thing, death eater etc). Remember, Sirius grew up in this environment that he hates, but Snape insults lily etc. That's all it takes for Sirius to attack him. Snape is a reflection of his family that he hates. The rest is coherent, he hated Snape for that, it is natural for him to want to kill Peter who did 10 times worse. An eye for an eye... And Remus... I don't have anything special to say. I think he was too happy to finally have genuine friends to always be the annoying prefect. I completely agree with your top 4. On the other hand, tom riddle has long been one of my favorite characters. Not because of his actions, because we all agree that this man is horrible, but because he is very interesting. On the contrary, Umbridge is cruel but has nothing in his brain. > I have strong dislikigs to other characters, but those 4 are my tops… I'm curious, who are you talking about? xx

Hawwah

I agree with Rod, it looks like a plot hole.

Mel

Hi there, According to the wiki, squibs can't see dementors but they can feel them (like a muggle actually). But they know what they are and what they feel like when you are around them, so Ms. Figg just deduced that they were dementors. However, when she says she saw them with her own eyes, yes, she is lying. At least, she's playing with words for the trial in OTP.

S1lm4r1l

> "I just think that if he'd been given time to grieve, process and heal, he may well have come to that decision on his own, in time." I think he'd have wanted to do anything he could to destroy Voldemort, especially once he found out Voldemort 'survived'. > "I think he only saved Severus because he realised the dire consequences Snape's death might have for himself and his friends." Perhaps, but there are worse reasons to save a life.

Dara Jeeling

@Rebecca May I loved Alan in anything, really. I preferd him on stage. I was lucky enough to have seen him on stage a few times. I do not say I did not like his performance. It's just... In my head Snape and McGonagall were always youger. I still loved both performances

Hawwah

@Josh Severus Snape hates Sirius Black because SB relentlessly bullied him for years, made his life a living hell and attempted to murder him. Sirius Black hates Severus Snape because... reasons? Because Severus was sorted into a house SB didn't approve of? These two aren't even remotely comparable.

Tana

I am in love with these chapters, to the point that my POA book you can tell where they start. For the people who always condemn the marauders, I agree, they are far from perfect, (although I love them and the depth to Sirius's character makes him my fave in the whole book series) however they have a beautiful friendship for immature kids. They literally turn into animagi to help just one of them.

Dara Jeeling

@Mel as said I "hate" or dissapprove of those 4 the most. ( i think hate is a strong word for a fictional character) I am also not a fan of Minster Fudge and Rita Skeeter ( and Lucius Malfoy and so on - McNair...). I think they are all greatly written characters (but then most characters we get to know during the books are wonderfully written - even if they are evil. Whenever we get a backstory, they are fascinating and I' be more then curious to do research into a few of them. I think your eglish is great (but I am not a native english speaker either)

Janie

Also, Snape, the little angel that invented the funny little spell called Sectumsempra... The prank Sirius pulled on Snape was wrong. Of course it was. There's no question about it. But I refuse to accept that Snape was completely innocent. He kept following them around, asking about Lupin, trying to find out what was wrong with him. He was already practicing dark magic, was a part of a group of future Death Eaters, eager to follow Voldemort as soon as he could. Was Sirius's prank out of line? Definitely. Should he have been punished by Dumbledore. Yes. Was Snape a poor innocent child? No.

Janie

Hmm... I wonder why it's mainly Snape's fans who try to silence people with different opinions. It's sad, really. Everyone has the right to say what they think. You don't have to agree with them but asking them not to respond to your comment if they dare to disagree with you is not right. I personally will respond to any comment to which I have something to say. It's called a discussion.

Janie

These chapters show why I love these books so much. There are no black and white characters (at least the major ones). A lot of those characters that are supposed to be on the good side have flaws and sometimes can be pretty dark. Sirius's prank has been discussed many times so I point out something else. I think it's interesting that Lupin is willing to commit a murder without a second thought. He could have insisted on taking Pettigrew to Azkaban but no, he agreed to murder him. Thank God Harry stopped them or the series would have ended with this book :) Also, I'm curious how did Sirius communicate with Crookshanks?

Michelle Linardis

Because Snape fans will not waste time having a 'discussion' with someone who only comments with Snape-hate, and come up with jargon that is not supported in the books. And considering Patreon does not have a block feature, asking someone not to respond is all we can do. I have better things to do with my time. I come here to enjoy Veggie's videos and comment with like-minded people, not to engage with people who simply want to hate.

Janie

I don't really see it as hate. Not liking a character is perfectly normal. I've never noticed any kind of really hateful commets from so called "Snape-haters". We just try to point out that Snape's behaviour is sometimes really out of line and we get frustrated when people make up excuses for him bullying his students. That's not hate. Bullying anyone is wrong, whether it's Snape doing it to his students or the Marauders doing it to Snape. I love Snape as a brilliantly written character. But I don't like his personality and definitely wouldn't want someone like him as my teacher.

Dara Jeeling

would you not try to find sort of a handle towards your bullies? Maybe the school/headmaster should have found a better way to make sure Lupin was safe each month. I never said Snape was - how do you call it? - "little angel" - I know he is moraly grey. But so is Sirius, James, Dumbledore and hell - even Mrs Weasley and the twins. I knoe Smape is a controbrrdial character, I am fine with people not liking him/being agsinst him. It just really irks me, that the anti Snape fans seem to measure with different weights. Heck, I would not even go fo far to say he is a great teacher - but then he didn't choose to be a teacher. He was told to be a teacher by the guy who prevented him to going to wizard jail. Not sure why - but I guess he had little choice. It's not thst teaching was (as it should be) his passion.... I do not go on sn insult your favorite character in your post. Yet, I gave had this for years - you say your favorite character (as in the one with the best story arc) is Snape you ALWAYS (and for me it has been 20 years) you get the same things and people are not willing to accept your view and kerp on bringing the same old arguments... thank you, for making me really welcome to post here - and I know it will knöy be getting worse!

Michelle Linardis

No one said you didn't have a right to hate a character. It doesn't matter if you hate him, or not, as long as you hate him for things he actually did, and not what you assume he did or wish he did. My opinions will not be the same as yours, and there is nothing wrong with that. When things are wildly exaggerated, misquoted, or so-called 'evidence' which dismisses important context, purposely ignoring character information, and double-standards in favor of another character...that's hate. I come to Veggie's channel to engage with positive comments, not negative or 'bashing' ones.

Hawwah

What Michelle said. It's one thing to dislike a character and a whole another thing to purposefully post blatantly false claims to provoke people and elicit angry reactions from them.

Janie

I'm sorry, Hawwah, but you just described yourself. See, we can say the same thing about you, yet no "Snape-hater" asked you not to reply to their comment ;)

Janie

@ Michelle > "When things are wildly exaggerated, misquoted, or so-called 'evidence' which dismisses important context, purposely ignoring character information, and double-standards in favor of another character..." Again, you just described Snape-fans.

Hawwah

Actually, that's where you're incorrect, Janie. Diego Zenhäusern asked me not to reply to his comments several book clubs ago and I respected it. I didn't throw a fit about it, I didn't complain about being silenced, I simply respected his wishes. It was really easy.

Hawwah

Janie, if you believe Snape fans are so horrible, I wonder why you even want to engage with us.

VEGGIE GAMER

Hi guys. Please do try and keep these replies respectful! I have no way of monitoring them without reading spoilers, so only ever see the first couple of words of comments. It is ok to disagree with each other on things (if there was only one way of looking at things, there would be no point of a Book Review), and it is also ok to ignore or not reply to a comment you disagree with. As long as we are all being friends and not hounding each other :) (that isn't a Sirius pun, btw).

Janie

Last comment on this topic, I promise. If someone asked you not to respond to them, Hawwah, then I must have missed it and I apologize. If I seem too argumentative then I apologize as well, but sometimes I get carried away with trying to get people to see my point. Also, I'm sorry, Veggie. I'll shut up now:)

VEGGIE GAMER

Hi Janie! My comment wasn't directed at any one person! Like I say, I only see the very start of comments, so just wanted to make sure everything was going ok! :) I know exactly what you mean about getting carried away with view points (i.e, me during Quidditch chapters XD)

Starryk

we really don't know the full story how the relationship between Sirius and Severus developed over the years. Sirius was a rebel who was sorted into Gryffindor which gave him a hard time with his proud Slytherin family at home. Not sure how he saw it as a kid during the first years in Hogwarts. Was he rebelling from the start of his school career or did this happen later after befriending James? What he says in the books gives the impression that he really hated the dark arts and Snape being fascinated by them and his own families attitude disgusted him. So i doubt that pure blood pride played any role in his relationship with Severus. It would be completely out of character. It might be possible in his early Hogwarts years but definitely not in his later years. This doesn't justify what he does to Snape in any way btw. especially not risking his life by sending him after Remus. And it is sad that he still doesn't see this after all these years.

John Phillips

@S1lm4r1l - It seems like you're downplaying the Marauder's bullying towards Snape. Even if Snape wasn't perfect, that's no excuse for them to treat him the way they did.

John Phillips

We don't know that James saved Snape out of the goodness of his heart. According to Snape, he might have only saved Snape to keep himself and his friends from getting expelled.

John Phillips

So we got more information about the prank that Sirius pulled on Snape in their youths during this chapter. I know James saved Snape, but I don't think he did it out of the goodness of his heart. As Snape said several chapters ago, I think James only saved him so that he and his friends wouldn't get expelled. Sirius doesn't even show any signs of regret about the incident when it was brought up in this chapter. I can't blame Snape for his negative feelings towards the Marauders.

Rebecca May

@Dara - That’s so wonderful you managed to see him on stage a few times, I wish I’d had that chance! Sadly he passed away only a few months after I moved to England. And yeah, totally agree it would have been ideal if he’d been a bit younger as far as playing Snape is concerned! 😊

Benjamin Hütz

Its very clear that Snape and James/Sirious hated each other. Reminds me a bit of Draco and Harry/Ron. But we only get half the story told... we are told that James and Sirious were bullies and Snape was that innocent little boy. I dont believe that one bit... we dont know what Snape did to them in the past

Hawwah

Yes, JKR somehow forgot to tell us about all the horrible things Severus did. But he definitely did them! /s

Janie

Well, that's the thing. We don't know all the things they did to each other. We only see it from Snape's perspective in his memory in later books/movies. I suspect that Snape wouldn't want Harry to see the bad things he'd done, so he didn't include them in the memory. If we had the chance to see for example Sirius's memory or James's memory, it could have been different. So it all depends on the perspective :) Actually, I really enjoy these discussions about characters. I realized that I really don't "hate" any HP character (well, except for Umbridge, but even with her I love to hate her!). They all are so complex, that it's kind of impossible to hate them. I certainly don't agree with a lot of things almost every character did but that's the beauty of it. Even a character that is supposed to be good has their flaws and I can actually understand why people don't like them.

S1lm4r1l

> "I suspect that Snape wouldn't want Harry to see the bad things he'd done, so he didn't include them in the memory. If we had the chance to see for example Sirius's memory or James's memory, it could have been different." In that memory, there's a whole crowd there, nobody except Lily stands up for Snape. Harry comments that Snape clearly "wasn't popular." The crowd clearly thought Snape deserved it. Judging from the company Snape keeps, the racial slurs he uses (because according to Lily, it wasn't the first time Snape called someone a Mud-blood) and the bully he grew up to be in later life. The idea that Snape was this innocent little lamb who never did anything wrong rather collapses. The hints and clues are there, for those able to see them.

Hawwah

@Janie No offence, Janie, but that's a lot of guesswork on your part. My stance is that if Rowling didn't write it, it didn't happen. People often say that we see SWM from Sev's perspective, but that's actually not true. We see it from Harry's perspective.

S1lm4r1l

@John - I'm not denying that they bullied him, what I am saying is that Snape was not passive. It wasn't like they picked on Snape as though they chose him at random. It was his politics, his beliefs, the magic he idolized and used, his attitude towards others, his frequent usage of the term "Mudblood" that got him into hot water. Draco calls Hermione a Mudblood in the 2nd book and Marcus Flint has to dive in front of Malfoy to stop the Gryffindor Quidditch Team attacking him. I think it was Snape's habit of constantly following them around and trying to get them in trouble that the Marauders found particularly irksome. Think about it. What kind of bullied kid actively follows their bullies around, spies on them, tries to get them in trouble with the teachers? The way Snape's fans talk about their relationship, you'd think Snape would be like Neville. Trying to avoid his tormentors at all costs. Not following them around and annoying them. But we know that isn't the case. I'm sure he and his Death Eater friends were plenty nasty to the Marauders and other students in the school. Just like the Golden Trio are pretty awful to Draco at times. The relationship between James Potter and Snape is compared to Harry and Draco's on a number of occasions. And nobody ever says Harry or Draco takes things lying down.

Janie

@ Dara - I don't hate Snape. He's a great, complex character. I strongly disagree with his teaching methods though. I've thought about it a lot today and I realized that someone like him should not be allowed to teach children. But it's not Snape's fault. I blame Dumbledore for making him do it, even though he must have known Snape is not exactly a suitable person for the job due to his childhood trauma. I understand Dumbledore wanted to keep a close eye on him and he needed him close in order to manipulate him, but surely, there must have been some other jobs/things Snape could have done. Writing potions book somewhere in Hogsmeade maybe. As for moraly grey characters. Yes, I completely agree with you. For example, you mentioned the twins. They are probably amongst my top five favourite characters. Yet, I admit that some of their pranks/jokes are pretty cruel and dangerous (the toffee incident in book 4 is the prime example of that). The same goes for many other characters. Hell, even Voldy is one of my favourites and I definitely wouldn't say he's a good person. What I mean to say is, your favourite character doesn't really have to be a good person for you to like them. I'd say Snape is one of my favourite characters because of his story arc and his complexity but at the same time I think he's not a very good person. That doesn't make me a Snape-hater. One last thing: I definitely don't hate you, or anyone else, for liking Snape. I wouldn't even hate you for liking Umbridge. I'd try really hard to understand the reason in that case, though :) Please, don't feel like you're not welcome to post here. I'm sorry if I made you feel that way, it wasn't my intention.

S1lm4r1l

> "The house was never haunted" No, but that's what most of the wizarding community thinks. > "and there's no basis to assume there's only one entrance and exit." Of course there is. The building was used to contain a werewolf. If Were-Lupin can simply exit through an open door or window he'd have bitten somebody, Werewolves can't control themselves. We know he stayed in the house until the moon changed because he was forced to stay in the house. There's no other explanation. > "People fear the house and the doors and windows are boarded up, but other than that it has no protection." And you don't think people would notice the removal of the boards and raise this? Ghosts can't move solid objects. Like you said, it's been established that Sirius must be hiding very close to the Castle. > "And if the staff believes Sirius is using dark magic to get in, the tunnel would be seen as a vulnerability that needs to be addressed." A tunnel that leads from the grounds to Hogsmeade, not into the Castle. > "Dumbledore is being careful enough to block every crack to the castle, it's hard to think he would ignore a large tunnel known by Sirius. And even if he did, Snape, who didn't forget his own experience in that tunnel, would certainly remind him." Because the tunnel doesn't get him into Hogwarts, doesn't get him into the Castle with the students. That's what they're trying to protect.

S1lm4r1l

> "According to Snape" Yeah, that's kinda my point.

Janie

@ Hawwah Well, we all do a lot of guesswork in these discussions, don't we? Not everything is written down in the books, some things are even meant for different interpretations. For example, we discussed Hermione's boggart in the last review where you interpreted it in a way that was certainly not written as a fact in the book. Hermione never said "I'm scared of McGonagall. She's my biggest fear."(Unlike Neville and his boggart). It apparently can be interpreted in more ways than one, you chose to believe she was scared of McGonagall, I chose to believe it was the failure :) Yes,, you are right, we see it from Harry's perspective. But the memory itself is shown from Snape's perspective, so it's, in a way, both Snape's and Harry's POV.

Dara Jeeling

I would so love that block option! really!

Dara Jeeling

that's fine with me! I often just get the impression that people interpret into absent things and say "must have happened" I guess we all do that. Usually I enjoy seeing new ideas and I even had a few "heureka" moments on here - since I had neve seen it that way. I never thought Snape is innocent and as I already said, I do not think he is a great teacher. For me (who actually is a primary school teacher / elementary school - now working in a retirement home) his actions are not okay. But I thnk working with people (in any job) requires actually passion (for people) and to be able to not take things personal. I am sometimes not good at not taing commenty on here personal - since it's just online. I may be getting on great with most people if I could see expressions / get voice infornation. And yes, I get that! I really dispise Umbridge, but she is wirtten brilliantly!

Jacqueline Chaiton

I’ve always been so disappointed in Snape in these chapters. He’s completely justified in his anger and hatred of Sirius, but he refuses to even hear anything that changes the narrative that he has in his head. I mean Lupin didn’t even want his friends to know he was a werewolf, he certainly would never let them tell anyone. And even if he did, never on a full moon.

Hawwah

@Janie I think you know perfectly well this is NOT AT ALL what I argued in the boggart debate. I wrote a very long post about it under the last Veggie's HP video, I'm not interested in going through all the points again, especially since I have a feeling that you misinterpreted my position on purpose. Interpretation is one thing, making up stuff that is not in the books is a whole another thing. There is not even one instance of Severus bullying the Marauders, but there are several scenes of the Marauders bullying him.

Janie

@ Hawwah Okay, I'm giving up. There are so many things I'd like to say to that but I won't because it would probably lead to an argument and I don't want that. Let's agree to disagree and leave it at that. Have a nice weekend :)

John Phillips

@S1lm4r1l - In Snape's Worst Memory, James flat out admitted to Lily that he was picking on Snape purely because he "exists". We only know one time of Snape calling someone (Lily) a mudblood. None of the rest of your accusations towards Snape have been confirmed in canon and they certainly do not justify the Marauders' treatment of Snape. The comparison you mentioned is James being compared to Draco and Snape being compared to Harry. Not the other way around.

John Phillips

@ Janie - Interpretations are fine as long as they don't contradict canon. Theories that are clearly just made to tear down and bash a character one doesn't like is biased, bad faith, and should not be taken seriously in discussion.

Janie

@ John - I completely agree with you.

Mordimer

actually when Harry talks with Sirius and Lupin about it in the fireplace, they tell him about Snape's fascination with dark magic and the fact that they both were at each other throats. Also don't forget who invented spells like sectumsempra while still being in school and joined magic nazis. Lupin: "Well, Snape was a special case. I mean he never lost opportunity to curse James,, so couldn't you really expect James to take that lying down, do you?" So yea, we know a bit, I don't know why people always forget about those informations ;)

Mordimer

it is theoretically a spoiler, but Veggie don't read replies so I think it's safe to answer: Harry talks with Sirius and Lupin about their relation in the fireplace, they tell him about Snape's fascination with dark magic and the fact that they both were at each other throats. Also don't forget who invented spells like sectumsempra while still being in school and joined magic nazis. Lupin: "Well, Snape was a special case. I mean he never lost opportunity to curse James,, so couldn't you really expect James to take that lying down, do you?"

H

Some things I think is interesting or funny in these chapters: - I love the image of Lupin being in his office as a harmless wolf, perhaps doing some admin (and yes, I imagine a wolf with glasses now). Of course it's not like that, but it's fun to imagine anyway. - Dumbledore being a brilliant person by helping Lupin going to Hogwarts – and also Dumbledore encouraging the ghost rumours, I imagine him talking loudly about it down at the pub. - One of Lupin's definining characters traits: being scared of losing those around him (and who can blame him of all people for that), and therefore not always being able to tell the truth. It makes such sense for him – such an interesting character! - How important it is for the trio to avoid that a POSSIBLY innocent man isn't given the dementor kiss. Standing up for the truth, and therefore the logical thing for them was to attack Snape. - Black's surprised reaction to Hermione speaking politely to him, because he isn't used to it. - "KEEP QUIET YOU STUPID GIRL" – no, YOU shut up, Severus. I like to imagine that Pettigrew, when the Weasley's weren't at home, turned human just for a few hours, always keeping an eye on the entrance door in case they come home.

John Phillips

James initiated every attack on Snape. Whether Snape was into dark arts or not, James was bullying Snape, it was not just a rivalry. He even pulled down Snape's pants and was about to pull down his underwear. Maybe it wasn't seen as sexual assault back then, but it would be nowadays. No matter how you try to spin it, what James did was 100% wrong. Also, can we please stop referring to Snape as a "nazi"?

Michelle Linardis

Same! It would easily get rid of those harassing the Snape fans with their childish deflection, no problem. I come here to enjoy Veggie's videos and engage with like-minded individuals, than have to escape those with torches and pitchforks for no reason at all. I don't go around to James fans and harass them with hate, so they shouldn't be doing the same for Snape fans. Hating a character this much must be so tiresome.

Dara Jeeling

also - stop nitpicking every sentence someone posts - since yo are not JKR and you do as much guesswork as I or anyone else does. Do not think you're imagination s canon, please! I am actually really happy to discuss things one the basisi that I see the other discussion partner trying to think about things and not just repeating things over and over, ignoring facts on the wizarding wolrd and the book

Dara Jeeling

@Darcy I always assumed (and yes, just my interpretation) is that Voldemort did not make it known who were hus folloers, even amongst them. Because ifor me it always seemed he had spies in a few ministry jobs - and I am not sure it would be wise to have every death eater (or even the whole iner circle) know about them. So for me it has always been the idea, that Peter was not known as a Death eater officially. I believe that after hearing the prophecy and knowing who the target would be - Snape would have told Dumbledore if he knew Peter was a known Deth Eater. But then - that is just my interpretation.

Michelle Linardis

The thing is, their nitpicking is just opinions, not actually supported by book facts, or 'facts' they heavily twist/exaggerate to support said opinion. The amount of outlandish claims I've seen is almost laughable. I am more than happy to engage with people who actually follow the books, and use critical thinking, without the unnecessary character bashing. But I just choose not to invest my time with illogical people and those who hate for the sake of hating. I pick and choose my battles, and I can easily stomp out those claims with facts. But this is not the place, and I have better things to do with my time than debate with negative people whose goal is to ruin the experience for everyone else. xx

Janie

@ Ashley >"I guess we can rule out the theory that only the Marauders can see each other on the map, since Snape can see Lupin on it in these chapters." Or only the Marauders could see each other in their animal form but everyone could see them when they were in their human form? Lupin wasn't in his werewolf form when Snape saw him on the map. That would explain why no one could see Pettigrew when he was a rat. Snape would have been able to see him on the map, too, so he would have known the truth just by looking at the map. Yet he never mentioned him. But that's only my theory :)

Janie

@ Michelle Yesterday, a comment replying to one of my comments appeared in my email notification, but I can't find it here so either you or Veggie must have deleted it. Still, I read it, so I know this comment is directed partly at me. You accused me of being a hater, or "Snater" as you put it. You couldn't be more wrong though. As I've said in other comments, I don't hate any character. Hating a fictional character seems a bit ridiculous to me, to be honest. Snape is one of my favourite characters, but I'm just critical of some aspects of his behaviour. He's a tragic character with many flaws and that makes him interesting. I feel the same way about many other characters, even the supposed evil ones. That's why I love them. I certainly can't speak for other people but I felt like I had to make myself clear. In the deleted comment, you asked me to stop responding to you and waste your time. And I will do as you asked. I just wanted to defend myself because I felt I was being unfairly accused of being something I'm not. (I wish there was an option to write to you in a private message but there seems to be no such option here.)

itsanursething

I read the comments prior to re-reading the chapters because I have a pretty solid recollection of what went on. But I did still re-read! I have a few thoughts, and I’ll try not to be too repetitive of what others have already said. I find it AMAZING that Sirius, James, and Peter started trying to become animagi at 12 years old! Like Hermione said, there have only been 7 in the last century. It’s not an easy feat! And the fact that they then accomplished it at 15 is just incredible. I’m glad we finally heard how Sirius escaped Azkaban. That bit was left out of the movie and I think a lot of people were confused about it. A couple things about Snape now…if he was so concerned for everyone’s safety, why didn’t he bring the Wolfsbane potion with him when he went after Lupin? Surely he didn’t think he could subdue a werewolf on his own? And I know he was a bit mad with rage, but he just REFUSED to listen to anyone in this scene. Talking about how James was so arrogant he couldn’t even fathom being wrong…pot, meet kettle. Alright, I’m going to play devil’s advocate here for a hot second. I don’t think Sirius was trying to murder Snape with his prank. They talked about how they would venture out of the shack with a FULLY FORMED WEREWOLF on the regular. Not smart, not safe. Dumb teenage boy behavior. So, maybe Sirius was genuinely just trying to scare Snape. Go with me on this! He grew up in the House of Black. Not nice people. Maybe his idea of a prank always included some form of danger because of the cruelty he saw in his home on a regular basis. So to him, he genuinely didn’t think Snape would get hurt (which he didn’t), but it also maybe never occurred to him that what he was doing was not ok. *dodges pitchforks* What do you think Veggie? Always happy to hear your thoughts! And sorry this got so long!!

Michelle Linardis

Your comments in support of prevous bashing comments (outside of this interaction), childishly deflecting comments to myself and Hawwah, and have written rather negative comments about Snape in general whilst missing tonnes of context...you being a Snape fan is very hard to believe. Hating him or criticising him is fine...but at least do so with canon context and not headcanon ones. His criticism often goes exaggerated, and supporting those who go after Snape fans for correcting that, is uncalled for. So yes, I would like to end this conversation. If I could block you I would.

Janie

We don't know that James initiated "every" attack on Snape. We just know about the ones that were shown in Snape's memory. I'm not defending James, though. I'm just trying to say, that we don't know what else they did to each other before or after the incident in the memory. But we do know, from the Prince's Tale chapter, that Snape was friends with Death Eaters (I wouldn't call them "nazi" though, maybe "a cult of blood purists" is the correct term?) and agreed with their ideas and thought the Dark magic one of his Death Eater friends tried on a fellow student was "a laugh". I'm not a huge fan of the Marauders either, btw. The werewolf prank and the underwear incident were absolutely awful and they should have been severely punished for it (though we don't know for sure they weren't).

Hawwah

"Snape would have told Dumbledore if he knew Peter was a known Death Eater." Precisely. Darcy's accusation has no basis in canon.

Janie

Hm... the thing is, Sirius wasn't in Azkaban for killing the Potters but for killing 12 muggles. If Snape knew that it was Pettigrew who'd given up James and Lily to Voldemort, I believe that he would have tried to hunt Peter down right after he found out about Lily's death. Or, at the very least, he would have told Dumbledore about it later.

S1lm4r1l

> "Dumbledore being a brilliant person by helping Lupin going to Hogwarts – and also Dumbledore encouraging the ghost rumours, I imagine him talking loudly about it down at the pub." Or asking that the Hogwarts Ghosts spread the rumour. They ask Nearly Headless Nick about the Shrieking Shack and he says that an "Extremely rough crowd live there." > "I like to imagine that Pettigrew, when the Weasley's weren't at home, turned human just for a few hours, always keeping an eye on the entrance door in case they come home." It's funny to think about, but I doubt it. I think Pettigrew was a rat the entire time.

S1lm4r1l

> "Also, I'm curious how did Sirius communicate with Crookshanks?" Sniffed his butt. Obviously. :D

S1lm4r1l

> "James initiated every attack on Snape." Evidence?

S1lm4r1l

> "And the fact that they then accomplished it at 15 is just incredible." And without anyone catching wind of their plans. Keeping it secret in a place like Hogwarts with ears and eyes everywhere must've been quite the feat too. > "I’m glad we finally heard how Sirius escaped Azkaban. That bit was left out of the movie and I think a lot of people were confused about it." The fact that even he doesn't really know how he did it is what gets me. Black might claim that his belief in his innocence kept him sane, but surely the Death Eaters thought they were in the right too? I think Black's ability to transform into a dog made him less susceptible to the Dementor's powers. > "A couple things about Snape now…if he was so concerned for everyone’s safety, why didn’t he bring the Wolfsbane potion with him when he went after Lupin?" This is an interesting question. Doubtless someone will attempt to explain it to you using that pitchfork. > "Surely he didn’t think he could subdue a werewolf on his own?" Rather uncuts the whole "Snape was completely traumatized by the experience" argument if he did. > "Maybe his idea of a prank always included some form of danger because of the cruelty he saw in his home on a regular basis." Given the artefacts they find in Sirius's parents house, that seems a positively dangerous environment for a child to grow up in. Maybe Sirius's judgement of safe and unsafe was a bit like Hagrid's? Extremely optimistic. > "So to him, he genuinely didn’t think Snape would get hurt (which he didn’t), but it also maybe never occurred to him that what he was doing was not ok." Sirius probably had a fairly skewed view of right and wrong if he grew up with pure-blood supremacists for family who liked to practice dark magic and keep mysterious, dangerous artefacts all over the place.

S1lm4r1l

> "It's heavily implied that James went around telling people he'd saved Severus' life" I mean, that's the truth isn't it? He did save his life. > "playing the hero without any context whatsoever" The context being that someone else lured Snape out of school, out of the school grounds against all school rules. That Snape went looking for trouble and found it. It wasn't like Sirius forced Snape to break the rules and go down the tunnel. Snape could've easily been the better person and ignored Sirius entirely. > "If that isn't blatantly rubbing it in Snape's face that Sirius got away with trying to murder him, I don't know what is." Assuming James was the person to spread the story, and assuming Sirius was trying to murder Snape.

H

Good point about the Hogwarts ghosts! (And yes, I agree about Pettigrew.)

Mordimer

@John Phillips I literally quoted line that proves, that James did not initiate every attack on Snape. You like him so much, that it blinds you ;) And I won't take it easy on his dark magic staff. And no, I can't stop referring to him as magic nazi, because he literally was magic nazi. Deatheaters are basically nazis. They want to clean the world of muggleborns, nazi wanted to do it with jews. Should I also remind you that Snape told Voldemort prophecy knowing that child with family will die, he just didn't know who. When he realized who prophecy is about, he asked Voldemort to kill only Harry and James and after that he went to Dumbledore to ask him to hide only Lily first. Dumbledore basically made him ask for hiding entire family. Here's proof: "“Well, Severus? What message does Lord Voldemort have for me?” “No — no message — I’m here on my own account!” Snape was wringing his hands. He looked a little mad, with his straggling black hair flying around him. “I — I come with a warning — no, a request — please —” Dumbledore flicked his wand. Though leaves and branches still flew through the night air around them, silence fell on the spot where he and Snape faced each other. “What request could a Death Eater make of me?” “The — the prophecy… the prediction… Trelawney…” “Ah, yes,” said Dumbledore. “How much did you relay to Lord Voldemort?” “Everything — everything I heard!” said Snape. “That is why — it is for that reason — he thinks it means Lily Evans!” “The prophecy did not refer to a woman,” said Dumbledore. “It spoke of a boy born at the end of July —” “You know what I mean! He thinks it means her son, he is going to hunt her down — kill them all —” “If she means so much to you,” said Dumbledore, “surely Lord Voldemort will spare her? Could you not ask for mercy for the mother, in exchange for the son?” “I have — I have asked him —” “You disgust me,” said Dumbledore, and Harry had never heard so much contempt in his voice. Snape seemed to shrink a little, “You do not care, then, about the deaths of her husband and child? They can die, as long as you have what you want?” Snape said nothing, but merely looked up at Dumbledore. “Hide them all, then,” he croaked. “Keep her — them — safe. Please.”"

Liz

These are probably my favourite chapters especially when lupin explains everything to them I was 9 when I first read this book and I think I remember everything clicking in my head at this point and you're the first person I've subscribed to on patreon now I'm working again 🙃 also it annoys me a little that the movie didn't make time for a few mins of screen time to explain the marauders and they don't specifically say in the film that Harry's dad turned into a stag it's just mentioned later on and gazed over (as we know that's the reason Harry's patronus is a stag)

Sam-I-Am

Hi Veggie! Missed the previous book club, but so happy to be joining back with these amazing information filled and action-packed chapters! First things first, I don't hate any Harry Potter character. Well, any except for Voldemort, Umbridge, Vernon, Petunia, and Pettigrew lol. But I certainly don't hate Snape or Sirius. They're both complex and flawed characters. They were both portrayed by incredible actors. I can definitely understand why both characters have such passionate fans. For me, when it comes to the great Snape vs. Marauders debate, multiple things can be true at once. The Marauders were bullies to Snape at Hogwarts. Sirius's "prank" was cruel and dangerous. But ultimately James, Sirius, and Lupin grew up and proved themselves to be good people. Not perfect and not always right, but good people. Snape was a victim and didn't deserve to be bullied. But he has no business being a professor and uses his position to bully students, which is not okay regardless of what he went through. Despite his flaws, when it comes down to it Snape is a good person too in my opinion. Maybe his motivation for turning over to the good side was selfish, but he still risked his life for Harry's safety. Can't wait to hear your thoughts on these chapters!

Sam-I-Am

@Ashley Evers couldn't agree with your second paragraph more! JKR really did Snape a disservice by making Lily's death his (seemingly) sole reason for changing sides. When I was younger, I definitely bought into the idea that his love for Lily was a redeeming quality, but now that I'm older I see how faulty and actually lowkey problematic that was of Snape's character. Not to mention, super unhealthy and unrealistic. He was hung up on someone who never reciprocated his feelings and never once moved on in all that time?! I still think his character is good and courageous at the end of it all, but it would have greatly benefited the readers to get some insight on his regrets beyond Lily and her death.

Janie

I agree. JKR didn't think it through. Also, I've always had a problem with Harry forgiving Snape so easily after seeing his memories in book 7. I mean, Harry hated him for seven years, but suddenly all that is forgotten and Snape is the bravest man ever? He suddenly admires Snape so much, that he even named his son after him? Really? Just because Snape claimed to love his mother, suddenly nothing else matters? Imagine poor Neville finding out Harry named his son after a man who used to be his biggest fear.

Hawwah

@Sam-I-Am I swore to myself not to engage in these discussions anymore, but I have to correct this common misconception. Lily's death wasn't Severus' reason for changing sides. Severus betrayed Voldemort, switched sides and became a spy for the Order approximately A YEAR BEFORE Lily's death.

Ashley Evers

I'm sorry, you are correct that Snape became a spy in an attempt to protect Lily, not after she died. It seems like we don't have the exact timeline, but it was after he gave the prophecy to Voldemort and after Voldemort decided to target the Potter's specifically. Thank you for correcting me :)

John Phillips

And you hate Snape so much that it blinds you. You make it sound like it was just a simple rivalry. It wasn't. The Marauders were bullying Snape. The books and JK Rowling have said so. Maybe he attacked James in self defense.

Hawwah

You're welcome. We don't know the exact date when Severus deserted Voldemort, but it must have been sometime in autumn 1980. I recently wrote an answer on Quora where I put together the timeline. If you're interested, you can check it out here: https://tinyurl.com/yujdeefs

Sam-I-Am

@Hawwah Good catch. Thanks for the timeline, I'll definitely check it out! But even still, his reason for changing sides a year earlier was to protect Lily because Voldemort thought the prophecy was talking about her son. I don't have a problem with Lily being his primary reason for changing sides, but my issue is that this is the only reason we ever get for why he does what he does. I get it, the series is not told from his POV, but we don't ever really get more info about whether he truly changed his beliefs and regretted his actions (becoming a death eater, telling Voldemort about the prophecy - if it hadn't been about Lily's son, he had to have known he was endangering the life of an innocent child and family). That coupled with how he treats some students, makes it hard for some fans to like him or think he was truly deserving of a redemption arc. To be clear, I think this is JKR's fault and not a fault of the character himself. I'm personally of the belief that there surely must have been other reasons. Maybe in the beginning it was all about Lily, but I'd like to think that over time he evolved as a person as did his beliefs and he had other reasons for going against Voldemort. But we're never treated to those reasons or changes, which is a shame. Despite my issues with this, I still think with what we were given he was at the end of it a good person and was courageous in what he did.

Janie

I would really love to read/watch a book/tv show about the Marauders told from Snape's POV. I want to know what he felt and thought, if the fact, that Voldemort was after Lily was really the only reason why he changed sides. Would he have decided to do that eventually, even if Voldemort had chosen Neville or would he have stayed a loyal Death Eater, not caring that an innocent child was killed? It's really hard for me to decide, whether Snape was, deep down, a good person or not, if the only reason we get for him changing sides was an unhealthy obssession with a woman.

Zachary Wynn

Great way to write out my exact thoughts!

S1lm4r1l

> "And you hate Snape so much that it blinds you." Directly quoting the books counts as hate? > "You make it sound like it was just a simple rivalry. It wasn't." Evidence? > "The Marauders were bullying Snape. The books and JK Rowling have said so. Maybe he attacked James in self defense." Perhaps James had good reason to attack him. Snape wasn't fussed when Lily told him that Mulciber performed dark magic on one of her friends. Karkaroff claims during his trial that Mulciber was a specialist in the Imperius Curse. Perhaps the Marauders were seeking to defend their fellow students from the dark magic and blood-status prejudice so obviously evident in Snape's friend group, most of whom would become Death Eaters? Perhaps they too were pro-active in displaying their political sympathies at school.

John Phillips

The evidence is literally in the books. Even Harry couldn't find a justification for their treatment of Snape. I get the impression that you are either denying the fact that the Marauders were bullying Snape or you're trying to justify their bullying towards Snape all because you dislike Snape so much that any attack on him must have been for a "good reason". You tell me to give you evidence, but there's no evidence on your side that the Marauders were always defending their fellow students from dark magic.

Dara Jeeling

@itsadancething - I am not doing "quote a sentece" not my thing, really first things, first - yes it is amazing that they managed to become aimagi so young. But then I guess we always get to hear who they were good students and (at leas James ad Sirius) quite capable. about the Snape thing I personally do not thing it's possible to think rational if you are under stress (not even PTS, just stress) - but maybe that's just me being bad at it, really. So for me (and just what I interpret) he comes into the office - and he knows until Remus drinks the Wolfsbane he will not be safe to be around. He can not find him - and he is in a school full of unknowing children he realizes the map (and discovers what it is I guess). He may have cought a glimpse of the kids vaishing under the tree and then realizes that Luin s also heading that way. He knows the kids will meet a fully grown werewolf and maybe, justmaybe he sort of to stressed now to remember picking up th cup (or maybe he could not have run fast eough with the cup/goblet) For me his leaving the wolfsbane behind just shows how desperate he is (ad again it's just my interpretation) to get to the children he is supposed to protect as a teacher. as for the Sirius part - please also keep your pitchforc at bay.... that they went out of their way to hlep Remus is great - but those excursions were dangers to others - for me this i NO excuse for plaing a "prank" on Snape. one should also think, that because he knew dark magic and actions he would (as he choose Gryffindor, or got choosen for it) not tr y to step up to the ways of his family. and sorry - the reason Snape did not get hurt was that James Potter risked his own health and life to get him out there. Peopel say Sirius is smart - so HOW IN HELL could he think a fully grwon werewolf would not hurt their classmate? Werewolfs attack because they can not stop themselves, once transformed and one can be lucky if he/she/they are only turned and not die.

Dara Jeeling

yay giving people another reason to come after me with pitchforkes... before writing this... I am all against bullying. I think whoever wants to be a (insert job here) teacher, social worker, doctor, nurse, works with people in general should have a passion to do so. I am Kindergarten teacher/social worker worki in a reitrement home with the eldery ( people with dementia) and I (and my old people can certainly) tell who is working out of passion and loves their job and who is not... now back to making sure to get hunted by pitchforkes Severus Snape has done a lot of bad things in his time as a teacher and should have at least acknowledged and apologized. But also... he started his job in his early 20s after suffering a though an immense trauma (loosing/getting killed the one person he loved/he thought cared for him and basically sentencig an innocent child to death at the hands of the master he only followed out of desperation and conditioning) on top of the previous 20 years of unadressed trauma (at the very least verbal abuse/neglect form his parents, extreme poverty, years of school bullying, at least one near deth experience, sexual assault, the general idea of bein coerced into a death cult, etc). He never choose to be a teacher. He was told to be a teacher by the man who kept him from going to Askaban and gave him the glimmer of a chance to save his childhood best friend/the person e thought he loved. Not sure, but I think it's undestandable he might be a little high strung or sappy when teaching preteens who do not know how to behave... ( and no I am NOT fine with the way he teaches - although I see the need to be very strict in Potions)

Sam-I-Am

@Dara Jeeling I hope no one comes after you with pitchforks! I agree, becoming a teacher was not Snape’s choice. Like so many other times, Dumbledore manipulated him and forced him into the role. It’s one of the many reasons I have a pretty low opinion of Dumbledore. However, I would still say the way Snape treats and talks to some students is unacceptable. I have sympathy for Snape and I understand that there is a reason he is the way he is, but that doesn’t excuse him in my opinion. He’s an adult (20s is still old enough to know better), regardless of whether he wanted the job or not, he should not take that out on innocent children. Like I said in my original comment, I think when you take into account the totality of everything and the sacrifices he made, he is a good person. But I do see why some fans get a little frustrated when people make excuses/downplay (that’s how it comes across sometimes) his behavior. As awful as the marauders treated him, they were kids at the time. Snape is an adult when he treats students the way he does.

Hawwah

I really don't want to start another argument, but how does Snape treat students? He takes points and assigns detention when students misbehave. That's literally a teacher doing his job. McGonagall does the same and her punishments are actually a way harsher than his.

Sam-I-Am

@Hawwah I’m not talking about taking points or assigning detentions. As a teacher, that’s his right as it’s McGonagall’s. But the way he speaks to students (particularly Harry, Neville, and Hermione) is awful. There’s definitely room for debate about whether it’s tantamount to bullying, but either way it’s not ok as a teacher or even as an adult. Some examples of this, calling Hermione an insufferable know-it-all, constantly making snide comments about James to Harry (to be clear he’s well within his right to hate James for bullying him, but it’s another thing when you talk badly about a dead man to his son), belittling Neville and warning Lupin about him, saying “I see no difference” about Hermione’s teeth after they were hit by the engorgement spell.

Mordimer

@John Yea, the evidence is in the books. I literally quoted it to you word by word xD you on the other hand just keep saying staff without any quotes and claim it's in the books ;)

Hawwah

Okay, I can see your point when it comes to talking about James to Harry. Yes, this can be seen as unprofessional. However, I don't agree he *constantly* makes comments about James. I remember only one such instance in this book so far - when Snape caught Harry sneaking out to Hogsmeade, despite all the security measures that were put in place to protect Harry's safety. Even Veggie acknowledged Snape was correct when he called Harry arrogant. I don't agree with the other examples, though. Hermione kept on speaking without permission even when Professor Snape repeatedly told her not to. It was clear that simply telling her to be quiet wouldn't work. Professor McGonagall wouldn't have tolerated such a disrespectful behavior in her class either. When Professor Snape warned Lupin about Neville, it perhaps wasn't very tactful, but he wasn't wrong. Neville *is* a danger to both himself and others. He proved it many times. When it comes to Hermione's teeth, Snape couldn't show concern for a muggleborn student in front of at least 4 children of Death Eaters. However, when Hermione ran off and skipped class, he didn't give her any punishment. I think it's very telling, given how strict he normally is.

Dara Jeeling

as I said I do not approve of is teaching style. But I can understand why he is sort of frustrated....

Sam-I-Am

I'm pretty sure there were other instances of Snape insulting James to Harry throughout the series, but would have to go back and find them, can't remember specifically off the top of my head. Even if telling her to be quiet wasn't working, it doesn't justify him insulting her. There were other things he could have said or done. Not tactful is putting it lightly. It's publicly putting him down, which there was no need to. True or not. And I think it's very debatable whether Neville truly is that dangerous to himself and others to need a warning. I don't think he was, though I can see how an argument can be made otherwise because of the situation with the passwords list. Still, the warning was unnecessary and just makes it seem like he enjoys picking on Neville. To say that he couldn't show concern for Hermione because there were 4 children of Death Eaters seems like a huge stretch to be quite honest. I understand and respect that we see things differently. I certainly don't hate Snape. I understand why you and so many other fans like him so much. But fact is despite being a good and courageous man, he made his fair share of mistakes, one of them being the way he treated his students.

Sam-I-Am

@Dara Jeeling I understand it too and do sympathize to an extent. I put a lot of blame on Dumbledore for putting him in that position in the first place and then allowing him (and other professors) to act unprofessionally and just do whatever they wanted.

itsanursething

I hear you Dara. Maybe I didn't explain it well regarding Sirius. In my experience, teenage boys (no matter how smart they are) make REALLY dumb decisions all the time - like adventuring with a fully formed werewolf (again I say, not smart!). What I was trying to say is, maybe Sirius's idea of a prank always involved some kind of violence. I know it's still true to an extent with guys nowadays (think the JackAss crew)...if someone isn't getting hurt, it's not funny. I don't agree with it, but it's the mindset I've seen in a lot of guys. I do agree, the only reason Snape wasn't hurt is because James stepped in. 100% true! I'm also wondering though, were Sirius and Peter with Remus when Snape went through the tunnel? Did he maybe think he (as Padfoot) could control Remus enough to keep Snape "safe"? Just questions. I don't know the answers! With his upbringing, yes Sirius wanted to get away from all the darkness, but he couldn't completely escape it. Look how he treats Kreacher. SOME things stuck with him, no matter how badly he wanted to be different. I'm not saying it was ok what he did! Not by a long shot, but I can kind of see where he would have thought it was funny. Does that make sense at all? I hope my response wasn't too pitchforky! :)

Rebecca May

> “The context being that someone else lured Snape out of school, out of the school grounds against all school rules. That Snape went looking for trouble and found it. It wasn't like Sirius forced Snape to break the rules and go down the tunnel. Snape could've easily been the better person and ignored Sirius entirely.” So you’re telling me that if the situation was reversed – if Snape had lured Sirius or James into an extremely dangerous situation – you’d be condemning Sirius or James for breaking school rules, and taking the bait? Would you let Snape off the hook because “Sirius went looking for trouble?” Forgive me if I’m wrong, but I really don’t think you would. I think you’d be telling me “That’s just the way the Marauders are,” or “Snape *knew* Sirius wouldn’t be able to resist, so it’s his fault,” or “Do you really think Sirius would be able to resist a challenge like that?” (All of which are equally true when applied to Snape). And then cue all the reasons that Sirius and James are justified for persecuting Snape. I’ve already said I don’t believe that James’ reasons for saving Snape were selfless. As such, the context (in my mind) is that he was trying to prevent Sirius being expelled. But I’m 100% sure that James would have spoken about it as though he selflessly and heroically threw himself into danger on Snape’s behalf, for no other reason than it was the right thing to do. (And to avoid us going around in circles on this point again, YES, I’m happy James chose to save Snape, whatever his reasons.) > “Assuming James was the person to spread the story, and assuming Sirius was trying to murder Snape.” Of course, you are more than welcome to disagree, but I believe these are both entirely fair assumptions. It had to be James and/or Sirius spreading the story – it’s within character, and no-one else was there. Sirius is clearly unashamed of the “prank” (or even outright pleased with himself for coming up with it), and James is proud of his heroic rescue. Lupin would be too mortified and Peter too timid to ever mention it. As for the murder attempt… In these very chapters, Lupin states: “Sirius here played a trick on him which nearly killed him…” To which Sirius replies: “It served him right.” He does not contradict Lupin. He does not attempt to clarify in any way that this was not meant to result in Severus’ death. He accepts this view of the situation completely, and without remorse. If Severus was banned from speaking about the incident and putting his own view forwards, the Marauders should have faced equal restrictions. My view is that they probably were told not to say anything, and ignored it because… Well, why wouldn’t they? It’s not like they faced any serious consequences for doing much worse. Also, you can’t have it both ways – both insisting that James saved Severus’ life (as I’ve said, I believe this to be true, and I'm glad he did so), and also insisting that Sirius’ “prank” was actually not that bad and probably wouldn’t have killed Snape. Seriously, which is it??

S1lm4r1l

> "I get the impression that you are either denying the fact that the Marauders were bullying Snape or you're trying to justify their bullying towards Snape all because you dislike Snape so much that any attack on him must have been for a "good reason"." They didn't have a 'good' reason. But they did have a reason. Why do you think the Marauders picked on Snape more than anyone else? They didn't like the way he ate porridge or something? > "You tell me to give you evidence, but there's no evidence on your side that the Marauders were always defending their fellow students from dark magic." Lucius Malfoy and Borgin complain in book 2 that Blood status is counting for less and less within the Wizarding World. Lily says that Snape and his friends call everyone of her blood status "Mudblood." Whilst in the books we hardly ever hear the term. The way the Gryffindor team reacts to Malfoy saying it to Hermione indicates it was clearly beyond the pale. Yet Lily says Snape and his friends use it all the time. Finally, James and Sirius only become angry with Snape after he uses it. James even demands that Snape apologise to Lily. He says "I'd never call you and you-know-what." He refuses to use the word in a generalised way and not directed at anyone. We absolutely have evidence for the Marauders standing up for their fellow students.

S1lm4r1l

> "James flat out admitted to Lily that he was picking on Snape purely because he "exists"." And what does he mean by that? Because Snape as a singular person exists? Or because people like him exist. Dark magic users, people who disdain and abuse muggle-borns, people who would blindly follow someone like Voldemort. We know that Snape is not the only person James and Sirius attack or bully during their time at school. > "We only know one time of Snape calling someone (Lily) a mudblood." Lily says he uses the term to refer to people of Lily's blood status. > "None of the rest of your accusations towards Snape have been confirmed in canon" I've literally just proved that they have. > "they certainly do not justify the Marauders' treatment of Snape." Of course not. But I don't think its hard to understand why they treated him the way they did. > "The comparison you mentioned is James being compared to Draco and Snape being compared to Harry. Not the other way around." The comparison doesn't specify.

S1lm4r1l

> "So you’re telling me that if the situation was reversed – if Snape had lured Sirius or James into an extremely dangerous situation – you’d be condemning Sirius or James for breaking school rules, and taking the bait? Would you let Snape off the hook because “Sirius went looking for trouble?” Forgive me if I’m wrong, but I really don’t think you would. I think you’d be telling me “That’s just the way the Marauders are,” or “Snape *knew* Sirius wouldn’t be able to resist, so it’s his fault,” or “Do you really think Sirius would be able to resist a challenge like that?” (All of which are equally true when applied to Snape). And then cue all the reasons that Sirius and James are justified for persecuting Snape." No. But Snape would never have bothered trying to save Sirius' or James's life. He didn't think their lives were worth saving. > "But I’m 100% sure that James would have spoken about it as though he selflessly and heroically threw himself into danger on Snape’s behalf, for no other reason than it was the right thing to do." If Snape is banned from speaking about it, why would Dumbledore be happy to let the Marauders talk about it? Far more likely Dumbledore made them all swear not to discuss it. > "It had to be James and/or Sirius spreading the story – it’s within character, and no-one else was there." What would James have said he saved Snape from though? James gives every inclination of trying to keep Lupin's secret. Boasting about how he saved Snape's life from some unknown danger in the Shrieking Shack seems like playing with fire in that regard. > ""nearly killed him…” To which Sirius replies: “It served him right.”" Sounds like Sirius is saying Snape deserved his near-death experience to me. Which is terrible. > "If Severus was banned from speaking about the incident and putting his own view forwards, the Marauders should have faced equal restrictions. My view is that they probably were told not to say anything, and ignored it because… Well, why wouldn’t they? It’s not like they faced any serious consequences for doing much worse." All of them were dragged up to Dumbledore's office. It makes no sense that Snape was forbidden to speak about the incident and the others not. Dumbledore wants to keep it a secret that Lupin is attending school with Lycanthropy remember. Why wouldn't he have forbidden the Marauders to talk? > "Also, you can’t have it both ways – both insisting that James saved Severus’ life (as I’ve said, I believe this to be true, and I'm glad he did so), and also insisting that Sirius’ “prank” was actually not that bad and probably wouldn’t have killed Snape. Seriously, which is it??" These are not contradictory ideas though. Sirius could believe that a teenage werewolf hidden in a boarded up house was not a threat to Snape's life. Just look at the house he grew up in, dark objects, artefacts, potions and things all over the place. Just like Hagrid vastly underestimates the danger of certain creatures to his students, maybe Sirius made a similar mistake. I don't think it likely at all, but you could argue this. The tunnel is well hidden at both ends, the last book is quite emphatic about the fact that the Trio could see Voldemort and Nagini in its defensive orb whilst they were none the wiser as to the Trio's hiding place. The positioning would be similar for Snape and Were-Lupin. The likelihood of Snape being able to see the Werewolf whilst the Werewolf being unaware of Snape seems fairly high. Especially if Were-Lupin is biting and attacking himself. But James might have held a different view of Were-Lupin's danger to Snape and that's why he went to help save Snape, regardless of his reasoning. More likely is that Sirius didn't care either way.

Rebecca May

> “No. But Snape would never have bothered trying to save Sirius' or James's life. He didn't think their lives were worth saving.” That might be fair – I’m undecided myself. But I definitely don’t think Snape would have pulled such a stunt to begin with. > “If Snape is banned from speaking about it, why would Dumbledore be happy to let the Marauders talk about it? Far more likely Dumbledore made them all swear not to discuss it.” Sorry, I don’t think I was clear on my point here. I absolutely think Dumbledore made them all swear not to discuss it. I just think Severus took that very seriously, while James and/or Sirius ignored it as much as they could without directly implicating Lupin. > “What would James have said he saved Snape from though? James gives every inclination of trying to keep Lupin's secret. Boasting about how he saved Snape's life from some unknown danger in the Shrieking Shack seems like playing with fire in that regard.” “Playing with fire” describes James Potter and Sirius Black perfectly, it's kind of their thing. As I mentioned earlier, in the Prince’s Tale, Lily says: “You went sneaking down that tunnel by the Whomping Willow and James Potter saved you from whatever’s down there…” I have no idea what James *precisely* told people he saved Snape from, but it’s absolutely clear that people know he saved him from *something*. Maybe he didn’t even specify, and let the other students fill in the blank from their own imagination. > “These are not contradictory ideas though. Sirius could believe that a teenage werewolf hidden in a boarded up house was not a threat to Snape's life… More likely is that Sirius didn't care either way.” I suppose so. I can agree with you that it’s unlikely Sirius misjudged the situation, and much more likely that he simply didn’t care what happened to Snape once he entered the tunnel. If nothing else, James can be commended for taking the threat seriously and pulling Severus out of harms way.

Hawwah

So I went through the books so far and the scene in Snape's office is indeed the first time Professor Snape brings up James in a conversation with Harry. The confrontantion in the Shrieking Shack is going to be the second time. Two times in three years is hardly "constantly".

Mate

Hi Veggie, We’ve already established and agree that Snape and Sirius are flawed and complex characters by now. I do believe one thing though. Snape has always protected harry as we know from the philosophers stone and the movies. He really thought Sirius was out to kill Harry and not only did he make a promise to Dumbledore to protect him but he also believed that Sirius gave up the Potters to Voldemort. Even if he did infact know Peter was passing information to Voldemort, he must have believed like everyone else that their secret keeper was Sirius. Even Dumbledore believed that. No one knew about the change of secret keepers. So Snape believes that Sirius actually betrayed James and his family which resulted in Lily’s death. More of a reason to hate one of his school bullies. He wanted revenge and he was really out to get it.

Methanoutput

Hey Said, i think the last part of your comment is a spoiler. I think that Snape told Voldemort about the Prophecy is mentioned in the 6th book? But i can be wrong.

Katie

Yes, that's right, it's a big revelation near the end of book 6! Definitely a spoiler

S1lm4r1l

> "Sorry, I don’t think I was clear on my point here. I absolutely think Dumbledore made them all swear not to discuss it. I just think Severus took that very seriously, while James and/or Sirius ignored it as much as they could without directly implicating Lupin." Maybe, but I don't see why Snape would obey those restrictions if James and Sirius were so blatantly flouting them. > "“Playing with fire” describes James Potter and Sirius Black perfectly, it's kind of their thing." No disagreement from me. > "As I mentioned earlier, in the Prince’s Tale, Lily says: “You went sneaking down that tunnel by the Whomping Willow and James Potter saved you from whatever’s down there…” I have no idea what James *precisely* told people he saved Snape from, but it’s absolutely clear that people know he saved him from *something*. Maybe he didn’t even specify, and let the other students fill in the blank from their own imagination." But this is the truth, maybe not the whole truth, but James Potter didn't lie. > "I suppose so. I can agree with you that it’s unlikely Sirius misjudged the situation, and much more likely that he simply didn’t care what happened to Snape once he entered the tunnel. If nothing else, James can be commended for taking the threat seriously and pulling Severus out of harms way." For all the talk about how Potter and Snape hated each other, I'd argue that Sirius was far more malicious towards him.

S1lm4r1l

> "It's really hard for me to decide, whether Snape was, deep down, a good person or not, if the only reason we get for him changing sides was an unhealthy obssession with a woman." Snape was not a good person. He was a terrible person on the good side. Much like Sirius Black or Mundungus.

Janie

Yes, please delete or change the second half of your comment. Snape telling Voldemort about the prophecy wasn't in the movies so it's a spoiler for Veggie.

Janie

Was Sirius Black a terrible person? He did some terrible things (his treatment of Kreacher, the prank on Snape...), but as far as we know he hated dark magic (that's why he hated Snape, after all), he left his family because he didn't agree with their beliefs, he never killed anyone, he cared about his friends. I wouldn't say he was a bad person. He wasn't a nice man though and I'm not really his fan either. Actually, the only Marauder I really like is Lupin.

Kattie Martin

I was 8 or 9 the first time I read this book and, although I was able to understand it enough to pass an AR test, I feel like I'm noticing new things reading it as an adult and one of them being how immature Sirius is. He's in his thirties and while I know he's been in a horrible prison for twelve years he was an adult before going there and he's still convinced that what he did to Snape was okay. It's as if he didn't even think about how it would have affected Lupin if James hadn't interviened. Lupin referring to it as a "prank" also seems to downplay the seriousness of the situation.

Mate

Thanks for the lookout guys, it has been amended. I appreciate that

Dara Jeeling

I always wondered if Snape even knew Peter was a Death Eater and if Peter kew Snape was. I mean, it would make sense that Voldemort sort of would not tell anyone who else were his followers, so that someone like Karkaroff could not give them all away... We also do not know when Peter joined (not that this is an excuse for him to "rat" out his friends) which would also explain, why Snape was not suspicious and was sure Peter was dead

Hawwah

@Dara Yes, that's precisely what Karkaroff said in the Pensieve. Only Voldemort himself knew all the Death Eaters.

itsanursething

I'm curious now, did anyone outside of the Marauders and Dumbledore know they had even USED the Fidelius charm? I mean, Snape said to hide them (the Potters) but I don't know if Dumbledore told him HOW he hid them. I mean, REMUS didn't even know they switched...

Maria

When I was re-reading these chapters, I kept thinking to myself "Veggie is going to love this; they're answering all his questions!" I've read this book many times, but I was struck by a couple of things this time. First, I was surprised by how willing Snape was to hand Lupin over to the dementors as well as Sirius. He even mentions the dementor's kiss. I know he doesn't like Lupin, but suggesting Lupin should have his soul sucked out is very extreme, even for Snape. I'm not sure he actually would have done it in the end, but it's very cruel to suggest. I was also really struck by Sirius' description of living in Azkaban. It made me emotional, especially when he talked about how his innocence was not a happy thought, so they couldn't take that away from him. I also loved how Hermione calls Sirius "Mr. Black." It's great.

Dara Jeeling

alos... the way he levitates Snape out of the Shack... Making him hit his head and such - really lovely

S1lm4r1l

Snape did not see the children on the map. He saw Lupin. Lupin alone. Snape had no reason whatsoever to be stressed, other than Lupin going somewhere odd (but away from the students and staff) having not taken the potion.

S1lm4r1l (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-20 18:00 &gt; "So Snape believes that Sirius actually betrayed James and his family which resulted in Lily’s death. More of a reason to hate one of his school bullies. He wanted revenge and he was really out to get it." Snape showed incredible restraint not killing Sirius on the spot. Although I suppose the lure of inflicting the Dementor's kiss on Sirius was just too much.
2023-05-13 20:13 > "So Snape believes that Sirius actually betrayed James and his family which resulted in Lily’s death. More of a reason to hate one of his school bullies. He wanted revenge and he was really out to get it." Snape showed incredible restraint not killing Sirius on the spot. Although I suppose the lure of inflicting the Dementor's kiss on Sirius was just too much.

> "So Snape believes that Sirius actually betrayed James and his family which resulted in Lily’s death. More of a reason to hate one of his school bullies. He wanted revenge and he was really out to get it." Snape showed incredible restraint not killing Sirius on the spot. Although I suppose the lure of inflicting the Dementor's kiss on Sirius was just too much.

Simon audsley

Allo' Allo' I was just..... Not much to say on these chapters that won't have been said already so will be brief. The reason for Hermione's reaction crying and hysterics at the Bogart where more to do with the self inflicted nervous breakdown she was about to have as much as anything else. So you will at least understand the marauders fully now, it not been in the film is like star wars without the "no I am your father". As for Brian Blessed, not long to wait for a goodish casting choice in three chapters time. Right now back to saving hyrule again for me.

Hairy Pothead

Hope you are well Veggie! This book really shows Snapes selfish and sadistic side that was toned down a lot in the movies. He's enjoying abusing his position of power to torment students, to the point of becoming their greatest fear. In the Shrieking Shack he doesn't care about the truth, as long as he gets revenge. He's listening to Lupins story while under the Invisibility Cloak, but interrupts it and doesn't let them explain further. He talks like Lupin is a creature even though he knows that the potion is making him harmless. Sirius offers to come quietly if they bring the rat, but Snape would rather have both Sirius and Lupin suffer a fate worse than death, than hearing a truth that could possibly deny him the revenge. He then has the audacity to say that he's saved the trios necks, even tho they are armed while Sirius and Lupin are unarmed and haven't tried to hurt them.

Methanoutput

Hey Hairy Pothead, i think the last part of your comment is a spoiler, since Snape is still unconscious at the point this chapter from the Book Club ends. But i could be wrong.

Katik

Hi Veggie! Normally re-reading these book, while knowing what some actions I am currently reading about mean for the future plot, I don't have a problem distancing myself from that and enjoying the story as it is. These chapters though are one of two exceptions to this for me: It fills me with anxiety every time I read about these details knowing where they lead, and what could be if any of these happened differently! - If only Lupin hadn't forgotten to take his potion that day - If only Harry hadn't left the cloak lying around - If only Lupin hadn't left the map open in his office - If only Snape even in his anger still brought the wolfsbane potion with him as he pursued Lupin - If only Snape listened to the whole conversation before making his entry - If only anyone in the room at that moment stopped and realised what it meant when Snape mentioned that Lupin had forgotten to take his potion and it was the full moon I'm sure there's even more critical details there! Everything might have worked out well, but we probably wouldn't have had any of the following books :D Anyway, question for you Veggie, if everything did go well that night, Pettigrew got arrested and Sirius's name got cleared, do you think Dumbledore would have agreed to Harry living with Sirius instead of the Dursleys? Given Dumbledore had reasons for placing Harry with them in the first place, rather than with any other wizarding family let's say from The Order? Or do you think Sirius would override him as Harry's godfather even if Dumbledore had a different opinion?

Noi. S

think the whole of this two chapters can win the most important/interesting part that they removed from the movies thus far . When you think about the context the movie gives you compared to the book you realize how little information and explanation they give you in the movie about basically everything that happens in the climax. They basically kept the twist and removed all the expansions to make it make sense in the story. I get why they did it but for me it removes the another one of the main reasons I liked the books so much, making the movies kind of meaningless for me. And last thing, I know a lot of people already told you this but giving criticism to something doesn’t mean you hate it. I really like the books but I can still acknowledge they have a lot of problems. So you don’t have to say “it’s not a criticism on the movie/book “, criticism is fine and it’s really interesting to hear.

Hairy Pothead

He's saying it twice before he gets knocked out. 'Get out of the way, Potter, you're in enough trouble already,' snarled Snape. 'If I hadn't been here to save your skin -' ... 'Like father, like son, Potter! I have just saved your neck, you should be thanking me on bended knee!'

H

Can't really remember 100%, and I've been wrong about this kind of thing before (sorry again, Kunzite!), but I can't remember much about it in the movie. It never felt like a massive relevation for me when I read the books, though, so it's probably OK? If you feel unsure, it would still be a good discussion topic without the whole part about Dumbledore's reasoning. If Veggie already knows, he'll discuss it with that in mind. If he don't, it's still interesting to hear it from that perspective. (So I guess I'm saying "either solution is probably okay")

itsanursething

It's not explicitly explained in the movies why Dumbledore placed Harry with the Dursley's. It's only ever explained in the books (I think in 6 or 7??). I think Veggie might be confused by the question, or he'll start asking why Dumbledore placed him with the Dursleys and start theorizing :)

Katik

Thanks @H and @itsadancething for your feedback! I've slightly edited the post now - hope it's ok to leave like that

Methanoutput

Oh okay sorry for the confusion :D I did not reread the scenes and thought you meant the scene in the hospital wing.

Frances Powell

SORT OF SPOILER AHEAD ... It really amazes me that a kid as smart as Snape could be stupid enough to do something Black told him to do. He already suspected Lupin was a werewolf "I know your theory", he already knew Black was a bit of an arse. WTF was he thinking? Did he think he was going to take on werewolf Lupin and ... do what? Get proof and tell people? Why? Because Lupin's mates gave him shit, and Lupin didn't stop them? This idiot kid was SO hellbent on revenge, he decided to follow a kid he thought was a werewolf down a hole under a tree???

Frances Powell

SLIGHT SPOILER ... I just listened to this on audiobook. The bedroom door opens by itself when they're having a chitchat. Lupin goes to it and checks the landing. Lupin then spends a full 10 minutes of audiobook time explaining about how he ended up a werewolf, how they became animagi, and about the dangerous trick Black played on Snape. Snape elects to show himself when it's mentioned that Potter pulled Snape back down the tunnel, and probably saved his life. He knew perfectly well that the kids weren't under any kind of spell (despite what he later told Fudge), and he'd been in there long enough to know that the kids all had their wands and no one was attacking anyone. He was also thrilled at the idea of being the one to hand over both Black and Lupin. "His eyes gleaming fanatically". He'd have denied everything out of spite.

Frances Powell

Have you forgotten the conversation Snape had with someone else in a later book? He had a very good idea what he would find, and that's what he was trying to prove. Black told Snape that if he prodded that particular knot at the base of the tree, he could get down the tunnel. I know that when my school bullies (who gave me such a hard time I had nightmares for 10 years) gave me hints and tips about how to get somewhere that was out of bounds, I assumed that they were trying to do me some form of harm (as usual). Poor little innocent Snape apparently though Black had turned over a new leaf?

Frances Powell

So while most comments are discussing something else, can we give three cheers to Ron and Hermione for being very good friends. It was chapter 17 and the relevant scene in the movie that made me realise Ron would never get a fair shake in the movies. What I had forgotten, was that Hermione also got a couple of Lupin's lines, too, not just Ron's. Frankly, I think Hermione is braver in the book, because she stands up for Harry even though she is absolutely terrified. It's harder to do brave things when you're scared.

Hawwah

Can we stop the victim-blaming, please? You're conflating what we, the readers, know, and what Severus knew. Black told Severus how to get past the Whomping Willow. That was it. He didn't tell him what was under the WW. He didn't tell him it was an enclosed area, a dead-end corridor. He didn't tell him that a transformed werewolf was roaming there freely. Severus didn't know it was a death trap. He couldn't have known. Black on the other hand knew it perfectly well.

Hawwah

Frances, could you please stop the victim-blaming? Besides, you're basically saying that Severus was a moron because he didn't think Black was capable of murder. You're saying he should have known Black was sending him to a death trap. You're saying only a moron like Severus would not realize Black was trying to murder him. That's not the great pro-Black argument you think it is. Quite the opposite.

Hawwah

"It's harder to do brave things when you're scared." Absolutely! That's why I admire Severus' bravery so much. When he realized what was happening, he set off to the Shrieking Shack at once. The place of his near-death experience, the place where he was almost mauled to death, the place that gave him PTSD. I don't think I would have been so brave if I had been in his place.

Q

These chapters are some of my favorites in the series! I'm a sucker for lore drops and character depth/development. We've talked extensively about Ron, but James Potter also gets done dirty by the movies, and especially by the omission of this whole explanation. He was a great and loyal friend, and with the way Sirius and Remus talk about him, everything he did for Remus at Hogwarts, the way Hagrid and Dumbledore and McGonagall talk about him, it's easy to adopt Harry's current viewpoint. His dad is his hero, his role model, and a great source of pride for him. We know from later movies, and with more detail from later books, that James was not as perfect as Harry imagines him now, but he's a big part of Harry's self-image at this point in his journey, whatever one's feelings on James as a character might end up being. Also, poor Remus! So many hardships and tragedies to talk about in his life, but I'm just going to point out the one: Imagine your greatest fear being an inevitable, monthly reality. I'm sure something along those lines is the case for a lot of people in the world with chronic illnesses and such, but putting it into words really hits home. I feel like I had more to say, but I can't remember it so I'll leave it relatively short! Thanks for the videos, Veggie!

Chorafini (Luiz)

You were spot on with your pronunciation of my username, but you can call me Luiz (my real name) if it's easier for you, Chorafini is just a nickname. So, about the "prank", that was terrible, I'm not a big fan of Snape as a person but that's clearly not okay, It's hard to believe that Sirius wanted him to literally die, but how would Snape escape? Saying that it was irresponsible is a BIG understatement. "I have just saved your neck, you should be thanking me on bended knee! You would have been well served if he'd killed you! You'd have died like your father, too arrogant to believe you might be mistaken in Black" I definitely did not remember Snape saying that. On another note, I'm really interested in your opinion on James saving Snape, Snape said that James only did it to save himself, but I personally think that he just thought that it was too much. I could be wrong, I wouldn't call this opinion biased for James because the only one that I really like on the Marauders is Lupin, i find the other interesting, but not my favorites. It has absolutely nothing to do with these chapters, but I was rewatching your Philosopher's Stone movie reaction and near minute 33 on the YouTube video Harry gets the Nimbus 2000, which was the best broom in the series at that point and your reaction was super happy and even said "winning already", how things have changed... Sorry to get off track, but it was so funny I couldn't stop myself from mentioning it here, keep up the good work, it's really nice having a reason to re-read these books after almos 10 years.

Dara Jeeling

and the wands would have done them any good,once Lupin had transformed? I am actually really fed up with all those "Snaters" ( this is not directed at you, but as someone who has gotten this for like 20 years - sometimes I am just really fed up) So here is my very unpopular thinking about Severus Snape Like... I've never seen a Snape fan trying to make Snape out to be perfect, but most anti fans only focus on his flaws. The main thing he is hated for - bullying, is something most popular characters in the series have done. EACH time I come across a post about why Snape`s the worst thing ever, that is pretty much the only point they have! Severus Snape has done a lot of bad things in his time as a teacher and should at least acknowledged and apologized that. But also... he started his job in his early 20s after suffering a though an immense trauma (loosing/getting killed the one person he loved/he thought cared for him and basically sentencig an innocent child to death at the hands of the master he only followed out of desperation and conditioning - and yes, again my personal opinion) on top of the previous 20 years of unadressed trauma (at the very least verbal abuse/neglect form his parents, extreme poverty, years of school bullying, at least one near deth experience, sexual assault, the general idea of bein coerced into a death cult, etc). He never choose to be a teacher. He was told to be a teacher by the man who kept him from going to Azkaban and gave him the glimmer of a chance to save his childhood best friend/the person he thought he loved. Not sure, but I think it's undestandable he might be a little high strung or sappy when teaching preteend who do not know how to behave... So the views of the Snape haters irk me. If you do not like him, fine. But most of the assumptions are innacurate and unfair (from my viewpoint) to judge his character as that. There is more to him, than just being a bully... And him being selfish - I do not really have a lot of roof of that one either... He maybe selfish in the way he kept his memories and feelings for Lily bottled up - but if he had been selfish he could just have said "f... you" and run along. EVEN JKR stated that Snape is all grey so neither bad or good. Just in between - as are most of us as well!

Jake M

@Katie I never knew this... And yet she knew they were there? ("Don't put your wand away, foolish boy, they might come back" or something). So she could only feel them?

Monique

I wholeheartedly disagree. Sexually assault? For what? Hanging him upside down? That's a stretch. Draco didn't resort to phsyical violence because he is a coward, not because he was noble. Let's not ignore thathe almost killed an innocent girl and almost killed Ron by willy nilly distributing cursed or poisoned items in HBP. I get that you have an affinity for Snape and the darker characters, apparently, but it seems like you maybe go out of your way to ignore aspects of their personalities in your assessment of these relationships. Interesting

Monique

I have yet to see anybody who insists that Snape was a victim acknowledge that he had a friend group as well. They were dark wizards who later all became Death Eaters together. Are we really going to just believe that that entire group of people who later spent their time torturing and killing people were swell to everyone they went to school with? Really?

Monique

Hi Dara. I'm sorry you were bullied and, clearly, that has affected how you view this story and the people in it. We'll just have to agree to disagree. Snape being a dark wizard hanging out with future death eaters is just a child victim that's complicated but everyone else is a one note character with no allowance for growth or capacity for change? That's one way to see the books but not one I'd choose or I'd never read them again. They'd lose all of their complexity for me. Hope you are able to come to grips with that bullying you experienced when you were a child and find some peace.

Monique

yeah, AFTER he spied on Dumbledore and Professor Trelawney to get only part of the prophecy which he then gave to Voldy which resulted in the death of the woman he supposedly loved so much he called her slurs and drove her away from his friendship, let alone love. He became a spy because it was what Dumbledore required from him for his help in trying to hide Lily. He didn't become a spy because he felt bad for torturing or killing others. His motivation was entirely selfish because in the books we know he was just fine if Lily's husband and baby ended up slaughtered. Just not her.

Jacqueline Chaiton

I just had a really spoiler-y thought based on Veggie's reaction to this comment and I'm not sure where else to put this, but do you think that Sirius shows no remorse for his actions regarding the "prank" because Snape is the one who told Voldemort about the prophecy?

Katerina Portokalia

hey I'm late and new here so a very late reply here : didn't Sirius say word for word that "it's just the fact that he exists"? I mean, we can have our own head cannons but I don't think we've seen evidence of Snape's "guilt", up until he said the M word to Lily. Let's be real - everyone has favourites and they make excuses here. To me both sides were inexcusable, from the info that we get, but Snape was traumatised into being horrible, even from his home life. Even Sirius had his family drama. But what's James's excuse, that I don't know. To me anyone who blames Snape but makes excuses for James has a bit of prejudice. You either accept both, or you blame both imho.