Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Qq7S5IgWK0jmyR4qo9jc0Binx1JdP7E7/view?usp=share_link

####### EPISODE SPOILER REVIEW BELOW! APPARENTLY SOME OF YOU ARE WATCHING FOR THE FIRST TIME ALONG SIDE ME, SO PLEASE DON'T READ BEYOND THIS POINT UNTIL YOU HAVE SEEN THE EPISODE YOURSELF! ######

------

"... Americans..."

Hi guys!  What a thought provoking episode!  It had me thinking of several plot lines that didn't come true, and made me think about every character in a light I wasn't expecting.  I expect a great discussion on "that argument" in the comments!  As for the episode it's self, another great Solid Side Quest!

Giles was TOP TIER in this episode, for several different reasons. XD

Love you, guys! Hope you have a great weekend!

As always, if you click the video just after this post, you may need to  download it first.  This should be fixed in a couple of hours!

Files

Buffy Redirect - Check out the Link in the Patreon Post!

Comments

FandomReferenceHere

Yay for Buffy! Here's a super long comment before watching -- Ok, Veggie.... THIS is my least favorite episode of the entire Buffyverse. I find it hella triggering. Buffy has made the best choices she could with the information available to her at the time. (She didn't run away, she was KICKED OUT. And while I understand Joyce said that in a moment of anger and fear and desperation, she still said it, and I don't know why Buffy has to take all the blame for, gee, I dunno, taking her mom's words at face value??) She comes back, she tries to make amends, and EVERYONE tells her that they are cool now, but EVERYONE is lying about that, and they're just holding on to all their resentment to unleash it on her in a very unhealthy way once she steps out of line too far. I am 100% projecting my own issues onto this episode :-) But a lot of the conversations really piss me off, and also I'm mad that the whole "Xander lying about Willow saying to kick Angel's ass" thing doesn't get cleared up. I actually haven't watched this one in years, so I'm interested to see what I think of it now, and very interested to see what you think of it! I'll probably skip past the part where they're all yelling at Buffy, tho.

Frederique Gillespie

I'm so glad to hear I'm not the only one who still has issues about the way they all treat Buffy when she comes back. Yeah, her absence was hard on all of them. I get it. What she did was irrational. But would it have killed them to maybe, I don't know, ask WHY she ran away like that? To remember the girl they all know and see that something pretty major must have been going with her for her to act like that?

The Ginger Historian

I agree that this episode is massively triggering for all of those reasons. People will argue with me that that’s what makes it so good because it “makes people feel,” but I disagree. Being difficult to watch is not in and of itself a virtue.

The Ginger Historian

Agreed! Particularly after her PTSD at the beginning of the last season. And no one asking why is just… so hard to understand.

The Ginger Historian

Also Pat. Great actor and very funny moments but that is a real person. The person who doesn’t know you but has bonded with people you know while you’ve been away and has decided that you must have been the only problem in this rocky relationship.

RavenLord

You could call him "the reformed bully," LOL. His name is Larry. I don't skip a single one of your reactions of this show, but this is one I would usually skip on a re-watch. The way they all ganged up on Buffy *and* publicly humiliated her in the process was absurd. Also, as much of a nosy busybody Pat was, I felt her death was unnecessary and abrupt. Let Joyce have ONE FRIEND! :p

RavenLord

You missed the quick line from Snyder about the Mayor. When Joyce said she would go all the way to the Mayor, Snyder said under his breath, "Wouldn't that be interesting?" And of course, that's all I'm going to say about that, no spoilers, :) Your questions will be answered by the show.

Giorgia M

Warning: This comment is extremely long. I can barely get through this episode without getting really annoyed and upset. First, I’m sorry Veg I have to disagree with you about Buffy making “bad choices” and having to live with the consequences, that feels very unfair. All the issues she’s had come from being the slayer and the incident for which she was expelled was turning up to the school to find Kendra dead and resisting arrest because she needed to go fight Angel. I don’t see how she could have done anything else? However, I do agree with you about Giles. Made me so happy to have him!! I just wish he was there with Buffy. He was the true MVP of the episode, Anthony Steward Head is so talented at making you cry just with his slight facial expression and then laugh with his amazing joke delivery. I love Giles!! He was so understanding and supportive of Buffy from the start, maybe because he’s the only one that truly understands the burden of a Slayer. Maybe that’s why Slayers don’t usually have a crew of civilians working with them, they just can never fully understand. Also I don’t know if you missed Joyce saying it’s almost worse having Buffy home, and that’s why Buffy started to pack. I don’t know, I think there is something to be said about the others being hurt or feeling resentful by Buffy leaving which I understand, they are teenagers so it’ll be hard to look at the full picture but to blame her for “ruining their lives” for months by not doing her slayer duties is ridiculous to me. They’d most likely all be dead without Buffy, god forbid they have to deal with some slayer stuff for a few months that Buffy has dealt with everyday for years. Joyce, however upset, is an adult and should not be handling this the way she is but it’s her daughter, she was trying at first so she is probably just distraught. Thinking Buffy did it to punish her is very odd but I don’t know how much she knew about Buffy having to kill Angel. I was extremely disappointed in the Scoobies particularly but Joyce as well. Avoiding her, having the party, making snide comments. Joyce saying it’s almost worse with her there. It is all so horrible. How much more do they need to know? They must know she likely killed Angel to save everyone as the world didn’t end so to call her selfish is crazy because I doubt Xander could kill Cordy or Willow kill Oz even if they had to. Humiliating Buffy in front of everyone is not helping anything. Why is no one actually trying to talk to Buffy? Why is no one actually trying to sort things? It’s not as if Buffy has come back and is being difficult and shutting herself off. She is traumatised!!! She killed the person she loved!! And she’s just to get over it so she can listen to Willow talk about her dating life? She’s not only grieving but has serious guilt and trauma for being responsible for the death of the loved one she is grieving. It’s like someone you knows family member dying, them not talking to you for months and when they come back to you, you make it about how they haven’t been there for YOU. This situation was handled terribly by the group. The fact Xander even gets involved between the situation with Buffy and Joyce is extremely out of line. The only person not making it about themselves is Giles. It actually really affected how I see the Scoobies for a while, the whole fighting zombies together in the end doesn’t just fix everything for me. It also made me see their relationship as quite transactional, as if Buffy was only worth being friends with because she is the slayer and protects them and the town. If she’s not doing it, she’s not worth their compassion and understanding during a hard time.

tvshrine

One of my least favorite episodes but not because of scooby drama, more just the mask and zombies is a weak side quest. Joyce's new friend was very old school tv show stuff of a new character appearing on one episode just to be killed. How would they explain her disappearance? Just a bad episode. Luckily I don't think there is another one even close to this bad for the rest of the series. Next episode is going to start an awesome season journey!! BTW Mr. Belvedere was a show about a British butler employed by an American family. That is why the kid called him that. Just a common reference at the time for a teen about someone with that accent. ...Americans...

Frederique Gillespie

I agree. On literally everything you said here. Every single point was spot on. They all act like running away is something Buffy did TO them instead of wondering why she felt it she had to do something like that. It's a tidal wave of recriminations and virulent negativity when she deserves so much better from all of those people.

Frederique Gillespie

Hiya Veg! I agree with you on a lot of things here. I am 10000% Team Buffy when it comes to the argument. And Giles was totally the MVP of the episode. He seemed to be the only to act from a place of knowing who Buffy is and understaning she wouldn't have run away without cause. This is an episode that makes me rage, if I'm honest. The way her friends treat her is appalling. I understand that her being gone put them in a bad spot, slaying-wise, but instead of taking this opportunity to learn about the difficulties of her life, they decided to blame her for not being there. Which is ridiculous. They didn't have to go out slaying. They chose to. And you know what didn't happen there? In all that "not talking" to each other, they also failed to mention that Angel came back before Buffy killed him. There was not a whisper on Xander's failure to let Buffy know Willow's real message to her about that. So I'm all for people living for the consequences of their actions. Buffy ran away, and I feel like Joyce has every right to be titchy with her when she comes back. But her friends crossed a major line, as far as I'm concerned. They know her better than to judge and lash out like that. I'm gonna give this episode a 2/10, but that's mostly because it makes me so angry at almost every character, and I hate being this angry because of fiction. Freddie

Jordan McLaren

I'm not as bothered by this episode as most people. It's definitely frustrating watching everyone fight like this, but I also like the fact that it's messy because other, lesser shows would probably just brush things under the rug and make everything hunky-dory. Things were said in this episode that needed to be said, and nobody is completely in the right or the wrong for feeling how they feel (though I do take issue with Xander's attitude). Having said that, I wish the characters could have had an actual conversation that wasn't interrupted before any conclusion was reached. It goes from the peak of the argument to fighting zombies to everyone's friends again, which is a bit weak, but whatever. I will say this is my least favourite episode of the season, but I don't think it's terrible. A little non-spoiler help for Veggie with names and places: The reformed gay bully is called Larry, and I kind of love him for no real reason. The girl from last episode has had several names: we first met her in "Lie to Me" as Chanterelle, then last episode as Lily and finally she took on Buffy's middle name Anne. Amy was the daughter from the body swap episode and the witch from the love spell episode. The city Buffy was in is actually Los Angeles, a few hours away from Sunnydale. When Buffy went through the portal, she and the others were in one of many hell dimensions. I won't say any more for fear of spoilers, but yes they were demons and it was different dimension. Hope that's useful, and can't wait for the next one 💜 Edit: forgot to mention, shout out to the Dead Man's Shoes reference. A criminally underrated film that I definitely watched way too young, but brilliant. I might have to watch it again now.

Amanda S

This is one of my least favourite episodes. I think it's because the group really rubbed me the wrong way with everyone ganging up on Buffy. A lot of that is probably personal bias and projections on my part, but I just can't feel good about how everyone was treating her. I do appreciate Cordelia for trying to be on Buffy's side though. :)

Svetlana Grabar

I love Giles's lines in this one! I enjoy this episode because it shows that our characters have flaws, though I wish at least one of her friends apologized at the end for confronting her like that. I'm on Buffy's side, I think they could have talked to her calmly and privately about any issues (like Willow's feeling of abandonment). But Joyce's criticism of Buffy not even calling, to tell her mom that she's ok, is somewhat warranted. Buffy really needed to get more support though.

Hanneli Norrgard

I don't like Buffy, so I'm probably biased. However, I don't think her friends are as horrible as most people do. Yes, it was wrong to yell at her publicly (and throw a party at her house). However, she did a lot of wrong, too. She knew her mom didn't actually mean for her to never come back. She knew she had people to turn to if her mom did mean it. She knew (or should have) that all of "her" people would be worried about her all summer with her saying nothing. I've known a lot of people who were kicked out in real life, and the only people who actually left town were those without people to turn to.

Diego Zenhäusern

I think this episode was intersting since it actually brought up what other people would go through when Buffy left and didn't act like that wouldn't leave scars on them as well. And I actually like that the episode confronted Buffy and made her understand that she wasn't the only one that was hurting. That said, I agree with most people here that the gang was totally out of line for ganging up on Buffy, especially in public where she couldn't talk about what actually happened for fear of revealing stuff to bystanders. To go a bit more in depth: Apart from yelling at Buffy publicly I actually enjoyed Willow and Joyce in this episode. Willow was being hurtful in the beginning, but when she eventually confronted Buffy in her room she seemed actually prepared to listen to Buffy (and Buffy to her) and it felt like they could actually talk this thing out (until Joyce came in). And though it was throughly frustrating I don't blame Joyce for filipping out when she saw Buffy had packed her things again (only for taking it downstairs like that). I also liked that she admitted that she didn't react perfectly, and I'm actually on her side that one couldn't expect her to accept a revelation like the one that Buffy made just like that and immediately support her in what she was doing. However, I had absolutely no time for Xander's bullshit. He was just escalating things without trying to have any productive conversation. I also find his reason for being so mad a Buffy ridiculous. Joyce and Willow seemed to be primarily hurt by the fact that Buffy left them alone and didn't even try to make contact when they were worried about her/ needed her to help them deal with their own trauma (whether it was fair of Willow to expect that help or not is another discussion). So they were upset because of reasons out of their control. But Xander seemed to be hung up primarily on the fact that Buffy "ruined his life, by leaving the salying buisness to them". But guess what: No one forced him to help out with the slaying! In fact he seemed to be perfectly content with playing hero in the last and this episode until Buffy actually turned up again. So yeah, I really have no patience for his bullshit anymore. As to Cordy...well Cordy's gonna Cordy and end up being hurtful as often as not, when she tries to be supportiv. But even if it was done very badly she still got bonus points in my book for at least trying to be on Buffy's side. And as Veggie pointed out: Giles was just the MVP of the episode on basically every level.🙂

Hanneli Norrgard

Mr. Belvedere was an eighties show where an American family had a British butler (Mr. Belvedere).

Jake M

The problem with calling the girl from the last episode Amy from now on, is what about the other Amy who is a witch? Don't want you getting confused, given it's not even her name XD

Jake M

Cripes...I'd blocked this one out of my memory. So uncomfortable to watch something so relatable (alienation, not the zombies XD). Buffy didn't act perfectly by running away, but nor does the attitude of Xander et al help. For some reason, my head remembered part of it being down to the mask's aura. I got exactly the same vibe sbout Pat, she reminded me of Ted. It felt like Pat was goading Joyce into voicing her negative thoughts. Like Palpatine to Anakin. Also, that party...what a terrible idea. Kinda selfish of the gang to organise it without checking with Buffy OR Joyce, whose bloody house it is! One last point- I don't think Buffy new specifically about the eyes. She just wanted to blind Pat, kinda like Fawkes and the Basilisk in Chamber of Secrets. Common videogame sense, to go for the glowing spot! XD

Q

Watching the first stretch of this season and focusing on Oz (because I love Oz), I am always struck by how much he just gets the sh*t kicked out of him almost every episode. Boy's gonna have bruises for days. Also, Xander is, to say the least, not at his best for most of this episode. But! I do love that as soon as the zombies attack, he and Buffy seamlessly coordinate defense. "I've got your back." For me, that's a hallmark of his character. He's frequently selfish and/or callous in lighter or less immediately dangerous moments, but when sh*t hits the fan, he's right there to help.

Luci Love

Interesting episode that I barely remembered. Everyone just seems to be letting their emotions get the better of them and lashing out. Lots of hurt and misunderstanding going on. And a zombie cat. No wonder I wanted to forget it. XD I'm kind of sad that Oz didn't get to "speak his piece" since I feel like he routinely "speaks peace" and maybe could have calmed people down a little. Also, I just love Oz. :D I watched Mr. Belvedere as a kid. I remember it being a rather heartwarming show about a butler who is so wise and endearing that he becomes a beloved part of the family despite the fact that he's British. (j/k) I'm sure it's a bit silly looking back, but as a kid I enjoyed it.

Temujin

It's funny everyone keeps saying that Buffy killed Angel but we know that a sword through the middle isn't going to be fatal and Drue and Angelus were trying to open that portal to hell expecting to go there with everything else so logically that won't be fatal. And before anyone yells spoilers these are the rules we already know about vampires. Just thinking about the situation.

Judith

i just listened to the part about what the other teachers would think if the knew about Lupin being a werewolf. Especially Professor McGonagall. It got me thinking about the Order of the Phoenix. Does anyone remember whether or not McGonagall was in the original Order? I know Lupin was. Because if she was, than she knows about Lupin.... Just a random thought!

Superplin

I enjoy this episode; I think it's necessary to work through everyone's feelings rather than just pretending everything is normal after Buffy shows up. One thing I greatly appreciate about this show is it's willingness to explore emotional dynamics.

x_Rhi_x

Dip guy is Jonathan 😀

Anonymous

I think enough has been said about the fight. All I'm gonna say is every time I see one of the windows or doors broken and houses get wrecked I stress out because how much are they paying every week in repairs? Also I think this is the first episode to debut the Sunnydale Downtown set (which includes the Espresso Pump, that neat little coffee shop at the end).

Giorgia M

Sorry, I don’t get notifications for these I was just looking back on the episodes and seen your comment. Thanks for the reply!! I was worried I went a bit overboard with my ranting lol. Everyone is just acting so different and it’s so unhelpful, I wish there was more resolution but that’s basically it now. Obviously there is more Buffy bashing to come sadly, it kind of reignites a lot of it again and Xander makes everything his personal business.. again 🤣

Milku Grace TV

THANK YOU. I am with Buffy on this, too. I think she maybe could have written or called, yeah, but if she had to deal with her emotions quietly then that's completely okay. Buffy tried to connect with the others when she got back, too. I guess they were so angry though. But Giles was great. He didn't bombard her or tell her she was stupid. Love him. THANKS SO MUCH! :D

T_phoenix

I love your humor Veggie, wearing this top hat and not even slight mention of why, how.... once I saw the hat I just burst out laughing. The same story in Harry Potter book club when you wore tea cosy

Todd Bolton

Tommy Ross, while I agree that "Being difficult to watch is not in and of itself a virtue" (I think it is a great episode but not for that reductionist reasoning), it also doesn't make it triggering. It may be triggering, I understand, but that also doesn't mean it is not great.

Todd Bolton

I actually think the resolution by monster fight is awesome. It’s the metaphor for the show, it’s what they share day in, day out – it gives closure. As Veggie Gamer said, some things are best left unsaid. It was an ingenious use of the show’s trope. The second the monster’s come in, after they’ve been arguing, Xander, to Buffy: “I’ve got your back”. I love this episode.

Todd Bolton

"I don't like Buffy" - one can't help wondering whether you are watching the wrong show.

Todd Bolton

Buffy saw what the mask did to Willow. Pat did nothing wrong, she was just a red herring, so we were played by the writing & acting to dislike her.

Todd Bolton

His seventh episode and Veggie Gamer who is generally good at keeping track of side characters has yet to notice him, except, now, as Dip Guy. You'd think his name was Andrew or something.

Todd Bolton

“This party was such a stupid idea.” Once again, Veggie Gamer expresses the moral of the story succinctly! You say (I think in the next reaction) that you were projecting how they should react. That is insightful. I think a lot of people do. I just hope you don’t let others’ opinions unduly influence you. While watching, and at the end of this reaction you seemed to enjoy this episode greatly. After reading the comments, and before the next episode, you seem to think that *maybe* it’s better than Reptile Boy. (It is so far superior to Reptile Boy!) Over ten years ago I ranked all BtVS episodes and this one was number 125, so at the top of the bottom twenty. My bet is that it would now be in my top 40, maybe 30. It has grown so much in rewatching. It seems to be the parallel/contrast to 2.1 (“When She Was Bad”), this time the Scoobies treating Buffy like crap, instead if vice versa. The human level emotions, having to work them out through the central trope of the show: monster fighting equal catharsis. I’ve seen some people say the monster themselves are lame – that never takes away from my enjoyment. I’m not looking to find the demons realistic. There are a few episodes when greatly attired monsters add to it, but they never detract. Stuff that happens in this episode may seem “out of character” for some of them, but actually it is us getting first glimpses of certain character traits (especially Willow’s flawed character). Love this episode. Always love your reactions. And your best comment was that if Giles had been there he’d have backed Buffy. And, thus, we see the problem with season six. (I don’t mean dramatic problem. Six is my favorite season. I mean the problems that the characters have.)