Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1fZej58OG2isNRg-nPiaLc0Zlv36VViOB/view?usp=sharing

####### EPISODE SPOILER REVIEW BELOW! APPARENTLY SOME OF YOU ARE WATCHING FOR THE FIRST TIME ALONG SIDE ME, SO PLEASE DON'T READ BEYOND THIS POINT UNTIL YOU HAVE SEEN THE EPISODE YOURSELF! ######

------

This one was awesome!! Very 'monster of the week, but definitely not Solid Side-Quest!  Xander is such a more interesting character than I expected him to be when I first started this series, and this is a very important one for him!Great villain!  Definitely didn't see the twist coming!  I got confused thinking she actually WAS Largos, but by the end I am sure I was mistaken.

Great to get a Faith episode, as I say at the start, she hadn't really been that involved since she joined the squad!  Definitely appreciate her in this one!

And some VERY good quotable lines this time!  Which was the best?

Love you, guys! Hope you have a great weekend!

As always, if you click the video just after this post, you may need to  download it first.  This should be fixed in a couple of hours!

Files

Buffy Redirect - Check out the Link in the Patreon Post!

Comments

Frederique Gillespie

Ooh, I look forward to seeing your reaction to Buffy finding out about Xander and Willow "fluking". LOL You can't talk about how satisfying it would have been to see Buffy have that moral high ground without me wanting to see your reaction to that. :) Favourite line of this episode is probably "Faith, word of advice, you're an idiot," because it really was a banger. I can't speak to the actor playing Mrs Post's English accent, but I will say that I haven't heard your comments on Faith's Bostonian accent. Or perhaps it is so spotty that you didn't realize she was doing one... I can't fault Eliza Dushku. Heck, if she was purposefully botching it, I would in fact commend her because I feel it's a little mean of the show to have the slayer with the abusive family background be from Southie (sounds like it anyway). I think watching two slayers fight is supposed to be a superior experience. After all, they have "superpowers." It'd have to be a bit like watching two demons fight or two vampires fight. The physicality of it is probably meant to be next level, and I think we see that the fight coordinators in this episode really put it all out there to show that. This episode is interesting. It's always a really frustrating one for me because, once again, I feel Buffy's friends are being incredibly unfair towards her. Giles is perfectly right in his expression of disappointment and hurt and I feel like Cordelia hit just the right note of being worried about the right thing. But, yeah, Xander was jealous and probably worried, too, but playing the Ms Calendar card (again!) was below the belt (again). I really do feel like they hold her up to a higher emotional standard than they are willing to have for themselves. Still, this episode is so important in the grand scheme of this season. It shows exactly where each character is in relation to the others. 7/10

Paul Thomas-Humphreys

I’m not mega familiar with the Boston accent to know what’s botched and what isn’t but I find it odd that Eliza would botch it given that she’s from Boston..?

Giorgia M

Great episode!! Maybe like an 7.5 or 8/10, it’s so hard to rate this season because it’s so good and consistent. It set up a lot of things going forward, more character arc things than real plot points. I think that Mrs Post definitely wasn’t Lagos. That was the Orc looking guy. She was just using the situation as an opportunity to get the glove herself, classic seeking of a powerful object to make themselves powerful type character. I think it’s really interesting how she manipulated Faith very easily by using her insecurities and soft spots, it’s really sad for Faith. I think this episode sets a really interesting base in place for Faith/Buffy relationship going forward, their characters having interesting parallels and dualities by being sort of two sides of the same slayer coin. As usual, Xander is annoying. I actually love him but he’s so annoying, even when I can sort of see his point or understand his perspective, he just goes about it all in such an annoying way that I end up being against him. He can be a very selfish impulsive person and he judges everyone else like he’s a saint. I know if he was in Buffy’s shoes, he wouldn’t be able to stay away from Angel or tell the truth. And a lot of the issues do stem from Angel hatred as much as he may have moved on. Giles handled it perfectly and I felt like that had more of a profound effect on Buffy. Edit: Thankfully he had the sense to call 911 and focus on Giles rather than revenge, so big ups for that. I don’t love Buffy and Angel as a couple honestly but I don’t think Angel should be killed or cut off if he can be an asset, Buffy obviously should have told them and shouldn’t take her decisions lightly. The trust and issues from season 2 finale and her being gone over the summer are still clearly affecting her judgement. The intervention thing was a bad idea especially after the group argument at the start of the season, I think Giles should have spoke to her one on one first maybe. But If I was a Scoobie, I would prefer if Buffy and Angel didn’t get back together. Sorry this comment is so long lol!! I can’t help it.

Tim Pierce

Knowing your appreciation of professional wrestling, I was waiting for your reaction to Buffy busting out the Superman Punch. Sorry, not followed by a spear though.

Temujin

Xander gets a lot of shit from people for his actions especially revolving around Angel. It's not just jealousy. First let's remember these are teenagers and are not going to be emotionally mature about things much of the time anyway. Second Xander has a very good reason not to trust Angel. Recall season 1episode 12 when Buffy goes to fight the Master, Angel who says he lives her and has the strength of a vampire let's her go alone knowing she will die. Xander has to force Angel to accompany him to the Masters lair where they arrive just in time to save Buffy's life. Now it appears Xander never told the gang he had to force Angel to go so he's held on to that but he never forgot it or forgave Angel and just does not trust him.

Giorgia M

I totally agree Xander has reason to be annoyed/upset/distrustful, as they all do. I just don’t think he has the reasoning to always be the loudest voice about Angel issues, especially making personal comments etc. I think you’ve brought up some really great, interesting points!!! That never occurred to me at all. I agree that Angel’s s1 actions may be a key factor in Xander’s negative feelings, however, I think it’s pretty clear that Xander is willing to say anything to make his point (e.g. bringing up Jenny’s death or Buffy’s sex life) so I don’t think this is likely to be a case of Xander holding back information. I think it’s more likely of writers either forgetting or not seeing it as that much of an issue or something. But I could very much be wrong!!

Temujin

Yeah you can never discount the writers forgetting or just manipulating situations for the story they want lol

Frederique Gillespie

It honestly wouldn't be the first time I got something dead wrong. But the Southie comes in just scarcely enough that I can't decide if she's going for it or not. Hence calling it "botched", But, again, I could be wrong. It just feels like she's not committing fully to it. But, also, if she's from Boston, then it would be all the more reason for her to realize the... ickiness?... of doing a Southie accent for a character with an abusive past.

RavenLord

Hello! Xander is definitely petty and immature, which arguably is not atypical for a teenager, so it works, even if it renders him a little unlikeable at times. He did do one mature thing in this episode, though; he did what Buffy *should* have done and immediately informed Giles about Angel. He could have easily gone to his friends instead, but he went to a trusted adult. That Buffy/Giles scene was very strong, and Anthony in particular delivered. "You have no respect for me or the job I perform." It gives me goosebumps even after multiple watchings. I'm not a fan of the Willow/Xander cheating subplot, but I can understand how it could be possible. Although Willow cares for Oz, she has literally loved Xander since childhood. Xander has already established that he doesn't always know what he wants and sort of wants it all. (Remember the love potion?) He also has shown that he wants what he can't, or shouldn't, have, and as evidenced in earlier episodes like with the online faux boyfriend Malcolm, he doesn't like not being the center of Willow's worship and adoration. It comes right back to his pettiness. Now that we have seen Faith a few times, I do have to confess that I absolutely detest the character and have from her very first appearance, with the "five by five" and referring to Buffy as "B." 😢 I have tried getting past it with multiple viewings, and I've seen the actor Eliza in other roles and have liked her acting (Tru Calling in particular). It's literally just the Faith character I can't stand. I hate the personality, I truly do; she grates on my nerves. Of all the prominent Buffy characters throughout 7 seasons, I like her the least. So I'm never excited to see her onscreen, LOL. I think we're supposed to feel sorry for her at the end of this episode with her swollen jaw and the camera panning away to see her all alone in her paltry room, but I just don't care. 😜 So yep, my favorite line is, "Faith, you're an idiot." BTW, once the entire series is done so that you don't get spoilers, you will want to check out a montage on YouTube about Giles and all his knockouts. It is highly amusing!

Jake M

I do love how you've gone from 'I don't want to make predictions' at the start of this series to basically calling about 80% of what happens in the episode based on the title alone 😂 seriously, job as a psychic is waiting for you Veggie! 😆 Also, Alyson Hannigan (Willow) is such a good 'nervous' actor. Great casting choice, never fails to make me laugh. "We aren't socialising!" 🤣 Not to sound boring, but "Faith, dear, a word of advice... You're an idiot" is definitely my favourite line, as I'm not really a fan of her. Gwendolyn's actress is English btw- she played Princess Diana in a TV movie once.

RavenLord

I will add one thing in Xander's favor that sort of gets overlooked because of all the stuff going on with Gwendolyn and the glove. Xander literally saved Giles' life. He called 911 immediately and stayed with him, and I think it's rather profound that were it not for this goofy, immature teenage boy thinking clearly and keeping a somewhat cool head in a crisis, Giles would have died.

Jake M

And he also was level headed enough to realise it wasn't Angel. Although not smart enough to release it had to be Gwendolyn once he saw her there at the manor.

Maggie

Let's not forget Xander's first experience with vampires was his best friend dying. I think it colors a lot of his feelings about vampires. He's not jealous, he didn't mind Buffy dating Scott, a human. He just can't trust vampires. And it's understandable. I think he is jealous early season 1, but he gets over that. At the end of season 1 he tells Angel "I don't like you", but with time, in the beginning of season 2 you can see he's making an effort to be nicer, he calls Angel his friend a couple times, and even says he likes him once. And just when he's starting to get comfortable around him, out pops Angelus. That probably just confirmed to him that he never should have let his guard down and was right to mistrust him at first.

Thom Purdy

Serena Scott Thomas, Gwendolyn Post, Mrs., is English, and the sister of Kristin Scott Thomas, who starred in the Oscar winning film, "The English Patient". Lagos was the demon with the axe.

Hanneli Norrgard

Not a favorite of mine, maybe 3/10. Every single character is so annoying this episode that I just can't with it. Xander has his points but then falls back on his, understandable, Angel hatred. Season 3 is one of my least favorite seasons, which explains all my low ratings. It was also so predictable, at least for me. As soon as Post walked in, I was all she's a watcher and evil.

Diego Zenhäusern

I mean, I like faith so far, but I'd still agree that that line was the best one of the episode😂

Anonymous

So the Buffy movie can be considered ambiguously canon. The big things, Buffy being called, her watcher dying, etc, can be considered canon. And yes 90% of Watchers are English because the council is in the UK.

Garry (Not Jerry)

Not sure if you caught on to this, but I liked the bit when willow got upset because people weren’t using the “I” statements during Buffy’s intervention. I noticed your top hat. But I just thought it was a bold fashion choice and I was all for it!

Garry (Not Jerry)

Oh and I’m pretty sure Giles did see willow and Xander fluking, he just pretended not to, so as not to make it awkward. He seemed like he was disappointed in them though.

Flora Smith

Agreed, though I’d argue jealousy is still a factor in S2, it’s not now and hasn’t been for quite a while.

Flora Smith

Agreed. I 💯think he saw them and pretended he didn’t because he didn’t want a bar of it 🤣

Flora Smith

It’s her real accent. She did vocal work to tone it down when she was older but if you look at interviews from this era, it’s just the way she speaks

Frederique Gillespie

That's awesome! 25 years it's bothered me and turns out I was wrong. Good to know! Thank you everyone. :) I stand corrected. I looked at her accent in True Lies and in this one and made assumptions. And we all know why I shouldn't have made assumptions. LOL

Catalina Saturnus

Not her library shaming! Uncalled for! LOL I never thought about Gwendlyn being Llagos, but that could've been cool. At the end it sounded more like she was really a rogue watcher though. Apparently Giles missed the memo. Still, the watcher's council communication system leaves something to be desired. 

The Ginger Historian

I've always found the "You're an idiot" line far more sad than funny. It's an authority figure who has gained someone's trust fully pulling the rug out from under them. And given Faith's constant isolation and lack of stable guidance, that's going to knock her WAY back in her ability to trust people again. It's cleverly written, but it's ultimately very tragic.

Frederique Gillespie

Well now, if you're going to get all grown up and empathetic...

Milku Grace TV

I LOVE seeing Buffy and Faith fight. It's so epic! :D THANK YOU.

Milku Grace TV

I like Faith's line of "I can't believe how much I'm going to kill you." :D

Todd Bolton

On Xander and Willow non-fluking (in other words, their ‘on-purposing’), you say, “The music seems to like it”. Yeah, we get a taste of them misleading us with the music. Not for one minute is the show on the side of Xander and Willow. We get some great stuff in a soon-to-come episode on the fun they have with the romantic music-themes. You not realizing that the Willow and Xander thing wouldn’t be just a fluke, not one and done, or three and done (the show wouldn’t treat us that cheaply), I think, kept you from seeing how Willow’s entire personality is affected, minute-by-minute, throughout the last three episodes. You keep asking, “Is that because of the fluking?” Yes, everything she is doing is because of the fluking. I’ve really appreciated how interested you are in Xander’s character. A lot of people love to hate him (and, in some things, I get it) but you’re able to see his complexity. Kudos. However, when Xander says that they’ll be alright as long as Buffy and Angel don’t get pelvic and you say “bitter”, I don’t think you’re right. As Cordelia says, it is no longer about that. Jenny and other things are his problem with Angel, now. While I agree that the Giles/Buffy scene is a great scene (the whole intervention was), I don’t think Giles’ handling of it is praiseworthy. His own gripe with Angel seems to be his priority. I get it, but it’s far below what he really needs to be to be a good watcher (or father-figure). He tells Buffy that Angel tortured him – so he doesn’t believe his own lore! of which he is supposed to be teacher and watcher of. Angel did not torture him, Angelus did. This is not a gripe at the show. Like with Xander, and them all, he’s a complex character. Usually, they will not sit down and have those talks that people want. It wouldn’t be good drama if they did, plus it would so often be unlike real life. At one point – I don’t remember when – you said that some things are best left unsaid. It was a good point. Some things are and some things aren’t, and, in real life, we often don’t determine well when one or the other is best. In drama it will happen even less. One thing that happens in Buffy, as in all great metaphorical fiction, the resolution is represented by the action. The fight with Gwendolyn Post *was* the resolution, just like the fight was at the dead man’s party. Some characters will come out closer, some further apart. The shows to come will reveal these things in greater detail. This is the way it will always be in this universe, because BtVS is great fiction. It leaves us to surmise what is going on between them and doesn’t subject us to a group analysis of what everybody’s feelings are. Look forward seeing your reactions going forward on all this. Serena Scott Thomas (Gwendolyn Post) is British. Loved your waffle on whether this was a main- or a side-quest. That question will be harder and harder to answer, going forward.