Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi guys!  Yet another 5 hour breaking Book review!  Even though it is only 2 chapters and one of those chapters is less than 13 MINUTES in audio book! XD BUT, we have a lot to discuss!

Loved these chapters, and even think the movie made a couple of nice changes here and there!  I give my thoughts, and then go through your in the Book Club!

Thank you all for taking part!  Sorry this turned out to be slightly later than expected (if you follow me on Twitter, you will know that all hell broke loose this weekend XD).

One thing I forgot to ask is - are Animagus always 'non-magical' creatures?  But I forgot. .-.

Oh!  And if you are reading this wondering where Buffy is, SO SORRY! It is my main priority to get it to you tomorrow, without fail!

Love you, guys! Hope you have / had a wonderful Sunday!

Files

Movie Watcher Reads Harry Potter For the First Time! - Prisoner of Azkaban Chapters 20 & 21!

Check out the Patreon for the Full Length Movie reactions, Buffy the Vampire Slayer and other exclusives and early access goodies! There is no minium Pay amount, so pay as little as you like! :) - https://www.patreon.com/VeggieGamer (Full Length Movie Reactions require a copy to sync with) My Mail Box is Now OPEN! Find the Address and other info here! - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G362I7JPgWY Come join the official Veggie Discord server! :) - https://discord.gg/mw36C7d GET YOUR VEGGIE MERCHANDISE HERE! - https://www.redbubble.com/people/VeggieGamer GO GIVE ME A FOLLOW OVER AT TWITCH TO BE A PART OF THE FUN! - https://www.twitch.tv/veggie_gamer GET 15% OFF YOUR E-WIN RACING CHAIR BY USING PROMOTION CODE : Veggie US store: http://www.ewinracing.com/ European store: https://www.ewinracing.eu/ CCs used in my Sims 4 series can now be found here! - https://docs.google.com/document/d/1b2u8qVdJ0KAjbtG2ZPHv-DjIs2Ds4xUrtHTiKEVPahA/edit?usp=sharing CHECK ME OUT ON INSTAGRAM & TWITTER! - Veggie_Gamer CAN WE GET THIS VIDEO TO 100 LIKES, VEGGIEKNIGHTS?? If you can spare anything, Patreon (NO pressure): Want to see more of this? Give the video a thumbs up and let me know in the comments :) Hit me up on the following websites! Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheVeggieGamer/ Twitter: https://twitter.com/Veggie_Gamer Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/VeggieGamer Be sure to Follow me on Roblox (I can not accept Friend Requests) - https://www.roblox.com/users/135078748/profile End Card music - Artist: UnderwaterBeats Track: Evolution Licence:https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0

Comments

Katik

Yay! And my pizza has just arrived! (Doubt it will last for the 5 hours though) Edit: It did not

emmainkeri

Very excited for this one! Love how around 22 minutes you ask about the origins of Dementors, knowing you'll get the answer immediately in this book club! (Thanks Mel)

Emiel Callaars

The part why Lupin didn't tell anyone about Sirius being an Animagus is explained in chapter 18. First of all they did it illegaly, and seeing the prejudice against werewolves he might have thought they would pin it on him. Secondly he tells that he has been battling with himself if he should tell Dumbledore. He doesn't because that would be admitting breaking Dumbledores trust when he allowed him to come to school as a boy and Dumbledores trust means everything to him because of that. So he convinces himself that Sirius is using Dark Magic to escape and evade the Ministry and not through his Animagus form. for first time reader/listeners it is just difficult to remember all this. For me who has read and listened for many many times it is easier to remember all that stuff. As for Pettigrew not killing Ron and Crookshanks you might be right. But also remember that at this point he is not in Voldemorts presence and might be reluctant to kill anyway. Being in Voldemorts presence and being ordered to kill by someone you are very frightened by might be a different thing.

emmainkeri

Oooh i love that you mentioned the editing (?) mistake with Sirius! That has bugged me since the movie came out in 2004 and I was NINE years old 😂 I feel like nobody ever talks about it

Rod

Abkut the moving not showing a Harry-shaped figure across the lake when the patronus first appears: you also have to take clothing into account. In the books, the characters still wear black robes and pointy hats, so it could be anyone across the lake. In the movies, they're wearing muggle clothes, and if they'd shown Harry that would've been a dead giveaway.

Jake M

What annoys me about movie Sirius is him saying "Go play with your chemistry set", as if Sirius would know what one of those is!

Jake M

Ron's massive feet. Being a godfather generally carries religious significance, but realistically nowadays equates to backup guardian. And putting horse heads in people's beds.

itsanursething

The continuity error you mentioned with Sirius in he movie, to me, I didn't see him open his eyes. I just saw him gasping for air, like he suddenly breathed again. So from my perspective, he was still unconscious, just now breathing, so when they cut away and show him still passed out, it never bumped for me. I think the reason Hermione passed out is because there was an overwhelming amount of dementors. She was ok with just one on the train, but now there's over a hundred. I think any person in that situation would pass out, regardless of how troubled their past was. But that's just my 2 cents.

Jake M

In my head, the rush to administer the kiss is because it's the middle of the night, and they'd rather not have a "murderer" locked in the castle alive when all the kids wake up in the morning- what's the betting people like Fred and George would attempt to sneak in and see him?

Lily Spungle

Lupin actually says why he didn't out black being a dog in the previous chapters. He basically said he was too ashamed to tell Dumbledore he'd let his friends do something that illegal and dangerous.

Janie

About Sirius not being guarded or tied up in Flitwick's office - maybe he was but Dumbledore untied him when he was there to talk to him? He could also send away any potential guards, After all, Dumbledore believed Sirius's story so he probably already had a plan for Harry to save him.

Katik

On Squibs Veggie, I absolutely get your point what you mean and I think the answer strictly depends on an agreement of who we call a Squib. If you mean anyone with magical genes or something in their nature that makes them not muggles but squibs then you are absolutely right - in that sense squibs can absolutely be born to muggles. If we, on the other hand, go strictly by the definition we are given in the books: "anyone with magical parentage but not magical abilities", then it's not their nature that makes them a Squib, it's their circumstance - so to fall within that category by definition they cannot be born to muggles. Once we agree on which it is, you've got your answer!

Hairy Pothead

@1:11:40 Lupin was the one who had opened the map when Snape was looking at it, so I think the theory that Marauders are only visible if another Marauder opened the map still holds up so far in the story :D

Wayne Joy

The Hermione howl scene in the movie lead to a weird 'Hermione is a Werewolf' theory because during Snape's werewolf lesson Hermione says that werewolfs only respond to a call from their own kind. If that is true than Lupin wouldn't respond to Hermione's howl.

Jacqueline Chaiton

Ron's massive feet. All I will say about time travel is that there is a reason a thing happens later on in the series. As I said in the book club, I love Dumbledore in the time travel sequence. The things like the stones being thrown are much more visual, so I understand why that wasn’t in the book. I never really considered that it feels like a small area around Hagrid’s before, but now that you mention it yeah it does seem pretty small. I think the equivalent of the death penalty in the UK wizarding world is the dementors kiss. I’ve never really thought about this until know but I don’t understand why they went to Hagrid’s. I assume now that he went to the pub in the village but they could not have known that. Like I get that they had to get out of Lupin’s way but why Hagrid’s and not just out of the forest? That’s part of why I like that part in the movie better. Plus it gives buckbeak a hero moment. The distance from the dementors probably also helped with being able to cast such a strong patronus, along with the confidence of knowing he’d already done it. Quidditch will come back eventually, but not for a little while. As you saw in GOF there is no quidditch due to the tournament. Also you just sounded like a passionate sports fan when talking about it, I never thought it was too much! Although I am a fellow Hufflepuff so I’m also a bit biased. I never liked Hermione and Sirius screaming because she absolutely would have woken someone up in one of the towers. Just logically made no sense to me. I think Ron reminds Sirius of himself, so he feels particularly bad about hurting him. It’s moments where Harry puts his logic over his emotions, like Harry telling Sirius to go, that make me love him more. Frozen hot chocolates, while ironic, are a great alternative to regular hot chocolate! The child of a Squib and a muggle is just a muggle as you need to have at least one magical parent to be a squib. Honestly it’s sometimes best to just not think too hard on things like this. I hope they keep the TV show in the 90s. I’m not Snape’s biggest fan, but I have to agree with the people who think book Snape would still protect the kids from werewolf Lupin. That’s a change from the book in the movie I agree with. I think it’s different with Sirius and Lupin for Harry simply because Sirius is his godfather. That’s why he turns more to Sirius. Veritaserum is what Umbridge uses on Cho to find out about the DA in the OOTP movie. Regarding Harry and the Dursleys, it’s not a spoiler to say Dumbledore has his reasons for him to be there. But I find it unforgivable to leave a child in an abusive household and they are clearly abusive to him. Now that you’ve put the image in my mind, I would LOVE to see Snape do a back flip 🤣 I think Dumbledore always planned on them saving Buckbeak, saving Sirius was added on to the plan after the fact. I can’t remember if this is mentioned later or not, but if I remember correctly Sirius never got a trial. He was just sent straight to Azkaban. He never got to prove his innocence.

Katik

Ron's Massive Feet Just to react to your reaction to my comment :) and my point that in the movie Pettigrew uses Lupin's wand to transform himself - I apologise, I assumed that was everyone's interpretation of that scene especially without the context from the books. Now I have re-watched it again I can see not everyone would have come to the same conclusion, as it is true there is a few seconds between Pettigrew pointing the wand at himself and actually transforming, in between which Harry disarms him. I kind of thought that was the only interpretation of pointing the wand at himself (rather at others to attack / protect himself). Now I think about it, it could have been meant as undoing the spell that Lupin and Sirius put on him to transfer from the rat initially? Also my view might have been coloured by watching the movies a few times with my family who have never read the books, so I tend to assume their interpretation of any scene is what everybody else sees there without having the additional information from the books. But I can see now not everyone jumped to that conclusion! Which one of the best things about this Book Club! :) So apologies for the confusion

Gothic Llama

Ron's massive feet Just wanted to say thank you for another great book club video! It's kind of a nice routine when I see you posted and I plan my day to watch (and even watched one from the previous book on a 5h train ride so thanks for keeping me entertained :D ). I may be overthinking the whole werewolf thing, but I wonder if there is a set time at which they turn... Like it was already dark when the trio went to the shrieking shack, but Lupin shifted only when the clouds cleared. Does a werewolf change only when it gets dark and would it mean the transformation lasts longer in winter and shorter in summer??? I know, I know, it may be an artistic choice, but to me it just doesn't make sense and is an example of lazy writing (or at least ignoring prevoiusly established information like Lupin spending his teenage transformations in the shack, meaning he was a werewolf in a locked building, just for artistic sake). As someone who is in the process of writing a book and doing research, this whole thing bothers me very much. Also, can't wait for the Goblet of Fire reviews as the books get waaaay longer, more detailed and include a lot plot points dropped in the films. I hope you got a lot of rest after filming this one, and have a great day!

Garfnob

-i do not think Black woke up in the movie. i think it was an involuntary gasp when the soul restarted the lungs. -i personally think the movie is a pit sexist. giving all the lines to Hermione so the group could do nothing without her. she NEEDS to be the strong female lead. at one point this would have had merit, but by the 90s i think the opinion that females are the weaker sex was already a minority opinion. i know no one in my cereal thought that way. -is having a thought implanted ready that weird. i do not remember the book stating he went into the book, or even implying it. -they changed time. if this does not count as changing time what would. as the changes are only 3 hours or less the impact is minimal. you go back years and stop Hagrid from getting thestrals, Hagrid never had thestrals then you get into paradox. and Dumbledore stated 2 lives "can be saved". implying they did die or will die. otherwise the statement wold be "will be saved". as a rule time traveler should be avoided in media. there are too many unsolvable paradox. the version that has the least problem is the type where you go back into your body but still have your memories. that would allow you to make different dissensions and impossible to make many of the worst paradox. you did not loos me i just wish i could have the conversation in read time. -how does Dumbledore? know X deus ex machina

Predaguy

I think the Time-Turner teleporting you to the Entrance Hall is a safety feature. Sticking to the same spot while time-travelling could land you in outer space, since the Earth would have moved on on it's journey around the Sun. Or if the travelling is anchored to Earth, you could appear and reveal yourself in front of someone who was there in the past, or literally appear inside of them if they're standing in your "landing spot." So maybe the Entrance Hall has countermeasures for such things, could be a designated landing zone for all time-travelling within the Hogwarts Grounds. Or it's plot convenience and I'm reaching hahah.

Katik

I do think it is a plot convenience - I actually believe most of the things we analyse here are either a plot convenience or just an oversight - I just have to keep reminding myself that that kind of attitude is no fun when people want to debate the points :)

Katik

Your last point is actually really good one - despite us seeing a lot of past trials in the Pensive in the next book, it's alarming how many times people have been punished without any proper trial in the books. Just think about Hagrid being sent to Azkaban last year just so that Fudge can be seen as doing something! Which makes the optimism from everyone about Harry's hearing in the Order really misguided - surely they're aware that Magical UK's justice system is haphazard at best given all the past occurrences? How can they rely on any kind of procedure like that to be fair? It makes me see the Ministry, even before Voldy's takeover, in a new light - despite all the bureaucracy it is literally just a dictatorship! And most people just go with that cause it does not impact their day-to-day lives.

Simon audsley

On the squib debate if as someone mentioned a Muggle born wizard/witch came about because they have a squib in their lineage it would mean they were not Muggle born. For example a squib marries a Muggle and has a kid that would make the kid a half-blood and if they have no magical powers they would be a squib by definition however their offspring would still have the potential of being a magic user, by this logic a magic user can never be Muggle born nor a squib as a squib or magic user has to have come from a magic possessing lineage even if that is a long line of squibs.

Katik

Then all Muggles are Squibs. As all of us share at least one common ancestor with every other currently living human on the planet only as far as 3000 years ago - it is statistically impossible that any living human would have absolutely no magical ancestor in their genealogical tree. in which case the world can be split between witches/wizards and squibs - and even that I would argue is a spectrum and not a hard line split. Or we go back to the definition, which clarifies it

Garry (Not Jerry)

No no no. Squibs are muggles. That’s it. They are just a type of muggle who has magical parents.

S1lm4r1l

Ron's massive, smelly, disgusting, ugly feet!!! 50:45 I think Snape uses the term 'Headmaster' both to distance himself from Dumbledore and impress upon Fudge that Dumbledore is perhaps not doing his utmost to keep Harry safe. 1:28:30 There is a number of spells Harry could use, but spells make noise, especially if they're done incorrectly or without finesse. Harry deliberately chooses not to use magic here. 1:40:30 The question about whether ghosts can cast magic is an interesting one. And there isn't really a definitive answer. However, as you point out with Myrtle, they can certainly affect the world around them some. 1:52:10 AH. But Veggie. Who is the last person to see or speak to Black before Harry and Hermione rescue him? Dumbledore. Perhaps there were protections, and Dumbledore removed them? Perhaps he locked Black in and told him to wait for rescue, just like he locked the Hospital Wing doors? :D 2:08:00 You be careful with that Elf hate. You'll have SPEW after you Veggie. :D 3:08:00 We'll get to Veritaserum, but not for a little while yet. 3:21:00. Hey, maybe Voldemort would taste nice to a Dementor? Just a nice tasty morsel. Finally, whilst Snape is brave. He isn't "stand-in-front-of-a-werewolf-and-let-it-swipe-at-you" brave. Book Snape would never do that, but that's not to say he wouldn't defend the Trio with spells to slow down or impede the Werewolf.

Hawwah

That's how I understand it as well.

Simon audsley

That all depends on what the genealogy of wizards and humans are , are wizards and humans evolved from the same common ancestor or are they a different evaluationary distinct branch much like neanderthal for eg.

S1lm4r1l

Actually, I think Sirius might know what they are, or at least. He's more likely to know than other people. We have to remember that Sirius is interested in Muggles. He has a muggle motor-bike which he's bewitched. He has Muggle mechanical manuals and put up pictures of Muggle girls in his room. In some ways, he's a bit like Mr Weasley. We only ever get tantalizing hints though. I think Sirius might well have known what a chemistry set was.

Monique

Hey Veggie, I was the person who commented that Sirius's patronus being a dog was fitting because his primary characteristic seems to be being loyal, to a fault at times, hence a dog animagus being so fitting.

Mordimer

Book Snape being knocked out while movie Snape protecting trio is one of the first changes that shows how different those characters actually are. Can't say anything else without spoilers ;)

H

Regarding you saying that Fudge was thinking "my only role here is getting Sirius kissed", that is also a James Potter quote from when he tried to be Sirius' wingman at a party once. :-) (Ron's massive feet)

Janie

Ron's massive feet! I finally made it to the end of the video. There's no way for me to watch a 5 hours long video in one go (not complaining!). I just want to mention a few more points: "Snape and Black are being petty gits." I think that sums them up very nicely :) About Veritaserum - yes, it is a truth potion. Umbridge used it in the movie to interogate students. I think Snape even told her she'd used the last of it on Cho Chang. But it was only a mention so I don't blame you for not remembering it.

Lisette C.

Ron's massive feet doesn't change the fact that Fudge is absolutely NOT in charge over the Black situation :P Yes, he might outrank Dumbledore on paper, but he turns to Dumbledore for help in all sorts of matters and only pulls rank when he is pushed into a corner. ^^ I also completely agree with you, Veggie - Pettigrew has no wand. I always watched it as if he was trying to attack Black and Lupin with the wand and when it was knocked out, he did the next best thing and transformed to run away :)

Annette Elliott

They majorly tone down how awful Snape is in the movies. You tend to make excuses for Snape's actions because you want to think the best of everyone. However, Snape was lying through his teeth. He knew perfectly well that the kids weren't bewitched or under any spell. He just didn't want anyone to actually listen to them or believe them because of his blind hatred of Sirius. I'm not saying that Sirius doesn't have the same blind hatred of Snape but you tend to give Snape a lot of leeway when he's obviously being a jerk. Everyone is pretty much aware that dementors are blind but I seriously doubt that anyone knew how ineffective they were against an anamagi or a regular animal. People avoid the dementors like the plague so I doubt anyone had done any in depth research on them. Also, as you said, anamagi are very rare so how would they possibly know how dementors react to them. As to Dumbledore having possibly used a time turner before every one forgets that at this point Dumbledore is still over 100 years old. Maybe once upon a time the time turners weren't quite so regulated. I'll try to remember to bring this up in more detail at a certain point in a later book.

Katik

:D

Giorgia M

I totally agree!! We’ll debate things and there’s a lot that doesn’t actually mean anything and is just the writer forgetting, plot hole or something coincidental. But again, I’m like, let people have their fun, Giorgia!!!

Nick Brønnum

Squib = disabled person in wizarding world ~ blind or deaf person. Squib have magic bot can't use it only a wizard can see a dementor - muggles can't se dementors - Squibs can se dementors + squib can see Hogwarts for what it truly is, not what a muggle sees 2 muggles can have a Squib, if a Wizard or Squib is in the family = magic is in the family if magic is in the family you can have a child of magic Squib or wizard

Maggie

I thought a squib was a non-magical child of two magical parents. Because if the parents have no magical ability, it's pretty standard for the kid not to have any either, even if there was a magical ancestor somewhere. And I'd think even with half-bloods (not like Harry, but like Voldemort where one parent has no magical ability), it'd be pretty 50/50 whether the kid has magic or not. So I always thought a squib was an anomaly, kind of like how a muggle-born has magic when neither parent has any.

Dara Jeeling

as much as I do not like Snapes actions (and I am a Snape fan) - I am not sure, how he could have known that they were nt under a spell. Maybe that Is truely what he thinks and the Ministry was not able to tell who was imperiused in the first Voldy war - so what makes you think, Snape can tell they are not bewitched? I am with you - he does not want anyone to listen to them (because he does not want anyone to stop thinking about Sirius punishment) I still think he may be under the impression they are bewitched. I have said it before regarding Sirius and his head bumping actions I can't prove he did it on purpose - so innocent until proven guilty And for me the same applies here with Snape. We can not prove is pure spite that makes him say the "bewitched" part - maybe he truly was thinking they are bewitched. That said - still do not like his intervention.

S1lm4r1l

Why can't both be true? Snape can perform legilimency after all. Perhaps Snape saw in Harry's mind that Harry believed Black was innocent and that it was really Pettigrew who betrayed Lily and James. Because he believes that such a series of events are impossible, he constructs a scenario in which Harry and the rest are Confunded. Because in his mind, that's the only way Harry would think that Black didn't betray his parents. It must also be said that if the Trio were Confunded, they would act the same way.

Christina Brock

I have a godson, and yes, the main idea with that is that I'll take care of him if his parents can't for any reason. There are some responsibilities for godparents while the actual parents are still fine as well, to varying degrees (in my case I'm almost a third parent), but it's mainly about ensuring that the child will be cared for by someone the parents trust, if anything happens. On a different topic (can anyone tell me how to start a new paragraph on here?) I think of Book!Padfoot as a Newfoundland, rather than the movie's Great Dane -- huge, shaggy, and a good swimmer. It seems to fit the description better. What do you think?

Ashley Evers

I know that you're not really being serious, but I do want to say this, cause it's important. You're not stupid, Veggie. You have no idea how often I have been impressed with your insight and deductions, especially based on the incomplete information the HP movies often provide. There have been so many times I've thought, wow, I can't believe he picked up on that with how little they explained it. I am regularly struck by your intelligence, and since I think it so often, it felt like something I ought to say 😁

Janie

Thank you for pointing it out. You have no idea how often I wanted to scream at him to stop calling himself an idiot in the videos. I do know he's not being serious, but it still kind of bothers me that he keeps doing that.

S1lm4r1l

Agreed. And he asks a lot of incredibly deep questions that I certainly hadn't considered. "Can Ghosts do Magic?" being an example. Because there isn't really a hard answer.

Kunzite Blossom

I know this is late, life has been chaotic. I haven't had a chance to just sit and watch. Here's my take on them going back in time. I believe 1 turn is an hour. So they are going back 3 hours. I used to think when they needed to be back was always midnight, because I assume the bell tower only rings at certain times. But 9pm would be too late for the sun to still be out, even for summer. I know for me sun sets around 8:30 in June. So maybe they went back to 7pm. Meaning they had to be back by 10pm. Which is nice and perfectly dark out.

Annette Elliott

I wish they had included a lot of this chapter in the movie. It shows how unreasonable, practically nuts, Snape can be on the subject of James and Sirius. Sirius I can give him a little leeway about because he could have died or at least been seriously injured because of Sirius' nasty prank. However, his hatred of James is totally unreasonable which we know from the last movie is fueled a lot by his jealousy over Lily marrying James and he lets that warp his view and causes him to bully Harry. I also love the scene on the train with the teeny little owl, the permanent permission slip for Harry to go to Hogsmeade and the scene at the station when Harry tells Vernon about his mass murderer godfather who likes to check up on him. I can just see Vernon's face looking absolutely gobsmacked after that info dump. Lol.

Katerina Portokalia

where do you live? where I am (Greece) the sun is well up until 20:30 around June (today at that time it certainly was daylight - sunset must have been past 21:00), and the further up north, the longer the days - from what I know in Scotland sunset can be up to 22:30 or something, late June that is.

emmainkeri

Hey Annette! I think you accidentally posted this on the wrong thread! You can still copy&paste this there though!

emmainkeri

Are you talking about the bit where Sirius is gasping for air before the dementors actually attack but he sees them, or after, when the piece of his soul or whatever it was goes back into his mouth? I think Veggie was talking about the former. He did open his eyes there 🧐

emmainkeri

I don't think so. Squibs can see dementors (and Hogwarts and other muggleproof places), muggles can't. Squibs have the magic gene but can't perform magic, muggles don't have the gene.

itsanursething

Hmm. I'll have to go back and rewatch the scene. I may have been thinking about a different part. Thanks!

Saiyasha

I think you missunderstand something: It is not common lnowledge that Dementors have less power over Animals then people. This is something Sirius found out for himself. Since there are so few Animagi, I don't think there have been extensive tests on how an Animagus would react differently to them then non-Animagi. Sirius is an outlier case

Saiyasha

To be honest, Sirius could have contacted Lupin at any point. I think there would have been a good chance that Lupin would have at least listened, but that isn't Blacks way. He didn't want to be proven innocent and he wasn't looking for Justice, he wasn't even looking for Harry. He wanted Pettigrew dead and that was that.

Saiyasha

I mean, I would say the Demenetors kiss is the death penalty. Sure, you are technically still alive, but you are not... YOU anymore. You are not an Idiot, but i do think it is very clear that Harry is using Hyperbole there. Of course McNair wouldn't immediatly chop Blacks head off, but there is a good chance Fudge would have ordered Dementors to immediatly perform the kiss without listening to anyone