Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

[POV: Catelyn Stark]

The banners had gathered beneath Winterfell’s walls before dawn.

They stirred in the cold wind beyond the outer gate, direwolves and flayed men, mailed fists and stone towers, bears and horned heads snapping beneath a sky the colour of old iron. Horses stamped upon the hard ground. Men shouted for squires, tightened girths, checked spearheads, and cursed the cold while pale steam rose from their mouths.

Balon Greyjoy had crowned himself upon Pyke.

The Ironborn had burned the Lannister fleet and risen against King Robert, and now Eddard Stark rode south with the strength of the North at his back. From Winterfell they would take the Kingsroad to the Neck, then turn toward Seagard, where the riverlords and royal host were gathering for the war.

Catelyn stood beside her husband upon the steps of the Great Keep.

Robb stood nearest Ned, solemn in a grey cloak fastened with a silver direwolf. At six he was still only a boy, yet he held himself stiffly before the northern lords, determined that no man should see him weep. Sansa remained at Catelyn’s side, one small hand buried in the folds of her mother’s gown. She was only three and understood little beyond the banners, horses, and the promise that her father would bring her something from the sea.

Arya had remained inside with her nurse.

The babe was scarcely a moon old, too young for the bitter wind and too young to know that her father rode to war.

Behind Robb and Sansa stood the other two children.

Jon and Lyarra Snow.

The living proof of sin.

Catelyn felt their presence without turning. They were always too near—too near her children, too near the highborn lords and ladies who passed through Winterfell, too near the place that belonged by every law of gods and men to Robb.

They wore good wool, though without the silver direwolf clasps given to her trueborn children. Their cloaks were plain grey, their boots sound, their faces clean.

More than most bastards ever received.

More than bastards had any right to expect.

The septas at Riverrun had taught Catelyn what such children were. Bastards were born from lust, broken vows, and surrender before temptation. They might bear no guilt for the act itself, but neither could their existence be separated from the sin that had made them.

Septa Mordane understood that well.

She spoke of charity when Ned or Maester Luwin might hear, but in private her words were less gentle. Bastards required firm hands, she said, lest indulgence teach them to reach above their station. They possessed the same hungers as trueborn children without the lawful place that taught those hungers restraint.

Jon was the greater danger, in her judgment.

“A bastard son raised beside an heir will measure himself against that heir,” Mordane had warned Catelyn. “Even should the boy possess no ambition, others may find ambition for him.”

Lyarra offended her in a different fashion. The girl resisted every lesson Mordane considered proper. She sat through sewing with a face as still as carved stone, completed her letters too quickly, and asked questions concerning histories and laws that no six-year-old girl had cause to ask.

“She has no humility,” the septa had said. “She receives correction as though indulging the woman who gives it.”

Catelyn had seen the same thing.

The girl obeyed often enough to escape proper punishment, yet never seemed chastened. Rebuke slid from her like rain from slate. There were moments when Mordane’s round face reddened beneath Lyarra’s silent gaze, as if the septa sensed the same thing Catelyn did.

The child was judging them.

Petyr understood the danger as well.

His letters came rarely and by cautious hands, tucked among merchants’ accounts or hidden beneath harmless news from the Vale. He never wrote anything that might shame her if another found it. Petyr had always known how to place meaning beneath innocent words.

A bastard raised beside the trueborn, he had once written, might eventually forget which of them was meant to inherit.

Catelyn had burned the letter.

She remembered every word.

She remembered the first time she had seen the twins more clearly still.

Ned had returned from war with grief carved into his face and two dark-haired babes beneath his protection. Catelyn had given him Robb and waited at Riverrun while he rode south to find his sister. She had prayed before the Seven for his safe return and feared every raven that passed through the castle gates.

Then he had brought the children north.

Not one bastard, which might have been dismissed as a single weakness committed amid fear, loneliness, and war.

Two.

A boy and a girl.

Twins born from the same shame.

Catelyn did not blame Ned as she blamed them.

He had been young, newly wed to a woman he scarcely knew, carrying the grief of a murdered father, brother, and sister. Men went astray in war. The septons spoke often of temptation, repentance, and forgiveness.

Ned had returned to her.

He had honoured her in every way that mattered. He had given her Winterfell, treated Robb as his heir, and stood beside her as husband and lord. Whatever weakness had overcome him in the south belonged to the confusion of those bloody days.

The twins were the wound that refused to close.

They remained.

They ate beneath Winterfell’s roof, learned beside her children, and called her husband Father. Every year made them less like the fading consequence of a distant error and more like a permanent part of the castle.

Catelyn might have forgiven a sin that had stayed buried in the south.

These two walked, watched, learned, and gathered affection.

Worse, they were exceptional.

Everyone saw it, though few dared speak too freely before her.

Jon was quiet where Robb was eager, patient where Robb rushed. He listened to Maester Luwin with grave attention and remembered lessons after hearing them once. He seldom boasted and almost never sought praise, which only caused men to praise him more.

Lyarra was worse.

She had learned her letters before Sansa could speak in full sentences. She listened to stewards, maesters, and visiting lords as though deciding which of their words deserved remembrance. Septa Mordane had ceased praising the girl’s quickness after Lyarra corrected her twice during a lesson on the lineages of the great houses.

The septa had struck her fingers with a willow switch.

Lyarra had not cried.

She had looked down at the red marks, then up at Mordane, calm and cold and wholly without fear.

That silence had enraged the septa more than tears or defiance might have done.

Afterward Mordane had doubled the girl’s sewing and made her remain upon her knees before the Seven until the evening bells.

Lyarra endured both without complaint.

Catelyn found nothing admirable in it.

Children ought to laugh, sulk, grow frightened, and seek forgiveness. They should lower their eyes before correction and feel shame when properly rebuked.

Lyarra watched.

When her grey eyes met Catelyn’s, there was no guilt in them. No nervous desire to please. No uncertainty concerning her place.

Only cold attention.

Catelyn had once found her standing before the heart tree after sunset, alone beneath the red leaves. Snow gathered in the girl’s black hair while she stared into the carved white face.

She had not been praying. Not as Catelyn understood prayer.

When Catelyn ordered her inside, Lyarra had turned slowly.

For one disquieting instant, Catelyn had felt as though she were the child and Lyarra the woman weighing her conduct.

She had hated the bastard for making her feel afraid.

The incident with the wooden horse had happened years before, when the children had been scarcely more than babes.

The carved toy had belonged to Lyarra. Robb had wanted it and taken hold of the body while she clung to one of its wheeled legs. The nurse had allowed them to struggle, expecting one child to tire.

Lyarra had bitten him.

Her small teeth had scarcely broken the skin. Robb had been more delighted than hurt and had laughed through the entire quarrel, even after Lyarra released the horse and sent him tumbling onto the rushes.

Yet the act remained what it was.

A bastard girl had sunk her teeth into Winterfell’s heir over a toy.

Catelyn had expected shame when she learned of it. Instead the nurses treated the tale as amusing, another sign that Lyarra possessed the wolf’s blood. Even Ned’s mouth had twitched when Robb proudly displayed the faint marks upon his hand.

Everything in Winterfell would one day belong to Robb.

The wooden horse had been nothing. A child’s toy, soon outgrown and forgotten.

Yet Lyarra had fought him for it as though possession alone made her right greater than his.

That was how it began, Septa Mordane said.

First a toy.

Then a place at table.

Then a name, a castle, or a crown.

Catelyn had thought Mordane severe at the time.

She no longer did.

A few months ago, both twins had begun training in the yard.

Jon’s presence had been expected eventually. Bastard or not, he was a boy raised beneath a lord’s roof, and Ned would not allow any boy in his household to grow unable to defend himself.

Lyarra had been another matter.

She had begged for a sword.

Not with tears or childish pleading. She had asked Ned calmly, received his refusal, and asked again the next day. Then she asked Ser Rodrik. When he laughed, she demanded to know why Jon should learn something she could learn as well.

Septa Mordane had been appalled.

“A young girl has no place in a yard striking at boys,” she told Catelyn. “It encourages immodesty, pride, and every ungoverned impulse already present within her.”

Catelyn had agreed.

Ned refused Lyarra at first.

The girl continued asking.

She followed Ser Rodrik to the armoury, watched lessons from the edge of the yard, and practised the movements with a length of firewood when she believed no one saw her.

At last Ned relented. He claimed a wooden sword would do no harm if she continued the lessons proper to a girl.

Catelyn had known harm would come of it.

She had merely misunderstood its shape.

Robb had already been practising under Ser Rodrik’s eye. He knew how to stand, how to grip a wooden sword, and how to strike the padded posts without losing his balance. He ought to have remained comfortably ahead of two children who had only just begun.

Within a fortnight, Jon matched him.

Within a moon, both twins surpassed him.

Jon moved with a restraint no child of six ought to possess. He did not strike merely because an opening seemed to appear. He waited. Watched. Drew Robb forward, then turned the boy’s strength against him.

Lyarra fought differently.

She pressed without fear. She was smaller than either boy and lacked their strength, yet she seemed to know where a blow would fall before the arm delivering it had fully moved. She slipped aside, struck wrists and knees, and recovered her footing before Robb could answer.

Ser Rodrik ceased laughing during their lessons.

He began watching.

Robb tried harder when the twins bested him. His face reddened, his strikes grew heavier, and the more he wanted victory, the more easily Jon drew him out of position.

Lyarra showed him less mercy.

She struck the wooden sword from his hand twice in one morning and swept his leg from beneath him the third time they faced one another.

Catelyn had watched her son fall into the mud while the bastard girl remained standing over him.

Ser Rodrik had stroked his white whiskers.

“Seven hells,” he murmured. “It is as though Arthur Dayne has been born again in two bodies.”

The name had chilled her.

The Sword of the Morning.

The deadliest knight in the Seven Kingdoms, if half the songs were true.

Ned stood beside Ser Rodrik, his face unreadable as he watched Jon and Lyarra.

“At times,” he said quietly, “I think the same.”

There had been no smile in his voice.

Perhaps the comparison troubled him. Perhaps the dead knight had left memories Ned preferred buried beneath the red mountains of Dorne.

Catelyn cared little.

The words had been spoken.

Ser Rodrik said them before two guards, half a dozen boys waiting their turn, and several servants lingering near the armoury.

Arthur Dayne born again in two bodies.

By evening the kitchens knew.

Within a fortnight, visiting bannermen had begun asking to see Lord Stark’s remarkable bastard twins train.

Praise that belonged to Robb was stolen before he was old enough to understand the theft.

The northern men watched Jon’s patience and nodded to one another. They laughed when Lyarra struck boys larger than herself and called her a little she-wolf.

They did not see what Catelyn saw.

Robb was the lawful heir of Winterfell.

He should have been the child praised in the yard. He should have been the one in whom guards and bannermen glimpsed the making of a great warrior.

Instead, men spoke of Ned Stark’s bastards as though the gods had placed swords in their hands at birth.

Septa Mordane tried to end Lyarra’s training.

She assigned the girl additional stitching before each morning lesson, then declared the work careless and made her begin again. When Lyarra still reached the yard in time, Mordane added prayers, sums, and the copying of passages concerning obedience and a woman’s proper place.

Lyarra completed them all.

The septa then complained that swordplay had made her wilful.

Catelyn did not correct her.

Jon received less attention from Mordane, for boys did not sit beneath a septa’s authority in quite the same fashion. Yet she found other means to remind him of his birth. He was seated below Robb at lessons when she was present, given the worn practice cloak rather than the newer one, and excluded from the small courtesies she offered the trueborn children.

Once, when Jon called Ned Father before her, Mordane’s mouth tightened.

“Lord Stark,” she corrected. “A bastard should be grateful for his lord’s protection without presuming upon the names of lawful kinship.”

Ned had not heard.

Jon had only lowered his eyes and said nothing.

Lyarra had stared at the septa for the remainder of the meal.

That look had earned her an hour upon her knees.

The twins never accepted punishment as other children did.

They endured it together.

If Jon was denied sweetbread, Lyarra left hers untouched. If Mordane kept Lyarra at her sewing after supper, Jon found some excuse to remain nearby with a book. When they were once given separate chambers, neither slept. Jon sat outside his sister’s door until dawn while Lyarra remained awake within.

They were six years old.

They behaved like conspirators.

Jon frightened Catelyn because he was male.

Lyarra frightened her because she seemed impossible.

Both possessed dark hair, grey eyes, and the long Stark face. They looked more northern than Robb or Sansa, whose auburn hair and blue eyes proclaimed the blood of Riverrun.

The bannermen liked that.

The North liked that.

Jon was a boy, nearly the same age as Robb. Law placed the trueborn son above the bastard, but law had not prevented Daemon Blackfyre from setting half a realm aflame.

Jon need not desire Winterfell.

Others might desire it for him.

A quiet boy with the Stark look, loved by northern men and gifted with a blade, could become dangerous merely by surviving long enough.

Lyarra would stand beside him.

Catelyn knew that as surely as she knew her own name.

The twins never competed with one another. Praise given to one pleased the other. An insult offered to either was remembered by both. They spoke little before adults, yet sometimes Catelyn saw them exchange a glance and knew some entire conversation had passed between them without a word.

Family, Duty, Honor.

She repeated the words silently as she looked upon Robb.

Family first.

Robb first.

She would protect his place because Ned could not see that it required protection. He looked upon the twins and saw children beneath his care. He did not see how the bannermen watched them or how quickly admiration might become loyalty.

His blindness was not wickedness.

It was honour carried beyond wisdom.

A horn sounded beyond the gate.

Ned crouched before Robb and placed both hands upon his shoulders.

“You are the Stark in Winterfell while I am gone.”

Robb straightened.

“I know, Father.”

“You will listen to your mother. To Maester Luwin and Ser Rodrik as well. A lord who refuses counsel soon finds himself ruling fools.”

“I will listen.”

Ned embraced him.

Catelyn saw Robb’s face tighten against his father’s shoulder, but the boy did not cry.

Ned rose and bent to Sansa next. She clung to his neck and asked whether he would bring her a shell from the sea. Ned promised he would try.

Then his eyes moved toward the twins.

Jon and Lyarra stepped forward together.

They were always together.

Ned rested one hand upon Jon’s head.

“Mind your lessons.”

“I will, Father.”

The word struck Catelyn as it always did.

Father.

Jon spoke it as freely as Robb.

Septa Mordane shifted behind the children. Catelyn saw disapproval pinch her mouth, but Ned did not look toward her.

He turned to Lyarra.

“And you will heed the septa while I am gone.”

For the first time, something changed in Lyarra’s face.

Only slightly.

“I always hear her.”

“That was not what I said.”

“No, Father.”

Mordane sniffed softly.

“The difficulty has never been the girl’s hearing, my lord.”

Ned looked toward the septa.

His gaze remained upon her long enough that she lowered her eyes.

“Then perhaps patience will serve where repetition has failed.”

Catelyn heard no rebuke of Lyarra in the words.

Lyarra heard none either.

Ned looked between the twins.

“Do as Lady Stark commands.”

Catelyn’s back stiffened.

“Yes, Father,” Jon said.

Lyarra gave a small nod.

For one moment Ned’s expression softened.

The bannermen saw it.

They saw Lord Stark’s affection. They saw the two black-haired, grey-eyed children standing beside Robb as though all three were equally his.

Some of those men had watched the twins train.

They had heard Ser Rodrik declare Arthur Dayne reborn in two bodies.

The North would remember.

Ned came to Catelyn last.

He kissed her brow and placed one hand against her cheek.

“I will return when it is done.”

“You will return when the king’s peace is restored.”

His grey eyes held hers.

“You will have Winterfell.”

“I will keep it for you.”

Ned mounted beneath the gatehouse.

The banners moved with him. Hundreds of men turned south beneath the direwolf of Stark, hooves beating against the frozen road. Steel flashed beneath the pale morning sun.

Catelyn watched until the last riders vanished beyond the hills.

Only then did she turn toward the castle.

Winterfell was hers until Ned returned.

The thought brought fear, but also opportunity.

There were corrections that could not be made while Ned watched the twins with his stubborn tenderness. They ate too well, slept too near the family chambers, trained beside Robb, and carried too few burdens.

Catelyn need not order cruelty.

She need only cease preventing those who understood proper order from enforcing it.

The northern servants were often too fond of the twins. Those who had come with her from Riverrun knew better.

Septa Mordane knew better.

The septa had already proposed moving them from the chamber they shared near the nursery.

“They are no longer babes,” she had said. “Nor should bastards sleep so near the lord’s lawful children.”

A colder room stood empty near the outer wall.

It would serve.

Their meals could be taken farther down the table. Their sword lessons could be delayed by useful work. There were floors to sweep, wood to carry, rushes to replace, and stable stalls that did not clean themselves.

A cook might become careless with salt.

A laundress might discover their cloaks at the bottom of the washing.

A servant might forget to build the fire in their room until late in the evening.

Nothing that could be called cruelty.

Nothing Ned could condemn upon his return.

Only reminders.

Jon would require the harsher lesson. A bastard girl might one day be married far from Winterfell. A bastard boy might become a rival.

Lyarra would resist whatever was done.

Catelyn found herself wondering whether Mordane could finally break that cold composure.

She had not yet decided where to begin when Howland Reed arrived three days later.

No herald announced him. No long line of riders passed beneath his banner. One moment the gatehouse yard held only guards and servants; the next a small, mud-stained man sat upon a shaggy horse beneath the walls, wrapped in a cloak mottled green and brown.

Catelyn received him in Ned’s solar.

Lord Reed bowed, though not so deeply as a southron lord might have done. His clothing smelled faintly of damp earth and stagnant water. He looked no more imposing than he had years before at Harrenhal, yet this was the man who had returned from Dorne beside Ned when all the others had died.

The man who had saved her husband’s life.

“My lady.”

“Lord Reed. We had no word of your coming.”

“There was little time to send it.”

His dark eyes moved briefly around the solar before returning to her.

“I met Lord Stark upon the road north of the Neck.”

“Then you know he has gone to Seagard.”

“I do.”

“And still you continued to Winterfell.”

“I came to speak with you.”

Catelyn folded her hands before her.

“About what?”

“Jon and Lyarra Snow.”

Her mouth tightened.

Even with Ned gone, the bastards reached into every matter.

“What of them?”

“I would take them as wards at Greywater Watch until Lord Stark returns from war.”

For a moment Catelyn only stared at him.

“You want the twins.”

“I do.”

“Not Robb.”

Howland’s expression scarcely changed.

“Robb is the heir to Winterfell. His place is here while his father is at war.”

“Sansa, then.”

“Your daughter is three and belongs beside her mother.”

“And the twins are only six.”

“Old enough to travel. Young enough to learn the ways of another household.”

The insult burned more fiercely than Catelyn expected.

A wardship was an honour. Highborn children were sent between castles to strengthen friendships, secure loyalties, and bind houses together.

Howland Reed was Ned’s most loyal bannerman. The man who had fought beside him in Dorne. The man who knew secrets Catelyn had never been permitted to hear.

And he wanted the bastards.

Not the heir.

Not Ned’s trueborn daughter.

Perhaps he had heard the tales from Winterfell’s yard. Perhaps even the crannogmen spoke of Arthur Dayne reborn in two bodies.

“Why?” she asked.

Howland regarded her quietly.

“The Neck is far from the western coast. Greywater Watch is difficult to find and harder to attack. Lord Stark agreed the children would be safer there while the North’s strength is drawn south.”

“He agreed?”

“We spoke upon the road.”

Ned had agreed without consulting her.

Catelyn pushed the thought aside before resentment could settle upon him. Ned had been riding to war, burdened with banners, roads, provisions, and King Robert’s command. Howland had likely pressed the matter upon him when there was little time to consider it.

The twins drew such complications to themselves.

They always had.

“Greywater Watch has no sept.”

“No.”

“No proper castle, by every tale I have heard.”

“The tales rarely find it.”

“And your people worship the old gods.”

“As do most men north of the Neck.”

Savage men beneath savage gods, living among black pools, poisoned spears, and lizard-lions.

Perhaps the twins belonged among them.

“How long would you keep them?”

“Until the rebellion is ended. Longer, should Lord Stark judge it wise.”

There it was.

Distance.

Jon away from Robb. Lyarra away from Sansa. Both removed from the bannermen who admired their Stark faces and their unnatural skill.

No more watching Robb fall beneath Jon’s wooden sword.

No more hearing men laugh with delight when Lyarra struck some larger boy.

No more whispers of Arthur Dayne reborn.

Catelyn ought to have felt only relief.

Instead, she remained angered that Howland Reed wanted them at all.

“They cannot travel alone.”

“I have asked that Alyse accompany them.”

Catelyn’s eyes narrowed.

“The steward from Winter Town.”

“She was their nurse once. They know her.”

“She serves Vayon Poole.”

“Lord Poole believes he can spare her. Most of the work required before the campaign has already been completed.”

“And Rhea?”

“She will accompany Alyse.”

Catelyn almost smiled.

Of course she would.

The girl followed the twins like a shadow whenever Alyse brought her inside the castle. She sat beside Lyarra, whispered with Jon, and treated them with greater affection than she ever showed Robb or Sansa.

Could the child not see which were better?

Which children were lawful?

Which children would one day matter?

Rhea was only the orphaned kin of a steward, yet even lowborn loyalty ought to rise toward the trueborn rather than cling to bastards.

Alyse had likely taught her otherwise.

Catelyn had noticed Ned looking at the woman on several occasions when she came to the castle with accounts or inventories. His gaze had lingered once or twice, though never in any manner that could be called improper.

She dismissed the thought.

Ned was honourable.

He had stumbled once during war and carried the consequence home. He would not betray her again, certainly not with a widowed steward living in Winter Town.

To suspect otherwise would dishonour her husband.

Still, Catelyn would be glad to see Alyse gone.

Septa Mordane would be gladder still. She disliked the woman’s easy familiarity with the twins and had more than once complained that Alyse weakened discipline by comforting them after correction.

“The twins, Alyse, and Rhea,” Catelyn said. “All of them to Greywater Watch.”

“If you consent.”

Catelyn went to the window.

Below, Jon and Lyarra crossed the yard together.

Both carried wooden swords.

Jon rested his across one shoulder. Lyarra turned hers slowly in her hand as she spoke, testing its weight as though it were castle-forged steel rather than ashwood.

Jon listened as though every word mattered.

They looked up at the same moment.

Both of them.

Their grey eyes found the window.

Catelyn stepped back before she could stop herself.

Uncanny children.

Let the crannogmen have them.

Let them sleep beneath dripping roofs and eat frogs beside black pools. Let them worship cold gods beneath twisted trees and learn the savage manners of swamp-dwellers.

Let distance teach them that Winterfell did not belong to them.

Robb would no longer share his father’s yard with a bastard who surpassed him.

Sansa would no longer have Lyarra’s unnatural cleverness placed beside her own gentler accomplishments.

Septa Mordane could devote herself to Catelyn’s lawful daughters instead of wasting hours attempting to beat humility into a girl who possessed none.

When Ned returned, perhaps he would see how peaceful his true family could be without the twins casting their shadows across it.

Catelyn turned from the window.

“My husband truly agreed?”

“He did.”

“And you will keep them safe.”

“With my life.”

She believed him.

That soured the satisfaction somewhat. Even in the Neck, the twins would possess the protection of one of Ned’s most trusted lords.

Yet they would be gone.

For now, that was enough.

“Then take them,” Catelyn said. “Take Alyse and Rhea with them.”

Howland bowed his head.

“We can leave at first light.”

“Not tomorrow.”

His brow lifted.

“They require clothing, provisions, and horses. Maester Luwin must be informed. Two days.”

“As you command.”

Howland bowed again and withdrew.

When the door closed, Catelyn remained alone in Ned’s solar.

Family, Duty, Honor.

She had fulfilled all three.

She had protected Robb’s place.

She had removed the bastards from her children without defying Ned or casting two six-year-olds openly into the cold.

Below, Jon said something to his sister.

Lyarra looked toward the solar window one final time. Then she rested her wooden sword against her shoulder and turned away.

Catelyn watched them cross the yard together.

She told herself the tightness in her chest was triumph.

Comments

Winter

Dumb trout as usual doesnt know the long game being played

Tristan

Trout wonders why the lords dislike her and her kids when she sees them as savages and despise their gods