Crackpots #82: A Brief History of Slash Fiction (Patreon)
Content
This week's edition of Crackpots comes courtesy of Arielle Gordon. Arielle is a writer from Long Island, currently based in Brooklyn. She previously wrote Crackpots #66.
*****
Long before he took to the podium last week to celebrate the Knicks’ triumphant championship win over the San Antonio Spurs, Mayor Zohran Mamdani used his platform to promote a very different kind of heated rivalry.
Bundled in an army green DSNY jacket and black leather gloves, the mayor held a press conference imploring the city to remain inside as a massive blizzard blanketed New York this past January. Perhaps hoping to offset stir-crazy madness in studio apartments across the five boroughs, he suggested one possible form of entertainment during the squall: “I can think of no better excuse for New Yorkers to stay home, take a long nap or take advantage of our public library’s offer of free access to Heated Rivalry on e-book or audiobook for anyone with a library card.”
The mayor did not elaborate on if he personally had read Rachel Reid’s hit franchise about two ice hockey players caught in a covert homosexual romance (which, as anyone with a throbbing—I mean, a pulse, anyone with a pulse—will remember, was adapted into an even more massively popular television series last year). But his endorsement struck me as a watershed moment in the broader genre of homoerotic fiction written for (predominantly straight) women, by (predominantly straight) women. Eric Adams wasn’t suggesting a The Song of Achilles bookclub during the brutal heatwaves of summer 2024. Bill de Blasio didn’t ask us to read Interview with the Vampire to ease our COVID quarantine isolation. So, how did we get here? On the occasion of pride month, I wanted to provide a brief history of women writing about two men doing it; an incomplete overview of so-called “slash” fanfiction.
Ancient origins
If we define “fanfiction” as any literary creation that develops new plotlines from preexisting characters, then it’s an art as old as the written word. Is not Midrash a form of Talmudic fanfiction, a way for rabbinic scholars to invent backstories for Moses’ lisp (an angel forced him to burn his tongue on hot coals) or pontificate on the taste of manna? Was Plato not writing fanfiction about his mentor Socrates when he imagined his dialogues in Phaedrus, or his speeches in Symposium?
Fanfiction scholar Henry Jenkins, in his book Textual Poachers, puts fanfiction in the lineage of folk storytelling, in line with epics like Camelot that expanded and changed to suit the themes and surroundings of its orators over time. These civilian interventions allow the stories to remain relevant throughout historical shifts, the same way that fanfiction allows its authors to repurpose preexisting relationships into nondominant readings that might better suit their emotional needs.
More often than not, these narrative divergences tend to indulge one specific emotional need. In a 2020 article for The Atlantic, Shannon Chamberlain posits that the genre began in earnest with Gulliver’s Travels fanfic, written not long after the book’s publication in 1726. In addition to some Lilliputian enemas rendered in these fan interpretations, she notes the particular focus given to Lemuel Gulliver’s wife, Mary, who isn’t too pleased that her husband won’t exactly jump her bones when he returns home from Lilliput. Setting a trend that foreshadows the erotic fanfiction that would spawn in its wake, Mary, a minor character in the original series, is magnified in these narratives, becoming a stand-in for female desire that is otherwise conspicuously absent.
An Enterprise of desire: Star Trek fanfiction
Star Trek premiered on September 8, 1966 and ran for just three seasons. Later dubbed “The Original Series,” it made celebrities out of its cast of relative unknowns, particularly William Shatner as Captain James T. Kirk and Leonard Nimoy as the half-human, half-Vulcan Science Officer Spock. Though the series included three female characters, including Janice Rand (Grace Lee Whitney), Kirk’s “personal yeoman” who had “a shape that even a uniform could not hide,” there was scarcely a hint of heterosexual desire in the show’s original run. When nurse Christine Chapel (Majel Barrett) confesses her love to Spock in “The Naked Time” (S1E4), he returns a perplexed look.
By contrast, the show seemed to imply not only a deep respect, but also a kind of symbiotic and beautiful friendship between Kirk, the morally driven and passionate human, and the coldly calculating Spock. The second season’s premiere, “Amok Time,” became known for this kind of romantic undercurrent that was never consummated officially in the show’s run, with Spock hinting at a shameful sexual secret. Their friendship was equitable, profound, and productive in ways their heterosexual interactions never approached.
The first fan-made Star Trek zine, Spockanalia, launched in 1967, before the series finale. Charmingly handmade, the zine was full of amateur drawings, songs, and stories expanding on the world of the Starship Enterprise, mostly created by young women.
Spockanalia
But it wasn’t long before these zines took on a more lurid dimension: Diane Merchant’s “A Fragment Out of Time,” published in a 1974 edition of the fanzine Grup (named for the Trekkian abbreviation for “grown-up”), is commonly recognized as the first piece of fan art to explicitly create a homosexual relationship between Kirk and Spock.
The pieces were all there in the original series: hand-holding, emotional stakes, intimate confessions; fan writing just brought them to the surface. Merchant’s story, which clocked in at about 500 words, was surprisingly similar to the stilted adolescent desires in fanfiction today: plenty of erect nipples, massaged buttocks and groins. From there, a whole world of horny alternate realities was born—the use of “slash” in “slash fiction” to imply homosexuality actually comes from the original name for this pairing: “K/S” (perhaps “Kock” was too on the nose).
Grup #5
It was during this time that Trekkies also pioneered what would come to be known as “Mary Sue” fiction, or the “self-insert.” Based on a 1973 fanfic by Paula Smith called “A Trekkie’s Tale,” published in the fanzine Menagerie, a “Mary Sue” story is one that invents a fictionalized female character, often as a stand-in for the author. These insertions feel similarly motivated to their homoerotic counterparts: a desire to visualize a more fulfilling romantic relationship in Star Trek.
“Mary Sue” in Menagerie
For the love of boy-love
At around the same time, Japanese writers and illustrators had begun to produce homoerotically suggestive content aimed at young women. The novelist Mari Mori is credited as the first to write a tale of shonen-ai (boy love), in her 1961 novella A Lovers' Forest. Like many in the boy-love genre, the story focused on a doomed age-gap romance between a professor and his underaged student, and was focused on desire and longing as much as sex and lust. The genre quickly developed, splitting into tanbi (fiction with more literary aims, inspired by the works of Yukio Mishima and Oscar Wilde) and yaoi (an acronym meaning essentially “no climax, no plot, no meaning,” and is just that—pure sex, without the messiness of narrative).
The characters in boy love stories were often depicted as androgynous, lithe and sinewy, with long hair and high cheekbones. There wasn’t a subversion of typical masculinity present as much as a consummation of a kind of beauty implicit in their appearances. In 1979, June launched as a magazine devoted to art and stories depicting boy love, with a focus on the aesthetic and literary aims, rather than explicitly prurient desires. These magazines, and similar boy-love mangas that would follow, were (and still are) broadly marketed to teenage girls and young women, and can be purchased without any content warnings in convenience stores throughout Japan.
Cover of June, 1982 edition
The internet
Fanfiction.net was launched by software engineering student Xing Li in 1998, initially as a UCLA school project. Now, it is the repository of millions of fan creations, with almost one million stories dedicated to the Harry Potter universe alone. Like the zinesters before them, online fanfiction writers took implied relationships to sexual conclusions (“Drarry,” between Draco and Harry, is perhaps the most popular, but fans have combined nearly everyone in the series— consider “Grindeldore,” or Grindelwald and Dumbledore).
But that is not how I found my way into the world of slash fiction. Instead, my home for homoerotic smut was Livejournal, an early blogging platform known today as an even mopier alternative to Myspace. There, I spent hours reading about invented relationships between members of my favorite third-wave emo bands, primarily Panic! At the Disco. Like so many of the characters rendered in boy love manga, the men in these bands highlighted their androgyny: they wore makeup liberally, they squeezed into painted-on jeans, they danced suggestively on stage.
My primary “ship,” or “relationship,” was between Panic’s outgoing lead singer Brendon Urie and its enigmatic songwriter, Ryan Ross, otherwise known as “Ryden” (not sure why it wasn’t “Rydon,” but it just wasn’t). Reading fanfiction is how I learned about the “nape of a neck” and the “small of a back,” these suggestive areas that aroused far more in a 12-year-old me than hardcore pornography, which seemed, in my brief exposure to it in friends’ basements, to be violent and terrifying. I read it for the smut, sure, but also for the plot; some authors even provided “mixtapes” to accompany these stories, which is how I found Wilco and Tegan & Sara for the first time.
Yet I also learned that I should hide my consumption of these lurid texts. Other Livejournal communities, like the influential emo gossip forum fbr_trash (which I investigated for The Outline in 2019), would immediately humiliate users who followed slash fiction pages. Eventually, luckily, I outgrew these communities for the real-life sexual tensions of my high school years. Around the same time, in 2007, Livejournal began to enforce stricter content policies, eventually leading to the creation of the non-profit Archive of Our Own (or AO3) in 2008, which hosts any number of transgressive narratives, from pedophilia to incest, on its open-source platform. And for anyone born after me (don’t tell me, I know, I’m old), the website Wattpad has become the go-to platform for a new generation of fanfiction authors to read and share their work.
Revenge of Mary Sue
The past decade has seen a mainstreaming of these once-underground storytelling traditions: Fifty Shades of Grey famously began as a Twilight fanfiction online before becoming a best-selling series and then a blockbuster film. And while that narrative is one of the rarer “ships” between a “canon” heterosexual couple (Bella Swan and Edward Cullen), others that have broken containment follow a familiar “Mary Sue” formula.
Take After, which began as a viral One Direction fanfiction published on Wattpad, and was eventually released as a 2014 novel by an imprint of Simon & Schuster, before being adapted into a 2019 film by the same name. After follows a classic “Mary Sue” format, with its protagonist, “Tessa Young,” falling for “Hardin Scott,” a thin stand-in for Harry Styles. Like many fanfics, After refashions its source material—the boys of 1D—into a new context, specifically the charged world of a college campus. These fanfics allow its readers to project even further onto the personas of the bands they love, a form of extensive make-believe with characters universally famous enough that any young girl in the world can engage with their plotlines.
Then there’s Robinne Lee’s The Idea of You, in which a middle-aged art gallery owner, “Solene Marchand,” has a covert affair with a 20-year-old boy band singer named “Hayes Campbell.” The book was later adapted into a film starring Anne Hathaway. Though Lee denies that the book was explicitly written as fanfiction (“When I'm writing for Hayes, I'm not picturing Harry Styles”), she admits that Campbell was based on the One Direction frontman. Here, as we see again and again in the world of fanfiction, the narrative plays into a specific vision of female fantasy: the concept of being recognized, and even sought out, as a sexual being beyond the prime of your youth.
So how does Heated Rivalry fit into this? It’s a wonderfully American amalgamation of fanfiction history: a repurposing of the bond between hockey teammates into one of romantic desire, starring two men who could reasonably be called “metrosexual” in appearance. It’s a live-action boy love and an on-screen wish fulfillment that began with Kirk and Spock half a century ago. In slash fiction, women see themselves as fully realized sexual beings through the lens of male characters. And until someone can write the next Mulder and Scully, that might be the best sexual tension we’re going to get.