Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Direct Link: https://youtu.be/UmKf8smvGsA

I did several towing tests in the Silverado! How far can it go with different types of trailer? How much does it cost to fuel? Does the efficiency of the tow vehicle matter, or is it all about the trailer? Why does answer have a 'w' in it? Answers to all but one of those questions are in this video!

Files

The Truth About Electric Towing

Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/agingwheels Merchandise: https://crowdmade.com/collections/agingwheels Silverado EV Charging: https://evchargingstations.com/chargingnews/2024-chevrolet-silverado-ev-rst-dc-fast-charging-analysis-0-100/

Comments

Rich Jeanes

Haven't watched this yet, and only got part way through the original, but I can't say I had any issues with how you presented the numbers. I will point out that there were at least a couple times when what you said didn't match your graphics, though.

Aging Wheels

Yeah, the mismatch was just misremembering of lines

Jamie ✨

thank u for the science 🙏

Raz

FWIW I think you did an excellent job with the numbers. I didn't see the 1st version, but the second version is clear and easy to follow. I appreciate that you present the hypothesis and then back it up with data. You made me understand that I was wrong about some of my understanding of EVs. BTW, My commute is uphill one direction and thus downhill the other. I'm always shocked by how much more energy I spend one direction vs the other. Does my downhill drive recoup (via regen) the energy I lost going uphill? Do ICE cars have the same issue?

thedeafguitarist

When you already have your sunday evening scotch standing next to you and Robert posts a new video. Good times.

John Jenson

This is the sweet spot for me Robert annoyed and confused by things (the DRL thing is bizarre) but not to the point where he’s defeated by it.

Aging Wheels

Yet more things I want to test! This could turn into a thing if I'm not careful

David Dellsperger

wait, a US Gallon is different from a UK Gallon? which one is "true" imperial?

The Traveling Bracioles

Would love to see you test how much charge you could get with a 3000W sine wave inverter generator with a gallon of fuel, to show it as an option for those with range anxiety going to remote places with their EV. Also, how much charge you could get from using solar panels while out camping.

Aging Wheels

I can already tell you the answer to this using math. Those 3000w generators typically only have 120v, which would limit them to 1200W for car charging. And that's essentially worthless unless you have tons of time. It would take 70 hours to fully charge a 70kWh battery pack from 1200W. And the solar charging will be even more limited unless you're carrying a simply enormous amount of solar panels with you and a 240v inverter

BrandEver

I really want to see a video like this but at LOWER SPEEDS. It would be interesting to see the same runs done at 65mph and 55mph, and to see whether there is enough of a range increase to make slower driving worth it when towing.

BrandEver

You will definitely regain some energy going downhill but not all of it back, as regen is not 100% efficient. If you were to haul a heavy load from work and drop it off at home every day, then maybe lol. Some electric mining trucks never need to be plugged in because they drive to the top of a hill empty, load up, and are able to fully charge from the increased regen taking the load down the hill.

Aging Wheels

I did everything at 75 because I would nothing but complaints that I wasn't driving at "real speeds" if I didn't. And also I never 65 myself. I don't know about towing, but I did do a loop in the Silverado (sans trailer) at 65mph and got almost 2.3mi/kWh

BrandEver

I'm not saying you shouldn't have done 75mph, it's important data and people would definitely complain if you didn't. But it would be interesting to see the efficiency differences for each speed, and whether or not it ever makes sense time-wise to ever drive at a lower speed vs charging time.

Aging Wheels

Oh, I see what you're saying. That's a very good question. I don't even know how I would math that out

DrumBrakes

I've just made the same comment on Youtube, before spotting this one. I've churned through some numbers. Driving at a steady 75mph for 200 miles (1.86mi/kWh) will take 107.5 kWh and 2.67 hours. Charging 107.5 kWh at a steady 100kW would take 1.07 hours. Total Time 3.74 hours. EDIT - Just seen Roberts mention of getting 2.3 at 65, so adjusting to use those numbers! Driving at a steady 65 for 200 miles at 2.3 mi/kWh would be 87 kWh and 3.08h of driving, followed by 0.87h of charging. Total time 3.95 hours. So driving faster IS faster, but not as much as you might think. If you stop at a 50kWh charger (we have lots of those here in rural Scotland, because they were installed in the days when that was considered fast. ) 75mph = 4.817 hours 65mph = 4.816 hours So, those times get closer with a slower charger and you'll get full benefit from driving fast with a faster charger But the extra drag from a trailer with a wooden sail on it probably give so much difference to consumption that it you would get a faster journey if you drive at a slower speed, particularly if you can reduce the number of times you stop to charge and all the extra time required to leave the highway and hookup to the charger etc.

Kristian Høy Horsberg

The imperial gallon is the one used in the British empire, and equals 4.54609 liters. The US use the United States customary units, not imperial units, where a gallon equals 3.785411784 litres or about 0.83 imperial gallons.

HenchmanHenk

That regen test was surprising. I can explain most of the other results but not that one (yet)

Honorary Octopus

More mass, more effort to stop, more regeneration would be my idiots guess.

Guardian Lion

Bravo! Easily one of your best videos. It puts a great many things into perspective. And I agree with BrandEver; if you had time, I'd like to see numbers for additional runs at lower speeds to see how the efficiency changes.

HenchmanHenk

Well, yes, but more importantly, no. Because equal energy needed to be spent in getting that extra mass up to speed, and this measurement was about total energy spend, so in a roundabout way it measured the efficiency of regeneration, minus rolling resistance and drag. Drag would have been roughly equal, rolling resistance would be a bit more given that is it equal to the product of the rolling resistance coefficient and mass. Same car same tire same road so Crr is constant (again, roughly, tire deformation is a thing), but mass was higher so rolling resistance should have been higher. The mass component in acceleration indeed works in both ways, so that should cancel out, but rolling resistance is always in opposition, so is additive. What's left is an electric effect. I'm not entirely sure what motor is in the Silverado, on what kind of switching elements are used. It might well be that different switching elements are used depending on what kind of load is demanded. Given that energy usage during acceleration was indeed higher, it may have been switching between different control modes. The control mode during acceleration was probably the same given that it was floored in both cases, but during regen the added mass may have given it the opportunity to stay in a more efficient regime for longer. Curiously, the effect was rather substantial. This is all assuming we can trust the readout, and while Robert gave it a fair shake given the tools at hand, the test did have some issues.

Adam Wishneusky

I didn’t see the original but sadly the new one is too many numbers for me. I can’t process them the speed you go and pausing to try to compare each set was kind of annoying 😕