Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello Patreons, This video is a bit of a strang thing, and in addition to giving you a preview, I'd just like to double check my thoughts about charging for it. It isn't a main video, it's more like a vlog and correction video. My feeling is that since it's the second video in the month, having it as a paid post is OK as the half of people who choose to support one video a month won't be changed, and only those who want to encorage more content will. And if anyone is unhappy, Patreon makes it very easy to withdraw a payment or change back to one video a month, but I'd really appreciate any feedback once you've watched this thing, whatever it is.  

Files

Re: The Trouble With The Electoral College – Cities, Metro Areas, Elections and The United States

The Trouble with The Electoral College: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7wC42HgLA4k How the Electoral College Works: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OUS9mM8Xbbw This vlog is a bit of a mess, but as the saying goes: "I would have written a shorter letter if I had more time." I needed to make this and upload this so I could stop thinking about it for now. Some day I will re-do "The Trouble With The Electoral College" video, but for now this is my mini update on why the Electoral College is a friend to no one. And in case you wondering, this is my official position as for as the elections of individuals goes, now and forever: https://twitter.com/cgpgrey/status/796246936072261634 P.S. Way to go, Maine! http://www.boston.com/news/politics/2016/11/10/maine-became-the-first-state-in-the-country-to-pass-ranked-choice-voting :: Sigh :: Illinois is colored wrong on the map.

Comments

K-Wings

I don't have a problem with two videos. Feel free to charge me twice. It is an important update/discussion.

K-Wings

and you speeled strange wrong in the first sentence.

Roy Eltham

Please, pretty please, upload this. This needs to be heard by as many people as possible. I am happy to pay for more videos from you. I just changed my setting to allow 2 videos a month. Let me know if it needs to be more.

Linden Hilson

I am very happy to pay for this, as someone who covers up to 2 videos per month. It adds new information AND is topical. This is the exactly the sort of content I want to support!

Oscar

CGP Grey, as many people here I'm completely ok with multiple videos per month as long as you keep with the quality that makes you stand above the rest.

TPRJones

I support this video and payment thereof.

Andrew O.

I've spent too many years watching your vids and not paying a cent, with adblock on (SHAME!!), so this vid is actually the one that motivated me to join Patreon to support. I definitely support the payment on this vid! :)

David W (d20dave) (d_dave)

Given the quality of your videos, even the most inconsequential or unusual one feels like Christmas morning. Charge away.

Ben Wilcox

I normally like your videos for their clarity, but to be honest, this one confused me. I think the problem is that I don't understand the argument you are pushing back against. Is it that people who like the electoral college think it protects a rural minority against an urban majority, or is it that the president should win a majority of states, because...that would be good, somehow? Because I don't understand the arguments you are countering, I think I'm not really following the points you are making. I understand the bit at the end, about how the electoral college is dangerous because the electors can just ignore the votes and do whatever they want, but it seems very tangential to the first half of the video. As for the charging thing, I don't mind.

Preston

I thought it was very good and am happy to pay for it. You might not want to start the video with a discussion of why you were wrong to use city v metro areas in a previous video. Some might think this whole video is a mere correction and skip it, when it does have interesting new thoughts. I just have an unfleshed out thought about the electoral college. Does it work as a balance between electing a president from the people and from the states by weighting rural states slightly higher than they would otherwise be.

Moti Lieberman

Yeah, it's fine to pay for this! It's enough of a thing in its own right. ^_^

Eric Hula

I'm ok with charging for this one. I need to go back and rewatch the original.

Travis Neely

Agree with others that yes, go ahead and charge, although I have not been able to get it to play (likely due to my own lack of technical knowledge). Am very interested in watching this, esp. after that most disappointing election.

Charles Yocum

Do it. I even promise that I won't get used to you churning out videos on current events in 3 days' time.

Tom Boland

I pay per video. No problem. Still averaging about one per month for the calendar year, so it all comes out in the wash. Two this month, none in some others. I am interested in more CGP Grey videos. If they start stacking up (a good thing), I might consider going to a per month pledge of the same net amount, just to even it out for my billing.

Bob Kunz

I am a conservative, so i kinda benefited from the election I guess(?) though I didn't vote for Trump. I don't really object to the electoral college either (or Pennies for that matter, they are perfectly fine). But it doens't matter, I support you and your work and love your videos--even when I disagree with them. So charge away!

Kristy

I pay per video, and if that means more videos it's worth every penny. I just saw your 22-sec re-edit. PLEASE charge for it. It was a 22 -second distraction from beating my head against the desk.

Phil Agosti

First, I read somewhere that some of the states electoral voters a sworn to follow the will of their states popular vote. Is this an honorary sort of promise or a legally binding one? Second, I appreciate that you put out these kinds of videos. Your occasional social commentary reaches a sizable crowd and I personally think I benefit from hearing different perspectives so I'm glad to have a robot to listen to ;) for real though, this stuff is good...

Jesse Tomlinson

Charge - this is a good video that I will share all over place like i normally do.

Todd Forsyth

I'm not ruling out that you should not charge for re: videos... But not this one in particular. But I'm not upset about being charged for this one, as it still had meat on the bones if that makes sense. It was a good enough informative video, but not the kind of content exactly that made me become a patron. Thanks for asking!

Jesse Tomlinson

another thought - i do not remember what the argument was from your 2011 video. you dive right into the details of why you were wrong about using something something........maybe a refresher or a little more context before getting into the details. the argument isn't fresh in our minds. the 2nd half of that video is excellent.

Jeffrey J Johnson

I am good with paying for this one but I am at a lower tier as well

Jeb Rach

I say charge. I will admit that if it becomes more frequent/more "vloggy" I'd probably drop down a level, but I still think this is worth charging for.

Heretofore

Charge it. You're not going to saturate the market for your videos any time soon.

laurens nieuwendijk

Grey, we love your videos! The more the merrier! When I watch a new one, i can't wait for the next! I'll be happy to pay twice this month, and next month, and on on on..! Honestly, i think my limit would be around 4 (per month) for what i pay now. But if you would make more, i'd be happy to at least pay the ad block absolution for every video plus what i do now (limited to 4 a month)! Keep on making them, I hope that patreon keeps enabling you to keep creating! And btw, i have great respect for how honest you've been about your mistakes in your past videos. I can't say i see them all as mistakes, but i love that you reflect and share your findings with your community. It supports self awareness, something the world desperately needs right now.

Joshua Schneider

I enjoyed this video as I've enjoyed all your election videos. They are informative and well constructed. One thing I differ on is the intention of the electoral college. It has plenty of problems, but its main flaw you point out, that it can override the popular vote, is exactly the point. I'm not saying that's a good thing, necessarily, but it fits with the overall theme of checks and balances within the government. Everything can be overridden. The House can refuse to pass the Senate's bills and vice versa, the President can veto, the Congress can override the veto, the Supreme Court can strike down laws even when they're passed (okay, this isn't in the Constitution, but I'm counting it anyway.) Everything is designed to prevent power from concentrating or running amok, including the citizenry as a whole, which is essentially treated as another branch of government which much has a check against its power. You make strong arguments about the disadvantages of having the electoral college, but you should present a more honest defense of why it was created in the first place. All that being said, I enjoy and admire your work.

Adam Berkan

I don't think it's a coincidence the number of electoral college voters is the same as the number of congressmen and senators... 200 years ago getting to Washington was a long painful process, and each state already had a few representatives there. Just let them vote! It'd be awkward to not let all of them vote, so we'll give each state C +S votes. Sure we'll leave up to the states to maybe pick the same number of electors some other way, but especially for far away states this will work great.

Russell Dunk

Go ahead with charge for this as well. Making corrections and expanding the argument you made in the original video doesn't somehow make this video "invalid." This is also very timely and I have always enjoyed the few videos that you have made that had a quick enough production cycle to be about current events.

Ben Wagner

I don't mind paying. I would like to get rid of first past the post voting in the US, which would allay significant fears about election results. The US from the beginning has tried to balance big vs small states interests, and avoid the tyranny of the majority. Although we have strayed from the founding, the individual states were supposed to be the primary power holders, not the national government (hence 10th amendment). The Constitution is deliberately difficult to change, and if we get rid of the electoral college we must be careful about what we put in its place, and what unintended consequences could arise. Strict popular vote is not a good idea in my opinion, because of the very valid "2 wolves and a sheep deciding what's for dinner" argument against pure Democracy.

Andreas Junghanns

Great stuff worth paying for, please keep it coming!

Andrew Berg

Yep, this is good stuff. And I agree, we need to have an adult conversation about how our system works, and (cautiously) replace it with something that produces results more reflective of the range of the public's views.

Zephram Harrison

Thanks for the preview. I'd like to pay CGPGrey another dollar, because his videos are so informative and logical. If he includes the Patreon "extra bill" notice / withdraw payment in the video or doobly doo, as well, then I think he will have all the bases covered. The video does deserve a follow-up, but I think it deserves a fourth video even more, to encourage the discussion of better alternatives to the electoral college. CONTENT: That graph showing the 50% of population in a small number of counties was great. Also, the distinction between cities and city limits was worth mentioning. He mentioned this as a reply vlog, but honestly, if it was released later, with more content, I think his viewers would be more satisfied. The US election (at least, the November one) and the reaction is mostly over, so there are few time-sensitive reasons to post the video ASAP. Can CGPGrey keep in the original music from the first three videos? It was great! Consider the other side (devil's advocate): -You discussed population distribution and where candidates visit, but I am more worried about budgetary spending. -Mentioning why democratic electoral systems using direct majority could hurt rural areas (I think this is one reason why the electoral college was originally made) Example: Imagine 5 counties by percent of population. These counties form a local government. County A: 49% city County B: 20% suburban County B: 15% suburban County C: 6% rural County D: 5% rural County E: 5% rural County A, B, and C have a strong majority. Depending on the branch of government and the office, if these three counties work together, and ignore the other counties, then the unfairness to the minorities is still possible. Let me give an example. If the local government spends 84% of its operational budget on these three counties, then everything's fair, right? However, if a department in its executive branch spends 100% of its budget, its choice of office locations, or its work to specifically benefit only its constituents, and the issues related to 84% of the population, this is unfair. For one day, this type of misallocation is immaterial, but over decades, these practices can lead to unfairly neglected, regionally-based minorities. Throughout history, there has been suffering and rebellions by unfairly neglected, regionally-based groups. Sure, a smaller population doesn't need as much funds, but they still deserve their 16% of the pot. Positive spin (musice helps with this, too!): Unfairness to a particular group is inevitable in a democracy, but what's the most fair voting system? CPGGrey could consider offering a fourth video proposing an alternative system that can still protect minorities from majorities, while giving the majority the power they deserve. Consider proposing better solutions, like: -study what Nebraska and Maine do, instead of winner-takes-all, rather than just mention it (if everyone does it, this way, he could argue why it would be a better system) -forward link to his single transferable vote / alternative voting videos at the end of this video

Crescentia

No problems paying for it. Thanks for checking and thanks for posting!

Ken Blackman

If it was an under one minute correction I'd have some qualms, but this is a nearly 5 minute video. I think you should charge for it. We have ways of limiting our spend rate on you if we so choose. But thanks for asking.

Sam Rossetti

Charge for it : this is definitely worth it (…as usual)

Bjorn

I think you should charge for it! Interesting and informative!

Jesso Ossej

I would be in favor of charging for it. It feel like a full video.

Kyle Cronin

I'd be a bit annoyed to pay for the 21-second "[UPDATED VERSION!] The Trouble With The Electoral College", but "Re: The Trouble With The Electoral College – Cities, Metro Areas and The United States" is a legit video and worth paying for.

CanIcallYouKate

Very happy to pay for this indeed. It's an excellent addition to the previous on this topic. I've been watching your vids for years and only recently found out about becoming a patron. I admire your ability to break down complicated issues in a didactically elegant and entertaining way. I've been sharing your vids in an effort to educate others and the response was wonderful and positive. Thank you for your dedication and your wonderful work! Looking forward to watching and paying for many more to come! On a general note (and I am not sure if this was intentional): your speaking speed is comparably slow in this one (and I think it's a good move). While I have no issue following your fast ones either, I know that combined with text/graphs/images appearing while you're talking at a higher speed can be overwhelming for some.

Brian Michalowski

Worth paying for. Once again you've found a topic where there's a lot of confusion and explained it extremely well.

White heron

Not a fan of this one. I find it actually less than helpful to point out flaws in a system without offering solutions. Clearly, you need to offer two. Although the popular vote is simple (majority wins). To support State power, however, you need to offer the best of the alternatives. Maybe in the third video on the topic.

DJ

Just switched myself **up** from 1 video max per month thanks to this video.

TC Safavi

You are one of my favourite content producers on youtube as is, and I'm always sad that you're not as prolific as many of my second-favourites. I've always gladly supported them on patreon and I'm thrilled for the opportunity to support you. I've always worked for tips (fine arts busking or American service industry) so the economic logic of "you provided a thing I like so I threw money in your jar" (while there are many arguments about it in the grand scheme) is extremely natural to me. Solid choice. Keep sharing your thoughts, I like how you communicate them in both content and entertainment value. I'll keep tipping.