Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank everyone who supports the channel.  Your patronage is the only reason the team can make these videos without relying on sponsorships.

Given increasing uncertainty on YouTube with shorts, plus in the comments the number of scams and bots that flood in, I'm trying an experiment:

New privilege for all 🐝 Bonnie Bees 🐝:

As the verified humans that you are, you alone will be able to post in the comment sections of the videos.

Unfortunately, there is no way to just approve everyone at once.  Instead, there's a three step process:

1. If you haven't already, sign up

2. Then leave a comment on the most recent video.

3. Send a message through Patreon with your YouTube name and the comment.

Then you be approved as a commenter -- afterward all your comments will be automatically approved.

I'm sorry that this is a bit annoying, and it will take a long and tedious time to get through everyone, so please be patient.   But the hope is this will get rid of all the bot/scam comments while also raising the visibility in the comments of all the people who help make the videos happen.

💚 🐝 💚

Comments

Joseph

You tube name jckatz411

The Dragonlord

Youtube name The Dragonlord comment: To me nothing can beat the "Lazer eyes kiwi" flag that could have made it on the New Zealand flag.

Demonac

@Demonac on youtube I wasn't going to bother, but then watching the latest video made me want to comment =P

Mystical Origins

YouTube name mystical origins @MysticalOriginz “commenting as an official Bonnie bee”

DasGanon

YouTube name "Das Ganon" comment on the comment video is "Ohhhh fun, moderation!"

Burt Clothier

bgclo on the YouTubez -- Also: YouTube shorts suck.

DebBoi

Youtube stuffs DebBoi @debboi3377 Also I loved that flags video, even if you said my home state, Connecticut, weirdly lol

Andrew Denton

Hello; FerretPirate here. (Arrr) Also FerretPirate on YouTube, as it happens.

Yorie1234

I have placed a comment with the YouTube account Yorie1234

Rei

I've placed a comment in the one about spam bots. My account is @lindsaygoto

lancedragons

Handle: @lancedragons, comment: "Spotted the Wisconsin cheese flag at 0:42! Nice hint of the new state flag tier list"

Will

Handle: @wj12p - commented on your pinned comment

Thomas Dalton

YouTube name is Thomas Dalton/thomasdalton1508

Glenn Johnson

You Tube Name: @realspacemodels Comment: I am proud to bee in the exclusive club that is the Bonnie Bees in support of some of the best videos on You Tube.

Paul Meyer

YouTube Name: Rowskey (@MrRowskey) Comment: "Wow, this is about the most hilarious thing I have ever seen!"

Sonia Deepak

Youtube Name: Sonia Deepak (@soniadeepak339) Comment: "Lol Ohio and her cape."

Peiji Xu

YouTube Name: Jgrre (@Jgrrr2558). Comment:"The one with a buffalo, yes you, Wyoming, that emblem is off center, and I hate that with a passion. You are now my least favourite state :)"

Nate Wilson

It seems like a developer could create an application to use APIs for YT and Patreon to automate the approval of commenters, to minimize admin overhead

Qui Le

YouTube name: Qui Le, comment is I promise I'm not a bot grey

Benjamin Moore

YouTube name: Benjamin Moore, comment about the George seal

Tyler Wolfe

Omg everyone, he said not to comment on this post but to send a message directly lol

Sander Mintjes

Youtube name: @cottilion I declare i’m 33% human, 33% bee, 33% beekeeper.

Qplayer

Youtube name: Xplayer007 Comment on "An Experiment With YouTube Comments…" Not sure if I'll ever use this privilege but I'll keep the door open just in case.

Ryan Marino

Youtube name: Yeffaros @yeffaros8419 comment on "An Experiment With YouTube Comments" It'll be weird to see comments without bots for once.

Conner Pierce

Youtube name: renic1000000 (@Renic1000000) Comment: " Bonnie bee here " Video: The Coolest ''''Country''''' Flag You Need To Know

Brent Hailpern

YouTube name: Brent Hailpern (@N2CJN) Comment: "Joined as Bonnie Bee today!" Video: "An experiment with youtube comments"

Alexa

Hey Grey, here from the State Flag video, commented as "Erraticonteuse"

Wesley Foxx

Commented on the Experiment with Comments video, Wesley Foxx @Foxpawed

Colin Wells

YouTube Name: Mouser1991 Comment: Denmark's flag still weirds me out.

Lisa Witzel

YouTube name: Lisa Witzel Comment: "I remember 3D Atlas!" Video: The coolest country flag you know.

Just Me

Guys it says "don't comment on this post" :)

Azerik

I resent needing to pay to comment. I understand the concern but this does a few things: it assumes your audience can't figure out what a bot comment looks like, and it stops your audience from engaging with your content without directly paying you to do so. People who are your patrons already pay to be heard in two extra spaces (here on Patreon and on your Discord server), so rather than giving your patrons something new, you're mostly just taking something away from everyone else under the guise of protecting them from themselves. I also doubt restricting comments is going to be good for your engagement metrics. (I also find the experiment odd given your stance on the financially unstable joining your Patreon. I can afford to be a Bonnie bee right now for example, but my financial situation is not set in stone, and frequently changes, and I am not a frequenter of Reddit).

Beth's Art

I commented on the 'experiment with comments' vid, username @unicornfoal, with the comment "I don't comment often, but just in case I ever want to...".

Michelle Hao

I fear putting the comments section behind barriers of entry that require you to already love and support CGP Grey (or at least care about enough to click onto a subreddit) is going to come at the huge cost of creating artificial environments where you will no longer recieve feedback from more casual viewers or people who dislike your content but have something productive to say about it. To me this is ripe grounds for creating an echo chamber of false positivity- fundamentally altering the function of the comments section as a whole into something way less engaging and isn't worth it just to get rid of scambots or sexbots.

Michelle Hao

Also the way you frame this pivot in your Patreon post focuses more on gaining more monetary support as the primary goal with the sexbot/chatbot deterrent almost as secondary. But it is the opposite for the Youtube video itself. I understand and would be happy to support your videos as you are one of my favorite Youtubers, but not empasizing the obvious monetary gains and even framing it as a better way to get rid of sexbots and chatbots (especially given my critisms with the experiment) feels irresponsible at best and fraudulant at worst.

Dave Land

If Patreon allows it, might I suggest adding “Can comment on YouTube videos” to the Bonnie Bee Brigade perks list? Yes, I might. In fact, I'm pretty sure I just did.

Stashue

Commenting for the comments!

Eli

YouTube: Eli Stettner

Jessica hawkins

Two copyright strikes against VTH’s channel is disgusting behavior by Grey. VloggingThroughHistory is a small channel run by a highschool history teacher. Chris (VTH) isn’t a bottom feeding reactor - he creates his own content in addition to adding his own deep historical analysis and commentary to other creator’s videos. He’s “reaction” to one of your older videos was my first introduction to your content and the reason for me subscribing to your channel and joining the Patreon. It was YOUR fans who begged him to react to your video in the first place, you authoritarian dolt. His students watch his channel. The guy is practically a saint and it’s sickening to watch you bully a small channel that’s beloved in the YT history community. Even much larger channels than yours love having him react to their content and often times comment their support directly. Instead of pitching a fit, you could’ve reached out to him and asked him not to react to your content. He would’ve pulled it immediately and apologized. He’s just a history teacher who sometimes uses other people’s content to serve as a video textbook for his history lesson.

Philip Charles

@pointless7453 On the new zip code video "Make a Switzerland postcode Video!"