Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey folks!

I think I need to have a quick chat with you about some of the comments I've been getting as we've reached the climax of Volume 4.

What spurred me to write this particular post was a comment expressing frustration at the protagonists being "totally helpless," seemingly because the chapter ended with the antagonist telling them they were totally helpless.

Guys—you don't need to believe the bad guy when they say that. They're the bad guy.

I understand that frustration around cliffhangers can be tough to deal with, especially in serial storytelling where you can't go right to the next chapter and see what happens next. But the nature of storytelling requires that characters experience setbacks in order for their triumphs to be more exciting. It seems like the serialized nature of the story is giving some people strife. On tension-building chapters, I get pages of comments complaining about powerlessness or perceived plot holes that will be covered in future chapters, and then during chapters where the protagonists successfully triumph and make progress, those commenters return to silence, only to resurface during the next obstacle.

When these comments show up, they read to me as a lack of trust, and--at the risk of sounding conceited--I feel like I've given you reason to trust me.

I am happy to engage with critique of the story at a macroscopic level, but this is a recurring complaint that I flat-out disagree with. I have read MANY serialized stories that seem to give into the complaints their serial-experiencing audience furnishes, and while it may provide more satisfaction on a per-update basis, it hugely weakens them in the long accounting. Meaningful tension cannot be built; effective or long-term antagonists cannot be set up. It's one of my storytelling pet peeves to encounter a narrative where the protagonists cannot fail without backlash. I would go so far as to say it is my number one problem with serialized fiction. I used to never understand why authors would tell their stories like this, with the trajectory only ever up-up-up. Now I'm getting the same kind of comments and I see that part of it is peer pressure.

So here's the thing, gang, and I'm saying this out of love and the desire to give you the best story I can:

I cannot tell a story where the problems are resolved within the same chapter they're introduced. Stories need peril. They need to dip before they rise. Our heroes are not going to look cool without meaningful, scary danger to be cool against.

All I can request is that, before you post a comment of this nature, you take a beat, reexamine the flow of the story in its actual flow, and not the chopped-up flow in which you're perceiving it, and give me some time to land the arc that I am writing.

If experiencing this story on a per-update basis is giving you enough strife that you're making these complaints every time, you are harming your overall experience of the novel. I suggest you step away from it and read it once all the chapters are out. If you're monthly and upon reading this you decide that this is not the Patreon for you, DM me and I will refund you the latest month you paid.

Comments

Chikkane

That's right you tell them Duke!

The Joy of Reading

Huge agree. It should be common sense to trust your favorite Authors to have a satisfying resolution in mind. We should know Dukerino well enough by now to understand that their cliff hangers are meant to incite curiosity, fan theories, and the good stress of worrying about our protagonists... not end flat out end the story bc the protagonists are helpless since the villain said so.

Bas van Lissum

Yea i meant to comment on this on the previous chapter, but the cliffhangers are fine. Especially considering your frequent update pace, i follow another author on patreon who updates every 7-10 days and can sometimes hit wayy harsher on the cliffhangers. Its part of the thrill of reading. Keep at it the way you go now Duke.

Laurent Jerry

Hey, you do as much suspence and twist and whatnot as you want. Its your story. As long as the story does not blattantly contradicts itself or does not dwindle in mindless fan service just to keep it going, you got my full admiration and support. The whole daemon arc is completely freaking awesome, please dont sweat it for a stupid comment. If we believe Grant&Kora are fucked, it means its great writing, because we know they not really gonna get obliterated, and yet we get kept on our toes. Means you did a good job

Doodlyboy15

I've heard some other internet related people opine on the internet/twitter/tiktok giving people the impression that they need to share every thought that goes through their head or every experience they have. I originally thought that the comments were a symptom of that and may still be to some degree. However, after reading your post I think you explanation also has a good point. I think serialized content, especially on a platform that allows for that interaction, is very different from reading an entire book. Thanks for the post, don't let the ctiritques sway your style, I've been enjoying it! I do really like you point about not believing the evil guys, made me chuckle.

alejandrox

Thank you for clarifying your situation. Personally, I have no problems with how you are handling the story. What I simply want is... 30 more chapters, another 5 volumes, and for you to prepare a trilogy of books with 10 volumes each, with more than 30 chapters in each volume, and ALL OF THAT IN 24 HOURS.... THAT IS WHAT I LIKE ABOUT YOUR NOVEL AND WHAT I HOPE FOR IN THE FUTURE..... GOD IF YOU WANT IT AND THAT IS WHAT YOU WANT.

Stirling

I'm going to be honest, whenever I read comments on your posts, I've come to realize people on patron seem to have the idea that they have a say so in how the story goes, it's insane, keep writing, your words, those are what I'm here for.

Ripley Riley

TLDR - let Duke cook I've been reflecting on the cliffhanger issue because I recently found myself irritated by it. Let's pretend there are two broad types of serialized story updates for a moment: tension building and non-tension building. In PotV there can be a long series of tension building updates, ratcheting up the danger with each post. Whereas in other stories there might only be an update or two that builds suspense before releasing it. Neither method is wrong; they're just different approaches to the tension-release cycle. I think the frustration with the cliffhanger issue comes from not recognizing that the resolution WILL come, it just might take a little longer than other stories. What I have been thinking about after today's update is not cliffhangers, it's main character death. I'm not the least bit worried about Sykora or Grant "Relaxed Fit" Hyde - Grant's fit is simply too relaxed for him to die - but we are reaching a point in many arcs where a named supporting character will die. That's got me nervous for the supporting cast.

Gato

I’m sorry that you have had to make a post like this. Personally, I enjoy when the main character receives setbacks, conflict, or has flaws. It highlights that they are indeed people rather than superhuman. In fact, I would love to see you play them out a bit longer. Mentioning Grant being more reluctant to take off his protection googles, etc. One suggestion I do have though is implementing some non evil antagonists/opposing characters. Most of the antagonists so far have been able to be shot and no one bats an eye. What about some characters on the Black Pike that don’t like Grant due to his rapid rise in power or are in general more xenophobic? I think the union workers were a great example. They weren’t friendly to the Black Pike, but weren’t terrible people. Maybe just some morally gray problems without a perfect solution where Grant can’t give Sykora a perfect answer on whether they are doing the morally/ethically correct thing.

Dukerino

Thank you for the comment! That's a great idea and in fact we're gonna see some stuff like this in volume 5. In general, though, I consider the entire empire kinda non-evil antagonists. In Volume 3 especially, Sykora was sort of the antagonist, since she was preparing to blast Taiqan to rubble. I totally agree that kind of antagonist is really cool and am for sure going to explore it more.

E_Traveler

Yup. Yup. I agree. Yes!

Wandering Scribe

Well said, Duke. Cliffhangers are a good pain, if it didn’t sting that I’m not getting 10,000 more words once I reach the end of a chapter is the book even good? This situation is reminding me of an another content creator putting together a great treatise on game design. In essence he said that public input is great to a point, but people are incredibly prone to ruining their own experience because of things they THINK they want.

disarmingsmile

You're doing great work! Every new chapter is a pleasure, no cliffhanger has been truly painful ad of yet lmao

Joe ?

You've earned the trust for tense cliffhangers. Those people must have short memories because this wasn't the first one.

Chris

If mine was one of the comments that this was meant to addess... honestly I think I was expressing the feelings I think you were trying to evoke from the chapters. And in my own defense... it has played out pretty much like I said I thought it would in my comment. Sorry if it came across as too negative. I feel that the cliffhangers are almost required in a serial story of this nature, in a fully written novel it just pushes the reader not to stop at that chapter. It's a good thing. Please dont take my comment as a plea for you to not put them in. I do think that the MCs have legitimate grievances that they should forcefully express once this is through (with the people who put them on this path). The lack of information directly lead to the death of a void princess. I'm sure said people will say something along the lines of the AI didn't have YOUR kill phrase, thats why you were the one to do it... but because they didn't know the nature of the threat it played out the way it did.

Dukerino

There is definitely a testy conversation to be had with the Empress, that's for sure

Zanna

You've got this!

Danielle W.

I was smart about it. After we discover grant was successfully drugged and flashed I decided to bank a few chapters before reading because I know how much grants helplessness in those chapters will rile me up and how much chapter to chapter cliffhangers will grind my gears so I don’t have to suffer from that very problem everyone is complaining about. I’m waiting for next positive falling action after a climax so I don’t drive myself crazy like I know I will if I cave now.

Lean

Serialized or not, in any story that utilizes mortal danger as a plot device, if there is no challenge to the main cast there is almost no point in writing the danger at all. These characters have flaws. Grant is vastly inexperienced in the more violent and borderline sociopathic side of the society he's basically been forced into living in. He was never a violent man to begin with. He has been winging it from the start and is almost hindered by his borderline obsessive empathy. Of course he's going to get taken down by trained killers when he doesn't even expect them to be around every corner (which, considering the people he and Sykora interact with, they pretty much are). Sykora is like the yin to Grant's yang. Her overconfidence borders narcissism. She was raised to be cruel and is emotionally and empathically challenged because of this. Her hubris is her downfall, so to speak. It's perfectly logical for her emotional state to fall apart as she starts to lose grip on controlling whatever situation she finds herself in. I genuinely don't understand how any person cannot see the logic behind how you've written out their disadvantages during their times of being in danger. It is perfectly reasonable to assume Grant could be used against the Black Pike and her crew due to his naivety and his inexperience. A couple of years of 'learning' cannot replace an entire lifetime of living in relative comfort and with significantly more relative 'freedom' and 'agency'. Critique is fine and all, and high tension arcs may not be everyone's cup of tea, but I've also been reading these comments and - while not all of them apply - a few of them really seem like they were made by someone who is just looking to read a romcom sci-fi where everything just magically works out for the main cast. Yeah, things *have* been working out for our favorite blue goblin aliens and country man turned prince, but they do so in a way that is logical to the world they exist in.

Dukerino

Coming back here after reading your comment, btw, to say that I appreciate the clarification here, but I think the original comment is kind of off-base when taking a look at the actual events of the story. The MCs are not struggling in a web without the power to affect anything, and they're not flailing to open levers of action. The MCs have been successfully fending off various attacks that have been coming in attempts to stop or stall their investigation, and using the information gained during those successful thwartings to narrow down and follow a trail of breadcrumbs to Chassak, where their hard-gained evidence forced their opponents into premature action that they have now parried. At no point have they been powerless, and I'm really not sure where that interpretation comes from. Their investigation has forced their enemies into reactivity, and that reactivity caused vulnerabilities or accidental disclosures our protagonists have repeatedly capitalized on.

Chris

Not powerless in general. Just they didn't know who/what the antagonists were. They didn't really work it out till this last chapter. So it seemed that their efforts weren't really finding purchase (flailing). Without knowing what the heck was going on they couldn't apply the power they had appropriately. Not really sure why niminoa didn't tell them stuff earlier... obviously kanri had just been nuked by the AI and who held it.

Dukerino

I take your point about Niminoa--I'll clear up her motivation during the edit and make it clearer that she has been sworn to secrecy by the Empress about the daemon. I still disagree that they were flailing. They didn't know who their enemy was because this arc is a whodunit, but there were no dead ends or setbacks they couldn't surmount, and there was never a point they were moving further away from the answer or unsure about what they had to do next (Sykora's little panic attack notwithstanding).

Chris

Yeah you are right... I guess I went a bit hyperbolic. They essentially had 40 minutes to figure it out before the big confrontation and with said antagonists sitting on essentially a self destruct button for their compromised ship though lol.

Chris

And we didn't know the kill phrase was a bluff until the confrontation. Sykora worked it out with the knowledge from Niminoa obv.

SesamePizza

I think a strong reaction to cliffhangers is a good sign (if not taken to far), it shows that people are invested into the story and characters. I actually read a bit on the history of cliffhangers because of this, apparently there were riots in the New York harbor back in 1841 when people were waiting for a ship carrying the latest sequel by Dickens. Think someone in the Discord already pointed out people getting upset about cliffhangers is as old as serialized fiction.

Vostok

Obviously, never a great idea to just ignore the audience - they are the customer base after all! But often, people don't know what they really want. If you wrote as these people asked you to, not only would you probably hate it, they probably would too! Flaws, challenges, and setbacks are critical for the story and character development, and this story without that would just end up as "chad thundercock and his hot wife dominate the known universe in record time" which gets very stale very fast.