Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

“Now we’ve been talking a lot today about the assistance programs we expect to provide to Earth when the annexation is complete.” Researcher Onkir polishes his anticomps and places them back over his face. The circle of Maekyonites are reflected in them, seated in an ersatz array of chairs, couches, beanbag seats, or cross-legged on the conversation room floor. “As always, you can discuss whatever you wish, but we’re especially interested in your reactions to that.”

A dark-haired British man whose name Grant still doesn’t know raises a heavy hand. “May I be excused?”

“You don’t have to participate,” Onkir says. “But we’d appreciate you sitting in if you’re able.”

“I’m not able.”

“You sick or something?” The Eqtoran guard at the exit is speaking Taiikari, but his reply displays on the translation pane on his chest, as well as the large cylindrical screen bank at the room’s center.

The man stands and straightens his shoulders. “Are you gonna handcuff me to my seat?”

The Eqtoran grunts bemusedly. “Do I have to?”

Onkir’s smile flags briefly. “All right. Randall, you can go back to your cabin. We’ll see you at lunch.”

The man does not reply. He attempts a shouldering-past of the Eqtoran, but he might as well have tried to shoulder past a minivan and it turns into a glowering shuffle out the door.

“Now, for everyone else.” The researcher’s smile catches its second wind. “What did you get from the session today?”

“What it says to me is that I’m not getting the whole truth.” Zhuyin says this in Mandarin; its translation flashes in English, Spanish, Taiikari, and Eqt. “If you can just land on Earth and declare it’s yours, what reason do you have to bribe us with these social programs?”

“What it says to me is socialism.” That’s Rita, a bank teller from Glendale. “And my grandparents lived under that. And it always falls apart. They—”

A flurried response:

“Fucking Americans and fucking socialism. Mate, it's monarchism.”

“Can we get back to—”

“They've got an empress, moron. How’s that socialism?”

“I don’t care about the name it’s given. It doesn’t matter. You people are always so obsessed with what to call it.”

“What’s you people?”

“You, them. Whoever can afford to fly planes above our heads. It’s spaceships or it’s planes. Sometimes they bring blankets, sometimes they bring bombs. Last time, your country—you’re American, yes? Last time you brought bombs. These little weird things bring blankets. I know to accept a blanket.”

“A smallpox blanket, more like.”

“Don’t sit back like you’ve just said something profound. That doesn’t mean anything.”

“Zhuyin had an interesting point, I thought—”

“How is that even an argument?”

“What do you mean, how? You think these things can actually be taken at their word? They even fucking look like demons. Look at them. Horns, tails. You know what they’re planning for us? Human experimentation. Sterility. You’ve all been eating their fuckin’ food, you’ve been letting them poke and prod you. Clueless.”

“You’ve been eating their food.”

“Well, I take it apart first.”

A middle-aged man, Gabriel Legrand, if Grant remembers right, pipes up at that. “If they want to poison or sterilize us, they will. If they want to blow our planet up they will. There’s no resistance to this.”

“So what, the only hope is collaboration?”

“No. That's not what I'm saying. I'm saying there is no hope. That's not human nature. We are violent, we are suspicious, we are greedy." Legrand emphasizes the words with the chop of his leathery hand into his palm. "How can we be expected to welcome the aliens? We can't even do that for each other. If the options are bow down or blow up, then we're done. This is game over. And maybe that's for the best. Maybe the galaxy's better off without humanity."

The rest of the room breaks out in a unison that sends a flurry of text across the translation pane.

"Absolutely not. Idiot."

"闭嘴,傻瓜."

"Shut yer fuckin' gob."

"Que le jodan a este tipo."

"Yeah, man, fuck outta here with that."

In a dimmer part of the conversation circle, Dylan leans from his easy chair, close enough to Xamika that his whisper’s picked up on her lapel mic and piped into the observation room. “Were you selecting for at least one dipshit per group, or was this guy a coincidence?”

She giggles behind her palm and gives his hand a light slap. “I can't comment on any guest like that.”

“But you laughed, though.”

She giggles again. “No, I didn’t. You didn’t hear that.”

In the dim observation room, surrounded by multiple camera angles, heart monitors, and live transcriptions, Grant watches the exchange and tries to excavate the brittle reaction in his stomach to it. How would it have been between him and Sykora if she’d known the whole time about his immunity? If they’d started as friends? How would it have turned out if they hadn’t kept his secret?

Terribly, surely. But here they are, anyway. Orbiting the worst case scenario.

Tap tap ta-tap tap.

Sykora's tail bops against his leg and pulls him out of his murk. The shave-and-a-haircut rhythm he taught her. Her face is still placidly on the feed, still the solemn monarch. But beneath the complex plaits in her night-dark hair, a blue sliver of horn is visible.

Her bare shoulder is so smooth and sinuous where it joins the soft downward sliver of her chest visible below her tunic’s armhole. A pinkish tinge at her neck as she realizes where he’s looking. She subtly tugs the hem of her uniform lower to show him more of herself.

Her collar is closed tight around her willowy neck.

“How much longer is this session, Jai?” Grant asks.

Researcher Jainema emerges for air from the ocean of paper notes she’s taking and pushes up the circular glasses on her nose. She looks up at him and there’s that little momentary catch he keeps seeing, or imagining he sees. The hesitation toward him he worked so hard to remove has come back, ever since they realized what he was, what all his people are.

“Thirty minutes, Majesty,” she says. “Then we break for lunch.”

“Has Edward said anything at this one yet?”

Jainema purses her lips. The turning of her tail swishes the silver sash hanging off her shoulder. “No, Majesty. Third session in a row he’s stayed quiet.”

“Okay.” Grant stands up. “When you’re done, I’d like to talk to him.”

He steps from the observation room. He pats his leg as he goes. Small and subtle. Here, girl. Sykora follows him.

When they turn down the hallway toward the spot they’ve been using, Grant picks his wife up and tucks her under his arm. The Princess’s tail wags madly.

Five minutes later, it’s wrapped around the crossbar of the shelf in the janitor’s closet, its sinuous muscle flexing, keeping its moaning owner anchored to the wall as he cums inside her.

Grant isn't sure how the switch got flipped, but something’s happened with him and Sykora. Her horns are out so often she’s started wearing her hair up to keep them hidden. They’ve always had a healthy appetite for each other but it's like their earliest days, when they’d only just discovered the joy of human/Taiikari sex and they were stealing into whatever empty chamber they could find aboard the Pike.

He notes as much to her as she wiggles her handprint-stamped ass back into her panties: “You’ve been frisky lately, huh?”

She looks over her shoulder, abashed. “It’s not too much, is it?”

“You kidding me?” He sits on the floor and kisses the back of her neck as he takes one of her braids, which is halfway unraveled from its use as a handlebar, and coaxes it the rest of the way straight. “Hold still while I do this back up for you.”

She lets out a little squeak as he pulls.

He chuckles. “We can’t do a round two yet, y’know. It’s lunch soon with the Maekyonites.”

She leans back against him. Her tail trails up his chest. “Back on the Pike, maybe?”

“Back on the pike.” He secures her braid back in place. “I’m not complaining. Not at all. I’m just curious.”

“I just—” Sykora sighs and shivers as he runs a knuckle up her spine. “I want to be there for you, I suppose. I want to help.” She turns around and shuffles into his arms. “I want to make sure you still love your life with me, the way you did before this began. I’ve gotten these stretch marks and I see how troubled you are about the compulsion thing and you have so much on your mind and we’re finally here at this moment of such consequence, and I…”

He loves her stretch marks, and she knows it, but he doesn’t interrupt. Just holds her.

“I just want to make sure that this is still what you want,” she whispers. “That I’m still what you want.”

He rests his head on her shoulder. “I’m fucking crazy about you, Batty,” he whispers, and cradles the back of her head. He rubs behind her ear and is rewarded by a vibrating purr out of his alien wife. “You’re the reason I’m ready to do this. You and Rory and Zee and Kiar.”

“I miss them,” she whispers, and it’s barely been a day without them, but he nods his agreement.

“We’ll be back soon. Just had to check in.” Grant gets to his feet and cracks the closet door. “Every dad wishes he could give his kids the world. I’m gonna get out there and actually do it.”

“Edward Dominguez.” Grant reads the name off Jai’s notes and connects it with the genial, balding man sitting across from him in the administrator’s office. “Can I call you Ed?”

“I’d prefer Edward, actually. Annoying as it is, I’ve never had the wherewithal to think of myself as an Ed.” Edward crosses his tweed-encased legs, the better to fit into the one-size-too-small chair on the other side of Grant’s desk. “Too dour, I guess.”

“Fair enough,” Grant says. “Tell me about yourself, Edward. What is it you do on Earth?”

“I write,” Edward says. “Or wrote, I guess. I worked in journalism for a while—local stuff, and then sports at the News-Gazette—and then I was an adjunct professor at Northwestern University. Then, about five years ago, that ended, and I’ve done a few different things. Apps, gigs, freelancing. The new economy, you know. I’d found a job at a warehouse when you picked me up; I imagine that’s probably over with. Now I’m told I’ll be rich, so that’s the whole resume, I imagine.”

“Not eager to go back to the pick-and-pack line?”

Edward chuckles good-naturedly and scratches his salt-and-pepper beard. “I think our hosts have maybe calibrated that wrong. You can’t exactly pay a guy 250 million and then expect them to badmouth you.”

“Tell Rita that.”

He chuckles again. “Fair point.”

“You don’t tend to share,” Grant says. “You were quiet in the session. I was always like that in big groups, but I always had a lot on the mind. I hope you’ll tell me what you think.”

“What do I think.” Edward steeples his fingers in front of his narrow, beaky nose. “I think enough people think like Rita and Gabriel think that it will present a challenge, certainly. But a civilization that can make the things I’ve seen, that can keep my feet on this floor in the middle of space in whatever miraculous way, surely has many ways to address those challenges. The degree to which the technology you’re introducing will change just about everyone’s lives, that’ll certainly cut down, too, on the number of Ritas you’ll get in the mix. I think there will be many of us—billions of us—quite ready to accede to the Imperial demand. And I think it will be a terrible shame.”

Grant’s stomach sinks at that conclusion. “Is there a way I can convince you otherwise?”

“Well, I guess I have a question,” Edward says. “The Empress. Does she have her own planet? Is there a Taiikari home world?”

“Yes.”

“Have you been?”

Grant nods.

“What's it like?”

Grant is quiet.

“I was expecting you'd say it's beautiful, it's opulent, it's, uh, I don't know. The silence is concerning.”

“It is beautiful and...” Grant rattles the cabinets on his limited English. “Opulent? What's that mean?”

“Rich and fancy.”

“Yes.”

“Okay,” Edward says, carefully. “So... it's an Empire, still. For all the high-minded stuff and for as cute as they are, it's still Empire in the human mode. You are the smiling mouth of the Imperial hose, sucking the resources of its subjects up into the homeland. Homeworld, in this case. You’re colonizing us.

“And despite all the benefits you’re bringing—the medicine, the infrastructure, the aqueducts and railroads, to use a historical metaphor. If I am to believe that a people will welcome their colonizers in peace, I need to see one time, ever, that this happened, in human history. One example. And I’m afraid I don’t. Even in those cases that a historian might argue it ended up benefitting the colonized, for whatever that’s worth. This has happened over and over again, and it never happened harmoniously once. Ever. Coexistant nonaggression, sometimes, for a while, but never for long. And nonaggression isn’t what the Taiikari are bringing.”

"I know it's hard to trust this," Grant says. "But our history is different from theirs. It's not something we can look back at Maekyon to understand." Earth. You meant to say Earth.

"I'm not denying that," Edward says. "I'm just saying that's what it is, right? A pyramid, and we are at the bottom. And I take your point that the Taiikari bottom looks a lot better.” He laughs quietly. “No pun intended. And for most of the people of Earth, it would be a better life. I can believe this. I can even believe that they believe they're doing this out of kindness. And what are the resource they're taking from Earth? In the main, it seems like they want to date us. Well, I'm sure many humans would be thrilled. I’d date a Taiikari.”

“I can highly recommend it.”

"And of course by ensuring a smooth transition you are saving many lives. Not only the lives that would be lost in resistance but the people who would otherwise die under the comparatively flawed rule of their fellow humans. Do I have your position right, more or less?"

Grant nods.

"But they are here to exploit us, Majesty.” Edward gives Grant a sad smile. “Dressed up as wonderfully as it can be, that's what this is. Their great kindness, real as it might be, is contingent on total submission. And I just don’t know if that’s compatible with a human mind. And I don’t know whether it ought to be. Whatever arrangement we agree to, they can change that agreement whenever they wish, entirely unilaterally. And since there is one supreme leader, and even the Taiikari are mortal, there is no divining what the future would be. What do we do if they get a bit too bored with their handsome pet humans and look for other value to extract from us? What recourse do we have if the generous Empire decides that its charitable redistribution of its loot back to the looted is a bit too charitable?"

"You have me." Grant rests a hand on his brocaded chest. "I'm a Maekyonite."

"I'm sorry, Majesty,” Edward says. “Really. But you are my enemy. And I'm yours."

Comments

Captain Nuclear

At the end, I expected edward to say something like like "Yes, you are. But I am Human."

Dukerino

damn that'd be heat actually

Its Generic

Edward’s view point is pretty much the same way I see it too. Great chapter. I’m excited to see how the annexation unfolds, especially with the betrayer still working in the shadows on Earth.

DeWhit

I’m glad we got the perspective of Edward, since he’s effectively voicing all the concerns and thoughts I’ve had about this so far. Taking over Earth is all well and good, but like he said, who’s to say an empress further down the line will be just as benevolent and open minded as the current one? And Grant is only one man, if the Empress does decide that a full scale invasion of Earth is needed, there’s not much he can really do… Overall another great chapter!

JV SandMan

Dang, that’s good. It’s more ambiguous in meaning but for Grant I imagine it would sting even more.

Logrus

The political arguments here… don’t really make much sense to me. I hope we can veer back toward intrigue, because the sophomoric political arguments are… not super entertaining. I see enough of that on Twitter. I understand this is the perspective of a myriad of random characters, but to be quite frank I don’t find Edward’s argument here particularly compelling, and I find the general misanthropy from both the Takarii and him to be, again speaking frankly, at least partially ahistorical nonsense. I was already wary after the pretty bad “the first world nations are wealthy because they exploit the third world” nonsense a few chapters ago.

Shane Johnson

I love Edward if he isn’t the new protagonist I’m rioting

Shane Johnson

I get why she’s horny she is afraid of losing grant but the human perspective on the invasion is much more interesting

Shane Johnson

The taiikari empire is doomed any way you can’t just up end the gender relations all across your civilization and expect the civilization to continue

DeWhit

Not sure what you mean by wealthy nations exploiting poorer ones being nonsense. Many of the items people in wealthy countries buy are made in much poorer and less developed countries because of the cheap labor, leading to less expensive products. If those items, such as phones or even shoes, were made in a wealthy country, their price would be much higher, since the companies that make them would just shift the cost onto consumers. It is an uncomfortable and unfortunate reality, sure, but it doesn’t make it less true…

Logrus

"Many of the items people in wealthy countries buy are made in much poorer and less developed countries because of the cheap labor, leading to less expensive products. " This is not exploitation and is explicitly good for the nations building stuff. See: Poverty reduction in China post-Deng market reforms, flourishing of Vietnam, the overall suffering and stagnation of North Korea, etc... "If those items, such as phones or even shoes, were made in a wealthy country, their price would be much higher, since the companies that make them would just shift the cost onto consumers. It is an uncomfortable and unfortunate reality, sure, but it doesn’t make it less true…" I... don't quite understand your point. Yes, it is obviously true that items produced in nations with higher labor costs would be more expensive. That's why the work ends up going to nations with lower labor costs, because they benefit more from producing those items than the purchasing nation would (AKA they have a comparative advantage). This isn't "exploitation", it is a market economy, which has been the most important and effective factor in reducing human suffering throughout our specie's history! And this is also 100% true in the Taikarii empire! We've seen multiple examples of comparative advantage already, and they pretty clearly have a market economy embedded within their Empire structure. The Taikarii are pretty clearly NOT a mercantilist Empire in the traditional age-of-exploration sense - they're just a large somewhat constitutional monarchy with a mostly-market economy where the government takes an interest in key assets (Exo). That's what makes Edward's objections fall entirely flat for me - We have ~no evidence of the Taikarii exploiting anyone! What resources have they stolen from Eqt exactly? AFAICT they have traded fairly with them, working with their government to set up trade agreements to allow Taikarii corporations (overseen and chosen by the Monarchy in the form of Princesses, so not an entirely free market for sure) to extract key resources under nominal Eqt control. What does Earth have that the Taikarii could POSSIBLY "exploit"? The only real danger I can see if rogue Taikarii elements kidnapping human men to create compulsion resisting male Taikarii... which actually seems like both the OPPOSITE of what their leadership class would want AND already a solved problem (anti-comps exist).

Logrus

::Looks at western civilization post-birthcontrol:: You sure about that bub? <_<

Shane Johnson

:: looks at western civilization post-birth control:: yep I’m sure about that bubba!

Shane Johnson

But also to compare Hormonal birth control to mind control abilities is silly . Compulsion props up female dominance in a species that is sexually dimorphic towards males necessitating a snapback when you remove the mind control ability since that’s the way that the matriarchy sustains itself, remember the first volume the exo miners were all male that’s immense decentralized power held back by compulsion alone

Raine

Civilization does and does not end. It keeps moving forward, changing until it becomes unrecognizable to those who came before. That is certainly an ending, even if its name and history remain connected. Ask anyone who lived before women’s suffrage, birth control, or women having the right to own property, vote, or lead. Does our world even remotely resemble their civilization? I’d say nope, and good riddance! Any man of the Taiikari Empire can be mind controlled by literally any Taiikari woman. I’m sure many of them are slaves in all but name. The Maekyonites will end this civilization and all will be better for it, though not without growing pains. One must steel one’s heart and take the long view when playing a game of nation building. Know what’s darkly funny? I hope we don’t see it, because I hate these plotlines, but I’d bet by volume 8 or 9 we could end up with the Pike rescuing Maekyonites from forced breeding programs led by rebels who would see this Empire collapse from the inside. Faster than raising a gun and storming the core worlds, though monstrous all the same.

Shane Johnson

While I disagree that feminism has made the world better, what I mean when I say the taiikari empire is a taiikari supremacist matriarchal totalitarian monarchical empire can’t exist with humans in it and there’s no need for a breeding program they’re synthesizing a cure for compulsion from grants children’s blood so long as the Empress doesn’t figure out what she’s doing they’re going to willingly end the empire. The great twist in this story is that the traditionalists were right all along ( at least from there perspective )

DeWhit

Hmm, perhaps I should have clarified that the reason the labor is so cheap is because the people are being paid barely enough to feed themselves, hence the cheap labor. I remember reading about how the conditions in sweatshops in some places were so bad, they had to place suicide prevention nets around the roofs since there were so many workers jumping. Yes, there are those that benefit from this system (mainly the people who own the factories or shops i.e. the big corporations, and a few local elites) and there is development, but you can’t deny that it is an exploitative process for most involved. Also, just because it’s a market economy doesn’t mean it can’t be exploitative, those aren’t mutually exclusive. I’m not arguing against market economics by any means to be clear, I just think it’s important to accept reality. It took China a lot of effort to get where it is today, and even then there are a lot of areas in western China that still have terrible living conditions. Most of China’s prosperity is focused on the coast and big cities. Vietnam is also on the rise, and better than off now than it was 30 years ago, but it still has its fair share of issues, and again the labor is cheap because people get paid pennies for their work. And well…North Korea is poor because sanctions and no one can trade with them (also the disproportionate military spending Mr. dictator likes to partake in while his people starve, not that the planned economy helps either). “What does earth have that the Taikarii could possibly exploit?” Is something Edward actually mentions, maybe it would be charitable at first, but why else take over if not to extract something from us, whether it be the population or something else entirely. And humanity will have no say, since it’s been established that the Taikarii don’t take “No” for an answer, it’s either “submit peacefully, or we’ll make you submit.” Inherently, there isn’t much wiggle room when it comes to negotiations in that scenario. Also we have seen that the Empire is exploiting its own people, hence why they form unions and the pushback they get from the nobles, who are inherently anti-union, which was a big chunk of the arc where Grant and Sykora met with the union lady (can’t remember her name off the top of my head). TLDR/In summation: Yes countries develop more rapidly, but there is a steep human cost in the form of cheap (borderline slave) labor. The Taikarii Empire is still “an empire” and empires don’t just show up on your doorstep only to shower you with gifts, there is some (likely exploitative) cost for those on the receiving end, but we don’t know what that will be just yet.

Logrus

"Hmm, perhaps I should have clarified that the reason the labor is so cheap is because the people are being paid barely enough to feed themselves, hence the cheap labor. " That's... fundamentally untrue though. The labor is cheap because the economies in those nations are less developed and their skills are less valuable. They choose to take that work because the alternative (subsistence farming) is so, so, SO much worse. So much so that the vast majority of human history has been one of humans trying to no have to do that, to the point where they will choose to live in (what seem to us to be) horrific conditions to avoid it. Nothing has reduced poverty more than giving poor nations access to international markets and allowing them to labor for those markets! "I remember reading about how the conditions in sweatshops in some places were so bad, they had to place suicide prevention nets around the roofs since there were so many workers jumping." That is very much not the norm, and also - You are complaining about the human condition, not the factories themselves. These people are not slaves - They CHOOSE to work in the sweatshops because the alternatives are often FAR worse. "Also, just because it’s a market economy doesn’t mean it can’t be exploitative, those aren’t mutually exclusive. " No, they mostly are. Voluntarily labor is not exploitative in the vast majority of circumstances. "Yes, there are those that benefit from this system (mainly the people who own the factories or shops i.e. the big corporations, and a few local elites)" No, the benefit is mutual. The labor actually gets significantly MORE relative benefit, because the relative increase in wealth means more when you're in extreme poverty! Extreme poverty is very, very bad, and we have nearly eliminated in may places across the world by opening up markets! " It took China a lot of effort to get where it is today, and even then there are a lot of areas in western China that still have terrible living conditions." The "effort" was Deng's market reforms, and has been in spite of, not because of, the efforts of the Chinese Communist Party. "labor is cheap because people get paid pennies for their work. " This is a tautology. You're saying "the labor is cheap because the labor is cheap." "And well…North Korea is poor because sanctions and no one can trade with them" So wait, does trade make a nation wealthier? You've been arguing that it doesn't! Also - Sanctions are very much NOT why NK is a shit hole. It is a shit hole because it is a communist dictatorship - full stop. "but why else take over if not to extract something from us" ...Because they want to control the entire firmament and impose their cultural will upon it? Because they believe their way of life and governance is fundamentally better than allowing a competitor to exist? Good will towards other sentient creatures? "And humanity will have no say, since it’s been established that the Taikarii don’t take “No” for an answer, it’s either “submit peacefully, or we’ll make you submit.” Yes, this is how being conquered works. They are very much conquering Earth. The debate is what humans should DO about that, not whether or not it is a conquering. "Also we have seen that the Empire is exploiting its own people, hence why they form unions" Individuals WITHIN the Empire are negotiating with other individuals WITHIN the Empire. AFAICT no one is being forced to work by the government outside of penal work, and slavery seems to be illegal in the Taikarii empire. I also don't think we've seen a draft? "Taikarii Empire is still “an empire” and empires don’t just show up on your doorstep only to shower you with gifts, there is some (likely exploitative) cost for those on the receiving end" The cost is pretty clearly that they don't get to entirely govern themselves anymore, and they have to submit to and follow Taikarii law. And yes, that includes Taikarii regulation of resources.

Shane Johnson

Funny that we have a leftist and a guy straight out of the mises caucus arguing with each other. Also, it seems pretty clear. That slavery is a widespread but often overlooked problem within the empire. That seems like part of the motivating factor behind the Empress wanting to cure compulsion. It also was made practically explicit that the taiikari fuck there colonies on exo which is one of the motivations for moving the timeline up would surprise me if Jupiter was a gold mine

DeWhit

Not sure why you think I said trade doesn’t make a country wealthy, my original point was that the current system is in fact exploitative. Trade is definitely a good thing for countries. Also, I think we’re just talking past each other at this point. I’m ultimately of the opinion that, empire bad, alien empire also bad, we must solve own problems, now I’m gonna go back to enjoying the story

Logrus

I am… not really a libertarian lol. Also - I don’t think we’ve seen evidence that slavery is tolerated in the empire Also also - …no one owns Jupiter. It would belong to whoever is capable of extracting its resources.

Shane Johnson

Not officially tolerated, but if you remember the compelled minors that died, I believe it was in volume one fairly explicit implication people are forced to work without consent. And yes no one technically owns earth that doesn’t mean it’s not exploitation to take a resource they haven’t discovered yet use it for your own purposes

Logrus

Wasn’t that illegal though? Also - it is very much not exploitation to extract a resource someone has no access to or ownership claim over just because it is geographically closer to them than you. Resources belong to whoever is capable of extracting them unless an earlier reasonable ownership claim is made (humans do not own the elements in Jupiter the same way that no one owned the gold in the California hills until a miner staked a claim)

Shane Johnson

Illegal but overlooked and even promoted by some of the aristocrats who benefit from it. you’ve already agreed that the thing that is at steak is human sovereignty. That sovereignty is fueled by the exo it is absolutely exploitation to take the resource that ensures human beings can be sovereign and use it for imperial ambition, especially when it’s in our own backyard extracting humans potential future to fuel the taiikari present is exploitation