Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Files

Comments

Ny & Minelys

Yesss been waiting for this 👏🏽

Lúcia Pacheco

Your question regarding Manon is valid to ask, specially in the context that the show is presenting the situation. To be honest, most, including me, do believe that at least 2 people were set up to most certainly debut: Manon and Lexie. The feeling we get, is that the vision and image for the group was going to Center around one or the other, because it's no secret that Manon as well as Lexie were the 2 contestants that Bang considered to have the most star quality and effortless image and vibes. But I don't think that it had something to do with Manon being black and them aiming for a "quota", but more about Manon herself. She's just stunning and her cool image is just magnetic. It's a kind of energy and identity that people are either born with, or not, regardless of skin color. The fact the public resonated with her so much, just confirmed what they already knew from the moment they saw Manon on social media. Plus, despite her not having professional training, she had enough natural abilites (without even knowing how) that it was something they could work with and evolve in time.

Lúcia Pacheco

And also, I don't think that "I don't wann see that" regarding Manon's struggles should be the right way of looking at it. I understand your concern, since it's absolutely valid, but I honestly believe that Manon, by being the way she is, is the most relatable out of all Dream Academy members. Her mistakes are what made her evolve into the person she is now. A person who takes accountability of her own life and actions and is strong enough to face it and grow from it, instead of running away. I know many people have an issue with Hybe and Netflix including those scenes in the documentary (considering it to cause unnecessary Drama in the fandom, when they had just debuted), but to me, this storyline with Manon just made me so proud of her, and I'm sure that it gave hope to many girls, that even if they f up, they don't need to feel ashamed and run away.. that they too, can face the situation with courage in their hearts and fix things. And that's such an important message. Kpop fandoms tend to idolise their favorites so much, and just see the Perfection of the craft, but fail to see the human behind the artist, and humans are far from perfect. They fall, they learn and they grow.

Lúcia Pacheco

Ah and regarding the comment that Celeste stood out, you misunderstood the guy 😂 What he said was, that in terms of Celeste's voice, despite her having a beautiful tone, hers seemed to not "blend in" as well with the other voices, which was something that stood out to him. So, it was a backhanded compliment, if we think about it. She stood out in not such a positive way as the others.

Mubarak Mahad

Manon was scouted she was a fast learner and has the star quality that no other person has she was a great catch and not just because she’s the black girl she was meant to be in this group as much as she did slack off for some part of time at some point she did take accountability for her absence and is now taking everything seriously and improving soooo much which is why I think people should move on but do I think everyone during the survival show has a reasonable opinion on her yes it’s very understandable

Sunnie

11:30 Manon wasn’t the only one not living in the house, anyone who was underaged was living with a parent/guardian nearby, they just extended that to Manon who was a little older because she was struggling mentally and being around family was better for her The practises she was missing weren’t mandatory, and given she was so new to all of this, it was a lot harder on her both physically and mentally, but she worked through it, apologised to the girls and had kept working hard. I think a lot of people have a really overblown reaction to what was going on, because it was one of the few points of contention any of them had, so people like to milk it for drama to pit them against each other

Sunnie

38:43 in my opinion, it’s likely because they’re so new. If they give them a REALLY complex song where they have to do all the difficult parts while dancing, live, for a whole promotional period or concert tour, it increases the risk of them making mistakes that could trigger hate trains that could break their momentum. They don’t have that much experience yet, so the tour they’re on right now is a test run to see what condition their voices are going to be in by the end of tour, and what they can still reliably do in that condition, which will be the new threshold for how far they can push it. I think it’s in part why the girls are going so crazy with the note changes for “my way” it’s the last song of the night, so they’re proving to their managers and execs that at the end of a two hour show they can still be relied upon to hit these notes. It may feel like they’re holding them back, but given the amount of hate trains that other Hybe artists have received for a handful of shaky moments in bad conditions, I think playing it safe makes sense— especially with how many eyes are on Katseye, their debut was such a big experiment, asking if the K-Pop methodology can lead to success for a western group. People have honestly been rooting for them to fail, not giving them ammunition is the smart thing to do until they’re a little more stable

Sunnie

1:07:10 I think they didn't realise how big of a factor it would be because people were allowed to vote for up to six people, but I think a lot of people were either only voting for one, or were voting for the person from their home country and picking the others more randomly, or based off who their favourite was interacting with. Plus, K-Pop has never had a competition this international before, so they didn't really have a metric of HOW major a factor this would be, the closest would be Girls Planet 999 which was split evenly at first between Korean, Japanese and Chinese contestants and the voting system for that was kind of catastrophic— the rules changed multiple times, the Korean vote was weighted heavily and there was a panic vote from everyone last minute to ensure a Chinese contestant would even make it into Kep1er's line up (which was likely why MNet revealed their interim line-up unexpectedly before the finale, because they knew that would be another PR disaster after they got in so much trouble for rigging the Produce series)