Which do you like better? (Patreon)

Hey guys,

Curious which layout you perfer on my online store?

The first one is from the Comedy site— https://thecomedyoutlet.com/collections/nikocado-avocado. You get to see all of the close together and in various colors.  Has a grey background. Squares. 

The second two pics is from my Personal site— they have a transparent background (floating on a white page) and they are uniform black.

Comedy Site or My Site?