Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Bye Alan! :)

Files

Comments

Hyde

Get his ass, Pen

RaoulleoXIII

I want Alan gone, someone run this man over

Pale

Hmmm...

Zoa

The death glare!

LunarFox

Yeah, no, not trusting that

SeigeTheProot

QUICK HIS BACK IS TURNED SUPLEX HIM

Kit Foxxy

I vote that Alan gets hit by a car as he leaves please.

Karl Absalonsen

I swear this guy makes me seethe, "We wont get replaced" vibes. But also love that our boy is seeing right though it👏

SENNE

I can't HATE the guy per se, but I feel uneasy about him and his relationship with Indy. Hoping to learn more about him though to be honest.

Lake

"We" no thank you

Merchant Of Menace

God dammit he's so cute, and it's gonna piss me off when the mask falls off. This really gotta be terrifying for Penn, though; there's so many bad directions this could go whether or not he is lying. Either way, he BETTER fucking talk about this!

Dawae

And that was the last time anyone saw Alan.

Zene_Fox

Bye, Alan.. >:(

Cascadian

His story makes no sense. He claims Indy was over possessive and violent with him, but when we see them interacting earlier, Indy is aggravated because hes trying to get away, but Alan grabs him.

Rader Ketron

Pen better not keep that. It might be laced or something.

Ruffian

That paper is going straight to the trash

KingMyth

Pen is still about ready to stab a guy, and I don't blame him

Husky

Bruh now pen has his number

Sasha Belmont

indy is gonna find that number on pen’s person, remember whose it is, and feel hurt/worried over it. called shot.

Kael Duranus

Good riddance to bad rubbish. That guy just comes off as a bit of a creep. Even if everything he says is true, which i doubt, what he did with Pen just now is highly inappropriate. You don't go up to a random stranger your S.O is hanging with and warn them off or try and play the martyr.

Thruster_Check

Glad Pen never let his guard down, even with Argyle Menace acting like a boy scout. Pen should get on the horn to Indy the instant this creep is out of sight and describe the whole exchange, including the phone number. Pen knows what to do with a phone number, I'm sure. He won't call it, he'll look up who it belongs to and who they're associated with; might be something interesting there. And am I the only one who noticed that Alan never gave a last name? I'll bet he didn't include it on that paper either.

Auctoritas

Although he makes a friendly and decent impression at first glance, despite his strange clothes... his mannerisms and behavior leave a very strange taste in the mouth, right back where it tastes bitter; absolute caution is advised! ( maybe in both direktions ) just talk to Indy asap.

Claeab

In the flashback on the last page he had a wound on the left side of his face, yet he has no scar to speak of. Hmm....

N.B. Eskerata

Pen is going to need an aspirin for those alarm bells going off in his head.

Cosmic

having a notepad at the ready in your pocket to write things down is uh a little strange there, bud almost if you planned this all along

Anubislaughed

"Eight, Six, Seven, Five....Three Ohhhhh Niiiiinnnneeee...."

Amberthyst

NOOOOOOOO. I don’t like him at all 😭

ashbat

Oh you knoowwww this is gonna be good.... guys we gotta grab some more popcorn

Tom Noyb

First of all, the only confrontation we've seen Indy in so far was at the playground and he retreated from that. It was Pen who was getting riled. Second, does it strike anyone else as odd that Alan, a pred, uses the phrase 'stay safe'. Isn't that a prey saying. The same one that was used in Chapter 5 page 4 by the flyer posting lady.

Thruster_Check

Good catch; I missed that about 'stay safe'.

Emersky studios

My theory is that he's one behind the anti-pred movement or highly involved in it. Likely a bitter ex like others have said.

Thruster_Check

Looking back at ch3p13 and the first frame, I thought that hand-grab and the facial expression could be Argyle saying something along the lines of "You owe me--" A somewhat nasty idea came to me: that the two of them were partners in some sort of crime, with Indy stealing goods and Alan fencing them, but in frame 2, Indy has decided he wants out. Maybe he's contemplating domestic bliss in a way he may not have before. Fast-forward to now, and maybe Alan is trying to get Pen out of the way in an effort to restart the criminal enterprise ... and he might be under pressure from a seriously nasty crime boss who also just happens to like killing and mutilating the minions who fail him.

Watchdog

Hey, I know this is a very long shot of you seeing this, but I was wondering do you have any plans of getting this comic published. I know you have it on Tumblr for free, but I personally would buy this comic if it was published and I would buy your published comic of NSFW one as well.

Thruster_Check

Yeah, he should get some business cards instead. Seriously, nothing wrong with a pocket notepad; I use one myself all the time, usually for shopping lists

Thruster_Check

Alan should have his ears and tail cut off.

Lennon

I’m seeing a lot of outright hatred toward Alan in the comments. Others are wishing he would die, saying he should be killed, and flat out declaring that he’s the serial killer from the story. I’m not going to join in with that, because honestly, I don’t think the comic has given anyone nearly enough information to make that kind of judgment. What the comic has given readers is a very incomplete picture of Alan, and I think that’s intentional. Readers see him approach a stranger with what appears to be genuine concern. He gives them his number, presents himself as Indy’s protective former partner, and talks about Indy’s temper and drinking. Those are the things that have actually been shown. Everything beyond that is still speculation. Nobody knows what Alan and Indy’s relationship was really like. Nobody knows whether there was mutual harm, whether one person hurt the other, or whether this was simply a relationship between two individuals who cared about each other but eventually became unable to make it work. It is equally unclear whether Alan is genuinely worried about Indy, whether he is still emotionally attached, or whether he is attempting to control the situation and keep himself involved. It could even be a mixture of several of those things. Honestly, that ambiguity is what makes the character interesting. Some of the criticism directed at Alan has also crossed the line from examining his behavior into treating his general demeanor as evidence of something sinister. I’ve seen people point to the way he dresses, the fact that he uses a notepad, his facial expressions, his somewhat unusual mannerisms, or the fact that he is excessively friendly as though these things somehow establish that he is dangerous. They don’t. Those details may contribute to an intentionally unsettling first impression, but an unconventional appearance or awkward social presentation is not evidence of violent tendencies. Someone can be strange, overly enthusiastic, socially awkward, emotionally intense, or simply different from what others are accustomed to without being a threat to anyone. The same applies to the scene where Alan pulls on Indy’s coat. It is understandable that people find that moment uncomfortable. Alan does physically grab him, and it is perfectly reasonable to question why he did it. But even if that action is interpreted as inappropriate, it still does not establish that Alan was being physically aggressive toward Indy. In fact, when the sequence of expressions and body language is actually examined, the idea that Alan deliberately engineered the entire encounter so Pen would witness Indy becoming angry becomes difficult to sustain. Alan initially looks sad and almost pleading with Indy. Indy turns away, appearing as though he does not want to hear what Alan is saying. Alan then becomes visibly frustrated and grabs Indy’s coat, which reads much more naturally as an exasperated attempt to stop him from walking away, something along the lines of “listen to me” or “don’t just walk away,” rather than some elaborate attempt to provoke him in front of Pen. Indy then forcefully pulls his arm away and moves closer into Alan’s personal space, baring his teeth. Alan’s posture subsequently seems to fold back slightly, and his expression looks considerably frightened. Then Alan notices that Pen has been watching. His expression changes again, appearing shocked or worried at having been observed. Indy waves toward Pen, while Alan leaves looking frustrated. Could there be another interpretation? Certainly. Nobody has access to the writers internal thoughts, and visual storytelling can deliberately leave room for ambiguity. But that sequence does not provide evidence that Alan was staging the confrontation. If Alan’s supposed plan was to provoke Indy into looking aggressive in front of Pen, his apparent surprise and fear when Pen witnesses the confrontation make considerably less sense. Based purely on what is depicted, it seems much more plausible that Alan became frustrated when Indy tried to walk away, impulsively grabbed his coat to keep the conversation going, and then found himself startled when Indy reacted much more aggressively than he expected. That distinction matters because I’ve seen people take the fact that Alan initiated physical contact and immediately reinterpret the entire encounter as though he were orchestrating everything. But initiating an interaction is not the same thing as controlling its outcome. Alan may have made a poor decision by grabbing Indy’s coat. He may have crossed a personal boundary. Those are things that can be criticized without inventing an elaborate motive that the comic has not established. When Alan is considered as a whole so far, what emerges is less a clearly dangerous individual and more someone who appears deeply troubled, emotionally complicated, and possibly unable to let go of someone he lost. There is something rather sad about that. Whatever else may be happening beneath the surface, Alan does not presently come across as someone who is simply plotting violence. He comes across as someone desperately trying to remain connected to someone who has apparently moved on without him. That can absolutely become unhealthy. It can become manipulative. It can even become harmful. But unhealthy attachment and dangerousness are not synonymous. People can behave in complicated ways when a relationship ends badly, particularly when drinking, anger, volatility, and unresolved feelings are involved. Someone can tell a story that emphasizes what another person did wrong without necessarily sitting down and consciously deciding to lie. Sometimes people do that because it is easier to live with a version of events that protects them. Admitting that you played a part, that you still care about someone who hurt you, or that you remain emotionally tied to a relationship you know should have ended can be incredibly difficult. That is one possible way of reading Alan. His careful choice of words, the fact that he still seems concerned about Indy, and the quiet offer to help “just in case” could come from someone who genuinely cares and has not completely detached himself from the relationship. The rush to declare Alan a monster says more about how badly some people want an answer than it does about what the comic has actually shown. The same applies to the theory that Alan is the serial killer. The story tells readers that the killer is a large feline whose bite structure matches the injuries. Alan is a raccoon dog of ordinary size. His physical characteristics simply do not seem to fit what has been established about the killer. Maybe there is some explanation that has not been revealed yet. If so, that is what mysteries are for. But taking everything people dislike or distrust about Alan and turning it into “therefore he’s the murderer” is not solving the mystery. It is filling an uncomfortable blank with the most dramatic answer available. It is also worth considering how differently some readers might react if the situation were reversed. If Pen were the one quietly warning someone about a former partner’s temper and drinking, there would probably be far more willingness to interpret the behavior sympathetically. The discussion might focus on unresolved trauma, grief, complicated attachment, or someone awkwardly trying to protect another person. There would likely be much more hesitation before assuming that the concern was inherently sinister. But because Alan is the individual standing between the protagonists and what they want, he gets treated as guilty almost by default. That is worth thinking about. Most readers naturally empathize with protagonists. Their history is known. Their feelings are understood. Their perspective is the one through which the story is primarily experienced. Someone who threatens their happiness therefore feels suspicious almost automatically. But real individuals are not divided that neatly into heroes and villains, and this story may not be doing that either. None of this means Alan is innocent. He could absolutely be manipulative. He could be hiding something. He could even be telling a carefully constructed version of events designed to make Pen distrust Indy. But he could also be someone who was hurt and is still trying to make sense of what happened. He could be someone who genuinely cares about Indy despite everything that happened between them. He could simply be someone who lost a relationship and has not figured out how to completely let go. Right now, all of those possibilities remain on the table. That is why the sheer amount of hatred toward him seems so disproportionate to what is actually known. Being suspicious of Alan is reasonable. Finding his behavior uncomfortable is reasonable. Even thinking he may be manipulative is reasonable. Wishing death on him, talking about how he deserves to suffer, or confidently labeling him a serial killer based on a handful of ambiguous interactions is something entirely different. There is also something rather sad about treating Alan’s suffering itself as evidence of his guilt. He looks like someone carrying around a great deal of unresolved emotion. His awkwardness, nervousness, strange attempts at friendliness, and apparent inability to completely sever his connection with Indy can certainly be interpreted as unsettling. But they can also be interpreted as the behavior of someone who is hurting. A person can be emotionally unhealthy without being evil. A person can make poor decisions without being a murderer. A person can become manipulative because they are frightened of losing someone without secretly intending physical harm. There is nothing wrong with being suspicious of Alan. That is clearly part of what the comic is inviting readers to feel. But suspicion and certainty are two very different things. Readers can dislike him, question his motives, and even believe he is probably hiding something without immediately deciding that he deserves to die or that he must secretly be a serial killer. At this point, it makes far more sense to allow Alan to remain complicated than to flatten him into a villain simply because doing so makes the story easier to understand. He may ultimately turn out to be exactly as awful as some people believe. He may turn out to be manipulative, dishonest, or something considerably darker. Or readers may eventually discover that the truth is far more tragic and complicated than either side currently realizes. And although this is ultimately a work of fiction, that is part of what makes stories like this meaningful in the first place. These characters represent people who actually exist in the world: people who are grieving, people who are angry, people who are difficult to understand, people who make mistakes, people who become attached in unhealthy ways, people who hurt others, and people who are themselves hurting. Real human beings are rarely as simple as the roles assigned to them from a distance. Empathy does not require anyone to excuse harmful behavior, and understanding someone does not mean declaring them innocent. It simply means being willing to look beyond a first impression and ask what might be happening inside another person before deciding that their entire character is already understood. The most compassionate thing someone can do is leave room for complexity: to recognize that someone can be flawed without being monstrous, troubled without being dangerous, and responsible for their actions without being reducible to the worst thing they have ever done. That, to me, is one of the more valuable things fiction can teach. Stories give people the opportunity to encounter individuals whose thoughts, experiences, and circumstances are different from their own and practice trying to understand them before passing judgment. If readers can learn to extend even a little of that patience and curiosity toward fictional characters, perhaps they become better equipped to extend it toward the complicated, imperfect people they encounter in real life. Sometimes the most honest answer is simply, “I don’t know yet.”

Lennon

This is one of the most grounded responses I’ve read here. You can feel uneasy about Alan and question his relationship with Indy without immediately jumping to “he’s evil”. I really appreciate that you’re willing to acknowledge what we don’t know yet and wait to learn more before passing judgment. That kind of measured response is honestly refreshing to see in these comments.