Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Sports teams named after animals still exist in this world, and just like sports teams named after groups of people in our world, they are universally yikes.

Files

Comments

Amy

We're sending him to the hammercar dimension for bullying Indy

Firepaw14

God this stresses me outtttt. God this is good.

Daniel

injecting this into my veins, screw my arms it’s right in my neck

Brendon

Minor spelling mistake :p

lateef

At school but the notification got me locked in

Panda

“Dress like the stereotype” is insane

Rumore Folf

Uggghh I cant wait aother week I need more now 😭

Sasha Belmont

Oh Big Yikes, Okay fuck this guy

Stormi Husky

Oh boy major lore drop, can definitely tell his personality is controlling and judgemental. Its always those who we think are put together who show their true colors isolated with someone they interact with all the time. Still gonna wait to hear what spiraled into physically hitting Alan but it had to be pushing Indy way too hard and possibly threatening him unless its not the case. Hope Pen realizes he'll be protected by Indys calm and reassuring presence <33

Evix

I like how Indy dresses! >:c

Hugo92

LET MY BOY LOOK LIKE A COWBOY IF HE WANTS TO!!

Salazaar Fyrfang

Ah so Alan is *THAT* type. Can't say a good, hard smack isn't deserved

Kael Duranus

Yikes. Cares about how things look, not how they are. Let me guess, Alan's next move is to try and force Indy to change in order to 'fit in', with what he wants, completely ignoring what makes Indy who he is.

Peyote

Wanting him to change how he dresses is a shame, Indy has such a distinct look :_:

Tom Noyb

Don't know where this will go. But verbal abuse can be as damaging as physical abuse. It might take longer. But it can also last longer. The worst part is it always comes from the abuser's loathing of self. And great job getting so much into one page.

Samuel Berz

Five. Hundred. New pages

Vim the Protogen

“Were you raking the leaves or rolling in them?” That sounds cute but then the next bit calling Indy a stereotype makes it sound much less nice TwT Also, I love the lack of color to show that it’s a memory

Micah Morell

Ahhhh. So he's like that. Poor Indy.

Franck Yvonnet

Now I want to see the base ball team mascot 😆

SENNE

Hate to admit it, but I was in Alan’s shoes when I was younger. I deeply cared about appearances to this degree back then, keeping a certain persona, etc. Thankfully I grew out of it as I went into college, but it is definitely a poisonous trait to have and an exhausting lifestyle to live. The mental erosion it does socially is immense cause you can’t recognize yourself anymore, just the persona that you’ve held as a societal crutch. It REALLY sucks.

Alex

I didn't like Alan since the moment he appeared for the first time. He was already raising alarm at the back of my mind, even then. But I chugged it up to me being overly conscious, possibly due to personal experience with a narcissistic parent. His recent attempted manipulation of Pen only cemented that he's bad news and manipulative as hell. And the red flags were at full mast at this point. But here, I can literally see some of the things that were done and said to me. And those were among the least damaging ones ☹️

Demon Cat

Oooooh he's a controlling type. I've had that type of relationship. Indy deserves the world. He is the sweetest.

Alex

Send him straight to the Backrooms.

SeigeTheProot

This is worse than I thought I hope pen hits Alan with a stone cold Steve Austin stunner next time they meet actual I guess in this universe it would be Steve Oxen

Junie

So Alan is racist.... speciesist? Yikes 😬

Jasper

Ahh....red flags

FunkSamurai

I never understand why people start dating other people just to try and change them, like YOU asked him out, and then you change him to fit what, your ideal ? how you WISH he was ? I truly dont understand it

Oki

"were" 👀👀👀

JRedWolf

I gotta say from the first moment that you introduced Alan, the sleeze alarm went off, and has been getting louder ever since. The scene a few comics ago with Pen made my skin crawl. That takes some damn good writing and illustration to get that kinda reaction out of me for something that isn't happening in real time and real life.

OR-69

I love how all the commentariat are so eager to take sides... "Indy is a serial killer..." "Alan is racist/*THAT*-guy/etc" and then just root for their chosen side. I'm trying to keep an open mind. We're all flawed in some way or another. In my experience every failed relationship is a learning opportunity. In the post-breakup period I'd try to identify the mistakes I made and the things I admired about the other guy to see if I could adopt those qualities in myself while letting go of the negative stuff. It took a few tries but eventually I got to the point where I could make a relationship last for 25 years... I like the advice RBG got from her mother in law on her wedding day: "in every good marriage, it helps sometimes to be a little deaf". It's just a clever way of saying "choose your battles wisely" My best guess is that Alan picked a bunch of petty battles and drove Indy away. Now Indy has moved on and Alan is trying to turn back time rather than learn from his mistakes.

Zane_Keratario

Alan just wow, You thought you could just change Indy like that! Indy looks very handsome the way he dresses! Also trying to make him fit in yea no fuck that. You ether love them for who they are or don’t. You don’t get to go around changing their whole entire personality. I can’t wait to see the justifiable reasoning to why Indy hit you. You deserved a full punch in the face after saying “do you always have to dress like such a stereotype”

Alex

It's a subtle way to infantilize/berate/embarrass someone, or not appreciate something they did for you, while still sounding positive and appreciative. My narcissistic parent did this to me a lot, way into my adulthood. It can seem small, but really fucks you up if done continuously over the span of many years. Causes a lot of self-doubt, low self-esteem, anxiety...

Thruster_Check

So, Alan wanted Indy for *something*, but found out fairly quickly that he wasn't going to turn him into a high(er)-society showpiece ... Alan's frustration builds, as he can't even talk about it to his upper-class 'friends', who are probably already dissing him behind his back over his questionable choice of partners. So all the anger and frustration comes out at Indy in the form of humiliating insults, contained within the walls of Alan's house. Indy had nowhere to take it either, and whatever he'd been getting from the relationship was turning more negative. Sad he didn't get out earlier, but maybe he understands himself better now. And now I have to admit to my own longstanding fears for Indy and Pen, as Indy himself stated above about 'educated guys with nice clothes and careers and stuff' ... it's one of the first things I wondered about, because very soon Pen is going to potentially become one of them, and his advancement through society (should he choose to pursue it) will meet the same challenge ... I still wonder what draws Pen to Indy, and can only surmise it 's pure infatuation, strictly a physical attraction, though that specifically included an attraction to those predator teeth, which seems awfully incongruous to me. I think Indy's got the same ... the difference is that they don't have any agendas to 'improve' each other, and that may save them. Anyway, onward; I need to hear the rest of Indy's story.

Beans

ALAN!! WHEN I GET YOU ALAN!

Alex

Manipulators and/or narcissists never "pick petty battles". They do everything with calculated intent to fuck up and bend the other person to their ideals. I'll be very surprised if Alan isn't one. Because if he wasn't, then he'd have no reason to act, do and say things the way he does.

Sir Doofus McDingbat

Aw, man, they were kinda cute for a little bit. But then he ruined it so fuckem. Also I'm curious, was this page easier to draw than normal because of the colors, or harder than normal because of how things overlapped and how dense the page is?

Thruster_Check

I'm pretty sure Alan has tried that already. Might be why they're apart now.

Maui

it takes a lot of bravery to let go of that control of how ppl see you, I'm glad you were able to escape that cycle!

Alex

You can be an educated person, wear nice clothes, have a career, friends similar to you, and still be nice and not want to manipulate people. But I agree that it's less likely than in the opposite circumstances. Capitalism breeds narcissistic, sociopathic behavior. I think Pen is drawn to Indy for several reasons. Him being a pred, and Pen being into preds. His personality, because he's caring, attentive, soft, silly, charming... And hand to heart, who doesn't want to have a partner like that? Him being undeniably handsome and Pen being undeniably smitten with him. Indy possibly being Pen's first male date/crush? I think it was mentioned by Falco that Pen's bi, but mostly attracted to women. Possibly Indy's hobbies and skills? We've seen how much Pen loved him playing his guitar. I could probably think of more, but this is what comes to mind from the top of my head. Edit: Reading my comment again to make sure I haven't made any obvious grammatical mistakes and I kind of just realized, that my partner is all of these things, just swap pred for top, and guitar playing for cooking...and I feel like I've fallen in love with him all over again 🥰

Thruster_Check

I don't see that, but being classist is at least as bad.

JP125

I'd pay money to watch Leon the Hellhound beat his ass up!

Amy

Agreed

Random old smuck (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-04 05:00 This page is excellent, it gives me a huge amount of context that was missing before and starts filling in several holes that earlier pages only let me speculate about. More importantly, it feels firmly based in reality. Nothing here reads like exaggerated melodrama or a simple attempt to tell us which character we are supposed to hate. It feels human. The attraction feels human, the class differences feel human, the insecurity feels human and even the way affection gradually starts rubbing against incompatibility feels painfully familiar. I have seen relationships like this from the outside. I have watched people I knew go through them and I have tried to help people put themselves back together after the inevitable fallout when insecurity, resentment, shame, social expectations and poor communication finally cause the whole house of cards to collapse. That is one reason this page hits me differently from some of the earlier material. It does not feel like a story about one good person and one evil person. It feels like two individuals who genuinely cared about one another, who were probably very happy for a while and who eventually discovered that some of the very differences that attracted them to each other were also capable of tearing them apart. I’ll explain my thoughts and reasons below as fairly and balanced as I possibly can while still remaining objective and honest. …And after spending about five and half hours staring at this page, pulling apart dialogue, expressions, clothing, social cues, body language and probably everything short of performing a forensic examination on the furniture while applying what has been established in past pages and then writing a feature length screenplay to accompany it, (its long as hell, I know) :P I think I have earned the right to say there is a lot going on here. :) I think I can now say with confidence that Alan and Indy once loved each other. There is simply too much here pointing in that direction. They met shortly after Indy came to town, they got along almost immediately, Alan was the one who asked Indy out and the relationship became serious enough that Indy eventually moved into Alan’s home. That last part matters enormously to me. Alan does not appear to be somebody careless about his home, his privacy or his personal life. Everything we have seen suggests someone orderly, particular, carefully presented, educated, professionally minded and conscious of his surroundings. Yet he trusted Indy enough to let him into that private world and effectively tell him that his home was Indy’s home too. People generally do not give somebody that level of access to their life if they do not trust them and care deeply about them. Indy’s own description of Alan makes this even clearer because there is obvious admiration in it, even while Indy is explaining why things later became difficult. He says Alan is the type who can command a room and that people can tell he is important even when he is quiet. He describes Alan as educated, well dressed, career oriented and belonging to a kind of social world Indy does not normally expect to welcome him. There is actually something quite sad in Indy’s surprise that Alan wanted him in the first place. When he says that educated guys with nice clothes and careers are not usually tripping over themselves to talk to him, I hear somebody who was already conscious of the difference between them and perhaps quietly wondering what Alan saw in him. That makes me feel a great deal of sympathy for Indy. Imagine loving somebody while also feeling that you do not quite belong in his world and then imagine that same person gradually becoming more concerned with how you dress, how you behave and how the two of you appear around his friends. Alan’s comments on this page are not harmless. Asking Indy whether he always has to dress like a stereotype and comparing him to a baseball team mascot is mean, embarrassing, and unnecessarily cutting. I am not going to pretend otherwise simply because I have defended Alan elsewhere. Alan deserves criticism for that. If this became a repeated pattern I can easily understand how Indy might begin feeling that the person he loved was embarrassed by him or wanted him to become somebody else. At the same time, Indy gives us what I think is the key to understanding Alan when he says Alan was not actually as confident as he appeared in mixed company. That changes the picture considerably. Alan can apparently walk into a room and project confidence, status, intelligence, and composure while privately being much less secure than everyone assumes. His concern with appearances around certain people may therefore come from insecurity rather than simple arrogance. That certainly doesn’t make Alan’s behavior acceptable but it does make it human. I have a close friend whom I’ve known for many years whose behavior reminds me strongly of Alan’s behavior here. He comes from a wealthy, upper class background in an affluent area of the Northeast, while I come from a small rural community in the South. He also has Asperger’s syndrome, and there are moments when the similarities are extremely remarkable. In private, he can be affectionate, comfortable, easy to be around and completely different from how he acts in certain social situations. Put him around particular friends or in an environment where presentation suddenly matters to him and clothing gets commented upon, expectations change, and things that were completely unimportant five minutes earlier suddenly become serious. We have remained close for years and we do share intimacy, but we are simply far too different to have ever worked successfully as a couple had I not met my partner of nearly three decades. That may be one of the simplest explanations for Alan and Indy I can think of as well. Opposites absolutely can attract but not all opposites are compatible over the long term. Indy is loud, informal, physical, outgoing, spontaneous, and very comfortable being Indy. Alan is quieter, educated, polished, socially conscious, particular, and apparently much more sensitive to how he is perceived. At first those differences may have been exciting. Alan may have loved Indy’s spontaneity and freedom. Indy may have admired Alan’s intelligence, refinement, stability, and confidence. But eventually those same differences appear to have landed directly on each man’s insecurities. Indy could hear Alan’s criticism as, “You are ashamed of me.” Alan could hear Indy’s refusal to change as, “You do not care about something that matters to me.” Indy becomes more insecure while Alan becomes more anxious about appearances. That leads them to argue more and each argument confirms what the other already fears. That is how two individuals who loved one another can slowly become terrible for one another without either secretly being a monster. The class difference is also becoming much harder for me to ignore. While I don’t have access to Alan’s bank account or family history, I still think evidence is beginning to stack up. Alan is educated, dresses carefully and apparently expensively, has a career, moves within a socially established circle, has a home he was able to share with Indy and is described by Indy as somebody whose importance is obvious even when he is quiet. I think it is becoming increasingly likely that Alan came from a wealthy or at least very comfortable background and probably has substantial resources himself. And that makes what happened after Indy hit him particularly interesting. If Alan genuinely wanted to destroy Indy, make his life miserable, or exercise some grand campaign of revenge against him, he appears to have had an almost perfect opportunity. Alan had been injured. Police involvement was apparently already on the table. Alan himself tells us that Indy could not afford another criminal charge and that he was able to get the police department to let the matter go. Somebody with money, education, social standing and access to legal resources could have made that situation extraordinarily unpleasant for Indy if revenge was Alan’s objective. Instead, according to what Alan tells us he actually helped prevent Indy from facing another charge. That does not make Alan a saint. It does not erase the cruel things he said or anything else we may later learn that he did wrong. But it is very difficult for me to reconcile that decision with the idea that Alan’s primary motivation was always to ruin Indy’s life. And this is where I remain absolutely firm about the physical assault while still having sympathy for Indy. Because the story repeatedly invokes Circle City which is a well known nickname for Indianapolis I’m going to use Indiana law as the closest real world legal framework. Under Indiana Code § 35 31.5 2 128, someone a person is dating or has dated qualifies as a family or household member. Under Indiana Code § 35 42 2 1.3, knowingly or intentionally touching a family or household member in a rude, insolent, or angry manner can constitute domestic battery. The basic legal issue is not particularly complicated. Alan could have said something absolutely vicious to Indy. He could have insulted him, humiliated him, called him names, deliberately hurt his feelings or said the nastiest thing imaginable during their argument. None of which are justified but none of that by itself gives Indy a legal right to punch him. Words can explain anger, hurt, and pain but they do not automatically justify physical force. Indiana’s self defense statute, Indiana Code § 35 41 3 2, concerns whether someone reasonably believes physical force is necessary to protect themselves from the imminent use of unlawful force. The important ideas are reasonableness, necessity, and immediacy. Even if we eventually discovered that Alan shoved Indy, grabbed him, grabbed his clothing or otherwise put his hands on him during the argument that would still not automatically give Indy the right to punch him in the face either morally or legally. Reasonable force is the key here. You use the amount of force reasonably necessary to stop the immediate danger and remove yourself from the situation. You do not get a blank check to retaliate however you please simply because somebody touched you first. And the physical difference between these two is enormous. Indy towers over Alan. He is heavier, stronger and overwhelmingly more physically imposing. Alan would have to present some genuinely serious threat before a strike powerful enough to leave him bleeding on the floor becomes easy to characterize as necessary force. Put rather bluntly, Alan would practically need a weapon or some extraordinary physical advantage before I would look at these two standing next to one another and assume Indy had no reasonable option except punching him in the face. The size difference does not mean Alan could never hurt Indy but it does mean that proportionality matters enormously. There is another problem with the self defense theory that has nothing to do with legal statutes. Indy himself has never claimed it. When Indy tells Pen what happened he says that he hit Alan. He does not say Alan attacked him. He does not say Alan had a weapon. He does not say he feared for his life. He does not say he had no way to escape. He does not say he struck Alan because he was defending himself. If self defense were the central fact of the incident that would be one of the most obvious and important things for Indy to tell Pen. Instead, the story presents the assault in the context of a relationship that had deteriorated badly. Until the comic gives us evidence otherwise so I’m not going to invent a self defense claim for Indy that Indy himself has never made. There is another reason I take the violence seriously, and it is something I think people occasionally forget when they dismiss this as one punch. Just one punch can kill somebody. If Indy had hit Alan and fractured his skull, caused permanent brain damage, left him in a vegetative state or caused Alan to fall backward, strike his head and die, the fact that Indy used his hand instead of a conventional weapon would not somehow make the outcome less serious. I will put it very plainly. If you beat someone to death, you might as well have used your gun and shot them. Murder is murder. The victim is still dead. A fist does not magically become harmless because it is attached to your body. A person can die from the initial strike. They can die from bleeding inside the skull. They can die because their head strikes concrete, furniture, pavement, or the edge of something as they fall. They can survive and live with permanent neurological damage for the rest of their life. If Alan had fallen differently and died that night we would no longer be talking about an ugly fight between former partners. We would be talking about a homicide case. The precise criminal charge would depend upon intent and all of the surrounding circumstances and Indiana law does distinguishes among different homicide offenses, including reckless homicide under Indiana Code § 35 42 1 5, voluntary manslaughter, and murder. But the fact that Indy used his fist rather than a gun would not make Alan any less dead or make the resulting criminal investigation disappear. There’s also a civil side to this that tends to get forgotten. Criminal prosecution and civil liability are different things. Alan apparently chose not to pursue the criminal matter as far as he potentially could have but that does not automatically erase the possibility of civil liability for emotional damages or injuries caused by the assault. Under Indiana Code § 34 11 2 4, actions involving personal injury generally have a two year limitations period. Depending upon exactly how much time has passed in the story, Alan could potentially still bring a civil action against Indy if he wanted to. That could involve compensation for provable medical expenses, lost income, pain and suffering, emotional distress and other damages resulting from the injury. If the hypothetical worst case had occurred and Alan had died from the blow or the resulting fall Indiana also provides for wrongful death actions separately from whatever criminal homicide proceedings the state might bring. So when I say Alan could have made Indy’s life a living hell after this incident if that were truly what he wanted, I mean it. Criminal consequences were one possibility. Civil consequences were another. Alan apparently has money, education, social standing and access to resources that Indy does not. Yet according to the story, Alan instead used whatever influence or opportunity he had to keep Indy from acquiring another criminal charge. That fact deserves to be part of the conversation just as much as Alan’s bad behavior does. And I want to make something else equally clear. None of this means I hate Indy. Quite the opposite! This page actually makes me feel considerably more sympathy for him. I see somebody who appears to have loved someone he believed belonged to a world above his own. I see somebody who was surprised that Alan wanted him at all. I see somebody who may gradually have begun feeling judged, embarrassed, inadequate or unwanted within Alan’s social world. I can understand how painful repeated criticism from someone you love can become, particularly when it lands directly on insecurities that were already there. Indy eventually crossed a serious line but that doesn’t mean every feeling that led him toward that moment was illegitimate. Understanding somebody’s anger, humiliation, jealousy, insecurity or emotional exhaustion is not the same thing as approving what they did with those feelings. The same standard should apply to Alan. He can be insecure, status conscious, snobbish, controlling about appearances, cruel with his words and deeply unfair to Indy without becoming some calculating monster whose every action was secretly malicious. In fact, this page gives Alan exactly the sort of flaw I have been expecting. His insecurity appears capable of hurting somebody he genuinely loves. That is ugly and it definitely deserves criticism but it’s also painfully human. Ultimately, I think that may be what this relationship was. Two very different individuals fell in love. They trusted one another enough to share a home, they laughed together, they went places together and they teased one another. Alan chose Indy despite apparently coming from a completely different social world. Indy clearly admired Alan and still remembers qualities in him that attracted him in the first place. Then their differences stopped being exciting and started hurting. Indy began feeling like he did not belong in Alan’s world. Alan became increasingly worried about how they looked within that world. Each individual insecurity began pressing against the other ones identity. Arguments replaced affection. Resentment accumulated, trust deteriorated. Eventually something that had once been loving became destructive and everything fell apart. That is very sad, but it is also very believable. And perhaps the biggest thing this page finally gives us is proof that there really was something valuable there before everything fell apart. Alan and Indy were not simply enemies who happened to date. They once trusted each other. They once wanted each other. They once shared a home. And most importantly they once loved each other. And perhaps that is the part I find most encouraging. If there really was love, trust, laughter, and tenderness between them once then I do not think their story has to end with nothing but bitterness. They do not belong together romantically now and that’s okay,but people can still grow, apologize, forgive, and eventually remember the good without denying the harm. Maybe it’s just wishful thinking but I would really like to see both of them reach a place where the past no longer owns them, where Indy can heal from his insecurities and mistakes, where Alan can face his own faults and soften some of the defenses he has built around himself and where they can finally look at each other without anger and hurting each other. After everything I think that would be a beautiful kind of victory for both of them. :)
2026-09-04 21:45

Thruster_Check

Get on youtube and look up "Mr. Businessman" by Ray Stevens

Random old smuck

I’ve met many people just like that even people I know extremely well care about.

Random old smuck

I can definitely understand why you read it that way, especially since Alan’s comments about Indy’s clothing and behavior clearly became hurtful and humiliating. Where I differ is in seeing evidence that Alan entered the relationship with an agenda to turn Indy into a higher society showpiece. That conclusion seems to go somewhat beyond what Indy actually tells us. We know Alan was attracted to him, asked him out, welcomed him into his home and remained with him long enough for the relationship to become serious. To me, that suggests genuine affection rather than Alan merely wanting Indy for some undisclosed purpose. The difference between them appears to have become more difficult once their private relationship began colliding with Alan’s social world. Alan may have felt embarrassed, anxious about appearances or unable to reconcile the person he loved privately with the expectations surrounding him publicly. None of that makes his insulting remarks acceptable but it does make the situation more human and complicated than a calculated effort to remake Indy. I actually talk about all of this in my post. It may also be that Alan initially believed their differences would not matter and only discovered later that he was not as comfortable with them as he thought he would be. I am also hesitant to assume that Alan’s friends were criticizing Indy behind his back since we have not met them or heard what they actually said. They may have exerted social pressure, but that remains an open question. The pressure might even have come largely from Alan’s own insecurity about how the relationship appeared to others. That would still have hurt Indy, but it would tell us something quite different about Alan’s motives. I agree that Indy was becoming increasingly unhappy and that the relationship was no longer giving either of them what it once had. At the same time I do not believe the available information presents Indy as simply absorbing Alan’s frustration with nowhere for it to go. Alan says that they fought and we already know that one of those conflicts eventually became physical. That does not erase the emotional pain Alan caused him but it does mean the deterioration cannot fairly be understood from only one side. As for Pen and Indy, I suspect their attraction runs considerably deeper than physical infatuation. Pen appears to find a sense of safety, acceptance and emotional ease with Indy, while Indy seems able to relax around Pen without feeling judged according to standards he cannot or does not want to meet. Whether that will remain enough once Pen’s life and social position change is a thoughtful question but their willingness to accept one another as they are may give them something Alan and Indy gradually lost. That is why I am also eager to hear the rest of the story. This page gives us important context but it feels more like the beginning of an explanation than the final verdict on either individual. :)

Lennon

Oh yes, this is definitely a major lore drop! And I’m right there with you about wanting to hear the rest of Indy’s story, because this page has filled in several important gaps while opening up even more questions. I also agree that Alan’s comments about Indy’s clothing and behavior were judgmental, hurtful and clearly contributed to Indy’s unhappiness. However, I am not ready to say that this establishes Alan’s entire personality as controlling. There is a meaningful difference between someone deliberately setting out to control his partner and someone who genuinely loves his partner but handles insecurity, social pressure and embarrassment in a very damaging way. Alan’s remarks were wrong either way but we still need more of their history before deciding exactly what was happening within the relationship. The one part I see differently is the possibility that Alan must have pushed Indy far too hard or threatened him before Indy hit him. We have not been shown Alan threatening Indy and Alan is considerably smaller and physically weaker. Indy also calls what he did awful, which sounds much more like remorse than someone describing an unavoidable act of self protection. Alan may have said something cruel or deeply upsetting immediately before it happened, but being pushed emotionally does not make physically striking someone inevitable. I would rather hear the missing part of the story before placing responsibility for Indy’s reaction onto Alan. Indy absolutely can be calm, affectionate and reassuring with Pen, and I believe those qualities are genuine. At the same time the gentle individual Pen knows and the person who lost control with Alan can both be real parts of Indy. That complexity does not make Indy evil or mean Pen cannot feel safe with him. It simply means his tenderness toward Pen should not cause us to minimize what happened to Alan or assume that Alan must have provoked it or simply deserved it. I am definitely looking forward to what comes next too. This page has made their history feel much more human and complicated than a simple division between a controlling Alan and a calm protective Indy, and I suspect we still have a great deal left to learn about both of them. :)

Lennon

Let’s please not condone violence.

Thruster_Check

Well put as always, Doc, but at least one thing still bothers me (and might get answered on a subsequent page) ... just a gut feeling here, but I have lingering doubts about Indy's past involvement with the police being as severe as Alan made it out to be. That seems like just the sort of thing Alan would use to dissuade Pen. Maybe we'll find out. As to your hoping for Alan and Indy to eventually reach some kind of peace with each other, I don't see much likelihood of that; it's only been a matter of weeks at most since the fountain incident, and of course this is still the very same day Alan approached Pen. That kind of change seldom happens in a hurry; in fact it might often be a regret expressed by people who are dying. Always to be hoped for, though, for the sake of peace.

Lennon

I understand what you mean, although I do not believe Alan necessarily began the relationship with the intention of changing Indy. When Alan first saw him I doubt he was already thinking, “I want to turn this guy into somebody else.” Alan was clearly attracted to Indy as he was, asked him out, continued seeing him and eventually trusted him enough to invite him into his home. That suggests genuine affection rather than some calculated renovation project. This was more likely a gradual process. Differences that seem charming or unimportant at the beginning of a relationship can become sources of tension once two individuals begin sharing a home, attending social events together, and becoming involved in each other’s wider lives. Alan may initially have admired Indy’s relaxed, unpolished nature because it was so different from his own carefully ordered world. Later, when Indy was around Alan’s friends or in settings where Alan felt conscious of appearances, those same differences may have begun triggering embarrassment, insecurity or social pressure. That does not make Alan’s comments harmless. Being repeatedly criticized over clothing or behavior would understandably leave Indy feeling that the someone who once accepted him had gradually become ashamed of him. I simply do not think we have enough evidence to conclude that Alan asked Indy out as part of a deliberate plan to reshape him into an ideal partner. To me, this looks much more human and unfortunate than that: Alan genuinely fell in love with Indy, but as their lives became more intertwined Alan began handling their differences in ways that were judgmental and hurtful. It was not necessarily his intention from the beginning but sadly it eventually became part of what damaged their relationship permanently.

Lennon

Was this meant as a response for me? I am guessing it was, since you said Doc and referred to my hope for Alan and Indy, although it did not appear beneath my post as a reply. You may be right that the full story will give us more context about Indy’s past involvement with the police. I am certainly open to that possibility. My only hesitation is with assuming that Alan exaggerated it specifically to dissuade Pen. Alan knew Indy intimately, lived with him and was in a much better position than Pen to know what had happened in Indy’s past. Unless later pages give us a reason to doubt his account, I do not feel comfortable treating it as dishonest simply because the information could discourage Pen. Alan may have wanted Pen to reconsider the relationship but that does not necessarily mean the warning itself was untrue. Both things could be true at once. As for Alan and Indy eventually finding peace, I agree that a complete reconciliation would be unlikely within the few weeks covered by the present story. Their emotions are still raw, the fountain confrontation happened recently and Alan approached Pen earlier that very day. I am not expecting them suddenly to resolve all of their pain before nightfall. The story could eventually move forward in time, though, or give us a later scene showing that the first small steps toward peace have been taken. The reason I hope to see that ending is not because I want Alan and Indy to resume their romantic relationship, (which we already know will not happen) or pretend that nothing happened at all. I want both individuals to acknowledge the ways they hurt one another. Indy physically hurt someone he once loved and a sincere apology from him would acknowledge that without excuses while showing genuine growth. Alan also needs to recognize that his criticism of Indy’s appearance and behavior was extremely hurtful and that repeatedly making someone feel inadequate or embarrassed can cause considerable emotional damage. While Alan’s actions should not be used to justify the violence against him, but they should still be addressed honestly. That is the ending I hope for because it would allow both of them to accept responsibility without reducing either of them to the worst thing he has done. It would give Alan the recognition and closure he needs while also giving Indy the opportunity to explain how Alan’s behavior affected him and to receive an honest apology in return. Neither would be declared entirely innocent or entirely at fault. They would simply recognize the pain between them, forgive what they are able to forgive and finally release one another from a relationship that had become harmful to both of them. Most importantly, that kind of peace would allow Pen and Indy’s future to rest upon honesty rather than an unresolved wound from the past. It would reinforce what I find most compelling about this story: these are flawed, realistic people who have hurt one another but do not have to remain frozen forever in the worst period of their lives. That sort of change may require time, but I sincerely hope neither of them must wait until the end of his life to express the regret, forgiveness or kindness that could help both of them heal.

Lennon

There’s something important to remember here, these are clearly not concurrent memories, Indy’s speaking about different things throughout a span of time and place. Alan didn’t make a cute joke then turn around and bash Indy in the next breath, they happened at very different times during their relationship, very likely months apart.

Foxtrot

LORE DUMP YAY :D

Foxtrot

Did Indy just stop wanting to wear his peircings?

Equinox

I am super glad I got Patreon.. my heart couldn’t handle waiting weeks to see what happened next. And from the start I knew Alan was gonna be trouble and it seems I guessed correctly

Thruster_Check

Yes, this was directed at you; sorry I botched it up; I know I could have fixed it. I very much like your final paragraph!

Thruster_Check

I generally do too, especially the nice leather jacket he wore to Trotters. I do *not* like that hat. I think it looks silly because it looks a couple sizes too small.

Random old smuck

That part means a great deal to me because I believe love, kindness and forgiveness are among the few things in this life powerful enough to reach backward without asking us to remain trapped in the past. We cannot undo every painful moment but we can choose whether pain becomes the final word. There is something beautiful in choosing peace when bitterness would be easier, in offering kindness where anger once lived and in allowing forgiveness to soften what time alone could never heal. Forgiveness does not erase what happened, nor does it ask us to pretend that wounds never existed. It simply means refusing to let those wounds decide what comes next. Life is too brief to leave every apology unspoken and every kindness un given and every chance for grace buried beneath pride or sorrow. Love does not always remain in the form in which it began but that does not mean it has to disappear completely. Sometimes it becomes compassion, understanding, mercy or the quiet hope that someone who once mattered finds peace. Perhaps that is one of the most beautiful things love can become. Not possession, not obligation, not the need to return to what once was but the ability to look back without hatred, to remember without being consumed by pain and to carry forward something gentler than what was left behind.

Random poster

I see how you feel and why Alan’s behavior would make someone angry. Some of what he says is cutting and there are moments where his concern with appearance and social expectations becomes very nasty. Those things deserve criticism on their own terms. Both a person and a relationship can be damaged deeply by words, by embarrassment, by repeated criticism and by making someone feel that who they are is somehow not acceptable enough. But none of that makes physical violence an acceptable response morally or legally. Cruel, insulting, judgmental, or humiliating words are terrible and they can and do cause serious emotional damage that shouldn’t be overlooked, however they do not create a lawful right to strike someone. Anger is not self defense. Humiliation is not self defense. Feeling emotionally pushed to a breaking point is not self defense. Hurtful treatment can explain anger, pain, or resentment, but it does not make physical violence an acceptable response. Hitting someone because of what they said crosses a fundamentally different line. That distinction matters because responsibility should remain with the action that was actually chosen. Alan can and should be held accountable for the pain he caused by his words, but he also should be without being held responsible for Indy choosing physical force on him. Recognizing that does not require turning either of them into a monster, it just allows each action to be seen clearly for what it was without one wrong being used to cancel out another out. There’s a quiet strength in reaching the point where pain can be acknowledged without continually being fed. Forgiveness allows room for growth, for understanding and for the possibility that someone can be more than the worst thing they have said or done. It does not demand closeness nor does it require forgetting. Sometimes forgiveness simply means refusing to keep carrying an old injury as though setting it down would somehow make the injury less real. Hatred can feel strangely protective because it convinces us that holding tightly to anger keeps us safe from being hurt again. But hatred has a way of preserving the very wound we are trying to escape. The longer it is carried, the more space it begins to occupy, until the past is no longer merely remembered but continually lived inside. But forgiveness offers something different. It allows the past to remain true without allowing it to remain in control. There is something profoundly freeing about being able to say, this hurt me, this mattered, this should not have happened and still choosing not to spend the rest of life chained to it. Pain deserves to be acknowledged but it does not deserve to become a permanent home.

Lennon

I know this is meant to be a joke and I’m a wrestling fan too, all be it a generation or two older than the attitude area. ;) But real life isn’t a wrestling match so let’s please not condone violence. :)

Dark Arkkon

First off, let me say this: Falco & Maui, your work is incredible. Not just the art or the character designs. The story and the story telling are truly excellent. You only have to look at the volume, length and complexity in the comments to see that. Excellent work, my friend! I'm also of the opinion (so far) that Indy and Alan's relationship was genuine in the beginning, and probably for a long time. Most couples don't move in together after only a few weeks. But in my opinion, the true test of most relationships begins with cohabitation. And it's very easy for the relationship to undergo new challenges and for unknown/overlooked incompatibilities to become significant. I'm also of the opinion that this could very easily be a 'mistakes were made on both sides' situation. This comic does an incredible job of feeling more like 'real life,' which vary rarely has a 100% villian and a 100% hero/victim. It absolutely happens, but it's not the norm. Usually it's just flawed people, dealing with life and their own realities, making mistakes and learning as they go. And to be clear, I am 100% team Indy. I don't believe that he and Alan are equally to blame. I believe that Alan treated Indy worse than Indy treated Alan. I just think it's usually not all or nothing. I do believe Indy made a mistake, and I believe he can still be a very good person and learn and grow, just like all of us can. Extreme situations can result in extreme reactions. That doesn't mean that he's completely unsafe, or even that an equally extreme situation is guaranteed with Pen. It also doesn't mean that Indy would behave the same way now, even if it did. And I can't wait to see what happens next! :) I do want to mention one more thing, as I've seen it come up a few times in the comments. Physical violence is deplorable. Definitely. But I consider severe verbal violence to be equally as deplorable, and it can often have more severe and more permanent consequences. In either case, I believe the right response, if things begin escalating to unsafe/unhealthy levels, is to remove yourself from the situation, if at all possible. But if not, I believe there are some scenarios where self-defense can include defense from severe verbal abuse as well. I don't personally believe one form of violence is inherently more permissible than the other. But I'm also completely open to changing my opinion. That's just where I'm at right now. :)

Lennon

Thank you for taking the time to write all of this out. I actually agree with a great deal of what you are saying here, especially about how human this story feels and how relationships can become complicated without either person necessarily being reduced to a villain. I also appreciate the way you are looking at both Alan and Indy as imperfect people who were capable of loving one another while also hurting one another because that is very close to how I have been reading their relationship as well. Moving in together can certainly expose differences that were much easier to overlook while dating, and I suspect that is going to be very important to understanding how things deteriorated between them. There is really only one part of your comment that I would approach a little differently and that concerns comparing severe emotional or verbal violence with physical violence, particularly when the subject of self defense enters the discussion. I want to be very careful about that distinction because I absolutely do not believe emotional abuse is trivial, harmless, or something people should simply tolerate. Quite the opposite. Emotional abuse can be devastating. It can destroy someone’s self confidence, alter the way they perceive themselves and other people, leave them frightened or hypervigilant long after a relationship has ended, and create wounds that can take years to understand and work through. Sometimes those wounds remain with people for the rest of their lives. I have been through both physical and emotional violence myself, so emotional pain is certainly not something I am looking at from a distance. I have also tried to help many other people dealing with these experiences on a professional level, and I have seen just how deeply emotional mistreatment can affect someone. I have tremendous sympathy for anyone who has lived through sustained humiliation, degradation, manipulation, intimidation, or emotional cruelty. A person does not need bruises or blood for what happened to them to be serious, damaging, or deserving of compassion and support. However, recognizing how severe emotional violence can become does not require treating it as interchangeable with physical violence. Physical violence introduces something additional into the situation, the deliberate use of bodily force against another person, together with the immediate possibility of injury, permanent disability, or even death. It also crosses a very basic boundary within a relationship, the expectation that anger, disagreement, humiliation, or emotional pain will not result in one person’s body being physically harmed by the other. That does not mean emotional wounds are automatically less painful or less lasting. In some people’s lives, the emotional damage may remain far longer than a physical injury. The distinction is not about deciding which person’s suffering counts more. It is about recognizing that the two forms of harm operate differently and therefore cannot always be treated as though they are the same thing. That becomes particularly important when we use the term self defense. Self defense means using proportionate force to stop an immediate physical threat to yourself or another person. Severe emotional or verbal mistreatment can absolutely justify leaving the situation, ending the relationship, establishing firm boundaries, seeking help or refusing further contact. What it does not do is transform physically striking another person into an act of self defense either morally or legally. The problem is that emotional injury is deeply personal and subjective. A statement that one person finds upsetting might be devastating to another because of their history, vulnerabilities, or circumstances. Their pain can be completely genuine but if emotional pain by itself becomes sufficient justification for physical force, there is no reliable boundary left. Almost anyone who lashes out physically could then argue that the other person’s words hurt, humiliated, angered, or overwhelmed them enough to justify the response. That is also why I can have considerable sympathy for what Indy appears to have experienced with Alan while still keeping the assault separate. Alan’s criticism of Indy’s clothing, behavior, and social presentation was clearly hurtful, and I have no desire whatsoever to minimize what repeatedly feeling inadequate or embarrassing to someone you love can do to a person. Indy deserves compassion for that pain, and Alan’s behavior can be criticized honestly where the story supports it. At the same time, that emotional harm does not have to become a justification for Indy physically hurting Alan in order for us to take Indy’s suffering seriously. We are capable of holding both truths at once. Indy could have been deeply hurt by the way Alan treated him, while Alan could still have been wrongfully physically hurt by Indy. So I think we are actually very close in how we see the larger picture. Emotional abuse deserves to be taken extremely seriously, and the people who endure it deserve enormous sympathy, understanding, and support. The important distinction is between recognizing emotional harm as profound and treating emotional and physical violence as equivalent when deciding whether physical force becomes permissible in response. And since you mentioned Falco don’t forget Maui too, they’re the writer and character designer behind these both Alan and Indy. But both of them definitely deserve credit for making the story and its characters feel as human as they do. :) I really appreciate that you said you are open to changing your opinion as more of the story is revealed. I also try to approach these pages the same way. Every new piece of context gives us an opportunity to reconsider what we previously believed, strengthen some conclusions, weaken others and hopefully understand both Alan and Indy a little better as people.

Dark Arkkon

Thank you for the reminder about Maui! I completely missed that. I updated the comment. Also, thanks for sharing your thoughts on the physical assult vs verbal assault. I read your other comments as well. And I appreciate your perspective. I'm considering what you've said. I'll continue to ponder on it. And to clarify, I was speaking entirely from a moral stance, not legally. I understand that there is very little legal protection against emotional or verbal damage, and I understand the subjective nature makes that extremely challenging, if not impossible. It's unfortunate, but true. And I'm also speaking more about specific circumstances and interactions between the people involved in the specific situation/conflict. I recognize that it's incredibly difficult to assess the severity of the relative 'damage' to those involved from the outside, after the fact. I was speaking more about within a given situation/conflict, I don't personally believe that the person who attacked physically is necessarily the 'worse' person in the conflict. And every detail is extremely important. I don't think it's right to say, well this person was verbally attacking and this person punched them, so the one who punched is automatically a worse person. I believe that there are levels of verbal abuse and levels of physical violence that can viewed as equal from a moral perspective, but the exact circumstances, situation, individuals, etc. must all be considered. But I do understand what you're saying about the disability/death risks (even unintentional) that physical violence presents. And also I am considering that there are severe, long-lasting and sometimes equally as debilitating consequences possible from verbal assault as well.

Dr. Cosmo Kaufman

I’ve been thinking about something for the past few days and this new page helped me put the pieces together enough to reach a possible conclusion that I wanted to share. I left it out of my longer post because that one was mostly focused on what we actually know, while this is purely speculation. I’m not arguing that any of this is proven fact or that it must be where the story is going, but I feel it’s worth thinking about nonetheless. It’s simply a possibility that keeps coming back to me whenever I look at the timeline, so take it with a grain of salt and keep an open mind. ;) What this new page gives me is a really useful emotional baseline for Alan which I will now use as fact. I can clearly see how Indy remembers him when he was genuinely happy and comfortable. His eyes soften or close, his cheeks lift, his smile spreads naturally and his posture becomes relaxed and open. When he is affectionate he’s comfortable being physically close to Indy. When he becomes uncomfortable or irritated, his brows lower, his eyes narrow, his mouth tightens and his gestures become sharper. Seeing these different sides of Alan on one page makes it much easier for me to compare his later expressions (past pages) and body language instead of reading every panel in isolation. That is part of what made me look at the fountain scene along with his interactions with Pen later on a lot differently. At the fountain scene Alan first appears confused with widened eyes and raised brows, then becomes urgent enough to try to stop Indy from leaving as he grabs Indy’s coat sleeve. Then when Indy turns on him, Alan immediately recoils in shock. But after he notices Pen his posture seems to sink and he walks away looking genuinely hurt. Now that this new page has shown me what Alan looks like when he is relaxed, happy, affectionate, uncomfortable, and upset, that emotional progression at the fountain stands out much more clearly than it did before. So I keep wondering whether Indy could still have been seeing Alan in some capacity while he was also becoming close to Pen. Alan believed they were on a break while Indy called Alan “a fella I know,” and yet Alan had apparently heard quite a lot about Pen anyway. If Indy and Alan were still physically, emotionally or sexually involved in some sort of way, their very well could been very different understandings of what their relationship still was. Alan’s reaction at the fountain could then be the moment he realized that Indy’s relationship with Pen was much more serious than he had initially understood. Again, this is only speculation and none of it has been proven. Future pages could take the story somewhere completely different, that’s the fun of it. I just find it an interesting possibility because this new page gave me some emotional reference points that helps me connect a few more dots. :)

Lennon

I’ve noticed that you’ve edited your response to me after your initial response and changed several key things that made me remove my original response of praise. I’ll just say this, thank you for reading my posts.

Equinox

I love Indy’s look it’s distinct to him, but wanting someone to change how they dress is a huge red flag I’m glad Indy go out of that relation with Alan

OR-69

Why assume he is an evil genius? We haven’t ruled out the possibility that he’s just another idiot that took a good thing for granted and ruined it as a result. That does seem to be a common cause of failed relationships.

Marcwolf

Sadly I have seen too many times where a woman gets a boyfriend can considers him to be a "Renovation Project" I.e. he'd be perfect once he stops smoking, seeing those annoying friends, get rid of the video games, climbs the corporate ladder etc etc.. If the guy is too passive and goes along she will resent him for that.. or if he pushes back then he does not care about her opinions... Personally I find Tolerance is the best solution and Pen and Indy are tolerent of each others differences.

Thruster_Check

Doc, You said: "And that makes what happened after Indy hit him particularly interesting. "If Alan genuinely wanted to destroy Indy, make his life miserable, or exercise some grand campaign of revenge against him, he appears to have had an almost perfect opportunity. Alan had been injured. Police involvement was apparently already on the table. Alan himself tells us that Indy could not afford another criminal charge and that he was able to get the police department to let the matter go. Somebody with money, education, social standing and access to legal resources could have made that situation extraordinarily unpleasant for Indy if revenge was Alan’s objective. Instead, according to what Alan tells us he actually helped prevent Indy from facing another charge." I'm trying to understand Alan's motive here too, and one possibility I see is that when he found himself on the floor, he realized that he actually HAD been abusing Indy, and that his way of trying to compensate was to dissuade the police. Somehow they never managed to make up, and I assume Indy moved out pretty much immediately after. This could shed a different light on the fountain incident, with Alan trying to apologize to Indy and not getting the chance to say much of anything. Now ask, what was Alan's upbringing like? Can you hear a constant stream of criticism, like, "Sit up straight at the table," "You're holding your knife/fork/spoon wrong," "Don't talk with your mouth full," "Tuck your shirt in," and so on? If Alan truly does lack self-confidence, this--being constantly corrected and rarely if ever complimented--could be a reason. And now I can't help thinking we're seriously gonna need to hear Alan's full story, from his own mouth ... *that * is gonna need another meeting, with others in attendance besides the three principal characters.

Marcwolf

The big issue is the word "Hit"... which can have all levels of force applied. Was it a full round-house fist on a jaw.. oe was it something as minor as tapping away a reaching paw.. I guess the story will play out - but when one is playing a victim, framing something in the worse possible light for emotional effect is a very common thing. I noted thar Alan did not say that Indy Beat him...

Lennon

I think the factual evidence should be separated from the terminology debate. The evidence is that Alan was physically struck in the head by his partner and was shown injured, laying on the floor and bleeding from his face afterwards.. Whether that is described as being “hit” or “beaten” is a question of wording but it does not change the underlying facts or the seriousness of the incident. The terminology should not be used to minimize what happened or distract from the evidence of domestic violence. The page I am referring to is Chapter 5, page 17.

Alex

Personal, life-long experience with a manipulator and narcissist in one. Which is why I said that I'll be very surprised if Alan isn't one. Because he acts and does things just like them.

Dark Arkkon

I only added Maui to my kudos. Thanks pointing that out. :) I didn't change anything else, but I should probably just remove the stuff about physical vs verbal attacks. I don't think it's actually useful to anyone.

MetalExveemon

Excellent points, although Indy said they dated for only 5 months, so it's more likely that these remarks didn't have such a big gap between them.

Ebonmere Art

Asks out a new guy straight into town with no close attachments, quickly isolates him by asking him to move in after what we know is less than 5 months, starts to degrade their individuality by denegrading their choice of clothes and choosing their friend groups. Oh Alan you're starting to smell awfully like coersive control = v=

Lennon

Where exactly is the line between coercive control and ordinary disagreement? If disliking a partner’s clothes is automatically coercive control, does every argument about appearance qualify? If disliking certain friends proves isolation, does every disagreement over friendships become abusive? Coercive control requires a broader pattern of domination, restriction, intimidation or loss of autonomy. Without that pattern, disagreement and coercive control are not the same thing.

Judas Hyena

Forgive me, but I actually dig Indy's fit. He actually looks good in it, and it kinda feels "fitting" (ba-dum tsch!) for him given his demeanor and accent.

Lennon

I agree but I can also kinda understand Alan at the same time, although he handled it very inappropriately. There’s nothing to reference the actual occasion to have a better understanding of the expectation. Was this just a trip to the grocery store or was it something that would require a more formal dress code for example?

Judas Hyena

I understand what you mean. Of course dress code is important for specific occasions. However, taking their interaction and Indy's explanation at face value, it seems that Alan may have been self conscious about Indy for a while.

Lennon

Oh, of course, I agree. That’s why I included the caveat that the way it was handled was very inappropriate. :)

Thruster_Check

Just FYI, in paragraph 26 of the above I got stopped by: "Indy is much more extroverted, outgoing, and naturally social, while I am far more introverted, shy, and very quiet in person. Even so there are plenty of things about him that feel familiar to me. We share that unmistakable Southern accent, *we’re both cigarette smokers* and we both dress in relaxed non-fashionable clothing." Sorry, but I just went over the entire comic, and found zero instances of Indy smoking anything at all. I had to check. Further, as far as I can tell, tobacco does not exist in any form anywhere in Circle City. I don't think there are even any NO SMOKING signs anywhere. The decorative piece on Indy's hat suggests he might be amenable to sampling a little ganja, but we haven't seen that either--yet.

Lennon

Why are you quoting paragraph numbers from something I wrote? Do I smoke? Yes. Does Indy smoke? Also yes. That is shown in multiple pinups of Indy and in Autumn Fever on pages 10 and 11, so there is nothing particularly mysterious or disputed about that statement. So again, I am asking plainly because I find all of this very concerning: what exactly are you doing here and what point are you trying to make by numbering and then singling out an entire paragraph of my post for this kind of pedantic scrutiny over trivial details? Are you seriously going through everything I have written word by word looking for some minor discrepancy you can seize upon?

Equinox

Send him to hueco mundo…

Equinox

Tell me about it.. Alan dresses WAY worse than Indy atleast Indy looks good the way he dresses

Panda

This is very true

wolvesday7

I hate where this is gonna go, but it is nice to see that Indy has always been the same adorable doggo dude even before meeting Pen 💙

Reagent

There is something amusingly reassuring getting the alternating "Will they survive the early trials of their relationship??" comic and the "Oh yeah they're going at it months/years later" comic in the same week