Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Videos

Content

PDM interviews Trevor Duvall of Me, Myself, and Die about his new TTRPG, The Broken Empires.

Files

Previews only

Broken Empires

Comments

MrGunn

Gotta get up early to get a Bagel, man! 🤣🤣🤣

Rod Thomson

PDM scores another critical hit on my bank account! Just Kickstarted Broken Empires. Really looking forward to it!

Steven Sweet

So looking forward to BEs! It's helping us simulationists come out of the shadows with the current trend of rules-lighter-and-lighter. I think a good portion of players actually lean towards skill based systems without realizing it which is why skills creep into many class based systems when they've been around long enough. Particularly if the system is above some nebulous complexity level in terms of overall rules and mechanics. Dead simple class based systems (like Deathbringer) are more likely to stay skill-less but once the rest of the game begins to have rules for nuance and circumstance based modifiers, players want it too. Thanks for coming to my TED Talk.

Firstspear

The combat does feel a lot like WFRP without the location/critical tables (I may have misunderstood). Something worth exploring.

Marc Acosta

Off topic but super stoked that Elemental Storm hit the tier where you get to design a monster

A Name Apart

Current DnD is current Hollywood: tons of diverse people walking around multicultural metropolises with magic phones

Jared Davis

I'm a player and GM who loves to tinker with game mechanics. I normally shy away from any system with considerable crunch. Shadowrun 5th edition broke my will to learn different "equations" for action resolution. Broken Empires is the first RPG I've seen since then that's more on the simulationist side with an effort to keep the action flowing. I definitely get what Trevor was saying about rules-lite games placing a burden on the GM to bring them to life. I've run into that during D&D, Cairn, Mork Borg, Dungeon World, and other PbtA RPGs. I'm genuinely excited for the eventual release of his game.

David Ford

PDM, why do you hate my bank account? Here I go backing another KickStarter 😉 On a more serious note the game system sounds very cool. The travel and social interactions kinda remind me of The One Ring’s Journey and Council rules. Looking forward to this.

Scott

Seems like a neat system.

David Lake

Listening to the two of you talk about what you love or want in your fantasy setting is so refreshing, as is hearing what you inherently find lacking in the new tone and setting of D&D. After years of playing at what feels like the proverbial “kids table at Thanksgiving,” I finally find out there is a grown up table out there! Not just another fantastic review, but I could listen to the two of you wax on game setting philosophy any time.

James C

I’m really glad and impressed you showcase other independent creators and their crowdfunding. It really helps people like me to learn about other games. I backed Shadowdark because you mentioned it and I plan to do the same for Broken Empires. And don’t you worry, I have money set aside for Deathbringer once you begin fundraising. I enjoyed Trevor’s enthusiasm and enjoyed the interview. And I loved the debate and game building at the end.

Glenn Fleetwood

I've backed it, hard. Looks like just the kind of system I would create for myself.

Jay

Just what I needed, another Kickstarter I can't resist supporting. Think this might be the last one for a while. Too many games and never enough time for them all. I want to avoid any more unnecessary spending and reduce my physical library to the games I use most. Therefore, I best make this the last game I support for 2024. Anyway, this was a great interview and with some interesting points to be made regarding game mechanics. I never really liked putting the nebulous idea of putting all the onus on the players or GM to explain precisely what happens when a character hits the monster and reduces their hit points yet there is the blaringly obvious lack of a mechanical effect on the so-called injured monster until the last hp is gone. While some GM’s might describe jamming a blade into a monster while it lets out a horrible cry of pain, often it has zero real mechanical effect that should accompany the injury as described. The baddies are still essentially functioning as if they were never injured at all right down to the last Hit Point. The best analogy I can see here is the movie “Monty Python and the Holy Grail” where the Black Knight has all of his limbs chopped off and is still demanding a fight as if uninjured. It’s no different that the GM saying the Hero chops off the Orcs head, yet it still has 1 HP remaining and the body still fights on still functioning as if nothing happened. Laughing as I type that because that is HP as you can assign any narrative you want to injury as there are no mechanical repercussions baked into the rules. Yes! ridiculously funny. In my opinion, any claim of injury without the mechanical effect that goes with that injury is worse than the so-called death spirals some people may complain about. As for my players and myself, described injury without repercussions removes verisimilitude. I mean really, have you ever banged your shin, injured a limb, or stepped on a piece of Lego barefoot. Such things have an immediate effect on a real person’s ability to function anywhere from a few seconds to a few days depending upon the severity of injury. My solution to this for the games I run that use HP is to never describe any form of severe injury until the last 10 - 20% of HP is remaining for that affected combatant. At that point I will prescribe an actual mechanical effect to go with that type of injury circumstances involved. Otherwise, the HP lost is shrugged off as hitting armor, loss of stamina or grit, the luck of a near miss, or anything but an actual injury other than bumps, bruises, or being shaken until the telling blow that does anything consequential. Actual described injuries of serious bodily harm should include fractured or dislocated bones, deep cuts, torn members of the body, damage to internal organs or other life-threatening injuries. Full disclosure, the ideas for my solution stem from games such as Palladium Fantasy, Outgunned, and various other games that do precisely this if not something similar and it has worked out just fine for my games. Just my two cents on HP and narrative for what that’s worth. As for the way he describes the magic system in Broken Empires, that is what hooked me as I haven’t read Ars Magica which is where he seems to draw his inspiration. I would like magic to be mysterious while providing a reason for players to go out and seek the knowledge to wield it. Spell books, Tomes, scrolls, provide a good reason for magic users to leave the library and seek out such treasures. This was my only issue with EZD6 as players could make up spells on the fly but never game them a reason to seek magic knowledge from books or treasures without some contrived mental gymnastics as to why they should. I decided they needed books and scrolls to learn spells outside of their path or to find or research ritual spells. Otherwise, I feel magic users would never have a reason to go adventuring. Lastly, I completely agree with Trevor Duvall that if everyone and their dog is sneezing out spells then it is no longer special, mysterious, or magical. The same goes for the point he made about the world being tied to something relatable. I primarily use humans in my games because that is what we are, and everyone knows there are countless variations of those from diverse cultures and ancestries throughout the world. If a player is allowed to play something other than human, it’s because that species is rare, and they will be treated as special in that single regard. Anyway, happy to have backed another independent creator with good ideas.