Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Videos

Content

PDM on Jon Peterson's book "The Elusive Shift" and why NOT teaching players the rules may make for a better game.

Files

Previews only

Elusive Shift

Comments

Bagel-Man

Exited to watch! My birthday just got better

Enishi X

Very excited about deathbringer coming out.

A Name Apart

Since modern DnD has a lot of combat it is only natural for players to optimize and make their character as powerful as possible. That can crowd out other kinds of role playing (sneaking, convincing, exploring, building).

Evil Chad

Bring on... THE DEATHBRINGER... Can't wait.

Elvis Ramone

Personally I really like the OSE Advanced Fantasy take on B/X + AD&D. The unshackling of race and class just has a better feel in my opinion. The only additional rule from AD&D I would use is fighter attacks, where the progression is to 3/2 at 7th and 2/1 at 13th, as there is no exceptional strength. Just to help with the linear fighters quadratic magic users issue, where thieves also have a super stab in reserve and practically no use limit.

Scott

I frequently flip flop when my groups switch games as to how simple or complex I'm in the mood for. Just can't pick a side I guess.

The Mando Commando

I've run a one shot with Deathbringer and our table had a blast. I ran Horrors on the Hill using Shadowdark as well, we finished the campaign in 7 sessions spanning 3 months and the players loved the creative freedom of the rules lite approach to the ampersand game

Graham Kane

Can't wait for the comments when this one drops on YT! also, roll on Deathbringer!

madcurry

This is essentially how I interact with my players. Very few of them have time to read rule books outside of game sessions. They still have their character sheets, but I encourage them to just tell me what their character is doing. As long as they know whether they are rolling D20 or D100 for the core mechanic, they are good to go. This works especially well with Call of Cthulhu and helps keep the focus on horror and mystery. The same approach is also good for DCC. They keep asking about playing 5e D&D. I’m holding off until they can commit to reading some of the rules!

MrGunn

@Bagel-Man Exited? Were you in class and had to leave the room to watch this post, that is dedication? 😁 I hope you found this post exciting. 🤣🤣🤣

MrGunn

@Scott All good, variety is the spice of life. Sometimes you want a hamburger, some times you want steak, sometimes you want chicken, other evenings sushi, and you never want anchovies on your pizza. 😀

Cee-Jay

Most of my players don't own the full official rules and spend little to no time worrying about the mechanics of their classes. This is mostly good, except actually I need them to be a little more involved so they know what they heck they are doing. Running multiple campaigns in multiple systems (OSE/5e/DCC), it's not feasible for me to memorize everything to play RAW... this is especially an issue with DCC which modules generally expect 6-10 players and which rules have so many tables for magic, deities, crit fumbles/successes. Now obviously it's my choice to want to learn to play these RAW, so in part I'm the creator of this burden. It's the benefit, and the curse, of having mostly very casual players. That said, my plan is to consolidate my three games into one open world in Q1 of next year with SD as the foundational system but with minor customizations around the edges, some borrowed from DCC and BECMI, many borrowed from PDM. Having one system with one set of house rules will really streamline things, making it far easier for me to take on the extra load of having the answers. And when your players aren't rules lawyers and aren't trying to optimize in game breaking ways, it's much easier to run the game actually. PS: Nothing wrong if you like min-max, strategic rules optimization style of play. Just that for me and my players, usually we have the most fun with randomness and off-the-wall creative solutions.

Chuck Thorin

Can't wait for the Deathbring RPG. And James Spahn is good people.

Chris Thomason

I did this and still am with my DCC group (running for about 18 months now) that is mostly comprised of people that don’t play any other table top games. It all just comes natural to them. The only ones that have had any problems at all are those that play boardgames and especially those that have played other TTRPGS.

TwinDad

I want to play in w Professor Dungeon Master game…