Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Videos

Content

PDM reviews the new DM's Guide. Should you buy it?

'

Files

Previews only

DM's Guide

Comments

Chad Wilkerson

Will watch as soon as I get home from church. 🥰

Enishi X

Great video Dungeon Craft! Seems they took out the optional rules like lingering injuries.

MrGunn

Baaaagel-Maaan, where are you???? 🤣

Rod Thomson

I've decided to add a Realtors' Guild and HOA fees to my campaign. They will become the ultimate nemeses, owning all the good property and forcing the other guilds into bankruptcy... muah-ha-ha-ha! Thanks for your honest review of the new DMG!

MrGunn

Dear PDM, Finally vindicated, pshaw, you don't need vindication from Wizbros, you are Professor Dungeon Master, you school them, not the other way round. 😉 I hope you and yours are well and thank you for reviewing the new Dungeon Master's Guide. Sounds like WotC scraped the internet for everyone else's good advice, which is fine if they gave others credit in a bibliography, which I am pretty sure they did not (please disabuse me of this notion if you can). Irrespective of my snark, advice on how to deal with toxic players is good stuff. I also agree and wish they had emphasized the DM has final say on all rulings, just like a judge/referee in a sports game. The in game timer to add tension was a good call out, surprised they missed that. Glad you liked the product. I was especially amused by the, Home Owners Association of Homlet, anecdote; did the PCs realize by creating an HOA and charging fees they became the monsters? 🤣🤣🤣 In closing, I am glad that Wizbros did create something usable for new players. Proper advice for a newbie on 'how to' become a good Dungeon Master in an 'official' product is great for the hobby, we always need more good DMs. Best regards, MrGunn PS I enjoyed the bonus content history lesson.

Steven Sweet

Just for the record ... I worked at an antarctic research station and you can play rpgs there, if you have the right crew :-)

MrGunn

@Steven Sweet Were you 'assigned' to Antarctica because you chatted up the Colonel's daughter? 🤣

Matthew Crismali

I cannot get over how much I do not like the art in these new books. I want to be able to ignore the art and focus on the other content (prose), but my eyes won't let me. *ugh*

MrGunn

@Rod Thomson 😂 Hilarious. Our HOA got after us b/c our mailbox was 'dirty', a bird had pooped on it and it was covered in yellow pine pollen. 🙄

Brent Norton

I don’t think I will pick up anything of the new Wotc stuff but this is a good review. I already have sly’s, Shadowdark, and ICRPG and your videos fill in the rest.

MrGunn

@Matthew Crismali Kind of agree, I mean the art is nice, well executed, but it feels too slick, it lacks texture.

Matthew Crismali

Yeah, when I'm playing D&D, I want wonder and excitement. Adventuring should be dangerous and the world should be a mix of Wonder and danger. I don't play D&D to bake bread or paint the landscape. The art is too pretty, and kind of boring. I don't want a pretty, boring game (that's what the art communicates to me); the art needs some grit, and communicate not only the beauty, but the dangers of the world.

Scott

Well, I was hoping for a return of the Harlot random monster encounters table, but I suppose no book can be perfect lol Good overall review, well presented with what it contains and who might be interested in it.

MrGunn

@Matthew Crismali Well said! Where's the grit, the sweat, the blood, the tears and the haunting beauty?

MrGunn

@Scott Whoo'a'ers! We need more whoo'a'ers in our games. 🤣🤣🤣

Terra Jones

For all my dislike of Hasbro, I can't say that this is a bad product at all. This is a really good book. I sure wish they didn't abusively copyright strike people who were reviewing it though. I also really wish they didn't lay off the people who wrote it.

Bagel-Man

I’ve already made up my mind on 5e24. Still, I’m excited to see your take on it.

Steven Sweet

That'd already happened by the time I got there. Every station I know has a closet someone has labeled "Flame Thrower Storage". It was a tradition to watch The Thing right after the last transport out left for the winter. The Shining at mid-winter and The Big Lebowski the night before the first spring transport.

madcurry

Your review is spot on. Even though I am fully invested in the likes of DCC and Shadowdark, I’m glad that I can recommend the 2024 DMG to my friends who enjoy the D&D silo. Quibbles about the homogeneity of the 2024 character classes aside, I think that is a much better book for new players as well. People having a good experience with official D&D will make it easier to trick them into trying Shadowdark or DeathBringer.

Elvis Ramone

It's good to see a DMG that is built around running the game. I absolutely love my 1E DMG and it's scattershot, half baked ideas, near unintelligible verbose language, but really would have liked something like this 40 years ago. Back in my day we Dungeon Mastered uphill, both ways, had to crack out the family 5" thick Webster's Dictionary, and use it as substitute terrain!!! In the snow....well okay, not in the snow, but you get the idea.

samurguybri

I’m guessing the “Stronghold” system is to finally give 5E players something to do with the gold they capture? It is a problem in all the systems: what to do with all that gold?

Frank Mitchell

An old school rebuild of 5e called _Into the Unknown_ made experience contingent on all the gold the PCs *wasted*, i.e. didn't spend on adventuring gear. Granted a Stronghold makes a good money sink, but so does carousing, living expenses (how many tables track those?), paying taxes, or simply giving to charity.

Frederic Schmitt

In my field of work, customer experience, we are promised the AI revolution for over 15 years now. It will take a lot of money to make AT GMing work and if so it will not be a free service, if it's any good.

Jay

Precisely my sentiments. I couldn't have said any of this better.

Jay

PDM, I enjoyed this review and will be recommending this book to a distant family member who is new to the hobby. Anything else I might add I believe I would only be echoing MrGunns post. Great job and thank you.

Bryan Stephens

Nothing published by a company lying about Gary Gygax is worth my money

Bruce Basson

TTRPG's aren't games, in the sense of players with equal starting conditions striving for tactical advantage to beat each other or the house. They are an experience. The value comes from creating an epic story of player interactions (incl. the DM). Will D&D 2024 make our storied interactions any better? Or just change the technicalities we have to remember (e.g. which spell can boost which action under what conditions)?