Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Videos

Content

Elon Musk mounts a spirited defense of Gary Gygax. PDM reports and analyzes. Let's keep it civil in the comments, please.

Files

Previews only

Musk

Comments

Bagel-Man

Wasn’t expecting this haha, excited to watch regardless

Bryan Stephens

I will never support WOTC based on their actions. Unless Musk buys them and cleans house. I guess I am a Hasbro Hater. They hate me, after all. Right back at them.

A Name Apart

I disagree with your categorical statement that the men who did not want to play DnD with women were wrong. Men are allowed to have spaces for themselves. Yes, there should be female spaces and mixed spaces as well

Bryan Stephens

Also, having Hasbro stock plummet warms my heart. Sorry it hurts unions. Laying companies should be punished.

MrGunn

Dear PDM: I hope you and your family are well. I appreciate this controversy, Wizbros needs a public pop to the chops for their crap treatment of D&D's history, IP, and D&D's fans, and while every other day of the week I am not a Musk fan, I am a fan on this day. Thanks for this. Best regards, MrGunn

Russell Miller

I understand what you are saying and I agree There is nothing wrong with wanting to hang out with the guys and enjoying guy stuff. There is nothing wrong with allowing women in, either. It's all freedom of association. Nobody should point the finger and scream sexism for that.

Scott

Well, if I was on X I would actually give Elon a thumbs up or whatever positive reinforcement they do on that platform.

A Name Apart

I don't totally agree that freedom of association is enough nor do I think that social media being judge and jury for sexism is enough. People are complex and imperfect

Frederic Schmitt

The less I see or hear from Elon, the better. I deeply dislike this guy.

Terra Jones

Twitter has always been a toilet but before Elon at least the plumbing worked. Now the whole sewer has backed up into our apartment.

Daniel Defazio

You're not wrong re: men and women having spaces to themselves. If TTRPGs are your "guy thing" that's cool. It's also cool to invite everyone, if that's what you want to do. Cheers!

A Name Apart

A gentle perspective: that "sewer" is actually people. There are certainly smart ways to talk about incentives making people behave worse. But I would prefer if we can lessen the insinuations that other people are garbage.

MrGunn

@Terra Jones Indeed, it was a bad day when we gave folks the ability to say exactly what was on their mind, just as they thought it, with no forethought and few consequences.

Bruce Basson

Back in the 1980's, we wished girls would come to our games! A few player's sisters would come by, just to see what we were up to; but they didn't become regulars. We played D&D to start with but quickly moved on to Chivalry & Sorcery by Ed Simbalist et al. for medieval flavor and "accuracy". Also Space Opera and Steve Jackson's Melee (i.e. The Fantasy Trip). However, nobody played those games outside our group, so we were often sucked back into D&D. The upside? I met TWO girlfriends through D&D games (woot! woot!)

Lee Dunning

It never even occurred to me that I shouldn't/couldn't play D&D. I got all my friends to play, and my dad DM'd for us until I found a guy at school who was thrilled to run for us. So, my group consisted of three high school females, one guy, and the DM. I'm eternally grateful to the men who created the game that has given me so many awesome memories and served as an entry level drug for me to play other tabletop RPGs.

Patrick Lee

Brave of you PDM - The TDS levels are at an all time high out here, and people are cutting off family members because of it. I love what you do, and salute you. Happy Thanksgiving.

Patrick Lee

Freedom of speech has always been a thorn in the side of those who can’t stand the prospect of competing in the arena of ideas. Your corporate overlords love censorship, too. Always have, always will.

Anthony Johnston

One of your best videos PDM. Good for Elon & good for you, sticking up for the DnD creators' respect & due credit. My respect for Musk grew even more today, just like the Grinch's heart. Agree wholeheartedly with extending some grace to older folks from older generations. Sometimes they were exactly right, and sometimes they were short-sighted or just plain wrong. But their contributions & creations should stand alone as other art you so insightfully mentioned. Spot on analysis PDM.

Flash Gorgon

I disagreed with Gygax about a ton of things, but he was right about feminism. As an aside, but related to the topic, the only reason women play D&D today is because it's become feminized. And really, the main company who brought women into the genre was White Wolf with Vampire.

Flash Gorgon

I had to laugh at Heidi Gygax saying that we now live in an "enlightened" society! What a joke! Everywhere I look, I see people who are dumber than we were 60 years ago! We are currently living in the literal Dark Ages, and the thing that makes it worse is that we have no reason to. Every one of us has a computer in our pockets that is more powerful than the computers that got us to the moon and what do we do with that power? Doom scroll and post about cats. Well, one good thing is that there is a saying that God looks out for drunks and fools. God help us!

Jay

PDM, I saw this subject filling up my news feed in the last 48 hours and ignored the banter as I knew you wouldn’t pass up the opportunity to give a well-grounded take on the subject and ya didn’t disappoint. Although I had little to no interest in this subject you covered it in an interesting and thought-provoking way. I would be surprised to see anyone pick this video apart or insinuate you meant something other than what you stated. I agree with your assessment and find your statements completely innocuous much less offensive. Thanks for being the adult in the room…even though you’re a union socialist. Haha …kidding of course. Now get back to work on Deathbringer so you can take more of my money.

Aron Krist

This is a difficult topic, but from my point of view PDM and Heidi Gygax were right to point out the simple fact that Gary Gygax was raised and lived in another time. I do not mind if Hasbro puts a notice in the reprints of the old books which says the same thing.

Máté Gergely Balogh

Calling normal, decent people racist, sexist, etc. relativizes the real racism, sexism, etc. We cannot judge people who lived in another era by the moral standards of today. There should be no disclaimer for this, it should be obvious. Thank you for this important video, PDM.

Graham Kane

Wanting space to oneself is one thing, that’s what hobbies are for, but stating that women aren’t suited to the hobby for biological reasons is wrong.

Daniel Defazio

It's strange to me anyone could cut off their family members at Thanksgiving. I could nod and agree with anyone for three hours in exchange for turkey and stuffing.

Graham Kane

Thank you for your measured and well thought out response. As you alluded to, separating art from the artist is something people seem to able to do only when it suits them. But in this case I do think Gygax is being judged a little harshly. As you said he was human and had flaws. We all do and I fully agree that you cannot judge people from the past based on today’s standards. It was a serious error in judgment to say that women just weren’t suited to playing RPGs, but I dare say many men were brought up with a similar outlook. But we’ve moved on from that and I think his detractors should do likewise. Oh and lastly, as a model train collector I can confirm that we have plenty of a@@holes in that hobby too!

Graham Kane

I’d disagree. I find that far too many people change when they have the ability to post online. Especially on Twitter.

Jane Ost

I think it's really important to point out that guys like Grummz and Elon Musk don't actually care about D&D, they see this as just another front in their culture war. Grummz does this all the time with different games and hobbies and it's just to whip up anger in their audience. It's irresponsible to take these guys' word in good faith.

Adam Maag

Hello Professor. While I don’t think you said anything out of line I do believe you missed the mark on a couple points. You mention Polanski and Jackson and how their work doesn’t have labels in front of them. People just enjoy them. However, Polanski hasn’t had a US theatrical release in over 10 years, and when is the last time Rock and Roll Part 2 (Gary Glitter) was played at a sporting event. These artists have had their works removed or limited due to their creators actions. TTRPG are such a small medium compared to music and film. Chinatown doesn’t have a label because it is one of thousands of movies. And when people think Movies, they don’t immediately say “Chinatown”. Or when you say music the majority of listeners say Michael Jackson. The medium is too big. DnD is the most recognizable brand in TTRPG medium. So I see nothing wrong with saying “Hey, this wasn’t great, but that’s not all there is. If this bothers you then we are sorry, but here is something else that is amazing.” I do think it unfair that they throw Gygax and Arneson under the bus when they cannot defend themselves, and yes they are products of their generation. However I do agree with the “shit on their shoe analogy”. As a 45 year old man I can look back at plenty of times where I was sexist, and insensitive. I am sure that if I was really self reflective I wouldn’t even have to go back that far, however I am trying to be better. I will never introduce myself with a warning of my past actions. But I am not a print media product, there for generations to see. If it makes someone’s experience better or more welcoming, especially a marginalized individual, then it is worth it.

A Name Apart

Targeting your product for a specific customer demographic is fine, stating that there are broad group based sex differences in interests is fine. If someone told me that romance novels were not suited for men for biological reasons I would be a bit offended but also understand what they mean and would still read them if I as an individual liked them and might even retort that all the classic save the princess hero trope is a kind of romance novel.

Elvis Ramone

The problem with Musk is that he has tied his wagon so tightly to Trump that anything he says comes off as part of that brand. Your video goes into the issue at the heart of the matter with Gygax and the perceptions of him, separating Musk and his issues from that core. And you are right, it's the message that is good, a broken clock is right twice a day. The messenger sucks. What he has done to his platform is take it from a left leaning centrist platform and thrown it hard to the right. Which as the owner, is his prerogative, as was his shutting down left leaning users and those critical of himself. And letting people like Alex Jones back in. Facts? We don't need no stinking facts! Free speech absolutist indeed. Keep doing good work, be careful, the minefield has been seeded by both sides.

Terra Jones

Sure they are people, they are people who flood my mentions with transphobic hate speech and dog whistles, like YWNBAW, telling me I am mentally ill or vermin, or telling me to "join the 41%" which is a transphobic dog whistle urging me to commit suicide. They are people who give themselves usernames referencing the 14 words and the "jewish question." Twitter used to have inadequate moderation and now it is moderated like 4chan. They can outright say the N-word but a script flags and filters post where we say "cis" a neutral term to refer to non-transgender people without the implication that calling the "normal" would have.

Terra Jones

I am going to repeat here what I said on reddit. No politics rules and politicized bullying in D&D space like TTRPG twitter/facebook I know there is wariness about talking about politics in geek spaces but "no politics" rules has an unintended consequence for those of us whose mere presence and existence within a space is politicized. Trans people are punching bags for the right. I am seen as an intruder in hobbies, I, a 40-year-old have been engaging with since I was 5. The ghouls can use dog whistles and bully me and its "just teasing, get over it" but when I push back on it, I am "bringing politics into everything." They can snicker about how I should "join the 41%" or "the JQ" or say "1488" or name themselves "Austrian painter" and it is not seen as political or hate speech or a death threat by automated or even human moderation. If we can't talk about politics at all then we cannot deal with politicized bullying. You can hardly say anything on DND/TTRPG twitter these days because none of that is moderated as hate speech anymore and there are so many hateful people around than there used to be. It's gotten lonely enough that I hardly want to engage with the hobby anymore. I think a "no politics in the discord or table" rule is flawed if it still leads to patterns of politicized bullying and exclusion.

Terra Jones

Calling Gygax misogynist is half-true but over stating the case and it is also irrelevant because, well, nobody is perfect. Gygax was a guy. He's just some guy. He had some great idea that he cooked up with his war gaming friends. Other people refined the idea further. It would be unreasonable to demand him to have no reactionary beliefs or beliefs that age perfectly. As far as I can tell, he wasn't in charge of anything, he wasn't the leader of some reactionary movement, just a niche business. I feel similarly about HP Lovecraft who was way worse, but again, not really in charge of anything. There are some problematic faves who actually *are* in charge of things that do lead reactionary movements and I tend to reserve my hate for me, like Mark Kern for instance.

David Lake

It’s interesting that companies like Hasbro or WotC have no problem taking the money that comes from such problematic and culturally insensitive material that Gygax and company created. They profit off of something they did not create, then wipe their pseudo-righteous feet on his memory and legacy.

Daniel Defazio

I concur. That is why on DungeonCraft FB I have a rule: "Don't have anything nice to say? Don't say anything at all." I realized it solved most arguments on the FB channel.

Jane Ost

He did work at blizzard until 2006, but it's difficult to say if he was actually important in the development of WoW. He then mismanaged another studio nearly to bankruptcy. He's spent the years since then bouncing from controversy to made up controversy complaining about how games are woke now and the women in them are ugly. He's not a serious person.

Terra Jones

Grummz (Mark Kern) was a developer of World of Warcraft. He left the company to found a video game company. That company was not successful and in the interests of neutrality I will say many people attribute that failure to poor decisions by Mark Kern. In particular his seagull style of management, being uninvolved for days at a time only to swoop in out of nowhere to demand his harebraned idea be implemented when he hadn't been in the conversation. The other issue was him blowing a massive amount of company resources on a custom built bus as an advertising expense that did not accomplish much. In the time since, Mark Kern has become a twitter influencer with many of his posts centering on perceived wokeness in various geek communities and complaining from the right. He often inserts himself into geek subcultures there is no evidence he has ever been involved with and the premise of his complaints are often misinformed. He has tried to cause a "gamergate 2.0." He often pushes conspiracy theories that are premised on some variation on some outsider we don't like is taking media and making it more left wing and culturally sensitive and that is bad. Media going forward will have nothing you love like big strong men and pretty girls and everything you hate such as not as pretty girls, people with dyed hair, and hidden away options to accommodate or represent queer fans.

Terra Jones

and even then, ultimately, he's just some guy. He's not like, the leader of the he man woman hater's club, trying to pass some woman hating laws. If he was alive and decided to run for president it might be a problem but he helped father the tabletop RPG medium. It's rare for an artist to invent a new medium entirely.

MrGunn

@David Lake Not surprising at all, while the NSDAP is gone, Bayer, AG Farbin, Porsche, and Krups are still thriving... You will find the same for all corporations.

Evil Chad

Well said. I think his daughter, covered all the bases. Continue the great content. Thanks PDM

Jay

Thanks for sharing. Our group started with just us five of us boys and three years latter we had six girls playing along side of us. As a forever GM, I the females added some change in perspective and interesting story aches. I miss the old group as your shared memory stirred up some of my own. Those were fun times. :)

Flash Gorgon

Oh heck yeah, I'm serious! Feminism is one of the worst things to ever happen to our society. I'm glad that Gary recognized the evil that it was back in the day and I'm sad that more people did not see what he saw. But perhaps I was a bit too hyperbolic about why women play D&D these days. I said feminism was the only reason, but that's not true. It's a major factor, but not the only reason. There were always exceptions to the rule back in the day, but D&D was like a 99% male dominated hobby and there was nothing wrong with that. Women, in general, simply did not find D&D interesting and again, there's nothing wrong with that. Back to my point though, it is clear that games that emphasized more "theater of the mind" and "edgy" and "romantic" kinds of play, like what you got in Vampire tended to be more appealing to women.