Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Videos

Content

So how much WoTC/Hasbro news does PDM REALLY cover? Not as much as you think--and he's bringing receipts.

Files

Previews only

Clickbait Controversy

Comments

Bagel-Man

Excited to see your take on this

Steven Sweet

No good deed goes unpunished.

steven bray

I watched 2 seconds of the video in question and clicked away. It was a shady clickbait title. People are unsubbing because you're chasing drama clicks. I'm here for DM advice videos and those have pretty much disappeared.

Ron F.

You tell 'em, Professor! If people care enough about your channel, they should allow you to have the chance to pay the bills! You're doing what I do not have the desire to do because of the sheer amount of work it takes to turn this from a hobby in and of itself to a small business which supports you.

Kenneth Wright

Thanks for the video! I watch all videos and I see what you're doing and it's great.

Timothy S Wattigny

Fantastic video (and great bonus content) illegitimus non carborundum est

A Name Apart

I have unsubbed from quite a few channels for clickbait titles and stupid faces in the thumbnails or complaining about shadow banning or aggressive politics. But then I also support on Patreon and YouTube other creators

Enishi X

So you can get to the part that you need to see skip to 3 minutes 40 seconds.

Enishi X

I'm sorry people feel this way but you know people are going to people. I love your videos.

Eric Avila

Way to fire back, Prof. Your integrity is accepted here. DOUBLE-PLUS SUBSCRIBE.

Scott

This is the internet, haters are gonna hate. But I appreciate all the work you put in and the videos you put out!

Benjamin Marra

Keep doing what you're doing, PDM. Love all your videos. Keep on making them. I'll watch them all.

Lee Dunning

I watch all of your stuff, regardless of the topic. The crafting and the reviews are my favorites, but even the so-called click bait stuff offer more than simple hype. You provide background and reasoning for the event in question that others don't, like the economic realities of big business. You're never nasty and you promote a lot of other great content creators. In fact, I'm going to go check out PaladinProse as soon as I finish typing this post. I have limited discretionary income, so I'm very picky about who I back. You're one of only two CC's I support with a Patreon subscription.

MrGunn

Dear PDM: I hope you and your family are well and your oncologist gives you the all clear. Someone was definitely feeling feisty, 😁. Thanks for sharing your thoughts and feelings in a respectful way, there are certainly some creators who would lash out immaturely. Personally, I was amused rather than upset by the title of the last video; I felt like a fish on a line leaping from the water after I bit down on the bait 🎣 🤣🤣🤣. I feel your frustration, the mob is fickle, they chant; "Give us more crafting and game play videos!", yet they only seem to watch the clickbait and controversy videos. I have groused in the past about, "Too much non-game content!". I even did the maths, which arguably had "click-bait" videos at about 45% at that time. As of now, I think you have struck the perfect balance, 33% of non-game content is the right amount. We have spoken directly and I understand the balance you have to play with YouTube and their rapacious algorithms; daddy's gotta put shoes on baby's feet. Keep being you and doing what you are doing. Your devoted patron, MrGunn

Frederic Schmitt

Does this video count as controversy clickbait? 😁 I love your videos too. Don't let the haters drag you down.

Chuck Thorin

Glad you're on the mend PDM. Yeah, IMHO. Youtube, X, Facebook, and just about every other Internet place in the RPG sphere is driven mostly by click bait and controversy over content. Sure there are a few. That's why I hang around the Dungeoncraft folks. :)

MelodicMethod

EVERYONE has clickbait thumbs!!! Anyone who hasn't cottoned onto that by now does not understand how YouTube works

Andyjagger

I watch all your videos, regardless of content and enjoy every one, just seems to be a very vocal minority of people who have nothing better to do than complain - hope your appointment with the oncologist goes well, btw I got the all clear myself last week

Daniel Defazio

Great news. The best video I ever made was the cancer one. So many dudes saw their doctor and caught it early. Peace, God bless, and Happy New Year.

Andyjagger

I might have been one of them, it wasn’t long after your video that I noticed the tumour - god bless yourself and happy new year too

Littlestump

Loved watching your videos over the holidays... thanks for finding time

Robert DeLuca

Been here since day 1, I believe I am the 6th subscriber, quiet in the background but love DungeonCraft; it always makes my day. I am not going anywhere. Hope next year is 100x's better for you and your family!

The Wayfaring Sword

Nothing wrong with your content, nothing wrong with you being able to make money while doing it. Keep up the great work, Prof. DM. Both you and your videos are much appreciated!

Anthony Johnston

Love the channel & content PDM. Only vids I tend to skip are some of the game reviews on games with themes that dont interest me. Thanks for the succinct explanation of the reality of a youtube creator's economics. It makes all your decisions much more understandable. Think I may bump up my patreon tier to help cover some of those unsubscribers.

Matthew Crismali

Keep doing what you're doing. You provide a great variety of video content and such is the spice of life. You hit the nail on the head when you said 'if you don't like those videos, then stop watching them; and if you want more of the other videos, then start actually watching them!'. If people want to complain, then let them, but don't let it get under your skin. Yours is the only Patreon I've kept and I still feel like I get my money's worth. Thanks!

Cee-Jay

I watch almost all of your videos. In my opinion, you are easily the best TTPRG 'tuber out there when it comes designing & running gameply, and your grimdark taste closely matches my own. And you are willing to give strong opinions while also being kind. Great man, great content. PS: The most recent D&D news title was obviously ludicrous click-bait, and therefore it didn't bother me at all. That said, I've certainly been annoyed by click-bait on YouTube plenty of times before. "Hate the game, not the player" applies... but so does "Live by the sword, die by the sword". Click bait will p*ss some people off, period. Just because a) everybody does it, and b) it works... doesn't mean it's not a little slimey. Besides weak content, politics is the kind of thing that will get me to unsub from somebody, because last thing I need is another source of people's opinions on politics. Actually I recently unsubed from Bob... he's a nice guy but he was always near the bottom of my D&D creators, and then his comments arguing with people about politics in the Elon post was enough to drop him. You are my main man, but I also subscribe to Ben, Baron, Shea, Kelsey, Seth, Justin, Coleville, Bandit's Keep and BECMI Beserker. I'm sure my political views are very, very different than some of these folks, but it won't be an issue if they stick to D&D.

Beardy B.

Obviously I like your stuff enough to subscribe, lol, but I subscribed BECAUSE of your news videos. You have journalistic integrity in your coverage of the story, even if the headline is sensational. I enjoy your DM and review content, and I don't do crafts, but I don't begrudge the crafting videos. I am looking forward to your new and improved Deathbringer! P.S. You could always hit up Brandish for some advice or perspective on your tower terrain since he is known to do "the crafting" as well.

Rob Edgar

Love the video (as usual)....very smarty and (more importantly) honestly done PDM!!....but I do really want to see the alternative Angry Dwarf version of it.....

Jeffery Zeilinger

Parasocial relationships aside... We do care about you and appreciate you. Thank you for your content. The unhappy will always be the loudest online and maybe that is a bit on us, the rest of the community. We should probably take the time to respond positively to content that we like and enjoy. I don't know that it will honestly change but for every 1 unhappy person there's usually 10-100 happy people. I literally started DMing because of your videos and after watching literal hundreds of hours of DnD and DM content, yours is the source of all sources for me. I've been running games for several years now and I can honestly say that without your content and direction I don't know that I would still be running games. Thank you! Sincerely

Rufus Lynks

Sounds almost like a real-world proof of Pareto. Maybe you could write up this video data for something like a Haaarvaaaard Business School case study. That's gotta net few more bucks. "Whatever it takes to keep the lights on," is a reality sometimes. I appreciate the content. Although not much of a painter, I get fascinated by the notion that you have this vision, and then combine the colors and textures for some amazing miniatures. My mind does not work quite that way, but it's fascinating to try and comprehend. It's nice to get insight on the business side of things, and I tend to grab some of that from Roll for Combat as well. In a previous role, I woudl listen to their long-form videos while conducting survaillance. The campaign diaries are way cool, no doubt, but I think I might get burned out if they came too frequently. I appreciate your offereing references to follow up on like the books you mentioned on life in midieval cities among others. I do like to hit the references an author uses for their work. I used to love challenging profs knowing they did not dig as hard as I did. Aaaaand, that may be why I do love investigations, really hard ones. All said, I found this channel because a friend was concerned about me and "ordered" me to get back to having a hobby. Your content hasn't disappointed yet. The cancer video was quite human, and offered context the channel activities. Were I to win the lottery, I'd gladly smite your bills (out of spite for a very broken system I too have had to endure). If you keep presenting, I'll keep showing up.

Thomas Inscoe

Screw the haters! I love the content, that tower looks badass!

MrGunn

@Rufus Lynks Silly, thahh’s no ahh in Haahvaahd 😁😋🤣

Eric Mason

The only thing I can think to add is about the play lists on your channel, where you have the types of videos specified so people can find the things they like best. You might want to append "Campaign" to the titles your newer campaign playlists so that someone who is new will know that Reviled Society, Lost City, and Tomb of Horrors playlists are campaigns and not simply reviews.

Mighty Zeus

Video topics- the place where idealism meets reality. Your topics are varied, engaging, and very much appreciated. Please do carry on, good sir.

Jeff Love

I've watched every video on YouTube for years now, obviously I'm a patron and a big fan... and the "Hasbro dumps D&D" title was tough for me. I understand that you need to make the titles a little clickbaity but there's a certain drop that happens when you think you've read a fact in the title and it turns out to be that particular level of misleading/untrue. "Hasbro dumps D&D videogame" would have gone a long way.

samurguybri

I appreciate that you explain how the sausage is made. I get it, it’s part of playing the ‘youTube game. I’m happy to be over here on Patreon as well. Nice folks and wonderful to see even more of the…sausage factory?

samurguybri

I struggle with the fact that social media encourages us to drop our opinions at every point, like my feeling and partial thoughts are important or something. Really the platforms just want ‘engagement’. Many things are in our hobby are political, but some spaces are just not suited for discussing them (like the comments thread in a video or a reddit post). These formats hate nuance or complex takes, so theres no way to get much of a measure of someone’s pov. grew up in the 80’s as well so I remeber the fight to push back a giant censorship all too well. I remeber when things could not even be talked about or brought up. I tend to be super lib/progressive but like to hear out others, in a nuanced way. I also practice mindfulness and other forms of mind training, so you’d think I’d be less prone to getting involved. But I get caught up easily as well, wanting to rage against the perceived other. It sucks. The main thing I do is not post a lot, I try to remeber the human on the other side of the keyboard. This a truly a safe space where we work hard to respect each other and give some positivity to a creative person who’s work we admire and by his behavior, respect.

Cee-Jay

Yes, I enjoy having thoughtful political discussion with intelligent, open-minded people that trully want to explore issues from multiple perspecties. But as you point out, that's an entirely different experience than that of the typical youtube coment thread.

NØKKEN_WAITS

You've gotta do what you've gotta do. As a wise man once said "what I said was true, from a certain point of view."

Jay

@MrGunn, thanks for the links. Also, replied to a comment you made on Once in a Six Sided Die. I'm new to 3D printing so hope that channel will help. Hope your holiday's have been going well and happy New Year.

Will Smith

It’s true about that 10% subscribers watching. I watch more of your creation videos here than YouTube. Sorry.

Jay

First, I want to wish everyone on here happy holidays to you and yours along will a brilliant outlook on the new year ahead of us all. PDM, your channel has never disappointed your die hard fans and those of us who don't like the term fan (short for fanatic) may enjoy most of your material but won't admonish you for the stuff we don't find interest in. As for my objective opinion, I find your videos and material very meticulously put together, well scripted or rehearsed, well edited, entertaining, and thoughtful if not thought provoking. I may occasionally whine about some of the stuff I'd like to see as we all have our favorites, yet understand you do what you need to to get views and increase your audience. Please know that there will always be those in comments sections who are asinine and make threats of false allegations. Also, why I rarely make comments except here on Patreon among those who are more like minded if not tolerant. Even I have grown as an individual and come to realize the harshness of the internet and the Golem / Smeagle like people who hide behind anonymous monikers and say awful things. Try not to let these things get to you if you can help it. I keep myself in check too. Having been here since the beginning I have noticed all the hard work you've put in to making content and running games. It's clearly not easy with a full time teaching job and a family to support abroad. As far as those who say "You are better than this", I say no...no I'm not. I'm a complete psychopath or I couldn't have done my job in the armed forces. I jus try to hide it best I can. Best wishes on the New Year to you and yours. For a laugh "Consider how stupid the average person is and realize half of them are dumber than that" ~ George Carlin.

Austin Bowling

Thanks for everything you do professor! My daughter is 6 and when I told her you were a teacher and a DM she thought that was the coolest thing ever. She happens to think those are the coolest occupations one can have and you have them both!

Jeff Krus

I think some of the so called subscribers don't understand business works...

Justin Watson

Some folks simply cannot comprehend that their own emotions and priorities aren't the only valid emotions and priorities in the universe.

David Lake

I love this absolute slap down you give to the “Perpetually Entitled.” I think this is a perfect response. You neither ignore it, nor do you acquiesce. I know we represent your more dedicated audience but even your so-called “clickbait” videos are measured and insightful. Your channel’s continued growth speaks for itself. Sometimes the dead fruit just needs to drop off the tree. Looking forward to what you have to offer in 2025.

Lance

F! cancer and faceless keyboard jockeys. Get that money, game the algo and argue with insurance until they pay! My wife had Hodgkin’s lymphoma and the ringer we went through with insurance was worse than the treatment! She’s been cured and cancer free for over a decade now. I wish you the absolute best on your health journey. Oh, and I personally DGAF if every one of your videos has a clickbait title! Why? Because they all are well produced, entertaining and have substance. The “unsubscribed” should go try and make their own channel. Stay well.

MrGunn

@Jay Thanks! I saw your comment, good luck with your new hobby, may all your minis come out perfectly.

MrGunn

@David Lake Or rather the tree that bears no fruit be thrown on the fire.

Jay

I agree regarding the playlists. However, many of his videos cover various subjects and have, in the past, suggested time stamping them into chapters with titles like some other creators do. I believe the response back then was that his wife was the tech savvy one and he might mention it. Both of them have busy schedules and I didn't purse it any further. However, if he were interested in what I mean here is a link as to how simple it might be. "NEW YouTube Chapters Tutorial: How to Add Timestamps on Your YouTube Videos" - Think Media - YouTube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yfEdhlBuxCU .

Jay

PDM, with 2025 right around the corner please consider adding Timestamps and Chapters to your videos if not playlists to next year’s videos. According to some creators, creating chapters with timestamps may improve your viewership for people searching for specific topics on Google / YouTube searches. Here is a short video on how and why to do it. "NEW YouTube Chapters Tutorial: How to Add Timestamps on Your YouTube Videos” - Think Media - YouTube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yfEdhlBuxCU . Hope you find this helpful.

Goblin88

Yeah, get'em!