Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Videos

Content

Patrons have been asking for this video for years: how I handle encumbrance. Enjoy! (I may be slow to respond to DMs and comments because I'm driving to PAGE with Baron DeRopp.) I'll be back Monday. Thanks for your patience!

PS: If you want to go to the Philadelphia Area Gaming Expo, use the code "PDM" for a discount. Badges are still available!

Files

Previews only

Encumbrance is boring. Do this instead.

Comments

Timothy S Wattigny

PDM, I think you should have explained the "why" of tracking encumbrance. In AD&D, 1gp=1xp, so that chest of 400gp the party finds is 400xp if they can haul it back to the town. I know later editions dropped that 1gp=1xp rule, so then tracking encumbrance loses its game-mechanic reason for existing. Anyway, enjoy Mythicon, I'll go back over to my side of Chesterton's Fence.

Cal Pearson

Whether RPG or some house add-ons to Tactical games (Battletech alpha strike and Space Weirdos being current favs), the critical failure becomes a nice spot to Weapon Jam or Ammo issue (clear, reload or just plain bingo ammo). Broken rope, rammed rod, no brakes - whatever. The scramble to find another way is most often a crowd pleasing variant to heighten tension - Heron the ranger must now spend some turns running downed target to downed target recovering arrows. Hum, they might even be stuck or damaged. better move onto the next bugbear. Maybe you'll recover multiple arrows outta that fella - Roll d4! Thx PDM

Daniel D. Fox

Another banger from PDM. Enjoy Philly!

A Name Apart

My favorite is blades in the dark where you have a quantum inventory limited by your stress resource. So if you need something more exotic than what is reasonable to assume you are carrying you can expend a meta-currency resource to call it into existence. But that resource (which also tracks health) does not replenish until after the adventure so you have to be careful to not use it too freely.

Rod Thomson

Love the funky intro music! I've been using a similar encumbrance system for years. Fiddling with weights is not fun, and it does not take into account volume so it's a highly-flawed system anyway. Here's a potentially useful fun fact from history regarding coins: most minted coins were actually small, no larger than a U.S. dime. The later weights 0.08 ounces, which means 400 of them would weigh a whopping two pounds. I've an Imperial Roman denarius and a Persian (IIRC) drachma in my collection and they are both smaller than dimes. The point of all this specie nerding out is that coins do not have to be a huge burden in RPGs, not unless the DM wants them to be.

Enishi X

Moussritter Tetris style of encumbrance is wonderful.

James M Spahn

I'm working on a sci-fi game where you can carry two "gear packs" and a handful of incidental items. If you've got the Planetary Explorer's Gear Pack you've got a water purifier, a GPS, and an all weather tent for example. If you've got a Ship's Mechanic Gear Pack, you've got a tool kit, a hand held analysis device, and maybe a breathing mask to give you a few rounds of breathing in low/no O2 environments. Incidental items are things like cellphone-sized pocket computers or weapon holsters.

Firstspear

I've developed an XL sheet that estimates Kcals from food and ask the players to track their caloric reserves, taking CON penalties for different levels of hunger...is what I would say if I was INSANE. That said - I've known some folks that love the minutiae of 'TTRPG Accounting' - it's just not my jam. I like and use 'is it reasonable' approach PDM uses. I do enough bookkeeping in RL that I don't need it for my Fantasy life. Play how you like, but don't let it get in the way of good stories

Bagel-Man

Excited to watch. I just do slot encumbrance.

MelodicMethod

Playing 3.X, we just used the weight system in the rules. I don't recall it causing any problems. The biggest sticking point was remembering to track fired arrows/bolts and rolling to recover them. I don't recall that being much of a problem, either. *shrug*

MrGunn

Dear PDM, I hope you and your family are well. I like this video, encumbrance is not a topic often discussed. Five Torches Deep has two game mechanics I like a lot, load and supply. ----- LOAD: Items and weight are tracked in terms of load. Each item the size of a human head or 5 lbs is considered 1 load. PCs are able to carry load equal to their STR score without issue. Heavy armor is 5 load, light armor is 2 load. Items and weapons are 1 load each hand used when holding or wielding that item. Other miscellany can be stacked into 1 load. Carrying load over your STR causes you to be encumbered, which reduces your speed by 5’ every point of load over your STR, and forces disadvantage on all checks. SUPPLY : Each PC has supply (SUP) up to their INT score. This is how much resupply the PC brought and represents their ability to plan ahead with what they might need to bring. You lose some SUP each time you replenish an expendable item (like a torch). You regain SUP by succeeding at a check to forage or cannibalize an item. You can buy supply in a town or caravan (usually 1 gp per SUP). ---- I also like the idea of rolling against a DC +INT bonus to determine if a PC has a unique item they might not be assumed to have brought, like in your battle axe example, you would ask the PC to roll against a DC plus their INT bonus to determine if remembered to bring their ice pick. Another way to go is, sure you can cobble together another torch, but it will cost you a Deathbringer Die. FATE Core also has some interesting ideas about giving items Aspects and Flaws. Sure Batman you have a grappling hook gun with a winch, but it is a prototype and sometimes fails to work properly, roll against DC# to determine if it functioned as intended. 🦇 Thanks for this practical advice. Your loyal patron, MrGunn

MrGunn

@Firstspear So you have played Phoenix Command. 🤣🤣🤣

Russell Miller

I didn't worry about tracking supplies, but weight I do. If I didn't, my power gamers would equip themselves with everything for every encounter instead of using their brains to get through the situations. One player, who put no points in strength (playing PF2E), gets upset that he can't carry his sword, pistol, morning star and...arquebus with tripod...while carrying a backpack full of loot and maintain his killing machine status. I have to remind him that it's about the decisions he makes. Do you want to return with the loot? What do you want to leave behind when the other characters can't carry any more, either? If you want to take it all, what kind of risk do you want to take if you are moving slower due to encumbrance? Don't like it? Put some points in strength. Spend money on a pack animal instead of shopping for more uber weapons. To me, that's the real value of encumbrance--setting limits so there is a chance of tension in the game and preventing a Monty Haul that snowballs out of control. I do like the idea of a flat resupply fee when in town, though. I'll have to try that next campaign.

Evil Chad

Great stuff as always PDM. Also a lot of cool stuff in the comments. Less or very little bean counting ... lets get to the action. Thanks again.

Bingo Mastermind

There are a BUNCH of hacks of Knave which use the slot based inventory system and pair it with stamina, so if you have left over inventory slots, you can spend that slot as stamina to do an extra attack, move, stunt, etc. So picking up a heavy item becomes a strategic choice- is this heavier sword worth it to have less opportunities to attack? I recommend looking at Grave (souls-like inspired) or Octave (Legend of Zelda)

Walter Barr

Hey. YouTube Noob. I watch this on youtube and then the extra content here, so I can like it on youtube. Does that help the channel?

Beardy B.

Why track anything in the rules unless it serves an important purpose? So we track equipment only if It forces our players to make choices that are interesting, important or meaningful. I love all the fascinating rules that different systems come up to deal with this. In Old D&D when you had to carry your experience points out in the form of gold and treasure, a bag of holding was truly a magical item, because it gave you so many more options on how to deal with logistics and difficult choices of what to carry and how much you can manage, to mitigate the risks of travel without supplies or dungeons without lighting. So I suppose, only track if the rules lead to fun and challenge and difficult decisions for the players. Take care y'all.