Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Videos

Content

Breaking news and analysis.

Files

Previews only

Orcs Are Gone

Comments

Bagel-Man

Very odd that they did this. Regardless, I’m excited to watch.

MrGunn

🙄

Bagel-Man

That was a great end segment with Death Bringer, I love the Rankin Bass lotr films.

Enishi X

Great video. No one is pure good or evil in my games. All my players have moral dilemmas.

Tom Giblin

Whoa whoa whoa. Hold on here. Not trading in Monopoly is how you win. You deny your opponents everything so they quit after 90 minutes, handing you victory.

Chris Franklin

Glad you called out World of Warcraft. I remember when WC3 came out in 2002 and they retconned them into being a society tricked into a demonic pact which gave them their bloodlust. Thrall was the first honorable orc I’ve ever encountered. I’m trying to think back before then. I think it was the first. It kind of blew everyone’s mind. It definitely started my love of the orcs from wow. That’s why my favorite dnd race is the gnolls. There is no sympathizing with a gnoll. They’ll eat you, your wife, your children and your dog. I always use gnolls to represent the chaotic evil monsters.

Chris Franklin

It’s also why Warhammer orcs are the perfect representation of an orc. They’re fungus who reproduce asexually. Don’t have to feel bad about slaughtering a fungus.

Jeff Krus

Others comes down do this, just like rules if your the DM and say Orcs are bad, ugly creatures and can not be be a playable character then you can't and if you allow it then fine. It comes down what type of game/campaign you want to run, IMO...

Terra Jones

If you really want a group of murderous psychopaths wielding a club as an antagonist I am pretty sure the NPC section has you covered. You could make them whatever humanoid species you like. You could make them orcs but we all know that gnomes are the real menace plaguing the multiverse

Terra Jones

"Who do you fight?" You fight the bad guys. The bad guys are the people that do bad stuff and want to do more bad stuff if you don't stop them from doing bad stuff. The bad guys are bad because of the bad stuff they do, not because of who they are. You might also fight hostile fauna or non-sapient threats.

Evil Chad

Roll playing/ D&D = Game. Heroes take out Monsters... Chess/ Checkers = Game. Players take out Pieces. Moving on... Lets just have fun and have a good time with friends... Playing a Game. Thanks, PDM

Terra Jones

In my current game, which is not d&d but an urban fantasy game set in modern-day Chicago, the main antagonist is a soul drinking techno lich whose cover story is that he is a commodities trader. He's not a bad guy because of what he is, he is a bad guy because of what he does and what he wants to do. (Terrorize the city to the point where people are willing to accept a reality where monsters exist so that he can summon a world devouring demon)

SpeakingBeast

For me, peak D&D Orcs are the ones depicted in the 2e players handbook by Douglas Chaffee - the ones storming the castle. Although, da best and meanest Orks are from Warhammer!

Graham Kane

Thank you for a balanced approach and for not letting it descend into the realms of culture war. I like evil orcs in my own games, but I play in other peoples games where things are not so simplistic. I like both and people can play however they want.

Chupacabra Smith

My rambling 2 cents on the matter (deleted initial comment trying to add a line): I'm one of those Grognards who has known of the game since the 80s, but only really played it in the late 80s early 90s I'm also one of the few who, to this day, has never read the LotR novels (I remember trying, but to me it was like trying to read Old English ^_^). That being said, I also think I'm one of the few people in my neighborhood (at the time) who even knew who J.R.R. Tolkien was (and that silly but lovable "The Hobbit" animated movie, with the singing orcs, started my interest in fantasy and later D&D ^_^) I can understand why the actual writers of the game (not their Corporate Overlords) would want to step away from Orcs being Monsters. I have actually played D&D with people who, I came to realize much later, took my old joke about "Orcs are Black Folk moving into town, Elves are the White Flight" a bit too seriously (I'm Black myself). They had no problem associating a fantasy race (Tolkien Orcs) that were created for nothing but Evil and Destruction with African-Americans (and later I learned this person had even more.....upsetting.....beliefs that I had ignored because of our friendship :( The easiest way to handle this, in my opinion, is the 'Drow Solution': These races act 'Evil' because the deity most of them follow forces them to be so. This also allows for individuals who have escaped the influence of this deity to start communities where they can be who they want to be (not necessarily 'Good' of course). On orcs being 'Pig Faced': I do recall in one of the old 'Gazetteer' supplements for the 'Mystara' setting that they several 'sub races' of orcs, and one was the 'classic' pig faced orc, known as "Orcus Porcus" ^_^ One last point: I've glanced over the 2024 Player's Handbook. I don't know if I agree with removing stat bonuses and penalties from each race, but they still do differentiate each race by the 'special abilities' each have, so its a good trade off, in my opinion.

The Terrorkeet

Orcs as "boar-folk." Basically, savage porcine counterparts to gnolls, kobolds, bullywugs, and tabaxi. They're as much boar as humanoid. The amount of boar characteristics (both physicality and mentality) varies wildly between orcs bloodlines. Some orcs can almost pass as human. These are known as half-orcs, who are better able to move among civilized races. Half-orcs serve as a bridge between their people and the outside world, though they are not always appreciated for it. As beast folk, orcs are not fertile with humans or any other race.

David Ford

“Grendel”. I haven’t read that book in decades. Another good Gardner book is “Freddy’s Book”. Gardner was taken from us too soon.

Elvis Ramone

Warcraft did a lot for the "redemption" of orcs, but it initially also did the same for minotaurs, called Tauren in game, and this kinda came out of left field, trolls. Later on undead, goblins, dark elves, and a whole motley crew of peoples. The intent was to tell the story from the monsters side. Some was done well, some, well, to say Blizzard does not have consistent world building is an understatement. I would also postulate there is another even more responsible for the "redemption" of orcs, Star Trek. Let's face it Klingons in the Original Series were cool, but once they hit the big screen, and then TNG, Qapla! This opened the door for orcs to get a makeover. I personally believe Gene Rodenberry and Michael Dorn did more for Klingons, and by default, for orcs and all other humanoid races than Warcraft. And it's perfectly fine to go full Angry Dwarf. Those aren't orcs, this is an orc! Your world, your orc. It would be interesting to have Tolkien, Gygaxian, Warcraft, and Warhammer orcs meet, now there's a crumping going on! The whole Star Trek thing has been bouncing around my head since the 2024 PHB got dissected.

Timothy S Wattigny

I may be the exception to your rule. Started playing around '82, and I've never read Tolkien other than one attempt to read the Hobbit circa 1986...never made it far, I found his prose unappealing.

Scott

I'm glad Angry Dwarf is around to tell it like it is!

Anthony Johnston

I honestly don't like this or other similar changes by WOTC to DnD, but then again, I don't have to buy it or support it. Orcs are an evil race IMO with few exceptions, same as drow, and there should be nothing wrong with that. But I don't like cat/turtle/rabbit/bird people running around in my TTRPGs either. Good perspective though, PDM. Still can't wait for the final full version of Deathbringer to come to KS. 2026 still seems too far off. Very excited to see the final design decisions & choices you make. Hoping for a custom Deathbringer dice of some sort.

Drago Russo

I also still remember the words to so many songs. The greatest adventure is what lies ahead....

Timothy J. Mallory

My view is basically If you want the creature to be a monster, treat it like a monster. If you want the creature to be a person, treat it like a person. What annoys me is when the game mixes the two. Keep on the Borderlands mixes the two. You are supposed to happily slaughter all the "Monsters" in the caves. But then all those tribes have women, children, and other non combatants. And the only people around for them to threaten are the garrison of a fortress. That recasts you from being the hero to being that guy who breaks into those other folks' home and kills their families. Not really heroic. "Nits make lice" and "kill them all, God will know his own" are not the quotes of the good guys, no matter what those guys thought about themselves.

Craig Sutherland

This was a great balanced and nuanced approach to this topic which is always popping off these days. Very logic driven. Thanks PDM.

David Lake

I’m also a Grimdark, low fantasy guy, so all the changes to D&D are pretty meaningless to me, as it’s not my game. However, even if it were, I think (culture wars aside) arguing and complaining about these kinds of changes to the game is tantamount to arguing over which way to play Poker is the correct one. 5 card draw? 3 card? One-eyed jacks are wild? Texas Hold ‘Em? Omaha Hold Em? How about it just be dealers (or in this case GM’s) choice. At least that’s what I think.

Larry Vieira

I remember having my PCs chased by torch wielding warg riders singing 15 Birds as their war cry back in the 80’s and they were quite terrified.

Larry Vieira

Warcraft orc responding to a Tolkien elf inquiring about some Gygaxian orcs “ it’s a matter, we don’t discuss with outsiders“

Frederic Schmitt

Orks are what you want them to be - they are not real. They can be your friends or your monsters. If the mages of the shore decide that orcs are now a normal fantasy friend in their default setting, that's fine. In my world everyone is a potential friend .. if an evil guy or gal comes around the evilness comes by their own desire to put their needs above the needs of others - Greetings from Germany P.S.: The Lord of the Ring is the substitute for the bible in our household. Just to make that clear. LotR-memes are heresy. Just to make that perfectly clear. Still I am not offended be hasbros new age orcs. They are fine.

Pyram King

First, your thumbnails are not clickbait. Clickbait relies on bait-and-switch tactics, but your thumbnails accurately represent the topics you discuss. Second, D&D's current direction seems more focused on expanding its market share through "inclusion," sometimes at the cost of excluding other perspectives. Inclusion is important, but it shouldn't come at the expense of alienating others. Orcs belong in the Monster Manual—having them there doesn’t mean you must use them. As you pointed out, Gygax already addressed the concept of monsters as playable races in the original edition, providing a detailed framework for those who want to incorporate them into their game.

Clint Sharp

Deathbringer is correct. Singing orcs are the best orcs!

Scott Miller

Deathbringer singing the orc marching song from the Rankin Bass “Return of the King” was great.

Rick Pinkston

Humans only 100%! Like Anthony commented, branded Deathbringer dice would be legit. TAKE MY MONEY! As you said we are all the authority on orcs since they don’t exist. It doesn’t stop at orcs. What if I want to play a dream dragon from OSE. I will haunt the dreams of the npcs like Freddy Krueger….. we are sorry for 50 years of orcs being a subhuman race….. SPECIES! I meant species. Some of my best friends are Orcs, congrats you are now real people. Btw be sure to file your taxes by April 15th” At the end of the day they just want to sell more stuff. It is business. More options equals more stuff they can sell. I get it.

Frank Mitchell

As someone who doesn't believe in "evil races", I still want orcs in the Monster Manual. As well as elves, dwarves, tieflings, humans, and the rest.

Frank Mitchell

You've just summarized my whole problem with "evil races". A one-off aberration might be evil, or at least too dangerous to live. An entire species of intelligent beings is too diverse to be summed up as "evil". Maybe they have a toxic culture or rampant xenophobia. Maybe in a particular situation it's kill or be killed. To exterminate them like vermin as a matter of policy, however, is the true evil. (_Goblin Slayer_ notwithstanding.)

Firstspear

This discussion reminds me of an old Fantasy Wargame - Hordes of the Things - which was developed by Wargames Research Group and was similar to DBA/DBM. It allowed one to field fantasy-based armies and resolve tactical unit combat (e.g. cavalry vs archers) where you might see goblin wolf riders go up against Ents. Great simple rules focused on command and control. Worth checking out It had army lists, and I vaguely remember the list for orcs including something akin to: We now know Orcs are misunderstood and should be considered nature and animal loving species more like the Mongols than blood thirsty evil creatures. Or some such. Made me smile

Salt

I didn't know "orc" came from ogre! Makes a lot of sense. I like a grotesque ogre and a violent orc in the fiction, especially when they aren't beaten head-on, because that's where their strength is.

Rob Edgar

Another awesome video PDM! One only has to view the menu of the local "fast" food establishments run by Orcs to see the truth... 'human baby burgers', 'Dwarf spleen fries', 'Elf ear fritters'.....'happy' meals with mystery Tiefling parts...

Timothy J. Mallory

You can make them be evil. They can be clone soldiers like Saruman's Orcs. Or they can be demonically mutated beasts like the current version of Gnolls.

Dorian Hawkmoon

"if you want to play with Cat People in your world, Go Nuts". Instant classic

Cee-Jay

Good job. Totally agree that removing them from Monster Manual makes perfect sense now that they are considered a kind, friendly playable character. Personally my subjective point of view is that Orcs are evil garbage for PCs to murder... but do whatever you want. I think the only thing that bugs me is that this doesnt' seem to be merely an asthetic choice that Wizards is making, but rather a misguided attempt to be inclusive basec on unsophisticated notions of cultural relativism coupled with the simplistic assumption that everything is a social construct. Applying that thinking to TTRPGs creates a game that starts to resemble playing nice with stuffed animals and dolls... which is fine, but not what I enjoy. But at the end of the day, it gets back to people being allowed to play however they want to play. And my opinion of their reasons really doesn't matter at all as long as they don't try to ruin my fun. Well some of them are trying to ruin my fun... but luckily the OSR is thriving, the pendulum seems to be swinging back a bit, and ultimately I can play however I want at my table.

Flash Gorgon

Coppola's Dracula is stolen nearly entirely from Fred Saberhagen's book The Dracula Tape. That book is written from the perspective of Dracula and portrays him as a hopeless romantic and victim. However, what nearly everyone forgets is that Saberhagen's Dracula is based upon Satan and therefore he's a liar. Saberhagen essentially makes Dracula an unreliable narrator and therefore, all the romance and victimhood is really Dracula believing his own BS.

Tuska

I don't mind players playing "aliens" with two caveats: First, do not play the alien as a person on cosplay. A monster is not a reskinned person. The player has to adopt the customs, mores, and values of the alien species. Second, the alien/monster advantages can't be free of charge. If the monster can breathe underwater, or has a higher strength, or can even see in the dark it should come as a cost, probably in terms of experience points.

Jay

PDM, I think ya hit the nail on the head here. Great video with some sound reasoning. I too try to keep my games with Human only characters. Making other species rare makes them mysterious and special. You can't have that where you find them everywhere as just another human variant. Also, I prefer my monsters to be more feral and uncivilized often using claws, stingers, teeth, and either crude or natural weaponry rather than behaving just like another reskinned human with pointy ears green skin and using a sword.

Peter Ferguson

"Don't believe them!!" 😂 Cracks me up every time!!