Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Videos

Content

Where do Daggerheart, Shadowdark, and Pirate Borg rank? PDM analyzes.

Files

Previews only

Top 20 Games at GenCon

Comments

Bagel-Man

Excited to hear your takes on these systems

Matthew Crismali

FYI - you said Shadowdark instead of Shadowrun.

HCPookie

I have to agree about MORK BORG (haha) in that it is really difficult to figure out the rules. I suspect that's part of the allure for some people, which gives a "puzzle book" vibe. Just my opinion... obviously done on purpose and that's what makes sense to me. We haven't ran it yet and I don't think we have any plans to do it.

Matthew Crismali

I noticed this list was slightly different than the list you shared in your front porch lecture. For example, I believe Dragonbane was ranked 16 on your previous list and is now 17 and Avatar The Last Airbender was not on the list at all and it's now ranked in the top 20. Curious to know about these changes.

The Mando Commando

I have the Star Trek Adventures Beginner Box. I have a few friends that want to play but after reading it, it looks REALLY good! Intuitive and cinematic.

madcurry

Well done! Would be interested to hear what Stephen Glicker has to say about the Avatar showing, It's level of popularity is frequently brought up on his streams.

Pyram King

That was very insightful and some surprises in there for sure. Too bad Krull did not make the cut.

Scott

A great breakdown, thank you!

Brian Griesbach

As Shadowrun is my favorite game ever (2nd and 4th are my favorite editions to run), it was really nice to see such a strong showing!

Walter Wooten

I was too late to get anything for Pirate Borg, Shadowdark, or Daggerheart. I was mainly playing Pathfinder or Starfinder. Maybe next year. There is a story link between the Edgerunner Mission Kit and the anime, but it's not necessary to watch it first.

Lee Dunning

I'm glad Savage Worlds made it into the top twenty. While Hero is my favorite (I'm so alone), some of my friends are involved in a Savage Worlds campaign and I'm hoping when our current D&D campaign dies, we can move onto that. I dream of exploding dice, though with my luck, I'll never experience them.

John Robinson

You kept saying Shadowdark when you meant to say Shadowrun.

MrGunn

@Lee Dunning Meh Shadowdark / Shadowrun, tomAY-toe / toe-mAH-toe, is it a fruit or vegetable, I cannot distinguish a medieval RPG from a Cyberpunk Fantasy RPG either. 🤣🤣🤣

MrGunn

I own many of these but have not played, e.g. Mork Borg, DCC, Cyberpunk, Savage Worlds. I have played and am fan of CoC, Shadowdark, and EZD6. I also enjoy D&D B/X or OSE, Mothership, Star Frontiers, Traveller, Gamma World, and HarnMaster. I have never played Blade Runner but it sounds fun. Pathfinder, Starfinder, D&D 2/3/4/5 have no appeal to me.