05-2025 Writer Commentary (Patreon)
Content
Haven, Cut sleep from schedule for more time with Homestuck: Hello, all, it’s time for something new.
James, is also here: Finally.
Miles, here from away: >:D It’s short, but oh... it’s sweet.
Floral, had too many Swedish Fishs from Trader Joes: This is one we were all excited for! We went into this update as a big tone change, a start to the new era. MEAT. Answering the biggest question of all, what the fuck is Callie doing in the vents? And what the hell does it have to do with Karkat?
Miles: Haw haw.
Floral: The last time we saw Karkat in HS2, he seemed pretty perturbed by the random meat. Who knows how long it’s been since then, for him to be so fed up and bored by it now?
Haven: The dual narration, I wonder if they even realize they’re talking outside the box here.
James: I like the bit a little later on where Karkat just starts talking about Callies scary head. I want to say the first draft was “weird head”. Karkat calling it scary is so mean. Why is he like that?
Floral: Cause he’s a bit of a turd! That’s his charm. His turd charm. Anyways it really felt like some classic Karkat to have him sort of jump to one conclusion just to be immediately shot in the street for it.
He’s such a smart boy but Callie is such a blind spot to him still, as he repeatedly mentions he literally does not know them at all.
Miles: Karkat’s “let them down easy” rant was so fun to write. We were all laughing our asses off in call, which is often the state one finds oneself in doing Karkat dialogue, but this session was particularly crazy. In his defense, I guess it’s pretty hard to guess what Callie’s intentions were with the meat heaps, and Karkat’s always got love on the brain.
Haven: He’s such an asshole LOL.
Floral: Meta! Meta! Meta! It felt good to put Karkat’s narrative interests back in the spot light. His personality takes such a different turn when he talks about his books and movies, he’s got the mind of a scholar (despite reading and watching slop.)
Miles: Yep. As Callie said, he really was The Right Guy to come to with this
Haven: You can be a scholar and still love slop.
Floral: Who doesn’t love Karkat coming in with the emotional intelligence after kind of extravagantly looking dumb as hell. Callie as per usual is an audience insert, their vantage point of the characters mirrors our own.
Miles: It’s very Karkat to dance effortlessly between deft emotional/social philosophizing and overblunt interpersonal bludgeoning. He has a good bloodpusher.
Miles: Karkat demonstrating the fandom-patented Post-Candy Emotion so familiar to all of us. He’ll learn to love it.
Floral: Lots of feelings about what it means to be a writer went into this update. Even when we are recounting events we’ve experienced, the details we choose to focus on say something about how we think and what we find personally interesting or important. What does the same events in the epilogues look like if narrated by someone other Callie, who has always been drawn to the dramatic extremes and struggles that mirror their relationship with Caliborn? That’s one of the things I really like about what the epilogues say about being an author, it isn’t just about forcing events or deciding canon but forcing someone’s personal sensibilities and making that the “truth.”
Anyways Callie is so cute in this update, with how they've sort of faded to the background, Karkat does his job right by unwittingly antagonizing them just enough back into the foreground.
Haven: We know damn well Dave's scripts are not “sophisticated” or maybe they are. What do I know? Who am I to argue with a man in love.
Floral: BOOM! Karkat “Knight of Blood” coming in with his understanding of bonds and his friends to help Callie with the carrying the capricious load that is Candyverse. That out of everyone, he’d mirror Callie’s empathy for even these versions of their friends.
Miles: Yeah. I think Callie is speaking to something every Homestuck fan feels, more or less, which is the conflict between the need to continue exploring these characters that we love with all our hearts because we know they have more to give us, and the creeping knowledge that we may be wearing them down by over-processing them. This is something that we think about OFTEN on the HS:BC team, and something we try to keep in our intentions with how we approach this story, but I’ll be the first to admit I have no idea what the true Right Answer is. All we can do is our best. Still... like Karkat said, there’s REAL LOVE in this, and there always has been, and being allowed to continue that legacy of love might just be the journey that justifies the destination. I guess that was kind of vague and corny, sorry LOL.
Miles: Let’s give some props to Callie (and, irl, to Haven and Floral) for this batshit Candy mural that definitely doesn’t scare anybody. Can you find all 108 references? Can you do it before the paint fumes make you pass out?
Haven: I saw someone solve one of my riddles the other day and I got really excited.
Haven: One of the first things I said to the team as a writer was “we need to get Jane and Jake on that ship” and they said “how” and i said we’ll figure that out when we get there. And then the perfect idea struck. A revelation; they were already there!! But what does that mean about all that other shit? Tune in next time1 to find out!
1 “next time” refers to the next time Jane and Jake appear on screen, which may not necessarily be the next update.
Floral: A lot of people had a lot of things to say about this last part of the update, which genuinely took by surprise. Lots of jumping to conclusions and worst case scenarios, but with most things in Homestuck the explanation will come in due time. Moments like these are stepping stones, not climaxes. Have faith and don’t stress yourselves out.
Most importantly! We get to see Jane and Jake again! Yippee!!
Miles: Yeah, this was a controversial one even on the team. At the end of it all, though, it just felt too crazy to move forward on this plot without Jane and Jake, and just as we felt Earth C was played out in Candy and Done With Its Job, we had the same feelings about Meat’s. There’s more Jane and Jake have to offer us, and I think we’d have regretted leaving them all alone on Earth C way more than I’d have personally regretted inventing some reason to arbitrarily go back to involve them or, worse, just... leaving them there, stalled out, to wrap up their arcs all on their lonesomes.