Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

MILES, tails prower: Hello hello, and welcome back to another episode of the HS:BC writers commentary!  We’ve got an absolutely packed roster full of update to get into today.  Pregnant with meaning.  Quadruplets.  I’m going to discontinue this metaphor right now.

HAVEN, Praise be to The Great Combiner: All the lonely people, where do they all belong...? At the bottom of the deep dark sea, of course! 

FLORAL, bara: Oh what a splendid day it is, to finally get to talk about this beautiful update. It seems like things are heating up!

MILES: As Del’fi gets to sketching out the reader-slash-con-attendee-suggestions for his webcomic, our daring duo drop what might actually be the longest command in Homestuck.  Leave it to Karkat.

FLORAL: We kept going back to make it longer and longer, it just never stopped being funny. 

MILES: To assuage the ravenous hunger of both fictional and real-life audiences, Del’fi decides to jingle some keys in the beautiful form of loreslop, delivered by means of a tutorial video for TRENCH2PEAK.  TRENCH2PEAK, as mentioned, is the “multiplayer life-sim romance actionRPG sandbox game” in which he’s been acting out his roleplays with CT.  It was conceived of as sort of a mishmash of The Sims (which we used to generate the High Quality Graphyxx used to communicate the concepts of these updates), GarrysMod/DarkRP, Second Life, and other sort of online life-sims in which you could set up elaborate roleplay scenarios if you were so inclined.  

MILES: Another brief behind-the-scenes aside is that we originally wanted to try doing all this shit in Second Life but none of us, for the fucking life of us, could figure out how to really get it to work at all, which is REALLY a shame because I think Second Life is much more spiritually in the realm of what TRENCH2PEAK actually is than the Sims.

FLORAL: Genuinely wished we had taped us trying because we were so bewildered by Second Life. 

MILES: TRENCH2PEAK was also useful to get more into something we explore a lot with Del’fi, which is the aforementioned need to use the internet/online space as a way to learn more about things that you might not really be able to encounter or act out in your own personal life.  I know we’re all well familiarized with the absolute shitslog being online has become, and the myriad ways in which it can royally fuck a person up (especially an impressionable teen), but we also still believe that a lot of good can come from the way it opens up an entire new world of information up to kids hungry enough to look for it.  The vaguely interconnected frontier-like nature of the interstitial zone that bridges the two separate satyr and nymph internets leads to spaces like this becoming small oases of mutual understanding between two cultures that are otherwise almost entirely cut off from each other.  That healthy interest in the people you share the world with, a desire to know more about them... that’s a strength of the internet that has always kind of meant a lot to me in so many ways.  I’m glad that Del’fi has it to rely on, even if it’s just a weird MMO.  

MILES: Now we get into what’s had the streets talking since Swiss dropped his so controversial-yet-so-brave-and-now-absolutely-confirmed-as-a-shipping-chart chart.  SATYR ROMANCE.  It wouldn’t be Homestuck without introducing some insane sociocultural alien bullshit and even though we’ve kind of done nothing BUT play around in that space we’re incapable of not doing it even more, so let’s see how much of this we can spell out before I leave the rest of the natural mysteries to ya.  We had a lot of fun hashing this stuff out and introducing a whole new schema via which our loyal fans can codify their favorite ships is just the kind of community-serving magnanimity we’ve more or less become known for.

MILES: One of the best things about Homestuck Aliens is the way they’re sort of good at emphasizing that everyone is really just kind of people, and that the weird fancy names these aliens give to their Super Special Concepts are as often as not just thinly veiled metaphors for shit we already know.  I can’t believe I even just bothered to explain the concept of metaphor as a literary device to you guys.  That’s so fucking patronizing, I’m sorry.  I disgust myself.  Anyway!  This first bit where the game gets really into MERIT and FRATERNITY is a fun way to emphasize what it is that satyrs find most important, which granted does paint a nice little picture of their jocular masculine Self-Improvement Society but also is just funny because it’s like... “in my culture, we value Being Good At Things and People.”  Like, yeah, no shit?  Everyone does.  That said, it can be pretty interesting examining the different weights various cultures give to different Universally Appreciated Values as a way to compare them to one another... this update also gets into a few ways that satyrs and nymphs are culturally appreciably pretty different, but that comes later.

MILES: There is a lot to be said about what we learn here, though.  This framework does help to examine the behaviors of our satyrs, especially poor neurotic Swiss, who, while being kind of a weirdly old-fashioned babytrad in a lot of ways, does at least attempt the facade of being the most Mainstream of the three.

FLORAL: It seemingly puts quite a bit of stress on him to be so rigidly normal, huh?

MILES: But what you really came here for is the steamy romantic shit, so let’s move on and get to that.

MILES: I really, really like how we set up Satyr Romance.  It’s all a bunch of overcodified bullshit, but that’s sort of part of the appeal, isn’t it?  We say so in this spiel, but the way that it allows for so many precisely defined yet fluidly evolving labels is kind of a shipper’s wet dream, an evershifting nomenclature of neatly-stated and yet non-euclideanly twisting romosexual expectations.  3 morphotypes lent itself naturally to the 3 different relationship roles, and- yeah you want me to get into the Alpha-Beta-Omega thing.  Fine.  The thing is, OBVIOUSLY we were going to get into that bucket of worms when cooking up a race of gay mpreg horse boys, and the three morphotypes and hellenistic cultural flavors only nudged us ever-more inevitably in that direction.  But when I was starting to get into this, I felt pretty strongly about averting what I’d say is one of Alpha-Beta-Omega’s more, uh.... controversial?  Unwieldy?  traits.  Which is the way that it creates Gender: TWO! by arbitrarily assigning societal roles to biological variances.  Real life already does that, and the Satyrs and Nymphs already deal with the complicated gender-racial-analogues inherent to their contrasted existences, so for the satyr romance system I thought it might be more interesting if their system was more individually roles-based.  Obviously our readers are free to project their own gender traumas and inherent sexual biases onto this system, and they most certainly will, but trying to define it as much as possible as a more... experience-based label system, as opposed to a mandate determined from birth, felt like something that was more interesting to me as a way to contrast the more “inherent divides” between the two species of the Contest.

MILES: It is my sincere, sincere wish that the fans start using A/O/B as another way of labeling their favorite fictional barbie-doll ships.  I feel like we did a pretty good job laying it all out in one page.

FLORAL: We as a friend group were actually using it while watching Princess Tutu. It’s enlightening. 

MILES: This update also gives the readers the framework to finally understand Swiss’ shameful shipping chart of him and his two closest bros.  TC’s is more or less spot on, from what we’ve seen so far, but Swiss... are you really an obvious alpha???  It doesn’t seem to be working out for you, man.

FLORAL: Just the fact he was pouring over this, and constantly changing his mind goes to show how while the baseline of aob may seem rigid you can apply so many different layers of framing to apply these categories. Tbh it’s a welcome difference from quadrants because it’s less focused on unconscious emotions. People have done a great job in complicating quadrants over the years but aob offers so much leeway, it feels very true to the new age of yaoi we are in that is very focused on playing with expectation/dynamics. More and more stories in these spaces are playing with the idea of dominance and desire outside of simply dom top and sub bottom. 

Even with traditional omegaverse, the meta is evolving constantly. We had long talks that boiled down to me getting these two up to speed with dominant-omegas or bdsm secondary sex traits or alpha on alpha “bitching” that are everywhere in the growing yaoi industry. I also like that unlike these tropes though, our aob is the farthest thing from bio essentialism. 

Traditional omegaverse is, in my opinion, primarily interesting because of how predominantly cis women use it to unconsciously explore the anxiety of SA explicitly in how it relates to pregnancy along with the fear of an untempered sexual desire in general. But with aob, the discussion moves away from this because a society made by men that all equally have the ability to get pregnant has infinitely more resources and support for unwanted pregnancy. We are taking the misogyny discussion to new places and playing in the space of speculative fiction. 

So in the same vein you can start thinking of aob along the lines of what happens if an omega puts more focus on their beta? What happens when an alpha can’t let themselves be taken care of? If two omegas push one another, how does one not having any authority change the dynamic?

It’s all quite fun isn’t it?

MILES: One last thing, here: A lot of how satyr society is set up is a fairly telling portrait of a busy, ambitious desire for things to Work Out, Make Sense, and Feel Empowering.  There’s a very utilitarian and goal-oriented fixation in much of what they do, a sort of Plotted Out Path-To-Paradise with enough of a sprinkle of personal ambition to keep things weird and interesting.  The comfort in AOB as a multifaceted and flexible-yet-efficient labeling system, the productivity-minded-positivity of Merit and Fraternity’s interweaving checks and balances... seems like the kind of thing a certain someone would really be into.

HAVEN: I don’t think I saw anyone comment on this one here but whatever the hell these two annoying grown ass men are doing aside, this shows that the narration shown to the reader is also being read by these two annoying grown ass men.

FLORAL: Are they even literate?

HAVEN: And now for something completely different. Kind of. It’s all so derivative isn’t it. I don’t even know if I want to comment on every single thing that happens in this sequence because there’s quite a lot and I'd rather have readers draw their own interpretations of events than spell everything out for them. It’d be a little rude too, wouldn’t it? To pry into a very private author's mind and leak out everything they’re hiding in that barrier between art and artist. You wouldn’t want to do that to them right? Alright fine you’ve twisted my arm, let’s pry a little..

MILES: Popping in really quick to say that I really adored that we were able to get more user-input on the comic.  I mean, that Del’fi was able to get more user-input on his comic.  Getting to combine FRAF-input and the real life physical scrawlings of fans from NYCstuck was such a blast.  I still have the notebook full of those suggestions sitting in my room right now.  I’m looking right at it, and it’s making me feel guilty because I was supposed to have uploaded this ages ago.  I’ll get to it in the next few days, for sure.

HAVEN: Well to start let’s meet the cast of Beyond Canon!

Vriska: A Pirate who sails onto land in search of adventure.

Terezi: A Ronin who hurts as much as he helps.

Jane: She wants to prove horses exist.

Dirk: A horse.

Rose: Dark sorceress, up to no good.

Roxy: Rose’s greatest rival.

Calliope: Her favorite food is twin.

Kanaya: Former lightsource seeking employment, though she didn’t end up making an appearance in this one! 

Jake: Also known as “Peepaw”

Dave and Karkat: Beta 4 Beta.

Calliope’s Twin Sister: Lunch that packs a punch.

Aradia: She heard what’s about to happen next and is very excited to see it.

Davebot: Worse Dave.

John: At present time: Currently missing.  

HAVEN: Satyr Jane wants that horse pretty bad. What’s he hoping to gain by proving horses exist? Do we even care in the face of possible Janevris Gem? Could this be peak? 

HAVEN: Just like that Rose is dropping even lower on the Homestuck character popularity polls. She definitely does not make this shit easy for us. A lot of people are going to be performative and say they like her more because of this because they don’t like davekat, and some will flock to say they’re not being performative they truly mean that shit. It’s sad that, even that, is performative. But how sad could you be when we got DAVEJAKE possibilities in the house now right?? Is this davejake gem? Is this peak? Damnnnn nobody in the history of the whole world has ever shipped that shit. And cute ol’ Calliope in the corner just cheesing.

HAVEN: This is one from NYCSTUCK, I read it and immediately was like “Yeah, we’re doing this one.” The implications are just astounding. Also Calliope, this is why you don’t stand in the corner.

HAVEN: This whole part is my favorite, Dave bleeding out in the background. Nymph Roxy seemingly very excited to see Nymph Rose but is met with a whole lot of animosity. Calliope being (alive) back there. Also wait a second guys Nymph Roxy is sitting on Horse Dirk. Could this be Roxydirk Gem? Is this peak? Wait, before you answer I’m getting word in just now from HQ that Dirk is a horse. Guys that’s a horse.

HAVEN: Roxy providing some classic uncritical support of good ol 'Gamzee over here. Could this be roxygam Gem? Is this peak? Gamzee, who seems to be sporting one of his classic Gamzee trophy hats! Where did this cute little bucktooth satyr get his hands on a hat like that? Also some more wonderful background Calliope checking on Dave. Aww you don’t need to do that... Unless this is implying DAVELLIOPE Gem. which im pretty sure actually for real has never been shipped before in the history of mankind. Is this what we’re moving on in 2026? Wait Wait Wait I just noticed Nymph Rose is sitting next to Nymph Vriska, Could this be Rosevris Gem? Is this peak? WAAAAAAAAAIIIT I didn’t even notice rose was sitting on jake in this scene is this jakerose gem is th

HAVEN: Holy shit.

HAVEN: With these two lackeys in the backeys the only real design note I had going in was they needed to both be Alkyrins. (Also Aradia’s tail being in a bun just seemed very cute to me.) But each shackled metal ball added to Davebot made me laugh harder and harder. I had to stop myself from adding a 5th.

HAVEN: Anyway some shit happens and The Beyond Anon gets a chance to reset the whole shebang. They seemed grateful. It was starting to get a little messy.

HAVEN:  The horse does some cute silly nonsense and then John appears? And she wants to court the horse? Wait. I didn’t notice before but Vriska is walking towards Terezi in the background of that saltlick panel? Could this imply Vrisrezi Gem? TOO BAD WE DON’T GET TO SEE IT. Stingy ass maker keeping the camera so low to the ground who gives a fuck about this damn horse. Guys so many suggestions were about various characters courting this horse. He’s a horse. You all like Dirk too much.

FLORAL: I loved this sequence because we were just trying to fit these commands into a workable narrative and somehow it all worked out? 

MILES: Here we have a frankly spectacular leethex UI designed by our very own Andi, with some help from Joey.  I’ll let them get into that in the Artist’s Commentary.

MILES: Definitely.  Could you imagine entire groups of children being exposed to this kind of technology, and then that sort of thing being flippantly treated as a game?  That’d be awful.  

MILES: Uh oh.  This conversation is a doozy if ever there was one.  There’s so much to get into here, but a lot of it I want to try and leave to your imaginations... what to do, what to do.  This is one of the conversations we were the most nervous about releasing, it’s packed with meaning and intensity and weirdly direct interpersonal and expository goodness.  Let’s get into it.

MILES:  One of the main flavors of this conversation is TC’s relentlessly open and enthusiastic engagement contrasted against Del’fi’s increasingly less hidden attempts to shut him out.  As TC demonstrates later in the conversation, he isn’t much interested in being shut out, dancing between the real invasive danger of the premise of their meeting and what it is he’s asking of Del’fi (to participate in a dangerous meeting of their friendgroup that, as the audience is all too aware, will also Destroy Everything) and what seems to be a legitimate attempt to speedrun what he sees as a friendship between two people who should, by all metrics, be natural friends.  Freaky mysterious isolated hacker bros... unite!  But it didn’t seem to work out that well, though whether or not he even picked up on that is up in the air.  The smile never cracked, at any rate, and the silly invitations to fuck around never stopped.

MILES: TC and Del’fi waste essentially no time setting themselves up as potent freaky ass foils.  There’s a lot of themes touched on by this conversation that, again, I don’t want to overdescribe, but one of the main driving impulses seems to be a real dissatisfaction with their circumstances that’s reflected in very different ways.  TC, for his part, is going full speed the fuck ahead and dragging basically everyone along with him.  This instance of Del’fi going mask off for a second and telling TC to shut the fuck up is met not with an apology, nor with an argument or any defensiveness, but the genuine delight of not only seeing Del’fi stand up to meet what he sees as circumstances trapping them both, but Seeing Del’fi, period.  

FLORAL: It’s almost as if to TC being seen could only be liberating. 

MILES: This bit serves to highlight kind of a core differentiation between nymphic and satyrical cultural mindsets, manifested in both the positive and negative by Del’fi and TC respectively in this conversation, that feels kind of important to touch on.  Del’fi stresses an emphasis on fate, the causal fact of prophecy, the importance of KNOWING where you stand in the world... all healthy beliefs, but spoken from a perspective of almost resigned, dysphoric defeatism.  TC, by contrast, here exemplifies the satyrical instinct to EARN where you stand in the world, fighting to give yourself the life you desire and reveling in the empowering possibilities of action, but he actively champions these beliefs by barreling into another person’s life in an extremely invasive and inconsiderate manner, with very little thought for perspectives outside his own. Ironically, TC’s framework for liberating Del’fi and giving him the life he thinks he deserves is predicated on putting Del’fi in ANOTHER predicament where he’s kind of at the mercy of dangerous circumstances that might be out of his control.

FLORAL: I want to give a shout out to some readers that have been very tuned into a very specific element of this conversation, where Del’fi’s rejection is not only protective/defensive but also a reflection of his greater cultural awareness. In the end race and gender are synonymous on Deltritus, and it felt right and true that despite admiring parts of satyr masculinity, Del’fi’s feelings aren’t so simple as we may assume. 

This conversation was the perfect tone shift we needed at this point of Act 2, and seeing it out in the world means so much. 

HAVEN: I've been excited to be able to talk about her for some time now.  A very simple pop culture reference to analog with Del'fi and The Great Combiner could be something like Knuckles' relationship with The Master Emerald. 

1.) Keep it safe 

2.) Do not leave it

3.) Thwart all intruders who could abuse its power. 

We’ve seen her vaguely associated with the role of "Caretaker" which seems to be a bit of a contentious title in Del'fi's (many) eyes. Del'fi sees her as something of a burden, with Del'fi feeling more like the actual caretaker around here. Which makes sense! Del'fi is literally here to take care of her. Kind of? I mean. There was a previous caretaker but she's been locked in a damn crystal for who knows how long. The Great Combiner yoinked Del'fi right out of the sky and dragged them down here for a reason right? Probably? What use does this massively powerful woman have for a child? She already has loving partners, the untold riches of countless victories, and claim to an entire layer of the ocean. (You could even say she has her very own kingdom down there.) Could a childhood bereft of attachment really leave you this disturbed well into adulthood?

HAVEN: I guess when you grow up a lonely kid, it’s hard to ever fully stop feeling like a lonely kid.

HAVEN: An entire generation of fatal widespread prophecy induced apathy. It seemingly faded... at least in the most part. Nymphs in the larger sense don’t seem (as) violently nihilistic anymore. AA’s earlier comment about Nymph Culture makes it seem like after this very scary era they tried to make a big turn around, and that’s the culture she’s been proudly raised in.

HAVEN: Though notably, the prophecy itself was never fulfilled. Which sucks because as we know: ALL PROPHECIES MUST COME TRUE. So It makes sense that that defeatist view would still hold some sway over parts of the population. In that case you’d get over the idea of doing anything to prepare for any future, “It’s not like you’ve got much time left anyway.”

HAVEN: That’s a really dangerous mindworm to still have amongst people like this!  A mindset that almost led to the entire planet's destruction(?) Question marked because, The logic was kind of sound right? If the rules state that, lets say 6 people, are going to make it off-world. Wouldn't it stand to say that if you are one of the only 6 people ON-world you'd be the ones to make it off? I'd be curious to see too! Though they were thwarted. A little sad for them, very relieving for everyone who valued their individualized existence. 

FLORAL: GC is truly the most peak. I love when a character almost destroys the world with pure intentions and unconditional love. I think if GC lived in our world, people would also come in droves. 

HAVEN: A few things here sound familiar. And the language used seems quite specific. Let’s keep this in the back of our minds, chums.

HAVEN: I don’t know why this line made so many people excited. Is this a reference to something?

Files

Comments

joycenotmanor

all this talk of gems and whatnot starting to think haven shouldnt be allowed to have access to the enligsih language

poppyfleece

wait I need to see the team's princess tutu ship chart

Gamze Makara

sImPlY aMaZiNg... WhAt MiRaClEs ArE iN sToRe FoR tHeSe ZaNy KiDs? WiLl AnY oF tHeM eVeR dRiNk WaTeR? fInD oUt NeXt TiMe On HoMeStUcK: bC! ):0) (Also, have a wonderful day! ):0) )

Andrew Frisina

"I guess when you grow up a lonely kid, it’s hard to ever fully stop feeling like a lonely kid." Yeah. You can snake through it with many different kinds of effort. But yeah, it's like a warp that you forever remember even as you coincide it with other feelings and memories. And now even the loneliness warp has a friend to vibe with. "GC is truly the most peak. I love when a character almost destroys the world with pure intentions and unconditional love." A real anxiety tbh.

Andrew Frisina

Give them access to the Greek language instead.