The Worst News Directors (Patreon)
Content
For quite some time when FTVLive has asked for nominations for our Best and Worst lists, the nominations for the Best people have outweighed the nominations for the Worst but quite a lot.
That is not the case when it comes to News Director nominations.
FTVLive got thousands of nominations and this time, the nominations for the Worst list were vastly more than the Best.
For example, when it came to our Best and Worst nominations for Morning TV News Anchors, the nominations of best were nearly 20 times more than the nominations for Worst.
That has certainly changed this time around.
But, that also should be a bit expected.
The News Director is the boss, so obviously more people are going to nominate the boss for the Worst list.
Also, as a former News Director, I can tell you it is a thankless job. You are always going to have people not like you.
You deny a person's vacation or put them on the Weekend shift and it is a good bet they will not be happy. No one comes to your office door and says, "Hey, thanks for all you are doing." If they are at the door, it is a good bet they have a problem. That's just the way it is.
So, when trying to put this list together, we had a lot of entries to go through and had to narrow it down.
For the first time, we will be doing the Top 5 Worst in a separate list from the Best.
There was a theme of those that made the Worst list and it was the fact that many of these News Directors think that the best way to lead their staff is by fear and intimidation.
If you made the list, you can blame FTVLive all you want, but I can tell you, you made the list because the people that work for you, or did work for you, put you there.
If a couple of people complained, you would not be making this list. We got a lot of nominations and if you made the Top 5, it is a good bet you deserve to be there.
You can be mad, hurt, or cast blame, or maybe you can take a deeper look at yourself and see how you do your job? Maybe you can treat your staff better? Maybe you can change?
Then again, maybe you think your way is the right way and nothing needs to change.
In this case, FTVLive is just the messenger. As they say, we don't have any skin in the game and we are just going with what the people working in newsrooms have to say.
Without further ado, let's start the countdown:
No. 5 Worst News Director
Coming in at No. 5 on the list is WPLG (Miami) News Director Bill Pohovey.
A number of insiders say that the way Pohovey the suicide of Anchor Todd Tongen and his handling of the COVID pandemic has caused them to lose all respect for the man.
Pohovey is long known to play favorites in the newsroom and often casts good people aside, just because he doesn't personally like them.
"I would call him out for his management style, but he doesn't have a clue how to manage," said one person that worked for Pohovey.
No. 4 Worst News Director
Coming in at the No. 4 spot on our list is WWMT (Grand Rapids) News Director Matt Johnson.
"Matt is someone who treats no one with respect, he regularly belittles his employees by treating them like children," said one employee at the station.
Sources say that there has been a lot of turnover of staff since Johnson was put in charge. They also say that when someone does decide to leave, he gets all mad and takes in personally. One staffer adds that Johnson "has a history of holding people back from better opportunities," even when it is within the company.
Lastly, looking at Johnson's on-air staff, it doesn't appearJohnson is big on diversity.
WWMT is owned by Sinclair.
No. 3 Worst News Director
Coming in at the 3rd spot on your Worst list is WMBB (Panama City) News Director Tom Lewis.
To be honest, this one did not surprise us one bit. FTVLive often hears from other News Directors that work at Nexstar stations (WMBB is owned by Nexstar) that say Lewis is hard to deal with.
"He is a washed-up Anchor that really would still rather do that than be the News Director," said one staffer that works for Lewis.
One staffer says he has a short temper and although he has only been an anchor in a tiny market, "he thinks he knows everything."
No. 2 Worst News Director
Coming on at the deuce spot on our list is another Sinclair News Director.
KUTV (Salt Lake City) Mike Garber has made these kinds of lists before and will likely make than again.
Insiders say that Garder is all about intimidation and that is the only way he knows how to lead.
"He's just evil," says one former employee that worked for him. "I have PTSD after dealing with him every day," another one added.
This should tell you all you need to know about Mike Garber.
The Utah legislator passed a law that bans non-compete clauses in the state. In other words, you can leave one station and cross the street at another station without having to sit out a non-compete.
Since that law went into effect, a number of staffers at KUTV have left the station to go work at another station in the market. Very few if any talent has left another station in town to go work at KUTV.
Very telling indeed.
Lastly, look at the on-air staff at KUTV and see if you can spot one Black person.
The Worst News Director
This one will not come as much of a surprise.
The Worst of the Worst is WTTG (DC) News Director Paul McGonagle.
A large number of people emailed FTVLive that either work or have worked with McGonagle and they say the only way he leads is through fear and intimidation.
"I have never met or worked with anyone as mean as Paul," said one staffer.
One employee said that McGonagle is a jerk but says he think that's because WTTG General Manager Patrick Paolini wants him to act that way. "Paul is bad, not he's not nearly as bad as Patrick," the employee said.
WTTG recently lost two high profile Black anchors in Allison Seymour and Shawn Yancy. Many point to the "toxic" newsroom as for the reason.
In Seymour's case, it is believed that she signed an NDA to keep her quiet. Now, if you treat your staff fairly and with respect, what is the need for having them sign an NDA?
Insiders say that rather than taking a hard look at themselves (management), they obsess on who is leaking information to FTVLive and other media outlets?
"I can assure you that there are others that are looking to get out as well," said one staffer. "How nice would it be if you went somewhere and we treated with respect?" said one staffer.
And that wraps up the list of the Worst TV News Director as nominated by you guys.
Keep logging on as we will be naming the Top 5 Best News Directors and that should be a bit more uplifting and let you know that there are some good ones out there.
Files
Previews only